π Lecture 1 β Introduction
π Overview: This introductory lecture sets the foundation for the entire course by outlining the objectives, methodology, grading, and texts for History and Systems of Psychology. It then provides a high-level overview of all topics to be covered up to the midterm and final exams, and concludes with an explanation of ancient philosophy/psychology in the Indo-Pak Sub-continent, introducing key concepts such as animism, magic, and early beliefs about the soul and consciousness.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by presenting the course objectives (introducing psychology's developmental history, preparing students for advanced materials, and providing basic and modern knowledge), the methodology (discussions, quizzes, homework, midterm and final exams), grading (35% midterm, 50% final, 15% assignments), and texts (Schultz & Schultz's "A History of Modern Psychology" and "Nafsiyat ka Irtika"). Next, it provides a course overview up to the midterm, covering ancient philosophy/psychology (Indo-Pak, Greek), 5th-12th century, Renaissance, British Associationism, French/German contributions, Reflexive Psychology, impact of physical sciences, Structuralism, Functionalism, Behaviorism, and Neo-Behaviorism. It then gives a course overview up to the final exam, covering Gestalt, Dynamic Psychology, Historico-Evolutionary Psychology, scientific outlook on mental illness, Psychoanalysis, Jung, Adler, Neo-Freudians, Humanistic Psychology, modern treatment trends, Anti-psychiatry Movement, psychology in Africa/Asia, and psychology in the 21st century. Finally, it dives into ancient philosophy/psychology in the Sub-Continent, defining psychology as the "study of mind and body," discussing the ancient concept of the soul (escaping during sleep, causing dreams), animism (seeing human qualities in inanimate objects), magic (used for control), Yoga (breath control and postures to connect body and soul), the belief that consciousness is related to the brain (contrasting with Greeks who thought it was a function of the heart), the differentiation between mental and physical labor (mental being superior), the idea of inherited mental faculties, and the concepts of Idealism (Atma/soul is pure self, world is illusion) and Materialism (consciousness and mind are products of material development).
π Lecture Summary
Course Objectives
The course has three main objectives. First, to introduce students to the developmental history of psychology as a subject. Second, to prepare students to appreciate and use more advanced psychological materials. Third, to provide both basic and the most modern knowledge related to psychology.
Methodology
The main features of a given topic will be discussed, supported by reference materials and examples from everyday life. Students may be quizzed verbally by the teacher, who asks a question, lets them write the answer, and then gives the correct answer. For example: "Freud established the Behaviorist School? Right or wrong?" The correct answer is "wrong" because Watson's name is associated with the Behaviorist School.
- At the end of two or three lectures, a homework assignment will be given in the form of a short essay-type exam or multiple choice questions (MCQs).
- A mid-term exam will be held after the completion of 21 one-hour lectures.
- A final exam will be held after the completion of all 45 lectures.
Grading
The midterm exam will carry 35% weightage of the total course marks. The final exam will be comprehensive and carry 50% weightage. A total of eight assignments shall be given, carrying 15% weightage of the total marks in the course.
Texts
Two main textbooks will be used. The first is "A History of Modern Psychology" by Duane Schultz & Sydney Schultz. The Urdu textbook used will be "Nafsiyat ka Irtika" by Rafiq Jaffer and Humair Hashmi. Handouts for the entire course, prepared by the instructor, will also be available.
Course Overview up to Midterm
The course up to the midterm will cover a review of ancient philosophy/psychology in the Indo-Pak Sub-continent, followed by ancient Greek philosophy/psychology, and philosophy/psychology in the 5th to 12th century AD. It will then consider the impact of the Renaissance on psychology, review British Associationism, and then review the French and German contributions to psychology up to the 18th and 19th Century. A review of Reflexive Psychology will follow, and then the impact of physical sciences on psychology. The lecture will then cover the Structuralist School, followed by the Functionalist School, and then a review of psychology in the beginning of the 20th century with the American contribution known as "Behaviorism" and "Neo-Behaviorism".
