๐ Lecture 20 โ Counselor Qualities
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the essential qualities of effective counselors and the structured stages of the counseling process. It covers how counselors establish rapport, conduct initial interviews, set goals, and utilize specific skills during the middle phase of therapy. Understanding these elements is critical for building a productive therapeutic relationship and achieving client outcomes.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers counselor characteristics identified by Strong (expertness, attractiveness, trustworthiness) and Okun (self-awareness, honesty, congruence, communication, knowledge). It details the 5-stage structure of interviews: rapport, data gathering, goal setting, generating solutions, and generalizing learning. The initial session is explored, distinguishing client-initiated vs. counselor-initiated interviews, information-oriented vs. relationship-oriented first interviews, and non-helpful behaviors like excessive questioning. Finally, it addresses counseling goals, guidelines, and skills for the middle phase, including empathy, self-disclosure, immediacy, humor, and confrontation.
๐ Lecture Summary
COUNSELING PROCESS
LESSON 20
-
Strong (1968) identifies 3 characteristics of influential counselors:
- Expert: Expertness is the degree to which a counselor is perceived as knowledgeable depending on culture. Initially nearly all clients like to work with counselors who are perceived as experts.
- Attractive: Attractiveness is a function of perceived similarity between a client and counselor. Counselors can make themselves attractive by speaking in a clear way by using simple sentences and offering appropriate disclosure.
- Trustworthy: This quality refers to care, concern, sincerity, and honesty. Many clients test the trustworthiness of the counselor by requesting information, telling a secret, asking a favour, inconveniencing the counselor, deprecating themselves, or questioning the motives and dedication of the counselor.
-
Okun (1992) lists 5 important characteristics:
- Self-awareness
- Honesty
- Congruence
- Ability to communicate
- Knowledge
๐ Definition โ Expertness: The degree to which a counselor is perceived as knowledgeable, which varies depending on cultural context.
๐ Definition โ Attractiveness: A function of perceived similarity between a client and counselor; counselors can enhance it by clear speech and appropriate self-disclosure.
๐ Definition โ Trustworthiness: A quality reflecting care, concern, sincerity, and honesty; often tested by clients through various behaviors.
5-Stage Structure of Interview
- Rapport & Structure โ Example: 'Hello, that is what we will be doing today'
- Gathering Data & Identifying Assets โ Example: 'Tell me about yourself; what is bothering you?'
- Determining Outcomes / Goal Setting โ Example: 'What you want to achieve?'
- Generating Alternative Solutions โ Example: 'How can we look at the story differently?'
- Generalizing & Transferring Learning โ The learning achieved during counseling sessions is generalized to daily life. Example: 'Will you do it?'
๐ Formula โ 5-Stage Interview Structure: Rapport โ Data Gathering โ Goal Setting โ Generating Solutions โ Generalizing Learning
The Initial Session
There is always an initial session. It is during this time both the client and the counselor are assessing one another to see if the relationship will work.
- It is the initial interview when subject of the subsequent sessions will be discussed and determined.
- There are several skills which are useful during this phase of counseling.
Client-versus counselor-initiated Interviews
-
Benjamin (1987) distinguishes between these two types of initial interviews:
-
Client-initiated:
- When the initial interview is requested by a client, the counselor is often unsure of the clientโs purpose. This uncertainty may create anxiety in the counselor, especially if background information is not gathered before the session.
- Benjamin advises the counselor not to inquire initially about any problem the client may have. The client may not have a problem in the traditional sense of the word and may just be seeking the information.
-
Counselor-initiated:
- Counselors should immediately state his/her reason for wanting to see the client. In the case of a school counselor, for instance, a session might be requested so that the counselor can introduce himself or herself to the client. If the counselor does not immediately give a reason for requesting the session, the client is kept guessing and tension is created.
- Manthei (1983) advocates that counselorโs presentations about themselves and their functioning be multimodal: visual, auditory, written, spoken and descriptive.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding whether an interview is client- or counselor-initiated shapes how the counselor should begin the session to reduce anxiety and build rapport.
Information-Oriented First Interview
- Initial interview can fulfill two functions (Hackney & Cormier, 1994):
- It can be intake interview to collect needed information
- It can signal the beginning of a relationship
- The intake interview is usually counselor focused. The counselor will respond to the client predominantly through the use of probes, accents, closed questions, and requests for clarification.
- Openโ and closed ended questions are asked.
