π Lecture 39 β Problems Associated With Femalesβ Reproductive Health
π Overview: This lecture examines key reproductive health issues affecting females, including dysmenorrhea, premenstrual syndrome (PMS), and menopause. It aims to create awareness that not all women experience these problems, that they have both physical and psychological components, and importantly, that they are manageable through various interventions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main reproductive health problems: Dysmenorrhea (painful menstruation) including its types, causes, and treatments; Premenstrual Syndrome (PMS) with its physiological and psychological explanations and treatment options; and Menopause, including symptoms, the socio-psychological approach to understanding it, and treatment modalities such as hormone replacement therapy and cognitive therapy.
π Lecture Summary
Problems Associated With Femalesβ Reproductive Health
Women visit physicians more frequently than men, partly due to their complex reproductive system which is vulnerable to various conditions. The lecture emphasizes four key objectives: creating awareness about these problems; recognizing that not all women experience these symptoms; understanding that problems have both physical and psychological components; and most importantly, knowing that these problems are manageable.
Dysmenorrhoea
Dysmenorrhoea is pain along with cramping of the uterine musculature accompanying the menstrual period. In some females, the pain can be very severe and debilitating, while many women do not experience this condition at all.
There are two types of Dysmenorrhoea: Primary Dysmenorrhoea, which occurs without any causal disease, usually begins in the teens and disappears after childbirth; and Secondary Dysmenorrhoea, which is caused by some primary disease process like endometriosis, with symptoms related to the primary condition.
π Definition β Primary Dysmenorrhoea: Menstrual pain occurring without any underlying disease, typically beginning in adolescence and resolving after childbirth.
π Definition β Secondary Dysmenorrhoea: Menstrual pain caused by an underlying disease process such as endometriosis.
Etiology/Causes: The physical cause involves prostaglandins β biologically active, naturally occurring unsaturated fatty acids that have potent actions on blood cells, smooth muscles, fat cells, and nerve tissues. Psychological causes include heightened stress levels, especially negative stress.
Treatment: Physical treatment includes prostaglandin inhibitors such as ibuprofen and naproxen sodium. Regular exercise, particularly aerobic exercise, is very helpful for symptom relief and control. Psychological interventions include relaxation exercises, which become more effective when combined with positive imagery.
Premenstrual Syndrome (PMS)
Premenstrual Syndrome (PMS) refers to symptoms experienced by many females approximately 10 days prior to the beginning of the monthly period. Common symptoms include depression, irritability, water retention, fatigue, and/or lethargy.
Etiology: The physiological explanation focuses on insufficient progesterone, or insufficient progesterone relative to estrogen, creating a high estrogen-progesterone ratio. The psychological explanation, based on Koeske (1980), proposes that cultural stereotypes of premenstrual women as depressed and irritable affect which environmental or physiological cues are attended to when attaching a label to increased arousal.
Treatment of PMS includes multiple approaches: Medical Treatment: Progesterone therapy (Dalton, 1964) for low progesterone levels; diuretics (Appleby, 1960); Bromocriptine which inhibits prolactin release (Steiner et al., 1984); medicines increasing serotonin levels (Harrison et al., 1984); prostaglandin inhibitors (Jakubowicz et al., 1984); and evening primrose oil (Horrobin and Phil, 1983).
Psychological Treatment: Relaxation exercises with imagery; cognitive therapy for changing appraisal of situation; and role modeling through video recordings of symptom-free females.
Lifestyle Changes: Regular aerobic exercise; healthy dietary habits with reduced dairy intake; restricting refined sugar and acquiring sugar through complex carbohydrates and cereals; and multivitamin supplementation.
π‘ Why this matters: PMS treatment demonstrates the biopsychosocial model β effective management requires addressing biological, psychological, and lifestyle factors simultaneously rather than relying on a single approach.
Menopause
Menopause refers to the cessation of menstruation, meaning the permanent end of fertility when ovulation stops permanently. The average age of menopause is about 51 years, occurring between 45 and 55 years in 4 out of 5 women (Avis, 1999; Messill and Verbrugge, 1999). Some women experience it as early as their thirties or as late as their sixties.
Symptoms of Menopause: Little or no physical discomfort is experienced by most women during the perimenopausal phase (NIA, 1993). Perimenopausal or climacteric, or "change in life," refers to the period during which changes leading to menopause are experienced, beginning usually in the 30s.
Common symptoms include: hot flashes (sudden sensations of heat that flash through the body due to expansion and contraction of blood vessels), increased body weight, headaches, profuse sweating, sleep problems/insomnia, depression, dizziness, sensation of cold in hands and feet, irritability, arthrosclerosis, and osteoporosis (brittle bones).
