๐ Lecture Summary
Strong Vocational Interest Blank (SVIB)
I. E. K. Strong, Jr., and colleagues studied the activities of persons belonging to different professions. They observed that different professionals had different likes and dislikes for different activities, and their interests followed different patterns. Hobbies of people working in the same profession were also similar, as they tended to indulge in similar pastime activities. Using the criterion-group approach, Strong developed a test to see if the interests of a test taker matched with the interests and values of people who were happy in their chosen careers.
The test is called Strong Vocational Interest Blank (SVIB). The 399 items of SVIB are related to 54 occupations for men and 32 occupations for women, presented separately. Items in the SVIB were weighted according to the frequency of occurrence of an interest in a particular occupational group compared to how frequently it occurred in the general population. The test provides strong psychometric characteristics, with normative samples of around 300 people in each criterion group. Raw scores were converted to standard scores with a mean of 50 and SD of 10.
Research showed that interest patterns usually become established by age 17 years and remain relatively stable over time. In a study of Stanford University students taking this test first in the 1930s and then later, interests remained relatively unchanged even after 22 years. However, the SVIB was criticized for gender bias (having used different scales for men and women) and lack of theoretical information โ there was no theoretical basis to explain why people in different professions had similar interests.
๐ Definition โ Criterion-group approach: A test development method where items are selected based on their ability to differentiate between known groups (e.g., people in different professions).
๐ Standard score formula: Raw scores converted to a distribution with mean = 50, SD = 10 โ allows comparison across different occupational scales.
Holland's Theory of Vocational Choice
Holland (1975) presented his theory of vocational choice, according to which people's personality is expressed in their interests. Furthermore, considering people's interests, we can classify them into one or more of the following six categories of personality factors:
- a. Realistic
- b. Investigative
- c. Artistic
- d. Social
- e. Enterprising
- f. Conventional
These factors were gender-bias free and could be used with both men and women. There was a similarity between Holland's factors and the patterns of interests yielded by research with SVIB. This appealed to Campbell, who incorporated this theory in his version of SVIB.
๐ก Why this matters: Holland's theory provided the theoretical foundation that SVIB lacked, explaining why occupational interests cluster together and allowing for more meaningful interpretation of interest test results.
The Strong-Campbell Interest Inventory (SCII)
The SVIB had certain features for which it was criticized. A new version was developed by D. P. Campbell and named The Strong-Campbell Interest Inventory (SCII).
- Developed in: 1974
- Population: Both men and women โ it is a gender-free version
- Special feature: Unlike the SVIB, the SCII does not have separate forms for men and women. The gender bias was removed and items from male and female forms were merged into one form
- Items: There are 325 items with response options including 'like', 'dislike', or 'indifferent'
- Parts: Seven parts including Occupations (131 items), School subjects (36 items), Activities (51 items), Amusements (39 items), Types of people (24 items), Preference between two activities (30 items), Your characteristics (14 items)
- Scoring: Several scores are obtained: General themes based on Holland's six personality types, scoring for administrative indexes, a person's basic interests, and occupational scales
- Strong feature: The test follows Holland's theory of vocational choice and therefore has a theoretical basis, and it is not gender biased
The Kuder Occupational Interest Survey (KOIS)
The Kuder Occupational Interest Survey (KOIS) requires the test taker to select the most preferred and least preferred activity among 100 triads of alternative activities. A triad is a set of three alternatives. The similarity between the test taker's interests and those employed in various occupations is assessed.
This instrument has separate norms for men and women, and separate scales for college majors are also available. The KOIS helps in two major ways: it suggests which occupational group may be best suited to a person's interests, and it can assist students in choosing their majors. A series of new scales has been added to KOIS for nontraditional occupations. Despite lack of research data, the KOIS is useful for guidance decisions for high-school and college students.
The Jackson Vocational Interest Survey (JVIS)
The Jackson Vocational Interest Survey (JVIS) was developed by D. N. Jackson, with a revised version from 1995 in common use. The test is used for career education and counseling of high-school and college students, and can be used for career planning of adults and those seeking mid-life career changes.
- Items: Contains 289 statements about job-related activities, completed in around 45 minutes
- Response format: Forced choice format where the respondent selects one interest they prefer over the other
- Forms: Available in both hand-scored and machine-scored forms
- Strong points: The test has strong psychometric properties and carefully avoided gender bias
The Minnesota Vocational Interest Inventory (MVII)
The Minnesota Vocational Interest Inventory (MVII) is designed for men who are not oriented toward college, emphasizing skilled and semiskilled trades. It has been used extensively by the military and by guidance programs for individuals not going to college. The MVII has nine basic interest areas and 21 specific occupational scales. Basic interest areas include mechanical interests, electronics, and food service. Occupational scales cover occupations like plumber, carpenter, and truck driver.
