📘 Lecture 10 — THEORIES OF GENDER DEVELOPMENT (2)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of theories explaining gender development, shifting from the biological approach to the behavioral or learning approach. It explains how gender roles are learned through classical conditioning, operant conditioning, and observational learning, rather than being innate.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the behavioral approach as an alternative to the biological approach, emphasizing nurture over nature. It details three learning mechanisms: classical conditioning, operant conditioning (with focus on positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, punishment, and no consequence), and observational learning. The lecture also raises the critical question of how initial gender differences might have started.
📝 Lecture Summary
Recap
The lecture recaps the previous discussion on the Biological approach, highlighting its strong and weak points. It then introduces the Behaviorist or Learning Approach as a contrasting perspective that emphasizes "nurture" over "nature."
The Behaviorist or Learning Approach
Background: According to this approach, all behavior and personality is a result of learning. Early behaviorists like Skinner emphasized reinforcement. Later, the social context, observation, modeling, and imitation were included, leading to the social learning approach.
According to the behavioral approach, learning of gender roles can be explained as a result of:
- Classical conditioning
- Operant Conditioning (use of reinforcement: positive, negative, punishment, or no reinforcement)
- Learning by observation
Behaviorists maintain that gender-role associated behaviors are learned and not innate, shaped by reinforcement (Guerin, 1992). Children's upbringing steers them toward learning specific, socially desired gender roles. From birth, children receive different treatment (Maccoby & Jacklin, 1974; Pomerlau et al, 1990). This difference increases in later childhood, in childcare settings and at home (Chick et al, 2002; Huston, 1986). Variations in gender roles across cultures indicate different treatments (Gibbons, 2000). However, the lecture poses a critical question: "If different treatments are the cause of gender differences then how did this difference start in first place? Can it be that there were small innate differences that were amplified after different treatment?"
💡 Why this matters: This question highlights the fundamental "chicken-and-egg" problem in the nature vs. nurture debate.
Classical Conditioning
Every time a child sees the parent of the same sex, they observe them wearing particular clothes, using fixed gestures, and a particular communication style. This forms an association (e.g., parent with masculine clothes = male) which leads to the adoption of gender roles. However, the lecture notes that operant conditioning provides a stronger and more plausible explanation.
Operant Conditioning
This is the type of learning where a voluntary response becomes stronger or weaker depending on its positive or negative consequences. The organism plays an active role and "operates" on the environment to produce the desired outcome (to meet or avoid certain consequences — reinforcement).
The lecture details the various consequences of behavior and their impact, using four figures:
Figure 1: Positive Consequence (Positive Reinforcement)
- Behavior: A girl plays with a doll.
- Consequence: Parent smiles and says "What a good girl!"
- Impact on Behavior: The behavior is likely to be repeated.
Figure 2: No Consequence (Extinction)
- Behavior: A boy plays with a doll.
- Consequence: No reaction from parent.
- Impact on Behavior: The behavior is likely to decrease (extinguish).
Figure 3: Negative Consequence (Punishment)
- Behavior: A boy plays with a doll.
- Consequence: Parent yells, "Boys don't play with dolls!"
- Impact on Behavior: The behavior is likely to stop.
Figure 4: Negative Consequence, causing the behavior to be avoided (Negative Reinforcement)
- Behavior: A boy plays with a truck instead of a doll.
- Consequence: Parent stops yelling.
- Impact on Behavior: The "truck-playing" behavior is likely to be repeated.
🔑 Definition — Reinforcement: A consequence that increases the likelihood of a behavior being repeated. Positive reinforcement adds a pleasant stimulus; negative reinforcement removes an unpleasant stimulus. 🔑 Definition — Punishment: A consequence that decreases the likelihood of a behavior being repeated. 🔑 Definition — Extinction: The decrease and eventual disappearance of a behavior when it is no longer reinforced (given no consequence).