There are diverse views about these symptoms: some see them as purely psychological, resulting from the menopausal woman's perception of her changed physical ability; others regard them as clearly physical from hormonal changes; and a third viewpoint considers them resulting from both factors. The fact that not all women experience these symptoms supports the psychological viewpoint β if symptoms were purely physical, all women would experience them.
π Definition β Hot flashes: Sudden sensations of heat that flash through the body due to expansion and contraction of blood vessels; the most common menopausal symptom.
The Socio-psychological Approach: Two factors determine the experience of menopause: a) The woman's perception of a major life change and the end of fertility; b) Societal stereotypes about menopause, especially the attitudes, awareness, and behavior of the husband and near relatives. Research shows that "so-called menopausal syndrome may be related more to personal characteristics or past experiences than to menopause per se" (Avis, 1999, p. 129).
Cultural factors are crucial β menopausal symptoms are experienced more seriously in societies where women feel important primarily because of their bodies (e.g., Western societies). Fewer problems are associated with menopause in cultures where older women acquire social, religious, or political power after menopause (Avis, 1999).
Treatment of Menopausal Symptoms:
- Hormone Replacement Therapy: Estrogen alone, or in combination with progesterone
- Evening Primrose Oil: Herbal remedy with claimed positive effects
- Exercise: Regular aerobic exercise helps prevent, control, and alleviate symptoms
- Cognitive Therapy: Focuses on correcting wrong perceptions about the end of fertility, helping women realize this is an age of more freedom, free from children's responsibilities, with more money, leisure time, and opportunity for creative or intellectual pursuits.
What Needs To Be Done: Health education for females; changes and additions in school curriculum pertaining to reproductive health; and encouraging girls to express their health concerns with mothers, teachers, or health professionals.
β Key Takeaways
The crucial points for exam preparation are: first, reproductive health problems including dysmenorrhea, PMS, and menopause have both physical and psychological components and are manageable through various interventions. Second, dysmenorrhea can be primary (without disease) or secondary (caused by underlying conditions), treated with prostaglandin inhibitors, exercise, and relaxation techniques. Third, PMS treatment requires a comprehensive approach including medical interventions (progesterone therapy, diuretics, serotonin enhancers), psychological treatments (cognitive therapy, relaxation with imagery), and lifestyle changes (exercise, diet modification). Fourth, menopause symptoms vary greatly across women and cultures, with the socio-psychological approach emphasizing that personal characteristics and cultural stereotypes significantly influence symptom experience. Finally, cognitive therapy for menopause helps women reframe this life stage as one of freedom and opportunity rather than loss.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes primary dysmenorrhea from secondary dysmenorrhea, and what are the physical and psychological causes of each?
- List four different medical treatments for PMS and explain the physiological basis for each one.
- According to the socio-psychological approach, what two factors determine a woman's experience of menopause?
- Why do some researchers argue that menopausal symptoms cannot be purely physical in nature?
- What specific lifestyle changes are recommended for managing PMS symptoms, and how do they differ from menopause treatment recommendations?
π Lecture 40 β Obesity and Weight Control
π Overview: This lecture examines obesity as a growing health concern, including its definition, measurement via BMI, and consequences. It then explores gender differences in obesity perception, therapeutic interventions, and the serious eating disorders of anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa, including their diagnostic criteria and etiology.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining obesity and overweight, explaining the Body Mass Index (BMI) as a measurement tool. It then outlines the consequences of obesity, highlighting gender-specific concerns. Therapeutic interventions like dieting, exercise, and cognitive therapy are listed. The second half focuses on eating disorders, specifically anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa, detailing their diagnostic criteria and exploring their etiology through genetic, cultural, media, and psychological factors.
π Lecture Summary
Obesity and Weight Control
Obesity refers to having too much excess body weight, specifically when that weight is due to excessive fat. In a normal female body, fat should constitute around 20% to 27% of body tissue; for men, it should be between 15% to 22%. Body weight that is 20% more than the ideal weight is considered overweight. If a person's weight exceeds even that 20% excess, they are considered obese.
The most reliable measure of obesity is the Body Mass Index (BMI). BMI is calculated by dividing a person's weight in kilograms by their height in meters, and then squaring the result.
