📘 Lecture 26 — Secondary/ Learnt/ Psychological Motives
📖 Overview: This lecture explores psychological motives that arise from social and cultural contexts, distinguishing them from basic biological drives. It covers six key psychological needs—achievement, curiosity, appraisal, affiliation, power, and work—before transitioning to major theoretical explanations of motivation, including instinct, drive-reduction, arousal, incentive, cognitive, and Maslow’s hierarchy approaches. Understanding these motives is critical because their non-satisfaction can lead to mental illness and because they shape human behavior in complex social environments.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing six secondary/learnt psychological motives: achievement, curiosity, symbolic reward/appraisal, need for affiliation, need for power, and work as motive. It then presents six major theories of motivation: instinct theory, drive-reduction theory, arousal theory, incentive theory, cognitive theory (including expectancy-value theory and intrinsic/extrinsic motivation), and Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Each theory is explained with its core concepts, mechanisms, strengths, and criticisms.
📝 Lecture Summary
Secondary/ Learnt/ Psychological Motives
Besides basic biological needs, the expression of psychological needs is of great significance through society and culture. Non-satisfaction of these motives may lead to mental illness. The main psychological needs are: achievement, curiosity, need for appraisal, need for affiliation, need for power, and work as motive.
1. Achievement
Self-actualization or attaining excellence in a relevant domain is the characteristic feature of the achievement motive. The need to achieve something includes objects, goals, or position/status. The source of satisfaction is not just achieving the goal but the very act of striving for it. The level of need for achievement varies from person to person—some are high achievers, others low achievers. Competition is an important element. People with high achievement motivation take and overcome challenges rather than finding easy ways; those with low motivation tend to avoid failure, find easy ways out, and avoid difficult tasks.
🔑 Definition — Thematic Apperception Test (TAT): A method for measuring achievement motivation where a series of ambiguous pictures are presented, and the person writes a story with a beginning, middle, and end, describing who the people are, what they think, feel, and want, and what is happening and will happen—depicting needs, desires, and motivation to succeed.
Factors Contributing to the Need for Achievement:
- Parents who are warm and make high standards for their child, encouraging independence
- Siblings who are high achievers in their own domain
2. Curiosity
Think why children break toys or constantly ask questions about things they see on TV, read, or hear. It is all their curiosity and need to explore to find answers. It is significantly inborn but also learned, found in both humans and animals. Parents encourage curiosity by satisfying inquisitiveness. Schools also play an important role; teaching methodology may encourage or discourage curiosity.
3. Symbolic Reward/ Appraisal
Appraisal is a powerful motive for everyone, especially for children and animals. Praising words, petting after doing well, etc., serve as symbolic rewards for the learner. The presence and attitude of a more liked person serves as a social reward—e.g., a child with his mother, a dog with its caretaker. Parent’s approval and disapproval, liking and disliking toward the child, are all included in symbolic rewards.
4. Need for Affiliation
The urge or desire to maintain relationships with other people, making friends, and having social contact. There is less desire to be isolated or alone. Studies show females spend more time among friends and peers compared to males. Although the need for affiliation is universal, cultural differences exist in its expression—some cultures have more group cohesiveness than others.
5. Need for Power
The desire to influence, hold, or rule over others in order to be recognized as a powerful individual. These people prefer to work in big organizations, businesses, and other influential professions. Gender differences exist: men are more apt to take challenges and respond aggressively, whereas women are socially restrained and traditional in behavior.
6. Work
Most people spend a large span of their life at work, so psychologists take it as another powerful motive. Work serves as a powerful motive because it satisfies other motives too—biological motives of hunger, shelter, etc., as well as sense of achievement, affiliation, and decision-making.
