📘 Lecture 44 — MUSLIM THINKERS: QUTBUDDIN AHMAD SHAH WALIULLAH (1703-1763)-II (TOPIC 180-184)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the study of Shah Waliullah's sociological thought, focusing on his theory of revivalist movement and his comprehensive theory of social evolution through four stages of Irtifaqat. It explains how society develops from primitive forms to a perfected state, integrating rational Islamic interpretation with a living organism model of society.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Shah Waliullah's Revivalist Movement and its three antecedent traits of modernity, then explores his Evolution of Society theory where society is likened to a living organism. It details the four stages of Irtifaqat — primitive society, life of cities and towns, nationalism, and the caliphate — with special focus on the five social wisdoms that constitute the second stage of social perfection and the emergence of the state (Madina).
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 180: Revivalist Movement
Shah Waliullah interpreted Islam in the light of reason and provided the rational interpretation of miracles. Maqulat (Rationalism) is the fundamental aspect of his ideology that tries to explain material aspects of miracles. He tried to establish accordance among religion and rational sciences and endeavored to eradicate the rationalist's doubt about the truthfulness of religion. With the ascendancy of colonial control, the effects of modernity began to permeate Indian society, and the Muslim reform movement could not escape this impact.
Three antecedent traits of Modernity transformed the character of the Movement:
- The western type of education and Missionary Agency
- Translation of scriptures into local languages
- Technology of printing
Topics 181-184: Evolution of Society
For Waliullah, society is just like a living organism and is more like the human body. Various parts are interlinked, interdependent, and interactive. Society, just like a living organism, is subject to health and soundness, advancement and progress, regress and weakness, and decay and death.
According to Shah Waliullah, human life grows in stages: Childhood, Adolescence, Manhood, and Maturity.
💡 Why this matters: The organic analogy allows Waliullah to diagnose social problems as diseases and prescribe remedies, making his theory both analytical and prescriptive for Muslim society.
Irtifaqat – Stages of growth
He divided society after its birth into four stages of growth until it reaches perfection and called these stages as Irtifāq. Ways and means by which one can tide over his social and economic difficulties are called Irtifāq. "Irtifāq" literally means gentleness or the use of gentleness. So, Irtifāqāt means a work done collectively with cooperation and approach the things with gentleness. It is quite useful in management of human affairs and growth of societies or civilizations for collective good.
🔑 Definition — Irtifāq: The stage or degree of social development achieved through collectively working with gentleness and cooperation to manage economic and social difficulties for the collective good.
Four stages of Irtifaqat
Waliullah studied the structure and formulated a theory for the preservation of Muslim society. Historically, the growth of civilization (societies) can be into four stages:
- The primitive society
- The life of cities and towns
- Nationalism
- The caliphate
1. Primitive Society
The first stage Irtifāq is that of primitive society which has a minimal code of social behavior. The urges of food and sex are basic human urges, which ensure the continuation of human existence on earth. Food keeps man's body intact while the sex-urge preserves the human race and regulates generation. Allah has also inspired mankind to build shelters to live in and to defend himself against the weather. These needs are common to all men who have an innate desire to excel in the modes of acquiring them. For this purpose, different ways and means are adopted which include the use of agricultural methods, cooperating with each other, adopting civilized style of speech, cooking and monogamy. When society achieves these requirements of social development it acquires the first degree of its perfection i.e. the first Irtifāq.
An instance of this primitive stage is the life of Adam. As Allah has created him with a specific purpose that was to be His vicegerent on earth. To fulfill his physical needs he looks to his surroundings where he would like to find food and drinks of his taste, would desire beautiful women, descent dress, a house for shelter etc. On the other hand, man needs spiritual fulfillment as well. But he is inherently unable to guide himself spiritually on his own, which is why Allah sends messengers to the human society from within in order to save them from any kinds of impediments, and guide them spiritually as well. These messengers or leaders act as agents of Allah being naturally capable of a higher kind of perfection in bringing law and order to society and curing it of evils and removing obstacles.
📌 Example: In the primitive stage, society's requirements are rude and unpolished — basic agriculture, simple clothing, and shelter. Adam represents this stage where basic physical needs (food, sex, shelter) are met through divine guidance and natural surroundings.