π Definition β BMI (Body Mass Index): A measure of body fat based on height and weight. π Formula: BMI = weight (kg) / [height (m)]Β² β This number indicates whether a person is underweight, ideal, overweight, or obese. π Example: A person weighing 80 kg with a height of 1.7 m has a BMI of 80 / (1.7 Γ 1.7) = 27.7, placing them in the moderately overweight category.
| BMI Rating | Body Weight Rating |
|---|---|
| 19-24 | Ideal |
| 25-29 | Moderately overweight |
| > 30 | Obese |
People with a BMI between 25 and 29 are 15%-30% above ideal weight. Those with a BMI over 30 have about 40% excess body weight. Obesity is a major health concern because it is associated with serious ailments like CHD (Coronary Heart Disease), cancer, and diabetes. In the US, 65% of adults are overweight, and 23% are obese. 15% of school-age children are obese. Similar trends are seen in Britain and Canada.
Consequences of Obesity
The consequences of obesity include negative self-perception and low self-esteem, self-consciousness, negative attitudes from peers, general lethargy and fatigue, increased risk of CHD, hypertension, stroke, many cancers, diabetes, and affected joints. It also leads to reduced physical activity, stress, and in many cases, helplessness.
Gender and Obesity
Obesity is a causal factor in poor self-concept for both men and women, but it is of much greater concern for females. People tend to ignore the excess weight of a man more than that of a woman. Women are ideally expected to be trim, slim, and smart. Furthermore, the risk of many ailments is higher in overweight women.
Therapeutic Interventions
The lecture lists four main therapeutic interventions for weight control:
- Wise eating and curtailed eating/Dieting
- Strenuous and regular exercise
- Behavior modification (e.g., contingency contracting)
- Cognitive therapy for changing perceptions about eating and the ability to reduce weight
Eating Disorders
While obesity is increasing, a segment of the populationβprimarily femalesβadopts harmful ways to lose weight. This can lead to two main eating disorders: Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa.
Anorexia Nervosa is marked by a drastically curtailed food intake with the intention to lose weight. Anorexics try to maintain body weight 15% below what should have been their expected weight, and they tend to have a BMI of 17.5.
π Diagnostic Criteria for Anorexia Nervosa (American Psychiatric Association, 1994):
- Refusal to maintain body weight at or above a minimally normal weight for age and height.
- Intense fear of gaining weight or becoming fat, even though underweight.
- Disturbance in the way one's body weight or shape is experienced, or denial of the seriousness of the current low body weight.
- Amenorrhea (the absence of at least three consecutive menstrual cycles).
Worldwide, the incidence is not exactly known. In the US, about 0.5% of all women have this problem. However, among women in professional schools for modeling and dance, 6-7% can be classified as having anorexia nervosa.
Bulimia Nervosa is characterized by binge eating followed by purging. The main intention is the same as anorexia: not letting body weight increase.
π Diagnostic Criteria for Bulimia Nervosa (American Psychiatric Association, 1994):
- Recurrent episodes of binge eating, where a large amount of food is eaten in a discrete period, with a feeling of loss of control.
- Recurrent inappropriate compensatory behavior to prevent weight gain, such as self-induced vomiting, misuse of laxatives, or excessive exercise.
- Both behaviors occur at least twice a week for 3 months.
- Self-evaluation is unduly influenced by body shape and weight.
The lecture notes that bulimia is rarely seen in Pakistani society. In North America, the prevalence rate is 1-3%, with some surveys suggesting around 10% of college women show symptoms.
Etiology of Eating Disorders
Although a concern with body weight and shape is the major variable, other triggering factors include:
- Genetic factors: Twin studies show a higher probability of eating disorders in identical twins than fraternal twins.
- Cultural factors: Eating disorders are more common in societies where physical beauty is the most important characteristic of a woman.
- The role of media: Media portrays extremely thin females, and teenage girls try to match these models.
- Stress and Anxiety: Under stress, some young females eat more and then purge if they are weight conscious. For a stressed teenager, her body is the only entity she feels she can control. For some bulimics, eating is a compensatory defense mechanism that provides pleasure.
β Key Takeaways
Obesity is defined by excess body fat (BMI > 30), and it carries significant health risks like CHD and diabetes. The lecture highlights a critical gender difference: obesity is a much greater concern for women due to social pressures for thinness. Two major eating disorders are anorexia nervosa (self-starvation with a BMI of 17.5) and bulimia nervosa (binge-purge cycle), both affecting women more than men. The diagnostic criteria for both disorders, as defined by the American Psychiatric Association, must be memorized for exams. Finally, the etiology of these disorders is multifactorial, involving genetic, cultural, media, and psychological stress factors.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating BMI, and what are the BMI ranges for "ideal," "moderately overweight," and "obese"?
- Why is obesity a more significant concern for females than for males, according to the lecture?
- List the four diagnostic criteria for Anorexia Nervosa as provided by the American Psychiatric Association.
- What is the key behavioral difference between Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa?