Theories/Explanations of Motivation
Different approaches focus upon biological, social, cognitive, and psychological factors. The six approaches are: instinct, drive-reduction, arousal, incentive, cognitive, and Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.
i. Instinct Theory
There is a biologically determined behavior pattern we are born with, known as instincts; biological variables drive our behavior. All humans and animals exhibit certain innate tendencies that are fixed, predetermined, and unlearned. Different behaviors are responses to specific instincts. Instincts are essential for species survival and provide energy for action, directing the organism’s behavior.
Shortcomings of Instinct Approaches:
- Disagreement on the number and identity of instincts (William McDougall said 18; Bernard proposed 5759)
- If instincts are the main driving force, why do different people behave differently under the same instinct (e.g., hunger or heat)?
ii. Drive-Reduction Theory
Our biological/physiological needs create an aroused or tension-producing state that motivates us to fulfill them. When basic biological requirements are lacking and the need is unfulfilled, drive (arousal or motivational tension) is produced, energizing the organism to obtain the requirement to satisfy the need.
🔑 Definition — Homeostasis: A stable, well-maintained state of internal biological balance required for proper body functioning; homeostasis is the process whereby this balance is maintained.
Primary and Secondary Drives:
- Primary Drives: Entirely biological—hunger, thirst, sleep, sex, air. Satisfied by reducing the underlying need (e.g., hunger followed by food).
- Secondary Drives: Psychological and social in nature, brought about by prior learning and experiences (e.g., academic achievement).
Criticism:
- What about behaviors directed toward maintaining or even heightened arousal?
- What about curiosity or risk-taking behavior?
- Is behavior guided by drive-reduction alone, or by goals too?
iii. Arousal Theory
A certain level of arousal and excitement is needed by our system. We try to maintain that level of stimulation and activity; maintenance may require reduction or increase in the existing level depending on circumstances. When arousal becomes too high, it needs to come down for optimal functioning, and vice versa. Too high a motivational arousal may negatively affect performance, producing anxiety and irritability. Too low arousal may also have adverse effects (e.g., performance in depression). A consistent, well-balanced, and leveled arousal is needed for optimal functioning—e.g., in exams, athletics, interviews.
iv. Incentive Theory
The motivational state is understood in terms of positive or negative environmental stimuli. Unlike drive-reduction and arousal theory, this explains motivation in terms of external events that stimulate/energize behavior, rather than innate instincts or drives. Characteristics of the external environment are important variables. Incentives are rewards that energize and drive behavior. Anything that provides a reward triggers motivation for action. Incentives may generate behavior even in the absence of an active, unsatisfied instinct or drive—e.g., eating ice cream when stomach is full after a heavy meal. Often drives and incentives go together and have a deeper effect.
Criticism:
- What about motivational processes when an individual tries to fulfill needs with no apparent incentive present? (e.g., working when paid very little and the job doesn’t match one’s aptitude)
- What about behaviors when no apparent incentive is available and threat is involved? (e.g., helping people stranded in a house on fire)
v. Cognitive Theory of Motivation
Theories that give importance to cognitive processes—thoughts, feelings, expectations, understanding, and evaluating—in explaining the motivational process.
Expectancy-Value Theory: Two types of cognitive processes underlie human behavior:
- Expectation: The hope or anticipation that our behavior will help us attain a goal
- Value: The perception, appraisal, or understanding of the value of the goal to us
🔑 Key Principle: The level of expectation and the value attached to it together determine the level of motivation. High expectation with high value produces higher motivation. If either is weak or low, corresponding motivation will also be low.
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation:
- Intrinsic motivation: Motivation from within—internal motivation that energizes the person to satisfy or accomplish a goal for enjoyment and personal satisfaction, with no external tangible reward (e.g., altruistic behavior)
- Extrinsic motivation: Revolves around tangible rewards like money, social contacts
Studies show intrinsic motivation produces better performance results than extrinsic motivation. When extrinsic motivation is more than intrinsic for a desired behavior and remains so for long, intrinsic motivation eventually declines. Example: a child given rewards for tidy homework—eventually focus shifts to getting the reward rather than doing tidy work. Teachers and parents should use extrinsic motivation with great care; it can enhance motivation but not at the cost of intrinsic motivation.
