π Lecture 1 β INTRODUCTION
π Overview: This lecture introduces cognitive psychology as the scientific study of mental processes involved in thinking, acquiring, and storing knowledge. It traces the historical evolution of the field from ancient Greek philosophy through behaviorism to the modern information processing approach, explaining how cognitive psychology emerged as a distinct discipline.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining cognitive psychology and its focus on cognition as "thinking" or "knowing." It then explores the historical background starting with Plato's theory of knowledge acquisition, followed by the contributions of Wilhelm Wundt and early psychophysics. The lecture examines the limitations of introspective methods and the rise of behaviorism, before detailing the pivotal developments during and after World War IIβincluding information theory, Noam Chomsky's critique of behaviorist language models, the emergence of computers and artificial intelligence, and Donald Broadbent's work on attentionβthat culminated in Ulric Neisser formally establishing cognitive psychology.
π Lecture Summary
Overview and Definition
Cognitive Psychology deals with cognition, which can be understood as "thinking" or "knowing." In other words, cognitive psychology deals with the processes involved in thinking, acquisition, and storage of knowledge. For this purpose, it adopts an information processing approach, viewing the mind as a system that processes information in stages similar to a computer.
Historical Background
Plato's Theory of Knowledge Plato, the great Greek philosopher, was the first person to present a coherent theory of how knowledge is acquired and retained. He proposed that ideas are created in the human mind and that these ideas are then projected out into the world. These projections serve as images that we see through our senses. In other words, the outside world is an illusion made up of projections of ideas and the true reality lies inside of us. Therefore, Plato concluded that perception is an internal process and we can learn everything by looking inwards.
Mental Philosophy and Epistemology When psychology was first taught in European universities, it was subsumed under the title of mental philosophy. Philosophers throughout history have been concerned with concepts of perception and knowledge, as to how these interact with reality. Similarly, the field of epistemology within philosophy has been concerned with the nature of knowledge. Thus cognitive psychology has been present as an undercurrent in the field of ontology and epistemology throughout the last two millennia.
Wilhelm Wundt and Psychophysics More recently, in 1875, Wilhelm Wundt set up the first psychological laboratory to study perception and cognition. A lot of the perceptual experiments and studies conducted were included in the field he called psychophysics. An example of psychophysics is the relationship of sensation and intensity of the stimulus.
π Definition β Psychophysics: The study of the relationship between physical stimuli and the sensations and perceptions they produce.
π Formula: [No specific formula provided in text] β The lecture only provides the example: relationship of sensation and intensity of the stimulus.
Problems with Introspective Methods A major problem with most psychological studies of this time was over-reliance on introspective reports. In these reports, information was acquired by asking subjects what they felt, thought, or saw, heard, etc., and these reports were then used for deriving psychological principles. This was around the same time that Freud proposed the idea of unconscious processing. We now know for sure that most cognitive processing takes place at an unconscious level.
The Rise of Behaviorism The criticism of the introspective technique soon led psychology to its opposite extreme, and the behaviorist school took over. The behaviorists argued that anything we could not observe could not form part of the science of psychology. They coined and exclusively used terms like stimulus, response, reinforcement, conditioning, etc. All of these had to do with phenomena that could be converted into some kind of numerical representation. Hunger, for example, was called "number of hours of food deprivation." Behaviorists relied only on things they could see and rejected phenomena such as memory and imagery as unscientific just because they couldn't think of a way of observing and measuring them.
π‘ Why this matters: Behaviorism's rejection of unobservable mental processes created a major gap in psychology, as it could not explain complex human behaviors like language, memory, and problem-solving.
The Cognitive Revolution During the 2nd World War, human factors research and information theory combined to generate the information processing approach. This approach, along with several other factors, led to the creation of a new field called cognitive psychology.
Among these factors was Noam Chomsky's critique of Skinner's book Verbal Behavior. Chomsky, in his groundbreaking paper "On Verbal Behavior," shattered the simple-minded behaviorist model of language designed by Skinner. He argued that language was far too complex to be explained by stimulus response alone.
Around the same time, computers had emerged as thinking machines, where a lot of similarities with human information processing were coming to the fore. The field of artificial intelligence had also emerged, which sought to make computers that thought like humans and solved problems and learned new things.
Donald Broadbent was working at the same time on attention and visual perception. A lot of experimental work during that time, along with Bartlett's classic experiments on memory, combined to create what Ulric Neisser called Cognitive Psychology in a book entitled Cognitive Psychology.
