📘 Lecture 42 — George H. Mead-IV (Topic 158-163)
📖 Overview: This lecture completes George H. Mead's analysis of the act by detailing the four stages: Impulse, Perception, Manipulation, and Consummation. It synthesizes Mead's overall contributions to sociological theory and concludes with remarks on the symbolic interactionist perspective. Understanding the stages of the act explains why humans initiate behavior and how they achieve integration with their social environment.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the four stages of the act as theorized by George H. Mead: Impulse (disequilibrium with environment), Perception (selective awareness of relevant objects), Manipulation (covert and overt behavioral responses), and Consummation (elimination of disequilibrium). It then summarizes Mead's contributions regarding behaviorism, mind, self, and society, and concludes with remarks on symbolic interactionism's focus on subjective meaning, micro-sociological analysis, and its role as an alternative perspective in sociology.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 158: Stages of Act: Impulse
For Mead, an impulse represents a state of disequilibrium or tension between an organism and its environment. Two implicit propositions govern impulses: (1) The greater the degree of disequilibrium, the stronger the impulse and the more likely behavior will reflect this fact. (2) The longer an impulse persists, the more it will serve to initiate and guide behavior until it is consumed.
Sources of disequilibrium for an organism are varied. Some impulses come from organic needs that are unfulfilled. Others come from interpersonal maladjustments. Still others come from self-inflicted reflections. Many are a combination of organic, interpersonal, and intra-psychic sources of tension. The key point is that impulses initiate efforts at their consummation, while giving the behavior of an organism a general direction. However, a state of disequilibrium can be eliminated in many different ways, and the specific direction of behavior will be determined by the conditions of the environment. For Mead, humans are not pushed and pulled around by impulses. Contrarily, an impulse is defined in terms of the degree of harmony with the environment. The precise ways it is consummated are influenced by how an organism is prepared to adjust to its environment. Hunger, an organic drive, is seen as arising from behavioral adaptations to the environment—types of foods considered edible, how they are eaten, and when they can be eaten will be shaped by environmental forces as they impinge on actors with mind and self. Impulse initiates behavior and gives it a general direction; the next stage—perception—will determine what aspects of the environment are relevant for eliminating the impulse.
🔑 Definition — Impulse: A state of disequilibrium or tension between an organism and its environment that initiates efforts at its own consummation.
📐 Principle: The greater the degree of disequilibrium → the stronger the impulse → the more likely behavior reflects this fact. The longer an impulse persists → the more it will initiate and guide behavior.
Topic 159: Stages of Act: Perception
Perception means to become aware through senses. What people see in their environment is highly selective, a process called selective awareness or perception. One basis for selective perception is the impulse—people become attuned to those objects in their environment perceived as relevant to eliminating an impulse. What objects are seen as relevant depends on past socialization, self-conceptions, and expectations from generalized others. For example, whether a hungry person sees a cow as a relevant food object depends on how they have been sensitized to potential food objects. The process of perception thus sensitizes an individual to certain objects in the environment. As objects, they become stimuli for repertoires of behavioral responses, which are a storage of permissible responses to stimuli. Perception is simply the arousal of potential responses to stimuli. As the organism becomes aware of relevant objects, it also is prepared to act in certain ways. Humans approach objects with a series of hypotheses or notions about how certain responses toward objects can eliminate their disequilibrium.
🔑 Definition — Perception: The process of becoming aware through senses; a selective awareness where people become attuned to objects perceived as relevant to eliminating an impulse.
Topic 160: Manipulation
Manipulation is the emission of behaviors toward objects—the process of handling in a skillful manner. Because humans have mind and self, they can engage in covert as well as overt manipulation. Humans can covertly: imagine consequences of action toward objects for eliminating an impulse; manipulate the world in their imagination; and imagine the consequences of various lines of action.