💡 Why this matters: The distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation has direct implications for education, parenting, and workplace management—over-reliance on external rewards can undermine genuine interest and long-term performance.
vi. Abraham Harold Maslow (1908-1970)
American psychologist and leading exponent of the humanistic approach, who gave a comprehensive theory of motivation. He found prevalent psychology too pessimistic and negatively oriented.
Key Points of Maslow’s Theory:
- Psychology should look at the positive side of human beings
- There must be more to living than being battered by a hostile environment or depraved instincts leading to self-destruction
- People’s needs are not low-level and base; we have positive needs that may become neutral in worst cases but will not turn negative or base
- Human behavior responds to needs, but not all needs are only physiological
- Needs motivate human action and are very few in number
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs: A stage theory where needs at one level must be met to move to higher orders. The lowest/primary/base level are physiological needs, while the highest order is self-actualization needs.
🔑 Definition — Self-Actualization: The most advanced human need, based on the desire to grow and utilize one’s potential up to the optimal level.
Categories of Needs:
- Metaneeds: Based on a desire to grow rather than meeting a deficiency; expressed in the need for self-actualization
- Deficiency needs: Triggered by the absence of underlying requirements (e.g., physiological needs, love needs, esteem needs)
Interactions of Needs and Behavior:
| Need | Fulfilled Through | Pathology Associated |
|---|---|---|
| Physiological | Hunger/food | Overeating, anorexia |
| Safety | Profession, job | Phobias |
| Love and belongingness | Marriage, friendship | Antisocial personality |
| Esteem | Awards, honors, scholarships | Depression |
| Self-actualization | Painting, writing, singing | Isolation, alienation, cynicism |
When expanded, Maslow’s hierarchy includes: Transcendence → Self-actualization (fulfilling potential, having meaningful goals) → Esthetic needs (order, beauty) → Cognitive needs → Esteem needs → Attachment needs → Safety needs → Biological/Physiological needs
Criticism Against Maslow’s Theory:
- Can we actually distribute and neatly order all these needs in every case?
- There is little empirical evidence to support Maslow’s way of ranking needs
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that psychological motives—achievement, curiosity, appraisal, affiliation, power, and work—are learned through social and cultural contexts and their non-satisfaction can lead to mental illness. The achievement motive is measured using the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) and is influenced by parenting style and sibling modeling. Six major theories explain motivation from different angles: instinct theory focuses on innate biological patterns; drive-reduction theory emphasizes biological need-based arousal and homeostasis; arousal theory stresses optimal stimulation levels; incentive theory highlights external rewards; cognitive theory includes expectancy-value and the critical distinction between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation (where extrinsic rewards can undermine intrinsic motivation over time); and Maslow’s hierarchy organizes needs from physiological to self-actualization in a stage model. Students must remember that no single theory fully explains all motivated behavior, and that the interaction between internal drives and external incentives is complex.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six secondary/learnt psychological motives discussed in this lecture, and why is their non-satisfaction clinically significant?
- How is achievement motivation measured using the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), and what two parental factors contribute to its development?
- What is the difference between primary drives and secondary drives in drive-reduction theory, and what role does homeostasis play?
- According to cognitive theory, how does excessive extrinsic motivation potentially undermine intrinsic motivation, and what is the practical implication for teachers?
- What are the five levels of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (in order), and what is the main criticism against his way of ranking these needs?