The Career Assessment Inventory (CAI)
The Career Assessment Inventory (CAI) was developed by Charles B. Johansson in 1976. The test is developed for American citizens with less than four years of postsecondary education, comprising around 80% of U.S. citizens. The test requires a reading ability of grade-6 reading level.
- Items: Test takers are evaluated on Holland's six occupational theme scales, basic interests in 22 areas are also assessed, and 89 occupation scales are used
- Strong points: The test has good validity and reliability, and the developer tried to make the CAI culturally fair and eliminate gender bias
The Self-Directed Search (SDS)
J. L. Holland developed the Self-Directed Search (SDS), which attempts to simulate the counseling process by allowing respondents to list occupational aspirations, indicate occupational preference in six areas, and rate abilities and skills in these areas.
- Items: The test has 228 items. There are six scales with 11 items each describing activities. Competencies are assessed by 66 items. Another six scales with 14 items each evaluate occupations
- Scoring: The SDS is self-administered, self-scored, and self-interpreted. Test takers score the inventory and calculate six summary scores; these scores and further codes reflect areas of highest interest
Eliminating Gender Bias in Interest Measurement
Advocates of women's rights pointed out discrimination against women in early interest inventories. The Associate for Evaluation in Measurement appointed the Commission on Sex Bias in Measurement, which concluded that interest inventories contributed to guiding young men and women into gender-typed careers. The SVIB had separate forms for women, but careers for women tended to be lower in status and commanded lower salaries. Because career choices for many women are complex, interest inventories alone may be inadequate, and more comprehensive approaches are needed.
Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank (RISB)
Sentence completion tests use verbal material as projective stimuli. The Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank (RISB) is a standardized test developed in 1950 for populations from grade 9 through adulthood.
- Items: The test consists of 40 incomplete sentences
- Scoring: Responses are interpreted according to several categories: family attitudes, social and sexual attitudes, general attitudes, and character traits. Each response is evaluated on a 7-point scale ranging from "need for therapy" to "extremely good adjustment"
- Strong points: The test may be used for obtaining diverse information relating to an individual's interests, educational aspirations, future goals, fears, conflicts, needs, and so forth
- Weak points: The sentence completion test is most vulnerable of all projective methods to faking on the part of the examinee intent on making a good or bad impression
Production Figure Drawings
The use of drawings in clinical and research settings has extended beyond personality assessment. It attempts to use artistic productions as a source of information about intelligence, neurological intactness, visual-motor coordination, cognitive development, and learning disabilities. Figure drawings are an appealing source of diagnostic data.
Draw-A-Person Test (DAP)
The Draw-A-Person Test (DAP) was developed based on the work of Karen Machover (1949). The test requires a simple pencil and 8ยฝ by 11 inch paper, and the person is asked to draw a person. Drawings are evaluated for various characteristics including placement, size of the figure, pencil pressure used, symmetry, line quality, shading, presence of erasures, facial expressions, posture, clothing, and overall appearance.
The House-Tree-Person Test (HTP)
The House-Tree-Person Test (HTP) was developed and popularized by Buck in 1948. The drawings of a house, tree, and person are used as a reflective source of psychological functioning. The test requires pencil and white paper, and the person is instructed to draw a picture of a house, a tree, and a person.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Projective Tests
Advantages: In-depth investigation, flexible nature, subjects' liberty to respond in whatever way, and used for psychodynamic examination.
Disadvantages: The psychologist has to be highly skillful, and these tests may be very time-consuming.
โญ Key Takeaways
The measurement of interests evolved from the atheoretical, gender-biased SVIB to theoretically grounded instruments like the SCII that incorporated Holland's six personality types (Realistic, Investigative, Artistic, Social, Enterprising, Conventional), with modern tests striving for gender fairness and cultural appropriateness. Key instruments serve different populations โ the KOIS uses triads for high-school/college students, the JVIS uses forced-choice for career planning, the MVII targets non-college men, and the CAI serves those with less postsecondary education. The Self-Directed Search is unique as a self-administered, self-scored inventory. Beyond interest measurement, projective techniques like the Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank (40 incomplete sentences, scored on adjustment level), Draw-A-Person test, and House-Tree-Person test use verbal and artistic productions to assess personality, though sentence completion tests are particularly vulnerable to faking.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are Holland's six personality types used in vocational interest measurement, and how did they address the criticism against SVIB?
- What is the criterion-group approach used by Strong in developing the SVIB, and how were items weighted in this test?
- How does the Strong-Campbell Interest Inventory (SCII) differ from the SVIB in terms of gender bias and theoretical foundation?
- What is the response format of the Kuder Occupational Interest Survey (KOIS), and what are its two major uses?
