π Lecture 23 β Acculturation
π Overview: This lecture examines acculturation as a specialized, often forced form of cultural change resulting from sustained contact between dominant and subordinate cultures. It explores the interrelatedness of cultural parts, the forces that drive or resist change, the barriers that maintain cultural boundaries, and the role of change agents in modern development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the concept of acculturation as distinct from diffusion, the principle of cultural interrelations and why change in one part affects others, the opposing forces that create reaction to change, various barriers to cultural change including language, values, and social disruption, and the role of change agents in facilitating or failing to implement change.
π Lecture Summary
Culture and Change (continued)
Acculturation is a specialized form of cultural diffusion that results from sustained contact between two cultures, one of which is subordinate to the other. While diffusion involves a single trait or complex of traits, acculturation involves widespread cultural reorganization over a shorter period of time. Historical events like colonization have caused acculturation in many parts of the world.
Some anthropologists describe situations of acculturation where the non-dominant culture voluntarily chooses the changes. Other anthropologists claim that acculturation always involves some measure of coercion and force.
π Definition β Acculturation: A specialized form of cultural diffusion resulting from sustained contact between two cultures, one subordinate to the other, involving widespread cultural reorganization over a shorter period.
π Definition β Coercion: An act of force rather than that based on the need or desire of a particular individual or society.
Cultural Interrelations
Because the parts of a culture are interrelated, a change in one part of a culture is likely to bring about changes in other parts of the given culture. This is the reason why people are often reluctant to accept change, since its consequences cannot be exactly predicted nor controlled. This insight of cultural anthropology should be kept in mind by applied anthropologists, who are involved in planned programs of cultural change.
π‘ Why this matters: Applied anthropologists designing development programs must anticipate that changing one cultural practice (e.g., farming methods) will inevitably ripple through other domains (family structure, rituals, economy), often in unpredictable ways.
Reaction to Change
In every culture there are two sets of opposing forces: those interested in preserving the status quo and others desiring change. The desire for prestige, economic gain, and more efficient ways of solving a problem are reasons why people embrace change. However, the threat of loss of these can lead other people to oppose change as well.
π Definition β Status Quo: The existing conditions or circumstances. There are always those interested in maintaining the status quo since they are doing well due to it, and others who oppose it since it tends to exploit them or puts them in a disadvantaged position.
Barriers to Cultural Change
Some societies can maintain their cultural boundaries through the exclusive use of language, food, and clothing. Some societies can resist change because the proposed change is not compatible with their existing value systems.
Societies resist change because it disrupts existing social and economic relationships. The functional interrelatedness of cultures serves as a conservative force discouraging change. Cultural boundaries include relative values, customs, language, and eating tastes.
π Definition β Cultural relativity: The realization that cultural traits fit in logically within their own cultural environments and that since circumstances around the world differ, cultures are also different.
Change Agents
Change agents including development workers facilitate change in modern times. Change agents sometimes fail to understand why some people are resistant to change and should realize cultural relativity and barriers to change.
π Definition β Facilitate: to make easier or to promote.
π Definition β Functional: useful or practical aspects.
β Key Takeaways
Acculturation is a rapid, forced, and widespread form of cultural change distinct from diffusion, typically involving a subordinate culture and elements of coercion. The functional interrelatedness of culture means that changing one part inevitably alters others, creating resistance to unpredictable change. Every culture has opposing forces for and against change, driven by desires for prestige and gain versus fear of loss. Barriers to change include exclusive language, food, clothing, incompatible value systems, and the disruption of social and economic relationships. Successful change agents must understand cultural relativity and the deep reasons for resistance, rather than assuming change will be easily accepted.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How does acculturation differ from diffusion in terms of scope, time frame, and power dynamics?
- Why does the functional interrelatedness of a culture act as a conservative force against change?
- What are the two opposing sets of forces regarding cultural change present in every society?
- List at least three specific barriers to cultural change mentioned in the lecture.
- What key principle must change agents understand to avoid failure in facilitating cultural change?