📘 Lecture 27 — EMOTIONS I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of emotions, their definition, components, and roles in daily life. It explores the physiological, behavioral, and cognitive aspects of emotional experience, examines how emotions are assessed through expressions, and explains the biological underpinnings of emotions including the role of the nervous system and brain structures. Understanding emotions is fundamental to psychology as they influence every aspect of human behavior and social interaction.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture defines emotions and their three components (physiological, behavioral, cognitive), classifies emotions into primary, secondary, and derived types, examines how emotions are assessed through facial and vocal expressions, explores the relationship between emotions and cognition, discusses the role of emotions in everyday life, identifies common and basic emotions including Plutchik's emotional wheel, details the physiological changes accompanying emotions, explains the role of the autonomic nervous system (sympathetic and parasympathetic) in emotions, and identifies brain areas involved in emotional processing.
📝 Lecture Summary
Defining Emotions
Emotion is derived from the Latin word "Emovere" meaning "to excite, stir up or agitate." It is defined as a response that includes feelings such as happiness, fear, sadness, grief, and sorrow. Emotion is the amalgamation of three components: physiological arousal, expression of emotion, and the conscious or cognitive experience of the situation that influences behavior.
In psychology, emotion is considered a response to stimuli that involves characteristic physiological changes—such as increase in pulse rate, rise in body temperature, greater or less activity of certain glands, change in rate of breathing—and tends in itself to motivate the individual toward further activity.
Emotions are feelings, highly subjective personal tendencies to respond to internal and external variables. Emotions have cognitive, physiological, and behavioral components. Our cognitive appraisals and evaluations of events in our lives are key determinants to our emotional responses. Emotions are accompanied by physiological arousal of the automatic nervous system that leads to physical symptoms such as increase in respiration and heart rate. The behavioral component of emotions is expressed in our nonverbal body language including facial expressions.
Components of Emotional Experience
Physiological/Physical Component
The physical component of emotion is a psychological arousal that usually accompanies the emotion the body is feeling. If the body did not experience this arousal, the intensity of this emotion would be greatly decreased. During the arousal, the body experiences a surge of powerful feelings known as emotions. People who can detect changes in their arousal level experience their emotions much more intensely than those who cannot detect the changes in their arousal level.
Behavioral Component
This component has been called the outward expression of our emotions. Body gestures, posture, facial expressions, and our tone of voice display what emotions we are feeling. Many of our facial expressions are universal. For instance, if somebody has a mad look on their face, it doesn't matter what language they speak or where they are from, chances are... they're mad. However, some emotional expressions are influenced by our cultures and society's rules for displaying emotions. For example, the guards outside of Buckingham Palace are not allowed to display any emotion on their face.
Cognitive Component
The cognitive component is how we interpret certain situations or stimulations. This determines which emotion our body will feel. For example; if you are alone, sitting in the dark, watching a scary movie, and you hear a loud noise, you may become scared... fearing that there is an immediate threat or that you are in danger. This emotional response to this imaginary threat is just as powerful as it would be to a real threat. Our perception to the imaginary threat is what makes it feel real to us and causes the emotion in our body.
Types of Emotions
McDougall divided "Emotions" into three types:
- Primary: Simple emotions as fear, happiness, anger, disgust etc.
- Secondary: Mixture of various instincts as curiosity, escape etc.
- Derived: Learned through experiences such as sadness, boredom etc.
The lecture poses important questions about emotional responses: Why does your heart pound and you burst into tears on hearing dreadful news? Why do people become afraid on seeing a snake? Why does the heart beat at a very high speed while jogging/exercise? Why do people's faces redden on hearing good news?
The answer is not simple: our heart may pound even at the sight of someone we hate, before an interview or presentation, or when we are scared. Our face may blush and turn red when we are self-conscious, embarrassed, or angry. Same bodily changes may be manifest in different emotional experiences. What makes the experience different is the accompanying expression and cognition.
Assessing Emotions: Expressions in Emotions
Vocal, verbal and facial expressions play a vital role in determining emotions as well as our interaction with the physical world. In interpreting emotion, the important things are:
- Acquaintance with the other person
- Type of association with that person
- Deriving clues from own emotional experiences in order to understand other's experiences as well
Facial expressions clearly reflect the intensity of emotional experiences such as happiness, sadness, anger, and sorrow: all can be understood from emotional expressions. However these vary from person to person. An adult's voice pattern clearly reflects their emotions. Variations in pitch or loudness express different types of emotions.