Course Overview up to Final Exam
After the midterm, more recent European contributions will be discussed, including the Gestalt School, English Dynamic psychology, and Historico-Evolutionary Psychology. A scientific outlook at mental illness will be taken, followed by the Psychoanalytical School, Jung's Analytical Psychology, and Adler's Individual Psychology, followed by Psychodynamic contributors. This will lead to a review of Humanistic Psychology, modern trends in psychological treatment (including the Anti-psychiatry Movement), the development of psychology in parts of Africa and Asia, and finally, a look at psychology in the 21st century.
Ancient Philosophy/Psychology in the Sub-Continent
The first problem in any discipline is that of scope and definition. Psychology for this purpose can be defined as the "study of mind and body." The ancient man regarded the soul as something invisible that resided inside a person. For example, the soul escaped the body when a person was asleep, and the escaped soul performed actions visible in the form of dream work. Dream work, fainting spells, epileptic fits, and mental and physical discrepancies were regarded as expressions of the soul.
The ancient man also believed in animism, which is the process of seeing human qualities in inanimate objects such as the moon, stars, or stones. He humanized those objects to make them easier to understand. The ancient man also had a strong belief in magic and tried to learn magical tricks to exercise control over things around him. In ancient Indo-Pak history, magic was an important element, used for negative or positive purposes.
The ancient man also indulged in exercises to gain control over his body. Yoga was one such exercise involving breath control and different body postures. One of yoga's beliefs was that body and soul are related and connected, influencing both. The ancient philosophy of the sub-continent advanced the belief that consciousness is related to the brain, while the ancient Greeks thought consciousness was a function of the heart.
About a thousand years B.C., sub-continentals differentiated between mental and physical labor. Mental labor (thinking and problem-solving) was considered superior, while physical labor (performing physical tasks) was considered inferior. They also believed that our mental faculties are inherited.
According to the sub-continentals, Atma (the soul) was the pure self. Further, the world around us was an illusion or deception played on us by our senses (Idealism). Some others believed that consciousness and mind were products of material development (Materialism).
π Definition β Animism: The process of seeing human qualities in inanimate objects such as the moon, stars, stones, etc. π Definition β Idealism: The belief that Atma (the soul) is the pure self and that the world around us is an illusion or deception played on us by our senses. π Definition β Materialism: The belief that consciousness and mind are products of material development. π Example: An ancient man's explanation for dreams: The soul escaped the body while the person was asleep, and the escaped soul then performed certain actions on behalf of the person, visible as dream work.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things to remember from this lecture are the course's definition of psychology as the "study of mind and body," the distinction between the course overview sections (midterm covering up to Neo-Behaviorism, final covering Gestalt through 21st century), the concept of animism (humanizing inanimate objects) and magic as ancient explanatory systems, and the sub-continental view that consciousness is related to the brain (contrasting with the Greek view of the heart). Also key are the views on mental (superior) versus physical (inferior) labor, the idea of inherited mental faculties, and the two opposing philosophical beliefs of Idealism (world as illusion) and Materialism (consciousness as product of material development) that emerged from this period.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main objectives of the PSY502 course?
- Define animism as understood by ancient man.
- According to ancient sub-continental philosophy, what is the relationship between consciousness and the brain (contrast this with the ancient Greek view)?
- How did the ancient sub-continentals view the relationship between mental and physical labor?
- Briefly explain the two opposing beliefs of Idealism and Materialism as described in the lecture.
π Lecture 2 β Ancient Greek Philosophy/Psychology
π Overview: This lecture explores the foundational contributions of ancient Greek philosophers to psychology, focusing on their views about the basic elements of matter, the nature of knowledge and the soul. It highlights the revolutionary ideas of Socrates and Plato, whose methods and theories on introspection, the psyche, and the structure of personality profoundly shaped later psychological thought.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the ancient Greek view that matter consists of water, air, and fire, and that contradiction is a permanent element causing constant flux. It then presents the idea of indivisible particles acting upon the soul to create sensations, a concept that foreshadows atomic theory. The major portion of the lecture is dedicated to the philosophies of Socrates and Plato, covering Socrates' emphasis on inward knowledge, virtue, happiness, and his teaching method, followed by Plato's elaboration on innate knowledge, the introspective method, idealism, the three parts of personality, and his tripartite theory of the soul.