π Lecture 24 β Culture and Change (continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of culture change by examining the complex process of change, particularly in the context of urbanization and migration. It then explores planned change programs and their mixed outcomes, before turning to globalization as a major force driving cultural change with both positive and negative consequences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main areas: the complex process of change, where urbanization is seen as a circulatory system of people, ideas, and resources between rural and urban areas; planned change, which highlights that development programs often benefit only some segments of the population; and globalization, which accelerates cultural change, spreads technology, but also compounds inequalities and carries environmental costs. Key terms like globalization, urbanization, revamping, and environmental costs are defined at the end.
π Lecture Summary
The Complex Process of Change
Accepting change in one part of a culture is likely to bring about changes to other parts of a culture. To understand socio-cultural aspects of urbanization, it is important to view the rural area, the urban areas, and the people who move between them as parts of a complex system of change.
Until some decades ago, anthropologists made differentiations between the mechanical solidarity of rural areas and the organic solidarity of cities. Recent research notes that there is not a simple flow of migrants from rural areas to urban areas but rather a circulation of people between these areas. Urbanization or the process of rural development therefore needs to take into account the fact that there is a constant criss-crossing of people, ideas and resources from urban to rural areas.
Rural migrants rely on kinsmen for land purchase, dispute resolution or general household management, while they go to the cities in search for cash based employment. Conversely rural kinsmen may in turn obtain economic support from a urban wage earner, or seek his support in finding work or a place to stay in the city for other kinsmen.
Planned Change
Planned change programs of change have been introduced into developing countries for decades under the assumption that they benefit the local people. Yet, a number of studies have shown that although some segments of the local population may benefit, many more do not.
Globalization
Globalization is a broad-based term which is used to describe the intensification of the flow of money, goods, and information across the world, which is seen to be taking place since the 1980s. Globalization has made the study of culture change more complex due to its varied effects on various cultural processes including that of change.
In some cases, globalization is responsible for an accelerated pace of change in world cultures. In other situations, the forces of globalization may stimulate traditional cultures to redefine themselves. Developing countries in the attempt to better deal with the forces of globalization, such as trade liberalization, have begun to revamp their own economic systems in order to make them more competitive internationally. This economic revamping has tremendous cultural impacts as well.
Globalization has resulted in diffusion of technology but also compounded existing inequalities. There are human and environmental costs associated with globalization. For example, increased productivity has led to pollution and there are many theorists who argue that globalization has also increased the gap between the rich and the poor, with those with wealth doing even better and those without it, experiencing even worse poverty than before.
π‘ Why this matters: Globalization is not simply a homogenizing force; it can simultaneously accelerate change in some contexts and trigger cultural revitalization in others, while also deepening economic and environmental disparities.
π Definition β Urbanization: the process of people moving from rural areas into the cities. This phenomenon is taking place in both developed and developing countries and cultural anthropologists are very interested in studying why and how urbanization takes place and the cultural changes it brings.
π Definition β Globalization: intensification of the flow of money, goods, and information across the world.
π Definition β Revamping: reforming or changing.
π Definition β Competitive: the process of trying to do better than those engaging in the same activity.
π Definition β Environmental Costs: the impact of a particular activity on land, water or air and on various other species which inhabit the Earth alongside human beings.
π Definition β Impacts: results or effects.
β Key Takeaways
A student must understand that culture change is complex and systemic, where a change in one part of a culture triggers changes in others, especially in the context of urbanization which involves a two-way circulation of people, ideas, and resources between rural and urban areas, not just a one-way migration. Planned change programs are not universally beneficial and often fail to help the majority of the local population. Globalization, a powerful driver of change since the 1980s, intensifies flows of money, goods, and information, accelerating cultural change in some cases while prompting cultural redefinition in others, but it also compounds existing inequalities and carries serious human and environmental costs. Finally, students should be able to define and differentiate between key terms like globalization, urbanization, revamping, and environmental costs.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How does the contemporary anthropological view of urbanization differ from the older distinction between mechanical and organic solidarity?
- What are two examples of the reciprocal flow of support between rural and urban kinsmen?
- What is a key finding about the outcomes of planned change programs in developing countries?
- According to the lecture, what are two contradictory cultural effects of globalization?
- Name two negative consequences of globalization mentioned in the lecture.
