๐ Lecture 11 โ Culture-III
๐ Overview: This lecture explores cultural universals that exist across all human societies, examines the concept of cultural lag where material culture outpaces nonmaterial culture, analyzes the relationship between culture, class, and media through different taste cultures, and discusses how cultural change occurs over time. Understanding these concepts is essential for grasping how cultures maintain coherence while evolving differently across societies and social classes.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main topics: cultural universals as identified by George Murdock through cross-cultural research; William Ogburn's concept of cultural lag where technology advances faster than nonmaterial culture; the three categories of taste cultures including high culture, folk culture, and popular culture as analyzed by Herbert Gans; and cultural change patterns that demonstrate cultural integration across different elements of society.
๐ Lecture Summary
Culture Universals
Anthropologist George Murdock searched through anthropological data on hundreds of communities worldwide in 1945 to determine if any cultural universals exist. He contrasted how different societies performed courting, marriage, funerals, games, legislation, music, taboos against incest, and potty training. He discovered that all societies engage in these behaviors, but different ethnic groups have unique practices. There is no uniform family structure, no worldwide method for teaching children bathroom use, and no universal method for burying the dead. Murdock found dozens of cultural universals by contrasting hundreds of cultures. The family is one aspect uniting all societies as it regulates sexual reproduction and child upbringing. All human cultures have funeral customs to deal with death. Another culturally universal tool for releasing social tensions is humour (Henslin, 2011).
๐ Definition โ Culture Universals: Values, rules, or other cultural qualities that are present throughout the incredible diversity of human cultures on the planet.
Cultural Lag
William Ogburn (1964) explained that technology advances quickly, creating new aspects of material culture (items) more quickly than nonmaterial culture (ideas) can catch up. Ogburn named this inconsistency "cultural lag" โ the reality that some cultural elements change more quickly than others, upsetting a cultural system (Macionis, 2012). The phrase was first used by Ogburn about three generations ago, meaning that not every aspect of a culture changes at the same rate. When one aspect changes, another aspect lags behind. The nonmaterial culture typically lags behind the material culture when it undergoes transformation, forcing nonmaterial (or symbolic) culture to play catch-up. For instance, if we become ill, we can enter symptoms into a computer and receive prompt diagnosis and suggested treatment. Software applications sometimes outperform doctors in examinations, yet we still visit doctor's offices because our traditions have not kept up with our technology (Henslin, 2011).
๐ก Why this matters: Cultural lag helps explain many contemporary social tensions, from debates about artificial intelligence and privacy to conflicts over medical practices and online behavior.
๐ Definition โ Cultural Lag: The inconsistency that occurs when some cultural elements change more quickly than others, particularly when material culture advances faster than nonmaterial culture.
๐ Formula: Material Culture Change โ Nonmaterial Culture Lag โ Cultural System Upset
๐ Example: Medical diagnosis software outperforms human doctors in some examinations, but people still prefer visiting doctors' offices because cultural traditions and beliefs about healthcare have not kept pace with technological advances.
Culture, Class and the Media
Cultural diversity was represented in the various aesthetic standards and tastes of socioeconomic classes during much of the twentieth century. According to Herbert Gans (1975), the three main categories of "taste cultures" during this time were high culture, folk culture, and popular culture.
High Culture: High culture encompasses the tastes and creations that the upper classes and intelligentsia encourage and use to set themselves apart from those lower on the social hierarchy and to draw fine distinctions within their ranks. High culture requires extensive education, technical know-how, and ample resources. It has long been seen by the affluent as a social sign of sophistication, learning, and fashion. Examples from Western cultures include classical music, opera, ballet, works by "great authors," and creations by artists regarded as having exceptional abilities and creative qualities. According to conflict theorists, the idea that high culture is much better than folk and popular culture reflects elite interpretations. One English researcher claimed that "the differences between trash culture and high culture show only that storytelling adapts to changing economic, social, and political conditions" (Simon, 1999:2). Shrum (1991:373) argues that aesthetic gatekeepers โ critics, reviewers, tastemakers, and opinion leaders โ are crucial in limiting artistic diversity and maintaining the separation of highbrow genres from folk and popular tastes. Their reviews are often shared through the media and "may be more widely experienced than the artwork itself" (Thompson and Hickey, 2016).
