π Lecture 45 β Relevance of Cultural Anthropology
π Overview: This lecture examines anthropology's role in a rapidly changing world. It discusses cultural homogenization versus diversity, the critical issue of cultural survival for indigenous peoples, and how contemporary anthropologists are adapting their methods to remain relevant by studying complex societies and engaging with the public.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture explores the impact of change on anthropology and the future of the discipline, focusing on the homogenization of cultures versus the need to study complex societies. It then addresses the tragic eradication of indigenous cultures due to progress, giving examples from Tasmania, Africa, and Brazil. Finally, it discusses the role of contemporary anthropologists, critiquing the professionalization and inaccessibility of the field and advocating for greater public engagement and "action anthropology."
π Lecture Summary
Change and the Future of Anthropology
Change is occurring at such an accelerated pace that it is difficult to keep up with all the changes in the world today. The recent revolution in transportation and telecommunications and the resulting increase in communications and travel are diffusing cultures at a much greater rate today than ever before. Some argue that cultural anthropology will lose importance in the future since it is only a matter of time when all cultures will be homogenized. Yet few cultural anthropologists are studying pristine cultures as the discipline is adapting to the realities of this changing world. Concern for survival of indigenous cultures and the study of complex societies is now the new focus area for many cultural anthropologists. There is also greater emphasis on using anthropological perspectives to deal with developmental problems. There is little evidence to suggest that the world is becoming a cultural melting pot, so despite cultural changes there is enough diversity in the world to keep cultural anthropologists occupied for a long time to come.
π‘ Why this matters: This section directly counters the idea that anthropology is becoming obsolete, instead positioning it as essential for navigating globalization and protecting cultural diversity.
Ensuring Cultural Survival
Cultural patterns β and in some cases people themselves β have been eradicated as a direct result of progress and economic development. The indigenous population of Tasmania in the 19th century, which was removed by white settlers for sheep herding, is a tragic example of cultural extinction. The 1884 Berlin Conference was a civilized way of dividing the spoils of Africa but did not safeguard the rights of indigenous people, and numerous conflicts on the African continent are based on this insensitive division and lumping together of different ethnic groups. The Brazilian Amazon shelters the largest population of the worldβs still indigenous people. But by building roads through the Amazonian frontier, the Brazilian government has introduced diseases such as influenza and measles amongst the indigenous communities.
π Definition β Cultural extinction: The complete eradication of a cultural group's patterns and practices, often caused by external forces like colonization and economic development.
π Example: The indigenous population of Tasmania in the 19th century was removed by white settlers for sheep herding, resulting in cultural extinction.
Contemporary Anthropologists
Anthropological research has great relevance for the public at large. Consider for example the role archaeology played in society during the nineteenth century. Books on the subject were widely read. Darwinβs work, for example, significantly changed beliefs on human history and development of the modern world. Throughout this era of advancements, academic archaeology was on the rise. This movement finally phased out the participation of amateurs in the field, creating a more elitist and inaccessible discipline. While professionalization has certainly had numerous benefits - including developments in "method, theory and culture historical knowledge", its negative aspects are causing a significant deterioration of popular interest in archaeology. A movement towards popularization through accessible writing must take place in order to involve the public and rekindle active interest in archaeology and indeed in other branches of anthropology. Accessibility glorifies the field of anthropology, rather than denigrates it. Nowadays, rather than writing holistic ethnographies, cultural anthropologists bring to the study of cities and complex societies a more nuanced sensitivity towards understanding and dealing with the issue of ethnic diversity. Anthropologists practicing "action anthropology" collaborate with other disciplines concerning the development of culture and how it relates to current pertinent issues.
π Definition β Holistic ethnographies: An overarching description concerning all aspects of life of a given community.
π Definition β Ethnic diversity: Different ethnic groups or the differences within or between them.
π Definition β Action anthropology: A collaborative approach where anthropologists work with other disciplines to address current, pertinent issues related to cultural development.
π‘ Why this matters: This section argues that for anthropology to survive and be relevant, it must move away from being an exclusive academic field and actively engage with the public on contemporary global issues.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture argues that while globalization is rapidly changing cultures, it has not created a cultural melting pot, ensuring the continued relevance of anthropology. A primary concern for anthropologists is ensuring the cultural survival of indigenous groups, who are often eradicated or decimated by "progress" and insensitive political decisions, as seen in the examples of Tasmania and the Brazilian Amazon. The lecture warns that the professionalization of disciplines like archaeology has made them elitist and inaccessible, leading to a decline in public interest. To reverse this, anthropologists must embrace accessible writing and public engagement. Finally, the future of anthropology lies in studying complex, modern societies with a sensitivity to ethnic diversity and by collaborating with other fields through action anthropology.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main argument against the idea that cultural anthropology will become obsolete in the future?
- Give two specific examples from the lecture of how "progress" has led to cultural extinction.
- According to the lecture, what was a negative consequence of the professionalization of archaeology?
- What does the term "action anthropology" refer to?
- How have the study subjects of contemporary cultural anthropologists changed from earlier practices, and what sensitivity do they bring to this new study?