⭐ Key Takeaways
The behavioral approach explains gender development through learning, not biology, via classical and operant conditioning. Operant conditioning is central, where "gender-appropriate" behaviors are positively reinforced, and "gender-inappropriate" behaviors are punished or ignored, leading to extinction. This theory is supported by cross-cultural variations in gender roles. However, a major limitation is the unresolved question of how the initial differential treatment of boys and girls originated, suggesting possible small innate differences that are amplified by learning.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main learning mechanisms proposed by the behavioral approach to gender development?
- According to operant conditioning, what is the likely result for a boy if he receives a positive consequence (e.g., praise) for playing with a truck?
- What is the term for the decrease in a behavior when it receives no consequence?
- What is a key criticism or unanswered question regarding the behavioral approach to gender development?
- How does the existence of variations in gender roles across cultures support the behavioral approach?
📘 Lecture 11 — Theories of Gender Development (3) The Cognitive Approach
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how cognitive processes—thoughts, perceptions, and mental frameworks—shape gender development. It explains that children are active agents in their own gender socialization, organizing information about gender into mental schemas. The lecture covers Kohlberg's theory of gender constancy, gender schema theory, and how cognitive development stages influence gender role acquisition, while also acknowledging the limitations of this approach.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by recapping the behaviorist/learning approach before diving into the cognitive approach to gender development. It covers Lawrence Kohlberg's Cognitive Development Theory and the concept of gender constancy, including its three stages: gender identity, gender stability, and gender consistency. The lecture then presents Gender Schema Theory, detailing how children develop mental networks of gender-related information across developmental stages. It examines learning of gender roles by preschoolers, the concept of self-socialization, and links Piaget's stages of cognitive development to gender role acquisition. Finally, it critically evaluates whether the cognitive approach alone is sufficient.
📝 Lecture Summary
Recap:
The recap reminds students of the behaviorist/learning approach, which focuses on the consequences of behavior and their impact, shaping, and the learning of gender roles through observational learning.
The Cognitive Approach
This approach focuses on the thought processes underlying learning and gives importance to cognition when understanding and explaining behavior. The theory emphasizes both internal states of the person and environmental events, but it is thinking and perception that are the key factors. The term cognition refers to "knowledge" as well as "the process of knowing." The cognitive approach emphasizes thoughts, feelings, thinking, values, expectations, etc. The core idea is that people’s thinking determines how they will perceive the world, and how these perceptions will be acted upon.
The Cognitive Approach to Gender Roles
This theory proposes the interaction of mental schema and social experience in directing gender role behavior. It focuses on the child's "understanding" —the way he/she perceives and tackles a phenomenon. Information about gender is organized into sets of beliefs about the sexes, i.e., gender schema. A gender schema (plural: schemata or schemas) is a mental framework that organizes and guides a child's understanding of information relevant to gender.
🔑 Definition — Gender Schema: A mental framework that organizes and guides a child's understanding of information relevant to gender.
📌 Example: Information about which toys are for girls and which toys are for boys forms schema that guides behavior. Another example: If a child has seen women being respected in his family, he will perceive women as a respectable being; if he has seen women being battered and maltreated, he will perceive them as a low-grade creature.
Lawrence Kohlberg's Cognitive Development Theory: The Concept of Gender Constancy
Kohlberg proposed that children understand gender just as they understand anything else. Children have experiences with people of both genders, think about their experiences, make mental notes of what males and females do, and adopt behaviors performed by people of their own sex. Children do their own gender typing themselves—they make classifications of themselves and of others as male or female, and organize their behaviors around that classification. According to Kohlberg, acquisition of gender roles results from gender constancy, which is a child's understanding and awareness that his/her sex is permanent, constant, and will never change. Gender constancy is also known as sex category constancy in modern literature. Gender appropriate behaviors are adopted after the realization that sex is a permanent feature of personality. Gender constancy emerges somewhere between 3-7 years of age and is the key to gender typing.
🔑 Definition — Gender Constancy: A child's understanding and awareness that his/her sex is permanent, constant, and will never change.