Folk Culture: The painting, dancing, music, and other creations of working-class and minority group members in their homes are included in folk culture, which is in many respects the antithesis of high culture. Folk culture encompasses activities like dance, low-rider car customization, quilting, doll making, and tube art. Produced for and by common people, folk culture is impulsive, familiar, and useful (Real, 1977). Susan Phillips (1999) in her book Wallbangin' divided graffiti into three categories: gang graffiti, political graffiti, and hip-hop graffiti (which she called "subway art") (Thompson and Hickey, 2016).
Popular Culture: Items that appeal to the population as a whole are considered popular culture. A bewildering variety of items that critics claim favor "vulgarity," "the commonplace," and the "lowest common denominator" are part of popular culture since they are produced for leisure, pleasure, and mass consumption (Bogart, 1991:63). According to Thompson and Hickey (2016), popular culture includes prime-time television, popular artist live performances, tractor-pulling competitions, mud wrestling, baseball cards, NASCAR, and mall Santa and the Easter Bunny.
๐ก Why this matters: The distinction between high, folk, and popular culture reveals how cultural preferences are linked to social class and power, with elite groups using cultural tastes to maintain social boundaries.
๐ Definition โ High Culture: Cultural tastes and creations encouraged by upper classes and intelligentsia that require extensive education, technical know-how, and ample resources to appreciate.
๐ Definition โ Folk Culture: Cultural creations of working-class and minority group members that are produced for and by common people, characterized as impulsive, familiar, and useful.
๐ Definition โ Popular Culture: Cultural items that appeal to the population as a whole, produced for leisure, pleasure, and mass consumption.
๐ Definition โ Aesthetic Gatekeepers: Critics, reviewers, tastemakers, and opinion leaders who limit artistic diversity and maintain separation between highbrow genres and folk/popular tastes.
Cultural Change: Today and Tomorrow
The most fundamental human lesson is that all things shall pass. Even dinosaurs, which lived for 160 million years on this planet, are now only represented by fossils. Will there be a human race after millions of years? The only certainty is that, given our dependency on culture, human history will continue to alter as long as humans exist. Usually, when one aspect of a culture changes, others follow. For instance, because women are now far more likely to be employed than their mothers or grandmothers were, today's college students are much more interested in producing money. Working for a living may not alter a person's desire to raise a family, but it does raise the average age of first marriage and divorce. These connections demonstrate the idea of cultural integration โ the intimate ties between diverse components of a cultural system.
๐ Definition โ Cultural Integration: The intimate ties and connections between diverse components of a cultural system, where changes in one aspect typically lead to changes in others.
โญ Key Takeaways
Cultural universals exist across all societies, including family structures, funeral customs, and humor, but specific practices vary by culture. Cultural lag explains why social norms and values (nonmaterial culture) often struggle to keep pace with rapid technological advances (material culture), creating social tensions. The concept of taste cultures reveals that cultural preferences are closely tied to social class, with high culture serving as a marker of elite status, folk culture representing working-class creativity, and popular culture appealing to mass audiences. Aesthetic gatekeepers play a crucial role in maintaining boundaries between these cultural categories. Finally, cultural integration demonstrates that all elements of culture are interconnected, so changes in one areaโsuch as women's workforce participationโinevitably affect other areas like marriage age and divorce rates.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What did George Murdock discover about cultural universals across hundreds of societies, and what examples did he identify?
- How does William Ogburn define cultural lag, and what is the relationship between material and nonmaterial culture in this process?
- What are the three categories of taste cultures identified by Herbert Gans, and how does each relate to social class?
- According to Shrum, what role do aesthetic gatekeepers play in maintaining distinctions between different taste cultures?
- How does the concept of cultural integration explain the relationship between women's employment rates and changes in marriage patterns?
๐ Lecture 12 โ SOCIALIZATION
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how society shapes human development through socialization. It examines extreme cases of feral and isolated children to demonstrate that social interaction is essential for becoming fully human, investigates the nature versus nurture debate, distinguishes between primary and secondary socialization, and explains how the self and emotions function as a form of social control.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the concept of socialization as the process through which humans learn culture and develop personality. Topics include feral children raised in the wild, isolated children deprived of human contact, the nature versus nurture debate regarding human behaviour, the distinction between primary and secondary socialization, and how society becomes internalized within us through the self and emotions, acting as a mechanism of social control.