π Lecture Summary
Ancient Greek Philosophy/Psychology
The ancient Greek philosophers believed that everything, including humans, was made of three basic elements: water, air, and fire. They also proposed that contradiction is a permanent feature of the world, causing constant flux. This means that every phenomenon has a counter-explanation, which leads to further investigation and the emergence of new phenomena and counter-phenomena, resulting in a world that is always changing.
A significant development was the view that everything consists of small, indivisible particles that act upon the soul to create sensations. This idea was later validated by the discovery of atoms.
π Definition β Flux: The state of being in constant change, driven by the contradiction inherent in all phenomena. π Definition β Contradiction: The principle that every phenomenon has a counter explanation, which is a permanent element of the world.
Socrates
Socrates (469BC β 399BC) is considered one of the most important ancient philosophers. He laid the foundation for many later thinkers. His central idea was that knowledge and truth reside in the mind, and one must look inward to find them. This means that to understand phenomena, one should look inside the self rather than at external things.
Socrates argued that knowledge creates virtue, so to be virtuous, one must study the soul (looking inwards). He rejected external observation as a path to true knowledge. For Socrates, true happiness is not gained through dishonest acts like stealing, but through the satisfaction of acquiring things honestly. He regarded the soul (psyche in Greek) as superior to the body, as it helps us distinguish between good and bad. He also asserted that everything has a definite purpose.
π‘ Why this matters: Socrates' inward-looking approach established introspection as a foundational method in philosophy and psychology, shifting the focus from the external world to the internal mind.
π Definition β Psyche: The Greek term for soul, which Socrates believed is superior to the body and helps distinguish between good and bad. π Definition β Socratic Method: A method of teaching based on a dialogue (not a monologue) between teacher and student, focusing on the logical correctness of an argument to enhance understanding and comprehension.
Plato
Plato (427BC β 347BC), a pupil of Socrates, was another influential Greek philosopher. Following Socrates, Plato believed that knowledge is innate and inside the mind. To extract knowledge, one must look into the mind rather than at external objects. This method was later called the introspective method.
Plato was an idealist philosopher who believed in the supremacy of ideas. He rejected empiricism (acquiring knowledge through observation of facts), arguing that ideas are the only true source of knowledge. He described the parts of personality as:
- Intellect: The ability to understand.
- Will: The drive to do something.
- Appetite: The part dealing with bodily needs.
According to Plato, ideas are eternal (neither born nor die), while worldly objects change and die. Therefore, true knowledge comes from ideas, not observation. He considered the soul (psyche) to be permanent and the body changeable. Sensory organs were seen as a hindrance to knowledge. Plato also proposed a tripartite soul:
- Reason, located in the head, whose function is to control and direct passion and appetite.
- Passion, located in the chest, which is the desire to perform an action.
- Appetite, located in the stomach, which refers to natural bodily needs like hunger and thirst.
Plato suggested that some passions and appetites are satisfied in dreams, a concept that foreshadows Freud's later theory of the id, ego, and superego. Plato established the first ever university, called the Academy.
π Definition β Introspective method: The method of looking into one's own mind or soul to gain knowledge, as opposed to outward observation. π Definition β Idealism: The philosophical belief in the supremacy of ideas as the only true source of knowledge, rejecting empiricism.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that ancient Greek philosophers believed that matter was composed of water, air, and fire, and that contradiction causes constant flux. The most critical contributions come from Socrates and Plato. Socrates is defined by his inward-looking method for discovering knowledge and virtue, and his use of the dialogue-based Socratic method. Plato, his pupil, is a key idealist who championed the introspective method, argued that the soul has three parts (reason, passion, appetite), and that personality consists of intellect, will, and appetite. Understand how Platoβs tripartite soul relates to bodily functions and how it anticipates Freudian concepts.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to ancient Greek philosophers, what were the three basic elements of all matter?