- Probesโrefer to questions which begin with who, what, where, how, or when.
- Example: 'What do you plan to do to complete your project?'
- Requests for Clarificationโ Asking the client for more information.
- Example: 'Help me understand what this relationship is for?'
Information Oriented Interview Format
- Identifying data
- Presenting problems: Both primary and secondary
- Clientโs current life setting
- Family history
- Personal history
- Description of the client during interview: clientโs readiness, motivation, appearance, behavior, tension, rate of talking, stream of thought, etc.
- Summary and recommendations
Relationship Oriented First Interview
When you can take the time to build the relationship with the client & gather information, there are other skills which you must possess and develop. In efforts to build the relationship:
- Focus more on the clientโs attitudes and emotions.
- Summary of Feelings.
- The required skills you need include the following:
- Restatement/Content Paraphrasing
- Summary of Feelings: A simple summary paraphrase several feelings which have been verbalized
- Reflection of Feeling: It refers to understanding of both non-verbal and verbal material.
- Acknowledgement of nonverbal behavior: You are noting to the client what you are seeing. You are not interpreting the non-verbal content.
๐ Definition โ Reflection of Feeling: A skill that involves understanding and communicating both non-verbal and verbal emotional material from the client.
Some Non-Helpful Behaviors
There are several lists of non-helpful behaviors. Most common among them include:
-
Advice Giving:
- However, Scak (1985) points out that advice giving need not always be destructive.
- For example, 70-90% of all responses on a crisis line are mainly advice giving (Knowles, 1979).
-
Lecturing:
- Lecturing is a disguised form of advice giving. It sets up a power struggle between counselor and client that neither individual can win.
-
Excessive Questioning:
- Excessive questioning is a common mistake of many counselors. Verbal interaction with clients needs to include statements, observations, and encouragers as well as questions. When excessive questioning is used, the client feels as though he or she is being interrogated rather than counseled. The client has little chance to take the initiative and many become guarded. Counseling relationships are more productive when counselors avoid asking more than two questions in a row and keep their questions open rather than closed.
-
Storytelling:
- Milton Erickson told stories metaphorically tailored to relate them to the clientโs life. However, generally story telling is discouraged as everybody cannot handle it skillfully.
๐ก Why this matters: Non-helpful behaviors can damage the therapeutic alliance; even advice giving, while sometimes necessary in crisis contexts, must be used judiciously.
Counseling Goals
- The counselor helps the client explore specific areas and begin to identify goals that the client wants to achieve. Without goals, the sessions will wander aimlessly.
- Goals within counseling help to set the tone and direction one travels with their client. The counselor gives the client an opportunity to talk about himself, reinforces the clientโs focus on self by providing structure, actively listening, and helping clients identify and clarify goals.
- Goals are the energizing fabric of daily living but are often elusive (Rule, 1982), such as:
- Unfocused goals are too broad, or not prioritized.
- Unrealistic goals are happiness, perfection, being number one, and self-actualization. They have merit but are not easily obtained.
- Uncoordinated ("Really" & "seemingly uncoordinated") are incompatible goals, e.g., a client who seeks counseling but does not wish to work on changing is an example of an individual with incompatible and really uncoordinated goals. Seemingly uncoordinated goals are those which appear to be uncoordinated but in reality are not so. Individuals with these goals donโt want to take responsibility, indulge in "yes but..." dialogue.
Goal Guidelines (Dyer & Vriend, 1977)
- Goals are mutually agreed on by the client and counselor.
- Goals are specific.
- Goals are relevant to changing self-defeating behavior.
- Goals are achievement & success oriented.
- Goals are quantifiable & observable.
- Goals are understandable & can be restated clearly.
- Goals are achievement & success oriented: Have intrinsic and extrinsic payoff for the client.
๐ Formula โ Goal Guidelines (Dyer & Vriend): Goals must be mutually agreed, specific, relevant to changing self-defeating behavior, achievement-oriented, quantifiable/observable, clearly restatable, and have intrinsic/extrinsic payoff.
Middle Phase: Working in a Counseling Relationship
- After relationship building (involvement and exploration phase), counselor moves with the client to understanding and action phases.
- The informed clients decide how to proceed.
- Johari window is a conceptual device to show that most of the clients enter the counseling relationship with the problem of self awareness. The clients extend the dimensions of the area of free activity while shrinking the dimensions of the more restrictive areas.
