📘 Lecture 27 — NEO-FREUDIANS
📖 Overview: This lecture concludes the exploration of Neo-Freudian theorists by examining Karen Horney and Harry Stack Sullivan, who departed significantly from Freud's emphasis on biological instincts. It focuses on Horney's neurotic needs and basic anxiety theory, Sullivan's interpersonal theory of psychiatry and participant-observer therapeutic role, and provides a summary comparing traditional psychoanalysis with all Neo-Freudian approaches covered so far.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with a link to the previous lecture by evaluating Jungian analytical psychology's strengths and limitations. It then introduces Karen Horney, her view of human nature, the ten neurotic needs, three basic orientations (moving toward, away, against people), and her differences from Freud. Harry Stack Sullivan follows with his interpersonal theory, view of human nature, self-system, modes of experiencing (prototaxic, parataxic, syntaxic), stages of personality development, therapeutic interview stages, and evaluation. The lecture concludes with a summary comparing Freudian theory with Adler, Jung, Horney, and Sullivan.
📝 Lecture Summary
Link to Previous Lecture: Evaluation of Jungian Analytical Psychology
Jung's strengths include his interest in Eastern philosophy, mystical religions, and mythology, which connected him with many great thinkers of the 20th century. He was a great opponent of the connection between mind, body, and soul. He made significant contributions to sand play therapy and art therapy. Limitations include that Jungian analysis is suitable only for those who can spend money, time, and effort, and the process is nonreplicable, confidential, and based on individual and archetypal processes.
Karen Horney (1885-1952)
Karen Horney was born in a village near Hamburg, Germany, excelled in medical studies, and obtained a degree from the University of Berlin in 1913. As a second-born child, she envied her older brother, believing her parents loved him more. She first acted as an adoring daughter to retain her mother's love, but this failed. She then became rebellious and ambitious, though her quest for love continued throughout life. As an adult, she realized how much hostility she had developed as a child. The roots of Horney's personality theory lie in her childhood experiences, stating that a lack of love in childhood fosters anxiety and hostility.
🔑 Definition — Basic Anxiety: The feeling of isolation and insecurity that grows out of the parent-child relationship, produced by anything that disturbs the child's fundamental security.
View of Human Nature
Horney parted with Freud over his deterministic mechanistic approach and emphasis on instinctual drives. She emphasized the concept of anxiety, which she felt grew out of the child's feeling of isolation and insecurity in the parent-child relationship. Insecure children handle these feelings by developing irrational (neurotic) solutions that compensate for emotional and psychological losses, which may become permanent personality characteristics.
Ten Neurotic Needs:
- The neurotic need for affection and approval.
- The neurotic need for a partner who will take over one's life.
- The neurotic need to restrict one's life within narrow borders.
- The neurotic need for power.
- The neurotic need to exploit others.
- The neurotic need for prestige.
- The neurotic need for personal admiration.
- The neurotic need for personal achievement.
- The neurotic need for self-sufficiency and independence.
- The neurotic need for protection and unassailability.
For the neurotic, these needs are not easily met and often cannot be satisfied because of the deep inner conflict at their source. Horney classified these ten needs into three basic orientations:
- Moving toward people (need for love)
- Moving away from people (need for independence)
- Moving against people (need for power)
🔑 Definition — Normal vs. Neurotic Individuals: Normal individuals resolve their conflicts by integrating the three orientations, while neurotics rely exclusively on one of the orientations.
Horney parted significantly from Freud in her view that conflict is developmental and arises out of the individual's social surroundings. Her greatest contributions were this awareness of the impact of environment in psychological dysfunction, and her identification of neurotic needs. During her self-analysis, Horney was influenced by Adler's notion of compensation for inferiority, leading her to masculine protest by excelling in a male-dominant profession like medicine.
💡 Why this matters: Horney's emphasis on social and environmental factors over biological instincts laid groundwork for modern psychodynamic and humanistic approaches.
Harry Stack Sullivan (1892-1949)
Harry Stack Sullivan differed greatly from Adler and Horney in background and training. He was born and trained in America and never had direct contact with Freud. His unique psychiatric approach was the first to emphasize the role of interpersonal relationships. His views on the importance of interpersonal relationships and the therapist as an involved participant significantly influenced present counseling theory and practice.