- What is the Rotter Incomplete Sentence Blank (RISB), how many items does it contain, and what is its primary weakness as a projective technique?
๐ Lecture 36 โ Measurement of Attitudes, Opinions, Locus of Control, Multidimensional Health Self-efficacy
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how psychologists measure attitudes, opinions, and related personality constructs. It covers classic attitude scaling techniques, the concept and measurement of locus of control, and specialized instruments for health-related beliefs and self-efficacy. Understanding these measurement approaches is essential for research in personality, social psychology, and health psychology.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition and measurement of attitudes and opinions, detailing the Thurstone and Likert scaling methods along with other popular formats. It then explains the concept of locus of control, Rotter's original internal-external dimension, and its evolution into multidimensional health locus of control. Finally, it covers the measurement of self-efficacy, distinguishing between general perceived self-efficacy and domain-specific measures like the GSE scale.
๐ Lecture Summary
Measurement of Attitudes
Besides measuring different personality characteristics, personality dynamics, and interests, psychologists assess and investigate many other aspects of personality too. Attitudes and opinions are two such aspects. An attitude can be defined as โa tendency to react favorably or unfavorably toward a designated class of stimuli, such as a national or ethnic group, a custom, or an institutionโ (Anastasi & Urbina, 2007, p. 418-419). Another related aspect is โopinionsโ. Attitudes and opinions are closely related since oneโs opinions are determined and directed by oneโs attitudes. The measures commonly used for the measurement of attitudes are called attitude scales. There are different types of scales available. However, in most attitude or opinion surveys, one needs to develop attitude scales or other instruments according to the theme of the research. One can develop scales following the formats available. Some of the scales whose format is commonly followed are as follows:
๐ Definition โ Attitude: a tendency to react favorably or unfavorably toward a designated class of stimuli, such as a national or ethnic group, a custom, or an institution. ๐ Definition โ Attitude scales: measures commonly used for the measurement of attitudes.
Thurstone (1931) Scale/ Equal Appearing Intervals
In this scale the scale development is most important. A large number of attitude-related statements are developed. The statements can be positive and negative toward the object of attitude. A panel of judges rates each statement from one to eleven. One means highly negative on the subject and eleven indicates highly positive. The ratings of all judges are processed and mean rating for each statement is gauged. When respondents are given scores according to the mean values obtained from the judges, they score the scale value of each item agreed with.
๐ Definition โ Thurstone Scale: an attitude scale where a panel of judges rates statements from 1 (highly negative) to 11 (highly positive), and respondents receive scores based on the mean rating of items they agree with. ๐ Example: A researcher develops 50 statements about recycling. A panel of 20 judges rates each statement. The statement "Recycling is essential for the planet" receives a mean rating of 9.8. A respondent who agrees with this statement earns a score of 9.8 on that item.
Likert (1932) Scale
In this type of scale a number of statements are developed regarding the object of attitude. The statements are both favorable and unfavorable. They are rated according to the following scale:
| 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strongly agree | Agree | Undecided | Disagree | Strongly disagree |
The value of a chosen response is the score of the person on that item. The total or overall score is calculated from the score on individual items.
๐ Definition โ Likert Scale: an attitude scale where respondents rate agreement with statements using a 5-point scale (Strongly agree to Strongly disagree), and the total score is the sum of item scores. ๐ Example: A statement "I enjoy exercising" is presented with the Likert format. If a respondent chooses "Agree" (score 4), that is their item score. If they choose "Strongly disagree" (score 1) for a negative statement "Exercise is boring", that score is reversed before summing.
Some other popular scales include the Guttman (1950) scale, the Semantic Differential Scale (Osgood et al., 1957), and the Social Distance Scale (Bogardus, 1925).
Locus of Control
Locus of control refers to a personโs perceptions or beliefs about the location of responsibility for his or her life circumstances, happenings, events, conditions. The perception of who is in-charge of oneโs life, who decides oneโs fate, and who is responsible for whatever the person is experiencing, is determined by the personโs locus of control (LOC). Peopleโs perceptions of success and failure, of health and illness, ability or inability, all reflect their locus of control. In other words, the concept of LOC refers to perceived control; the perception of how much a person feels in control of life (Lefcourt, 1982). The earliest formal investigations of the concept were reported by Julian Rotter (1966, 1975). Rotter showed that people have different views about things that happen to them. People have their own beliefs or generalized expectations about where the control of life, or events, resides.
Rotterโs original formulation of LOC had a dualistic approach. Peopleโs beliefs regarding who is responsible for events, and who influences life, were classified along a bipolar dimension. Rotter showed that people have different views about the source of control, and the things happening to them; these beliefs, and therefore people holding them, were seen as falling into two categories namely, internal and external, that could be measured with the I-E scale. Later on Levenson and others added to this construct as well as its measure. However, perhaps the most quoted contribution in this regard is in the assessment of Multidimensional Health Locus of Control.
