π Lecture 16 β Social Learning Model and Violence
π Overview: This lecture examines the Social Learning Theory of Albert Bandura, which explains how aggression and violence are learned through observation, imitation, and modeling rather than being innate. It also introduces the Humanistic perspective of Carl Rogers, which views violence as a result of society blocking an individual's natural tendency toward growth and self-actualization. Understanding these contrasting theories is crucial for forensic psychology to explain the origins of violent behavior.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the core concepts of Albert Bandura's Social Learning Theory, including observational learning, imitation, modeling, and the four necessary conditions for modeling to occur. It explores vicarious learning through vicarious reinforcement and vicarious punishment, along with factors influencing modeling. The lecture then transitions to the Humanistic Model presented by Carl Rogers, discussing unconditional positive regard, empathy, client-centered therapy, and the perspective that aggression results from societal blockage of personal growth.
π Lecture Summary
Social Learning Theory and Violence
Albert Bandura is considered the leading proponent of Social Learning theory. He argued that although learning takes place through reinforcement and punishment, behaviorists ignored another important phenomenon: social learning. Social learning theory focuses on learning that occurs within a social context and includes concepts such as observational learning, imitation, and modeling. Bandura believed that aggression is learned through a process called behavior modeling β individuals do not inherit violent tendencies but model them after three principles (Bandura, 1976: p.204). He argued that individuals, especially children, learn aggressive responses from observing others, either personally or through the media and environment. Many individuals believe that aggression will produce reinforcements such as reduction of tension, gaining financial rewards, gaining praise from others, or building self-esteem.
The general principles of Social Learning Theory are: 1) People can learn by observing the behavior of others and the outcomes of those behaviors. 2) Learning can occur without a change in behavior β unlike behaviorists who say learning must be represented by a permanent change in behavior, social learning theorists say learning through observation alone may not necessarily be shown in performance. 3) Cognition plays a role in learning β awareness and expectations of future reinforcements or punishments can have a major effect on behaviors people exhibit. 4) Social learning theory can be considered a bridge between behaviorist learning theories and cognitive learning theories.
Modeling
Models that people imitate take a wide variety of forms. A student may imitate another student, a teacher, a parent, a sports celebrity, a movie star, a cartoon character, a fictional character in a novel, or anyone performing a behavior that can be observed β even in the observer's imagination. The behavior to be imitated takes shape within the mind of the observer. This means that if the observer thinks the model has been reinforced for performing a behavior, the observer is likely to imitate that behavior β even if the model did not really perform that behavior or if the model himself perceived the consequences as unpleasant. It is even possible to have people serve as models for themselves, such as a teacher viewing a videotape of her own performance to visualize improvement.
Bandura mentions four conditions necessary before an individual can successfully model someone else's behavior:
- Attention: The person must first pay attention to the model.
- Retention: The observer must be able to remember the behavior observed, which can be increased through rehearsal.
- Motor reproduction: The observer must have the ability to replicate the behavior demonstrated β a learner who is not developmentally ready may struggle (e.g., little children having difficulty with complex physical motion).
- Motivation: Learners must want to demonstrate what they have learned. Since these four conditions vary among individuals, different people will reproduce the same behavior differently.
Types of models include the live model (an actual person demonstrating the behavior) and the symbolic model (a person or action portrayed in some other medium such as television, videotape, or computer programs). Many behaviors can be learned through modeling, including reading, mathematics, acting bravely in fearful situations, and aggression. Research indicates children become more aggressive when they observe aggressive or violent models. Moral thinking and moral behavior are also influenced by observation and modeling, including moral judgments regarding right and wrong.
Vicarious Learning
Vicarious learning occurs when consequences of the model's behavior affect the observer's behavior indirectly. Three major factors influence the likelihood that vicarious learning will occur:
- Similarity of the model to the observer: An observer is more likely to imitate a model perceived as similar. Similarity is especially important when observers have little information about the functional value of the modeled behavior (Bandura, 1986). The degree of similarity is determined within the mind of the observer.
- Prestige of the model: An observer is more likely to imitate a model perceived as prestigious. Again, prestige is determined within the mind of the observer β a person viewed as low in prestige by a parent may be viewed as highly prestigious by a young child.