View of Human Nature
According to Sullivan, personality exists only through the individual's interactions with others. Processes like thinking, perceiving, and even dreaming are considered interpersonal.
🔑 Definition — The Self-System: Develops out of anxiety experienced in interpersonal relationships, originally from the mother-infant relationship. Individuals learn that pleasing parents brings praise (good-me self), while misbehavior brings punishment (bad-me self). The self protects from anxiety and guards security.
The self-system will avoid information inconsistent with its organization, protecting itself from criticism. It may lose its ability to be objective and prevent accurate self-assessment. If an individual experiences much anxiety, the self-system becomes inflated and prevents growth and healthy relationships. This shows antecedents of Rogers' self theory and links to Freud's view of the ego distorting reality through defense mechanisms.
Modes of Experiencing
Sullivan delineated three modes of experiencing:
- Prototaxic: Experiences with no connection or meaning for the individual; infants undergo this.
- Parataxic: Seeing a relationship between events that occur simultaneously but have no actual relationship; superstitions are examples.
- Syntaxic: Using language with commonly agreed-upon verbal symbols enabling communication.
🔑 Definition — Prototaxic Mode: The earliest, simplest mode involving disconnected, momentary experiences without logical relationships. 🔑 Definition — Parataxic Mode: A mode where the individual sees causal relationships between coincidental events, leading to superstitious thinking. 🔑 Definition — Syntaxic Mode: The most mature mode involving consensually validated symbols and logical, shared meaning.
Stages of Development of Personality
Sullivan's personality theory emphasized stages of development but differed from Freud on the role of sexuality. His views are similar to Erikson in their emphasis on interpersonal influences. The six stages are:
- Infancy
- Childhood
- Juvenile era: Children's experience with friends and teachers rivals parental influence; social influence becomes important; "reputation" becomes a source of self-esteem or anxiety.
- Preadolescence: A relationship with a closer friend or chum becomes particularly important, providing the basis for love relationships with the opposite sex.
- Early adolescence
- Late adolescence
Role of the Counselor/ Therapeutic Interview
Sullivan's major contribution was his view of the therapeutic interview as a highly personal and interpersonal experience where the therapist functions as a "participant observer." The therapist's attitudes, feelings, doubts, or personal difficulties influence the interaction, so the therapist cannot assume a strictly observational stance.
The psychiatric interview consists of four stages:
- The Formal Inception: The therapist is viewed as an interpersonal relations expert. The primary task is to determine the nature of the patient's problem and begin communication, being sensitive to nonverbal behavior (voice tone, speech rate, volume changes). The patient has a right to benefit from the initial session; emphasis is on relationship building.
- Reconnaissance: The therapist structures sessions to gather factual information about the patient's past, present, and future. The goal is to develop hypotheses regarding the patient's problems.
- The Detailed Inquiry: Both questioning and listening help the therapist sort through tentative hypotheses and select the most accurate one. Information about functioning in all areas is collected.
- The Termination: A summary of the therapist's learnings and observations characterizes this stage. The therapist may prescribe guidelines for the patient following termination.
🔑 Definition — Participant Observer: A therapist role where the therapist is an active, involved participant in an interpersonal relationship rather than a removed observer and interpreter.
Sullivan's influence is most obvious in his humanistic view of the psychiatric interview. He was among the first to change the therapist's role from a remote observer to an active participant. His emphasis on the therapist as a person and the power of the relationship in facilitating client change was probably an antecedent of humanistic thinking and client-centered therapy.
Evaluation
- Sullivan was a very creative thinker among the first to change the therapist's role from a remote observer to an active, involved participant.
- His emphasis on the therapist as a person and the power of the relationship in facilitating client change was an antecedent of humanistic thinking leading to client-centered therapy.
Summary: Traditional Psychoanalysis and Neo-Freudians
Freud viewed personality as a complex energy system consisting of the id (pleasure principle), ego, and superego. Behavior is largely a result of instinctual drives and unconscious processes. The ego employs defense mechanisms (repression, projection, reaction formation, fixation, regression) when flooded with anxiety. Personality develops in five psychosexual stages: oral, anal, phallic, latency, and genital. Techniques include interpretation, dream analysis, transference, and free association.