Gender constancy does not occur at once but takes place in three stages (Ruble & Martin, 1998; Szkrybalo & Ruble):
- Gender Identity (Age 2-3 years): Becoming aware of one's own gender, and that of others.
- Gender Stability: Realization that boys and girls will grow up as men or women respectively—gender is a fixed, permanent quality and an integral feature of personality. However, at this stage, children understand this based on superficial, external appearances and stereotyped behaviors.
- Gender Consistency: The awareness that gender remains the same no matter what one wears, how one behaves, or whatever hairstyle one has.
Although Kohlberg put forth gender constancy as significant, there is not much solid research evidence supporting it. Research findings differ from, and are even contrary to, Kohlberg's hypothesis. It has been seen that at 2½ years of age, children begin to prefer the company of children of their own sex. Girls are more interested in dolls and boys in cars (Ruble & Martin, 1998). Long before attaining gender constancy, children exhibit gender-typed preferences (Bussey & Bandura, 1992; Ruble & Martin, 1998). Children can categorize activities and objects by gender, know a lot about what males and females do, and often acquire gender-appropriate behaviors (G. D. Levy & Carter, 1989; Leucke-Aleksa, Anderson, Collins, & Schmitt, 1995). Five-year-old boys having reached gender constancy pay more attention to male characters on TV and watch more sports and action programs (Leucke-Aleksa et al., 1995).
Gender Schema Theory
"A schema is a mentally organized network of gender-related information that influences behavior" (Papalia et al., 2001). A gender schema is a mental framework that organizes and guides a child's understanding of information relevant to gender. For example, information about which toys are for girls and which are for boys forms a schema that guides behavior.
According to gender schema theory, children first develop a simplified concept of male-female distinctions and later apply it universally (Bem, 1989, 1993). First, children learn what sex they are. Then they develop a concept of what it means to be male or female in their culture. On the basis of this concept, they begin to take on gender roles. Whatever observations they have of men and women, they organize those around the gender schema they have formed as a result of observing how their society classifies behaviors as male and female.
📌 Example: A child observes that it is always the mother who cooks, and the father is always the one who fixes electrical appliances. Gradually, the child develops the concept that household chores are for the mother (woman) and tougher tasks for the father (man). This leads to the assimilation of other ideas—that men are strong and women weak. If the father has to cook on a rare occasion, it doesn't match the "all in control schema of the father," and the child notes this discrepancy. Gender schemata influence judgments about behavior, thus promoting gender stereotypes.
The gradual process of development of gender schema is as follows:
| Stage | Age | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Gender Identification | 2-3.5 years | Children believe it is possible to change sex by wearing clothes of opposite sex. Can identify household gender stereotypes (e.g., mechanical tools used by father, mother works in kitchen). Gender labeling is learned. |
| Gender Stability | 3.5-4.5 years | Sex is stable over time, not situations. Older peers and siblings are models for social learning of gender roles. Boys may play with toys socially labeled as girl's toys but do not own them. Child applies labels to self and others, but they may be inconsistent. |
| Gender Consistency | 4.5-7 years | Sex is stable. Children value and imitate same-sex behaviors. This leads to development of gender-appropriate attributes. |
Slaby and Frey (1975) found that children with gender consistency attend more to the same-sex model. Children use cognitive processes to choose appropriate gender-related behaviors.
Learning of Gender Roles by Preschoolers
Preschoolers have an idea of gender roles, but their cognitive experiences are simple, not complex. They see things in simpler terms, at a concrete level. They see males and females as total opposites, judging things on their appearance and face value (e.g., thinking the volume of water changes when poured into differently shaped glasses). Past experiences have not yet assimilated into their existing schema. Preschoolers' cognitive patterns are egocentric and static. Children develop a simplified concept of male-female distinctions and then apply it universally (Bem, 1989, 1993).
Children form a script describing what various gender roles should be and then intellectually follow that script (Levy & Fivush, 1993; Martin, 1993). Children fit their cognitive experiences into the script they have. If their experiences are vague, ambiguous, or contradictory, preschoolers look for the script.