๐ Definition โ Johari Window: A conceptual device illustrating client self-awareness, with areas of free activity, blind area, avoided/hidden area, and area of unknown activity. The goal is to expand the area of free activity.
Counseling Skills in Understanding and Action Phase
Changing Perceptions There are several ways to "lead" the client forward in a session. They include using silence, acceptance, paraphrasing, etc. Be aware of how you lead and where you are going. You are working on the clientโs issues, not your issues, or what you think the client should be working on.
Leading Through the use of appropriate silence, acceptance, approval paraphrasing, reassurance, interpretation, etc.
Multifocused responding: Affective, cognitive and behavioral
- Affective Responding: Focusing on feelings.
- Behavioral Responses: Focusing on actions and behaviors.
- Cognitive Response: Focusing on thoughts and cognitions.
You will balance these throughout the session with a client.
Accurate empathy The use of empathy is one of the most vital elements in counseling. There are two types of empathy. The basic type is called primary empathy. The second level is known as advanced empathy (Carkhuff, 1969). Accurate empathy on both levels is achieved when counselors see clientsโ world from the clientsโ point of view and are able to communicate this understanding back.
๐ Definition โ Primary Empathy: The basic level of empathy in counseling. ๐ Definition โ Advanced Empathy: A second, deeper level of empathy where the counselor understands and communicates the client's world from the client's perspective (Carkhuff, 1969).
Self disclosure (Egan, 1990) Self disclosure has generated more than 200 studies. Self-disclosure is making oneself known to another person (the client) by revealing personal information. Counselorโs self-disclosure is necessary as it relates to the therapeutic process. Too much self-disclosure hinders the counseling process, while too little of it may inhibit the client from forming a bond with the counselor. Clients are more likely to trust counselors who disclose personal information. Egan pointed out two helpful functions of self disclosure: modeling and developing a new perspective.
๐ Definition โ Self-Disclosure: Making oneself known to the client by revealing personal information; it serves modeling and perspective-development functions.
Immediacy (refers to relationship during current counseling session, here and now) This involves a counselorโs understanding and communicating of what is going on between the counselor and client within the helping relationship. There are 2 types:
- "Relationship immediacy" (Between client & counselor)
- "Here & Now" immediacy focuses on some particular event in the session.
๐ Definition โ Immediacy: A skill involving the counselor's understanding and communication of what is happening between counselor and client in the therapeutic relationship, focusing on the "here and now."
Humor Humor can have a positive effect on the counseling process when used properly.
Confrontation This is not a skill at putting the client down for doing something wrong! This is an invitation to the client to look more closely at behavior that is not working or interfering with growth, change, or healthy functioning.
๐ Definition โ Confrontation: An invitation to the client to examine behavior that is not working or is interfering with growth, change, or healthy functioning.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam preparation are: (1) the three counselor characteristics identified by Strong (expert, attractive, trustworthy) and the five by Okun (self-awareness, honesty, congruence, communication, knowledge); (2) the complete 5-stage interview structure (rapport, data gathering, goal setting, generating solutions, generalizing learning); (3) the difference between client-initiated and counselor-initiated interviews, and between information-oriented and relationship-oriented first interviews; (4) the list of non-helpful behaviors (advice giving, lecturing, excessive questioning, storytelling) and their exceptions; and (5) the key skills for the middle phase of counselingโchanging perceptions, leading, multifocused responding, accurate empathy, self-disclosure, immediacy, humor, and confrontation.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three characteristics of influential counselors according to Strong (1968), and how are they defined?
- List the five stages of the interview structure as described in this lecture, including the example prompt for each stage.
- What is the difference between client-initiated and counselor-initiated initial interviews, and what advice does Benjamin (1987) offer for each?
- Name four non-helpful behaviors in counseling and identify the specific context in which advice giving may be considered appropriate.
- What is the Johari window, and how does it relate to client self-awareness in the middle phase of counseling?
๐ Lecture 21 โ Counseling Process
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the complex dynamics of the counseling process, focusing on initial resistances that clients and counselors bring to therapy. It explores transference and counter-transference phenomena, and concludes with guidelines for effectively terminating both individual sessions and the overall counseling relationship.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers initial resistances in counseling, including cultural handicaps and counselor-induced barriers, using the force field analysis model. It then addresses practical strategies for dealing with client reluctance and resistance. The second major section explains transference and counter-transference, including their forms and patterns. The final part details the termination of counseling sessions and the professional relationship, including timelines and facilitation techniques.