Each Neo-Freudian departed from Freud: Adler, Horney, and Sullivan developed social-psychological views rejecting Freud's view of sexuality, emphasizing environmental and interpersonal factors. Jungian analysis is more philosophical, focusing on both individual and collective unconscious consisting of archetypes. The most obvious similarity between Freud and Rogers is the importance placed on feelings. Freud used both cognitive (recall of early memories, interpretation) and affective (transference, corrective emotional experience) techniques to facilitate client insight.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember are Horney's concept of basic anxiety stemming from lack of love in childhood, her ten neurotic needs classified into three orientations (moving toward, away, and against people), and her social-environmental departure from Freud's instinctual drives. For Sullivan, remember that personality exists only through interpersonal interactions, his self-system developing from the good-me/bad-me distinction, the three modes of experiencing (prototaxic, parataxic, syntaxic), and his revolutionary concept of the therapist as a participant observer in a four-stage therapeutic interview. Finally, understand that all Neo-Freudians (Adler, Jung, Horney, Sullivan) departed from Freud by emphasizing social, environmental, and interpersonal factors over biological instincts and sexuality.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Horney, what is the root cause of basic anxiety and neurotic needs?
- What are the three basic orientations into which Horney classified the ten neurotic needs, and how do normal individuals differ from neurotics in using them?
- According to Sullivan, what is the self-system, how does it develop from the good-me/bad-me distinction, and what happens when it becomes inflated?
- What are Sullivan's three modes of experiencing, and what does each mode mean?
- What are the four stages of Sullivan's therapeutic interview, and what is the role of the therapist as a "participant observer"?
📘 Lecture 28 — Client-Centered Approach
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the client-centered approach to counseling, developed by Carl Rogers as a reaction to psychoanalysis. It emphasizes the importance of the therapeutic relationship and the client's inherent capacity for growth, focusing on feelings rather than thoughts or behaviors. This approach revolutionized counseling by demystifying the process and empowering clients.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by outlining the common characteristics of affective approaches, including a focus on emotions, human phenomenology, and a humanistic orientation. It then delves into the client-centered approach developed by Carl Rogers, covering his background, view of human nature, the role of the counselor, and the goals of therapy. The lecture also details the specific conditions for growth, therapeutic techniques, and key emphases like the "here and now," before concluding with an evaluation of the approach's strengths and weaknesses.
📝 Lecture Summary
Affective Approaches: Common Characteristics
This lecture begins a series on affective approaches, where the counselor focuses primarily on the client's feelings. These approaches share several characteristics: they focus on primary affect as the cause of actions, help clients change emotions, emphasize human phenomenology (the client's subjective experience), and stress a person-to-person relationship. They are humanistic in orientation, holding an optimistic view of humans as having the ability to grow (human potential). All affective approaches share some vagueness in technique description, with existential therapy being the weakest and Gestalt the strongest. The three types of affective approaches discussed are Client-Centered Approach, Gestalt Therapy, and Existential Counseling.
Client-Centered Counseling
Carl Rogers (1902-1987) developed client-centered therapy in reaction to the traditional, highly diagnostic methods of psychoanalysis. His background included an evangelical upbringing that later shifted to liberal beliefs, influenced by his studies and contact with Otto Rank (who believed a person should have the opportunity to exert free will) and Jessie Taft (a humanistic social worker). Rogers brought their ideas to the USA with a core belief that no man has the right to run another man's life. His key works include Counseling and Psychotherapy (1942), which first presented his approach, and the classics Client-Centered Therapy (1951) and On Becoming a Person (1961).