What determines whether manipulation will be covert before it is overt? The key condition is what Mead saw as blockage. Blockage is a condition where the consummation of an impulse is inhibited or delayed. Consider breaking a pencil while writing—this creates an impulse or disequilibrium with the environment, leading to efforts at manipulation. Possible outcomes: the person sees a pile of pencils readily available (overt manipulation); or the person covertly starts thinking about finding a pencil. When blockage of the impulse generates conscious imagery, manipulation becomes overt. When impulse, perception, and overt manipulation stages of the act do not lead to consummation, thinking occurs and manipulation becomes covert, utilizing the capacities of mind and self. In case of blockage, an actor immediately starts covert thinking. Thinking is a behavioral adaptation of an organism experiencing disequilibrium with its environment and unable to perceive objects or manipulate behaviors in ways leading to consummation of an impulse.
In the process of thinking, an actor comes to perceive relevant objects; may even role-take with the object if it is another individual or a group; a self-image may be derived, and one may see self as yet another object; and various lines of conduct are imaginatively rehearsed. The stage of manipulation involves behavior, feedback, readjustment of behavior, feedback, and readjustment. This process continues until an impulse is eliminated. Mead calls this a 'cybernetic' process, having automatic control systems, requiring persistent motivation. Motivation is a process of constant adjustment and readjustment of behaviors to restore equilibrium with the environment. The assumption is that the more often an impulse is blocked, the more it grows in intensity, and the more it consumes the process of thinking and the phases of self.
💡 Why this matters: Blockage is the crucial mechanism that activates human mind and self—it explains when and why thinking, reflection, and covert rehearsal occur.
🔑 Definition — Manipulation: The emission of behaviors toward objects, which can be either overt (physical action) or covert (imaginative rehearsal of action).
🔑 Definition — Blockage: A condition where the consummation of an impulse is inhibited or delayed, generating conscious imagery and covert thinking.
Topic 161: Consummation
Consummation denotes the completion of an act through the elimination of disequilibrium between an organism and its environment. For any person, there are multiple impulses operating, each at various stages of consummation and potential points of blockage. Successful consummation of acts leads to the development of stable behavior patterns, which become guidelines for others. For humans, perception involves seeing physical objects, oneself, others, and various generalized others as part of their environment. Manipulation for humans with the capacities for mind and self involves both overt behavior and covert deliberations. Covertly, individuals weigh alternatives and assess their consequences with reference to individuals' conception, the expectations of specific others, and various generalized others.
Humans must live and survive in social groups. Consummation for humans almost always revolves around adaptation to, and cooperation with, others in ongoing collective enterprises. The point of blockage at any point determines the strength of a particular stage of the act. Intense impulses are typically those that have been blocked, thereby causing heightened perception. Heightened perception generates greater overt and covert manipulation. If blockage occurs, then perception is further heightened, as are impulses. The same applies to manipulation—if manipulation is unsuccessful, escalated covert manipulation ensues, thereby heightening perception and impulse. This explains why people initiate action and why behaviors take a certain direction: humans initiate and direct their actions in an effort to achieve integration into ongoing social process.
🔑 Definition — Consummation: The completion of an act through the elimination of disequilibrium between an organism and its environment.
Topic 162: George H. Mead - Summarizing the Contributions
Mead's basic premise of behaviorism is that behaviors that facilitate the adjustment and adaptation of organisms to their environment will be retained. For any individual organism, its environment is society. The young infant must adjust to society and develop its behavioral capacities for language, role-taking, mind, and self. For the mature individual, the continued use of these fundamental capacities is essential for ongoing adjustment and adaptation to society. For Mead, the capacities for mind and self are behaviors.
These capacities assure that much human action will be covert and involve role-taking, reflective thinking, self-criticism, and self-assessment. Behavioral capacities for mind and self make humans distinctive. Only out of interaction by actors with mind and self is society possible. For a species not organized by instincts (as are ants and bees), the ability to role-take becomes crucial in such interactions. Humans have to learn their behaviors. Impulses are both caused and constrained by the capacity to role-take as regulated by the culture. Cultural constraints on impulses allow for the organization of species into society. The behavioral abilities facilitate the adjustment and adaptation of the species as a whole to the environment. Acquisition of mind and self enables the individual to adapt to its social environment. The flexible interactive abilities of individuals with mind and self facilitate the species' adaptation to the environment and help in the creation, maintenance, and change of society.