๐ Definition โ Locus of Control (LOC): a personโs perceptions or beliefs about the location of responsibility for his or her life circumstances, happenings, events, and conditions. ๐ Definition โ Internal LOC: the belief that one's own actions determine outcomes. ๐ Definition โ External LOC: the belief that outcomes are determined by external forces like fate, luck, or powerful others.
Measurement of Multidimensional Health Locus of Control (MHLC)
Health locus of control can be measured by using specifically designed instruments. Its quantification gives an edge to this construct over many other constructs pertaining to health beliefs. The Multidimensional Health Locus of Control (MHLC) scales were developed by B. S. Wallston and K. A. Wallston, and their colleagues (Wallston, Wallston, Kaplan, & Maides, 1976; Wallston, Wallston, & De Vellis, 1978). These are the most popularly used measures for quantifying HLC.
Krischt and his colleagues (Dabbs & Krischt, 1971; Krischt, 1972) were the ones who produced the first published version of an LOC measure specifically meant for use in the domain of health and illness. Due to some inherent flaws in this measure however, it could not gain popularity and a need was felt for more precise measures. B. S. Wallston and K. A. Wallston have so far made highly significant contributions to the measurement of HLC.
๐ Definition โ Health Locus of Control (HLC): a person's beliefs about who or what controls their health outcomes.
Multidimensional Health Locus of Control (MHLC) Scales
The MHLC follows the 6-point Likert response pattern, and includes three scales. In conceiving these scales, Levensonโs (1973, 1981) multidimensional approach was followed, in which the dimension of externality was split into two components. Hence the scales for powerful others health locus of control (PHLC), and chance health locus of control (CHLC). Instead of treating EHLC as a single dimension that covers the influence of powerful others and that of chance as one and the same dimension, the new versions treated PHLC and CHLC as two separate components. PHLC, that measures the powerful others health locus of control, pertains to a personโs beliefs about the influence of other people on her health. The people who are believed to have the power to determine oneโs health may include the family, friends, doctors, hospital staff and others. The extent to which a person believes in the influence of chance, luck, or fate is measured by the CHLC Scale. CHLC measures the beliefs about health or illness being related to chance, fate or luck, instead of being related to oneโs own responsibility.
The three MHLC scales include:
- Internal Health Locus of Control (IHLC)
- Powerful Others Health Locus of Control (PHLC)
- Chance Health Locus of Control (CHLC)
A six-point rating scale is used with the MHLC items, where one can make a choice from response options ranging from โstrongly disagreeโ to โstrongly agreeโ. The scale contains three subscales and eighteen statements in all. Each subscale carries six items/ statements. The items pertaining to the three subscales have been mixed up. The scoring procedure is very simple. The values of the marked responses to each item in a subscale are added up. The sum indicates the personโs score on that subscale. The subscale on which the person obtains the highest score indicates the type of health locus of control that the person has. One may choose any one from forms A or B. The IHLC Scale assesses the internal health locus of control that is the extent to which a person believes that her health or illness is determined by internal factors. K. A. Wallston and B. S. Wallston (1982) have asserted that the dimensions measured by the scales are more or less statistically independent. Therefore a low IHLC score does not necessarily indicate that the person believes in the influence of external factors, powerful others, or chance. A low IHLC score may be understood to mean that the personโs belief in the influence of internal factors is low (or may be non-existent in some cases).
๐ก Why this matters: The multidimensional approach allows researchers to distinguish between different types of external beliefs (chance vs. powerful others), providing more nuanced insights into health behaviors and beliefs.
๐ Definition โ IHLC: the extent to which a person believes that her health or illness is determined by internal factors. ๐ Definition โ PHLC: measures a personโs beliefs about the influence of other people (family, friends, doctors, hospital staff) on her health. ๐ Definition โ CHLC: measures the extent to which a person believes in the influence of chance, luck, or fate on health or illness. ๐ Formula: MHLC Score = Sum of responses to items in each subscale (IHLC, PHLC, CHLC), each subscale has 6 items rated on a 6-point scale. ๐ Example: A patient scores 28 on IHLC, 15 on PHLC, and 20 on CHLC. Since IHLC is the highest, this indicates the patient has an internal health locus of control, believing their own actions primarily determine their health.
The Measurement of Self Efficacy
Self-efficacy, as the very name suggests, is the perception of oneโs own ability to produce some desired outcomes. Researchers have used the construct of self-efficacy for assessing the impact of peopleโs perceptions of personal control and capability on their behavior in a variety of situations. A divergent range of self-efficacy measures is available to researchers interested in investigating the relationship between thought and action. Although a considerable majority of studies in this regard have investigated the influence of perceived self-efficacy on peopleโs health-related behaviors, measures like collective teacher self-efficacy, and teacher self-efficacy scales have also been devised.