๐ Lecture Summary
Society Makes us Humans: Feral children
Socialization is defined by sociologists as the lifetime social experiences that help people reach their full potential and acquire cultural knowledge. Unlike other species whose behaviour is largely biologically determined, humans require social experience to learn culture and thrive. The foundation of personalityโa person's enduring tendencies of acting, thinking, and feelingโis social experience. We develop our personalities by internalizing our environment. The nature versus nurture debate examines how much of a person's traits come from heredity versus the social environment. Feral children are children who are thought to have been reared by animals alone in the wilderness. Reports describe them as mute, walking on all fours, biting, scratching, growling, eating grass, lapping water, tearing raw meat, and showing indifference to pain and cold.
๐ Definition โ Socialization: The lifetime social experiences that help people reach their full potential as individuals and acquire cultural knowledge. ๐ Definition โ Personality: A person's enduring tendencies of acting, thinking, and feeling, which develops through social experience. ๐ Definition โ Feral children: Children who are thought to have been reared by animals alone in the wilderness.
Society Makes us Human: Isolated Children
Isolated children are youngsters who have grown up in severe social isolation. Examples include the girl named Anna who spent most of her childhood in a dark room, and the Austrian Fritzl family where a father imprisoned his daughter in the basement for 24 years. There have also been isolated incidents of such cases in Pakistan. Research on isolated children provides insights into the value of socialization and the effects of severe social isolation on human development. These children frequently experience developmental delays and lack fundamental social skills, showing how environmental conditions affect human development.
๐ Definition โ Isolated children: Youngsters who have grown up in severe social isolation. ๐ก Why this matters: Cases of feral and isolated children provide natural experiments demonstrating that without social interaction, humans fail to develop normal language, social skills, and cognitive abilities, proving that society is essential for becoming fully human.
The Role of Socialization: Nature vs Nurture
The role of Nature Following Charles Darwin's 1859 work on evolution, people believed human behaviour was instinctive and part of our "nature." According to these views, the American economic system reflected "instinctive human competitiveness," certain people were "born criminals," and women were "naturally" emotional while men were "naturally" analytical. Western Europeans incorrectly blamed biology for cultural variations between societies, leading to the ethnocentric and harmful assertion that people in technologically underdeveloped countries were less biologically advanced and "less human." This perspective contributed to justifying colonialism.
๐ Definition โ Nature (in this context): The theory that human behaviour is instinctive and biologically determined.
The Social Sciences: The Role of Nurture Biological explanations for human behaviour came under attack in the 20th century. Behaviourism, proposed by psychologist John B. Watson (1878โ1958), maintains that behaviour is learned rather than instinctive. Watson concluded human behaviour was rooted in nurture, not nature. Modern social scientists are wary of labelling any human behaviour as instinctive, though biology does play a role. Children inherit biological characteristics like height and hair colour, and genes contribute to intelligence, musical and creative skill, and psychological factors. However, whether you reach your inherited potential depends on how you are raised. For instance, children's brains do not fully develop unless they use them from an early age. While nature plays a significant role, nurture plays a larger role in determining human behaviour. Our nature is actually nurtured.
๐ Definition โ Nurture (in this context): The theory that behaviour is learned through social environment and interaction, not instinct. ๐ Definition โ Behaviourism: A theory proposed by John B. Watson that behaviour is learned rather than instinctive.
Primary and Secondary Socialization
Primary socialization refers to the early stages of socialization, which usually take place during childhood and within the context of the family. Secondary socialization describes the subsequent stages of socialization, which usually take place apart from the family. In Pakistan, family and religious traditions frequently influence primary socialization, while exposure to technology and international media has an increasing impact on secondary socialization. Understanding these different means through which cultural norms and values are passed down and reinforced is crucial. Socialization influences our sense of self, our attitudes, and our behaviours. Socialization can also exacerbate social injustices and keep prejudice and discrimination alive.
๐ Definition โ Primary socialization: The early stages of socialization, usually during childhood and within the family. ๐ Definition โ Secondary socialization: The subsequent stages of socialization, usually taking place apart from the family.
Society Within Us: The Self and Emotions as Social Control
A large part of socialization aims to make us obedient members of society through socialization into the self and emotions. Both the self and our emotions shape our actions. Influences affecting behaviour include expectations of friends, parents, neighbours, teachers, classroom standards, college rules, and local, state, and federal laws. What stops someone from running naked down the street in a fit of rage? The answer is socializationโthe society inside of you. Through social experiences, you develop a self that thinks and feels in certain ways, which disciplines you. Awareness of the self in relation to others is reflected in questions like "Would I get kicked out of school?" and "What would my friends think?" The desire to avoid embarrassment and shame goes hand in hand. As a result, your social mirror establishes reliable restraints on your behaviour. Socialization into one's body and emotions is so powerful that for some people, the mere thought of running naked makes them feel ashamed. In short, socialization is crucial for human growth. Through interaction with others, we develop our ability to think, reason, and feel. The end result is that our behaviour, thoughts, and feelings are shaped according to cultural norms. This is what sociologists mean by "society within us."