π Lecture 25 β Political Organization
π Overview: This lecture explores how societies organize themselves politically to manage public affairs, maintain social order, and resolve conflict. It introduces the four main types of political organization recognized by anthropologistsβbands, tribes, chiefdoms, and statesβand explains how these systems vary in complexity, integration, and leadership structure.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of political organization as involving allocation of roles, levels of integration, and mechanisms of social control. It introduces four types of political systemsβbands, tribes, chiefdoms, and statesβand explains that non-state forms often exist alongside state systems today. Specific examples include the Kung in the Kalahari for bands, the Nuer in Sudan for tribes, and pre-colonial Hawaii for chiefdoms.
π Lecture Summary
Political Organization
All societies have political systems that function to manage public affairs, maintain social order, and resolve conflict. Yet the forms of these political systems are diverse, sometimes embedded in other social structures.
π Definition β Political Organization: involves issues like allocation of political roles, levels of political integration, concentrations of power and authority, mechanisms of social control, and resolving conflicts.
π Definition β Public Affairs: issues concerning the public at large instead of specific individuals only.
π Definition β Social Order: the state of being where society functions as per the expectations of people and can provide them with a sense of security.
Anthropologists recognize four types of political organization based on levels of political integration, concentration, and specialization. Political organization is found within bands, tribes, chiefdoms, and states. Nowadays, non-state forms of political organization have state systems superimposed on them.
Types of Political Systems β Bands
Societies based on bands have the least amount of political integration and role specialization. A key example is the Kung in the Kalahari.
Bands are most often found in foraging societies and are associated with low population densities, distribution systems based on reciprocity, and egalitarian social relations.
π Definition β Egalitarian: a social system where all members have roughly equal access to resources and status, with no centralized leadership or formal hierarchy.
Types of Political Systems β Tribal Organizations
Tribal organizations are most commonly found among horticulturists and pastoralists. A key example is the Nuer in Sudan.
With larger and more sedentary populations than are found in band societies, tribal organizations do also lack centralized political leadership and are egalitarian. Tribally based societies have certain pan-tribal mechanisms that integrate clan members to face external threats.
π Definition β Sedentary: settled, not nomadic.
Clan elders do not hold formal political offices but usually manage affairs of their clans, including settling disputes and representing the clan in negotiation with other clans.
π Definition β Pan-tribal mechanisms: social structures or practices that unite members of different clans within a tribe to cooperate, especially in response to external threats.
Types of Political Systems β Chiefdoms
Chiefdoms involve a more formal and permanent political structure than is found in tribal societies. Political authority in chiefdoms rests with individuals, who act alone or with advice of a council. Most chiefdoms tend to have quite distinct social ranks and rely on feasting and tribute as a major way of distributing goods.
In the late nineteenth and twentieth century, many societies had chiefdoms imposed on them by colonial powers for administrative convenience, for example, British impositions in Nigeria, Kenya, and Australia. The pre-colonial Hawaiian political system of the 18th century was a typical chiefdom.
π Definition β Colonial powers: at different phases of history, different nations have been powerful enough to colonize other nations. In the 19th century, Britain was a colonial power which was able to colonize many other countries located on the African and Asian continents.
π Definition β Pre-colonial: the period in history when a particular nation had not yet been colonized.
Useful Terms
π Definition β Allocation: distribution. π Definition β Integration: tied together or linked in a particular manner.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the spectrum from bands to chiefdoms shows how political complexity increases with population density, sedentism, and social stratificationβbut all forms are legitimate systems for maintaining order.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture defines political organization as the system for managing public affairs, maintaining social order, and resolving conflict, with four recognized types based on levels of integration and specialization. Bands, found in foraging societies like the Kung, have the least political integration and are egalitarian. Tribal organizations, found among horticulturists and pastoralists like the Nuer, are also egalitarian but use pan-tribal mechanisms and clan elders for integration. Chiefdoms, like pre-colonial Hawaii, have formal, permanent leadership with distinct social ranks and distribution through feasting and tribute. A critical point is that modern states often overlay these non-state forms, and colonial powers sometimes imposed chiefdoms for administrative convenience.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four types of political organization recognized by anthropologists?
- What type of society is associated with bands, and what is a key example given in the lecture?
- How do tribal organizations differ from bands in terms of population and integration mechanisms?
- What two methods of distribution are typical of chiefdoms, and what is an example of a historical chiefdom?