View of Human Nature
Rogers's view of human nature is built on several core beliefs. He holds a strong commitment to the dignity and worth of each individual, believing all persons have the right to their own opinions and control over their destiny. Central is the phenomenological world of the client: individuals behave and adapt based on their perception of themselves and their situations. A truly adjusted person can integrate all experiences into their phenomenal field. Rogers also posits a tendency toward self-actualization, an inherent directional tendency of the organism to develop all its capacities to maintain or enhance itself, similar to Maslow's hierarchy. Finally, Rogers believes that people are fundamentally good and trustworthy; negative behaviors arise from defensiveness due to an incongruence between an individual's ideal self (how they believe they ought to be) and their real self (how they think they are).
🔑 Definition — Ideal Self: The way an individual believes they ought to be, which can be incongruent with their real self.
Role of the Counselor
The counselor's role is to promote a climate where the client is free to explore all aspects of self. The counselor acts as a facilitator rather than a director and makes limited use of psychological tests. When tests are used, the focus is on the meaning to the client, not the scores. The Q-Sort techniques are often employed: the client sorts 100 cards with statements into 9 piles (from "most like me" to "least like me") and then sorts them again by "how I would like to be." The counselor calculates the correlation between the two ratings.
Goals
Client-centered counseling is an "as if" approach: if certain conditions exist, a definable process leads to personality and behavior changes. The basic premise is that once the proper conditions for growth are established, the client will gain insight and take positive steps.
Conditions for Growth:
- Psychological contact: A situation where each person makes a difference in the other's experience, setting up a two-way interaction.
- Minimum state of anxiety: The more anxious the client is about their incongruence, the more likely successful counseling will occur.
- Counselor congruence: The therapist is genuine.
- Unconditioned positive regard: The therapist accepts the client unconditionally, without judgment.
- Empathic understanding: The therapist understands the client's frame of reference.
- Client perception: The client must perceive the counselor's unconditional positive regard and empathic understanding.
Outcomes of successful counseling include a client who is more realistic and objective, has reduced vulnerability to threat, feels more confident and self-directing, and accepts more behaviors as belonging to themselves.
Techniques
The development of client-centered therapy shifted focus from what the therapist does to who the therapist is. The self is used as an instrument, and techniques are simply ways of expressing genuineness, unconditional positive regard, and empathic understanding. Because applying a technique self-consciously would destroy the therapist's genuineness, the only acceptable techniques are those that implement the therapist's philosophy to facilitate client growth.
Certain Emphases within Client-Centered Approach
The approach emphasizes the here and now rather than the client's history. For example, why a client hates her brother is less important than how she feels now and how that feelings affect her behavior. This emphasis on present feelings replaces diagnosis, which is considered undesirable because: (1) only the client can truly diagnose their own difficulty, (2) diagnosis can be dangerous if the counselor's perception is inaccurate, and (3) diagnosis denies the unique qualities of each person by placing them in categories.
The approach also emphasizes concentration on emotional rather than intellectual elements. The counselor must be a patient and expert listener. Boy and Pine (1982) suggest an expanded two-phase model: Phase 1 focuses on building the therapeutic relationship with empathy, acceptance, and genuineness. Phase 2 centers on the client's specific needs, such as a job or adequate housing, which depend on the relationship built in Phase 1.
Evaluation: Strengths
- Revolutionized the counseling profession by demystifying it with the publication of actual transcripts of counseling sessions.
- Provides a facilitative environment where the focus is fully on the client's concerns.
- Has generated a great deal of research.
- Empowers clients by leaving responsibility with them, helping them recognize their own power.
- Concepts are applicable to a wide variety of helping situations, including adjustment issues, interpersonal problems, mild to moderate anxiety, and uncomplicated bereavement.
💡 Why this matters: The client-centered shift from the therapist as an expert diagnostician to a facilitator of the client's own growth has had a profound and lasting impact on all modern counseling approaches.
Evaluation: Weaknesses
- The approach lacks clearly defined terms and techniques, making it difficult for some counselors to distinguish between using a technique and using their personality.
- Clients may fail to understand what the counselor is doing and may withdraw from the process.
- It ignores diagnosis and unconsciously generated impulses, and deals only with surface issues.