- Name three etiological factors (causes) for eating disorders discussed in the lecture.
π Lecture 41 β Gender and Psychopathology
π Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between gender and psychopathology, challenging stereotypical views that men and women have markedly different risks for mental disorders. It explores gender differences in stress, coping mechanisms, physiological reactivity, and how diagnostic criteria may be biased. The lecture also investigates the sources of stress related to modern lifestyles, employment, and marriage, providing a nuanced understanding of gender-specific experiences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining psychopathology and challenging gender stereotypes in mental illness. It then covers gender, stress, and coping, including the fight-or-flight versus tend-and-befriend responses, gender differences in physiological reactivity to stress, and the potential role of religiosity (prayer) in coping. The discussion progresses to who feels more stress and why, examining the sources of stress, the impact of modern lifestyles and dual roles for women, and the relationship between marriage, employment, and mental health for both genders.
π Lecture Summary
Gender and Psychopathology
Psychopathology refers to mental disorders or mental illness. Stereotypically, there are marked gender differences in psychopathology, but empirical research does not support this view. Men and women both have an equal risk of developing any mental disorder. Many mental health professionals believe that diagnostic criteria are designed in such a manner that women are more likely to be diagnosed with certain mental health problems than men. The discussion focuses on three areas: gender, stress and coping; gender bias in diagnostic criteria; and gender differences in mental disorders.
π Definition β Psychopathology: mental disorders or mental illness.
Gender, Stress and Coping
Stress refers to "a state of challenge or threat that disrupts the normal rhythm and balance of a person's life" (Sanderson, 2004). People feel stress when circumstances tax or exceed their resources and endanger their well-being (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984). If a person feels out of resources and without skills for handling a situation, they feel trapped and threatened, hence stress. If another person in the same situation feels equipped with skills and resources, no stress may be experienced. Stress is accompanied by a physical component and is marked by an activated Sympathetic Nervous System, leading to increased heart rate, hyperventilation, sweating, dry mouth, and shaky legs.
π Definition β Stress: a state of challenge or threat that disrupts the normal rhythm and balance of a personβs life.
Gender Differences in Reactions to Stress
For many years, psychologists relied on Walter Cannon's finding that people respond to stress with the fight or flight response (heightened arousal). Recent research proposes a divergent viewpoint, noting that most previous research used male samples. Research suggests that females' reactions may differ from males. While men exhibit the traditional fight or flight response, women may demonstrate the "tend-and-befriend response" (Taylor et al., 2000). This means that in periods of stress, women prefer to affiliate with others, while men prefer less social interaction. Experiments show women prefer to wait with other women when expecting painful electric shocks, while men prefer waiting alone.
π Definition β Fight or Flight Response: the traditional response to stress involving heightened arousal, typically observed in males. π Definition β Tend-and-Befriend Response: a stress response observed in females where they prefer to affiliate with and seek social support from others.
Gender Differences in Physiological Reactivity to Stress
Men and women may experience different types and levels of physiological strain from stressors. Men show more physiological reactivity than women when psychologically stressed (Collins & Frankenhaeuser, 1978; Kudielka et al., 1998). Men generally have higher blood pressure than women and show greater blood pressure variations in stressful situations. This higher physiological responsiveness may be a contributory factor in the higher risk of CHD (Coronary Heart Disease) for men.
π Definition β Physiological Reactivity: the degree of physical response (e.g., increased heart rate, blood pressure) to a stressor.
Religiosity: Does prayer help in Coping with stress?
A study (Kwaug Cha et al., 2001) investigated the impact of praying on physical health. A group of 199 women in Korea seeking treatment for pregnancy was randomly assigned to a prayer group and a non-prayer group. Photographs of the women in the prayer group were sent to churchgoers in the U.S., Australia, and Canada who were requested to pray for their pregnancy. π Finding: 50% of the prayer group became pregnant, while only 26% of the non-prayer group became pregnant. The clinic's usual pregnancy rate was 33%. π Example: Women 30 years or above in age benefited from prayer, not those below 30. Neither the women in the prayer group nor their medical staff were aware they were being prayed for.
Who feels how much stress and why??
Compared to men, women report a greater number of stressors, including major and minor ones (Davis, Matthews, & Twamley, 1999). This may be partly due to women's self-disclosure style. Greater reactivity is shown by men when their competence is challenged; women show greater reactivity when their friendship or love is challenged (Smith et al., 1998). Men show greater reactivity than women when stressed psychologically.
The sources of Stress
Research (Taylor et al., 2000) shows no gender differences in the biological/physiological reaction to stressβstress triggers the same sympathetic nervous system activation in both men and women. However, the sources of stress may vary.