β Key Takeaways
Cognitive psychology is the scientific study of thinking and knowing, adopting an information processing approach to understand how the mind acquires and stores knowledge. The field has deep philosophical roots extending back to Plato, but modern cognitive psychology emerged as a reaction against behaviorism, which had rejected the study of unobservable mental processes. The cognitive revolution was driven by multiple forces: Chomsky's critique proving behaviorism couldn't explain language, the development of computers and artificial intelligence as models for human thinking, and experimental work by researchers like Broadbent and Bartlett. The key insight is that most cognitive processing occurs unconsciously, and valid scientific methods can study internal mental processes through observable behaviors and information processing models. Students must remember that cognitive psychology is NOT behaviorismβit embraces the study of memory, imagery, attention, and other mental phenomena that behaviorists rejected as unscientific.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does the term "cognition" mean, and what approach does cognitive psychology adopt to study it?
- How did Plato explain the relationship between ideas, perception, and reality?
- What was the main limitation of introspective reports, and what did Freud propose around the same time?
- Why did behaviorists reject the study of memory and imagery, and how did Chomsky challenge the behaviorist model of language?
- Which three major developments during and after World War II contributed to the creation of cognitive psychology as a distinct field?
π Lecture 2 β The Information Processing Approach
π Overview: This lecture introduces the information processing approach, which focuses on how sensory input is transformed into behavioral output through mental processes. It explains why cognitive psychologists study what happens between sensation and behavior, using the computer analogy of hardware and software level descriptions to understand human cognition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the information processing approach as an alternative to behaviorism, the concept of stages and levels of processing in the mind, the distinction between hardware level and software level descriptions of cognitive processes (with visual processing as an example), the role of attention and limited capacity models, and how cognitive psychologists develop and test theoretical models through experiments.
π Lecture Summary
The Information Processing Approach
Unlike behaviorism's stimulus-response model, the information processing approach examines how input is transformed into output. The key question is what happens between sensation and behavior. Cognitive psychology treats sensations as bits of information that undergo various mental processes, which may or may not result in behavior.
π‘ Why this matters: This shift from behaviorism to information processing marks the foundation of modern cognitive psychology, allowing researchers to study internal mental processes scientifically.
Stages and Levels of Processing
These processes are usually performed in stages, with different layers or levels of processing in each stage. These layers can be understood as levels of description rather than actual processes themselves. Just as computers have hardware and software levels, human information processing can be described similarly:
- Hardware level description: What happens in the brain or nervous system when a sensation occurs
- Software level description: Mental processes like closing eyes to recall an image of a sensation
Hardware Level Description Example: Visual Processing
A hardware level description of visual processing includes:
- Studying the visual sensation itself
- How sensory neurons carry information higher in the system
- Studying the visual cortex (the brain part concerned with visual processing)
- Connections between visual cortex and other brain parts
- Complex brain processes we don't fully understand
- Afferent neurons carrying decisions via nerves to muscles that implement the decision
Software Level Description
A software level description would start at sensation and continue with:
- Sensory storage
- Possibility of a filter underlying selective attention
- Short term/working memory that processes and transforms material
- Storage in long term memory
- Retrieval from long term memory back into working memory when needed
Attention and Limited Capacity Models
The lecture uses the example of attention to show how doing two tasks simultaneously can impair performance quality at both tasks. This observation has allowed psychologists to generate limited resource or limited capacity models of attention.
Model Development and Testing
Cognitive psychologists generate descriptions of different stages of information processing and develop models that incorporate these descriptions into new theoretical frameworks. These models are then tested in the laboratory using experiments, mostly on human subjects.
β Key Takeaways
The information processing approach fundamentally shifts focus from stimulus-response associations to understanding the internal mental transformations between input and output. Students must remember that cognition can be described at both hardware (neural/brain) and software (mental process) levels, similar to computer analysis. Attention operates as a limited resource system, meaning multitasking degrades performance. Cognitive models are built from these descriptions and tested experimentally on humans. Finally, the stages of processingβsensory storage, attention, working memory, and long term memoryβform the backbone of cognitive psychology explored throughout this course.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between the information processing approach and behaviorism's stimulus-response model?
- What are the two levels of description used to understand human information processing, and what does each level describe?
- In the hardware level description of visual processing, what role do afferent neurons play?