- It is best suited for bright, insightful, and hard-working clients and is less effective with resistant clients, those with limited contact with reality, or those who have difficulty communicating.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Client-centered therapy, founded by Carl Rogers, is a humanistic and affective approach that rejects the diagnostic, interpretive methods of psychoanalysis. It is built on the belief in a person's inherent tendency toward self-actualization and the crucial importance of the therapeutic relationship. The counselor's role is to create a facilitative environment by being congruent, offering unconditional positive regard, and demonstrating empathic understanding, which allows the client to resolve incongruence between their real and ideal self. The approach focuses on the client's present feelings ("here and now") and empowers the client to take responsibility for their own growth, though it is less effective with resistant or severely disturbed clients.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three core conditions that a therapist must provide in a client-centered approach?
- According to Rogers, what is the "actualizing tendency"?
- Why does the client-centered approach consider psychological diagnosis to be undesirable?
- What is the "Q-Sort" technique and how is it used in client-centered counseling?
- List two strengths and two weaknesses of the client-centered approach as presented in the lecture.
📘 Lecture 29 — Gestalt Therapy
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces Gestalt therapy as an existential, experiential approach to counseling, contrasted with the client-centered perspective through a detailed case study of "Farzana." It explores the theory's roots in Gestalt psychology, the life and work of founder Fritz Perls, and the core principles of wholeness, awareness, and the "here and now." Understanding Gestalt therapy matters because it offers a framework for helping clients integrate fragmented aspects of self and resolve unfinished business.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a case illustration (Farzana) and her autobiography, presented first from a client-centered perception and then as a transition to Gestalt therapy. It introduces the founder Fritz Perls and the controversial association of Gestalt therapy with academic Gestalt psychology. The core of the lecture covers the Gestalt view of human nature—emphasizing wholeness, the here-and-now, self-actualization, and awareness—followed by six specific causes of human difficulties including "topdog vs. underdog" conflicts and unfinished business.
📝 Lecture Summary
Case of Farzana
The lecture opens with the case of Farzana, a 43-year-old housewife presenting with general dissatisfaction, panic over aging, psychosomatic symptoms, depression, and weight issues. Her psychosocial history reveals a distant authoritarian father and a critical, difficult-to-please mother, with early messages to not behave like "bad" girls. She took care of younger siblings, felt socially isolated, and wished to become a teacher. After her children became adolescents, she graduated but remains unsure of her identity apart from others' expectations, feeling unappreciated and concerned about losing her children and her "looks."
Farzana's Autobiography
In her own words: "I have become aware of recently that I have pretty much lived for others so far. I have been the superwoman who gives and gives until there little left to give." She describes waking at night with a racing heart, cold sweat, and shaking, feeling "a terrible sense of doom" and worrying about death and going to hell despite reading Quran for comfort.
Farzana: A Client-Centered Perception
From a client-centered perspective, diagnosis derives from a Greek word meaning "to know" or "to discover"—the client's self-discovery is more important than what the counselor knows. No DSM-IV diagnosis would be made, as assessment is an ongoing process. The critical endeavor is the definition and redefinition of the self: "Who am I?" and "Who am I becoming?" Key issues include incongruence between the person she is and the selves "trying" to emerge, resulting in anxiety and physical symptoms. She is both excited and afraid, afraid that life is slipping by.
The therapeutic process requires careful listening, accurate understanding, and creating a supportive, trusting environment. The counselor must communicate belief in her resourcefulness and use techniques that "fit," with the counselor being fully present in the relationship.
Gestalt Therapy
Gestalt therapy draws from Gestalt Psychology, Moreno's psychodrama, and existentialism. It stresses the perception of completeness and wholeness—when perceptions become abnormally inaccurate, they can lead to psychopathology. Gestalt emphasizes increasing an accurate perception of reality and understanding how people function in totality.
Fritz Perls
Frederick Salomon Perls was born in 1893 in Berlin into a middle-class Jewish family. His parents fought bitterly, and he disliked his older sister, yet remembered childhood as happy. He trained as a psychoanalyst in Vienna and Berlin and became associated with Kurt Goldstein, learning to view humans as complete entities rather than separate parts. In 1936, Perls met Freud at a congress and felt humiliated by a brief interchange—thereafter dedicating himself to proving Freud wrong. He immigrated to the U.S. in 1946 and gained prominence with the publication of Gestalt Therapy (1951), establishing the Gestalt Institutes and working at the Esalen Institute.