- Observability of the behavior: Behaviors that are more easily observed are more easily imitated. Observability can be increased through strategies such as having the model perform deliberately, using slow-motion or videotaped replays, verbalizing or focusing attention on difficult-to-observe behaviors, and pairing written instructions with visually modeled behaviors.
Vicarious learning takes two forms:
Vicarious reinforcement: This occurs when the model is reinforced for a response and the observer shows an increase in that same response. Bandura illustrated this by having students watch a film of a model hitting an inflated clown doll β one group of children saw the model being praised, and without being reinforced themselves, they began to also hit the doll. The environment reinforces modeling in several ways: 1) The observer is reinforced by the model (e.g., a student who changes dress to fit in is accepted by that group). 2) The observer is reinforced by a third person (e.g., a teacher notices and praises the observer for modeling outstanding behavior). 3) The imitated behavior itself leads to reinforcing consequences (e.g., a student observes extra work being fun and receives enjoyment from doing the same).
Vicarious punishment: Both reinforcement and punishment have indirect effects on learning. Vicarious punishment is more effective than direct/physical punishment. A child who is being beaten becomes used to such beatings, but the child who is observing this takes very serious effect β vicarious punishment makes that child stay far away from doing that thing.
Criticisms of Social Learning Theory
One important thing ignored by Bandura is the importance of books β while reading a book, the reader feels the same pain and happiness the characters are going through. Biological theorists argue that the social learning theory completely ignores an individual's biological state and rejects differences due to genetic, brain, and learning differences. For example, if a person witnessed a hanging or violent murder, they might respond in many different ways β biological theorists believe responses come from the autonomic nervous system (increased heart rate, blood pressure, nausea, fainting) and are not learned but partially inherited. The social learning theory rejects classical and operant conditioning processes, and the biological preparedness of the individual to learn as well as the role of the brain in processing information from the social environment are critical to learning theory but ignored by social learning theory.
Humanistic Model and Violence
Western society needed a new philosophy after moving away from churches and religion, and that philosophy was called Humanism. This philosophy came into psychology quite late through Carl Rogers, who was a psychoanalyst. After deciding to honestly listen to his client with full concern and attention for just the first few sessions without any interpretation, his patient was cured in five sessions. This was a turning point for Rogers, leading him to devise a theory that only acceptance can cure a person β no reinforcement and punishment is effective. This was totally opposing the mechanistic views of behaviorism.
The Humanistic perspective offers a very positive viewpoint of human nature and potential, emphasizing the personal worth of each individual. It suggests we are each responsible for our own happiness and well-being, and we have the innate capacity for self-actualization β our unique desire to achieve our highest potential. James Bugental (1964) summarized this with five postulates: 1) Human beings cannot be reduced to components. 2) Human beings have in them a uniquely human context. 3) Human consciousness includes awareness of oneself in the context of other people. 4) Human beings have choices and responsibilities. 5) Human beings are intentional; they seek meaning, value, and creativity. Additional postulates state that all humans have a natural ability to grow, man is not basically animal, and human natural tendency is towards growth, development, and progress. Carl Rogers administered the concepts of reinforcement but opposed the wish of controlling other people.
Why do mental problems occur? If all human beings are innately good and have the potential to grow, why do they resort to violence? Carl Rogers viewed that humans encounter mental diseases and resort to aggression because society blocks an individual from growth and development.
How does one become a person? 1) The individual must make contact with another person. 2) The individual develops a need to be loved, referred to as positive regard. 3) The individual then develops a prizing or valuing of one's self called positive self-regard.
Perspective about violence: Society blocks an individual from growing. Aggression results from this blockage. Violence is resistance to this blockage. Violence is also a manifestation of this blockage. Rogers viewed that aggression can be a result of society's blockage and frustration, and sometimes aggression and violence are shown as resistance to hurdles raised by society. Another source of aggression could be the manifestation of society's aggression β a person who has been the target of society's aggression internalizes that aggression and manifests violence to other people.
Perspective about education: Rogers paired up with educationists and took over a school where children were given freedom to decide their curriculum, set their study targets, and study subjects of their own choice. They were given the chance to grow according to natural potential. It was assumed such children would grow up to be calm, non-violent, gentle, and peaceful adults who would not believe in solving problems by aggression, violence, or taking away other people's rights. The experiment was a success, contributing to teaching and learning.
