📘 Lecture 7 — The Humanistic Approach and the Cognitive Approach
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces two major theoretical perspectives in psychology—the humanistic approach and the cognitive approach. It explains how humanistic psychology emerged as a "third force" against psychoanalysis and behaviorism, emphasizing free will, self-actualization, and personal growth, while the cognitive approach shifted focus to mental processes, information processing, and the role of mediating factors in understanding behavior.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the basic assumptions, central themes, and emergence of the humanistic approach, along with detailed theories from Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow. It then transitions to the cognitive approach, discussing its historical context, computer metaphor, key contributors like Piaget and Chomsky, and applications including emotion, social behavior, behavior modification, and cognitive therapies for depression and irrational beliefs.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Humanistic Approach
The humanistic approach emerged in the 1950s and 1960s as an alternative to psychoanalysis and behaviorism. Psychologists felt that Freud focused on darker unconscious forces and Skinner only on observable reinforcement, leaving a void in understanding human nature. Humanistic psychology became known as "the third force" because it emphasized the conscious mind, free will, human dignity, and the capacity for self-reflection and growth. This approach focuses on the idea that people are in control of their own lives, and it stresses the person, the self, and personal growth and development. It includes related orientations like existential and phenomenological psychology.
Basic Assumptions of the Humanistic Approach To understand behavior, we must consider the subjective experience of the person. Neither past experience nor current circumstances constrain the person's behavior. Unlike the psychodynamic approach (which stresses unconscious determinants) and the behaviorist approach (which focuses on external determinants), the humanistic approach is more optimistic, believing in a person's ability and will. Limiting ourselves to observable behavior ignores the thinking-feeling person and is dehumanizing. A key concept is free will: humans possess the ability to make decisions about their lives.
🔑 Definition — Free will: The belief that humans possess the ability to make decisions about their own lives.
Central Themes of Humanistic Approach Human beings are capable of shaping their own destiny. They can think, design their course of action, and follow it as they like. People can overcome or minimize environmental and intrinsic influences. The "here and now" is important, as is the "wholeness" or "completeness" of the personality, rather than its separate, disintegrated structural parts. The approach emphasizes an individual's freedom in directing their future, capacity for personal growth, intrinsic worth, and potential for self-fulfillment.
Emergence of the Humanistic Approach It emerged in reaction to the perceived limitations of psychodynamic theories (especially psychoanalysis) and the behaviorist way of understanding behavior. Individuals like Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow felt that the prevalent approaches could not adequately address the meaning of behavior and the nature of healthy growth. The founders asserted that people need a value system — a system of understanding or frame of orientation — through which life gets meaning and purpose.
Carl Rogers: (1902 – 1987)
Carl Rogers was one of the founders of the humanistic approach and one of the most influential therapists in the 20th century. Research even after his death showed he was cited by more therapists as a major influence than any other person in psychology, including Freud.
Rogers’ Approach This is primarily a clinical theory based on years of experience with clients. The theory emphasizes a single factor called the actualizing tendency — a built-in motivation present in every life form to develop its potentials to the fullest extent possible. Rogers had a person-centered approach, believing that the most powerful human drive is to become "fully functioning" , meaning a person becomes all that they are capable of.
🔑 Definition — Actualizing tendency: A built-in motivation present in every life form to develop its potentials to the fullest extent possible. 🔑 Definition — Fully functioning: A state where a person becomes all that they are capable of, experiencing optimal psychological adjustment, optimal psychological maturity, complete congruence, and complete openness to experience. 🔑 Definition — Congruence: A feeling of integration when the self and the ideal self match. 🔑 Definition — Incongruence: A feeling of conflict or unease experienced when there is a mismatch between the self and the ideal self.
Main Concepts The self is a fluid perceptual structure based on one's experience of one's own being. The ideal self is an individual's goals and aspirations. The phenomenal field is an individual's unique perception of the world. The actualizing tendency is the innate drive to grow and enhance capacities. The need for positive regard is a need for positive social contacts like love. Conditions of worth are restrictions imposed on self-expression in order to earn positive regard.
Defenses When there is incongruity between the real and the ideal self, defenses develop. Rogers talks about only two defenses:
- Denial: Blocking out the threatening situation altogether, which also includes what Freud called repression.