Topic 163: Concluding Remarks
The main focus of symbolic interactionism has been on discussions of the self, self-interaction, taking the role of the other, interpretation, gestures, and symbolic meanings. The discussions of these major areas have emphasized studying processes of interaction between individuals. The methodology primarily used has been inductive, qualitative, and geared toward micro-sociological analysis.
The perspective is basically a socio-psychological approach. The results can be described as a "moving picture" rather than a still photograph of human behavior, providing a close-up picture. This perspective places primary value on subjective meaning and on processes opposed to structure. Researchers take great pains to capture the "world of the other" as seen by that other and ask important sociological questions that cannot be answered by mainstream sociology. While this perspective does not appear to be a "mainstream" of sociology, many of its core concepts have been accepted. Some interactionists have developed concepts that connect the macro and structural demands of sociology. Symbolic interactionism can be seen as an alternative perspective providing theoretical tools missing in other perspectives. It follows a distinctive approach that makes important contributions to sociology and has experienced a resurgence recently.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The act consists of four sequential stages—Impulse (disequilibrium), Perception (selective awareness of relevant objects), Manipulation (covert or overt behavioral responses), and Consummation (elimination of disequilibrium)—which explain why humans initiate and direct their behavior toward integration with the social environment. Blockage is the critical mechanism that activates higher mental capacities: when consummation is inhibited, thinking becomes covert and involves role-taking, self-reflection, and imaginative rehearsal of alternative actions. Mead's core contribution is that mind and self are behavioral capacities acquired through social interaction that enable humans to adjust and adapt to their social environment, making organized society possible without instincts. Symbolic interactionism, as an alternative sociological perspective, emphasizes subjective meaning, micro-sociological processes, and inductive qualitative methods to capture the "world of the other" and has experienced recent resurgence.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four stages of the act according to Mead, and what does each stage involve?
- What is blockage, and why is it critical for activating covert manipulation and thinking?
- How does Mead define consummation, and why does it almost always involve adaptation to and cooperation with others?
- According to Mead's summary, why are the capacities for mind and self essential for both individual adjustment and the organization of society?
- What are the primary methodological and theoretical emphases of symbolic interactionism as presented in the concluding remarks?
📘 Lecture 43 — Symbolic Interactions: Some basic principles (Topic164-165)
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational principles of symbolic interactionism, a sociological perspective that emphasizes the human capacity for thought, the role of social interaction in shaping meaning, and the dynamic nature of symbols and interpretation. It contrasts symbolic interactionism with behaviorism and explains how thinking and interaction are mutually constitutive.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers seven basic principles of symbolic interactionism as enumerated by theorists like Blumer. It then delves into the human capacity for thought, distinguishing it from mere behavior and explaining how it is shaped by social interaction, particularly socialization. Finally, it explores the relationship between thinking and interaction, differentiating between nonsymbolic and symbolic interaction, and discusses how actors define objects based on socially learned meanings.
📝 Lecture Summary
Symbolic Interactions: Some basic principles
Symbolic interactionists have enumerated basic principles that differentiate this theory from its behaviorist roots. These principles outline a view of human beings as active, thinking agents who learn and modify meanings through social interaction. The principles form the core of the theoretical orientation, emphasizing that humans are not merely reactive to external or internal forces but are reflective units that construct their actions.
🔑 Definition — Symbolic Interactionism: A theoretical perspective that focuses on the subjective meanings that people impose on objects, behaviors, and events, and how these meanings are created and modified through social interaction.
📌 Example: The seven principles listed by Blumer and others include: 1) Humans have the capacity for thought. 2) This capacity is shaped by social interaction. 3) People learn meanings and symbols through social interaction. 4) Meanings and symbols enable distinctively human action. 5) People can modify meanings based on their interpretation of situations. 6) This modification is possible because people can interact with themselves to assess courses of action. 7) These patterns of action are intertwined.
Capacity for Thought
The crucial assumption that human beings possess the ability to think differentiates symbolic interactionism from behaviorism. This ability allows people to act reflectively rather than unreflectively. The mind is not seen as a physical structure but as a continuing process, originating in the socialization of consciousness. It is distinct from the physiological brain, meaning a brain does not inevitably produce a mind (as seen in lower animals). The mind is related to socialization, meanings, symbols, the self, interaction, and society.