Association of Gestalt Therapy with Gestalt Psychology
Whether Gestalt therapy is based on Gestalt psychology is controversial. Perls' biographer called him a "traditional gestaltist," but Perls maintained that "academic gestaltist never accepted me." Two opposing opinions exist: "No one can understand Gestalt Therapy without an adequate background in Gestalt Psychology" (Emerson & Smith, 1974); versus "Gestalt Therapy revolves around Perls' own personality" (Shane, 1999).
View of Human Nature
Gestaltists believe humans work for wholeness and completeness—man is a composite of interrelated parts where none (body, emotions, thoughts, sensations, perceptions) can be understood outside the whole person. They emphasize the "here and now," influencing other theories like behavioral and cognitive approaches. The person must attend to the current need (figure) while relegating others to the background; when the gestalt is closed, that need moves to background and another becomes figure. One must avoid fantasizing.
Man is part of his environment, with a self-actualizing tendency emerging through personal interaction and self-awareness. The Gestalt view trusts inner wisdom, much like person-centered counseling, with each person seeking to live interactively and productively as a healthy unified whole. It is antideterministic—each person can change and become responsible. Many troubled individuals have over-dependency on intellectual experience, diminishing emotions and senses. Another common problem is the inability to resolve unfinished business. Gestaltists do not attribute difficulties to unconscious forces; rather, the focus is on awareness. Healthy individuals realize body signs (headache, stomach pains) may indicate need to change behavior and are aware of personal limitations.
💡 Why this matters: The shift from "why" (unconscious causes) to "what" (current awareness) fundamentally changes how counselors work with clients—focusing on present experience rather than historical interpretation.
Causes of Human Difficulties
According to Gestaltists, difficulty arises in several ways:
- Losing contact with the environment and its resources
- Becoming overinvolved with the environment, losing touch with the self
- Failing to put aside unfinished business
- Becoming fragmented or scattered in many directions
- Experiencing conflict between the top dog (what one thinks one should do) and the underdog (what one wants to do). The topdog contains introjected "shoulds" (analogous to Freud's superego) and underdog as id. Both roles are played in a dialogue to integrate them.
- Difficulty handling dichotomies of life, such as love/hate, masculinity/femininity, pleasure/pain
🔑 Definition — Topdog: The aspect of personality containing introjected "shoulds" and moral demands, analogous to Freud's superego.
🔑 Definition — Underdog: The aspect of personality representing what one wants to do, analogous to Freud's id.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember are: Gestalt therapy emphasizes wholeness and the integration of body, emotions, thoughts, and sensations—no part can be understood outside the whole person. The "here and now" focus distinguishes it from psychoanalysis, as does the antideterministic view that clients can change and become responsible. Human difficulties stem from losing contact with environment or self, failing to resolve unfinished business, fragmentation, topdog/underdog conflicts, and difficulty with life dichotomies—none attributed to unconscious forces but rather to lack of awareness. The topdog-underdog conflict (introjected "shoulds" versus genuine wants) must be resolved through dialogue to achieve integration. Finally, healthy individuals are those most aware—of body signals, personal limitations, and their current figure-ground needs.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six causes of human difficulties according to Gestalt therapy?
- How does the Gestalt view of human nature differ from psychoanalysis regarding the role of unconscious forces?
- What is the difference between the "topdog" and "underdog" in Gestalt theory, and what are they analogous to in Freud's structural model?
- Why is the "here and now" emphasis important in Gestalt therapy, and what does it mean for a person's current need to become "figure"?
- What is the controversy regarding the association between Gestalt therapy and academic Gestalt psychology?
📘 Lecture 30 — Gestalt Therapy
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the Gestalt approach to counseling, focusing on the counselor's role, therapeutic goals, techniques, and evaluation. It emphasizes the importance of present-moment awareness ("the now") and experiential techniques over diagnosis. A case example of "Farzana" illustrates how Gestalt principles are applied in practice.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the role of the Gestalt counselor, including key rules for practice and therapeutic goals such as exposing defenses and fostering responsibility. It details the five layers of neurosis and various techniques like dream work, the empty chair, and confrontation. The lecture concludes with an evaluation of the approach's strengths and limitations, and a case application from a Gestalt perspective.