📌 Example: In a study, children were given gender-neutral, unfamiliar toys. Initially, they tried to find out and decide if they were meant for boys or girls. Then they made a decision considering which ones they wanted to play with or not (Martin et al., 1995).
The Concept of Self-socialization
Self-socialization means that children are the protagonists in their own gender role socialization and act as active agents. It is a three-step process:
- Around ages 5-6, children learn to classify themselves as males or females, and sex as a permanent quality is recognized.
- Children are motivated by this self-categorization to value characteristics and behaviors associated with their sex.
- They try to bring their own behavior into alignment with the behaviors considered gender-appropriate in their culture (Geis, 1993).
Thus, children identify and note gender behaviors, identify and note their gender identity, and make an effort to remove disparities between the two.
Piaget’s Stages of Cognitive Development and Development of Gender Roles
The lecture links Piaget's stages to gender role development:
| Stage | Age | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Preoperational Stage | 2-4 years | Thinking is concrete, not logical, judges on appearance. Gender labeling occurs. Uses cues such as dress and hair. Believes sex can change if appearance is changed. Develops categories associated with sex/gender. Identifies as male or female. Uses stereotypes as rules. |
| Concrete Operational Stage | 7-12 years | Thinking is logical, but limited to concrete. Cognitive understanding of permanence of gender develops. |
| Formal Operational Stage | 12 years-adulthood | Thinking is scientifically logical, can be applied to abstract concepts. Adolescents become more rigid in sex-typing. |
Is the Cognitive Approach the Only Best Approach?
The lecture concludes with a critical note: this approach has ignored the role of biological factors that are involved in developing cognitive schema. Additionally, cultural differences in forming gender roles are not addressed by this approach.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The cognitive approach views children as active agents who organize gender information into mental frameworks called gender schemas, which guide their behavior and perceptions. Kohlberg's theory of gender constancy—developing through identity, stability, and consistency stages—proposes that children adopt gender roles only after realizing sex is permanent, though research shows gender-typed preferences emerge much earlier. Gender schema theory explains how children first learn simplified male-female distinctions and then apply them universally, organizing observations around these mental networks. Preschoolers' concrete, egocentric thinking leads them to see genders as opposites and follow cultural scripts for gender roles, while self-socialization describes how children actively align their behavior with their gender identity. However, the cognitive approach is limited by its neglect of biological factors and cultural differences in gender role formation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the core idea of the cognitive approach to gender development?
- What are the three stages of gender constancy according to Kohlberg, and at what approximate ages do they occur?
- How does gender schema theory explain the development of gender stereotypes?
- What is self-socialization, and what are its three steps?
- According to the lecture, what are two major limitations of the cognitive approach to understanding gender development?
📘 Lecture 12 — Theories of Gender Development (3)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the psychodynamic approach to gender development, primarily based on Freud's theory of psychosexual development and the resolution of the Oedipus complex. It then examines alternative views from Karen Horney, Nancy Chodorow, and Ellyn Kaschak, highlighting how social and relational factors, rather than solely biological drives, shape gender identity. Understanding these theories is crucial for analyzing the psychological underpinnings of gender roles, inequality, and family dynamics.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Freudian perspective on gender development, focusing on the phallic stage and the Oedipus complex. It then presents Karen Horney's critique of Freud, including her concepts of womb envy and the social origins of female inferiority. Finally, it details contemporary psychodynamic theories, specifically Nancy Chodorow's theory on mothering and the pre-oedipal period, and Ellyn Kaschak's theory of the Antigone phase in patriarchal societies.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Psychodynamic Approach
The psychodynamic approach is rooted in Freud's theory of psychosexual development. It posits that family dynamics influence individuals at a subconscious level, leading to the internalization of gender identities.
🔑 Definition — Psychodynamic Approach: An approach to gender development based on Freud's theory, emphasizing that unconscious family dynamics and conflicts shape internal gender identities and roles.