- Perceptual Distortion: Reinterpreting the situation so that it appears less threatening, similar to Freud's rationalization.
Neurotics and Psychosis Neurotics are apart from the real and the ideal self. As they become more incongruous, they face more threatening situations, higher anxiety levels, and use more defenses—creating a vicious cycle they cannot escape on their own. Psychosis occurs when a person's defenses are overwhelmed, and their sense of self becomes "shattered" into disconnected pieces, causing inconsistent behavior.
Carl Rogers’ Psychotherapy Carl Rogers is best known for his person-centered/client-centered/non-directive therapy (also called Rogerian Therapy). His main technique is "Reflection" — mirroring of emotional experiences. The aim is to help a person grow and self-actualize. Rogers maintained that the therapist must possess three qualities: congruence (genuineness and honesty), empathy (the ability to feel what the client feels), and respect (acceptance and unconditional positive regard towards the client).
Abraham Harold Maslow (1908-1970)
Abraham Maslow was an American psychologist and a leading exponent of the humanistic approach. He gave a comprehensive theory of motivation, finding the prevalent psychology at the time too pessimistic and negatively oriented.
Key Points of Maslow’s Theory Psychology should look at the positive side of human beings. People's needs are not low-level and base; humans have positive needs that may become neutral but will not turn negative. Needs motivate human action, and these needs are few in number.
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs This is a stage theory where needs at one level must be met for one to move to a higher order. The lowest/primary/base level needs are physiological needs, and the highest order needs are self-actualization needs.
The hierarchy, from lowest to highest, is:
- Physiological Needs (hunger, thirst)
- Safety Needs (security, protection)
- Love and Belongingness Needs (affection, relationships)
- Esteem Needs (respect, achievement)
- Self-Actualization Needs (fulfilling one's potential)
🔑 Definition — Self-Actualization: The most advanced human need based on the desire to grow and utilize one's potential up to the optimal level.
Categories of Needs Maslow categorized needs into two types:
- Deficiency Needs: Triggered by the absence of underlying requirements (e.g., physiological needs, love needs, esteem needs).
- Meta-needs: Based on a desire to grow rather than meet a deficiency, expressed in the need for self-actualization.
💡 Why this matters: This distinction explains that once basic survival needs are met, humans are motivated by higher, growth-oriented goals like creativity and purpose, not just by filling a lack.
Interactions and Needs of Behavior
- Physiological needs: Fulfilled through food; Pathologies → Over-eating, Anorexia.
- Safety needs: Fulfilled through a profession or job; Pathologies → Phobias.
- Love and belongingness: Fulfilled through marriage, friendship; Pathologies → Antisocial personality.
- Esteem needs: Fulfilled through awards, honors, scholarships; Pathologies → Depression.
- Self-actualization needs: Fulfilled through painting, writing, singing; Pathologies → Isolation, Alienation, Cynicism.
Criticism against Maslow’s theory Despite being comprehensive, the theory has been criticized. It is questionable whether these needs can be neatly ordered for all cases, and there is little empirical evidence to support Maslow's ranking of needs.
Extensions of Humanistic Approach
This approach extends into Existential Psychology (Jean Paul Sartre, Rollo May), Frankl’s Logotherapy, and Positive Psychology (Martin Seligman).
Cognitive Approach
From the 1920s through the 1960s, behaviorism dominated U.S. psychology. However, psychologists eventually moved away from strict behaviorism and became interested in cognition — a term for all mental processes involved in acquiring, storing, and using knowledge, including perception, memory, thinking, problem solving, imagining, and language. This shift, known as the cognitive revolution, had a profound influence on psychology, leading to the field of cognitive psychology.
🔑 Definition — Cognition: All the mental processes involved in acquiring, storing, and using knowledge (e.g., perception, memory, thinking, language).
Cognitive processes vs. computer The invention of the computer provided a metaphor for the human mind. Computer hardware was likened to the brain, and computer programs modeled how information from the environment is input, stored, and retrieved to produce a response. Based on this metaphor, psychologists formulated information-processing models of human thought and behavior.
