📘 Lecture 21 — Rogers Person Centered Approach
📖 Overview: This lecture examines Carl Rogers' person-centered approach to personality, a phenomenological and humanistic theory that emphasizes subjective experience, the self-concept, and the innate drive toward self-actualization. The lecture covers the core constructs of Rogers' theory, including the actualizing tendency, conditions of worth, unconditional positive regard, and the fully functioning person, and applies these concepts to therapy and education.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition of the phenomenological theory and humanistic view, followed by Rogers' biographical sketch, actualizing tendency as life's master motive, and Rogers' phenomenological position. It then covers the concept of self, need for positive regard, conditions of worth, and unconditional positive regard, continuing with the experience of threat and process of defense, defense mechanisms, the fully functioning person, Rogers' view of science and research, measuring self concept, personality organization, client centered therapy, psychotherapy and gardening, and student centered teaching.
📝 Lecture Summary
Roger’s Person Centered Approach – A Phenomenological Theory of Personality
Phenomenology is the study of the individual’s subjective experience, feelings, and private concepts as well as his or her personal views of world and self. For Rogers, behavior is utterly dependent upon how one perceives the world — behavior is the result of immediate events as they are perceived and interpreted by the individual. Such an approach to personology emphasizes the self and its characteristics. Rogers’ theory is often referred to as a self theory of personality because, for him, “the best vantage point for understanding behavior is from the internal frame of reference of the individual himself” (Rogers, 1951, p. 494).
Biographical Sketch
Carl Ransom Rogers was born January 8, 1902, in Oak Park, Illinois, a suburb of Chicago. He was the fourth of six children. His father was a civil engineer and contractor. Rogers has written several books on counseling and personality, including Psychotherapy and Personality Change, On Becoming a Person, Freedom to Learn, Carl Rogers on Encounter Groups, Becoming Partners, and Carl Rogers on Personal Power. Carl Rogers is unquestionably one of the most influential American psychologists.
On the basis of his clinical experience, Rogers concluded that the inner-most core of human nature is essentially purposive, forward-moving, constructive, realistic, and quite trustworthy. He regards the person as an active force of energy oriented toward future goals and self-directed purposes, rather than a creature pushed and pulled by forces beyond his or her control. Rogers contends that Christianity has nourished the belief that man is innately evil and sinful, and that this negative view has been reinforced by Freud. Rogers agrees that people occasionally express bitter and murderous feelings, abnormal impulses, and bizarre actions. However, when people are functioning fully, they show themselves to be positive and rational creatures that can be trusted to live in harmony with themselves and others. Rogers has a profound sense of respect for human nature, positing that the human organism has a natural tendency to move in the direction of differentiation, self-responsibility, cooperation, and maturity.
Actualizing Tendency as Life’s Master Motive
In line with his positive view of human nature, Rogers hypothesizes that all behavior is energized and directed by a single, unitary motive which he calls the actualizing tendency — an innate need to survive, grow and enhance one’s self.
Certain definitive characteristics mark the actualizing tendency. First, it is rooted in the physiological processes of the entire body (it is a biological fact, not a psychological tendency). At an organic level this inborn tendency involves not only the maintenance of the organism by meeting deficiency needs (air, food, water) but also the enhancement of the organism by providing for development and differentiation of the body’s organs and functions, its growth and continual regeneration. Of even greater significance for the human personality is the motivating force which the actualizing tendency provides for increased autonomy and self-reliance, for enlarging one’s field of experience, and for being creative. Additionally, Rogers maintains that the actualizing tendency is common to all forms of life — it is characteristic not only of human beings, or only of animals, but of all living things. It is the essence of life.
🔑 Definition — Actualizing Tendency: An innate need to survive, grow and enhance one’s self; a single, unitary motive that energizes and directs all behavior.
📌 Example: A child who is naturally curious and explores their environment, seeks new skills, and strives to become more independent is expressing the actualizing tendency.
💡 Why this matters: The actualizing tendency is the fundamental motivational force in Rogers' theory — understanding it is essential for grasping why people behave as they do and what drives personal growth.