- What role did colonial powers play in the development of chiefdoms in the 19th and 20th centuries?
π Lecture 26 β State Systems
π Overview: This lecture examines the most complex form of political organizationβthe state system. It explores how states differ from bands, tribes, and chiefdoms through their monopoly on force and centralized authority, and reviews key theories explaining why people surrender autonomy to state power, including voluntaristic and coercive models of state formation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the defining characteristics of state systems, including their monopoly on force, taxation, and law enforcement. It introduces the concept of the nation-state and the distinction between nation and state. It then presents three major theories of state formation: the voluntaristic theory, the hydraulic theory, and the coercive theory, along with definitions of key terms.
π Lecture Summary
POLITICAL ORGANIZATION (continued)
State systems have the greatest amount of political integration, specialized political roles, and maintain authority on the basis of an ideology. States are associated with intensive agriculture, market economies, urbanization, and complex forms of social stratification. States began to be formed 5,500 years ago, with the Greek city-states and the Roman Empire providing impressive examples of state-based political organization.
States have a monopoly on the use of force and can make and enforce laws, collect taxes, and recruit labor for military service and public works. These powers differentiate states from other forms of political organization. States are now the most prominent form of political organization found around the world today.
Nation-States
A nation is a group of people sharing a common symbolic identity, culture, history, and religion. A state is a distinct political structure like bands, tribes, and chiefdoms.
A nation-state refers to a group of people sharing a common cultural background and unified by a political structure that they consider to be legitimate. Few of the worldβs 200 nation-states have homogenous populations to fit the description of a nation-state.
Political Organization Theories
Theories explaining the rise of state systems have centered on the question of why people surrender some of their autonomy to the power and authority of the state. Some theorists argue that political organization is influenced by self-interest, while others argue that self-interest is not enough and that such organization often involves a certain amount of coercion.
Voluntaristic State Formation
Some theorists suggest that those engaging in specialized labor voluntarily gave up their autonomy in exchange for perceived benefits. Political integration can mediate between and protect interests of varied groups and provide them an economic superstructure required for specialization (Childe, 1936).
Hydraulic Theory of State Formation
Small-scale farmers in arid or semi-arid areas also voluntarily merged into larger political entities due to the economic advantage of large-scale irrigation (Karl Wittfogel, 1957).
Coercive Theory of State Formation
Another explanation for state-based political organization is offered by Carneiro, who holds that states developed as a result of warfare and coercion rather than due to voluntary self-interest.
π Definition β Coercion: use of force π Definition β Arid: dry π Definition β Small-scale farmers: farmers possessing a little amount of land π Definition β Irrigation: the channeling of water from its natural route for the purposes of agriculture π Definition β Monopoly: dominating the production of a particular product π Definition β Hydraulic: water-based π Definition β Homogenous: identical to others, opposite of heterogeneous π Definition β Recruit: to include or to involve
β Key Takeaways
State systems represent the highest level of political integration, characterized by a monopoly on force, lawmaking, taxation, and labor recruitment for public works. The nation-state combines a shared cultural identity with a legitimate political structure, though few states are truly homogenous. Three main theories explain state formation: voluntaristic theories emphasize voluntary surrender of autonomy for economic benefits; the hydraulic theory attributes state formation to the advantages of large-scale irrigation in arid regions; and coercive theory argues that states emerged through warfare and force rather than voluntary agreement.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key differences between a state and other forms of political organization like bands, tribes, and chiefdoms?
- What is a nation-state, and why do few of the world's 200 nation-states fit this description perfectly?
- According to Childe's voluntaristic theory, why did people surrender their autonomy to form states?
- How does Wittfogel's hydraulic theory explain state formation in arid and semi-arid regions?
- Contrast Carneiro's coercive theory with the voluntaristic approach to state formation.
π Lecture 27 β Political Organization (continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of political organization by examining how societies maintain social control. It contrasts informal mechanisms used in band and tribal societies with formal mechanisms like laws and courts, explaining how different cultures define and enforce their social norms to ensure order and resolve conflicts.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture addresses the universal need for social control in political organization, defining social norms and their sanctions. It then explores maintaining social control through both informal mechanisms (socialization, public opinion, age organizations) and formal mechanisms (song duets, social intermediaries, moots, and courts with codified laws). Useful terms like administrative, judicial, and legislative systems are also defined.