- How does the example of doing two tasks simultaneously inform our understanding of attention?
- How do cognitive psychologists test the models they develop from information processing descriptions?
π Lecture 3 β Cognitive Neuropsychology
π Overview: This lecture introduces cognitive neuropsychology, which examines cognition at the hardware (neural) level of the brain. It explains how studying brain-injured humans, brains of deceased individuals, neuro-imaging, and animal studies contribute to our understanding of cognitive processes, and it details the fundamental biological units of the brain, including neurons and synapses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Cognitive neuropsychology describes cognition at the hardware level, utilizing methods like studying brain-injured humans, brains of dead people, neuro-imaging (X-rays, MRI, fMRI), and animal studies. It then covers the structure and function of the neuron, including the cell body, dendrites, and axon, and explains the synapse and the role of neurotransmitters in transmitting impulses. Finally, it outlines the organization of the brain into its four main lobes: occipital, frontal, temporal, and parietal.
π Lecture Summary
Cognitive Neuro-psychology
Cognitive Neuro-psychology describes cognition at the hardware level, using the computer metaphor. The neural architecture of cognition is the basis on which the software level is built. At this level, it is possible to explain many visual and auditory phenomena, but higher-level cognitions remain a mystery. π‘ Why this matters: This lecture establishes that while we can observe brain activity patterns, the highest forms of thinking are not yet fully understood at a neural level.
Neuropsychological Methods: Brain-injured Humans
The study of brain-injured humans has greatly enriched our understanding of human cognition. It has allowed psychologists to design split brain experiments, which revealed the differences between the right and left hemispheres of the brain.
Neuropsychological Methods: Brains of Dead People
The study of brains of dead people has also added to the understanding of cognition, but to a limited extent. Researchers studied the brains of people with certain brain disorders to see if any traces of the illness could shed light on normal brain functioning.
Neuropsychological Methods: Neuro-imaging
X-rays have contributed to our understanding of brain processes, but Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and functional MRI (fMRI) scanning techniques have been even more revealing. The MRI technique is quite intrusive and yields relatively limited information. The fMRI, however, allows for live brain scans, is less intrusive, and is radiation-free. Despite these advances, it remains a hardware-level understanding of the brain and can never substitute a software-level description.
Neuropsychological Methods: Animal Studies
A controversial method of studying neural processes is studying live animals. This method is controversial because these animals are subjected to procedures like brain surgeries where parts of the brain are removed to observe their function. The conditions in which these animals are kept have also come into question. While a lot of useful information has been obtained, the ethical controversy remains.
The Neuron
The brain contains approximately 70 billion neurons. A neuron is a specialized cell that transmits and stores information of different kinds. The cell body contains a nucleus at its center, which governs the functions of the neuron. Tiny branches called dendrites bring information to the neuron from other neurons. On the other side, the neuron has a branch called the axon, which transmits information from the neuron to the muscles.
π Definition β Neuron: A specialized cell that transmits and stores information of different kinds.
The Synapse
The neuron is not directly connected to other neurons. A fluid called the neurotransmitter moves between the dendrites of one neuron and the axon of another neuron. The gap between the neurons, which contains the neurotransmitter, is called the synapse. The synapse transmits the electric impulse generated in one neuron to the other neurons.
π Definition β Synapse: The gap between neurons which contains the neurotransmitter, transmitting the electric impulse from one neuron to the next.
Organization of the Brain
The brain can be divided into four lobes: Occipital lobe, Frontal lobe, Temporal lobe, and Parietal lobe. Each lobe performs certain specialized functions.
β Key Takeaways
The study of brain-injured humans, especially through split brain experiments, has been crucial for understanding hemispheric differences. While animal studies provide useful information, they remain ethically controversial. Neurons, composed of dendrites and axons, are the fundamental functional units, and they communicate across the synapse via neurotransmitters. The brain is organized into four main lobes, each with specialized functions. fMRI allows for live, non-invasive brain scanning, but provides hardware-level data, which cannot replace software-level descriptions of cognition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the core difference between hardware-level and software-level descriptions of cognition in this context?
- What are the four methods for studying brain processes discussed in this lecture?
- Name the three main parts of a neuron and their respective functions.
- What is the synapse and what is its role in neural communication?
- List the four lobes of the brain mentioned in the lecture.