📝 Lecture Summary
Role of the Counselor
The role of the Gestalt counselor is to create an atmosphere that promotes a client’s exploration of what is needed in order to grow. Polster and Polster (1973) indicate that gestalt counselors must be exciting, energetic and fully human. Involvement occurs in the now which is a continuing process.
There are several rules that Gestalt counselors follow in helping clients become more aware of the now:
- The principle of now: always using the present tense
- I and Thou: always addressing someone directly instead of talking about him or her to the counselor.
- The use of I: substituting the word I for it, especially when talking about the body.
- The use of an awareness continuum: Focusing on how and what rather than why
- The convention of questions: asking clients to convert questions into statements
- Gestalt counselors do not use standardized assessment instruments, such as psychological tests, nor do they diagnose their clients according to DSM-IV classification standard.
- Therapist examples: counselor sets example for client by being an open and aware person.
- Role play: counselor and/or client engage in role play to help the client manage feelings.
- Nonverbal-behavior congruence: counselor encourages client to be in touch with whether verbal behavior matches nonverbal behavior. In order to probe the patient’s defenses and expose the games being displayed, therapist often pays close attention to nonverbal behavior. The counselor also uses posture cues to get to the feelings that exist now.
💡 Why this matters: The Gestalt counselor's role is active and directive, using specific rules to keep the client focused on present experience rather than past explanations or future anxieties.
Goals
Perls (1970) developed a formula that expresses the word’s essence: “Now = experience = awareness = reality. The past is no more and the future not yet. Only the now exists” (p.14).
- Getting clients to accept responsibility for their own actions and feelings
- To expose the games clients play and the defenses behind which they hide. To experience and become aware of these shams is an important goal of counseling. The experience of awareness may be threatening for the client.
Perls (1970) identifies five layers of neurosis that potentially interface with being authentically in touch with oneself:
- The Cliché layer: consists of non-contacts/ pretending to be something that one is not.
- The phony layer: Role-playing layer. It refers to an attempt to avoid recognizing aspects of self that the person would prefer to deny.
- Below this layer is the impasse layer, where individuals wonder how they are going to make it in the environment.
- The fourth and fifth layers, the impulsive and explosive are often grouped together. People at these layers frequently feel vulnerable to feelings. When people peel back the layers of defensiveness (implosion) then they experience explosion of joy, sorrow or pain that leads to being authentic. When persons reach this point, the now can be experienced most fully.
💡 Why this matters: The five layers describe the process of moving from inauthenticity to genuine self-awareness, which is the core journey of Gestalt therapy.
Techniques
Some of the most innovative counseling techniques ever developed are found in Gestalt therapy. These techniques take two forms: exercises and experiments.
- Exercises are ready-made techniques such as the enactment of fantasies, role-playing and psychodrama (Covin, 1977). They are employed to evoke a certain response from the client, such as anger or exploration.
- Experiments on the other hand, are activities that grow out of the interaction between counselor and client. They are not planned and what is learned is often a surprise to both the client and the counselor. Many of the techniques of Gestalt therapy take the form of unplanned experiments.
Common Exercises employed in Gestalt Therapy:
- Dream work: Perls describes dreams as a message that represents a person’s place at a certain time. Dream is a kind of condensed reflection of the individual’s own existence and the ways used to avoid facing oneself. The person with repetitive dreams is encouraged to realize that unfinished business is being brought into awareness and that there is a need to take care of the message delivered. Gestaltists believe that:
- The dream conveys messages
- The dream also epitomizes the contradicting sides of the self
- Empty chair: In this procedure clients talk to the various parts of their personality, such as the part that is dominant and the part that is passive.
- Confrontation: Confrontation involves asking clients what and how questions.
- Making the rounds: Some powerful Gestalt exercises are individually oriented but used primarily in group. This technique is employed if the counselor thinks that the theme applies to everyone in the group.