The Client Centered Therapy
Rogers is regarded as the father of client centered therapy. He believed that when congruence, unconditional positive regard, and empathy are present in a relationship, psychological growth will invariably occur.
Empathy means "I can feel what you feel" (Reflection). It is commonly defined as one's ability to recognize, perceive, and directly experientially feel the emotion of another. As states of mind, beliefs, and desires of others are intertwined with their emotions, one with empathy may often be able to more effectively define another's modes of thought and mood. Empathy is often characterized as the ability to "put oneself into another's shoes" or experiencing the outlook or emotions of another being within oneself β a sort of emotional resonance.
Unconditional Positive Regard: "I accept you as you are" (no conditions) β I respect you no matter what you have done. Unconditional positive regard encourages the therapist (termed a counselor by Rogers) to treat the client as worthy and capable, even when the client does not act or feel that way. According to Rogers's theory, mental illness is often caused by the absence of love or by a defective kind of love the client received as a child. By showing the client unconditional positive regard and acceptance, the therapist provides the best possible conditions for personal growth.
To practice unconditional positive regard while maintaining congruence, the therapist provides specific feedback and demonstrates care with their actions. If a clinician finds it hard to unconditionally regard their patient positively, they need to keep in mind Rogers' belief that all people have the internal resources required for personal growth. According to this theory, it is the environment that makes the difference as to whether growth occurs. A patient's past environment may have developed patterns of behavior to survive, and these patterns can become entrenched even when no longer appropriate. The clinician needs to feel for the person under those patterns and for the person who was damaged and then survived by adapting.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding both the Social Learning and Humanistic models provides forensic psychologists with complementary frameworks β one explaining how violence is learned through observation and modeling, and the other explaining how societal blockage of natural growth leads to aggression β which inform intervention and rehabilitation strategies.
β Key Takeaways
The Social Learning Theory by Albert Bandura explains that aggression is learned through observation, imitation, and modeling, with the four necessary conditions being attention, retention, motor reproduction, and motivation. Vicarious learning occurs through vicarious reinforcement (increasing behavior when the model is reinforced) and vicarious punishment (decreasing behavior when the model is punished), with vicarious punishment being more effective than direct punishment. The Humanistic Model by Carl Rogers offers a positive view of human nature, proposing that all people have an innate capacity for self-actualization and that violence results from society blocking an individual's growth and development. Rogers' client-centered therapy emphasizes that unconditional positive regard, empathy, and congruence are essential for psychological growth, and that mental illness often stems from defective love received in childhood. A critical comparison shows that Social Learning Theory ignores biological factors and individual differences, while Humanistic Theory provides remedies through acceptance and freedom rather than reinforcement and punishment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four conditions necessary for successful modeling according to Bandura?
- What is the difference between vicarious reinforcement and vicarious punishment, and which is more effective?
- According to Carl Rogers, what causes humans to resort to aggression and violence if they are innately good?
- What are the three key components of Rogers' client-centered therapy that facilitate psychological growth?
- What are the three major factors that influence the likelihood of vicarious learning occurring?
π Lecture 17 β Moral Development and Violence
π Overview: This lecture examines how moral development relates to violent behavior through multiple theoretical perspectives. It explores Piaget's theory of moral reasoning stages, biopsychological explanations for criminality, attachment theory's role in empathy development, Adler's concepts of inferiority/superiority complexes, and Foucault's critical view of social institutions. Understanding these frameworks is essential for forensic psychologists working with violent offenders.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers moral development through Piaget's four cognitive stages and their implications for understanding rights and violence. It then examines the Bio-Psychological Model's focus on genetic predisposition and personality traits like low constraint and negative emotionality. Attachment theory explores how early caregiver relationships shape empathy and violence potential, followed by Adler's model examining will to power, inferiority/superiority complexes, and birth order. Finally, Michel Foucault's critical perspective compares prisons, schools, and mental hospitals as institutions enforcing conformity.
π Lecture Summary
Moral development
Moral development is the process through which children develop proper attitudes and behaviors toward other people in society, based on social and cultural norms, rules, and laws. It is a concern for every parent, teaching a child to distinguish right from wrong. Moral development has been discussed since the beginning of human civilization but was not studied scientifically until the late 1950s.