๐ Definition โ Society within us: The internalized social norms, self-awareness, and emotional controls that shape and discipline our behaviour according to cultural standards. ๐ก Why this matters: This concept explains why most people conform to social rules even when no one is watchingโsociety has been built into our very sense of self and emotional responses.
โญ Key Takeaways
Socialization is the essential lifetime process through which humans learn culture and develop personality, and cases of feral and isolated children prove that without social contact, humans cannot become fully developed individuals. The nature versus nurture debate shows that while biology provides potential, nurtureโthe social environmentโlargely determines whether that potential is realized. Socialization occurs in two main stages: primary socialization within the family during childhood, and secondary socialization later in life in contexts outside the family. Through socialization, society becomes internalized within us, creating a self and emotional responses that act as powerful mechanisms of social control, restraining our behaviour even in the absence of external authorities.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are feral children, and what do they demonstrate about the importance of socialization?
- How did the misinterpretation of Darwin's theory contribute to colonialism?
- According to behaviourism, what determines human behaviourโnature or nurture?
- Distinguish between primary socialization and secondary socialization, providing an example of each.
- Explain what sociologists mean by "society within us" and how it functions as social control.
๐ Lecture 13 โ Understanding the Socialization Process from Theoretical Perspectives
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the socialization process through multiple sociological theoretical lenses, including functionalism, conflict theory, and feminism. It also explores how individuals develop self, mind, personality, morality, and emotions through interaction, with particular emphasis on the symbolic interactionist contributions of Cooley and Mead.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers theoretical perspectives on socialization from functional, conflict, feminist, and symbolic interactionist viewpoints. It then delves into the development of self and mind through Cooley's looking-glass self and Mead's role-taking theory. The lecture concludes with an examination of how personality, morality, and emotions are learned through socialization, referencing Freud, Kohlberg, Gilligan, and Ekman.
๐ Lecture Summary
Theoretical Perspectives on Socialization: Functional Approach
According to functionalists, socialization plays a crucial role in maintaining society, strengthening social order, and passing down culture from one generation to the next. People are injected with the attitudes, values, beliefs, and conventions necessary to take and successfully fulfill the responsibilities of full, contributing citizens throughout the socialization process, which is compared to an inoculation. According to functionalists, one of the fundamental requirements for the social system's survival is the ability and drive to fulfill role expectations. These qualities are learned through socialization (Parsons, 1951).
Resocialization is crucial from a functionalist point of view since it assists a person in letting go of one role and assuming another, which is a crucial task. This method is thought to be necessary for smooth transitions from home to school, from work to education, from civilian life to military life, from the "free world" to prison, and so forth. According to functionalists, when socialization breaks down, the social system as a whole also breaks down. The failure to internalize social standards and poor socialization are thus blamed by functionalists for a variety of aberrant behaviors. In light of this, resocialization is seen as a means of rehabilitating criminals and promoting the survival of civilization. This is a sharp contrast to the conflict perspective's viewpoint (Henslin, 2010).
๐ก Why this matters: The functionalist view explains why societies invest so heavily in education, parenting, and other socialization mechanismsโthey are seen as essential for social stability and continuity.
Theoretical Perspective on Socialization: The Conflict Perspective
Socialization is one of the most potent and useful tactics used by individuals in positions of authority to uphold the status quo and justify preexisting social inequities, according to a conflict viewpoint. On a very basic level, socialization gets people ready for the roles they will play in society's hierarchy. The lower class may be socialized from birth to show deference to those above them in the social hierarchy and may be trained in skills that will boost their chances of serving those who are higher on the social ladder.
The media encourages racial, gender, and age stereotypes and teaches people how to see and treat the elderly, women, and people of color. Additionally, they frequently present a binary picture of society that reduces complicated problems to battles between good and bad, moral and immoral, and right and wrong. The government, the police, the wealthy, and the powerful are frequently shown as the moral, just, and righteous side that wins out, which conflict theorists argue is not a coincidence because they are all seen as legitimate sources of power and control over others. The media frequently portrays criminals, drug addicts, crazy people, and other threats to the status quo as being from lower social classes, other planets, or foreign wicked empires (Parenti, 1992).