Rogers’ Phenomenological Position
A phenomenological position holds that what is real to an individual (what reality is thought, understood, or felt to be) is that which exists within that person’s internal frame of reference, or subjective world, including everything in his or her awareness at any point in time. It follows that an individual’s perceptions and experiences not only constitute that person’s reality but also form the basis for his or her actions; one responds to events in accordance with how one perceives and interprets them.
One important implication of a phenomenological perspective for a theory of personality is that the best understanding of a person’s behavior is obtained through observation of his or her internal frame of reference. Subjective experience is thus the key to understanding behavior. This means that the most important object of psychological study is a person’s subjective experiences, because these experiences alone are the ultimate causal agents of behavior. Finally, Rogers’ choice of a phenomenological approach reflects his belief that the complexity of behavior can only be understood by reference to the entire person. Rogers espouses a holistic view of personality, the view that a person behaves as an integrated organism and that his or her unity cannot be derived from atomistic (reductionistic) approaches to behavior.
🔑 Definition — Phenomenology: The study of the individual’s subjective experience, feelings, and private concepts as well as his or her personal views of world and self.
🔑 Definition — Internal Frame of Reference: The subjective world of the individual, including everything in his or her awareness at any point in time; the individual's perception and interpretation of reality.
📌 Example: A thirsty man stranded in the desert will run as eagerly to a pool of water that is a mirage as to a real pool — because his perception and interpretation of the event (his internal frame of reference) determines his behavior, not objective reality.
Concept of Self: Who am I anyway?
The self is the most important construct in Rogers’ theory of personality. The self-concept denotes the individual’s conception of the kind of person he or she is. The self-concept is one’s image of oneself, especially including awareness of being (what I am) and awareness of function (what I can do). The self-concept includes not only one’s perceptions of what one is like but also what one thinks one ought to be and would like to be. This latter component of the self is called the ideal self, which represents the self-concept that the individual would most like to possess. It is basically equivalent to the superego in Freudian theory.
Rogers postulates that when the self is first formed, it is governed by the organismic valuing process alone. In other words, the infant or child evaluates each new experience in terms of whether it facilitates or impedes his or her innate actualizing tendency. For instance, hunger, thirst, cold, pain, and sudden loud noises are negatively valued, since they interfere with the maintenance of biological integrity. Food, water, security, and love are positively valued; they favor the enhancement of the organismic tendency. In a sense, the organismic valuing process is a monitoring system that keeps the human infant on the proper course of need satisfaction.
🔑 Definition — Self-Concept: The conscious perceptions and values of the concept “I” or “me”; one’s image of oneself, including awareness of being and awareness of function.
🔑 Definition — Ideal Self: The self-concept that the individual would most like to possess; what one thinks one ought to be and would like to be.
🔑 Definition — Organismic Valuing Process: A monitoring system that evaluates each new experience in terms of whether it facilitates or impedes the innate actualizing tendency; keeps the infant on the proper course of need satisfaction.
Need for Positive Regard
Rogers contends that all persons possess a basic desire to experience attitudes such as warmth, respect, admiration, love, and acceptance from significant people in their lives. This need for positive regard develops as the awareness of self emerges, and it is pervasive and persistent. It is first seen in the infant’s need to be loved and cared for, and is subsequently reflected in the person’s satisfaction when approved by others and frustration when disapproved. Rogers indicates that positive regard may be either learned or innately given to all persons.
🔑 Definition — Need for Positive Regard: A basic desire to experience warmth, respect, admiration, love, and acceptance from significant people in one's life; develops as the awareness of self emerges.
Conditions of Worth
Given the fact that a child has a compelling need for positive regard, she becomes increasingly sensitive to or influenced by the attitudes of others. This sensitivity can lead to conditions of worth, which are imposed when significant others make their positive regard conditional — that is, when they give or withhold approval and support based on specific behaviors of the child. For example, such is the case when a father tells his son that bringing home a straight “A” report card will earn him an increase in his weekly allowance and excuse him from chores. Rogers states that conditions of worth imposed on a child are detrimental to his or her becoming a fully functioning person, because the child tries to attain standards set by others rather than to identify and attain what she or he really is or wants to be.
🔑 Definition — Conditions of Worth: Standards imposed by significant others that make positive regard conditional on specific behaviors, thoughts, or feelings; the child evaluates himself only in terms of those actions, thoughts, and feelings that received approval and support.