Piaget's Theory of Moral Reasoning
Jean Piaget, a Swiss psychologist, explored how children developed moral reasoning. He rejected the idea that children simply learn and internalize rules by being given them and forced to adhere. Through his research, he recognized that children learn morality best by having to deal with others in groups. He reasoned there was an active process by which children conform to society's norms.
Piaget found two main differences in how children thought about moral behavior. Very young children's thinking is based on how actions affected them or what the results of an action were. For example, young children will say that when trying to reach a forbidden cookie jar, breaking 10 cups is worse than breaking one. They also recognize the purity of rules β they understand they cannot make up new rules to a game. Piaget called this "moral realism with objective responsibility," explaining why young children are concerned with outcomes rather than intentions.
Older children look at motives behind actions rather than consequences of actions. They can examine rules, determine whether they are fair or not, and apply these rules to situations requiring negotiation, assuring everyone affected is treated fairly. Piaget felt the best moral learning came from cooperative decision-making and problem-solving events.
Piaget proposed four developmental stages:
1. Sensorimotor stage β The child primarily explores the world with senses (mouth and body movements) rather than through mental operations. Infants are born with a set of congenital reflexes, in addition to a drive to explore their world. Their initial schemes are formed through differentiation of the congenital reflexes.
2. Pre-Operational stage β Occurs between 2-7 years of age. It includes:
- Symbolic functioning β characterized by the use of mental symbols, words, or pictures representing something not physically present
- Centration β characterized by a child focusing on only one aspect of a stimulus or situation. For example, pouring liquid from a narrow beaker into a shallow dish, a preschool child might judge the quantity to have decreased because it is "lower," attending to height but not the compensating increase in diameter
- Language acquirement is another mark of this stage
- Intuitive thought β occurs when the child believes in something without knowing why
3. Concrete operational stage β Occurs between 7-11 years, characterized by appropriate use of logic and abstract concepts like love, hate, pain, happiness. Children start pointing out right and wrong deeds of their parents. This stage is very critical for moral development.
4. Formal operational stage β The fourth and final stage, commencing at around 11 years of age (puberty) and continuing into adulthood. It is characterized by acquisition of the ability to think abstractly and draw conclusions from available information. The young adult functions cognitively normally and can understand things like love, "shades of gray," and values. If a person develops inability to understand the link between one's own rights and other people's rights and does not care for other people's rights, this can result in aggression and violence.
π Definition β Moral realism with objective responsibility: Piaget's term for young children's thinking where they are concerned with outcomes rather than intentions when judging moral behavior.
π Example: Young children say breaking 10 cups while trying to reach a forbidden cookie jar is worse than breaking one cup, because they focus on the consequence (more cups broken) rather than the intention.
Main concepts relevant to violence
- Without formal operations you can't have moral reasoning
- Moral reasoning includes awareness of rights of others
- Since I have rights, you also must have rights
π‘ Why this matters: This directly links cognitive development stage to capacity for understanding others' rights β suggesting that individuals who never reach formal operations may be unable to fully grasp why violence against others is wrong.
BIO-PSYCHOLOGICAL MODEL
Basic assumption: People commit crime because they are genetically and biologically predisposed to commit. This model ignores the importance of environmental factors (only can hinder or foster). They believe criminals cannot be corrected and totally opposes the humanistic point of view.
It focuses on the effect of psychological factors on crime, particularly involving relationships with others: other people take individuals' valued possessions, treat them in an aversive manner, or prevent them from achieving their goals through legal channels.
Biopsychological theories focus on individuals' traits, especially personality traits. Two traits especially conducive to crime are:
- Low constraint β Individuals who are low in constraint are impulsive (tend to act without thinking), like to take risks, reject social norms or rules, and have little concern for the feelings or rights of others. In popular terms, such individuals might be described as "wild" or "out of control."
- Negative emotionality β Individuals who are high in negative emotionality are easily upset and quick to anger, tend to blame their problems on others, and have an aggressive or antagonistic interactional style.
These traits are partly inherited from one's parents (genetically transmitted). Many statesmen and politicians hold the extreme view that criminals cannot be corrected. For an offender rapist, they would suggest sterilization; for murder, death penalty; or long sentences for acute crimes.