The conflict viewpoint emphasizes that socialization is a multifaceted process. People experience a constant barrage of contradictory and competing attitudes, values, beliefs, and behaviors throughout their lives, especially during adolescence. For instance, most adolescent guys are taught that fighting is wrong, but if they leave a fight, their friends view them as cowards. Similarly, teenage girls may experience intense peer pressure to engage in sexual activity despite being taught that premarital sex is unethical.
Resocialization is seen by conflict-theoretic sociologists as an illustration of how those in control try to oppress and take advantage of others in order to maintain their own power. Resocialization reinforces the value of status hierarchies and compliance with the laws set forth by those in authority in total institutions like the military, prisons, and mental hospitals. Additionally, they support the status quo by rewarding unquestioning conformity and punishing individuals who question social injustices, challenge established hierarchies, or even dare to be different (Henslin, 2010).
Becoming Humans: A Symbolic Interactionism
The field of socialization may have made symbolic interaction the most significant addition to sociology. For the analysis of the socialization process, it is best to place a focus on the micro-level analysis of social interaction, the significance of primary groups, the interpretation of relevant symbols, the creation of a social identity, and viewing oneself as an object. Cooley's looking-glass self serves as a crucial theoretical foundation for the interactionist perspective on socialization. Mead expanded upon this framework with his research on the "I" and the "me," meaningful and generalized others, the processes leading to role playing, and the indissoluble connection between mind, self, and society.
Theoretical Perspective on Socialization: Feminist Approach
Socialization fosters patriarchy and maintains gender roles. It instructs people to internalize and accept gendered expectations and norms, many of which are harmful to women and other marginalized groups. The feminist perspective emphasizes the part that socialization plays in establishing gendered identities and influencing how people view one another and themselves. According to this method, socialization is seen as a place of conflict where people and groups can struggle against and question gendered expectations. This perspective has a weakness in that it tends to ignore other forms of social oppression and inequality in favor of focusing solely on gender.
Socialization into Self and Mind
When you were born, you had no ideas. You didn't know that you were a son or daughter. You didn't even know that you were a he or she. The lecture asks: How did you develop a selfโyour image of who you are? How did you develop your ability to reason?
Socialization into the Self and Mind: Cooley and the Looking Glass Self
The self is a component of how society makes us human, according to symbolic interactionist Charles Horton Cooley (1864โ1929). He claimed that social engagement is how our concept of self grows. Cooley (1902) invented the phrase "looking-glass self" to characterize the method through which this particular characteristic of "humanness" emerges.
Three components make up the looking-glass self:
- We visualize how others might perceive us.
- We interpret the responses of others.
- We create a sense of who we are.
๐ Definition โ Looking-glass self: The process by which our concept of self develops through social interaction, based on how we imagine others perceive us, interpret their responses, and develop a self-concept accordingly.
๐ Example: If we believe people think we are clever or uninteresting (step 1), we draw conclusions about what they think of us (step 2), and this frames our feelings and conceptions of ourselves (step 3). A positive reflection in this social mirror results in a positive self-concept, while a negative reflection results in a negative self-concept.
Remember that correct assessments are not necessary for self-development. Even if we blatantly misread what people are thinking about us, those misconceptions become a part of who we think we are. The self is never a finished object; it is ever a work in progress (Henslin, 2010).
Socialization into the Self and Mind: G.H. Mead and Role Taking
Play is crucial for our self-development, according to George Herbert Mead (1863โ1931), a symbolic interactionist. Playing with others teaches us how to assume the position of the other. In other words, we develop the ability to place oneself in another person's position in order to understand their feelings and thoughts as well as to predict their behavior. This takes time to developโyears pass until we fully master this skill (Mead 1934; Denzin 2007).
๐ Definition โ Generalized other: Mead's term for our sense of what other people think of us generallyโour understanding of "the group as a whole."
As we grow in this capacity, at first we can only play the parts of substantial othersโpeople who have a substantial impact on our life, such parents or siblings. Eventually, our capacity to assume the roles of others extends to our capacity to assume the role of "the group as a whole." To function well in human groups, we must learn to assume the roles of others. By predicting what other people will do, we can change how we act.
As we learn to assume the position of the other, we go through three stages:
- Imitation: Young children can only mimic others. They can only mimic other people's movements and statements since they do not yet have a sense of self that is distinct from others.
- Play: Between the ages of around 3 and 6, we pretend to assume the roles of particular persons. We may make up identities such as a firefighter, wrestler, nurse, or superhero.