🔑 Definition — Capacity for Thought: The uniquely human ability to act reflectively, construct and guide actions, and examine possible courses of action, which is shaped and refined through social interaction.
📐 Formula: Brain ≠ Mind → A brain is necessary but not sufficient for a mind; the mind is a social process, not a physical thing.
💡 Why this matters: This idea places agency and reflection at the center of human action, rejecting the idea that people are simply puppets of social structure or biological impulses.
Thinking and Interaction
The general capacity for thought is shaped and refined in the process of social interaction, particularly socialization. To symbolic interactionists, socialization is a dynamic, two-way process where actors not only learn culture and roles but also shape and adapt information to their own needs. Interaction is the process in which thinking is both developed and expressed.
Blumer distinguishes between two basic forms of social interaction:
- Nonsymbolic interaction (Mead’s “conversation of gestures”) – does not involve thinking.
- Symbolic interaction – requires mental processes.
Blumer also differentiates among three types of objects: physical objects (e.g., chair, tree), social objects (e.g., student, mother), and abstract objects (e.g., idea, moral principle). The key is not the object itself but how it is defined by the actor. Different actors may define the same object differently, as with a tree: it is a different object to a botanist, a lumberman, a poet, and a home gardener. Individuals learn the meanings of objects during socialization, and these meanings can vary.
🔑 Definition — Nonsymbolic Interaction: A form of social interaction that does not involve thinking, such as a reflexive or instinctive gesture. 🔑 Definition — Symbolic Interaction: A form of social interaction that requires mental processes, involving interpretation and the use of meaning.
📌 Example: A traffic light is a physical object. A driver learns its meaning through socialization (red = stop, green = go). This is symbolic interaction. However, if a driver flinches at a sudden flash of light without interpretation, that is nonsymbolic interaction.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Human beings possess a unique capacity for thought that differentiates them from lower animals and from behaviorist models. (2) This capacity is not innate but is developed and refined through social interaction, especially the dynamic process of socialization. (3) Meaning and symbols are central to human action and are learned, used, and modified by individuals based on their interpretation of situations. (4) There is a distinction between nonsymbolic interaction (without thinking) and symbolic interaction (requiring mental processes). (5) The meaning of objects is not fixed; it depends on the actor’s definition, which is learned socially and can vary between individuals.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the crucial assumption that differentiates symbolic interactionism from behaviorism?
- According to symbolic interactionists, how is the human capacity for thought developed?
- What is the difference between nonsymbolic interaction and symbolic interaction, as defined by Blumer?
- Why do different individuals (e.g., a botanist and a poet) define the same physical object (e.g., a tree) differently?
- How do symbolic interactionists view the process of socialization differently from conventional sociologists?
📘 Lecture 44 — Learning meanings and symbols (Topic 166-167)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how symbolic interactionists, following George Herbert Mead, understand the creation and learning of meanings and symbols through social interaction. It explains the crucial role of symbols—especially language—in enabling human action, thought, and social life, and details how meanings and symbols shape both individual action and mutual social interaction.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main topics: first, how people learn meanings and symbols during social interaction, differentiating signs from symbols, and detailing the specific functions of symbols and language for human actors. Second, it examines how meanings and symbols influence human action and interaction, distinguishing between covert and overt behavior, and explaining the process of mutual influence and interpretation in social encounters.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 166: Learning meanings and symbols
Symbolic interactionists, following Mead, accord causal significance to social interaction. Meaning stems not from solitary mental processes but from interaction, a focus derived from Mead’s pragmatism—his concern with human action and interaction, not isolated mental processes. The central concern is not how people mentally create meanings and symbols, but how they learn them during interaction in general and socialization in particular.
People learn symbols as well as meanings in social interaction. Whereas people respond to signs unthinkingly, they respond to symbols in a thoughtful manner. Signs stand for themselves (e.g., the gestures of angry dogs or water to a person dying of thirst). “Symbols are social objects used to represent (or ‘stand in for,’ ‘take the place of’) whatever people agree they shall represent” (Charon, 1998:47). Not all social objects stand for other things, but those that do are symbols. Words, physical artifacts (e.g., a cross or Star of David), and physical actions (e.g., a clenched fist) all can be symbols. People often use symbols to communicate something about themselves—for instance, driving a Rolls-Royce to communicate a certain style of life.