π Lecture Summary
Need for Social Control
All forms of political organization must provide means for social control. Every culture defines what are considered normal, proper, or expected ways of behaving, known as social norms. These norms range from etiquette to laws and imply different forms of enforcement and sanctions. Breaking some norms has minor consequences, while others (like taking a life or stealing) result in severe punishment.
Social Norms
All social norms are sanctioned according to the values held by different cultures. Positive social norms reward people for behaving in socially expected ways, ranging from praise or social approval to awards or medals. Negative social norms punish people for violating norms, ranging from disapproval to corporal punishment.
Maintaining Social Control
Band and tribal societies (such as the Inuit and Kung) maintain social control through informal mechanisms. More complex societies control behavior through formal mechanisms like laws and law enforcement agencies, whose major function is maintaining social order and resolving conflicts.
Informal Mechanisms
Socialization ensures that people are taught their social norms. Public opinion or social pressure serves as an effective mechanism to avoid censure and rejection. Age organization provides distinct age categories with defined sets of social roles. Lineage obligations and informal sanctions also guide behavior.
Formal Mechanisms
Formal mechanisms include song duets among the Inuit to settle disputes. Social intermediaries, like the Leopard-skin Chief of the Neur in southern Sudan, settle murder disputes through property settlements. Moots are formal airings of disputes involving kinsmen and friends of litigants, with ad hoc adjudicating bodies. Finally, courts and codified laws forbid individual use of force and provide legal frameworks established by legislative bodies, interpreted by judicial bodies, and implemented by administrative systems like law enforcement agencies.
π Definition β Social Norms: Expected ways of behaving in a society, ranging from etiquette to laws. π Definition β Social Control: Mechanisms, both informal and formal, that maintain social order and resolve conflicts. π Definition β Sanctions: Rewards for following norms (positive) or punishments for violating them (negative). π Definition β Moots: Formal airings of disputes involving kinsmen and friends, adjudicated by ad hoc bodies. π Contrast: Band/tribal societies use informal mechanisms (socialization, public opinion); state societies use formal mechanisms (laws, courts, police). π‘ Why this matters: This shows that all societies, regardless of complexity, have systems to enforce norms, but the mechanisms shift from personal and community-based to impersonal and institutionalized as societies become larger and more stratified.
β Key Takeaways
- Every political organization must include mechanisms for social control to enforce social norms through positive and negative sanctions.
- Band and tribal societies rely primarily on informal mechanisms like socialization, public opinion, lineage obligations, and age organizations.
- State societies use formal mechanisms including courts, codified laws, and law enforcement agencies to maintain order and resolve disputes.
- Examples of formal dispute resolution include song duets (Inuit), social intermediaries (Leopard-skin Chief of the Neur), and moots (ad hoc hearings with kinsmen and friends).
- The progression from informal to formal control reflects increasing social complexity and the need for non-personal, institutionalized authority.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of social norms, and why do they require different types of sanctions?
- List three informal mechanisms of social control used in band and tribal societies.
- What is the role of a social intermediary like the Leopard-skin Chief of the Neur?
- How do moots differ from courts with codified laws in terms of procedure and participants?
- Name the three systems (legislative, judicial, administrative) that support formal social control through law.
π Lecture 28 β Psychology and Culture
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between psychology and culture, focusing on how psychological development varies across societies. It examines universal psychological traits versus culturally-specific patterns, particularly in emotional development, cognition, and child-rearing practices, challenging ethnocentric stereotypes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Anthropologists study psychological differences and similarities between societies, rejecting stereotypes based on hasty ethnocentric judgments. Key inquiries include whether all humans develop psychologically in the same way, what explains personality differences across societies, how different cultures conceive of personality and psychological development, and what cultural variations may be explained by cultural factors. The lecture addresses emotional development, psychological universals, cognition and culture, and cross-cultural variations in child-rearing practices.
π Lecture Summary
PSYCHOLOGY AND CULTURE
Anthropologists are interested in the psychological differences and similarities between societies and cultures of the world. Cultural Anthropologists reject stereotypes based on hasty ethnocentric judgments.