Other Influences on the Cognitive Revolution The pioneering work of Jean Piaget on how children think inspired the study of cognition. He theorized that children advance through a predictable series of cognitive stages. The study of language also contributed, as Noam Chomsky (1959) criticized B.F. Skinner's behaviorist account of language. Chomsky argued that children start speaking at roughly the same age and proceed through similar stages without explicit teaching or reward, suggesting the human capacity for learning language is innate and that the brain is "hardwired" for language—a serious blow to behaviorist assumptions.
🔑 Definition — Cognition: Means "the known," "knowledge," or "the process of knowing."
The cognitive approach emphasizes thoughts, feelings, thinking, values, and expectations as factors that determine personality.
Main Emphasis For a proper understanding of behavior, the cognitive approach emphasizes mediating processes — processes that lie between environmental stimuli and the behavioral response. It focuses on how we remember, how information processing takes place, and how decision-making appraisals are done. Unlike behaviorism, this theory gives equal importance to the internal state of the person and environmental events. Internal events are referred to as "Mediators" or "Meditational Processes".
Areas of Special Interest The cognitive approach focuses on emotions, social behavior, and behavior modification. It is considered a hybrid science because it includes elements of psychology, linguistics, computer science, and physiology.
🔑 Definition — Mediating processes: The internal mental processes that lie between environmental stimuli and the behavioral response.
Elements of Cognitive Model Experiments on apes by Wolfgang Kohler discovered the use of insight in problem solving. Edward Tolman introduced the concept of cognitive maps (relationships between stimuli), arguing that a person can learn without showing an apparent response—an association between stimulus and response is not necessary. Both Kohler and Tolman laid the foundation for the cognitive approach by showing that internal processes are essential in understanding behavior and that mediators work in a systematic, organized way, not through trial and error.
Emotions and Cognitive Approach
The pioneer in this area was Stanley Schacter (1971). According to him, emotions result from both physiological arousal and cognitive appraisal (evaluation) of the situation. Arousal comes first and is general in nature. To understand what one is feeling (the label of the emotion and the meaning of the reaction), the arousal is appraised cognitively.
Schacter’s Theory of Emotions Schacter's theory can be visualized as: a stimulus (e.g., an incoming car) → perception of the stimulus → physiological arousal (e.g., pounding heart, perspiration) → cognitive appraisal/label (e.g., "I am afraid") → felt emotion (e.g., fear). The emotional experience is thus a combination of bodily arousal and cognitive interpretation.
Richard Lazarus (1984) maintained that emotional experience cannot be understood without understanding how environmental events are evaluated. Emotion leads to cognition, and cognition in turn leads to emotional experience.
🔑 Definition — Cognitive appraisal: The evaluation or interpretation of a situation that gives a label and meaning to the physiological arousal, determining the specific emotion felt.
Cognitive Approach to Social Behavior
John Dollard and Neal Miller (1950) first emphasized the importance of cognitive processes in determining behavior.
Kelly’s Personal Construct Theory Developed by George Kelly (1955), this theory emphasizes how a person cognitively constructs their world. People develop their behavior cognitively towards their world and develop attitudes and opinions called 'personal constructs'. These constructs then develop into a person's 'belief system'.
Mischel’s Cognitive Social Personality Theory Walter Mischel, a student of George Kelly, proposed that how a person responds to environmental stimuli depends on five variables:
- Competencies: What the person knows, what they can do, and how well they generate cognitive/behavioral outcomes.
- Encoding Strategies: Ways of processing information.
- Expectations: Anticipating the likely outcome (mainly positive).
- Personal Values: The importance of one's beliefs, stimuli, people, and events.
- Self-regulatory System: Maintaining rules for better performance by setting goals and evaluating performances.
Bandura’s Cognitive-Social Learning Theory Given by Albert Bandura (1986), this theory combines the rules of learning with an emphasis on complex human interactions in social settings. It uses a model of reciprocal determinism involving behavior, person (cognitions), and environmental events.
Observational Learning This is a main component of social-learning theory where a person makes changes in their own behavior by watching or imitating others (a model, superstar, or cartoon character). It is effective for acquiring skills, attitudes, and beliefs simply by watching others.
Cantor’s Social Intelligence Theory Given by Nancy Cantor and her colleagues (1987), this theory refers to the expertise a person uses in different life situations or tasks. It explains several types of individual differences, including:
- Choice of Life Goal: Giving priority to the most important goal at a particular point in life (e.g., a student prioritizing "good grades").
