📘 Lecture 18 — Development of Gender Role Identification
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the process through which children develop gender role identification, covering its three core aspects: preference, adoption, and identification. It explains how gender identity forms in early childhood, the cognitive milestones of gender constancy, and the external factors that shape this development.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the three aspects of gender role identification: gender role preference, gender role adoption, and gender role identification. It then discusses the distinction between gender identity and gender roles, the basic ingredients and early development of gender identity, the progression from gender labeling to knowledge of gender-related behaviors, and the concepts of gender constancy, stability, consistency, and discrimination. Finally, it lists external variables contributing to gender identity.
📝 Lecture Summary
Development of Gender Role Identification
The process involves three aspects: Gender Role Preference, Gender Role Adoption, and Gender Role Identification (Lynn, 1959). The child prefers attributes and objects associated with their sex, adopts these, and identifies oneself as a member of that sex while seeing others as different.
Gender Role Preference
Gender role preference is the perception that the role of one sex is more desirable compared to the other. This preference begins at around 3 years of age and is quite firm and established by 5 years of age. This preference is commonly manifested in children’s preference for toys considered to be associated with the sex of the ones going to play with them; toys are seen as “boys’ toys” and “girls’ toys”. Around 3 years of age, girls prefer to play with dolls, doll’s house, playing house, tea cups etc., usually indoors. Boys prefer to play more outdoors than indoors and show preference for cars, trucks, and airplanes. Children younger than these do not seem to be bothered about the gender association of toys. In a study by Jacklin et al. (1973), a variety of toys were presented to one-year-old boys and girls, in the presence of their mothers. The toys included robots, stuffed animals, and a ferries wheel decorated with pink ribbons. No significant sex differences were found in the children’s preference for toys except that boys preferred robots; nor were the mothers’ selection of toys different for boys and girls.
🔑 Definition — Gender Role Preference: The perception that the role of one sex is more desirable compared to the other.
Gender Role Adoption
This aspect involves displaying sex-typed or sex-related behaviors. Children adopt observable, sex-related behaviors performed by members of their own sex. There are differences in gender role adoption by boys and girls. In the case of girls, gender role adoption and gender role identification develop simultaneously with gender role identification. For boys, the processes follow a sequence. In the case of girls, when they start exhibiting sex-typed behavior, at the same time they begin internalization of the female role and its related attributes (Williams, 1987). In a study by Ward (1969), girls 5–7 years of age could perceive similarities between their mothers and themselves; same-aged boys could not do so with reference to their fathers.
🔑 Definition — Gender Role Adoption: Displaying sex-typed or sex-related behaviors by adopting observable behaviors performed by members of one’s own sex.
Gender Role Identification
Gender role identification incorporates the response characteristics of a gender role into one’s personality. In early childhood, both boys and girls are closely attached to the mother, but development of gender identity requires boys to detach from the existing behavioral pattern. Gender role identification is easier for girls, since all they have to do is elaborate the early parented identification. The boy has to step out of the early parental identification, learn and adopt the “masculine” role.
🔑 Definition — Gender Role Identification: Incorporating the response characteristics of a gender role into one’s personality.
Gender Identity, Gender Roles and Socialization
Gender identity refers to children’s identification and acceptance of themselves as male or female. It is the “awareness developed in early childhood that one is male or female” (Papalia, Olds, and Feldman, 2001). Although used interchangeably, the terms “gender identity” and “gender roles” have a different connotation. Gender identity is more of an internal phenomenon, whereas gender roles pertain to observable behaviors typically associated with the two genders. Children may have developed gender identity but may not behave in a gender-typical way.
🔑 Definition — Gender Identity: The awareness developed in early childhood that one is male or female (Papalia, Olds, and Feldman, 2001).
Basic ingredients of gender identity — Certain elements must be present for a child to develop gender identity: a. The awareness that human beings exist in two categories with separate labels i.e., males and females. b. Males and females are different from each other in terms of their characteristics. c. What behaviors or activities are undertaken by men and women? d. The basic cognitive data or information about the basis on which the child fits into one category or the other.
Gender Identity in Early Infancy
Infants do not have a sense of gender identity; however, parents usually set up the environment so that children, as they grow, are automatically steered toward developing accurate gender identity. Some research evidence suggests that even infants have some sense of gender typical or atypical behaviors. In one study, 7, 9, and 12-month-old infants could distinguish between male and female faces when shown their photographs. The distinguishing cue was the length of hair (Fagot and Leinbach, 1994; Leinbach and Fagot, 1993). Another study suggested that 24-month-old infants have some knowledge of gender-typical or gender-atypical activities. Infants attended to photographs for longer durations where people were performing gender-atypical activities (Serbin, Poulin-Dubois, and Eichstedt, 2002). In another study of 12 and 24-month-old children investigating knowledge of gender-typical toys, it was revealed that girls demonstrated some such knowledge but not the boys (Serbin, Poulin-Dubois, Colburne, Sen and Eichstedt, 2001).