Gender Development: Freudian Perspective
Freud believed that gender roles develop from the resolution of the conflict at the phallic stage. During this stage, a boy experiences the Oedipus complex, developing feelings of rivalry and hatred towards his father, whom he sees as a stronger, unconquerable rival for his mother's affection. This creates a conflict that is resolved through the defense mechanism of identification. By identifying with his father, the boy adopts his father's characteristics, leading to sex-typed behavior and the development of gender roles. An absent same-sex parent can disrupt this process. For instance, Stevenson & Black (1988) found that boys with absent fathers around the oedipal stage show less sex-typed behavior.
🔑 Definition — Identification: A defense mechanism where an individual adopts the characteristics of another person (e.g., the same-sex parent) to resolve a conflict and internalize a gender role.
Gender Development: Karen Horney’s Perspective
Karen Horney reexamined Freud’s concepts, remaining within the psychoanalytic paradigm but diverging on gender differences. She disagreed with Freud on three key points:
- Female Envy: She argued that females' envy of males was symbolic, representing a desire for the social prestige and position men enjoy, not a desire for a physical penis.
- Womb Envy: Horney hypothesized that men experience womb envy, a feeling of inadequacy due to their inability to reproduce. Men then overcompensate through a struggle for achievement and may devalue women to deal with their own inferiority.
- Origin of Female Inferiority: Horney believed female inferiority stemmed from male insecurity and a society with a masculine bias, not from a perceived physical inferiority. Men's resentment leads to attempts to weaken women, leaving them with feelings of inferiority.
🔑 Definition — Womb Envy: A term coined by Karen Horney to describe men's unconscious envy of women's ability to bear children, leading them to overcompensate through achievement and the devaluation of women.
Contemporary Psychodynamic Theories
The feminist thought influenced psychoanalysis, leading to psychoanalytic feminism. This perspective, with roots in Freud, argues that gender is not biologically determined but results from psychosexual development and childhood experiences in a male-dominated society.
🔑 Definition — Psychoanalytic Feminism: A contemporary psychodynamic perspective that uses Freudian concepts to explain how childhood experiences in a patriarchal society lead to gender inequality.
Nancy Chodorow’s Theory
Nancy Chodorow (1979) focused on early childhood experiences with mothers, particularly the pre-oedipal stage. Key points include:
- Mothering is Central: Most children are primarily mothered by women. This creates a deep, imprinted bond.
- Differential Bonding: Mothers and daughters are closer (same-sex), while mother-son relationships are less close. This affects emotional closeness (Benenson, Morash, & Petrakos, 1998).
- Gender Identity Development: For girls, identification with the mother is smooth and continuous. For boys, they must separate from the mother and reject femininity to develop a masculine identity. This process is tougher and more turbulent.
- Impact on Men: The need for boys to separate from their mothers creates a fear and mistrust of the feminine (Chodorow, 1978). This effort results in the worldwide denigration of women by men (Brannon, 2004).
💡 Why this matters: This theory shifts the focus of gender inequality from anatomical differences (Freud) to the social structure of parenting, where women are the primary caregivers.
Antigone Phase: Kaschak’s Theory
Ellyn Kaschak (1992) used the character of Antigone, the devoted daughter in Sophocles’ plays, as a symbol for the dilemma of women in patriarchal families. Key points include:
- Patriarchal Structure: In societies where men are granted power, they treat women as possessions. Women are socialized to see themselves as subservient.
- The Antigone Dilemma: Like Antigone, "good daughters" sacrifice their own freedom and identity for men (fathers, husbands). This leads to a personality where women see themselves as extensions of men, not independent people.
- Consequences for Men: Men, feeling they have a right to power, may engage in self-centered and harmful behavior, such as family violence (Johnson, 1995).
- Consequences for Women: Failure to resolve the Antigone phase leads women to deny their own wishes, impose limitations on themselves, and deny their physicality. This can result in eating disorders, self-hatred, or shame. Women may then seek relationships with others to attain self-worth.