The major questions of relevance to cultural anthropologists attempting to understand the linkage between different cultures and what they can reveal about the human personality are:
- Do all human beings develop psychologically in the same way?
- What explains the psychological differences in personality characteristics from one society to another?
- How do people in different societies conceive of personality and psychological development?
- What types of cultural variations may be explained due to cultural factors?
Emotional Development
Early research in anthropology was concerned mainly with supposedly universal stages of emotional development which seems to be affected by cultural differences. Margaret Mead found Samoan girls were much less rebellious or emotional turmoil than those in western societies. In western societies, adolescence is a time of turmoil that helps prepare emotionally for independence.
Psychological Universals
The ability to make binary contrasts, order phenomenon, plan for the future, and have an understanding of the world are universal psychological traits. All people have a concept of the self, they can empathize with others and feel and recognize emotions in others.
Cognition and Culture
Recent research on psychological universals focuses on cognitive, or intellectual, development. For example, it considers how different cultures acquire thinking habits such as formal-operation notions, which enable a person to think of the possible outcomes of a hypothetical situation. In looking for universals, many researchers have discovered some apparent differences. Yet most tests used in anthropological research favors thinking patterns taught in formal schools in Western cultures.
π Definition β Universal: common in all cultures π Definition β Formal schools: schools organized by the public or private sector, but with a standardized curriculum and professional teaching staff π Definition β Intellectual: concerning the intellect and the process of thinking
Cross-Cultural Variations
Instead of focusing on uniqueness, anthropologists look at psychological differences found within and between different cultures. Researchers focus on child rearing practices to account for observable personality differences. Some anthropologists believe that child rearing practices are adaptive and societies produce personalities according to their requirements (obedience, self reliance, etc.).
π Definition β Variations: differences π Definition β Rearing: bringing up
π‘ Why this matters: This perspective challenges ethnocentric assumptions that Western psychological development is the norm, and instead reveals how cultural contexts shape personality, cognition, and emotional expression in adaptive ways.
β Key Takeaways
Cultural anthropologists reject ethnocentric stereotypes and instead examine how psychological development, including emotional stages like adolescence and cognitive abilities like formal-operational thinking, varies across cultures. While certain psychological universals existβsuch as binary thinking, self-concept, and empathyβmost research tools favor Western educational patterns. Child-rearing practices are a key focus, as they are adaptive strategies through which societies cultivate specific personality traits like obedience or self-reliance. Understanding these cross-cultural variations is essential for avoiding biased generalizations about human psychology.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What four major questions do anthropologists ask about the linkage between culture and personality?
- What did Margaret Mead discover about Samoan girls' adolescence compared to Western societies?
- List at least four psychological universals shared by all human beings.
- Why might cognitive tests used in anthropological research be biased toward Western thinking patterns?
- How do child-rearing practices relate to a society's requirements for personality development?
π Lecture 29 β Socialization
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between psychology and culture, focusing on how socialization shapes personality and behavior across societies. It examines different personality types, cultural variations in normal and abnormal behavior, and the methods anthropologists use to study these psychological differences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the concept of socialization and its direct and indirect forms, the origin of customs in relation to survival needs, David Riesman's three common personality types (tradition-oriented, inner-directed, and other-directed), cross-cultural variations in abnormal behavior, the applied perspective in psychological anthropology, and projective testing methods like the Thematic Appreciation Test.
π Lecture Summary
PSYCHOLOGY AND CULTURE (continued)
Socialization is the term that psychologists and anthropologists use to describe the development of, through the influence of parents and others, of patterns of behavior in children that conform to cultural expectations.
π Definition β Socialization: the process of learning behavior that conforms to cultural expectations through the influence of parents and others.
Direct and Indirect Socialization
Socialization takes place both directly and indirectly. Indirectly, the degree to which parents like children, the kinds of work children are asked to do, and whether children go to school may at least partially influence how children develop psychologically.
π‘ Why this matters: This shows that not all cultural learning happens through explicit teaching β everyday experiences and parental attitudes also shape a child's psychological development.
Origin of Customs
Anthropologists not only seek to understand the link between personality traits and customs, but also how customs were themselves developed. Some anthropologists believe that societies produce the kind of customs best suited for undertaking activities necessary for the survival of society.