📌 Example: A father tells his son that bringing home a straight “A” report card will earn him an increase in his weekly allowance and excuse him from chores — this creates conditions of worth, where the child's sense of worth depends on meeting specific standards.
Unconditional Positive Regard
While it is obvious that no person is completely devoid of conditions of worth, Rogers feels that it is possible to give or receive unconditional positive regard irrespective of the worth placed on specific aspects of a person’s behavior. This means that a person is accepted and respected for what he or she is without any ifs, ands, or buts. Such unconditional positive regard is strikingly evident in a mother’s love for her child when — regardless of the child’s actions, thoughts, and feelings — he or she is genuinely loved and respected. She loves the child because it is her child, not because the child has fulfilled any specific condition or lived up to a specific expectation. Rogers’ emphasis on unconditional positive regard as the ideal approach to child rearing does not imply an absence of discipline, social constraints, or other forms of behavioral control. What it does mean is providing an atmosphere in which a child is valued and loved for exactly what he or she is — a precious human being.
🔑 Definition — Unconditional Positive Regard: Acceptance and respect for a person for what he or she is, without any conditions or expectations; valuing and loving the person regardless of specific behaviors, thoughts, or feelings.
📌 Example: A mother who loves her child regardless of the child's actions, thoughts, and feelings — she loves the child because it is her child, not because the child has fulfilled any specific condition or lived up to a specific expectation — demonstrates unconditional positive regard.
Conditions of Worth and Unconditional Positive Regard (Continued)
When children perceive themselves in such a way that no self-experience is more or less worthy of positive regard than any other, they are experiencing unconditional positive self-regard. This represents the ideal state where the individual values all aspects of themselves equally, without conditions.
📌 Example: A child who feels loved and accepted by their parents regardless of whether they get an A or a C on a test is experiencing unconditional positive regard and developing unconditional positive self-regard.
Experience of Threat and Process of Defense
When there is an inconsistency between the self-concept and an experience, the person experiences threat and anxiety. Threat occurs when a person becomes aware of an incongruence between some aspect of the self-concept and an actual experience. Anxiety is the emotional response to this threat — a state of uneasiness or tension that signals that the self-concept is in danger of being disrupted.
🔑 Definition — Threat: Awareness of an incongruence between some aspect of the self-concept and an actual experience.
🔑 Definition — Anxiety: The emotional response to threat; a state of uneasiness or tension that signals that the self-concept is in danger of being disrupted.
Defense Mechanisms
To protect the self-concept from threat and anxiety, the individual uses defense mechanisms. The two primary defense mechanisms in Rogers' theory are:
- Distortion — The experience is reinterpreted or distorted to make it consistent with the self-concept.
- Denial — The experience is simply denied or blocked from awareness entirely.
🔑 Definition — Defense Mechanisms: Processes used to protect the self-concept from threat and anxiety by distorting or denying experiences that are incongruent with the self-concept.
Fully Functioning Person
The fully functioning person is Rogers’ view of the Good Life. It is a term used by Rogers to designate individuals who are using their capacities and talents, realizing their potentials. The fully functioning person has five characteristics:
- Openness to experience — The ability to receive and process all experiences without distortion or denial.
- Experiential living — Living fully in each moment, being flexible and adaptable, allowing the self to grow and change with each new experience.
- Organismic trusting — Trusting one's own organismic valuing process as a guide for behavior, rather than relying on conditions of worth imposed by others.
- Experiential freedom — The subjective feeling of freedom to make choices and take responsibility for one's own life.
- Creativity or psychological maturity — The tendency to produce creative acts and live creatively, adapting to new conditions and contributing to the enhancement of others.
🔑 Definition — Fully Functioning Person: An individual who is using their capacities and talents, realizing their potentials; Rogers' view of the Good Life, characterized by openness to experience, experiential living, organismic trusting, experiential freedom, and creativity.
💡 Why this matters: The fully functioning person represents the ultimate goal of human development in Rogers' theory — understanding these five characteristics provides a clear picture of psychological health and maturity.
Rogers' View of Science and Research
Rogers placed a strong emphasis on scientific research to validate his theoretical concepts. He believed that personality theory should be empirically testable and supported by research evidence. Rogers and his colleagues conducted extensive research on self-concept, client-centered therapy outcomes, and the conditions necessary for therapeutic change.