2. Life of Cities and Towns
While in the primary stage the requirements are rude and unpolished, in the secondary stage they are more refined and polished as expansion to the former with behavioral knowledge and good morals. By means of dividing them into different classes such as domestic, social, and political etc., and testing them in the light of sound experience, high morality and the common welfare, they are rendered into such forms as make them better, more beneficial and less harmful. Therefore, the chief difference between the requirements and principles of the two stages is one of degree rather than of kind.
When these first requirements are met in its refined and sophisticated way, according to Shāh Waliullah, they need five sciences to usher in the second degree of social perfection. These requirements and the five sciences embraced together constitute the second degree of perfection, i.e. the second stage of Irtifāq.
The five sciences are:
i. Economic wisdom: As stated by Shāh Waliullah, it includes the adoption and utilization of edifying manners, new experiments and modes of eating, drinking, dress, domestic habits, dwelling, etiquette, sitting, walking, sleeping, enjoying conjugal life, travelling, the rules of cleanliness, of conversation, of medical treatment, of foresight, of festivities, of fellow-feeling, and of removing the death, etc. When those requirements are met in the proper manner and in the light of past experience it gives rise to economic wisdom.
All civilized people observe the above-mentioned items in some form or other and all great thinkers have tried to find out the best possible form of observing those conventions from their respective angles of vision. The naturalist has given more importance to the natural side; the astrologer has put much stress on the effects of the stars; while the divines have applied the principles of good and evil to decide its best form.
ii. Domestic wisdom: This wisdom shows the ways and means of preserving good relations amongst the different members of the family (society) in the secondary stage of civilization. It refers to married life, rearing children, protection, slavery, the right and responsibility to relatives, management and manners of companionship etc.
iii. Earning wisdom: It means that everyone should pursue a distinct and separate activity appropriate to his energies and faculties, such as agriculture, trade, crafts of fellah, carpenter, smith etc.
iv. Business wisdom: It includes matters of dealing, purchasing and selling, exchanging gifts, tenancy and hiring, landing, incurring debts, loans, or mortgage and so on.
v. Cooperative wisdom: It enjoins surety (security etc), bail, guarantees, co-proprietorship, commercial enterprise, power of attorney and tenure etc.
All these five social wisdoms have a great bearing on the economic life and activity of a society. This shows the extent to which Shāh Waliullah gives importance to the economic dimensions of social development. The second Irtifāq is the most important in the process of the perfection of a society and its role is more fundamental. If the second Irtifāq is duly achieved, its perfection in the remaining degrees is easily attainable. If these five wisdoms are practiced in a sound and suitable way, they give birth to innumerable developments in culture and civilization.
💡 Why this matters: Waliullah's emphasis on the second Irtifāq makes economic and social organization the foundation for all higher stages of civilization, mirroring modern sociological insights about economic base and social superstructure.
3. Nationalism
When these five wisdoms interact with the moral human excellences they give rise to the third degree of social development. This Irtifāq is mostly based on cooperation of men so as to achieve the outcome of the five wisdoms. Without cooperation these sciences can neither be put into practice nor produce the expected results. Cooperation is very much needed because men are not equally endowed with all sorts of qualities to work for the society. They include fools, the wise, the wealthy, the poor, the one who is capable of earning, and the one who is not. Some of them are practicing small and ordinary professions and the others do high professions, while some others have several commercial undertakings and the others are unemployed. It is just a composite figure of various professions. If these people do not co-operate with each other in realizing their socio-economic objectives their socio-economic life will be of no effect.
The interaction of the five wisdoms with each other and with the moral excellence and mutual cooperation naturally leads to the emergence of a socio-political organization — Madina or state. Madina is not merely a city; if the citizens of a group of cities and towns have this interaction and cooperation, their group will also be termed as Madina. Every Madina has a unity, which must be preserved in its original and perfect form, and its benefits should also be accomplished. This unity and perfection can be maintained and accomplished by Imam i.e. the government or the ruling group in Shāh Waliullah's terminology. The state is not confined to its boundaries, its marketplace or its edifices. The state, in fact, means a special kind of relationship among various groups. This relationship is imperative and is necessitated by the five principles.