๐ Lecture Summary
Initial Resistances
Resistances may be broadly defined as anything that gets in the way of counseling. Resistances can be present at any stage of counseling. Most clients are ambivalent when they come for counseling. At the same time as wanting change, they may have anxieties both about changing and about the counseling process, for instance, talking about themselves. Some clients come reluctantly: for example, 'problem' children sent to school counselors for disrupting class. Sullivan (1954) observed cultural resistance in non-medical counseling, noting there were cultural handicaps to the work of the psychiatrist. These 'anti-psychiatric' or โanti-counselorโ elements in the culture can also lead to resistances. Such culturally handicapping norms include: people ought not to need help. Other cultural thinking errors contributing to resistances are that people who need helping are 'sick' and that you should be able to solve all problems by 'common sense'. A study about Pakistani peopleโs perceptions showed that people seeking help for depression were perceived as less intelligent, sociable, kind, etc. (Suhail & Anjum, 2004). Sometimes resistance could be as a consequence of poor counseling skills or models. Counselors may wrongly attribute the sources of clients' resistances by being too quick to blame them, when the lack of progress may actually be the consequence of poor counseling skills, for example, not listening properly. Furthermore, some counseling models, especially if incompetently applied, may engender resistances. Counselors also bring their own resistances to their work, for example, fatigue and burnout.
The lecture introduces a force field analysis using a table of "Driving" and "Restraining" forces, illustrating how different forces can interplay in resistance. The table is structured with a scale from 1 to 5 for each force, with items labeled A through E listed in a column. ๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these forces helps counselors identify the sources of client resistance and plan interventions to strengthen driving forces or weaken restraining forces.
๐ Definition โ Resistances: Anything that gets in the way of counseling, present at any stage, stemming from client ambivalence, cultural norms, poor counselor skills, or counselor fatigue. ๐ Example: A client who thinks "people ought not to need help" may resist opening up because seeking counseling violates their cultural norm of self-sufficiency.
How to deal with Initial Resistances?
Use non-judgmental listening to convey understanding. By using good active listening skills, you do much to build the trust needed to lower resistances. Communicate acceptance of the clientโs unwillingness to change. Rather than justify yourself, one approach to handling aggression is to reflect. Join with clients. Just showing clients that you understand their internal viewpoints, especially if done consistently, may diminish resistances. For instance, counselors can initially listen and offer support to children expressing resentment about parents. Counselors need to be sensitive to the pace at which different clients work. Clients who feel pressured by counselors may become even more resistant. Furthermore, if attacked prematurely and clumsily, clients may reinforce their defenses. When dealing with client resistances, counselors require sensitivity, realism, flexibility and tact. Discuss reluctance and fears โ for example, a parole officer might say to a juvenile delinquent: "I detect an unwillingness to open up to me because I'm your parole officer. If Iโm right, Iโm wondering what specifically worries you about that." Invite cooperation โ initial statements should create the idea of a partnership. Enlist client self-interest โ ask questions like 'What are your goals in the situation?' and 'Wouldnโt you like to be more in control of your life?' Reward silent clients for talking.
๐ Example of joining with clients: Client: I think coming here is a waste of time. My parents keep picking on me and they are the ones who need help. Family Counselor: You feel angry about coming here because your parents are the people with problems. Client: Yes (and then proceeds to share his/her side of the story).
Transference & Counter-transference
These are concepts as old as Freud. Transference and counter-transference are issues that affect all forms of counseling, guidance, and psychotherapy. Transference can be direct or indirect and is the clientโs projection of past or present feelings, attitudes, or desires or relationships onto the counselor. It originally emphasized the transference of earlier emotions, but today it is not restricted to psychoanalytic therapy and may be based on current experiences. According to Gelso and Carter (1985), all counselors have a transference pull, which is an image generated through the use of personality and a particular theoretical approach. The way a counselor speaks, looks, gestures, or sits may trigger a clientโs reaction. Cavanagh (1982) describes that transference can be either direct or indirect. Direct transference is well represented by the example of the client who thinks of the counselor as his/her mother. Indirect transference is harder to recognize, usually revealed in clientโs reactions and behavior. Transference can be both negative and positive, and Cavanagh considers both as forms of resistance. Corey et al. (1993) sees a therapeutic value in working through transference. Mild or indirect positive transference is less harmful, and the relationship improves once the client resolves distorted perceptions about the counselor.