π‘ Why this matters: This functionalist perspective suggests that customs are not arbitrary but evolve to meet a society's practical needs for survival.
Personality Types
Several anthropologists have tried to describe the influence of culture on personality. In the early 1950's, for example, David Riesman proposed that there are three common types of personalities around the world.
I. The tradition-oriented personality places a strong emphasis on doing things the same way that they have always been done. Individuals with this sort of personality are less likely to try new things and to seek new experiences.
II. Those who have inner-directed personalities are guilt oriented. That is to say, their behavior is strongly controlled by their conscience. As a result, there is little need for police to make sure that they obey the law. These individuals monitor themselves. If they break the law, they are likely to turn themselves in for punishment.
III. In contrast, people with other-directed personalities have ambiguous feelings about right and wrong. When they deviate from a societal norm, they usually don't feel guilty. However, if they are caught in the act or exposed publicly, they are likely to feel shame.
π Definition β Tradition-oriented personality: a personality type that emphasizes doing things the same way they have always been done, with little desire for new experiences.
π Definition β Inner-directed personality: a guilt-oriented personality whose behavior is strongly controlled by their conscience, requiring little external enforcement of laws.
π Definition β Other-directed personality: a personality type with ambiguous feelings about right and wrong, where shame is felt only if caught or exposed publicly, not guilt.
Abnormal Behavior
Just as there are cross-cultural variations in βnormal behaviorβ, there are also variations in βabnormal behaviorβ. Abnormality is relative to a degree and a cultureβs ideas about mental illness and how to deal with it can also vary.
π‘ Why this matters: This highlights the cultural relativity of mental health β what is considered abnormal in one society may be accepted or even valued in another.
Applied Perspective
Anthropologists are interested in understanding the possible cause of psychological differences and the possible consequences of psychological variation. Anthropologists are particularly interested in how psychological characteristics may help explain statistical associations between various aspects of culture.
Projective Testing
People tend to project their feelings, ideas and concerns onto ambiguous realities. In Thematic Appreciation Tests, subjects are shown vague drawings and asked to interpret them by projecting their own personalities. An aggressive person may see a weapon in a vague drawing, whereas a more industrious person may visualize a more productive tool in the same vague drawing.
π Definition β Thematic Appreciation Test (TAT): a projective test where subjects interpret vague drawings, revealing their own personality characteristics through the interpretations they project.
π Example: An aggressive person viewing a vague drawing may see a weapon, while a more industrious person may see a productive tool in the same drawing β demonstrating how personal traits influence perception.
Useful Terms
π Definition β Ambiguous: unclear or vague
π Definition β Variation: differences
π Definition β Socialization: the process of learning behavior
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: socialization occurs both directly through teaching and indirectly through life circumstances; David Riesman's three personality types (tradition-oriented, inner-directed, and other-directed) show how culture shapes individual psychological orientation; abnormal behavior is culturally relative and varies across societies; anthropologists use projective tests like the Thematic Appreciation Test to study personality by having subjects interpret ambiguous stimuli; and that customs may develop as functional adaptations necessary for society's survival.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of socialization according to anthropologists and psychologists?
- What are the three personality types proposed by David Riesman in the early 1950's?
- How does an inner-directed personality differ from an other-directed personality in terms of guilt and shame?
- Why is abnormal behavior considered relative rather than universal across cultures?
- How does the Thematic Appreciation Test (TAT) work, and what does it reveal about a person's personality?
π Lecture 30 β Ideology and Culture
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of ideology as a collection of ideas that form the basis of public opinion and common sense in any society. It explores how dominant ideologies appear neutral while shaping social norms, how organizations influence ideology for power, and the relationship between ideology and hegemony, particularly through the work of Antonio Gramsci.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture defines ideology and explains its role in everyday life, including how it appears neutral while marginalizing alternative viewpoints. It discusses how political organizations and moral entrepreneurs influence ideology, introduces the concept of hegemony through Gramsci's work and the lacunar discourse, and examines epistemological ideologies including the critique of science as an ideology (scientism) and misleading fields such as ecology and economics.