🔑 Definition — Symbols: Social objects used to represent whatever people agree they shall represent. 📐 Formula: Symbol = social object + agreed-upon representation → thoughtful response. 📌 Example: A clenched fist is not just a hand position; it is a symbol that people agree represents defiance, anger, or solidarity, and people respond to it thoughtfully, not unthinkingly.
Symbolic interactionists conceive of language as a vast system of symbols. Words are symbols because they are used to stand for things. Words make all other symbols possible; acts, objects, and other words exist and have meaning only because they have been and can be described through words. Symbols are crucial in allowing people to act in distinctively human ways. Because of the symbol, the human being “does not respond passively to a reality that imposes itself but actively creates and re-creates the world acted in” (Charon, 1998:69).
In addition to this general utility, symbols and language have several specific functions for the actor:
- Naming, categorizing, and remembering: Symbols enable people to deal with the material and social world by naming, categorizing, and remembering objects, ordering a world that would otherwise be confusing. Language allows much more efficient naming, categorizing, and remembering than other symbols like pictorial images.
- Improving perception: Symbols improve the ability to perceive the environment by alerting the actor to some parts rather than others, preventing being flooded by a mass of indistinguishable stimuli.
- Improving thinking: Although pictorial symbols allow limited thought, language greatly expands this ability. Thinking can be conceived of as symbolic interaction with one’s self.
- Solving problems: Symbols greatly increase the ability to solve problems by allowing humans to think through symbolically a variety of alternative actions before acting, reducing the chance of costly mistakes (compared to lower animals using trial-and-error).
- Transcending time, space, and self: Symbols allow actors to imagine the past or future, and to transcend their own persons symbolically to imagine the world from another person’s point of view—the well-known concept of taking the role of the other (D. Miller, 1981).
- Imagining metaphysical reality: Symbols allow us to imagine realities like heaven or hell.
- Avoiding enslavement by environment: Most generally, symbols allow people to be active rather than passive—self-directed in what they do.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these functions explains how human beings are not simply reactive to their environment but actively create and re-create their world through symbolic meaning-making.
Topic 167: Action and interaction & Modification of meanings and symbols
Symbolic interactionists’ primary concern is with the impact of meanings and symbols on human action and interaction. It is useful to employ Mead’s differentiation between covert behavior and overt behavior. Covert behavior is the thinking process, involving symbols and meanings. Overt behavior is the actual behavior performed by an actor. Some overt behavior does not involve covert behavior (habitual behavior or mindless responses to external stimuli). However, most human action involves both kinds. Covert behavior is of greatest concern to symbolic interactionists, whereas overt behavior is of greatest concern to exchange theorists or traditional behaviorists.
🔑 Definition — Covert behavior: The thinking process involving symbols and meanings. 🔑 Definition — Overt behavior: The actual behavior performed by an actor. 📌 Example: When deciding whether to greet a colleague, the internal deliberation about how to greet and what it will mean (covert behavior) is followed by the actual greeting gesture or words (overt behavior). A habitual wave goodbye may involve only overt behavior with minimal covert thought.
Meanings and symbols give social action (involving a single actor) and social interaction (involving two or more actors engaged in mutual social action) distinctive characteristics. Social action is that in which individuals are acting with others in mind—in undertaking an action, people simultaneously try to gauge its impact on the other actors involved. Although people often engage in mindless, habitual behavior, they have the capacity to engage in social action.
In the process of social interaction, people symbolically communicate meanings to the others involved. The others interpret those symbols and orient their responding action based on their interpretation. In other words, in social interaction, actors engage in a process of mutual influence. Christopher (2001) refers to this dynamic social interaction as a “dance” that partners engage in.