- Team games: This third stage starts when we first start school. The relevance for the self is that we need to be able to play multiple parts in order to participate in these games, such as in a baseball game where each participant must be able to assume the role of every other player.
Mead added that the ego is divided into two components: "I" and "me." The "I" is the subject of oneself, the energetic, impulsive, and creative aspect of oneself. The "me" is the self as an object, consisting of the attitudes we absorb from other people's interactions. In English, "I" denotes the subject of an action, as in "I shoved him," whereas "me" denotes the object of an action, as in "He shoved me."
๐ Definition โ I: The subject of oneselfโthe energetic, impulsive, and creative aspect of the self.
๐ Definition โ Me: The self as an objectโconsisting of the attitudes we absorb from other people's interactions.
๐ Example: In the 1968 experiment by John Flavel, 14-year-olds gave more specific instructions to blindfolded participants than did 8-year-olds, demonstrating that older children could play the role of the other while younger children could not.
Learning Personality, Morality and Emotions
Our personality, morality, and emotions are vital aspects of who we are.
Freud and the Development of Personality
Sigmund Freud (1856โ1939) created a theory of personality development that has had a significant influence on Western thought. According to Freud, personality is made up of three components:
- IdโFreud's word for the innate desires that lead us to pursue self-gratification, present at birth. The pleasure-seeking id demands immediate satisfaction of basic needs like food, safety, attention, and sex.
- Egoโforms to adjust to the limitations imposed by the demands of other people, particularly parents. The ego acts as a check and balance between the id and the social pressures that stifle it.
- Superegoโrepresents our internalized cultural standards and values adopted from our social groups. The superego makes us feel guilty or ashamed when we violate societal norms or proud and content when we uphold them.
๐ Definition โ Id: The innate desires that lead us to pursue self-gratification.
๐ Definition โ Ego: The part of personality that balances the id and the superego against social pressures.
๐ Definition โ Superego: The conscienceโinternalized cultural standards and values.
According to Freud, when the id overpowers us, we violate social standards to satisfy our cravings for pleasure. When the superego outgrows itself, we become overly dogmatic in upholding those standards and wind up living in a restrictive set of rules. The ego works to keep the id or the superego from taking control. In the emotionally stable person, the ego is successful in resolving these tensions.
Kohlberg, Gilligan, and the Development of Morality
According to psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg (1975, 1984, 1986), moral development occurs in a series of stages:
- Amoral stage: Children only care about meeting their own needs; there is no right or wrong in their eyes.
- Pre-conventional stage (around 7 to 10 years old): To avoid getting into trouble, children follow the rules they have learned. They define right and wrong in terms of what their parents, friends, and teachers find acceptable or unacceptable.
- Conventional stage (around age 10): Morality involves upholding the ideals and standards they have learned.
- Post-conventional stage: People ponder on abstract notions of right and wrong and evaluate others' conduct in accordance with these notions. According to Kohlberg, the majority of people never reach this stage.
Carol Gilligan felt uneasy about Kohlberg's results because he had only investigated males. She decided to investigate whether men and women had different perspectives on morality. She found that women are more likely to judge morality in terms of interpersonal ties and how their actions impact others, while men tend to think more abstractly about what constitutes right and wrong, believing that interpersonal ties are mostly irrelevant. Later research found that both men and women use interpersonal connections and abstract ideas when making moral decisions.
Socialization into Emotions
Sociologists who research emotions find that emotions are not simply the results of biology. Like the mind, emotions depend on socialization (Hochschild 2008).
Global Emotions: Psychologist Paul Ekman (1980) identified six basic emotions that everyone feels: anger, disgust, fear, pleasure, sadness, and surprise. He noted that when we experience these emotions, we all exhibit the same facial expressions, concluding that these six emotions are hardwired into our DNA.
Expressing Emotions: We can convey our emotions in a variety of waysโusing words, gestures, and bodies. There are "rules" of culture, social class, relationships, and situations, in addition to "gender rules" for emotional expression. For example, American women are free to "squeal with glee" and jump while hugging in public to express their joyous surprise, but American males doing the same would be breaking a basic "gender rule" (Henslin, 2010).