- What is the Socratic method of teaching, and how does it differ from a monologue?
- What did Plato identify as the three parts of the soul, and where did he locate each part in the body?
- What is the core difference between Plato's idealism and empiricism?
- How did Plato's concept of the parts of the soul (reason, passion, appetite) foreshadow a later psychological theory?
π Lecture 03 β Greek Thinkers
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the Greek philosopher Aristotle, considered the first psychologist in history due to his work De Anima (The Soul). It explores his key contributions to psychology, including his rejection of dualism, his laws of association of ideas, his empirical approach to knowledge, his classification of human motives, and his concepts of individual differences and catharsis. This matters because Aristotleβs ideas laid foundational principles for later psychological thought.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Aristotleβs life and his rejection of Platoβs dualism, followed by his three laws of association of ideas: similarity, contiguity, and contrast. It then discusses Aristotleβs view of man as a biological being with specific functions, his disagreement with Plato over the source of knowledge (empiricism vs. introspection), and his classification of human motives into primary and secondary categories. Finally, the lecture addresses Aristotleβs contributions on individual differences, the impact of childhood experiences, and the concept of catharsis.
π Lecture Summary
Aristotle
Aristotle was one of the greatest philosopher/thinkers in history. Born in 384 BC and died in 322 BC, he was a student of Plato. His ideas both show the influence of Platoβs thinking and sometimes present completely opposing views. Aristotle wrote a book called De Anima, meaning βthe Soul.β Since the soul was considered the primary topic of interest for philosophers/psychologists at that time, Aristotle is considered the first psychologist ever. He rejected the idea of dualism of soul and body, putting forward the view that these two are not separate but one entity.
Aristotle was of the view that ideas tend to become associated with each other for three reasons:
π Definition β Similarity: The mind tends to see certain similar patterns between two things and relates them together. This is the simplest explanation of the association of ideas. π Example: Two events which a person witnesses have certain common elements. These may then be associated with each other due to the similarities present in them.
π Definition β Contiguity: Two things or events happening close to each other so that the person is able to relate them to each other. π Example: If two events occur consecutively, one after the other, they tend to get associated with each other. One event may remind of the other event which is contiguous to it.
π Definition β Contrast: Two events or ideas are completely opposing to each other, which results in the formation of a link between the two. π Example: Two conflicting statements by someone. One statement would remind a person about the other conflicting statement immediately.
According to Aristotle, man is a biological being whose functions include eating, perceiving, having children, thinking, and doing things. All of these are characteristics of living organisms. It eats for nourishment and growth, perceives and responds to stimuli, has the ability to procreate, and higher forms like humans can use their mind to think and analyze. One of the functions of human beings is βdoing things,β meaning they are involved in various activities throughout their lives.
According to Aristotleβs teacher Plato, ideas are eternalβneither born nor do they dieβwhile worldly objects change. Therefore, for Plato, the true source of knowledge is ideas themselves. Plato asserted the soul to be permanent and the body as changeable. According to Plato, knowledge could be acquired through the soul, and sensory organs were a hindrance to the acquisition of knowledge. This was an introspective and subjective method of learning (looking into the mind to find solutions). Aristotle rejected his teacherβs views on introspection and said that true knowledge can only be gained through observation and empiricism. As human beings observe the world around them, they make judgments and decisions based on objective perception rather than subjective biases. Therefore, instead of looking to the mind, one needs to look at the world around to gain knowledge. In Aristotleβs views, sensory organs are not a hindrance to learning, but the source of gaining knowledge.
Aristotle also described two types of human motives:
π Definition β Primary motives: Basic motives which are the desires of all human beings and are mostly bodily desires such as hunger, sex, thirst, anger, and need for rest. Such motives may also be possessed by other living beings. An important aspect is that they are not learnt but are part of the genetic makeup of all organisms. Humans are born with these motives; they are inherited and become the cause of propelling a person to perform a certain act. π Example: Hunger may cause a poor man to beg for food. His basic bodily desire has caused him to perform a certain action.