Beginning of the Use of Gender Labels
When children start talking, they start using different words denoting gender. This is the beginning of gender-labeling. Children may make errors in the use of gender labels in the beginning (e.g., a girl addressing herself as a boy or labeling boys as girls). This error may be found more commonly in languages like Urdu that treat not only people but also all objects and even events as male or female, with grammar changing according to gender. Children soon overcome this problem with guidance. Gender-labeling has been observed to develop after 18 months of age. In a study by Fagot and Leinbach (1989), no toddler under 18 months of age could pass the gender-labeling tasks. The gender-labeling task could be done successfully by few children at 20 months old (Levy, 1999). Most children are capable of correct gender-labeling by 24 months of age. Correct gender-labeling by half of the 27-month-olds sampled has been reported (Fagot and Leinbach, 1989). Another study found that 67% of two-year-olds could use gender-labeling accurately. All 28-month-olds have been reported to be successful in gender-labeling (Levy, 1999).
🔑 Definition — Gender-labeling: The beginning of using different words denoting gender, starting when children begin to talk.
Knowledge of Gender-related Behavior, Traits and Attributes
Successful gender-labeling does not ensure that the child can successfully adopt and understand gender roles. Their labeling may not be based upon accurate cues of information; they may label a person as male or female considering their dress or haircut. Accurate understanding and knowledge about gender-related behaviors and characteristics develops after accurate gender-labeling. Some indication of the understanding of male and female categories, and objects associated with each category has been found in 20–28-month-olds (Levy, 1999). Research shows that 3-year-olds are able to label the sexes, make groupings based on gender, and exhibit some knowledge of behaviors typically associated with men and women (Martin and Little, 1990; Ruble and Martin, 1997). Most children have not developed gender-constancy at three years of age. Although they are aware of their own gender, they think gender can be changed by changing appearance (e.g., hairstyle, make-up, or dress).
Gender Constancy, Stability, Consistency, and Gender Discrimination
Gender constancy refers to the knowledge that gender is a permanent and unchangeable feature of one’s self. Gender-stability and gender-consistency are two cognitive ingredients of gender constancy. Gender stability refers to the awareness and knowledge that gender is a stable personal characteristic. Gender consistency refers to the belief that gender is an unchangeable characteristic that remains fixed and unalterable even when appearances or actions change. Gender stability can be observed in children even in the absence of gender consistency, but the latter cannot exist in the absence of the former (Martin and Little, 1990). Most children, by years of age, are successful in tests of gender-discrimination and gender-stability; they also have developed an understanding of gender-typical clothes and toys that is closer to the stereotype (Martin and Little, 1990; Ruble and Martin, 1998). But this cannot be taken as a rule. Preschoolers and even some elementary school children may not have acquired gender-stability and gender-consistency (Warin, 2000). In elementary school children, changed appearance and changed name of a character may produce confusion about the character’s gender (Beal and Lockhart, 1989). Once children have developed both gender-stability and gender-consistency, gender becomes a more salient aspect of their lives. They are more concerned about gender-appropriate behavior and making gender friends (Warin, 2000). Children who develop gender constancy become motivated to adopt gender role behaviors, causing them to avoid some activities and engage in others (Newman, Cooper, and Ruble, 1995). Therefore, gender constancy is accompanied by a motivation to adopt and practice gender-typical behaviors.
🔑 Definition — Gender Constancy: Knowledge that gender is a permanent and unchangeable feature of one’s self. 🔑 Definition — Gender Stability: The awareness and knowledge that gender is a stable personal characteristic. 🔑 Definition — Gender Consistency: The belief that gender is an unchangeable characteristic that remains fixed even when appearances or actions change. 📌 Example: A child who has not yet achieved gender constancy may believe a boy can become a girl if he puts on a dress or changes his hairstyle (appearance-based reasoning).
External Variables Contributing to Gender Identity
- Parental attitudes
- Peers and siblings
- School
- Media
⭐ Key Takeaways
Gender role development involves three sequential aspects: preference, adoption, and identification. Girls typically develop gender role adoption and identification simultaneously, while boys follow a sequential process requiring detachment from early maternal attachment. Gender identity, the internal awareness of being male or female, develops gradually from infancy through milestones like gender labeling (around 18–24 months) and gender constancy (typically by age 3–5 years). Gender constancy is comprised of stability and consistency, and once achieved, motivates children to adopt gender-typical behaviors. External factors such as parents, peers, school, and media significantly influence this developmental process.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three aspects of gender role identification, and how do they differ between boys and girls?