π Lecture 04 β Cognitive Neuropsychology (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of cognitive neuropsychology, focusing on the hardware level of cognitionβthe neural architecture underlying mental processes. It examines the structure and function of sensory systems, particularly vision and audition, and how they transmit information to the brain, providing a foundational understanding of how perceptual information is processed at the neural level.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the structure and function of the eye, including contributions by Ibn-al-Haitham, the visual pathway from retina to brain including the optic chiasma, lateral geniculate nucleus, and superior colliculus, the structure of the ear and the auditory pathway, and the neural architecture of sound localization through delay detectors.
π Lecture Summary
The Eye
Cognitive Neuropsychology describes cognition at the hardware level using the computer metaphor, where the neural architecture of cognition serves as the basis for the software level of mental processes. At this level, it is possible to explain many visual and auditory phenomena, though higher-level cognitions remain a mystery.
Visual information passes through the lens, which helps focus the image on the retina. From the retina, information travels to the optic nerve, which transmits it to the brain.
π Definition β Hardware level: The neural architecture of cognition, analogous to computer hardware, that forms the physical basis for mental processes.
π Formula: Visual pathway β retina β optic nerve β brain (basic transmission sequence)
π Example: When light enters the eye, it passes through the lens which adjusts to focus the image precisely onto the retina, similar to a camera lens focusing light onto film.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the hardware level helps explain why certain visual phenomena occur and provides the foundation for understanding visual disorders.
Ibn-al-Haitham
Ibn-al-Haitham, a great Muslim scientist, discovered not only the structure and function of the eye but also how it links with the nervous system. He proposed that the eyes transmit information to the brain via the optic nerve and was aware of different visual fields in the eye. He also proposed a dual visual pathway system. Among his other contributions were the development of spectacles and telescopes.
π Definition β Dual visual pathway system: Ibn-al-Haitham's proposal that visual information follows two distinct neural pathways from the eyes to the brain, processing different features of the visual image.
π Example: Ibn-al-Haitham recognized that the left and right visual fields from each eye are processed separately before being combined in the brain, a finding that preceded modern understanding by centuries.
The Visual Pathway
The visual pathway starts from the retina where the image is formed, then travels to the optic nerve. From the optic nerve, information goes to the optic chiasma, where visual information from both eyes is combined. The combined information then moves to the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN), which processes information about colors and details of the image. A separate visual pathway takes information about global features such as localization and movement to the superior colliculus. There is considerable evidence for two different visual pathways that take different features of an image to different parts of the brain.
π Definition β Optic chiasma: The point where visual information from the two eyes is combined before being sent to the brain for further processing.
π Definition β Lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN): A structure in the brain that processes information about colors and fine details of the visual image.
π Definition β Superior colliculus: A brain structure that processes information about global visual features such as localization and movement.
π Formula: Visual pathway β retina β optic nerve β optic chiasma β lateral geniculate nucleus (colors/details) AND superior colliculus (localization/movement)
π Example: When viewing a moving red car, the lateral geniculate nucleus processes the car's red color and detailed features like the license plate, while the superior colliculus processes where the car is located and its direction of movement.
The Ear
The ear receives auditory information in the form of sound waves that impact the eardrum (tympanic membrane). From the eardrum, information is transmitted via the cochlea to the auditory nerve. The ear consists of three parts: the outer ear, middle ear, and inner ear, which includes the semicircular canals for balance and the cochlea for hearing.
π Definition β Cochlea: The spiral-shaped structure in the inner ear that converts sound vibrations into neural signals sent to the brain via the auditory nerve.
π Formula: Auditory pathway β sound waves β eardrum β cochlea β auditory nerve β brain
π Example: When a bell rings, sound waves travel through the air, strike the eardrum causing it to vibrate, these vibrations are transmitted through the middle ear bones, then converted to neural signals in the cochlea before traveling to the brain via the auditory nerve.
The Auditory Pathway
The auditory pathway transmits auditory information from the ear to the brain for processing.
Sound Localization
Sound localization refers to the process of determining where a sound is coming from. This is enabled by delay detectors in the nervous system. These delay detectors are connected to each ear and process information about which ear received the sound first and which received it later. Depending on the delay between the ears, the system determines which direction the sound came from.
π Definition β Delay detectors: Neural mechanisms that compare the timing of sound arrival at each ear to determine the direction of the sound source.
π Definition β Sound localization: The neural process of determining the spatial origin of a sound based on the time difference between when it reaches each ear.