Counter transference is the counselorโs projected emotional reaction to or behavior towards the client. It can take on many forms, from a desire to please the client, to wanting to develop a social or sexual relationship with the client, to identifying with the client's problems so much that one loses objectivity, giving advice compulsively, etc. (Corey et al., 1993). When this happens, supervision or counseling for the counselor is called for. There are three approaches to counter transference: negative, positive, and both positive and negative. Intentionally or unintentionally, some counselors use both involving and information self-disclosures to manipulate clients to meet needs for approval, intimacy, and sex. Watkins (1985) identifies four forms of counter transference: overprotective, benign, rejecting, and hostile. The first two are examples of identification, while the rest show misidentification. Working through counter transference requires: being willing to examine your own reactions, monitoring your own counter transference, seeking supervision or consultation with difficult cases, avoiding blaming or judging the client, avoiding labeling clients, and demonstrating understanding and respect.
The lecture provides Table 2: Patterns of Transference (Watkins, 1983), which describes client and counselor attitudes for different transference patterns: Ideal (client idealizes, imitates; counselor feels pride or anger), Seer (client views counselor as expert; counselor feels al-knowing or self-doubts), Nurturer (client shows profuse emotions; counselor feels sympathy, depression), Frustrator (client is cautious, distrustful; counselor feels uneasiness, anger), and Nonentity (client topic shifts; counselor feels used, lack of recognition).
๐ Definition โ Transference: The clientโs projection of past or present feelings, attitudes, or desires onto the counselor, which can be direct or indirect, and positive or negative. ๐ Definition โ Counter Transference: The counselorโs projected emotional reaction to or behavior towards the client, stemming from unresolved areas in the counselor's life. ๐ Example: A counselor felt anxious when counseling a 59-year-old female client because her manipulative manner reminded him of how his mother controlled him as a child. This is a classic example of counter transference.
Termination of Counseling Relationships
Life is a series of hellos and goodbyes. Termination refers to the decision, one-sided or mutual, to stop counseling (Burke, 1989). A formal termination serves three functions: it signals that something is finished; it is a means of maintaining changes already achieved and generalizing problem-solving skills; and it serves as a reminder that the client has matured, indicating it is time for the client to face their life challenges independently. Guidelines for termination of a session include: start and end on time; leave 5 minutes or so for a summary; introduce the end normally ("Our time is coming to a close"); assign homework; set up next appointment; and limit the number of sessions. Limiting the number of sessions can facilitate termination, as both counselor and client are motivated by knowing the experience is limited. For termination of the relationship, both client and counselor should give each other verbal messages about readiness to terminate. It is wise to spend the final 3-4 weeks discussing termination in a relationship lasting more than 3 months (Hackney & Cormier, 1994). One-sixth of the time spent in a counseling relationship should be devoted to focusing on termination (Shulman, 1979). For example, if there are 18 total sessions, 3 can be devoted to termination. Two ways to facilitate the ending (Dixon & Glover, 1984) are: fading โ gradual decrease of reinforcement for behaving in certain ways; and helping the client develop successful problem-solving skills.
๐ Definition โ Termination: The end of the professional relationship with the client when session goals have been met, signaled by mutual or one-sided agreement. ๐ Formula: 1/6 of total sessions โ time to devote to termination (e.g., 18 sessions ร 1/6 = 3 sessions focused on termination). ๐ Example: In a 18-session counseling relationship, the final 3 sessions should explicitly discuss termination, helping the client prepare for independence and maintain gains.
โญ Key Takeaways
Resistances are normal and can originate from client ambivalence, cultural norms (e.g., "people ought not to need help"), poor counselor skills, or counselor burnout. Effective strategies include non-judgmental listening, joining with clients, inviting cooperation, and discussing fears directly. Transference involves the client projecting past or present feelings onto the counselor, while counter-transference involves the counselor's own unresolved issues projecting onto the client โ both require self-awareness and supervision to manage ethically. Termination should be planned, with one-sixth of total sessions dedicated to it, using techniques like fading and skill generalization. Successful termination signals client maturity and readiness to face life independently.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main functions of formal termination in counseling?
- According to the lecture, what is the recommended proportion of total sessions that should be devoted to discussing termination?
- What is the difference between direct transference and indirect transference?
- Name at least three strategies for dealing with initial client resistances as described in the lecture.
- What are Watkins' (1985) four forms of counter transference, and which two represent identification versus misidentification?