The modern lifestyle and Stress
In the modern world, many women perform dual roles at home and at the workplace, adding to a hassled routine. However, being employed outside the home has a positive effect on women's well-being. Working women tend to exhibit less distress than housewives but more distress than employed men (Glass & Fujimoto, 1994). Employed married women are under greater strain than their husbands (Nathanson, 1980). For married women, especially those in low-income families, psychological distress is increased by the strain of working and doing the majority of child-raising work (Cleary & Mechanic, 1983). π‘ Why this matters: Employment enhances psychological well-being when women have control over their job (Lennon, 1994). The most positive mental health is seen in women who like combining a job with homemaking (Kessler & Mc Rae, 1981).
Marriage of Experience of Stress
Marriage has a positive effect, with married people experiencing less stress than unmarried people. However, women, whether married or unmarried, show more psychological distress than men. For married women, the quality of the relationship with the husband is important for positive mental health (Gove, Hughes, & Style, 1983). A woman's employment may negatively impact the husband's mental health if he earns less or does more housework (Rosenfield, 1992). Both spouses are less depressed when the woman's employment is consistent with her preference. If the husband helps with housework, wives are less depressed, and it does not increase depression for the husband (Ross, Mirowsky, & Huber, 1983). π‘ Why this matters: Research in the US and Australia showed that being married is a mental health advantage for both spouses, with lower levels of mental disorders seen in married people.
β Key Takeaways
Gender differences in psychopathology are not about unequal risk of mental disorders, but rather about how stress is experienced, expressed, and diagnosed. The traditional fight or flight response to stress is more typical of males, while females often exhibit a tend-and-befriend response, seeking social affiliation. Physiological reactivity to stress is generally higher in men, contributing to their greater risk for CHD, but the biological reaction to stress itself is similar across genders. The sources of stress and coping mechanisms are heavily influenced by social roles, lifestyle factors like employment and marriage, and the quality of relationships. Finally, diagnostic criteria and social expectations may create a gender bias, leading to different rates of diagnosis for certain mental health problems rather than reflecting actual differences in prevalence.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between the fight-or-flight response and the tend-and-befriend response to stress, and which gender is each typically associated with?
- How do men and women differ in their physiological reactivity (e.g., blood pressure) when under psychological stress, and what is a potential long-term health consequence for men?
- According to the research cited, what are the primary social contexts (e.g., work, marriage) that create different sources of stress for men and women?
- Describe the findings of the study on prayer and pregnancy rates in Korea. What was the pregnancy rate for the prayer group versus the non-prayer group and the clinic average?
- How does the quality of a marital relationship and a woman's employment status interact to affect the mental health of both spouses?
π Lecture 42 β Gender and Psychopathology
π Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between gender and mental illness, challenging traditional stereotypes about which disorders affect men versus women. It critically analyzes gender bias in diagnostic criteria, particularly the DSM system, and explores how cultural expectations may lead to the over-diagnosis or under-diagnosis of certain disorders based on gender.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by addressing stereotypical beliefs about gender-specific mental disorders and presents modern research findings showing few actual differences. It then focuses on two main areas: gender bias in diagnostic criteria (specifically the DSM system) and facts about existing gender differences in psychological disorders. The lecture examines how typical male and female behaviors can be pathologized, discusses culturally promoted behaviors that may be labeled as disorders, and concludes with specific statistical data on gender differences in various psychopathologies.
π Lecture Summary
Gender and Psychopathology
Psychopathology refers to mental disorders or mental illness. Traditionally, certain mental disorders were believed to be specific to or more common in one gender. Stereotypical beliefs include: hysteria and dissociative disorders are specific to women (especially young girls); mostly women suffer from anxiety disorders; women are phobic about insects, animals, or people; men are brave and do not develop phobias; depression in women is not serious and they recover naturally; habit disorders, smoking, drug abuse, or alcoholism are men's problems.
Modern research suggests there are no significant differences in mental illness except a few. Only two or three categories show higher proportions in women, and differences are not consistent. Higher rates in women are found for: a) Mood disorders and b) Anxiety disorders (Cockerham, 1996; Kessler et al., 1994). Men have higher rates of personality disorders (Cockerham, 1996; Kessler et al., 1994). Females also show higher tendencies toward depression and anxiety that, while not clinically diagnosable, cause psychological distressβa finding consistent across the U.S. and other countries (Cockerham, 1996; Desjarlais et al., 1993; Lai, 1995).
The lecture focuses on two things: (1) gender bias in diagnostic criteria, and (2) facts about existing gender differences in psychological disorders.