- Use of ‘knowledge’ in social interactions: Using life experiences and expertise in problem solving.
Cognitive Approach in Behavior Modification
Negative and unacceptable behavior is modified through constructive strategies. According to this approach, a person's beliefs and attitudes affect their motivation and behavior. To modify behavior, reinforcement techniques are used. For attaining a desired goal, realistic strategies are used with continuous feedback.
Altering the Belief System Psychologists view that psychological problems arise from the way people perceive themselves in relation to the people they interact with. The main focus of the therapist is to alter the irrational belief system of a person.
Cause of Psychological Illness Psychological illness is caused by three types of faulty thinking:
- Illogical Reasoning/Beliefs (e.g., "Being perfect in every way")
- Rigid Rules that occur automatically after repeating several times (e.g., "I must obey the authority")
- False Premises (e.g., "If I can do whatever is required, then I'll be recognized by everyone")
Cognitive Theory for Depression Aaron Beck formulated a therapy for depression patients. The therapist helps the depressive person change faulty patterns of thinking through problem-solving techniques. Beck believed depression reoccurs because negative thoughts occur automatically, and the patient is often unaware of them.
The therapist uses four tactics:
- Challenging the patient's ill beliefs
- Evaluating the cause of depression
- Attributing the cause to the environmental situation/event, not to the person's incompetencies
- Finding alternative and effective solutions for complex problems
Rational-Emotive Behavior Therapy Developed by Albert Ellis (1962, 1977), this therapy focuses on altering irrational beliefs into more acceptable ways. Clients are forbidden to use words like "should," "must," and "ought." Confrontation techniques are used to change attitudes through rational reasoning. The task is to protect self-worth and the potential to be self-actualized by blocking irrational thinking patterns.
In short, in recent decades, researchers have made significant breakthroughs in understanding the brain, nervous system, mental processes, consciousness, memory, intelligence, motivation, and the benefits of psychotherapy.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the humanistic approach is an optimistic "third force" focusing on free will, subjective experience, and the actualizing tendency, with Rogers emphasizing congruence and unconditional positive regard for full functioning, and Maslow presenting a hierarchy of needs culminating in self-actualization. The cognitive approach, sparked by the computer metaphor and challenges from Piaget and Chomsky, focuses on mediating mental processes and information processing between stimulus and response. Key cognitive models include Schacter's two-factor theory of emotion, Kelly's personal constructs, and Bandura's observational learning. Finally, cognitive therapies by Beck and Ellis focus on altering irrational beliefs and faulty thinking patterns to treat psychological disorders like depression.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main defenses Rogers identified, and how do they relate to Freudian concepts?
- According to Maslow's hierarchy, what needs must be met before an individual can be motivated by self-actualization?
- How does Schacter's theory of emotion explain the difference between experiencing fear and excitement?
- What was the "cognitive revolution," and what major developments (e.g., computer metaphor, language studies) contributed to it?
- What are the four main tactics a therapist uses in Beck's cognitive therapy for depression?
📘 Lecture 8 — Research Methods in Psychology (I)
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the scientific method as it applies to psychology, outlining its systematic, predefined steps for objective investigation. It then categorizes and explains non-manipulative (descriptive) research methods, including observation, correlation, surveys, and unobtrusive measures, which are used to study behavior as it naturally occurs without interference.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the scientific nature of psychology and the systematic steps of the scientific method: identifying a research problem, reviewing literature, formulating hypotheses, designing and conducting research, analyzing data, and drawing conclusions. It then delineates two broad categories of research methods—non-manipulative/descriptive and manipulative/experimental—before diving into specific descriptive methods: observation (with and without intervention), correlation research, surveys, and unobtrusive measures of behavior such as archival data and physical traces.
📝 Lecture Summary
Scientific Nature of Psychology
The lecture establishes that psychology is a science because it uses the scientific method, a systematic, predefined series of steps to ensure objectivity. The method is systematic, meaning it follows an organized, predefined sequence that cannot be altered. Objectivity means the researcher’s personal biases do not interfere.