- At what age does gender role preference typically begin and become firmly established?
- What is the difference between gender identity and gender roles?
- Define gender constancy and explain its two cognitive ingredients: gender stability and gender consistency.
- At what age range does accurate gender-labeling typically develop, and what is a common error children make early on?
📘 Lecture 19 — Gender Differences in Personality
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the evidence for and against psychological differences between men and women in personality traits. It critically evaluates research on gender differences in aggression, non-verbal communication, and expressiveness, concluding that most differences are small and inconsistent, with aggression being a notable exception. The lecture explores biological and social explanations for these differences.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing that research on gender differences in personality traits is largely inconclusive, with most differences being insignificant and inconsistent except for aggression. It then systematically covers gender differences in aggression, including biological and social explanations, bullying, non-verbal communication and behaviors, touching, and expressiveness and sensitivity.
📝 Lecture Summary
Gender and Aggression
Research provides strong empirical evidence that males are more aggressive than females, a difference that appears as early as age 2 and persists throughout life. Women feel more anxiety and guilt over their aggression and are more concerned about its effects on victims. While physical aggression is much more common in boys, relational aggression (or social aggression), which aims to cause psychic pain through insult or social rejection, is considered more hurtful, especially in older girls. Girls use relational aggression—such as snubbing, ignoring, and undermining others—more than boys, though both sexes use it. Most research shows greater gender differences in physical aggression than in verbal aggression. In most societies, men account for violent crime in disproportionately large numbers.
🔑 Definition — Relational Aggression: Aggression that aims to cause psychic pain to the victim rather than physical pain; it involves insult or social rejection. 📌 Example: A group of girls deliberately excluding a classmate from a birthday party and spreading rumors about her to ensure she remains isolated.
The Biological Explanation
This viewpoint argues that the gender difference in aggression is innate and biologically based in hormones (Maccoby & Jacklin, 1980).
💡 Why this matters: This explanation suggests that aggression differences are fixed and inevitable, which has implications for how we view gender roles and justice.
Learning and Social Factors Explanation
This approach argues that learning and socialization are the responsible factors for gender differences in aggression, not biology. If aggressiveness were purely biological, it should be the same in children and adults. However, if the tendency develops in adulthood or increases with age, then social factors are responsible. Some research, though not conclusive, suggests that aggression tends to increase with the age of the child.
Gender Differences in Bullying
Bullying is common in school-going children. Mostly boys are bullied by older boys or peers. For girls, a dimension of sexual teasing or touching has been reported. In the US, one third of all 9-15 years old girls reported having experienced sexual teasing or touching, which caused problems so serious they wanted to avoid school (American Association of University Women Foundation, 1993).
Gender Differences in Non-Verbal Communication and Behaviors
Men and women differ in non-verbal communication. Females are more sensitive to subtle non-verbal cues than men (Hall, 1990) and may be better at decoding or interpreting others' body language (Eagly, 1987; Hall, 1978). However, there are no differences in the display of postures or gestures associated with dominance in non-verbal social situations. Women have a tendency to gaze when someone is talking, especially a man; men typically do not look at women talking. Women are generally more formal and tense in posture and demeanor, while men are generally informal and relaxed (Henley, 1977). Women are also more likely to smile than men. According to Henley, these differences reflect the power position of men and submission of women, indicating men have a higher and women a lower status in society.
Touching
Men and women differ in the use of touching as part of non-verbal communication. Men touch, but do not generally like being touched. Women generally give a positive response to touching, but do not usually take the initiative in touching (Whitcher & Fisher, 1979; Henley, 1977; Major, 1981).
Expressiveness and Sensitivity
Men and women vary in expressiveness and sensitivity to what the other person is communicating. Women have been found to be superior both in accurately sending and in understanding non-verbal communication (Hall, 1984; Mayo & Henley, 1981; Rosenthal & Benowitz, 1985). Women have an ability to identify negative feelings, except anger in many cases. According to Brown (1986), this heightened ability may be a function of women’s less powerful position, as they may have had to develop sensitivity to the leakage of negative feelings from those in power.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For the exam, students must remember that most research on gender differences in personality shows these differences are small and inconsistent, with aggression being the most robust exception. Understand the distinction between physical aggression (more common in males) and relational aggression (more common in females). Know the two competing explanations for aggression differences: the biological (hormone-based) and the learning/socialization approach. For non-verbal communication, remember that women are generally more sensitive, better at decoding cues, smile more, and gaze more at speakers, while men are more relaxed, touch more frequently, and avoid being touched. Finally, recall that gender differences in non-verbal behavior are often interpreted as reflecting power and status differences in society.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What does the research evidence (e.g., Huston, 1985; Hyde, 1984) generally conclude about the magnitude and consistency of most gender differences in personality traits?