The Diagnostic Criteria
Diagnostic criteria refer to the standards used by psychiatrists and psychologists for categorizing and labeling people as mental patients or as suffering from a mental illness. These criteria decide whether a person is mentally ill and specify the type of disorder. Many psychologists believe there are inherent biases in diagnosing procedures that make women more likely to be diagnosed as mentally ill.
The most commonly used worldwide criteria is the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), developed by the American Psychiatric Association. The first version came in 1952, the second in 1968, the third in 1980, a slightly revised edition in 1987, DSM-IV in 1994, and a text revision (DSM-IV-TR) in 2000. The DSM covers more than 240 different diagnoses and includes descriptions of symptoms. It has a multi-axial system containing five axes or dimensions for diagnosis. The first three axes cover the diagnosis, while the remaining two evaluate stressors and overall functioning. Information includes age of onset, course of disorders, and gender ratio.
The Issue of Gender Bias in Diagnosis of Clinical Disorders
Researchers have criticized the DSM for inherent gender bias (Kaplan, 1983a, 1983b; Lerman, 1996; Marecek, 2001). The main criticism is that women are more likely to be diagnosed with problem behavior when the problem may be due to other causes than pathology. In diagnosis, men are used as the norm, increasing the likelihood of females being diagnosed as disorder-positive when the behavior occurs more frequently in women. "Professionals have used male-based norms to define healthy versus pathological behavior" (Cook, Warnke, and Dupuy, 1993, Pp. 312-313).
Consequently, characteristic male behaviors like competitiveness, assertiveness, independence, and aggressive attitude are considered healthy mental functioning. Characteristic female behaviors like emotional experiences are taken to indicate underlying psychopathology. Critics also argue that cultural background and life circumstances are ignored in DSM criteria (Lerman, 1996; Marecek, 2001). Although DSM-IV and DSM-IV-TR consider cultural factors, they do not give them due importance (Dana, 2001). The DSM assumes that although circumstances may be relevant, the problem primarily resides within the person.
π Definition β Gender bias in diagnosis: The tendency to use male behaviors as the norm for healthy functioning, making female-typical behaviors appear pathological.
π Example: If a raped or acid burnt woman is depressed, isolated, phobic, or severely anxiety-ridden, she will be labeled as having one of the relevant disorders. "What" she is becomes important, not "why" she is like that.
The American Psychiatric Association itself has warned about over-diagnosis or under-diagnosis, stating that clinicians "must be cautious not to over-diagnose or under-diagnose certain Personality Disorders in females or in males because of social stereotypes about typical gender roles and behaviors" (American Psychiatric Association, 2000, P. 688).
Typical Gender Behaviors Likely to be Diagnosed as Disorders
In personality disorders, certain behaviors or symptoms are actually exaggerated forms of typical male or female behavior. The Schizotypical Personality Disorder is characterized by "a pervasive pattern of social and interpersonal deficits marked by acute discomfort with, and reduced capacity for, close relationships as well as cognitive or perceptual distortions and eccentricities of behavior" (American Psychiatric Association, 2000, P. 697). The Antisocial Personality Disorder is described as "pervasive pattern of disregard for, and violation of the rights of others" (American Psychiatric Association, 2000, P. 701), including physical cruelty, lying, stealing, or fighting. An exaggerated picture of the traditional male gender role can be seen in these descriptions (Brannon, 1976).
On the other hand, the Dependent Personality Disorder is described as "a pervasive and excessive need to be taken care of that leads to submissive and clinging behavior and fear of separation" (American Psychiatric Association, 2000, P. 701). This is a blow-up of the conventional, stereotypical feminine role.
π‘ Why this matters: This shows how the diagnostic system may pathologize normal gender-role behaviors when they are expressed intensely or frequently, rather than recognizing them as culturally promoted traits.
Culturally Promoted Behaviors that can be Labeled as Mental Disorders
Anxiety in Women: Most women are trained to be dependent on men and taught that men are their protectors. Major decisions about household, girls' education, occupation, mobility, and marriage are usually taken by men. Women find it hard to make independent decisions, so they feel anxiety in problem situations. In a male-dominated society, girls are brought up to always please others, especially men. A consistent attempt for perfection and fear of failure nurture anxiety and obsessive tendencies.
Women and Phobias: From early childhood, girls learn to be scared of insects, animals, strangers, and strange situations. Dependence on perceived protectors and mothers as role models are contributory factors. Young boys do not have fathers as role models for phobias and fears. Since girls are kept more protected than boys, they turn into over-cautious mothers with phobic tendencies.