π Definition β Secondary motives: Motives which are learnt by organisms and become habits of the individuals. π Example: It is the habit of certain people to socialize with others. Some people have the desire to dominate their fellows. These motives become habits and individuals tend to follow them quite often.
Another great contribution of Aristotle was his recognition that there are individual differences in various respects in people. These differences may be in intelligence level, abilities, sports, math, etc. For example, one individual may be a very good sportsman but not a very good musician, while another may be a very good musician but not a sportsman. Therefore, differences exist in all individuals as far as their personal characteristics are concerned. This is the reason for some individuals to excel in certain fields. Aristotle further suggested that these individual differences are created during the life span of a person, but they are inherited by the personβhe is born with these differences which may be discovered later in life.
Apart from inherited individual differences, Aristotle was of the view that early childhood experiences and training have a profound impact on an individual. Childhood is the time when the mind is open to all influences from the environment. A child learns to behave in a certain manner as he sees individuals around him doing. The way a child has been trained and educated during early childhood is expected to show some influence in every part of his or her life. π Example: A child of a Pakistani family who has been educated and grown up in the United States cannot be expected to behave similarly to one grown up in Pakistan, because his experiences and training are absolutely different. This influence is expected to last throughout his or her life.
π Definition β Catharsis: The sudden release of emotions by a person when he sees, hears, or feels something. π Example: A person may start crying when he hears about a tragedy someone else has encountered, or people often have soaked eyes when they watch a tragic scene in a movie. There may also be emotions such as happiness or joy which someone feels when a villain is being beaten up by the hero of the movie.
π‘ Why this matters: The list of contributions of Aristotle is long, which is why he is considered one of the greatest thinkers of mankind. His ideas have left a profound and long-lasting impact on manβs thinking.
β Key Takeaways
Aristotle rejected Platoβs dualism, arguing that soul and body are one entity, and he established empiricism as the true source of knowledge in contrast to introspection. He formulated three laws of association of ideasβsimilarity, contiguity, and contrastβwhich explain how the mind connects different thoughts. His classification of motives into primary (inherited, bodily desires) and secondary (learned, habitual) laid groundwork for modern theories of motivation. He pioneered the concepts of individual differences being inherited and the profound impact of early childhood experiences and training on later behavior. Finally, his concept of catharsis as a sudden emotional release through observing events (like plays or tragedies) remains an important idea in understanding emotional expression.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was Aristotleβs book on the soul called, and what does its title mean?
- What are the three laws of association of ideas proposed by Aristotle? Provide a brief example for each.
- How did Aristotleβs view on the source of knowledge differ from his teacher Platoβs view?
- Differentiate between primary motives and secondary motives according to Aristotle, giving an example of each.
- What did Aristotle mean by the term βcatharsis,β and what is one example he would have considered?
π Lecture 4 β Psychology in the 5th to 12th Century
π Overview: This lecture covers the development of psychological thought during the "dark ages" of Europe (5thβ11th century), a period when intellectual inquiry was discouraged and religious edicts replaced empirical investigation. It focuses on the significant contributions of Saint Augustine and Avicenna, who advanced ideas about introspection, consciousness, the soul's operation, and the mind-body relationship that would later influence modern psychology.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by describing the historical context of the "dark ages" in Europe, highlighting the shift away from Aristotelian empiricism toward Platonic idealism and the belief that wisdom was gained through inward reflection. It then details the contributions of Saint Augustine, including his views on free will and sin, his method of introspection and explanation of consciousness as a constant flow, and his influence on later psychologists. Finally, the lecture presents Avicenna's theories on the non-material soul, the soul's power over the body (including hypnosis and healing), his four stages of motion explaining human action, and his distinction between primary and secondary perceptions, as well as the concept of "Wahm" (nervous response).