For a health psychology researcher, primarily two types of measures of self-efficacy are available. These instruments can be used to assess health related self-efficacy in two ways, including:
- General perceived self-efficacy
- Perceived self-efficacy pertaining to specific health behaviors.
The measures included in the above mentioned categories may be used in their original form as well as with alterations made according to the nature of problem under investigation.
๐ Definition โ Self-efficacy: the perception of oneโs own ability to produce some desired outcomes.
General Perceived Self-efficacy (GSE) Scale
The most widely used measure of self-efficacy, General Self-Efficacy (GSE) Scale, was developed by Matthias Jerusalem and Ralph Schwarzer in 1981. The original version, in German language, comprised 20 items, but the later version consisted of only 10 items (Schwarzer & Scholz, 2000; Schwarzer & Jerusalem, 1995). It is this 10 item version that is used by researchers studying self-efficacy in recent researches.
The GSE scale is available in at least 26 different languages. The scale was originally devised for predicting both coping and adaptation; how people coped with daily hassles, and how they adapted after having undergone stressful life events. This scale gauges a generalized sense of self-efficacy, indicating the overall global confidence that a person has about personal ability to cope with a wide range of situations that may be new, novel, taxing or demanding. GSE focuses upon a sense of competence that is broad and stable, rather than being only domain-specific (Schwarzer & Scholz, 2000).
The response format of GSE scale is uniform for all 10 items, consisting of a 4-point scale. The response options range from โnot at allโ (definitely not) marked as 1, to โexactly trueโ marked as 4. The final composite score is obtained by adding up the responses to all 10 items. The final score may range from 10 to 40. If the person marks โnot at allโ in response to the entire range of items, he will be understood to be standing at the lowest possible level of self-efficacy. This can be taken to indicate a lack of self-efficacy. On the contrary a score of 40 will mean the person has the highest possible level of feeling self-efficacious. On average, the scale can be completed in 4 minutes. Some people may take longer, or lesser than the average time.
๐ Definition โ General Self-Efficacy (GSE) Scale: a 10-item scale measuring a generalized sense of self-efficacy, or global confidence in one's ability to cope with a wide range of demanding situations. ๐ Formula: GSE total score = sum of responses to all 10 items (each item scored 1 to 4); possible range = 10 to 40. ๐ Example: A person responds to all 10 GSE items. For item "I can always manage to solve difficult problems if I try hard enough," they select "exactly true" (score 4). Their total score across all items is 35, indicating a relatively high sense of general self-efficacy.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture covers two major areas: attitude measurement and locus of control/self-efficacy assessment. For attitudes, you must know the difference between Thurstone (judges rate items, respondents receive scale values) and Likert (respondents rate agreement on a 5-point scale, total scores are summed) scales. The MHLC scale is the most important tool for health locus of control, with three statistically independent subscales: IHLC (internal), PHLC (powerful others), and CHLC (chance). The GSE scale is a 10-item, 4-point measure of general self-efficacy, with scores ranging from 10-40. For exams, focus on the definitions, structures, and scoring procedures of each instrument, especially the MHLC and GSE scales.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between the Thurstone and Likert attitude scaling methods in terms of how items are scored?
- What are the three subscales of the Multidimensional Health Locus of Control (MHLC) scales and what does each measure?
- According to Rotter, what are the two main categories of locus of control, and how are they measured with the I-E scale?
- How is the General Self-Efficacy (GSE) scale scored, and what is the range of possible total scores?
- Why did the MHLC scales split the external dimension into two separate components (PHLC and CHLC) rather than treating it as a single dimension?
๐ Lecture 37 โ Alternate Approaches to Personality Assessment: Behavioral and Cognitive- Behavioral Testing
๐ Overview: This lecture explores alternative approaches to personality assessment beyond traditional psychometric tests. It introduces behavioral assessment, which provides direct, observable evidence of a person's behavior, and cognitive-behavioral assessment, which adds a focus on the individual's cognitions. These approaches are crucial for supplementing test results in decision-making, diagnosis, and treatment planning.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the need for behavioral assessment as a supplement to psychological testing. It then details the core method of behavioral observation, including self-observation and self-monitoring, and covers various recording methods such as narrative records and behavioral rating scales. Following this, situational performance measures are introduced. The lecture then transitions to cognitive-behavioral assessment, explaining its rationale, the four steps involved, and providing examples of specific methods including the Fear Survey Schedule (FSS), the Irrational Beliefs Test (IBT), and Kanfer and Saslow's Functional Approach.