Women and Depression: Men are discouraged from expressing pain, hurt, and grief, while women and young girls are not discouraged from open expression of such feelings. For women, crying, weeping, sighing, and lamenting are socially acceptable behaviors. Anger and aggression are discouraged in women but considered acceptable for men. Consequently, women may cry and lament uninhibitedly but may not express anger over matters involving relationships with men (fathers, brothers, or husbands). Such circumstances promote behaviors similar to clinically diagnosable depression.
Some Facts about Gender Differences in Psychopathology
| Disorder | Gender Difference |
|---|---|
| Schizophrenia | Males: earlier onset, more hospitalization, higher relapse rates (Szymanski et al., 1995) |
| Major Depression | More common in women (ratio 2:1) |
| Bipolar Disorder | No known differences (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) |
| Dysthymia | More prevalent in women (ratio 2-3:1) |
| Depression (general) | Prevalence in women almost double that in men (Culbertson, 1997); gap widens during mid to late adolescence (Hankin et al., 1998) |
| Personality Disorders | Higher rate among men |
| Alcohol Dependence | Men higher (ratio 5:1) |
| Amphetamine Dependence | Men higher (ratio 3:1-4:1) |
| Cannabis, Cocaine | Men higher (ratio 1.5-2:1) |
| Hallucinogens | Men higher (ratio 3:1) |
| Opiates | Men higher (ratio 1.5-3:1) |
| Sedatives, Hypnotics, Anxiolytics | Women at higher risk (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) |
| Panic Attacks (with/without Agoraphobia) | Women higher (ratio 2-3:1) |
| Social Phobias | Women higher in general population; men higher in clinical settings |
| Obsessive Compulsive Disorder | No gender differences (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) |
| Posttraumatic Stress Disorder | No gender differences (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) |
| Conversion Disorder | Substantially more common in women (ratio 2-10:1) (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) |
| Somatization Disorder | Women account for 95% of patients (Tomasson, Kent, and Coryell, 1991); rare in men in U.S. but not in other cultures |
| Body Dysmorphic Disorder | No gender differences |
| Dissociative Identity Disorder | More common in women (ratio 3-9:1) |
| Sexual Dysfunction, Paraphilias | Rarely diagnosed in women (ratio 20:1 men to women) |
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that traditional stereotypes about gender-specific mental disorders are largely unsupported by modern research, which finds only a few consistent gender differencesβwomen showing higher rates of mood and anxiety disorders, and men showing higher rates of personality and substance-related disorders. However, these findings are complicated by significant gender bias in diagnostic criteria, particularly the DSM system, which uses male behaviors as the norm for healthy functioning and may pathologize female-typical behaviors. Cultural and social factors, such as the training of women toward dependence and emotional expression, can produce behaviors that resemble clinical disorders but are actually normal responses to life circumstances. Students must remember that diagnostic categories like Dependent Personality Disorder and Antisocial Personality Disorder may represent exaggerated forms of stereotypical gender roles rather than genuine pathology, and that the "what" of a diagnosis should never override the "why" of a person's circumstances.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two categories of mental illness where research consistently finds higher rates in women?
- What is the main criticism against the DSM regarding gender bias in diagnosis?
- According to the lecture, which personality disorder represents an exaggeration of the stereotypical female gender role?
- What is the gender ratio for major depression, and when does the gap between men and women widen?
- Why does the lecture suggest that women may show more phobic tendencies than men from a cultural perspective?
π Lecture 43 β Gender and Psychotherapy
π Overview: This lecture examines the influence of gender on psychotherapy, critiquing traditional male-dominated therapeutic models and introducing feminist therapy as an alternative. It explains how conventional approaches have pathologized feminine behavior and outlines the core principles and characteristics of feminist theory that center women's experiences and address power imbalances.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by highlighting that major therapeutic approaches were developed by male psychologists, establishing a male norm. It then contrasts traditional versus feminist theory, detailing six characteristics of conventional theories (androcentric, gendercentric, ethnocentric, heterosexism, intrapsychic orientation, determinism). The characteristics of feminist theory are presented (gender-free, flexible, interactionist, life-span perspective), followed by the principles of feminist psychology, including the personal is political, egalitarian relationships, honoring women's experiences, reformulating mental illness, and integrated analysis of oppression.
π Lecture Summary
Traditional Versus Feminist Theory
The lecture opens by noting that major psychotherapeutic approaches like psychoanalysis, behavioral therapy, client-centered therapy, existential therapy, and rational emotive behavior therapy were all created by male psychologists from the West, such as Freud, Jung, Adler, Watson, Skinner, Rogers, Maslow, and Ellis. This male dominance established masculine behavior as the norm, making stereotypically feminine behavior more likely to be labeled pathological. The feminist movement of the 1960s shifted focus, leading to feminist therapy which centers on two key elements: gender and power. Feminist therapy is built on the premise that understanding a person's social and cultural context is essential to understanding their problems.