🔑 Definition — Antigone Phase: A concept by Ellyn Kaschak describing a developmental stage in patriarchal societies where women resolve their identity by becoming a "good daughter," sacrificing their independence and allowing themselves to be extensions of men.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must understand that the psychodynamic approach emphasizes the role of subconscious family dynamics in gender development, moving beyond simple biological or social learning. Freud's theory focuses on the Oedipus complex and identification with the same-sex parent as the basis for gender roles. However, Karen Horney critiqued this, arguing that "penis envy" is symbolic of social power and proposing the concept of "womb envy" in men. Contemporary theories, like Nancy Chodorow's, shift the focus to early mother-child relationships, proposing that the structure of mothering (where women are primary caregivers) differently impacts male and female identity formation, leading to male fear of femininity. Ellyn Kaschak's Antigone phase further explains how patriarchal social structures create a relational pattern in women that can lead to self-limitation and psychological distress, such as eating disorders.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Freud, what specific conflict must a boy resolve during the phallic stage, and what defense mechanism facilitates this resolution?
- How did Karen Horney reinterpret the concept of "penis envy," and what concept did she introduce to describe men's feelings of inadequacy?
- What is the central premise of Nancy Chodorow’s theory regarding the impact of mothering on gender development for boys and girls?
- According to Ellyn Kaschak, what psychological and behavioral outcomes can result from a woman's failure to resolve the "Antigone phase"?
- How do contemporary psychodynamic theories (like Chodorow's and Kaschak's) differ from Freud's original theory in explaining the root cause of gender inequality?
📘 Lecture 13 — The Humanistic Approach
📖 Overview: This lecture explores multiple theoretical perspectives on gender role development, including humanistic, socio-cultural, epigenetic, and gender script theories. It examines how cultural influences shape gender stereotypes and discusses gender relations through Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, making it clear that gender development is a multifaceted process influenced by biological, social, and cognitive factors.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the humanistic approach based on Rogers’ theory, cultural influences on gender roles including technological impacts and stereotypes, gender role stereotypes for males and females, Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in understanding gender relations, the socio-cultural approach to gender development, the epigenetic systems theory emphasizing gene-environment interaction, and the gender script theory as a sequential variation of gender schema theory.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Humanistic Approach
This approach is based on Rogers’ theory that does not directly explain the process of gender role development. The main concepts in this regard are ideal self and conditional positive regard. In the process of gender development, conditional positive regard can be seen as a set of expectations for gender roles, and ideal self can be understood as gender appropriate behavior. To achieve positive regard, gender appropriate behavior becomes an ideal self for an individual.
Like boys are told that cooking is for girls, cultural stereotypes function as conditional positive regard for individuals. To achieve this regard, the individual develops a concept of ideal self that results in gender appropriate behavior. This approach does not directly explain the process of gender development, so no research data is found from this perspective.
Cultural Influences
Technological advances have affected societies in the following ways: Women are transferred to the less influential social sphere of home. Men are associated with the public sphere of politics, economy, etc. Women are fighting for becoming independent. The feminine role is defined as subordinate to the masculine role. In non-industrialized countries males are considered self-reliant and achievers. Women are regarded as nurturing, responsible, and obedient.
The Western stereotypes for men and women are:
- Men to be instrumental (assertive, competitive, independent)
- Women to be expressive (co-operative, supportive, sensitive)
💡 Why this matters: These cultural stereotypes are not universal but are heavily influenced by industrialization and regional values, shaping how gender roles are learned and reinforced across societies.
Some Gender Role Stereotypes
Male Attributes: Acts as a leader, aggressive, ambitious, dominant, forceful, independent. Female Attributes: Compassionate, gentle, loves children, sensitive to needs of others, tender, understanding.
Understanding Gender Relations With Reference to Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
- Maslow’s theory can be seen basically as a stage theory.
- Each stage is marked by a particular class of needs.
- The needs at one level have to be met before one moves on to the fulfillment of needs at a higher level.
- Self Actualization is the most advanced human need marked by the desire to grow and utilize one’s potential up to the optimal level.