- What is "relational aggression," and which gender is more likely to use it compared to physical aggression?
- Compare and contrast the biological explanation and the learning/social factors explanation for gender differences in aggression.
- According to Henley (1977), what do the observed gender differences in non-verbal behaviors like smiling, posture, and gaze reflect about societal power structures?
- What is the gender difference in the behavior of touching, and how do men and women differ in their initiation of and response to touching?
📘 Lecture 20 — Gender Differences in Personality
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how gender influences various aspects of personality, including communication styles, friendship patterns, altruistic behavior, and self-perception. Understanding these differences is crucial for recognizing how social expectations and gender roles shape human behavior and interpersonal dynamics.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers gender differences in communication style, including self-disclosure patterns and verbal communication differences. It then examines gender and affiliation/friendship patterns, followed by gender differences in altruism and helping behavior. Finally, it explores gender differences in self-confidence and self-esteem, including how men and women evaluate their abilities differently.
📝 Lecture Summary
Gender Difference in Communication Style
Although women are stereotypically thought to be talkative, it is men who are more talkative and likely to interrupt others (Key, 1975). Communication style differences are among the most studied areas of gender and personality research.
Self-Disclosure
Females are more likely to indulge in self-disclosure. They are more likely to share their inner ideas and feelings (Cozby, 1973). Men and women consistently differ both in degree of disclosure and what they actually reveal (Shafer, Pegalis, and Bazzini, 1996). As compared to men, women generally disclose more, especially about emotions, relationships, and other personal matters (Cozby, 1972; Davidson and Duberman, 1982). Men, especially highly masculine men, disclose more in one context—they disclose more with women with whom they anticipate future interaction. In disclosing more to women in such a context, these men seem to want to take the lead in exploring possibilities for a future romantic relationship with the women (Schaffer, Pegalis, and Bazzini, 1996).
According to Henley, men disclose only to women with whom they are intimate, or wish to become intimate. Self-disclosure is also influenced by gender-role stereotypes. People, both men and women, if insecure and socially anxious, are likely to disclose themselves in a way that is consistent with gender-role stereotypes; in doing so they may reinforce and perpetuate those stereotypes (Snell, 1989).
Gender Differences in Communication
Gender differences are found in non-verbal as well as verbal communication styles (McMillan et al., 1977; Feingold, 1994). The nature of the content of speech used by women is different from that used by men. Women use a less assertive speech pattern. But the way women talk leads others to evaluate them as less assertive and tentative. Women have a tendency to add tags at the end of an opinion instead of a straight opinion statement. They tend to raise the pitch at the end of a sentence. When they add tags at the end of an opinion, women appear to be less certain about the statement they are making. As a result of their use of tentative language, women are viewed as less competent and knowledgeable; this opinion is not made in case of those using an assertive style of speech (Martin, 1987; Carli, 1990; Crawford, 1995).
Women, although stereotypically considered talkative, talk less than men. Men are more talkative in a variety of settings. As compared to women, men are more likely to interrupt others (Key, 1975). According to Davidson and Duberman in a study of communication between pairs of best friends (1982), there are no differences between men and women in terms of talking about topical issues like politics, current events, movies, or work. However, they differ in their discussion of relational and personal topics. Women are more likely to make specific talk about:
- Personal aspects of their life, and
- their relationship with the friend
Men and women are not different, and are similar, in reciprocity in self-disclosure; if the intimacy of the disclosure is increased by one person, the other person will be likely to respond similarly (Cozby, 1973).
Gender, Affiliation and Friendship
Some gender differences have been found in affiliation and friendship patterns. Robert Hays and Diana Oxley (1986) report that first-year university resident students' social networks were different in some respects. As compared to women, men included more females in their social network. The exchange of informational and emotional support with friends was higher in females. In terms of interactions with family members, males and females were alike, but within their networks, females interacted more.
The friendship pattern also varies with gender. Verbal communication is an important element in female friendships; female friendships depend more on verbal exchange. In case of male friendships, these evolve from shared activities (Hays, 1985). Some studies have revealed that in interpersonal communication, males use less touching than females.
Gender and Altruism
Altruism is "a special form of helping behavior that is voluntary, costly, and motivated by a desire to improve another person's welfare, rather than by the anticipation of reward" (Deaux, Dane, and Wrightsman, 1993). It is the "helping behavior that is beneficial to others but clearly requires self-sacrifice" (Feldman, 2002).