π Formula: Sound localization β time delay between ears β delay detectors β direction determination
π Example: If a person is standing to your left and calls your name, the sound reaches your left ear slightly before your right ear. The delay detectors in your brain detect this time difference and determine the sound came from the left side. If the delay is zero (sound reaches both ears simultaneously), the sound source is directly in front of or behind you.
π‘ Why this matters: Sound localization is critical for survival (detecting threats) and daily functioning (identifying who is speaking in a crowd).
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that cognitive neuropsychology examines cognition at the hardware level, focusing on the neural architecture underlying mental processes. The visual system involves a complex pathway from the retina through the optic nerve and optic chiasma to either the lateral geniculate nucleus (processing colors and details) or the superior colliculus (processing movement and localization). Ibn-al-Haitham made foundational contributions to understanding the eye's structure and dual visual pathways, as well as inventing spectacles and telescopes. The auditory system processes sound waves through the eardrum and cochlea to the auditory nerve, with sound localization achieved through neural delay detectors that compare the arrival time of sound at each ear.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between what the lateral geniculate nucleus and the superior colliculus process in the visual pathway?
- What are the three main structures in the visual pathway from the retina to the brain, in order?
- How do delay detectors in the nervous system enable sound localization?
- What were Ibn-al-Haitham's key contributions to understanding the visual system?
- What happens to visual information at the optic chiasma?
π Lecture 5 β COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture explores how visual information is processed from the retina to the visual cortex, based on classical experiments by Kuffler, Hubel & Wiesel, and David Marr. It then introduces sensory memory, focusing on iconic (visual) memory and Sperling's groundbreaking partial-report procedure, which revealed the capacity and rapid decay of visual sensory storage.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers information processing in ganglion cells (on-off and off-on cells), Hubel & Wiesel's discovery of bar and edge detectors in the visual cortex, David Marr's computer model of visual processing, an introduction to sensory memory (including the five senses), iconic memory and Sperling's whole-report experiment, Sperling's partial-report procedure demonstrating the high capacity of visual sensory memory, and the decay of visual memory over time.
π Lecture Summary
Information Processing in Visual Cells
Information processing of visual information occurs in our visual cortex. Classical experiments were conducted to understand how sensation transforms into perception. In 1953, Kuffler studied ganglion cells and discovered on-off cells and off-on cells. These cells define visual information processing. If light fell on the centre of the retina, on-off cells were activated; if light fell on the periphery, off-on cells started firing. When light is on the centre, on-off cells work and off-on cells do not. When there is illumination on the surrounding point, on-off cells become silent and off-on cells start working. When there is diffuse illumination, both cells fire slowly. This processing happens at the ganglion cell level, before information reaches the visual cortex.
Hubel & Wiesel
In 1962, Hubel & Wiesel conducted an important experiment using cats. They showed different stimuli, lights, and shapes to cats and viewed the visual cortex. They found that visual cortical cells respond in a more complex manner than lower cells. They named these cells bar detectors and edge detectors. Edge detectors help us understand where an object ends and another starts. They respond positively to light on one side of a line and negatively to light on the other side. Bar detectors respond positively to light in the centre and negatively to light at the periphery, or vice versa. Both bar and edge detectors are specific with respect to position, orientation, and width β they respond only to stimulation in a small area of the visual field. Bar and edge detectors combine to help us see many objects.
David Marrβs Work
David Marr developed a computer model of how information from on-off and off-on cells could be used to yield a useful analysis of the visual image. Marr and Hildreth (1980) combined the output of on-off and off-on detectors to calculate bars and edges of various widths and orientations. In this computer system, symbolic descriptions were created. The boundaries of objects in real images pose a difficult problem in computer vision. This system combines symbolic descriptions to identify the contour of an object.
Sensory Memory
When information first enters the human system, it is registered in sensory memories. Sensory memory allows us to take a snapshot of our environment and store this information for a short period. Only information transferred to other levels of memory will be preserved, and it lasts no more than about two seconds. Sensory memory holds a short impression of sensory information even after the sensory system stops sending information. There are 5 basic senses: 1) Vision, 2) Hearing, 3) Smell, 4) Taste, and 5) Touch. Most research has focused on vision and hearing because technology is advanced in these areas (e.g., cameras, microphones, computers).