π Lecture Summary
Ideology and Culture
An ideology is a collection of ideas that can be thought of as a comprehensive vision or a way of looking at things. It can also be seen as a set of ideas proposed by the dominant class of a society to all members of that society.
For example, different types of gender ideologies would describe what roles are expected of women and men in a society. The ideology of economic liberalization could be seen to particularly promote the interests of the business classes.
Ideology in Everyday Life
Every society has an ideology that forms the basis of public opinion or common sense, a basis that usually remains invisible to most people within the society. This dominant ideology appears as 'neutral', while all others that differ from the norm are often seen as radical, no matter what the actual circumstances may be.
Influencing Ideology
Organizations that strive for power influence the ideology of a society to provide a favorable environment for them. Political organizations (governments included) and other groups (e.g., lobbyists) try to influence people by broadcasting their opinions, which is the reason why so often many people in a society seem to think alike.
A certain ethic usually forms the basis of an ideology. Ideology studied as ideology (rather than examples of specific ideologies) has been carried out under the name systematic ideology. There are many different kinds of ideology: political, social, epistemological, ethical.
The popularity of an ideology is in part due to the influence of moral entrepreneurs, who sometimes act in their own interests. A political ideology is the body of ideals, principles, doctrine, myth or symbols of a social movement, institution, class, or large group that references some political and cultural plan. It can be a construct of political thought, often defining political parties and their policy.
Hegemony
When most people in a society think alike about certain matters, or even forget that there are alternatives to the current state of affairs, we arrive at the concept of Hegemony, about which the philosopher Antonio Gramsci wrote. The much smaller-scale concept of groupthink also owes something to his work.
The ideologies of the dominant class of a society are proposed to all members of that society in order to make the ruling class' interests appear to be the interests of all, and thereby achieve hegemony. To reach this goal, ideology makes use of a special type of discourse: the lacunar discourse.
A number of propositions, which are never untrue, suggest a number of other propositions, which are. In this way, the essence of the lacunar discourse is what is not told (but is suggested).
Epistemological ideologies
Even when the challenging of existing beliefs is encouraged, as in science, the dominant paradigm or mindset can prevent certain challenges, theories or experiments from being advanced. The philosophy of science mostly concerns itself with reducing the impact of these prior ideologies so that science can proceed with its primary task, which is (according to science) to create knowledge.
There are critics who view science as an ideology itself, called scientism. Some scientists respond that, while the scientific method is itself an ideology, as it is a collection of ideas, there is nothing particularly wrong or bad about it.
Other critics point out that while science itself is not a misleading ideology, there are some fields of study within science that are misleading. Two examples discussed here are in the fields of ecology and economics.
π Definition β Ideology: a collection of ideas that forms a comprehensive vision or way of looking at things, often proposed by the dominant class to all members of society.
π Definition β Hegemony: when most people in a society think alike about certain matters or forget there are alternatives to the current state of affairs (Antonio Gramsci).
π Definition β Lacunar discourse: a special type of discourse where a number of propositions that are never untrue suggest a number of other propositions which are; the essence is what is not told but is suggested.
π Definition β Scientism: the view that science itself is an ideology.
π Definition β Moral entrepreneurs: those who make up new morals according to their cultural needs.
π Definition β Groupthink: a much smaller-scale concept related to hegemony where people think alike.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that ideology is an invisible force shaping every society's public opinion and common sense, appearing neutral while marginalizing alternatives. Hegemony, as described by Gramsci, occurs when the dominant class's ideology becomes accepted as universal through lacunar discourse that suggests more than it states. Political organizations, governments, and moral entrepreneurs actively influence ideology to create favorable environments for themselves. The lecture also critically examines science as potentially being an ideology itself (scientism) or containing misleading fields within it, particularly ecology and economics. Understanding these concepts is crucial for recognizing how power operates through shared beliefs and how dominant paradigms can prevent alternative theories from being advanced.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is an ideology, and how does it function in everyday life within a society?
- Define hegemony according to Antonio Gramsci, and explain how it relates to the dominant class's ideology.
- What is a lacunar discourse, and how does it help achieve hegemony?
- Explain the concept of scientism and the arguments for and against viewing science as an ideology.
- What role do moral entrepreneurs play in influencing the popularity of an ideology?