🔑 Definition — Science: An approach using the scientific method for the observation, description, understanding, and prediction of any phenomenon. 🔑 Definition — Scientific Method: The procedure employing a systematic, predefined series of steps for attaining optimal efficiency, accuracy, and objectivity in investigating the problem of interest.
Steps of Scientific Method
The scientific method follows a strict sequence: identifying a research problem, reviewing related literature, formulating hypotheses, designing and conducting the research, analyzing data, and drawing conclusions.
- Identifying the research problem: This is the most important step, where the area of interest is specified. Problems can be identified through personal interest, brainstorming, scientific developments, or knowledge.
- Review of the related literature: Searching for research findings related to the problem to see how others approached similar issues and to get an idea of the probable outcome.
- Formulation of hypotheses: A hypothesis is a speculative statement about the relationship between two or more variables. Reviewing literature helps formulate these hypotheses.
- Designing and conducting the research: The research is conducted using strategies like questionnaires, mail interviews, telephonic interviews, or face-to-face interviews. A variety of research designs are available.
- Analysis of data: Data is tabulated using statistical methods to see if the findings prove or disprove the hypotheses.
- Drawing conclusions: After statistical analysis, a decision is made about the rejection or acceptance of the hypothesis.
🔑 Definition — Hypothesis: A speculative statement about the relationship between two or more variables.
Identifying a Research Problem
Research problems can be identified through several avenues: personal interest and observation, brainstorming, review of related literature, technological advancements, and a request from concerned quarters.
Non-manipulative/descriptive Methods
These are methods where the phenomenon is studied as it exists in nature. The researcher acts as a passive recorder and does not interfere with events.
Manipulative/Experimental Methods
In these methods, the researcher exercises control over variables and events. They may introduce or withhold variables. These methods are used for determining cause and effect relationships. This is responsible for the scientific nature of psychology.
Descriptive Research Methods
a) Observation
Systematic observation is used, where the phenomenon is observed, recorded, and analyzed. There are two main types:
- Observation without Intervention
- Observation with Intervention
Observation without Intervention:
- Naturalistic Observation: The phenomenon is studied in its natural setting without any interference from the observer. The observer may use narrative records, field notes, or audio/video equipment.
Observation with Intervention: The observer intervenes to create a situation that occurs infrequently, test the impact of variables, or gain access to an otherwise inaccessible situation.
- Participant Observation: The observer becomes an active part of the situation. This can be disguised (participants don't know they are being observed) or undisguised (participants know the observer's role).
- Structured Observation: Used when a situation is infrequent or inaccessible. The observer may "create" or initiate the situation. The level of control is less than in other techniques. It is mostly used by clinical and developmental psychologists.
- Field Experiments: Experiments conducted in a natural setting with far less control than in a laboratory. One or more independent variables are manipulated. A confederate is an assistant who behaves in a pre-planned manner to initiate an experimental condition.
b) Correlation Research
This method is used for identifying predictive relationships among naturally occurring variables. A correlation exists when two different measures of the same individuals, objects, or events vary together.
🔑 Definition — Correlation: A statistical concept that exists when two different measures of the same individuals, objects, or events vary together.
📌 Example: The relationship between I.Q. score and academic achievement, or entry test marks and academic achievement.
Nature of Correlation:
- Positive Correlation
- Negative Correlation
- Zero Correlation
Measures in Correlation Research:
- Questionnaires: In-person, mailed, or via internet.
- Interviews: Personal and face-to-face, or telephonic.
- Official Record: Official statistics, raw data, crime records.
💡 Critical Reminder: Correlation is not causation. Just because two variables are related does not mean one causes the other.
c) Surveys
This is the most frequently used method for obtaining information quickly and evaluating public opinion, interests, likes, and dislikes. It is relatively cheap and easy to use. Surveys consist of presenting a series of questions or statements for participants to respond to.
Sources of data/information in Surveys:
- Questionnaires (in person, mailed, internet)
- Interviews (personal, telephonic)
- Newspaper Surveys
Steps involved in conducting survey research:
- Conceiving the problem: The purpose of the study must be carefully thought out and precisely defined.
- Designing the instrument: Decide the most effective way to gather information (e.g., mailed questionnaires, telephonic interviews, internet).
- Sampling the population: Obtaining a representative sample is crucial. Each individual must have an equal chance of being selected.