๐ Lecture 22 โ Theory in the Practice of Counseling
๐ Overview: This lecture addresses the timing and handling of termination in counseling, including premature termination and follow-up procedures. It then provides a comprehensive overview of the theoretical foundations of counseling, exploring philosophical, sociological, and psychological underpinnings that inform practice, and concludes with an introduction to eclectic approaches.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by examining termination issues in counseling, including timing, premature termination by clients or counselors, and follow-up. It then shifts to the role of theory in counseling practice, exploring the philosophical foundations (Essentialism, Progressivism, Existentialism), sociological foundations (influence of social organizations, socialization processes, development of cultural values), and psychological foundations (social psychology and learning principles). The lecture concludes with a discussion of eclectic approaches that integrate multiple theoretical perspectives.
๐ Lecture Summary
Link to Previous Lecture (Termination Issues) โ Timing of Termination
There is no single answer for when termination should occur. Counselors should ask themselves several questions: Have clients achieved behavioral, cognitive, or affective goals? Can clients concretely show where they have made progress? Is the counseling relationship still helpful?
Premature Termination
Many clients or counselors may end counseling before all goals are completed. Premature termination by clients can be indicated by not making appointments or resisting new appointments. It is advisable to schedule a termination/review session with the client for proper closure, and a referral may be in order at this time.
Counselors may also have to end counseling prematurely for various reasons. A summary session is always necessary, and referrals should be made to another counselor if appropriate. When making a referral, specific issues must be addressed with the client: the reason for the referral, providing names of several other counselors, and discussing the confidentiality issue โ the counselor cannot follow up with the new counselor to see if the client followed through.
๐ก Why this matters: Proper termination and referral procedures ensure ethical closure and continuity of care for the client.
Follow-Up
Follow-up sessions may be scheduled for various reasons including evaluation, research, or checking in with the client. Follow-ups must be scheduled carefully so as not to take the responsibility of change away from the client.
Theory in the Practice of Counseling
A theory provides a structure from which to understand what we are doing and the process of doing it. A theory is a framework on which interventions are based. The lecture asks why we have a theory: does it provide a therapeutic road map or create a sense of false certainty? Arguments for theory include that it creates structure and order. However, sometimes the theoretical knowledge under that theory is not sufficient to conclude or generalize โ for example, there is criticism of psychoanalytic theory regarding the importance of sexual and aggressive instincts in human beings.
Theory of Counseling
As a relatively new discipline, the theory and practice of counseling has drawn insights from other disciplines, including philosophy, psychology, sociology, and other social sciences. These disciplines have provided data and comprehensive hypotheses that counselors use to clarify theoretical structures. Generally, there are three foundations to counseling theory:
- Philosophical Foundations
- Sociological Foundations
- Psychological Foundations
Philosophical Foundations
In a healthy personality, the individual has a realistic perception of himself; he knows what he wants and how much he wants it. A goal of counseling is to help individuals reach their maximum potential, which occurs only when they develop consistent philosophical outlooks. Psychologists have argued that philosophy has no place in the scientific study of human behavior, but May (1967) points out that every scientific method rests on philosophical presuppositions.
Different Philosophical Positions
Belief in the dignity and worth of the Individual: One consistent theme in counseling philosophy is belief in the dignity and worth of the individual, recognition of the individual's freedom in determining values and goals, and the client's right to pursue his own life-style. These beliefs center on the concept of individualism, which accords importance to the individual. Over time, the idea has evolved that an individual has value in and of himself, not just for accomplishments. In Western culture, a counselor is encouraged to help the client become more independent and more autonomous.
Arbuckle's (1975) Philosophical Model about a responsible and free individual: A responsible and free individual is one who has narrowed the gap between attitudes and behaviors; the literal meaning of freedom and responsibility changes as the culture changes; and a responsible individual has no need to impose himself or his ideas on others.
Blocher's grouping of relevant philosophical systems: Blocher (1966) proposed grouping philosophical systems into three major categories:
Essentialism: An individual's destiny is to discover truth by distinguishing between the essential and the accidental. Essentialistic philosophies assume humans are endowed with reason and chief function is to use reason to know the world. Truth is universal and absolute. It refers to belief in fixed, unchanging absolutes of the good, the true, and the beautiful. Arbuckle (1975) questions whether a counselor committed to absolutistic concepts of right and wrong can allow a client freedom to develop values in the client's own unique way.