🔑 Definition — Altruism: Helping behavior that is voluntary, costly, and motivated by a desire to improve another person's welfare rather than by anticipation of reward (Deaux, Dane, and Wrightsman, 1993).
As far as willingness to indulge in altruistic behavior or self-sacrifice for others' welfare is concerned, more females than males report this willingness. However, there is no clear cut empirical evidence to suggest if there are any differences in the actual performance of altruistic behavior (Rushton et al., 1986; Sennecker and Hendrick, 1983). Women are more likely to provide help and emotional support in connection with their traditional role as nurturers (Brody, 1990; Eagly and Crowley, 1986; Pleck, 1985). However, in situations involving dangerous emergencies, men are more likely to intervene. In a study reported by Huston and others (1981), all people in their sample who intervened to stop criminals were men. As part of their traditional role, males are expected to behave heroically in dangerous situations. Men and women both may consider the consequences of their behaviors in risky situations, but their perceptions and patterns may be different. Men may perceive the costs of intervening in risky situations to be lower than women do, since men are physically stronger and more likely to have relevant skills such as self-defense training (Huston et al., 1981).
💡 Why this matters: This distinction shows how gender roles and social expectations influence the type and context of altruistic behavior, with women gravitating toward nurturing help and men toward heroic intervention.
Gender Self Confidence and Self Esteem
When asked to perform a task, especially a new one, females hesitate more than men. If women are given a task, particularly one usually associated with a male role, women tend to be less self-confident than men, whereas actually they may perform the same way as men did (Beyer, 1990; Lenney, 1977). Although the gender difference in self-esteem may not be huge, men generally score higher than women; a number of factors contribute to this difference. Women's perception of their sense of interdependence and connection with others largely influences their self-esteem. Men's self-esteem, on the other hand, has roots in their assessment of their unique characteristics and abilities—traits that help them distinguish themselves from other people (Feingold, 1994; King et al., 1999).
Some studies have reported gender differences in terms of how people make positive assessments of their abilities and their potential for future success. Women generally evaluate themselves more harshly than men. In one survey, first-year college students were asked to rate themselves as being above or below average. More men than women rated themselves as above average. They felt they were above average in overall academic and mathematical ability, competitiveness, and emotional health (Gabriel, Critelli, and Ee, 1994; Orenstein, 2001).
💡 Why this matters: These findings reveal that self-confidence differences are not about actual ability but about perception and social conditioning, particularly in tasks associated with traditional gender roles.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that gender differences in personality are shaped by social roles, stereotypes, and expectations rather than inherent biological differences. In communication, men talk more and interrupt more, while women use more tentative language and disclose more about emotions and relationships. Friendship patterns differ fundamentally—women's friendships are based on verbal exchange, while men's develop from shared activities. Regarding altruism, women report greater willingness to help but perform nurturant help, while men are more likely to intervene in dangerous emergencies. Finally, men generally show higher self-esteem and self-confidence, especially in male-typed tasks, while women evaluate themselves more harshly and base their self-esteem on interpersonal connections rather than unique abilities.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What three communication patterns characterize women's speech that make them appear less assertive?
- According to Davidson and Duberman (1982), what is the difference between men and women in their discussion of topics with best friends?
- How do male and female friendship patterns differ in their foundation?
- In what types of situations are men more likely to help compared to women, and what explanation is given for this difference?
- How do men and women differ in the basis of their self-esteem according to the lecture?
📘 Lecture 21 — Cognitive Differences
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the stereotypical beliefs about gender differences in intelligence and cognitive abilities, contrasting them with empirical research findings. It explores the nuanced reality that while some small differences exist in specific cognitive domains (like math and verbal skills), overall intelligence shows no significant gender gap, and these differences are influenced by social and educational factors.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by challenging the stereotype that men are inherently more intelligent than women, presenting meta-analytic evidence showing minimal average differences. It then examines specific claims about Gender Differences in I.Q, analyzing research on mathematical ability, spatial skills, and the declining gender gap. Finally, it explores Gender and Verbal Ability, presenting evidence of female advantages in language acquisition and verbal tasks across age groups.
📝 Lecture Summary
It is stereotypically believed that men and women are intellectually very different...
Empirical research does not indicate any significant gender differences in terms of overall intelligence and cognitive ability. While some differences have been noted in specific cognitive areas, there are no true differences in overall performance. An analysis by Hedges and Nowell (1995) of teenage mental ability test performance over 30 years found very minute average differences. However, in some tests, the number of boys performing very high or very poor was disproportionately large: in science tests, seven times more boys than girls scored in the top 5 percent; in math tests, twice as many boys scored in the top 5 percent. Conversely, in tests of perceptual speed, reading comprehension, and writing skills, boys were much more likely than girls to score lower.