🔑 Definition — Social action: Action undertaken with others in mind, gauging its impact on them. 🔑 Definition — Social interaction: Mutual social action involving two or more actors engaging in a process of mutual influence. 📌 Example: A person decides to raise their hand in a meeting (social action, gauging how others will perceive it). Others see the raised hand, interpret it as a request to speak, and the speaker responds accordingly—this back-and-forth is social interaction, a “dance” of mutual adjustment.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical idea is that symbolic interactionists view meanings and symbols as learned through social interaction, not created in isolation—this is the core of Mead’s pragmatist approach. Symbols differ from signs in that they elicit thoughtful, not unthinking, responses, and language functions as a vast symbolic system with seven key capacities including naming, thinking, problem-solving, and transcending time and one’s own perspective. The distinction between covert (thinking) and overt (actual) behavior is essential: symbolic interactionists focus on covert behavior and how meanings guide action, while other theorists focus on overt behavior. Social action is always undertaken with others in mind, and social interaction is a dynamic process of mutual influence and interpretation, described as a “dance.” Students must remember that symbols allow humans to be active, self-directed creators of their reality, not passive respondents to their environment.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How do symbolic interactionists, following Mead, explain the origin of meanings—do they come from solitary mental processes or from social interaction?
- What is the key difference between a sign and a symbol, and give one example of each from the lecture?
- List at least five of the seven specific functions of symbols and language for the human actor.
- What is the difference between covert behavior and overt behavior, and which type is of greatest concern to symbolic interactionists?
- How does Christopher (2001) describe dynamic social interaction, and what does this metaphor emphasize about the process?
📘 Lecture 45 — Making choices (Topic 168-170)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the symbolic interactionist perspective on human agency, emphasizing that people can make independent choices through their interpretation of symbols and meanings. It examines how symbolic interactionists view groups, societies, and large-scale social structures not as deterministic forces but as frameworks emerging from joint action. The lecture concludes with critical evaluations of symbolic interactionism's strengths and weaknesses.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing how humans uniquely possess the capacity to make choices by forming new meanings, illustrated through the Thomas Theorem and the concept of social networks. It then examines the symbolic interactionist critique of macrosociological determinism, presenting Blumer's view of society as consisting of acting people and joint action emerging from micro-level interactions. Finally, it offers concluding remarks including the primacy of Mead's theory and four major criticisms of symbolic interactionism regarding scientific methodology, conceptual vagueness, neglect of macro-structures, and insufficient attention to microscopic psychological factors.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 168: Making choices
Humans, unlike lower animals, can make choices because of their ability to handle meanings and symbols. People need not accept meanings imposed from without; based on their own interpretation, they can form new meanings and new lines of meaning. To the symbolic interactionist, actors have at least some autonomy — they are not simply constrained or determined but are capable of making unique and independent choices, and developing a life with a unique style.
W. I. Thomas and Dorothy Thomas underscored this creative capacity through their concept of definition of the situation: "If men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences." The Thomases recognized that most definitions are provided by society (especially family and community), but their position is distinctive for emphasizing the possibility of spontaneous individual definitions of situations, which allow people to alter and modify meanings and symbols.
This ability to make a difference is reflected in Gary Fine and Sherryl Kleinman's analysis of social network. Instead of viewing it as an unconscious/constraining structure, they see a network as a set of social relationships that people endow with meaning and use for personal and/or collective purposes.
🔑 Definition — Definition of the situation: If men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences. 📌 Example: If a person defines a harmless remark as an insult, the consequences (anger, confrontation) become real regardless of the speaker's original intent.
Topic 169: Groups and societies
Symbolic interactionists are highly critical of other sociologists' tendency to focus on macro structures. Paul Rock states that interactionism discards most macrosociological thought as "an unsure and overambitious metaphysics." Dmitri Shalin points to interactionist criticism of the classical view of social order as "external, atemporal, determinate at any given moment and resistant to change."
Herbert Blumer is at the forefront of criticizing sociological determinism, where social action is treated as an outward flow of forces playing on people rather than acts built up through interpretation of situations. Traditional sociologists tend to reduce actors to "mindless robots on the societal or aggregate level."