- Conducting interviews: A poor interviewer can bias results. Experiments suggest the best interviewers are female, at least 21 years old, unbiased, and good listeners.
- Interpreting the results: Errors in questionnaires, statistical methods, and investigator subjectivity can bias the results.
d) Unobtrusive Measures of Behavior
These are indirect ways of data collection where the person of interest may not be present. They can supplement or replace direct observation when it's not possible.
Types of Unobtrusive Measures:
- Archival data: Already existing records, documents, literature, newspaper items, photographs, movies, biographies, etc. Example: Using newspaper records to study crime rates over 20 years.
- Physical Traces: Remains, remnants, or products of past behavior are used as evidence. These can be:
- Use traces: Cues to the use or nonuse of objects (e.g., wall chalking, graffiti, milk cartons in garbage bags).
- Products: Study of tools, weapons, or sculptures (used less frequently than physical traces).
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that psychology is a science because it follows the systematic, objective steps of the scientific method. The two main categories of research are non-manipulative (descriptive) and manipulative (experimental), with the latter being key for establishing cause-and-effect. Descriptive methods—naturalistic observation, correlation, surveys, and unobtrusive measures—are used to study phenomena as they naturally exist without manipulation. A crucial distinction to remember is that correlation does not equal causation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six steps of the scientific method in psychology?
- What is the key difference between "non-manipulative/descriptive" and "manipulative/experimental" research methods?
- In observation, what is the difference between "observation without intervention" and "observation with intervention"?
- What is a hypothesis, and how is it related to the review of literature?
- What are the two main types of unobtrusive measures of behavior, and provide one example of each.
📘 Lecture 9 — Research Methods in Psychology (II)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of research methods in psychology, covering content analysis, focus groups, and meta-analysis as non-experimental approaches. It then provides an in-depth examination of experimental research, including variables, experimental designs, and the critical concept of control. Finally, it introduces applied research methods such as quasi-experimentation and single-case designs, which are used when true experiments are not feasible.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers content analysis as a systematic method for categorizing behavior or related content, followed by focus groups for gathering attitudes and opinions, and meta-analysis for statistically reviewing existing research. It then defines experimental research's core components—independent, dependent, and control variables—and explains why experiments are conducted for control and hypothesis testing. The lecture details classical experimental designs (within-subjects and between-subjects), their associated problems, and then transitions to applied research with quasi-experimentation (retrospective, prospective, and time series designs) and single-case research designs, using twin and adoption studies as key examples.
📝 Lecture Summary
e. Content Analysis
An approach for systematically categorizing and analyzing the content of the behavior or its related aspects/variables being studied. Content analysis is part of archival research and may cover contents of live human behavior, books, journals, magazines, poetry, drama, movies, folktales, TV programs, school textbooks, curricula, and advertisements. Inferences are made and conclusions are drawn after objective identification of specific characteristics of contents. This analysis is done keeping specific goals, objectives, themes, and constructs in mind.
📌 Example: Content analysis of textbooks with reference to gender equity and equality; analysis of TV programs with reference to portrayal of women.
f. Focus Groups
A variety of interviews conducted in a group setting. The researcher talks to the participants to learn about their opinions, attitudes, preferences, and likes/dislikes, trying to find out their reasons or causes. Focus groups are used as a source of data collection in surveys but are also used otherwise.
g. Meta Analysis
A statistics-based method for reviewing existing research literature in the same field, about the same phenomena. The analysis covers the results of several independent experiments within the same field. Computer-aided statistical analysis yields overall conclusions.
Experimental Research
Experimental method is the use of experimentation for studying a phenomenon. Experimental design is the plan, structure, or layout of an experiment. In an experiment, the variable of interest (independent variable) is manipulated or altered, and the effect of this manipulation is studied.
Why experiments are conducted?
- For testing hypotheses
- To test the impact of a treatment or a program on behavior
- The main feature of experimentation is CONTROL; keeping all those variables and conditions under control that can have an impact on the findings of the study—i.e., variables that can interfere with the impact of the independent variable.
