π Lecture 22 β The Behavioral Assessment Through Interviews, Inventories and Check Lists
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental principles and methods of behavioral assessment, a cornerstone of behavioral therapy. It defines key behavioral concepts like respondents and operants, outlines the core tasks of behavioral assessment, and details how it differs from traditional assessment through sample versus sign approaches and functional analysis. The lecture then provides a comprehensive examination of three primary assessment methods: behavioral interviewing, self-report inventories, and rating scales, along with technological advancements in the field.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining two broad categories of behavior: respondents and operants. It then outlines the five basic tasks of the behavior therapist in assessment: identification, classification, prediction, specification, and evaluation. The behavioral tradition is contrasted with traditional assessment through sample vs sign perspectives and functional analysis, including the SORC model. Finally, the lecture details methods of behavioral assessment, specifically behavioral interviewing, inventories and checklists, rating scales, and concludes with technological advancements in the field.
π Lecture Summary
BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT
Careful assessment is at the heart of all clinical interventions, especially when using the behavioral theoretical model. The emphasis on making a careful assessment of the patient and their life circumstances before, during, and after treatment is one of the most distinguishing features of clinical procedures.
DEFINITION OF BEHAVIOR
There are two broad categories of behavior recognized by most behavior therapists: respondents and operants. Respondents are antecedent-controlled behaviors that function in a reflexive manner. They are the most stereotyped kinds of behaviors, with relatively fixed patterns across populations and within individuals. Respondents include somatic reflexes, emotional reactions and other responses of smooth muscles, glands, and the heart, and sensations. For example, a sudden unexpected noise may cause a person to hear the noise (an auditory sensation), to jump (a somatic reflex), and to be afraid momentarily (an emotional reaction). Operants include actions, instrumental responses of smooth muscles, glands, and the heart, and cognitions. Whereas respondents are antecedent-controlled, operants are consequence-controlled. In operant behavior, the patient's behavior produces changes in their world.
ASSESSMENT TASKS
The basic tasks of the behavior therapist in performing an assessment are to identify, classify, prophesy (predict), specify, and evaluate.
Identify: The therapist needs to identify all antecedents affecting target behaviors, the respondents and operants of concern, the consequences following operants, those consequences that could be programmed into therapy, and the setting events influencing the patient's behavior to get a full overview of the biological, physiological, and anatomical concomitants of the clinical picture.
Classify: Behaviors are grouped into behavioral excesses (need to be weakened or removed), behavioral deficits (need to be strengthened or added), behavioral anomalies (inherently inappropriate), and behavioral assets (valued by the patient or others and present in their repertoire). This classification is crucial for planning treatment.
Prophesy (prediction): Behavior therapists tend to use actuarial data as a basis for predictions. More commonly, they attempt to control therapeutically the present target behaviors rather than predict how a patient might react to a hypothetical future situation.
Specify: Specifying precise goals, methods of intervention, and therapeutic agents is an important part of behavioral assessment. This corresponds to the βrecommendationsβ section of a traditional psychological evaluation. The goal is to specify clearly enough so that any informed clinician could carry out the prescribed procedures.
Evaluate: This final task is broken into three subcategories: process evaluation (changes during treatment), outcome evaluation (status at treatment termination), and follow-up evaluation (status after a specified period following treatment).
THE BEHAVIORAL TRADITION
Behavioral assessment differs from traditional assessment in three broad ways.
Sample Versus Sign: When test responses are viewed as a sample, one assumes they parallel how a person is likely to behave in a non-test situation. When responses are viewed as signs, an inference is made that the performance is an indirect or symbolic manifestation of some other characteristic. Traditional assessment has mostly used a sign approach, while behavioral assessment exclusively uses the sample approach, focusing on how well the assessment device samples the behaviors and situations of interest.
β οΈ Functional Analysis: Traceable to Skinner (1953), functional analysis means exact analyses are made of the stimuli that precede a behavior and the consequences that follow it. To change an undesirable behavior, the clinician must: 1) Identify the stimulus conditions that precipitate it and 2) Determine the reinforcements that follow. Key considerations for behavior assessors include:
- Behavior must be described in observable, measurable terms.