๐ Lecture Summary
Behavioral Assessment:
Traditional psychological tests measure underlying traits and characteristics, but for more confident judgments, behavioral assessment offers direct, tangible evidence. It samples a person's behavior in specific situations, which is safer to use alongside test results for diagnosis or screening. This approach can be used independently but is best employed as part of a battery of procedures.
๐ Definition โ Behavioral assessment: A method of personality assessment that yields information regarding a sample of behavior, assumed to represent a person's behavior in various situations, providing first-hand, direct, and tangible evidence.
Behavioral Observation:
The most basic method for behavioral assessment is observation, commonly used by developmental, educational, child, and school psychologists. They observe and record the behavior of interest. Technical devices like audio or video recordings can increase accuracy by capturing details the observer might miss. Trained staff may also be employed for record-keeping.
An offshoot of this is self-observation, where a person reports their own behavior. A similar approach is self-monitoring, in which the subject keeps a record of their own behavior as it happens. For example, a smoker might record each cigarette smoked during the day, or a bulimic might record binge eating episodes.
Recording Observed Behavior:
Several approaches can be used to record the behavior in question: a. Narrative records: The observer takes detailed notes, but this can lead to missing information. A better approach is to take short notes and fill in gaps afterward. b. Audio/video recordings: These capture the behavior accurately. c. Behavioral rating scales: Observers use codes instead of narratives to record behavior, saving time and ensuring inter-rater uniformity. These scales can record presence/absence, frequency, intensity, and other aspects. Examples include the Play Performance Scale for Children, the Walker Problem Behavior Identification Checklist, the Behavior Rating Profile, and the Social Skills Rating System.
Situational Performance Measure:
This is a form of observation where a person's behavior is observed under specific, either real or simulated, circumstances. For example, a lecturer candidate might deliver a model lecture to a real class, or an astronaut candidate might perform in a simulated state of weightlessness.
One form of this is a situational stress test, where behavior is observed under stress, anxiety, or frustration. This is used for jobs involving psychological pressure, such as in the armed forces. The U.S. Office of Strategic Services (OSS, 1948) used such tests during World War II for selecting military intelligence candidates.
Cognitive- Behavioral Assessment:
This approach is similar to the behavioral approach but includes a cognitive component. It is based on the cognitive-behavioral model, which is relatively modern.
Why Cognitive Behavioral Testing Is Needed?
Cognitive-behavioral testing focuses on an individual's own cognition, behavior, and related physiological responses. The target is the problem behavior itself, not unconscious determinants or underlying causes. According to Kaplan & Saccuzzo (2001), these tests target 'disordered behavior' rather than the underlying cause. The analysis of this behavior is the goal of cognitive-behavioral assessment.
There are four steps involved in cognitive-behavioral assessment (Kaplan & Saccuzzo, 2001):
- Identification of critical behavior.
- Determining if the critical behaviors are in excess or deficits.
- Evaluation of the frequency, duration, or intensity of the behavior.
- Based on step 3, the frequency, duration, or intensity of the critical behavior is decreased (if in excess) or increased (if in deficit).
The Fear Survey Schedule (FSS):
The Fear Survey Schedule (FSS) is a self-report procedure used for clinical purposes. Primarily, it takes ratings on fear using a rating scale. Initially introduced by Akutagawa (1956) with 50 items, it now has versions with 50 to 122 items, employing 5-point or 7-point scales. The items involve fear-provoking situations and avoidance behaviors, derived from clinical observations (Wolpe & Lang, 1964) and laboratory studies (Geer, 1965).
Irrational Beliefs Test (IBT):
People often hold irrational beliefs that lack a logical or realistic basis. The Irrational Beliefs Test (IBT), developed by R.A. Jones (1968), is one such test. It contains 100 items using a 5-point scale format. The subject indicates their level of agreement or disagreement with each item. Half of the items pertain to the presence, and the other half to the absence, of particular irrational beliefs.
๐ Definition โ Irrational beliefs: Beliefs that do not have a logical or realistic basis but are held by a person and cannot be separated from their cognitive system.
Kanfer and Saslowโs Functional Approach:
Kanfer and Saslow (1969) played a lead role in initiating the cognitive-behavioral approach with their functional approach, a behavior-analytic approach. It focuses on excesses and deficits in people's behavior, rather than traditional psychopathological labels. According to Kaplan & Saccuzzo (2001), "a behavioral excess is any behavior or class of behaviors described as problematic by an individual because of its inappropriateness or because of excesses in its frequency, intensity, or duration." Conversely, "behavioral deficits are classes of behavior described as problematic because they fail to occur with sufficient frequency, with adequate intensity, in appropriate form, or under socially expected conditions."
This approach proposes that the same laws operate in the development of normal and disordered behaviors, with the difference being only in extremes. The psychologist first identifies the excesses and deficits and then helps the client decrease or increase them accordingly.