Encountered deaths: Police officers holding such extreme views stage encountered deaths for repeated criminals because they believe such criminals cannot be corrected and should be eliminated.
Main views of Bio-Psychological Model
- People are born different
- With different genetic make-up
- Environment can help or hinder
- The predisposition to crime is biological
- Such people can't be corrected
- Extreme views such as sterilize the rapist
- Death penalty for murder
- Long sentences for repeat offenders
- "Encounter" deaths usually result of such thinking
ATTACHMENT THEORY
This theory resembles the psychodynamic model but unlike psychodynamic perspective, it is an environmental theory. It proposes that early attachment style of child with parents and caregivers is crucial to determine what type of person they would become.
π Definition β Attachment: An affectional tie that one person or animal forms between him/herself and another specific one [usually the parent] β a tie that binds them together in space and endures over time.
If you are loved and empathized with by your mother in childhood, then you are able to love and empathize with others. Early attachment theory looked at case studies of people who were violent, wild, offenders who do not respect others' rights, and found that all such people had early separation from mother or father or both. Such separation can be traumatic.
Trauma of early separation: Trauma leaves a lasting effect. Trauma especially in boys can lead to a numbing of emotions, resulting in the suppression of empathy, compassion, flattening of emotions like sadness or happiness. Such a boy can resort to cold blooded violence.
Attachment styles and physical abuse: If an infant is beaten up and maltreated by parents or caregivers, it is also a kind of trauma. Such a child, when becoming an adult, can target other people for assault, torture, and violence as they do not understand others' emotions and the value of rights.
Attachment styles
Secure Attachment β If the child protested the mother's departure and quieted promptly on the mother's return, accepting comfort from her and returning to exploration, the child's relationship would be classified as secure attachment.
Avoidant Attachment β If the child showed little to no signs of distress at the mother's departure, a willingness to explore the toys, and little to no visible response to the mother's return, the child-mother relationship would be classified as avoidant.
Ambivalent Attachment β If the child showed sadness on the mother's departure, ability to be picked up by the stranger and even 'warm' to the stranger, and on the mother's return showed some ambivalence, signs of anger, reluctance to 'warm' to her and return to play, this child would be classified as ambivalent.
A mother whose child is securely attached would respond appropriately, promptly, and consistently to the emotional as well as physical needs of the child. She would help her child to transition and regulate stress, and as a result, the child would use her as a secure base in the home environment.
A mother whose child has an avoidant attachment would show little response to the child when distressed, discourage crying, and encourage independence and exploration. The avoidantly attached child may have lower quality play than the securely attached child.
A mother whose child is ambivalently attached would be inconsistent with her child, at times appropriate and at other times neglectful. The child raised in an ambivalent relationship becomes preoccupied with the mother's availability and cannot explore freely or use mother as a secure base. The ambivalently attached child is vulnerable to difficulty coping with life stresses and may display role reversal with the mother.
Key concepts of Attachment Theory
- Early attachment crucial for love, caring, affection, empathy
- Early separation from mother/father can be traumatic
- Trauma leaves a lasting effect
- Trauma especially in boys can lead to a numbing of emotions
- Suppressing empathy, compassion
- Causing cold blooded violence
ADLER'S MODEL
Alfred Adler was an Austrian medical doctor and psychologist, founder of the school of individual psychology. He was one of Freud's first disciples and held important positions in the psychoanalytical movement, but was the first great dissident from Freudian psychoanalysis, criticizing its purely sexual sense.
Will to power: Adler saw people as goal oriented, with an urge toward personal growth and wholeness β often summarized as 'the will to power'. He did not give the unconscious enormous power as Freud did. Instead, he saw social drives, training from cultural heritage, and family influences as prime forces in our behavior and feelings. These primal influences could be modified by an individual in a personal way, so each person develops personal styles in dealing with life.
Sexual crimes and will to power: Feminist theories understood Adler's views and concluded that rape is not a sexual crime but rather an expression of will to power. If a woman rejects a man, he feels a challenge and takes revenge.
Inferiority complex: A feeling that one is inferior to others in some way. Such feelings can arise from imagined or actual inferiority. It is often subconscious and is thought to drive afflicted individuals to overcompensate, resulting either in spectacular achievement or extreme antisocial behavior, or both. Unlike a normal feeling of inferiority (which can act as an incentive for achievement), an inferiority complex is an advanced state of discouragement, often resulting in retreat from difficulties.