- Assessment ignores internal determinants like βneedsβ and focuses on the target behavior.
- A functional analysis follows the sequence: stimulus β behavior β consequence.
- Most therapists have broadened this to include organismic variables (physical, physiological, or cognitive characteristics of the individual) like attitudes and beliefs that are important for conceptualizing the problem and treatment.
π Definition β SORC Model: A model for conceptualizing a clinical problem from a behavioral perspective. π Formula: S (stimulus/antecedent conditions) β O (organismic variables) β R (response/problematic behavior) β C (consequences) π Example: For a client with social anxiety, S could be being asked to speak in a meeting, O could be their belief that they will embarrass themselves, R could be rapid breathing and avoidance, and C could be the temporary relief from avoiding the situation. Clinicians use this model to guide information gathering and intervention planning.
BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT AS AN ONGOING PROCESS
Behavioral assessment is not a one-shot evaluation before treatment. It is an ongoing process that occurs before, during, and after treatment. It informs the initial selection of treatment strategies, provides feedback on treatment efficacy, allows evaluation of overall effectiveness, and highlights situational factors that may lead to recurrence of the problematic behavior(s).
π‘ Why this matters: This ongoing nature allows for continuous refinement of the treatment plan based on real-time data, making therapy more adaptable and effective.
METHODS OF BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT
A wide range of methods is used in behavioral assessment, applicable across the age range and for different areas of functioning. Information can be drawn from different sources (clinicians, clients, significant others) and settings (home, school, work). A critical feature is the emphasis on behaviors, cognitions, or physiology that occur in specific situations. Three broad classes are described: behavioral interviewing, self-report inventories, and rating scales.
BEHAVIORAL INTERVIEWING
In contrast to many other clinical interviews, behavioral interviewing is used to obtain information for formulating a functional analysis of behavior. These interviews focus on describing relationships among antecedents, behaviors, and consequences. They are more directive than other interviews, allowing for detailed descriptions of problem behaviors and the patient's environment. Kratochwill (1985) suggests a four-step problem-solving format:
- Problem identification: Identify a specific problem and select procedures to measure target behaviors.
- Problem analysis: Assess the client's resources and contexts where behaviors are likely to occur.
- Assessment planning: Establish a plan with ongoing procedures to collect data relevant to assessment and intervention.
- Treatment evaluation: Outline strategies to assess treatment success, including pre- and post-assessment procedures.
A key reason behavioral interviews are more directive is that clients often describe difficulties in trait terms (e.g., "anxious," "depressed"). The clinician must translate these into specific, observable behaviors. For example, "being anxious" might mean breathing rapidly, sweating, increased heart rate, and avoiding specific situations.
π Example: The lecture provides an interview excerpt where a client describes conflict with a roommate. The interviewer asks for a specific disagreement, uses a 1-10 rating scale for anger and tension, and probes for the timing of these feelings (e.g., "When do you feel the most angry?... When you were walking into the room. Before? After he didn't turn down the TV?"). This helps quantify and specify the problem behavior.
An excellent example is found in the work of Russell Barkley on ADHD. The interview generates information on specific parent-child interactions related to defiant behavior. It reviews situations like temper tantrums, determining precisely what the behaviors look like, where they occur (e.g., while the parent is on the phone), and where they do not (e.g., when the child is playing alone).
In sum, behavioral interviewing is the first step in a comprehensive assessment. It is more direct than unstructured interviews and focuses on the occurrence of specific behaviors. However, it is only moderately reliable, and we know little about its validity.
INVENTORIES AND CHECKLISTS
Behavioral clinicians use a variety of self-report techniques to identify behaviors, emotional responses, and perceptions of the environment. The Fear Survey Schedule lists 51 potentially fear-arousing situations for patients to rate. Other frequently used inventories include the Rathus Assertiveness Schedule, the Beck Depression Inventory, the Youth Self Report, and the Marital Conflict Form.