Measuring Self Concept
Rogers and his associates developed methods for measuring the self-concept and the ideal self. A key measurement technique is the Q-sort technique, where individuals sort cards containing self-relevant statements into categories ranging from "most like me" to "least like me." This allows researchers to assess the discrepancy between the actual self-concept and the ideal self — a smaller discrepancy indicates better psychological adjustment.
Personality Organization
Rogers views personality as organized around the self-concept, which serves as the central organizing principle. The self-concept develops through interactions with the environment and significant others, and it becomes increasingly differentiated and complex over time. When there is congruence between the self-concept and actual experiences, the personality is well-integrated and the individual functions fully. Incongruence leads to threat, anxiety, and defensive functioning.
Client Centered Therapy
Client-centered therapy (also called person-centered therapy) is Rogers' approach to psychotherapy. The therapist creates a therapeutic environment characterized by three core conditions:
- Unconditional positive regard — The therapist accepts and values the client without conditions.
- Empathic understanding — The therapist accurately understands the client's internal frame of reference and communicates this understanding.
- Genuineness or congruence — The therapist is authentic and honest in the therapeutic relationship.
The goal of client-centered therapy is to help the client reduce incongruence between self-concept and experience, reduce conditions of worth, and move toward becoming a fully functioning person. The therapist does not direct or interpret but rather facilitates the client's own self-discovery and growth.
Psychotherapy and Gardening
Rogers uses the analogy of gardening to describe psychotherapy. Just as a gardener provides the optimal conditions for a plant to grow (sunlight, water, nutrients, soil), the therapist provides the optimal conditions (unconditional positive regard, empathy, genuineness) for the client to grow and actualize their potential. The therapist does not "make" the client grow but rather creates the environment in which growth naturally occurs.
Student Centered Teaching
Rogers applied his person-centered approach to education through student-centered teaching. In this approach, the teacher acts as a facilitator rather than a lecturer, creating a classroom environment characterized by:
- Unconditional positive regard for students
- Empathic understanding of students' perspectives
- Genuineness and authenticity
- Trust in students' natural tendency to learn and grow
The goal is to foster self-directed learning, creativity, and personal growth, rather than simply transmitting information.
Summary
Rogers' person-centered approach is a phenomenological, humanistic theory that emphasizes the subjective experience of the individual. Key concepts include the actualizing tendency, the self-concept, conditions of worth, unconditional positive regard, and the fully functioning person. Rogers applied his theory to psychotherapy (client-centered therapy), education (student-centered teaching), and scientific research. His positive view of human nature and emphasis on the therapeutic relationship have had a profound impact on clinical psychology, counseling, and education.
Evaluation
Rogers' theory has been praised for its positive view of human nature, its emphasis on the therapeutic relationship, its applicability to diverse settings (therapy, education, parenting), and its strong research foundation. Criticisms include that the theory is overly optimistic about human nature, that it neglects the role of unconscious processes, that it may be culturally biased (individualistic Western values), and that some concepts (like the actualizing tendency) are difficult to define operationally.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember from this lecture is that Rogers' person-centered approach is fundamentally phenomenological — it holds that behavior can only be understood from the individual's internal frame of reference, and that subjective experience is the key to understanding behavior. The actualizing tendency is the single master motive that energizes all behavior, driving the individual toward growth, enhancement, and self-actualization. The self-concept is the central organizing construct of personality, and when there is incongruence between the self-concept and actual experience, the individual experiences threat and anxiety and uses defense mechanisms. Conditions of worth, imposed by significant others who make positive regard conditional, are the primary source of psychological maladjustment, while unconditional positive regard fosters the development of a fully functioning person. The fully functioning person is characterized by openness to experience, experiential living, organismic trusting, experiential freedom, and creativity — representing the ultimate goal of human development in Rogers' theory.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the actualizing tendency and what are its key characteristics according to Rogers?
- What is the difference between conditions of worth and unconditional positive regard?
- What are the five characteristics of the fully functioning person?
- What are the three core conditions of client-centered therapy, and how does each contribute to therapeutic change?
- How does Rogers' phenomenological position explain why two people can observe the same event and later recall very different outcomes?