Adler originated the term 'inferiority complex,' arising from his view that as babies and young children, much of our feeling life is a compensation for a sense of inferiority or inadequacy. He argued that human personality could be explained by the guiding purpose of the individual's unconscious self ideal to convert feelings of inferiority to superiority. If corrective factors were disregarded and the individual over-compensated, an inferiority complex would occur, fostering the danger of becoming egocentric, power-hungry, and aggressive.
Superiority complex: A subconscious neurotic mechanism of compensation developed by the individual as a result of feelings of inferiority. Those exhibiting the superiority complex commonly project their feelings onto others they perceive as inferior. Behaviors may include an exaggeratedly positive opinion of one's worth and abilities, unrealistically high expectations, vanity, extravagant style in dressing, pride, sentimentalism, snobbism, a tendency to discredit others' opinions, forcefulness aimed at dominating those considered weaker, credulity, and others.
Birth order: Defined as a person's rank by age among siblings. Birth order is commonly believed to have a profound and lasting effect on psychological development. In childhood, a person may learn to compensate for feelings by either pushing toward superior performance in some area, or by aggressive action, or perhaps even withdrawal.
Key concepts of Adler's Model
- Individual develop a sense of inferiority
- Inferiority Complex
- Superiority Complex
- Considered the will to power the basic motive of human life
- Most crimes are expressions of will to power
- "Rape is not a sexual crime" comes out of this approach
MICHEL FOUCAULT'S MODEL
Michel Foucault is known for his critical studies of various social institutions, most notably psychiatry, medicine, education, and the prison system, as well as his work on the history of sexuality. He presented a model similar to Roger's model and focused on the evils of society. He presented extreme views about prisoners, saying that society does not like differences and seeks to create compliance. He considered schools as the factories of making people who are not different from each other.
Prisons Vs Schools: Foucault viewed that there is no difference in schools and prisons as both have a specific starting time with the ring of a bell and specific places for specific works. He considered schools as the manifestation of society's will to create compliant people who do not think differently, and if they do not obey authority, they get punishment like prisoners.
Prisons Vs mental hospitals: Michel Foucault viewed no difference in the system and goal of mental hospitals and prisons.
Key Concepts of Foucault's Model
- Society has no tolerance for differences
- It seeks to create compliance
- Schools and prisons are similar institutions perpetuating conformity
- Mental institutions are no exceptions
- Psychiatry and Psychology are partners in crime
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that moral development progresses through Piaget's four stages (sensorimotor, pre-operational, concrete operational, formal operational) and that without formal operations, an individual cannot achieve full moral reasoning about others' rights β directly linking cognitive development to violence potential. The Bio-Psychological Model attributes crime to genetic/biological predisposition with traits of low constraint and negative emotionality, arguing criminals cannot be corrected. Attachment Theory emphasizes that early separation from parents and trauma, especially in boys, can cause emotional numbing leading to cold-blooded violence, with three attachment styles (secure, avoidant, ambivalent) determining future capacity for empathy. Adler's Model introduces will to power as the basic human motive, with rape understood as power expression rather than sexual crime, while inferiority and superiority complexes explain compensatory violent behavior. Finally, Foucault controversially equates schools, prisons, and mental hospitals as institutions designed to enforce societal compliance and eliminate difference.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
According to Piaget, why can't an individual who never reaches the formal operational stage fully understand why violence against others is wrong?
-
What are the two personality traits that the Bio-Psychological Model identifies as especially conducive to crime, and how do they manifest in behavior?
-
How does secure attachment differ from avoidant and ambivalent attachment in terms of the mother's responsiveness and the child's resulting behavior?
-
According to Adler's Model, how does the concept of "will to power" explain rape, and what is the relationship between inferiority complex and superiority complex?
-
What is Michel Foucault's central argument about the relationship between schools, prisons, and mental hospitals, and what does he mean by "society seeks to create compliance"?