Gender Differences in I.Q
There is no strong evidence suggesting any real gender difference in I.Q scores. The few studies that show differences indicate very small gaps that have become even smaller in recent decades. Females generally outperform males in verbal skills, while males perform better on tasks involving spatial ability or mathematical ability. While Maccoby and Jacklin's (1974) early study supported these stereotypes, a meta-analysis by Hyde and associates (1990) of 100 studies with over 3 million participants showed that on average, males and females are not very different in mathematical performance. In elementary and middle school, females were slightly better in computational skills; at high school or college, males did slightly better in mathematical problem solving, especially in advanced tests. When all age groups were considered, differences were almost insignificant. The stereotypically perceived gender differences are declining, though when they exist, they are slightly skewed in favor of males. Some research shows more boys than girls are gifted in mathematics, with a 4-to-1 boys-to-girls ratio in one North American study. Explanations include the positive relationship between spatial ability and math achievement (males score higher on visual-spatial measures from grade school onward) and social learning: math is often not considered "a girl's thing." Educational experiences also matter: males enroll in more advanced math courses, which correlates with better math performance.
💡 Why this matters: These findings show that cognitive differences are not fixed biological facts but are heavily influenced by social expectations, educational opportunities, and cultural stereotypes.
🔑 Definition — Spatial ability: The capacity to manipulate and reason about visual and spatial relationships, which contributes to better understanding of geometry and math achievement. 📐 Formula: spatial ability → better geometry understanding → contributes to gender difference in math achievement 📌 Example: Boys at around ten years of age begin to show better spatial ability than girls. This contributes to a better understanding of geometry, which in turn leads to a great part of the gender difference in math achievement (Johnson and Mead, 1987).
Gender and Verbal Ability
Similar trends exist for verbal ability, but in favor of females. Females in all age groups exhibit better verbal ability and skills on average. Female children start speaking slightly earlier than boys; in school years, girls have better reading scores and higher vocabularies. Literature reviews indicate that females have an advantage over males in performance on verbal tasks, including rapidity and proficiency in language acquisition. This trend is maintained all the way through elementary school years (Halpern, 1994, 1997, 2000; Maccoby and Jacklin, 1974).
⭐ Key Takeaways
The critical takeaway is that empirical research, particularly meta-analyses, shows no significant overall gender difference in intelligence or cognitive ability. While small differences exist—males tend to perform slightly better on spatial and advanced math tasks, and females on verbal tasks—these gaps are shrinking over time and are strongly influenced by social learning and educational experiences rather than inherent biological differences. Students must remember that stereotypes about male intellectual superiority are not supported by evidence, and that within-gender variation is far greater than between-gender variation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What did the meta-analysis by Hyde and associates (1990) reveal about gender differences in mathematical performance across different age groups?
- What is the relationship between spatial ability and gender differences in math achievement, and at what age does this difference typically emerge?
- According to the lecture, what are the main social and educational explanations for the small gender differences observed in math performance?
- What pattern do females show in verbal ability across the lifespan, according to Halpern (1994, 1997, 2000)?
- How did the Hedges and Nowell (1995) study show that boys were overrepresented at both the high and low extremes of test performance?
📘 Lecture 22 — GENDER AND MEDIA
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how media—including print, television, cinema, and children's books—functions as a powerful agent of socialization that shapes and reinforces gender stereotypes. It explores how portrayals of men and women across various media platforms influence attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors, particularly in children and adolescents, and discusses both the problems of stereotypical representation and the potential for change.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the role of media as an influential agent of socialization in forming gender attitudes; how television, print media, and movies portray men and women in stereotypical ways; the impact of media on children's and adolescents' gender role learning through observational learning; research findings on television viewing and sexism scores; the portrayal of gender in TV commercials and music videos; findings from Pakistani research on media representation; and the changing trends toward more realistic gender depictions in media.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Influence of Media on Gender Attitudes
Media, particularly mass media, is one of the most influential agents of socialization. It has a direct impact upon an individual's mind on cognition, affect, and behavior. Media may change one's thinking, feeling, and actions (attitudes) or further strengthen already existing attitudes. Media consists of print media and electronic media, with electronic media including TV, cinema, and the internet. Today, no other source of impacting people's mind can match the impact of electronic media, particularly television. When TV was not commonly available, print media used to be the major agent of attitude formation and change. Television influences one through both visual and auditory sensations.