Visual Sensory Memory β Iconic Memory
Iconic memory (visual sensory memory) can store a great deal of information but only for a very brief period. In an experiment, a subject sits looking at a screen. A dot is shown in the centre, and the subject focuses on it. A set of letters is presented at that fixed point for a very brief period, then removed. Subjects are asked to report the items. Normally, subjects report only 4β5 items out of 12 letters.
π Definition β Iconic Memory: A brief visual sensory store that can effectively hold all the information in a visual display for a very short period (less than one second).
Sperlingβs Partial Report Procedure
Sperling conducted an experiment in visual sensory memory using the same array of letters but asked subjects to report letters according to a cue (an auditory beep). After the array was turned off, a tone was sounded: high tone cue for reporting the top row, medium tone for the middle row, and low tone for the bottom row. Subjects reported at least 3 out of 4 letters, no matter which row was cued. Since subjects did not know beforehand which row would be cued, they had at least 3 letters from each row available β meaning they had at least 9 out of 12 letters available in their visual memory. This method was called the partial-report procedure.
π‘ Why this matters: This experiment demonstrated that the capacity of iconic memory is much larger than previously thought β we briefly hold nearly all visual information, but it decays too quickly to report it all in whole-report tasks.
The Decay in Visual Memory
Sperling also varied the length of the delay between the offset of the display and the tone. As the delay increased to 1 second, subjects' performance decayed back to the original whole-report level of 4 or 5 items. This indicates our visual memory loses most of the information in one second. A criticism of this experiment is that it is an artificial or laboratory phenomenon, not related to real-life vision. Sperling's experiments indicate the existence of a brief visual sensory store β a memory that can effectively hold all the information in the visual display. We receive a lot of visual information from our surroundings, but it is all stored in visual sensory memory for only a very brief period. Information that receives attention is stored in other memory systems; the rest is lost.
β Key Takeaways
Kuffler's discovery of on-off and off-on ganglion cells and Hubel & Wiesel's identification of bar and edge detectors in the visual cortex demonstrate how the brain processes basic visual features hierarchically. David Marr's computer model showed how these neural outputs can be combined to recognize object boundaries. Sensory memory, particularly iconic (visual) memory, briefly holds a high-capacity snapshot of our environment. Sperling's partial-report procedure revealed that iconic memory can store nearly all visual information (e.g., 9 out of 12 letters) but decays rapidly β within about one second β returning to whole-report levels of only 4β5 items.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are on-off cells and off-on cells, and under what lighting conditions does each fire?
- How do edge detectors and bar detectors differ in their response patterns?
- What was the key finding of Sperling's partial-report procedure compared to the whole-report procedure?
- How does the delay between stimulus offset and the cue affect performance in Sperling's experiment, and what does this reveal about iconic memory?
- What are the five basic senses, and why has most sensory memory research focused on vision and hearing?
π Lecture 06 β VISUAL SENSORY MEMORY EXPERIMENTS (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of visual sensory memory through Sperlingβs classic experiments, revealing how post-exposure field brightness affects memory duration. It introduces the concept of iconic memory and echoic memory, and presents fascinating evidence that our perception of the present is actually delayed β a phenomenon known as psychological time.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Sperling's 1967 variation using dark versus light post-exposure fields and the resulting increase in retention time to 5 seconds. Neisser's coining of the term iconic memory for brief visual storage is explained, along with the overwriting/erasure effect. The lecture then introduces psychological time β the idea that we perceive the present after a delay. Finally, auditory sensory memory (echoic memory) is examined through the experiments of Moray, Bates & Barnett (1965) and Darwin, Turvey & Crowder (1972).
π Lecture Summary
Sperling (1967) & Neisser (1967)
Sperling made another variation of his classic experiment: after the array of letters disappeared, he made the visual field dark instead of white. This produced fascinating results β the retention power of the subjects increased to 5 seconds. When the post-exposure field was light, sensory information remained for only 1 second, but when the field was dark, it remained for a full 5 seconds.
Ulric Neisser wrote the first cognitive psychology book (1967). He coined the term word icon and devised the term iconic memory for short-term visual memory. According to Neisser, visual memory is neither short-term memory nor long-term memory β it is a very, very brief memory and should be called iconic memory. Without such a visual icon, perception would be much more difficult. Many stimuli are of very brief duration; to recognize them, the system needs some means of holding onto them for a short while until they can be analyzed.