Progressivism: Such systems begin not with universal truths but with specific and particular experiences. The question "What is true?" is less important than "What will work?" The present and the future are stressed. A fact is valued for its usefulness, not its universality. Values have no existence in themselves; they are individual to the observer, and truth is dynamic. This view describes the philosophy underlying behaviorism, which is primarily pragmatic โ that which works is good; that which does not is discarded. No absolutes exist.
Existentialism: Existentialism is concerned with human longing and seeking importance within the individual's self. It emphasizes the view of reality most meaningful to individuals โ their own existence. It represents an approach that involves empathic response by the counselor, as the counselor attempts to reconstruct the personal meaning structure of the client.
To analyze human behavior in philosophical terms is to ask serious questions about what a person values, whether it should be valued, how it fits with other values, and whether it hampers or assists important values. Philosophical questions arise when an individual faces personal, vocational, or interpersonal problems.
Sociological Foundations
Sociology is the study of social group behavior. A basic premise is that people's behavior is largely determined by their social interactions and relationships as individuals and group members.
-
Influence of social organizations on Individuals: Merton (1957) suggests that individuals cope with social controls through five means: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism, or rebellion.
-
Socialization processes: This process transmits values and purposes of the group to the individual, teaching how to fit into the social organization. Socialization focuses on adaptation and adjustment to culture rather than individual uniqueness. Since the counselor's primary commitment is to individual growth and development rather than group ends, the counselor is concerned with socialization processes that help develop identity, self-awareness, values, and goals. But the counselor does not ask for resisting the social organization just to have a balanced approach.
-
Development of social/cultural values: Effective counselors must understand how an individual's culture influences their value structure and how conflicts between individual and cultural values influence development. Values and gender roles have changed in modern society. At fault is what sociologists call a cultural lag โ habits and beliefs from previous times conflict with cultural patterns brought by new technology.
Psychological Foundations: Social Psychology
Behavior is a product of the perceptual field of the individual at the moment of action. When an individual views a situation as threatening, they act as if it were indeed threatening. The counselor must understand the nature of the individual's perceptual experiences. The person will behave defensively or aggressively depending on what they see as the best reaction to the perceived threat.
An example of how perceptual theory has affected counseling is the "directive state" theory, which suggests that the direction of perceptual experience is influenced by factors such as sex, attitudes, values, needs, and similar variables. Studies show that factors operating to organize stimuli include: the nearness of elements, physical likeness, inclusiveness of patterns, tendency to see a complete object (closure), and context or part-whole relationships. Personal factors also influence perception โ our tendency to create a stable structure, past experience, organic condition, and needs and values. Social and cultural factors encourage or discourage certain perceptions.
Psychological Foundations: Learning Principles
- Behavioral theories emphasize learning as essentially a mechanical matter.
- Field theories emphasize that perception forced behaviorists to stop speaking as if stimuli were purely objective and equivalent for everyone.
- Cognitive theorists conceptualize learning as an active restructuring of perceptions and concepts, not as passive responses to stimuli.
Eclectic Approaches
Eclectic approaches refer to developing systematic blends of therapy by drawing ideas, concepts, and practices from a variety of sources. Each theory focuses on a relatively specific aspect of human personality (e.g., behavior, philosophy of human existence, individual perception). The advantage of eclecticism is taking the best features of various theories while avoiding disadvantages. Eclectic approaches, by their nature, are holistic.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must understand that termination in counseling has no fixed timing and should be evaluated based on goal achievement; premature termination requires a closure session and careful referral procedures that respect confidentiality. The three foundational pillars of counseling theory are philosophical (Essentialism, Progressivism, Existentialism), sociological (social organization influence, socialization, cultural values), and psychological (perception and learning principles). Individualism, pragmatism, and existential meaning are key philosophical themes that shape how counselors approach client autonomy and value formation. Perceptual and learning theories from psychology explain how clients interpret experiences and change behavior. Finally, eclectic approaches allow counselors to integrate the best elements from multiple theories holistically, avoiding the limitations of any single model.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three questions a counselor should ask to determine if termination is appropriate?
- What three issues must be addressed with a client when making a referral for premature termination?
- What are the three categories in Blocher's (1966) grouping of philosophical systems, and what does each emphasize?
- According to Merton (1957), what are the five general means by which individuals cope with social controls?
- What is the key difference between how behavioral theories and cognitive theorists conceptualize learning?