The way men and women are portrayed on television represents the stereotypes held in a society. Similarly, how newspapers report events reflects stereotypically held beliefs about men and women. Fiction, poetry, and fine art created at various times in history are indicators of how society perceives men and women. For example, the way women were painted in the Victorian Era was totally different from today—a round, slightly overweight female figure was considered healthy and representative of fertility, motherhood, and affluence, while very thin bodies were considered symbols of disease or poverty.
Even children's books are a source of teaching and promoting stereotypical gender roles. Modern books do have female characters that are braver and more resourceful, and friendship between boys and girls is shown more often. However, male characters still predominate, females are more likely to need help, and males are more likely to help (Beal, 1994; Evans, 1998).
Research shows that the amount of television viewing affects sexism scores of adolescent girls. For girls, particularly those from middle-class families, their sexism scores increased with heavy television viewing (Morgan, 1982). The same study showed that such impact was not found in boys—the attitudes of boys who already held sexist views and watched TV heavily did not change by their TV watching experience.
Television delivers messages through soap operas, talk shows, news, documentaries, and most importantly, advertisements. TV programs promote and fortify gender-typed beliefs and behaviors. TV watching provides an opportunity for observational learning. If characters on TV follow a stereotypical pattern of behavior, viewers are highly likely to adopt similar attitudes. This is truer for children and adolescents who tend to imitate attractive characters and models.
💡 Why this matters: Media functions as a hidden curriculum, teaching gender roles continuously through entertainment, making its influence pervasive yet often unnoticed.
🔑 Definition — Sexism: Prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination based on sex, typically against women.
📐 Formula: Amount of TV viewing → Increased sexism scores (for adolescent girls) → Reinforcement of traditional gender stereotypes
📌 Example: In a natural experiment in Canada, TV transmission became available for the first time in several towns. After two years of TV watching, a significant increase was found in the traditional views of children who previously held relatively un-stereotyped views (Kimball, 1986). Conversely, children who watched less stereotyped or un-stereotyped roles on TV developed un-stereotyped views. In one study, children watched nontraditional episodes (e.g., father and son cooking together) and subsequently had less stereotyped views than those who had not watched these episodes (J. Johnston and Ettema, 1982).
Print Media and Portrayal of Genders
Before the advent of electronic media, print media remained the major source of attitude formation. Even after the popularity of television, the written word did not lose its effect. However, in the 21st century, more people, especially youngsters, spend most of their time with TV or computers. Still, print media remains one of the first sources of information a child encounters. Print media includes newspapers, books, and magazines.
So-called women's magazines make women more conscious of their looks, causing them to worry about their appearance and strive to please men (Peirce, 1990). One negative fallout is an over-concern about weight. The models appearing in these magazines are extremely thin, to an extent where it is not possible for most women to match them. In extreme cases, over-concern about losing excess body weight may lead to eating disorders, specifically bulimia and anorexia nervosa.
Children's story books also promote stereotyped gender roles. The hero is usually male, the one to be rescued by him is usually female, wizards are male, and witches are female. Media is the most forceful agent of socialization that has a direct impact on minds, especially those of the young and impressionable.
🔑 Definition — Anorexia Nervosa: An eating disorder characterized by an intense fear of gaining weight, self-starvation, and excessive weight loss.
🔑 Definition — Bulimia: An eating disorder characterized by episodes of binge eating followed by purging behaviors such as vomiting or excessive exercise.
📌 Example: Women's magazines consistently feature extremely thin models, creating an unrealistic standard that most women cannot achieve, leading to body dissatisfaction and potentially eating disorders.
Portrayal of Gender in Movies
In movies, the depiction of gender roles is widely exaggerated compared to real life. Cinema is a highly attractive, glamorous, and effective medium that presents role models to impressionable minds far from reality. Female characters in movies are very different from what women are like in real life.
One hardly finds a female lead playing the role of a successful, professional, self-made woman who runs her own life and that of her children like any able man does. In real life, we see many such women. The heroine is most often the damsel in distress who is rescued only when the hero arrives. Female characters are meant usually only for romance, dispute, or marriage. Men are shown to be strong, brave, independent, professional, and wise—they never make wrong decisions. Women cannot make quick decisions in crisis; they are overwhelmed by emotion, fearful, and weak.
Since cinema is a source of observational learning with all ingredients of attitude formation, girls learn to be dependent, weak, indecisive, non-assertive, and confused. Boys learn to be self-confident, bold, daring, in charge, self-reliant, and macho.
📌 Example: In typical movie plots, the heroine needs rescuing from danger and can only be saved when the hero arrives. She rarely rescues herself, scares away robbers, or protects herself from violence, whereas male characters regularly perform these actions.