Neisser also reported that if another display is presented during that one second when you are already retaining an image, it is like erasing or washing out the first and overwriting it with the second. Almost all information is held for a very brief period (1 second). It is quickly washed out after removal of the stimulus unless attention is paid to it.
The sensory store is particularly visual in character and is sensitive to light. We cannot pinpoint where sensory memory is located in the brain β this is a software-level description, not a hardware-level description. The sensory visual store is not physical but seems like a physical phenomenon and is sensitive to light.
π‘ Why this matters: This distinction between light and dark post-exposure fields reveals that iconic memory is fundamentally a sensory-level phenomenon β it decays when light overwrites it, but persists in darkness. This explains why afterimages seem to linger longer in dark rooms.
Psychological Time
Are we living in every moment in this moment, or are we living in the past? The conclusion drawn is that our new information synthesizes with our old information as it happens at the same time and space. If we see things that happened one second ago, we perceive them as happening here and now. We are attending to visual information after some delay β no matter how brief that period may be (less than one second). And because we perceive the information after we have seen something, we know we are not living in the past; we see things here and now.
This is called psychological time. We found that our perception is delayed by about a second. Our visual system is recombining things within a second and putting them together, constructing a visual image based on the information we receive.
Auditory Sensory Memory
Evidence for an auditory sensory memory similar to visual memory comes from experiments by Moray, Bates and Barnett (1965) and Darwin, Turvey & Crowder (1972).
Moray, Bates and Barnett (1965)
Their experiment is a copy of Sperling's experiments, but instead of top, middle, and bottom, sounds were manipulated as coming from left, right, or front. The cue was presented visually (the opposite of Sperling's experiment, where the cue was auditory). In their experiment, subjects listened to a recording over stereo headphones, hearing three lists of three items read simultaneously. Because of stereophonic mixing, one list seemed to come from the left side of the subject's head, one from the middle, and one from the right side.
The investigators compared results from a whole-report procedure (subjects reported all nine items) with a partial-report procedure (subjects were cued visually after presentation to report items from left, middle, or right). A greater percentage of the letters were reported in the partial-report procedure than in the whole-report procedure. This was statistically significant β an obvious, marked difference.
Thus, all the information is available to short-term sensory storage, but it quickly decays. The delay is significant but not as striking as visual sensation because visual sensation is central and hearing only supports it. Neisser (1967) has called this auditory memory echoic memory.
Neisser pointed out many things we understand and perceive but cannot perform β like the difference between competence and performance. This was a big blow to behaviorism. Cognitive psychology scientifically proved that psychology is much more than observable behavior only. Neisser's conclusion: the whole-report paradigm was a limit to our production, not a limit to our process. We process everything but we cannot produce all. Time delay, overwriting, and light contrast intervene in the production aspect, not in the storage aspect.
π‘ Why this matters: The whole-report vs. partial-report distinction reveals that our sensory systems register far more information than we can consciously report. The bottleneck is in production (reporting), not in processing.
Psychological Time (Recap)
We all are living in the past. This past is not in passive terms. We receive visual information that is one second old, and we receive auditory information that is 5 seconds old. Information is not only being received but is also being reconstructed. We are creating reality afresh every moment. Every icon is a separate entity. New information is a different entity. It reconstructs reality by combining with other entities. The heart of cognitive psychology lies in its experimentation.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that iconic memory persists for ~1 second in a light post-exposure field but up to ~5 seconds in a dark field, and echoic memory (auditory sensory memory) persists even longer. Neisser's distinction between competence (what we process) and performance (what we can report) revolutionized cognitive psychology by challenging behaviorism β showing that the whole-report paradigm measures a production limit, not a processing limit. The concept of psychological time reveals that our perception of "now" is actually a reconstruction of information ~1 second old (visual) and ~5 seconds old (auditory), meaning we are constantly creating reality afresh from delayed sensory input. Finally, sensory memory is a software-level description, not a hardware location β it is sensitive to light and sound but cannot be localized to a specific brain area.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the difference in retention time for iconic memory between a light post-exposure field and a dark post-exposure field in Sperling's variation?
- According to Neisser, what distinguishes iconic memory from short-term memory and long-term memory?
- What does the concept of psychological time reveal about how "present" our perception actually is?
- In Moray, Bates, and Barnett's (1965) experiment, how was the procedure different from Sperling's original experiment, and what was the key finding?
- What did Neisser mean when he said the whole-report paradigm was "a limit to our production, not to our process"?