📘 Lecture 22 — ROGERS PERSON CENTERED APPROACH
(Client Centered Approach or Client Centered Therapy / Self Theory of Personality)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores Carl Rogers' phenomenological and humanistic theory of personality, centered on the individual's subjective experience and innate drive toward growth. It covers the core concepts of self, the actualizing tendency, conditions of worth, and the process of becoming a fully functioning person, along with Rogers' revolutionary person-centered therapy. Understanding this approach is critical for grasping how a supportive, non-judgmental environment can facilitate profound personality change and psychological well-being.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the biographical sketch of Carl Rogers and his core concepts: the actualizing tendency, phenomenological position, and the concept of self. It then explains the need for positive regard, conditions of worth, and unconditional positive regard, followed by the experience of threat, anxiety, and defense mechanisms. The lecture details the five characteristics of the fully functioning person, Rogers' view of science and the Q-sort method for measuring self-concept, personality disorganization, and the evolution of client-centered to person-centered therapy, including an analogy to gardening and student-centered teaching.
📝 Lecture Summary
1-Biographical Sketch
2-Actualizing tendency 3-Rogers phenomenological position 4-Concept of self 5-Need for positive regard 6-Conditions of worth 7-Unconditional positive regard
Rogers' theory is phenomenological, meaning a person’s behavior is understood by observing their internal frame of reference. To know why an individual thinks, feels, and behaves, one must see how that person perceives and interprets the world. It is also humanistic, emphasizing the positive aspects of life, free choices, and personal growth. The core motive is the actualizing tendency, an innate need to survive, grow, and enhance one’s self. The fully functioning person is Rogers' view of the "good life," designating individuals who are using their capacities and talents and realizing their potential.
🔑 Definition — Actualizing Tendency: The innate, singular master motive to actualize, maintain, and enhance oneself. 🔑 Definition — Fully Functioning Person: An individual who is using their capacities and talents, realizing their potential, and moving toward complete knowledge of themselves and their full range of experiences. 📌 Example: To understand the personality of Pakistani students, one must study their frame of reference and empathize with how they think, feel, and behave by putting oneself in their position.
8-Experience of threat and process of defense
• Threat • Anxiety
In Rogers’ theory, threat exists when a person recognizes an incongruity between their self-concept (and its incorporated conditions of worth) and their actual experience. Experiences that are incongruent with the self-concept are perceived as threatening and are kept from entering awareness. If an individual views himself as an honest person and behaves dishonestly, he is in a state of threat. Anxiety is the emotional response to this threat, signaling that the organized self-structure is in danger of becoming disorganized. The process of defense is the behavioral response of the organism to threat, with the goal of maintaining the current self-structure through perceptual distortion or denial of the experience.
💡 Why this matters: This explains why people often resist changing their self-image, even when evidence contradicts it. The defensive process protects the personality from fragmentation.
🔑 Definition — Threat: A state of incongruity between one's self-concept and actual experience. 🔑 Definition — Anxiety: An emotional response to threat that signals the self-structure is in danger of disorganization. 📌 Example: A student who receives a grade of "F" can maintain her self-concept as a good student by saying "The professor has unfair grading practices" or "I just had bad luck," which is a form of rationalization (a defense mechanism).
9-Defense mechanisms
Rogers refers to defense mechanisms like rationalization, where an individual selectively perceives or distorts experiences to protect the self-concept. For example, a student getting an "F" might blame the professor's unfair grading rather than accept the failure as congruent with her self-image.
10-Fully functioning person
Five characteristics 1-Openness to experience 2-Experiential living 3-Organismic trusting 4-Experiential freedom 5-Creativity or psychological maturity
Rogers specifies five major personality characteristics common to fully functioning people:
- Openness to experience: The polar opposite of defensiveness. Individuals are able to listen to themselves, experience their feelings without threat, and admit them to awareness even if they don't act on them.
- Existential living: The quality of living fully in each moment. Each moment is perceived as new and different, and what a person will be in the next moment grows out of that moment and cannot be predicted in advance.
- Organismic trusting: In decision-making, the fully functioning person trusts their own inner experiences and feelings as a guide, rather than relying on external codes of social norms or the judgment of others.
- Experiential freedom: The subjective sense that one is free to live one's life in any way they choose, able to play a responsible part in shaping their world, even though behavior is influenced by biological makeup and past experiences.