- Gender roles and relationship in a society affect the fulfillment of a person’s needs.
The Socio-cultural Approach
- The Socio-cultural Approach proposes that social factors, societal expectations, cultural practices, norms, and values all affect development of gender roles.
- The gender patterns adopted by children reflect the cultural emphasis on gender distinctions.
- Some societies make sure that gender distinctions are firm and practiced, whereas others are less concerned about this.
- In such societies skills taught to girls are different from those taught to boys.
- Throughout the world, young children and chicken are looked after by girls, whereas the larger animals like sheep, cattle, or pigs are tended by boys (Whiting & Edwards, 1988).
- When these distinctions are so seriously practiced, they get engrained in the minds and behaviors of children as well as adults in the form of clear-cut and inflexible distinctions.
- In most segregated cultures, the boys are encouraged to be educated and to learn skills that can get them a good source of earning.
- Girl’s education at higher levels is generally discouraged, and they usually get married early.
- In a study of Khmer refugees in the US, it was revealed that boys are urged to continue their education; the girls are urged to get married and have children before passing out from high school, in order to get protected against the corruptive effects of sexual permissiveness in that society (Smith-Hefner, 1993).
- In most cross-cultural studies on preschoolers, it has been found that boys are encouraged to take on different roles than girls.
- All societies and cultures have values and attitudes for desirable or preferred behaviors for males and females, and these begin to be taught in early childhood.
The variations in how different societies promote and teach gender roles depend upon the following:
- The region (we see regional similarities)
- The flexibility or inflexibility of cultures
- The socio-economic status of the person, group, or society in question
- The historical period
- The belief system, particularly the religious values
The Epigenetic Systems Theory
- Emphasis is upon the interaction between the genetic endowment and early experiences.
- All aspects of behavior including gender related behaviors, beliefs, and attitudes are a result of this interaction.
- The biological differences between males and females are given due importance and are considered to be the origin of gender differences.
- Yet at the same time it is emphasized that environmental factors shape, enhance, or halt the manifestations of the innate differences.
🔑 Definition — Epigenetic Systems Theory: A theory emphasizing that all aspects of behavior, including gender-related behaviors, beliefs, and attitudes, result from the interaction between genetic endowment and early experiences, with environmental factors shaping or halting innate biological differences.
The Gender Script Theory
- This theory is a variation of the gender schema theory that includes an additional ingredient of sequential order of events.
- Social knowledge regarding gender is organized in sequential form.
- As compared to gender schema, gender scripts contain events as an organized sequence.
🔑 Definition — Gender Script: “An ordered sequence of actions appropriate to a particular spatial-temporal context, organized around a goal” (Nelson, 1981). Children thus learn the particular sequence of behaviors performed by individuals with a particular gender.
Conclusion
Development of gender-roles is a positive factor for socialization and adjustment process of an individual. There are also some cultural differences, though the stereotypes of females being nurturing and males being instrumental are very widespread across culture. Gender differences may be accounted for by a range of biological, social, and cognitive factors.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The humanistic approach explains gender development through Rogers’ concepts of conditional positive regard and ideal self, but lacks direct research support. Cultural influences are powerful drivers of gender stereotypes, with Western societies categorizing men as instrumental and women as expressive. Maslow’s hierarchy shows that gender roles impact need fulfillment across all stages, including self-actualization. The socio-cultural approach highlights that gender distinctions vary by region, flexibility, socio-economic status, historical period, and belief systems. Finally, epigenetic systems theory and gender script theory both emphasize interaction — the former between genes and environment, and the latter providing sequential organization of gender-related knowledge that children learn through observation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How does Rogers’ concept of conditional positive regard relate to the development of gender appropriate behavior?
- What are the two Western stereotypes for men and women, and how do they differ?
- According to the socio-cultural approach, what five factors influence how societies promote and teach gender roles?
- What is the key difference between gender schema theory and gender script theory?
- How does the epigenetic systems theory explain the origin of gender differences?