Portrayal of Gender on Television
Television, being a strong medium providing role models, plays a vital role in teaching all sorts of behaviors. Children take TV to be a reliable, believable, and trustworthy medium—their major source of information. Children obtain information about various occupations from TV and believe this information to be accurate (Greenberg, 1982). Most TV programs portray men and women indulging in stereotypical occupations (M. Harris and Vorhees, 1981; Zuckerman and Zuckerman, 1985). Thus, children learn that surgery is a male profession and nursing a female profession, university professors are mostly men, and women are mostly school teachers.
TV shows have traditionally depicted men and women in stereotypical manner (Signorielli and Bacue, 1999). Men are depicted as assertive, independent, and competent; women are portrayed as submissive, passive, and emotional. Men are shown to be in charge of life, and women in need of support.
Women on TV have to be good-looking and physically attractive. It is not necessary that men on TV will always be handsome, but most women are young, attractive, and sexy (Davis, 1990). Men solve mysteries and show acts of chivalry; when women unmask villains, it is by mere chance, luck, or accident. In children's programs, including cartoons, male characters are active, aggressive, violent, and brave; female characters are generally attractive but dependent. Female characters are mostly passive, more likely to make mistakes, deferential, and ignored.
TV commercials are another source of promoting male and female images. TV commercials transmit highly effective messages in very short duration and are designed to leave a deep imprint on viewers' minds. TV ads use only most attractive females; the female model is usually shown bothered about trivial matters like the whiteness of laundry or the shine of dishes. Music channels in their videos portray women as sex objects, influencing viewers' attitudes about sexual conduct (Hansen and Hansen, 1988; Signorielli, 1993). Research in the US shows that an average child watches more than 20,000 TV ads in a year (M. Macklin and Kolbe, 1984). In one study of 300 TV commercials, researchers reported that the difference between male and female gender roles depicted in these commercials was far greater than the actual difference found in society (Mammay and Simpson, 1981).
Research in Pakistan has revealed similar trends (Shahed, 2003). A majority of people sampled reported that TV was portraying women as mere show pieces, as a cause of dispute and conflict, as talkative and stupid. Subjects of both genders and all age groups felt that the way women were portrayed on TV did not reflect real life scenario.
The most preferred traits listed by subjects for women were: i. Educated ii. Self-confident iii. Intelligent iv. Binding force for the family v. Morally strong vi. Good looking vii. Brave/not panicky in crisis
The most undesirable traits in females listed included:
- Talkative
- Quarrelsome
- Panicky
- Uneducated
Subjects said they wanted to see these desirable traits in women in media.
📌 Example: In TV ads, women are shown worrying about laundry whiteness or dish shine while men are shown as knowledgeable professionals who help women make the right choices, even when the woman is supposed to be a professional herself.
Changing Trends
The way media depicts men and women and their roles is changing nowadays. With significant real-life changes in gender roles, media, especially TV, is adopting a realistic path. The same is the case with movies. However, the change is not as prominent and rapid in our part of the world as it is in the west. Most TV programs still promote traditional stereotypical gender roles and reinforce such views. Today we see women working outside the home and men doing shopping or caring for children; however, even today, life is portrayed on TV in a manner more stereotypical than life in the real world (Coltrane and Adams, 1997; Ruble and Martin, 1998).
Many TV ads now show professional women like bank managers or traveling sales representatives, but most ads show women as housewives, mothers, or sex objects who defer to men's needs, wishes, and preferences. When even a professional woman is shown buying something, it is the male who helps her make the right choice. If TV programs or commercials show non-stereotyped roles shattering traditional ones, it has an effect. If children watch non-stereotyped characters in major roles, their views of gender roles are more flexible; they accept males and females in nontraditional occupations (Wroblewski and Huston, 1988).
💡 Why this matters: Media has the power not just to reinforce stereotypes but to break them, making it a crucial tool for promoting gender equality in society.
📌 Example: When children watch prime-time TV programs featuring non-stereotyped characters (e.g., female doctors, male nurses, or fathers cooking), their views become more flexible and they accept people in nontraditional occupations more readily.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Media is one of the most powerful agents of socialization, influencing cognition, affect, and behavior through observational learning. Research consistently shows that stereotypical media portrayals increase sexist attitudes, particularly in adolescent girls and children, while exposure to non-stereotyped portrayals promotes more flexible gender views. Across print, television, and cinema, women are consistently portrayed as dependent, emotional, and focused on appearance, while men are shown as independent, competent, and in charge. Pakistani research confirms these patterns and reveals that audiences desire more realistic portrayals of women as educated, self-confident, intelligent, and brave. While media is gradually changing toward more realistic depictions, it still lags behind real-life gender role changes, highlighting media's social responsibility to promote positive social change rather than reinforcing outdated stereotypes.