Emotions and Cognition: Understanding Emotions
Some psychologists believed that memory and cognition are entirely separate systems that function independently; some argue that we emotionally respond to the situation and then understand it cognitively. On the other hand, others believed that we first cognitively evaluate the situation and then exhibit the emotional experience we are facing at that time. Both points of view are somehow supported by the studies and the debate is still unresolved—this may be due to the fact that emotional experiences vary from situation to situation and so do the cognitive appraisal and the emotional experiences.
Role of Emotions in Everyday Life
Emotions make our life bright and enlightened, because without the experience of emotions, our life would be dull, uninteresting, gloomy and without any purpose. Psychologists identified number of functions of emotions that have a vital role in our daily life:
- Stirred up for the fight or flight action: After seeing a snake or after an unusual incident such as natural disaster, the body is prepared to stir up our bodies to face and deal with them.
- Modifying the future responses and behavior: Learning takes place after the emotional state that prepares us to manifest appropriate behaviors in future, i.e., strategies should be adopted to minimize the aftermath of disasters and avoid us facing the snake.
- Social interactions are enhanced: As emotions are both verbal and non-verbal, they help people to better understand the responses whether they are being expressed or not.
Common Emotions: Range of Emotions
There are a number of basic emotions that have been identified by people in instances:
- Happy
- Anger
- Fear
- Disgust
- Surprise
- Sadness
J.B. Watson talked about three main emotions: Anger, Love, and Fear. He proved in his experiments that infants are capable of these three primary emotions. Psychologists have also identified other emotions or related expressions such as contempt, shame, and startle.
Robert Plutchik (1984) became able to determine the basic emotions and their relationship through his studies. He identified eight fundamental emotions: joy, anger, sadness, surprise, fear, acceptance, disgust, and anticipation. He named it as Plutchik's emotional wheel. The emotions nearer to one another are closely related, while those that are opposite to each other are conceptually opposites. The existence of only these emotions is the major shortcoming of this model; he believed that emotions can better be understood by breaking them into components/elements.
🔑 Definition — Plutchik's Emotional Wheel: A model identifying eight fundamental emotions (joy, anger, sadness, surprise, fear, acceptance, disgust, anticipation) where emotions nearer to each other are closely related and opposite emotions are conceptually opposite.
Physiological Component of Emotions
Many physiological changes take place in an emotional state, in the form of changes in:
- Heart rate
- Pulse rate
- Respiration
- Blood pressure
- Digestion and appetite
- Muscular activity
- Body temperature
- Perspiration
- Endocrine and neurotransmitter secretions
- Blood sugar
- Salivary gland activity
- Pupil dilation
Role of the Nervous System in Emotions
All the emotional experiences and their expressions are controlled and regulated by the autonomic or visceral nervous system. The autonomic nervous system (A.N.S.) is an integral part of the peripheral nervous system.
The Peripheral Nervous System consists of:
- Autonomic (Self-Regulatory/Self-Governing): Sympathetic Nervous System (arousing) and Parasympathetic Nervous System (calming)
- Skeletal/Somatic: Sensory Input, Motor Output
Autonomic Nervous System (A.N.S.) is considered the "self-governing or self-regulatory mechanism" because of our involuntary control over it. It controls the glands and muscles of our internal organs such as heart (heartbeat), stomach (digestion) and glandular activity. A.N.S. has a dual function; i.e. both arousing and calming.
Sympathetic Nervous System (S.N.S.): This part of A.N.S. arouses us for defensive action. If something alarms or enrages someone, the sympathetic nervous system accelerates heartbeat, slows digestion, raises the sugar level in blood, dilates the arteries, and cools perspiration, making one alert and ready for action.