🔑 Definition — Madina (as per Shah Waliullah): A socio-political organization or state characterized by interaction and cooperation among citizens, unified under an Imam (government), preserving a special kind of relationship among various groups.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Shah Waliullah's theory of social evolution presents society as an organic entity that grows through four determined stages of Irtifaqat — from primitive society to caliphate. The second stage (life of cities and towns) is the most critical, defined by five social wisdoms (economic, domestic, earning, business, cooperative) that form the economic foundation for all higher social development. His concept of Madina (state) emerges naturally from the interaction of these wisdoms with moral excellence and cooperation, governed by an Imam. The revivalist movement was shaped by three modern forces: Western education, scripture translation, and printing technology. Waliullah's integration of rationalism (Maqulat) with religious interpretation was his key contribution, allowing him to explain miracles rationally and reconcile faith with reason.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three antecedent traits of modernity that transformed the Muslim reform movement according to Shah Waliullah?
- What is the literal meaning of "Irtifāq" and how does Shah Waliullah apply it to social development?
- What are the five social wisdoms that constitute the second stage of Irtifāq, and why does Waliullah consider this stage the most important?
- How does Shah Waliullah define Madina (state), and what role does the Imam play in preserving its unity?
- What is the chief difference between the first (primitive society) and second (life of cities and towns) stages of Irtifāq according to Waliullah?
📘 Lecture 45 — MUSLIM THINKERS: QUTBUDDIN AHMAD SHAH WALIULLAH (1703-1763)-III (TOPIC 185-189)
📖 Overview: This lecture concludes the examination of Shah Waliullah's sociological thought by focusing on his concrete analyses of social institutions (family, economy, polity, and religion). It matters because it shows how Waliullah applied his systemic, organismic theory of society to diagnose the ills of 18th-century Mughal India and prescribe cures, including revolutionary change and the revival of jihad as a sacred duty.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Shah Waliullah’s treatment of four major social institutions: the family as the pivotal unit of society with detailed household management advice; the economy as a system requiring vocational balance and just distribution of wealth; the polity as an integrated religious-political system centered on the institution of Khilafah (caliphate) with procedures for choosing a leader, conditions for rebellion, and a three-point program for Muslim revival; and religion as the guiding force requiring purification of Islamic ideals, implementation of Shari’ah, and the obligation of jihad (understood as both armed struggle and revolution against corruption).
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 185: Social Institutions
Family Shah Wali Ullah considered family as the pivotal institution of society and provided valuable information about household management. He explained the psychological difference between the sexes, showing how in marriage they both complement each other. He noted that wife played a distinct role in tarbiyah (upbringing) of progeny. He listed seventeen prominent issues that needed attention in the successful conduct of households, emphasizing rights and duties of married persons and according special consideration to the rights of women. He devoted considerable effort in explaining ways that could create curable amity between marriage partners.
Shah Wali Ullah mentioned that the range of social affairs is extremely wide — all aspects of human activity, from cradle to grave, fall in the purview of social affairs. He advised that social conduct might be assessed from the beauty of culture and nicety of social interaction. Every nation is diverse in dress and manners. He asserted that food affects the body and morality in a subtle way, and consumption of intoxicants abates intellects and boosts bestial faculties. He stated that modes of customs existed in all societies. He recorded that when families who care more for personal gains than the benefits of society come in power, they plunge society into total social chaos. Under their protection, lecherous practices, drinking, gambling, usury, and reduction in weights and measures are revived. He advised that the solution lay in fighting these aberrations, stressing that it is obligatory on righteous individuals to strive hard in the eradication of these social evils.
Topic 186: Economy
Shah Waliullah mentioned that cooperation and smooth business dealings are pleasing signs in a society. In vocations he listed agriculture, mining, tool making, and many other occupations. He wrote that in commerce and trade, silver and gold came to be used as standard of exchange because these metals were precious and lighter in weight. He observed that many persons find difficulty in adopting a useful vocation and resort to gambling and larceny as profession. He pointed out that vocational balance is essential for economic stability — for instance, if the majority of people take to commerce and trade, agriculture will fall in dire straits. He advised that professions which encourage lewdness should be curbed in the larger interest of society.
Shah Waliullah observed that the economic system of his era in the subcontinent was predominantly dysfunctional. He believed that:
- Wealth originates from labor.
- Laborers and farmers are the fountains of labor and consequently of wealth.
- The system is made to help in the concentration of wealth.
- The labor gets exploited.
- The system becomes dysfunctional.
- Economic conditions influence man’s character.
- For upholding moral values, just economic order is necessary, i.e., proper distribution of wealth.