Variables i. Independent Variable (IV): The variable whose impact is being studied; that is manipulated in terms of kind or level. ii. Dependent Variable (DV): The measure of behavior on which the impact of the independent variable is being studied. iii. Control Variable (CV): A potential independent variable that can have an impact upon the dependent variable; it has to be controlled.
Groups in a Typical Experiment i. Experimental Group: This is treated with the independent variable. ii. Control Group: The no-treatment group that is kept under controlled conditions.
Classical Experiment Design (Standard format: Example of impact of music on stress)
- The experimental group is measured on the DV (stress level), then treated by the IV (soft music), and then measured on the DV again.
- The control group is measured on the DV (stress level), kept under controlled conditions (no music), and then measured on the DV again.
Experimental Designs i. Within-Subjects Design: The experimental design in which the subjects' performance is compared with their own performance; only one group of subjects is used. This is often called the Before-After No Control Group Design, with varieties like ABABA and ABABABBA designs. ii. Between-Subjects Experimental Design: The experimental design in which two or more groups of subjects are used and their performance is compared with each other. This includes: - Classical Experimental Design - After-Only Experimental Design
Problems associated with experimental research:
- Artificiality of behavior is a possibility
- Subjects may be under stress or pressure
- Time consuming and expensive
- Ethical issues: can we tell all about the nature of experiment to the subjects?
- BUT...the very element of control gives an edge to this approach, as this is what makes psychology a science.
💡 Why this matters: The control achieved in experiments allows for causal conclusions, distinguishing psychology as a scientific discipline from mere observation.
Applied Research: Quasi Experimentation
A kind of research that fits into the experimental framework, although it is not planned, initiated, or controlled by the experimenter: it is "sort of experimentation." It is experimentation in which the independent variable occurs, or has occurred, naturally, and the researcher studies its impact the way it is done in a laboratory experiment.
Groups in a Quasi-Experiment i. Exposure Group ii. Comparison Group
Quasi-experimental Design i. Retrospective/Ex Post Facto Design: Ex post facto means "after the fact." There are two groups: the exposure group and the comparison group. The process of "constructing" comparable exposure and comparison groups is called "matching". The subjects are already naturally divided like that; however, the experimenter selects the relevant subjects according to the nature of the research.
ii. Prospective Design: This design is similar to the retrospective design, except that in a prospective design, variations in the independent variable are measured as they occur, rather than retrospectively. Researchers are equally careful in interpreting the prospective and retrospective quasi-experiments. In neither case are the subjects randomly assigned to the exposure and the control groups. Generally, prospective designs are more persuasive than retrospective designs, especially when the independent variable occurred long ago.
iii. Time Series Design: This design is mainly concerned with observing whether the values of the dependent variable change in apparent response to changes in an independent variable.
Examples of Quasi Experimentation i. Twin Studies: Twin studies investigate different aspects of behavior and mental processes of twins, whether identical or fraternal. The studies on identical twins reared apart have generated very significant results, showing amazing similarities as well as differences among such twins.
ii. Adoption Studies: Most people have one set of parents. However, 1% of infants born in western countries every year are adopted at or near birth by persons unrelated to them. Such children have two sets of parents: parents who rear them and those who give them their genes. Social scientists have used this to help determine how much influence genetic factors and family environment have over behavior. Like twin studies, adoption studies suggested that many human behaviors are genetically influenced. That is why the nature-nurture issue is always remaining controversial.
Applied Research: Single-Case Research Designs
A type of research in which a single case is focused upon and studied. This approach is employed in rarely occurring cases.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the core components of experimental research: the independent variable is manipulated, the dependent variable is measured to see the effect, and control variables are held constant to isolate the IV's impact. The experimental group receives the IV treatment, while the control group does not, allowing for causal inference. The major advantage of experiments is control, which provides a scientific edge, but they also come with problems like artificiality and ethical concerns. Finally, when true experiments are impossible, researchers use quasi-experimentation (with naturally occurring IVs) or single-case designs, exemplified by twin and adoption studies that help unravel the nature-nurture debate.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between an experimental group and a control group in a classical experiment?
- Define content analysis and give one example of what it can be applied to.
- What is the key feature that gives experimental research its scientific edge over other methods?
- Explain the difference between a retrospective (ex post facto) and a prospective quasi-experimental design.
- How do twin studies and adoption studies serve as examples of quasi-experimentation?