To avoid this determinism, Blumer argues that society is not made up of macro structures. The essence of society is found in actors and action: "Human society is to be seen as consisting of acting people, and the life of the society is to be seen as consisting of their actions." Group life is a "complex of ongoing activity." There is also collective action, which involves "individuals fitting their lines of action to one another" — giving rise to what Mead called the social act and Blumer calls joint action.
Blumer accepted emergence — that large-scale structures emerge from micro processes. A joint action is not simply the sum total of individual acts; it comes to have a character of its own. It is not external to or coercive of actors; rather, it is created by actors and their actions.
However, Blumer recognized that joint action often has a "well-established and repetitive form." Most joint action recurs in patterns guided by systems of preestablished meanings such as culture and social order. Following Mead, Blumer admitted that large-scale structures are important, but they have an extremely limited role in symbolic interactionism. Large-scale structures are little more than frameworks within which the really important aspects of social life — action and interaction — take place. They set conditions and limitations but do not determine action. People act in situations, not within structures. Large-scale structures shape the situations in which individuals act and supply the fixed set of symbols that enable them to act.
Even in prescribed areas, joint action must be created and re-created consistently. Actors are guided by generally accepted meanings but are not determined by them — they can make minor or major alterations. As Blumer states: "It is the social process in group life that creates and upholds the rules, not the rules that create and uphold group life."
Blumer did not accord culture or social structure independent and coercive status. A network or institution functions not because of inner dynamics or system requirements, but "because people at different points do something, and what they do is a result of how they define the situation in which they are called on to act."
💡 Why this matters: This section explains how symbolic interactionists reconcile micro-level human agency with the existence of large-scale social structures — structures are real but emergent from, and sustained by, ongoing human interpretation and interaction.
🔑 Definition — Joint action: Collective action that emerges when individuals fit their lines of action to one another, creating a character of its own not reducible to individual acts.
Topic 170: Concluding remarks
The single most important theory in symbolic interactionism is that of G. H. Mead. Mead's theory accorded primacy and priority to the social world — it is out of the social world that consciousness, mind, self, and so on, emerge.
Four major criticisms of symbolic interactionism:
-
Giving up on conventional scientific techniques: Just because consciousness is qualitative does not mean its exterior expression cannot be coded, classified, or counted. Science and subjectivism are not mutually exclusive.
-
Vagueness of essential Meadian concepts: Concepts like mind, self, I, and me are confused and imprecise, incapable of providing a firm basis for theory and research. They are difficult to operationalize, so testable propositions cannot be generated.
-
Downplaying or ignoring large-scale social structures: The concept of social structure is necessary to deal with the incredible density and complexity of relations connecting episodes of interaction. It minimizes the impact of macro-organizational features of society on behavior.
-
Not sufficiently microscopic: It ignores important factors such as the unconscious and emotions. It ignores psychological factors like needs, motives, intentions, and aspirations that might impel the actor to act. Symbolic interactionism has moved in a decidedly micro direction, contrasting with the more integrative title of Mead's Mind, Self and Society.
The lecture notes that symbolic interactionism has entered a new, "post-Blumerian" age. Ongoing efforts seek to synthesize symbolic interactionism with ideas from other theories, "cobbling a new theory from the shards of other theoretical approaches," both micro and macro, while trying to redefine Mead's ideas.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the symbolic interactionist view emphasizes human autonomy — people are not determined by social structures but actively interpret situations and make choices, as captured by the Thomas Theorem. Blumer's concept of joint action shows that society emerges from micro-level interactions, not the other way around; large-scale structures are frameworks that shape situations but do not determine action. The lecture identifies four key criticisms: lack of scientific rigor, vague core concepts, neglect of macro-structures, and insufficient attention to psychological factors like emotions and unconscious motives. The post-Blumerian age involves attempts to synthesize symbolic interactionism with other theoretical approaches to address these limitations.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the Thomas Theorem and how does it demonstrate human creative capacity in making choices?
- How does Blumer define "joint action" and what is its relationship to large-scale social structures?
- According to Blumer, what role do large-scale structures play if they do not determine human action?
- What are the four main criticisms of symbolic interactionism discussed in this lecture?
- How does the "post-Blumerian" age differ from earlier symbolic interactionism?