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that socialization is understood differently by each major sociological perspective: functionalists see it as essential for social stability and cultural transmission, conflict theorists view it as a tool for maintaining inequality and the status quo, and feminists emphasize its role in perpetuating patriarchy and gendered expectations. The symbolic interactionist perspective, particularly through Cooley's looking-glass self (three components of self-perception through others) and Mead's stages of role-taking (imitation, play, team games) and the I/me distinction, explains how the self develops through social interaction. Additionally, personality (Freud's id, ego, superego), morality (Kohlberg's stages and Gilligan's gender critique), and emotions (Ekman's universal emotions with culturally specific expression rules) are all significantly shaped by socialization processes rather than being purely biological.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of Cooley's looking-glass self, and how do they contribute to self-concept?
- Describe Mead's three stages of role-taking development and explain what the "I" and "me" represent.
- According to the conflict perspective, how does socialization reinforce social inequality and the status quo?
- What are the three parts of personality according to Freud, and what role does each play?
- How did Carol Gilligan critique Kohlberg's theory of moral development, and what did her research reveal about gender differences in moral reasoning?
๐ Lecture 14 โ AGENTS OF SOCIALIZATION
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the key social entities that shape individuals' perspectives, values, and behaviors throughout life. It explores how the family, school, peer groups, mass media, religion, and total institutions serve as agents of socialization, influencing everything from core self-concept to social class reproduction. The lecture also explains processes of de-socialization and resocialization within total institutions, highlighting how identities can be fundamentally reshaped.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the family as the primary agent shaping core values and self-concept, including how social class influences parenting styles (Kohn's research). It then examines the neighborhood's impact on child development, followed by the school's manifest and latent functions including the hidden curriculum. Peer groups are analyzed for their powerful conformity pressures, especially during adolescence. Mass media's role in shaping attitudes and beliefs is discussed, along with religion's influence on moral frameworks and social mobility. The lecture concludes with an analysis of de-socialization and resocialization processes within total institutions like prisons and military boot camps (Goffman's concept).
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-072: Family
Our family is the first entity to have a significant impact on us, with effects that last a lifetime. Core views, values, and drives are formed through these experiences. In the family, we acquire our fundamental sense of self, notions about who we are, and beliefs about what to expect from life. We begin to judge ourselves as strong or weak, intelligent or stupid, attractive or ugly. The process of establishing ourselves as female or male also starts in the family.
๐ Social Class: How parents socialize their children depends greatly on their social position.
๐ Kohn's Theory (1959-1986): Working-class parents emphasize conformity and use physical punishment; middle-class parents emphasize curiosity, self-expression, and self-control through negotiation. The reason lies in parents' work experiences: blue-collar workers receive detailed instructions and prioritize compliance in their children, while middle-class workers have jobs requiring initiative and raise children accordingly. Some working-class parents with autonomous jobs (e.g., home repair workers) adopt middle-class parenting approaches, while some closely supervised middle-class workers (e.g., office workers) follow working-class patterns.
๐ Example: A factory worker who receives strict daily instructions will likely raise their children to obey authority figures without question, while a self-directed professional will encourage their children to question and explore.
The Neighbourhood
Neighbourhood quality significantly affects child development outcomes. Sociological research (Brooks-Gunn et al. 1997; Sampson et al. 2001; Wheaton and Clarke 2003; Yonas et al. 2006) shows children from underprivileged areas are more likely to encounter legal issues, become pregnant, drop out of school, and experience worse mental health later in life. More affluent neighbourhoods have fewer families in transition, allowing adults to know neighbourhood children and their parents better, enabling them to protect kids and keep them out of trouble.
Topic-073: The School
Formal education has both manifest functions (intended purposes like teaching knowledge and skills) and latent functions (unintended consequences that benefit society). Children learn universality at schoolโthat the same rules apply to everyone regardless of who their parents are. Schools have a hidden curriculum: principles not expressly taught but part of a school's "cultural message," such as patriotism, democracy, justice, and honesty embedded in lessons. There is also a corridor curriculum that children teach one another, which often emphasizes sexism, racism, and "coolness."
๐ก Why this matters: Conflict theorists emphasize how socioeconomic class divides children into different educational contexts. Wealthy parents send children to private schools where they learn values for higher status, while public schools serve middle-class and lower-class children. Blue-collar families teach children that few of "their kind" will become professionals, while middle-class families teach that decent employment beckons. Schools worldwide serve to perpetuate the social class, economic, and political systems of their respective countries.
Topic-074: Peer Groups
As a child's interactions with socialization agents increase, family influence diminishes. School introduces children to peer groups, which help them resist parental and educational socialization efforts. The Adler study (1998) of Colorado primary schools found children segregate by sex and create separate gender worlds. Boys' popularity was based on being athletic, cool, and tough; girls' popularity was based on upbringing, appearance, and ability to attract popular boys. High grades hurt boys' popularity but boosted girls' status.