๐ก Why this matters: This approach shifts the focus from diagnostic labels to observable, modifiable behaviors, which is crucial for designing effective behavioral interventions.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must understand that behavioral assessment provides direct, observable evidence of behavior to supplement traditional tests, using methods like observation and self-monitoring. The recording of behavior can be done via narrative, audio/video, or with specific behavioral rating scales. The lecture distinguishes cognitive-behavioral assessment, which targets the disordered behavior itself through a four-step process of identification, analysis, and modification. Key tools include the Fear Survey Schedule (FSS) for fear-provoking situations, the Irrational Beliefs Test (IBT) for irrational cognitions, and Kanfer and Saslow's Functional Approach, which analyzes behavior in terms of excesses and deficits rather than psychopathological labels.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between what traditional personality tests measure and what behavioral assessment measures?
- What are the two types of self-report methods in behavioral observation, and how do they differ?
- According to the lecture, what are the four steps involved in cognitive-behavioral assessment as outlined by Kaplan & Saccuzzo (2001)?
- What is the primary purpose of the Fear Survey Schedule (FSS), and from where were its items derived?
- In Kanfer and Saslow's Functional Approach, what are the two key categories into which all problem behaviors are analyzed, and what is the goal for each of these categories in treatment?
๐ Lecture 38 โ Testing and Assessment in Health Psychology
๐ Overview: This lecture explores key psychological assessment tools used in health psychology, focusing on measures of anxiety, coping, social support, locus of control, and self-efficacy. Understanding these instruments is crucial for evaluating patient responses to health conditions, stressors, and treatment adherence in clinical and research settings.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) for measuring anxiety types, the Ways of Coping Scale and Coping Inventory for assessing stress management strategies, and the Social Support Questionnaire (SSQ) for evaluating support networks. It also examines several scales for specific health-related locus of control (drinking, weight, perceived behavioral control, desired control, and health engagement control strategies). Finally, it provides an extensive overview of perceived self-efficacy measures for specific health behaviors including exercise, nutrition, habit cessation, and health-protective behaviors.
๐ Lecture Summary
Testing and Assessment in Health Psychology
Health psychology is a popular field with practical relevance to most people's lives. As research in health-related issues grows, the number of available assessment tools also increases. This section discusses tests and scales that psychologists use when assessing clients or conducting health psychological research.
The State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI)
The STAI is based on Charles D. Spielberger's State-Trait Anxiety theory. The theory assumes anxiety is of two types: state anxiety, which is an emotional reaction varying from situation to situation, and trait anxiety, a personality characteristic stable across situations. The inventory yields two scores: A-State and A-Trait. The STAI uses a 4-point scale format with 20 items per scale (40 items total). It has been used with patients suffering from various health conditions and undergoing surgical or stressful procedures for anxiety assessment.
๐ State Anxiety: An emotional reaction that varies from situation to situation ๐ Trait Anxiety: A personality characteristic stable across situations
The Ways of Coping Scale
The Ways of Coping Scale (Lazarus, 1995; Folkman & Lazarus, 1980) assesses how people cope with stress. It is one of the most popular tools in health psychology. It is a checklist where subjects indicate items/thoughts and behaviors that apply to them. It contains 68 items and seven subscales: problem solving, growth, wishful thinking, advice seeking, minimizing threat, seeking support, and self-blame. Research suggests the subscales divide into two broad categories: Problem-focused strategies (cognitive and behavioral strategies for coping, attempting to solve the problem) and Emotion-focused strategies (ways of dealing with emotional response to stress, not resolving the problem).
Coping Inventory
The Coping Inventory (Horowitz & Wilner, 1980) contains items derived from clinical interview data. Its 33 items fall into three categories: activities and attitudes people adopt for avoiding stress, strategies for working through stressful events, and socialization responses.
The Social Support Questionnaire (SSQ)
The SSQ (Sarason et al., 1983) measures social support and related aspects. It contains 27 items, each having two parts. For every item, respondents endorse two things yielding two scores: the Number (N) score, listing people the respondent can count on for support (average calculated from all 26 items), and the Satisfaction (S) score, indicating overall satisfaction with supports (ranging from 1 = very dissatisfied to 6 = very satisfied, average calculated from all items).