- I take responsibility: In this exercise clients make statements about perceptions and close each statement with the phrases “and I take responsibility for it”. To repeat again & again and louder and louder the important remarks is the technique. Benefits of these games is not demonstrated empirically.
- Exaggeration: Clients accentuate unwitting movement or gestures.
- May I feed you a sentence: The counselor asks if the client will say a certain sentence (provided by the counselor) that makes the client’s thoughts explicit.
- Locating feelings.
Evaluation: Strengths
- The approach emphasizes helping people incorporate and accept all aspects of life.
- The approach helps a client focus on resolving areas of unfinished business.
- The approach places primary emphasis on doing rather than talking.
- The approach is flexible and not limited to a few techniques.
- The approach is appropriate for certain affective disorders, anxiety states, somatoform disorders, adjustment disorders, and DSM-IV diagnoses such as occupational problems and interpersonal problems.
Evaluation: Limitations
- The approach lacks a strong theoretical base. Some critics view Gestalt counseling as all experience and techniques.
- The approach deals strictly with the now and how of experience.
- The approach eschews diagnoses and testing.
- The approach is too concerned with individual development and is criticized for its self-centeredness.
Summary and Conclusion
Gestalt therapy continues to generate strong interest among practitioners. As a group, effective approaches do not make much use of psychological tests, formal diagnoses, or rigid procedures. A trademark of these approaches is that they tailor what they do to the needs of the client. Counselors assess needs by establishing strong relationships with clients. Existential counseling is the most nondirective of the theories while Gestalt therapy is the most directive.
Farzana: Gestalt Perspective
Assessment:
- Examining the process that occurs as the individual interacts with self and environment.
- The need fulfillment model refers to a “cycle of experience” which begins with physical or emotional sensations and proceeds through awareness, excitement, and toward contact with the environment.
- The panic attack continues because she is unable to move from the sensation level into some type of action.
The lecture presents a diagram of the Gestalt Need-Fulfillment Cycle for Farzana:
- Sensation: Panic, Anxiety, dizziness, heart palpitations, and headaches occur.
- Awareness: Interrupted by introjections (“shoulds” and “oughts”) and projections.
- Excitement: Interrupted by anxiety over her right to think and act selfishly; cannot move toward action.
- Action: Interrupted by retroflection, punishing self through guilt and self-recrimination.
- Contact: Cannot be made, because action can never be directed purposely toward the “other”.
- Withdrawal: Since contact is not made, there is nothing to withdraw from.
- New figure: Cannot move to new figure, because old ones remain to disturb new organization.
- Closure: No closure, because satisfaction of needs does not occur.
Goals:
- Providing a context in which Farzana can expand her awareness of what is going on within herself.
Counseling Procedures:
- Experiential techniques aimed at identifying here-and-now.
Techniques:
- Empty chair: she can indulge in conversation, dialogues with different facets of herself, and also with different characters in her life.
- Dream analysis.
- Homework to reduce polarities: for example eating slowly so that she gets a sensation of fullness, and also achieve the goal of slimness.
- Noticing nonverbals: (e.g., Farzana’s fidgeting with clothes). Asking her what else she might like to do with her hands?
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the Gestalt counselor's role is to promote present-moment awareness using specific rules (e.g., "I and Thou," "use of I") and without relying on diagnosis or testing. The core goal is to help clients move through the five layers of neurosis (from cliché to explosive) to achieve authentic self-awareness. Key techniques include dream work, the empty chair, and confrontation, which are used either as planned exercises or spontaneous experiments. The approach is praised for its emphasis on action and flexibility but criticized for a weak theoretical base and focus on the individual. The case of Farzana demonstrates how the need fulfillment cycle can be used to assess and intervene in a client's experience of panic through experiential techniques.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "principle of now" in Gestalt therapy, and how does it differ from focusing on the past or future?
- Name the five layers of neurosis according to Perls, and explain the significance of the "impasse layer."
- What is the difference between a Gestalt "exercise" and a Gestalt "experiment"?
- How does the "empty chair" technique help a client, and what is its purpose?
- In the Farzana case example, explain how her panic attack illustrates a disruption in the "need fulfillment cycle," specifically at the "action" stage.