π Lecture Summary
Psychology in the 5th To 12th Century
The period from the 5th to 11th century A.D. is considered the dark ages of Europe, a time between the great Greeks and progressive industrialized Europe. During this period, there was a general discouragement of research and investigation. Problems were not solved through research and observation but by invoking religious edicts. Intellectuals adopted Plato's idealism while Aristotle's empiricism and observation were rejected. It was believed that God was the most exalted being, followed by wisdom, then soul, and then matter. Matter of the body was the lowest form of existence, and wisdom the highest after God. Wisdom could be gained by looking inwards and by reflection, which was the Socratic and Platonian point of view.
π Definition β Dark Ages: A period (5thβ11th century) in Europe characterized by a discouragement of scientific research and observation, where problems were solved by invoking religious edicts rather than empirical investigation.
Saint Augustine
An important contribution to psychology during this time came from Saint Augustine, who was born in 354AD and died in 430AD. He proclaimed that evil or sin is a product of free will. This means it is the free will of an individual that makes him indulge in sins, evils, and crimes. Society imposes certain limits to the exercise of free will, resulting in the regulation of society. Saint Augustine further proclaimed that pride is a cardinal sin and the cause of many other evil acts, as it makes a person unaware of the consequences of his actions. Saint Augustine pointed out certain psychological elements in human beings that influence their actions and society as a whole. He agreed with the prevailing idea that the universe contains two basic principles: the principle of light and goodness, and the principle of darkness and evil. It is up to the individual to decide which path to take.
π Definition β Free Will: The capacity of an individual to choose his own actions; according to Saint Augustine, the source of evil and sin when unchecked by society.
According to Augustine, we can discover these principles by looking inwards into our minds, or what is called introspection. This idea is similar to the Socratic-Platonian ideas. Plato even considered the sense organs as a hindrance to the acquisition of knowledge. Saint Augustine added that a person can look into the self in the same way as one looks at external objects. He provided a simple solution for how to introspect: we can look at external objects through our sense organs, but we can look in by reflection. Reflection here refers to looking at and understanding ideas and thoughts and finding solutions to problems through the association of ideas within the mind. Because of this stress on looking inwards and his method, Saint Augustine is usually regarded as the first introspective psychologist.
π Definition β Introspection: The process of looking inward into one's own mind to examine thoughts, ideas, and find solutions to problems, as opposed to observing external objects through the senses.
Another great contribution of Saint Augustine is his explanation of consciousness, which in his view is constantly flowing in the form of a stream. It is up to us how we look into the stream to get ideas and generate solutions to our problems. This stream of ideas is the basis of all knowledge. His ideas of introspection were later used by psychologists such as Wundt and Titchner.
π Definition β Consciousness (Augustine): A constantly flowing stream of ideas and thoughts that is the basis of all knowledge; accessible through introspection.
π‘ Why this matters: Augustine's concept of consciousness as a "stream" directly anticipated William James' famous "stream of consciousness" metaphor and established introspection as a legitimate psychological method, which later became central to structuralist psychology.
π Example: Augustine's method of introspection versus Aristotle's method. Augustine would suggest that to understand why a person is angry, one should reflect inward on the thoughts and associations that led to that feeling. Aristotle would instead observe the angry person's external behaviors (clenched fists, raised voice) and the environmental triggers.
Avicenna
Avicenna was born in 980AD and died in 1037AD. He studied the Holy Quran, physics, theology, and medicine and adopted a rigorous method of distinction between concepts. Like the ancient thinkers, Avicenna believed that the human soul was non-material and immortal. It does not exist in any material form but nevertheless exists in the body. He rejected Aristotle's concept of a unity between soul and body; to him, the soul was a separate entity and the body was a separate one. Avicenna was of the view that the soul has its identity and its own operative laws, just as there are the operative laws of the body. Once the operative laws of the soul are determined, it would be easier to know how the soul thinks and what governs its actions.
π Definition β Soul (Avicenna): A non-material, immortal entity separate from the body, possessing its own identity and operative laws that govern its thinking and actions.