- Imbalance in organism creates health problems — same is true about the health of the system.
Shah Waliullah suggested that:
- Improving the health of the nation requires improvement in economic conditions.
- Revolutionary measures must be taken because when society becomes corrupt beyond control, then revolution is a must.
- When economic institution becomes an abscess, it needs surgery for its removal.
- The forces which hinder the performance of the working classes should be crushed mercilessly.
- For just distribution, centers of power to be smashed.
- A government which does not properly and justly manage the economic system should be up-rooted.
- The working classes should not be exploited; everyone should be paid on the principle of mutual cooperation.
- Production and income not based on mutual cooperation is not valid.
- Working hours of the working classes should be fixed.
- The economic system will become functional and society’s ailments will be cured.
💡 Why this matters: Waliullah's economic analysis is strikingly modern — he identifies labor as the source of wealth, diagnoses systemic exploitation and concentration of wealth, and prescribes radical structural change including revolution for a just economic order.
Topic 187-188: Polity
Shāh Walīullah did not see religion and politics separately. As a scholar of Islamic sciences, he conceived religion as a way of life, and in his Hujjatullah al-Baligha he successfully strived to present Islam as a code of human life, spiritual as well as temporal. Matter and spirit do not make any contrast in his system of thought.
Khilāfah relates to both of these aspects, and as man is the Khalifah (vicegerent) of Allah on earth, he is duty-bound to carry out the demands of Khilāfah. According to Shāh Walīullah, it is collectively incumbent (Fard Kifāya) upon Muslims at all times to elect and install a Khalifah possessing the requisite qualifications and preconditions. He gave several arguments: first, the collective reason of mankind requires that a Khalifah should be there to look after interests which otherwise cannot be protected. Secondly, the Khalifah is appointed to achieve the two categories of objectives that the Prophet (SAAS) was also sent to achieve. Therefore, obedience to the Amir or Khalifah is equal to obedience to the Prophet of Allah and his disobedience amounts to disobedience to Allah.
Shāh Walīullah argued that the establishment of Khalifah was given importance to appoint immediately after the death of the Prophet (SAAS), even before the funeral. Upon the Khilafah develops: the Jihad, the administration of justice, the revival of Islamic science, the establishment of the pillars of Islam, the defense of the Darul Islam, and such other things collectively enjoined upon the Muslim Ummah.
Two Kinds of Khilafah: Unlike early political thinkers of Islam (including Ibn Khaldun), Shāh Walīullah makes a distinction between Khilafah Zahiriyyah (outer/succession in temporal matters) and Khilafah Batiniyyah (inner/succession in spiritual matters). The outer caliphate is responsible for securing order and stability, whereas the inner caliphate guides the ruler spiritually and instructs the community accordingly. Shāh Walīullah also divided the Khalifah into: khalifah-i-khassah (special vicegerent) confined to the first two successors of Prophet Muhammad (SAAS), and khalifah-i-‘ammah (common vicegerent) dependent on traditional conditions outlined by orthodox Sunni jurists.
Process of choosing a Khalifah — Khilafah is established by one of four ways:
- Through the Bay‘ah (oath of allegiance) by the people of loosing and binding (from amongst the ‘Ulama’, judges, leaders, army commanders and eminent people) as was established the khilafah of Abu Bakr (R).
- Through the will of the outgoing or departing Khalifah who nominates the most highly qualified person — as was the choice of ‘Umar.
- Through the Shura (mutual consultation) of a certain group — as was the khilafah of ‘Uthman and even ‘Ali.
- Through the successful assumption of power by a man possessing requisite qualities — as applicable to Caliphs succeeding the Prophet (SAAS).
However, these four means are not inflexible. The most important consideration is the pleasure of the masses with the person, their consensus on him, and their respect and honor towards him. If he enjoys the confidence of the masses, establishes the Hudud, defends the Millat (nation), and implements the commandments of Islam, he is the Khalifah in whatever way he became Khalifa.
Conditions for Rebellion: According to Shah Walīullah, Khalifah-i-‘Amma and the Sultan (king) were interchangeable terms. He stressed three conditions under which rebellion was permissible:
- If the caliph refuses to obey the rules of the faith and turns apostate — rebellion is the best form of jihad.
- If the caliph kills his people, plunders their property, and rapes their women — he and his followers come under the category of robbers, and it is imperative to defend the people and annihilate such tyranny.