๐ "Conformity or rejection": The guiding principle of peer groups. Anyone who disobeys group rules is labeled an "outsider," "non-member," or "outcast." Peer group norms frequently rule our livesโyou will likely enjoy the same music, take the same math classes, and follow the same fashion and dating norms as your peers. This applies to both socially acceptable and unacceptable behaviors.
๐ Example: If your high school friends use drugs or engage in theft, you are likely to do the same; conversely, if they are college-bound and upwardly mobile, you will likely share those aspirations.
Topic-075: Mass Media
Mass media (television, movies, social media, advertising) are significant socialization agents that convey messages and images molding people's attitudes, beliefs, and values. In Pakistani society, mainstream media can influence perceptions of gender roles, cultural identity, and physical attractiveness. Media informs the public about social issues and shapes political beliefs, as well as influencing health-related behaviors like smoking, dieting, and exercise.
Topic-076: Religion
Religion has a significant impact even on non-religious people. Religious concepts are so ingrained in American culture that they serve as a moral compass for both religious and nonreligious persons. For two out of five Americans who attend religious services weekly, the effect is more overtโthey acquire doctrine, morals, and values through congregational life.
Beyond doctrine, religious attendees pick up ideas about proper speech, attire, and etiquette for formal events. Congregational life provides a sense of identity and belonging. Additionally, it promotes social mobility for the underprivileged, helps immigrants make job connections, and has significantly influenced societal transformation (e.g., African American churches).
Topic-077: De-socialization and re-socialization: Total institutions
Total institutions (prisons, mental health facilities, military boot camps) are locations where people are completely blocked off from the outside world and immersed in institutional activities. They are designed to re-socialize people with new beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors while de-socializing them from former identities. De-socialization involves eliminating personal belongings, attire, and haircuts, establishing a uniform setting where everyone is treated equally.
๐ Resocialization: Learning new standards, ideals, attitudes, and behaviors to fit new circumstances. Occurs when learning conflicts with prior experiences. Most resocialization is minor (adapting to a new boss), but it can be powerful (Alcoholics Anonymous members surrounded by ex-drinkers reinforcing the harm of binge drinking).
๐ Total Institution (Erving Goffman 1961): A setting where residents are cut off from society and under the complete authority of ruling authorities. Examples include boot camps, jails, prisons, concentration camps, convents, some religious cults, and military schools.
๐ Degradation Ceremony (Garfinkel 1956): The process that welcomes a person into a total institution, attempting to recreate the self by removing the individual's current identity and imprinting a new one. This may involve photographing, shaving the head, or fingerprinting. Newcomers may be told to strip, endure humiliating semi-public inspection, and put on a uniform. The personal identity kit (clothing, jewelry, haircuts, body decorations displaying uniqueness) is removed.
๐ก Why this matters: Total institutions keep outsiders and prisoners in through guards, gates, fences, and bars. Eating, sleeping, showering, and recreation are all standardized. Prisoners discover their prior identities (student, employee, spouse, parent) are meaninglessโonly their current situation matters. The experience leaves a permanent imprint on identity and alters worldview.
๐ Example: A military recruit enters boot camp, has their head shaved, is issued a uniform, and undergoes a degradation ceremony that strips their civilian identity and replaces it with a military identity where their individual prior self is irrelevant.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must understand that socialization occurs through multiple agents operating simultaneously throughout life. The family is the primary agent that shapes core self-concept and values, with social class significantly influencing parenting stylesโworking-class parents emphasize conformity while middle-class parents encourage self-direction (Kohn's theory). Schools serve both manifest functions (teaching skills) and latent functions including the hidden curriculum and social class reproduction. Peer groups exert powerful conformity pressures during adolescence, often overriding family and school influences. Finally, total institutions demonstrate how complete control over an environment can fundamentally de-socialize and re-socialize individuals through degradation ceremonies and removal of personal identity.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Melvin Kohn, why do working-class parents tend to emphasize conformity while middle-class parents encourage self-expression in their children?
- What is the "hidden curriculum" in schools, and how does it differ from the "corridor curriculum"?
- How did the Adler study (1998) find that popularity differed between boys and girls in primary school?
- What is a "degradation ceremony" according to Garfinkel, and what function does it serve in total institutions?
- Explain the difference between de-socialization and re-socialization in the context of total institutions.