Notably absent from this list are instruments with a psychiatric diagnostic orientation. Historically, this was a conscious omission, as behavioral assessors found little merit in psychiatric classification. Their tests are oriented toward assessing specific behavioral deficits, behavioral inappropriateness, and behavioral assets. The focus is behaviorβclients are asked about specific actions, feelings, or thoughts.
Inventories have also been developed to assess a person's perception of the social environment (Insel & Moos, 1974). These scales assess environments in terms of opportunities for relationships, personal growth, and systems maintenance and change. Separate scales exist for work, family, classrooms, wards, and others.
RATING SCALES
Rating scales and behavior checklists provide information on a wider range of an individual's behavior over a longer period than direct observation.
Rating scales have been developed for children, adolescents, and adults. For children, it is important to obtain reports from different informants (parents, teachers, peers) in different settings (home, school) because children's behavior can differ critically. Studies find only modest levels of agreement among different informants and between informants and the children themselves. This highlights the importance of situational factors and that different informants offer unique perspectives.
The most widely used rating system for child and adolescent psychopathology is from Achenbach and his colleagues. This system integrates data from parents (the Child Behavior Checklist or CBCL), teachers (the Teacher Report Form or TRF), and adolescents (the Youth Self-Report).
For adults, rating scales exist for specific disorders (e.g., the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, the Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale) and broader scales (e.g., the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, the Global Assessment Scale). For instance, the Yale-Brown scale requires interviewers to rate a client's level of distress or impairment around obsessions and compulsions from 0 to 4. The Hamilton Scale rates symptoms like insomnia and depressed mood on 3- to 5-point scales. The total score from such scales is used as an index of severity.
These rating scales have sound psychometric properties with good internal consistency and test-retest reliability. Due to imperfect agreement among informants for child scales, Achenbach and McConaughy (1997) have formulated a decision tree for assessors to follow based on different informant responses. These scales are currently used more frequently in clinical research than in practice.
TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENT IN BEHAVIOR ASSESSMENT
Technological advances, as outlined by Haynes (1998), are changing behavioral assessment involving observation:
- Laptop and hand-held computers facilitate coding of observational data by assessors.
- Hand-held computers can be assigned to clients for real-time self-monitoring data.
- Hand-held computers can be programmed to prompt clients to respond at specified times.
- Data from these computers can be loaded onto other computers with greater capacity to be aggregated, scored, and analyzed.
Behavioral assessment emphasizes direct assessments of problematic behavior, antecedent conditions, and consequences. It is an ongoing process throughout treatment. Common methods include interviews, naturalistic observation, checklists, and role playing. The reliability and validity of observation can be affected by the complexity of behavior, observer training, and reactivity.
π‘ Why this matters: These technological advances allow for more precise, real-time, and ecologically valid data collection, reducing reliance on retrospective self-report and improving the accuracy of functional analysis.
β Key Takeaways
Behavioral assessment is defined by its focus on observable behavior and the functional analysis of antecedents and consequences, rather than on inferring internal traits. The core tasks of assessment are to identify, classify, predict, specify, and evaluate behavior, with a strong emphasis on continuous evaluation before, during, and after treatment. The SORC (Stimulus-Organismic-Response-Consequences) model provides a key framework for conceptualizing clinical problems. Among the methods of assessment, behavioral interviewing is the first, directive step in formulating a functional analysis, while self-report inventories like the Beck Depression Inventory and behavior checklists like the Achenbach scales provide standardized, reliable measures across different settings and informants.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two broad categories of behavior recognized by behavior therapists, and how do they differ in terms of what controls them?
- According to the SORC model, what does each letter stand for, and how is this model used in clinical practice?
- How does a "sample" approach to test interpretation differ from a "sign" approach, and which approach is used in behavioral assessment?
- Describe the four-step problem-solving format suggested by Kratochwill (1985) for conducting a behavioral interview.
- Why is there often only modest agreement among different informants (e.g., parents, teachers) when rating a child's behavior, and how does this impact the assessment process?