- War against the caliph who clearly violated Islamic laws is permissible in order to establish the law of Shari‘ah.
Guidelines for Khalifa: Should not involve himself in problems purely for worldly motives; should consider overall prosperity or the majority of his supporters; should not expect from a person more than his natural ability; should use persuasion and threats to prepare people to fight the enemy. The Khalifah should be: brave in the face of opposition, affable (halim) and wise, have highly developed senses of sight and hearing, and be well known to arouse universal respect.
Three-Point Program: Walīullah regarded the entire Muslim world as a single entity. His main concern was to restore Muslim dominance in the government of India, for which he outlined:
- Muslims must rely on military force to overcome political adversaries.
- Muslim society in India must be structured in accordance with early Islamic ideals.
- Muslims must explore the possibility of inviting Muslim intervention from outside, if necessary.
This is how he invited Ahmad Shāh Abdali to help Muslims against Marathas and the Jats, and invade India.
Revolution: Walīullah claimed that when the socio-political climate of the state goes incurably corrupt, it becomes necessary for every member of the state to bring about a revolution in order to remove the cancer of corruption.
Topic 189: Religion
The real mission of Shah Waliullah was: to purify Islamic ideals of all unhealthy influences, and to provide a fresh intellectual ground to meet the challenge of the time. He explained some significant factors for religious decline. According to Shah Waliullah, truth and Deen are identical terms as both have the same origin.
He observed that there was a prevailing situation of: corruption all over, sexual anarchy, a need for perfect implementation of the Shari’ah, and that Jihad was the answer. According to Shah Waliullah, the performance of Jihad at his time was inevitable for the betterment of society and for the perfect implementation of Shari’ah. By Jihad he generally meant revolution (inqilab), which is why he strongly recommended the retention of the spirit of Jihad for all times — neglecting Jihad is equivalent to the loss of collective good.
According to Shah Waliullah, Muslims must make their worldly life and economy strong and prosperous. They must make themselves militarily so strong that the enemy’s sudden and unexpected attack be effectively repelled. Muslims must always be prepared for both defense and offence against aggression, and must be infused with the spirit of jihad. He encouraged people to launch a rigorous fight against the corrupt order and rotten society till the rule of justice is established.
Crucially, Shah Waliullah explained that Jihad does not mean that all non-Muslims are forced to be converted to Islam by sword. He was against Islamization by sword. Instead, he was a strong believer of removing doubts from the mind of non-Muslims and newly converted Muslims, suggesting that the Imam (ruler) should convince people through rational argument instead of converting them forcefully.
Shah Waliullah suggested that the office of the Qazi (Judge) should be given to those who have never been charged with bribery; the Imam of the mosques should be paid high salaries; strict orders should be issued for the observance of prayers and the fasts of Ramadan for the overall betterment and welfare of the state.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Shah Waliullah’s sociological contribution lies in applying his systemic, organismic theory of society to diagnose institutional dysfunction and prescribe remedies. For family, he saw it as society’s pivot requiring male-female complementarity and moral vigilance against social chaos. For economy, he identified labor as the source of wealth, diagnosed exploitation and concentration of wealth, and prescribed revolutionary surgery — including smashing centers of power and uprooting unjust governments — to restore functional order. For polity, he insisted on the integration of religion and politics, distinguished between outer (temporal) and inner (spiritual) caliphate, outlined four methods for selecting a Khalifah (Bay'ah, will, Shura, assumption of power), permitted rebellion under three conditions (apostasy, tyranny, violation of Shari'ah), and proposed a three-point program including outside military intervention (inviting Ahmad Shah Abdali). For religion, he emphasized jihad as revolution (inqilab) against corruption, but explicitly rejected forced conversion by sword, advocating rational persuasion instead — all while calling for purification of Islamic ideals and strong worldly preparation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Shah Waliullah, what is the relationship between labor and wealth, and what specific economic problems did he identify in 18th-century India?
- List and explain the four ways by which a Khalifah can be established according to Shah Waliullah.
- Under what three conditions did Shah Waliullah permit rebellion against a caliph?
- What is the distinction between Khilafah Zahiriyyah and Khilafah Batiniyyah, and between khalifah-i-khassah and khalifah-i-‘ammah?
- What was Shah Waliullah’s stance on jihad and forced conversion? How did he define jihad in the context of his time?