Scales for Specific Health Conditions Related Locus of Control
a. Drinking Locus of Control Scale: A 25-item scale measuring drinking locus of control (Donovan & O'Leary, 1978), using a forced choice format involving pairing of internal and external control alternatives.
b. Weight Locus of Control (WLOC) Scale: Assesses internal and external determinants of one's weight (Saltzer, 1982), using a 6-point Likert scale format with 4 items.
c. Perceived Behavioral Control Measure: Developed by Armitage and Connor (1999) to assess perceived behavioral control, including items like "Whether or not I eat a low fat diet is entirely up to me."
d. Desired Control Scale: A 70-item rating scale (Reid & Zeigler, 1981) using a 5-point response scale from 'strongly agree' to 'strongly disagree'. It has two subscales with 35 items each: Desire of outcomes and Beliefs and attitudes.
e. Health Engagement Control Strategies (HECS): A 5-point rating scale comprising 9 items (Worsch, Schulz, & Heckhausen, 2002). Rating options range from "almost never true" to "almost always true," with items like "I invest as much time and energy as possible to improve my health."
Assessment of Perceived Self-Efficacy Pertaining to Specific Health Behaviors
While the GSE (General Self-Efficacy) scale predicts general personal competence across situations, numerous studies use self-efficacy for assessing its impact on specific health behaviors. These include healthy lifestyles, avoiding/quitting unhealthy behaviors, and coping with specific health conditions. Unlike GSE, specific health behavior measures focus on the health condition alone rather than global ability to handle stressful situations. Researchers can replace original items with health-specific ones or devise similar measures. Many studies use brief scales of only 4-5 items, sometimes even single-item measures. Items must be theory-based with appropriate wording, clearly mentioning both the health action and the perceived barrier. The semantic structure recommended is: "I am certain that I can do XX, even if YY (barrier)" (Luszczynska & Schwarzer, 2005).
Specific Health-Condition Related Self-Efficacy Measures
a. Measures for Assessing Exercise-Related Self-Efficacy: The exercise self-efficacy scale (Schwarzer & Renner, 2000) focuses on overcoming barriers to exercising, with a 4-point format from 'definitely not' to 'exactly true'. The Exercise Regularly Scale (Lorig et al., 1996) assesses confidence in regular physical activities with ten response options from 'not at all confident' to 'totally confident'.
b. The Nutrition Self-Efficacy Scales: The Nutrition Self-efficacy Scale (Anderson, Winett, & Wojcik, 2000) offers ten response options from 'very sure I cannot' to 'very sure I can', assessing confidence in using nutritious foods. Schwarzer and Renner's (2000) Nutrition Self-efficacy Scale uses 4 response options from 'definitely not' to 'exactly true', assessing ability to overcome barriers to healthy eating.
c. Habit Cessation and Abstinence Self-Efficacy: The Situational Confidence Questionnaire (Annis, 1987) examines alcohol abstinence self-efficacy using a 6-point scale with response options in percentages (0% to 100%), where 0% = 'not at all confident' and 100% = 'very confident' in resisting heavy drinking. Schwarzer and Renner's (2000) scale assesses control over drinking behavior with 4 response options from 'definitely not' (1) to 'exactly true' (4). The Smoking Cessation Self-efficacy Scale (Dijkstra & De Vries, 2000) uses a 7-point scale from -3 ('not at all sure I am able to') to +3 ('very sure I am able to').
d. Health-Protective Behaviors and Adherence to Medical Advice Self-Efficacy: The Preaction BSE Self-Efficacy Scale (Luszczynska & Schwarzer, 2003) examines a woman's ability to perform regular breast self-examination (BSE) despite odds, with 5 response options from 'definitely not' to 'exactly true'. The Maintenance BSE Self-Efficacy Scale uses the same options to gauge self-efficacy in maintaining regular BSE habit. The Adherence Self-efficacy Scale (Mohr et al., 2001) assesses self-efficacy related to self-injection, with response options from 1 ('I will not have any problems') to 6 ('I will not be able to tolerate it at all').
๐ก Why this matters: These specific self-efficacy measures allow researchers and clinicians to target particular health behaviors (exercise, nutrition, smoking cessation, medical adherence) rather than using general measures, enabling more precise assessment and intervention planning.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember the distinction between state and trait anxiety in the STAI and that it yields separate A-State and A-Trait scores. The Ways of Coping Scale distinguishes problem-focused from emotion-focused coping strategies, a critical framework in health psychology. The SSQ provides both Number (N) and Satisfaction (S) scores for social support assessment. For specific health behaviors, self-efficacy measures must be theory-based with wording including both the health action and the perceived barrier using an "if-then" format. Finally, multiple specific measures exist for exercise, nutrition, smoking cessation, alcohol abstinence, and medical adherence self-efficacy, each with different scale formats and response options.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two types of anxiety measured by the STAI, and how do they differ?
- List the seven subscales of the Ways of Coping Scale and explain the difference between problem-focused and emotion-focused coping strategies.
- What two scores does the Social Support Questionnaire (SSQ) produce, and how is each calculated?
- What is the recommended semantic structure for wording items in specific health behavior self-efficacy measures?
- Name three specific health conditions or behaviors for which researchers have developed self-efficacy scales, and identify the response format for one of them.