Avicenna was of the view that the mind has a tremendous effect upon the body, such that it can make it sick or make it healthy. He thought that the soul has an influence to the extent that if a person thinks that he is not well, the body responds in a similar fashion and he actually becomes ill. Therefore, the soul is stronger than the body and can dictate the body to behave in a certain manner. He further added that a strong soul or mind can not only affect a person's own body but can affect others as well, such as in hypnosis. Avicenna said the soul had the power to the extent that it ordered the body to move and the body obeyed; the soul was responsible for all actions of the body.
Following the Aristotelian tradition, Avicenna recognized four stages of motion to explain human actions. Motion refers to the process of performing a certain act.
π Definition β Motion (Avicenna): The process of performing a certain act, explained through four sequential stages that lead from thought to action.
π Formula: Four Stages of Motion
- Imagination β 2. Desires β 3. Impulsion β 4. Movement Plain-English meaning: A person first imagines something, which creates a desire for it; this desire pushes (impels) the person, and finally the person makes a physical movement to satisfy the desire.
π Example: A person sees a delicious apple on a tree.
- Imagination: The person thinks about how sweet and juicy the apple would taste.
- Desires: The person develops a willingness or wanting to possess and eat that apple.
- Impulsion: The desire to eat the apple pushes the person to plan and initiate actionβreaching out or walking toward the tree.
- Movement: The person actually climbs the tree and picks the apple to satisfy the desire.
Another of Avicenna's contributions is his distinction between primary and secondary perceptions.
Primary Perception is the subjective perception of a person that is based on his personal dispositions. For example, if a person is walking in a garden and has in his mind that there are snakes there, he is quite likely to confuse a twig with a snake. An illusion is a primary perception.
Secondary Perception is objective perception based on logical reasoning and rationality of observation. Personal biases and dispositions do not influence these perceptions, which are totally based on empirical evidence.
π Definition β Primary Perception: A subjective perception influenced by a person's personal dispositions, biases, or expectations; often results in illusions.
π Definition β Secondary Perception: An objective perception based on logical reasoning and empirical evidence, free from personal biases.
π‘ Why this matters: Avicenna's distinction between primary and secondary perception is strikingly similar to the Gestalt School's later concepts of "geographical reality" (objective, physical environment) and "subjective reality" (a person's perceived, psychological environment). This shows Avicenna anticipated key ideas of 20th-century perceptual psychology by nearly a thousand years.
Avicenna also elaborated the concept "Wahm," which is akin to what modern psychologists describe as "nervous response." Modern psychotherapists have explained that nervous response is the forerunner of many psychological and physical ailments. An example of "Wahm" is the stress created in a person, which ultimately has negative impacts on health, behavior, and psyche. Because he considered psychological factors in disease, Avicenna is considered both a great physician and a psychologist, being the first to develop a system that looked at diseases from not just the physical but also the psychological point of view.
π Definition β Wahm (Avicenna): A concept akin to the modern psychological idea of "nervous response," referring to a psychological stress state that is the forerunner of many psychological and physical ailments.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the "dark ages" were not a complete void of intellectual progress, and that both Saint Augustine and Avicenna made foundational contributions to psychology during this period. Saint Augustine is remembered as the first introspective psychologist for his method of using reflection and association of ideas to examine the mind, and for his concept of consciousness as a constantly flowing stream. Avicenna's most crucial ideas include the soul's power over the body (mind-body relationship), the four stages of motion (Imagination β Desires β Impulsion β Movement) as a model for human action, the critical distinction between primary (subjective, illusion-prone) and secondary (objective, evidence-based) perceptions, and the concept of "Wahm" as a precursor to modern understanding of nervous response/stress and its link to psychosomatic illness.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the dominant intellectual method during the "dark ages," and whose philosophical approach (Aristotle or Plato) was favored?
- According to Saint Augustine, what is the source of evil and sin, and why does society impose limits on it?
- What specific method did Saint Augustine propose for looking inwards, and why is he considered the "first introspective psychologist"?
- Describe Avicenna's four stages of motion in order, and provide a brief original example to illustrate the sequence.
- What is the difference between Avicenna's concepts of "primary perception" and "secondary perception"? Which modern psychological school's concepts did this distinction anticipate?