π Lecture 18 β Bio-psycho-social Model
π Overview: This lecture introduces the bio-psycho-social model, which integrates biological, psychological, and social factors to explain criminal behavior. It challenges the idea that increasing prison populations reduces crime, advocating instead for treatment of offenders, while critically examining the model's limitations and introducing the concept of proportionate punishment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the core tenets of the bio-psycho-social model, including how genetic predispositions interact with environmental and psychological factors to produce criminal behavior. It then critiques the model's strong stance against punishment, noting that mental hospitals can be as harmful as prisons. Finally, it presents the alternative idea of proportionate punishment, including the concept of day jails for minor offenders.
π Lecture Summary
Bio-psycho-social Model
The bio-psycho-social model emphasizes that biological, psychological, and social factors all play a significant role in human functioning and criminal behavior. It posits that biological predisposition, environmental/cultural factors, and psychological elements are all equally important for making a person criminal. The model is used in fields such as criminal psychology, medicine, and sociology, representing the popular concept of the mind-body connection.
π Definition β Bio-psycho-social model: A model which emphasizes that biological tendencies, environmental/cultural factors, and psychological elements all play an equally important role in making a person a criminal. π Example: Twin and adoption studies (Mednick et al., 1984) have clearly shown there is a genetic basis to antisocial, aggressive, and violent behavior, but these biological predispositions interact with psychological and social factors.
The model explains that youth with early onset behavioral problems have genetic factors that strongly influence temperamental predisposition, particularly oppositional temperament, which can affect experiences negatively. However, when antisocial behavior occurs later in childhood or adolescence, genetic factors contribute less, and such youths engage in delinquent behavior primarily because of peer influences and lapses in parenting. π‘ Why this matters: This shows that the same type of behavior can have different causes depending on when it starts, requiring different interventions.
Limitations of the Bio-psycho-social Model
This model is quite optimistic and believes in treatment, not punishment. It suggests all criminals should be treated in mental hospitals instead of being locked in jails. The core concern of this model is to challenge the conventional wisdom that increasing the prison population is an effective way to reduce crime. The model argues that jails are "factories of criminals" because new criminals are imprisoned with hardened criminals and the abnormal environment of jail does not reform the criminal but instead makes them a habitual criminal.
However, the lecture warns that the model's implications should be taken with "a pinch of salt." If all offenders were sent to mental hospitals instead of prisons, the environment of a mental hospital is not better than any jail, and offenders may become subject to torturous and inhuman treatment. Applying the idea of "no punishment only treatment" can be dangerous for two reasons:
- Removing punishment can encourage people to commit crime.
- On the name of treatment, people can be subjected to very negative experiences of sublimation, suppression, and inhuman treatment.
Proportionate Punishment
The lecture advocates for the idea of proportionate punishment instead of the bio-psycho-social model's blanket treatment approach. The basic rationale of proportionate punishment is:
- Punish those who have committed a crime
- Treat those who are mentally ill
- Repeated offenders should be kept in separate jails from other criminals
The concept of day jails is being successfully applied in many western countries. In day jails, people who have disobeyed the legal system (like fast driving) but have not committed any serious kind of criminal act are kept for a few hours a day. The most striking evidence for this proposition is the recent experience of New York City, which during the 1990s and into the 2000s registered huge reductions in recorded crime while substantially decreasing its use of prison. The number of people New York City annually sends to prison fell from around 20,000 in the early 1990s to 8,000 today.
β Key Takeaways
The bio-psycho-social model integrates biological, psychological, and social factors to explain criminal behavior, acknowledging genetic predispositions but emphasizing the role of parenting, attachment, and cultural variables. While the model is optimistic and believes in treatment over punishment, its implication of sending all offenders to mental hospitals is problematic because it can encourage crime and subject people to inhuman treatment. The better approach is proportionate punishment, which distinguishes between criminals (to be punished) and the mentally ill (to be treated), and advocates for day jails and separate facilities for repeat offenders. The New York City example demonstrates that decreasing prison use can coincide with reducing crime rates. All psychological models must be applied with reference to one's own society and situation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main factors in the bio-psycho-social model of criminal behavior?
- According to the bio-psycho-social model, why do youth with early onset versus later onset behavioral problems differ in their causes?
- What are the two main dangers of applying the "no punishment only treatment" approach from the bio-psycho-social model?
- What are the three principles of proportionate punishment as described in the lecture?
- What is a "day jail" and how did New York City's experience demonstrate its potential effectiveness?