π Definition β Feminist therapy: A therapeutic approach that emphasizes women's issues, the impact of socialization, gender stereotypes, issues specific to women's well-being, and considers the social and cultural context contributing to a person's problems.
Worell and Remer (1992) described the following characteristics:
Conventional theories have six outdated characteristics that determine the nature and process of psychotherapy:
- Androcentric Theory: Draws conclusions about human nature from male-oriented constructs.
- Gendercentric Theory: Assumes that men and women follow separate developmental paths, implying they are separate entities.
- Ethnocentric Theories: Proposes that all cultures, nations, and races have the same factual evidence related to human development and interaction.
- Heterosexism: Views heterosexual orientation as normative, socially acceptable, and desirable.
- Intrapsychic Orientation: Tends to find the origin of behavior in intrapsychic causes, leading to blaming the victim instead of external circumstances.
- Determinism: Assumes behavior and personality are pre-determined and fixed at an early stage of development.
π‘ Why this matters: These characteristics make conventional therapies fixed, inflexible, and single-tracked, whereas feminist therapy offers more flexibility, human element, and an interactionist approach.
The Characteristics of the Feminist Theory
Worell and Remer (1992) also described essential elements of feminist therapy that serve as criteria for evaluating suitability for counseling women:
- Gender-free Theories: Feminist theory considers socialization processes as key to explaining gender differences, unlike conventional theories that attribute differences to the 'true' nature of people.
- Flexible Theories: Involves constructs and strategies equally applicable to individuals and groups of all ages, races, cultures, genders, or sexual orientations, giving due importance to lifestyle, gender, and cultural origin.
- Interactionist Theories: Covers cognition, affect, and behavior while also considering contextual and environmental variables.
- Life-span Perspective: Does not limit understanding to early socialization; the whole life-span is important, and human development is a lifelong process where changes can occur at any stage.
Principles of Feminist Psychology
Feminist theory is based on the following principles (Herlihy, and Corey, 2001):
- The personal is political: Social transformation should be a goal; we should go for social change, not just individual change.
- The counseling relationship is egalitarian: The client has an active and important place, perceived as having potential to change. The therapist is not the final authority but another source of information. Clients have an active role in defining themselves.
- Feminist theory honors women's experiences: Men's behavior is not considered a norm. Women's experiences are at the core of understanding their distress. Feminist therapy aims to replace patriarchal "objective truth" with feminist consciousness that acknowledges diverse ways of knowing.
- Feminist therapy reformulates the definitions of mental illness and distress: Distress is not seen as a disease. Only part of distress consists of intrapsychic and interpersonal factors; the rest is explained by external factors. Feminist therapy reframes distress as a communication about unjust systems, rather than a disease, and pain as evidence of resistance and the will to survive.
- The use of an integrated analysis of oppression: Feminist therapists use an integrated approach that gives importance to culturally shaped gender roles, stereotypical upbringing, and differential treatment of genders. Cultural practices affect personalities and attitudes of both men and women, differently influencing their ability to engage in therapy.
π Definition β Feminist consciousness: An awareness that acknowledges a diversity of ways of knowing, replacing patriarchal "objective truth" and encouraging women to express emotions and intuition as touchstones for determining reality.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture critically evaluates conventional psychotherapy for being male-dominated and pathologizing feminine behavior, while introducing feminist therapy as a corrective approach centered on gender and power. Students must remember the six characteristics of traditional theories (androcentric, gendercentric, ethnocentric, heterosexism, intrapsychic orientation, determinism) that make therapy inflexible and victim-blaming. The four characteristics of feminist theory (gender-free, flexible, interactionist, life-span perspective) offer a more inclusive framework. The four principles of feminist psychology emphasize social change, egalitarian relationships, honoring women's experiences, and reformulating distress as a communication about unjust systems rather than disease. Finally, the integrated analysis of oppression shows how gender roles and socialization differentially affect men's (difficulty expressing emotions) and women's (difficulty identifying their own wishes) participation in therapy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key elements at the core of feminist therapeutic process according to this lecture?
- List and briefly describe the six characteristics of traditional theories identified by Worell and Remer (1992).
- How does feminist therapy's definition of mental illness differ from conventional approaches?
- What does the principle "the personal is political" mean in the context of feminist therapy?
- According to the lecture, what is the goal of replacing patriarchal "objective truth" with feminist consciousness?