- Creativity: A person involved in the "good life" will be the type from whom creative products (ideas, projects, actions) and creative living emerge.
11-Rogers view of science and research
Rogers is strongly committed to phenomenology as a basis for developing a science of persons. This refers to a disciplined effort to understand the essence of a person’s subjective experience—specifically, how people come to know and understand their world and themselves.
12-Measuring self concept
The Q Sort: Developed by William Stephenson (1953), this is a method of studying one's views about oneself. The subject is given a deck of cards with statements (e.g., "I am an aggressive person") and must sort them into categories from "most like me" to "least like me" according to a forced distribution. Research-oriented Rogerians have subjects do this twice: a self-sort (describing themselves as they are now) and an ideal-sort (describing the kind of person they would most like to be). The product-moment correlation coefficient is used to show the degree of congruence or divergence between the self-concept and ideal self-concept.
📐 Formula: Q-sort correlation (product-moment r) → Measures the degree of congruence between a person's self-concept and their ideal self-concept. 📌 Example: A patient with a low correlation between her self-sort and ideal-sort would be seen as having low self-esteem and significant incongruence, which therapy aims to resolve.
13-Personality organization
Personality disorganization and psychopathology occur when the self is unable to defend against threatening experiences. Persons undergoing such disorganization manifest bizarre, irrational, or "crazy" behaviors. Rogers posits that psychotic behavior is often congruent with the denied aspects of experience, rather than with the self-concept. For example, a person who has kept sexual impulses under rigid control may make obvious sexual moves toward others. The goal of therapy is to reestablish a harmonious relationship between the self-concept and the total organism.
14-Client centered therapy
With his 1951 book Client-Centered Therapy, Rogers emphasized entering the clients’ world of subjective experience and focusing on their perceptions. This evolved from a "nondirective" technique to a focus on the relationship between therapist and client as the most important aspect underlying personality change. Later, the term evolved to "person-centered therapy" to more accurately reflect the focus on the relationship rather than techniques.
15-Psychotherapy and gardening
Rogers draws an analogy between person-centered therapy and gardening. Just as a gardener provides the conditions for a plant to grow (water, fertilizer, pest control), the therapist provides the conditions for a person to grow (empathy, unconditional positive regard, genuineness). The question is the same: "What are the effective conditions for growth?"
16-Student centered teaching
Rogers views the education system as based on faulty assumptions: that the learner must be given huge amounts of information without active participation. Instead, the teacher is a facilitator of education who creates an atmosphere conducive to learning. This is a student-centered teaching approach emphasizing freedom to learn.
17-Summary
Rogers holds that the innermost core of human nature is essentially benevolent, purposive, and trustworthy. All human motives are subsumed under the actualizing tendency. His theory is phenomenological, holding that only subjective reality matters. Key elements in self-concept development are the need for positive regard, conditions of worth, and unconditional positive regard. Threat arises from incongruence, leading to perceptual distortion and denial. When incongruence becomes too great, psychopathology results. The fully functioning person is open to experience, trusts it, and moves toward self-actualization.
18-Evaluation
- It is phenomenological and humanistic.
- It focuses on unconditional positive regard.
- It introduces person-centered therapy.
- It applies a student-centered teaching approach, where the teacher is a facilitator.
- His theory can be applied to education, marriage, and family.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The single most critical concept in Rogers' theory is the actualizing tendency, the innate drive to grow and fulfill one's potential. Personality development hinges on the self-concept, and incongruence between the self-concept and actual experience leads to threat, anxiety, and defensiveness (through distortion or denial). The conditions for healthy development are unconditional positive regard and the removal of conditions of worth. The fully functioning person is characterized by openness to experience, existential living, organismic trusting, experiential freedom, and creativity. Finally, person-centered therapy emphasizes the quality of the therapeutic relationship—not techniques—as the primary vehicle for healing and growth.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "actualizing tendency" and how does it differ from Freud's view of human motivation?
- Explain the difference between "conditions of worth" and "unconditional positive regard." How do they affect self-concept development?
- What is a "threat" in Rogers' theory, and what two defense mechanisms does he describe for dealing with it?
- List and briefly describe the five characteristics of a "fully functioning person."
- What is the Q-sort technique, and what does a high correlation between a person's self-sort and ideal-sort indicate?