Parasympathetic Nervous System: When the stressful situation subsides, the parasympathetic nervous system starts its activity. It produces the opposite effect to that of the sympathetic nervous system. It conserves energy by decreasing heartbeat, lowering blood pressure, lowering blood sugar, and so on. In daily life situations, both sympathetic and parasympathetic systems work together to keep us in a steady internal state (homeostasis).
🔑 Definition — Homeostasis: The steady internal state maintained by the balanced activity of the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems in daily life.
Areas for Emotions in the Brain
The Autonomic Nervous System is not the only center of emotions in the peripheral nervous system. Cortical and sub-cortical structures are involved in emotions. The cerebral cortex is involved in relating the present and past emotional experiences; other areas are involved in speeding up the heartbeat and in learning emotional experiences. Sub-cortical regions are involved in organizing emotional expressions.
The right hemisphere is the most active in recognizing and expressing the emotions we are feeling. It also responds to emotions being conveyed by another person's body language or tone of voice. For example, an employer sarcastically says to an employee who comes to work late, "Glad to see you could make it today." If the employee had damage to his right hemisphere, he may only understand the words and not the sarcastic undertones, whereas a person whose right hemisphere is functioning normally would usually have a sarcastic response.
The right hemisphere helps in our expression through our tone of voice and by controlling our facial expression. Since the right hemisphere controls the left side of the face, the left side usually portrays stronger emotion than the right side of the face. Research continues to accumulate information showing the mechanisms in the brain responsible for negative emotions reside in the right hemisphere, while the left hemisphere is believed to control positive emotions. Research has shown that patients who suffer from manic depression or major depression have decreased activity in the left prefrontal cortex where the positive emotions are produced.
Much of the frontal lobes consists of areas that are involved with motivation, thinking, positive emotion, impulse control, and other emotional responses. Any damage that occurs to the frontal areas usually produces deficiencies in the ability to anticipate the results of our actions.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding that different brain hemispheres process different types of emotions (right for negative, left for positive) has major implications for treating mood disorders like depression, where activity in the left prefrontal cortex is decreased.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Emotion is a response combining physiological arousal, behavioral expression, and cognitive interpretation—and the same bodily changes can occur across different emotions, with cognition and expression making the experience distinct. The three components (physiological, behavioral, and cognitive) work together, and the autonomic nervous system's sympathetic branch (arousing) and parasympathetic branch (calming) regulate these responses to maintain homeostasis. Basic emotions include those identified by Watson (anger, love, fear) and Plutchik (joy, anger, sadness, surprise, fear, acceptance, disgust, anticipation) displayed in his emotional wheel. The right hemisphere processes negative emotions while the left hemisphere processes positive emotions, and the frontal lobes are involved in motivation, impulse control, and emotional responses.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of emotional experience, and how does each contribute to the overall experience of emotion?
- According to McDougall, what are the three types of emotions, and how do they differ from each other?
- What is the difference between the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems in terms of their roles in emotional responses?
- What did Robert Plutchik identify as the eight fundamental emotions, and what is the significance of their arrangement in the "emotional wheel"?
- Which brain hemisphere is associated with negative emotions versus positive emotions, and what happens when there is damage to the frontal lobes?
📘 Lecture 28 — Emotions II
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the physiological changes that occur during emotional states, which psychologists use as measurable indicators of emotion. It then examines several major theories of emotion, each offering a different explanation for the relationship between physiological arousal, cognitive appraisal, and the subjective experience of emotion. Understanding these theories is crucial for comprehending the complex interplay between our bodies and minds during emotional experiences.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by detailing the major physiological changes during emotions, including respiratory changes, pupillometrics, changes in blood pressure and heart rate, glandular responses including adrenaline and noradrenaline secretion, gastrointestinal function, neural reactions, and the galvanic skin response, as well as emotional intensity and state of arousal. It then transitions to a comprehensive overview of several theories of emotion, starting with the James-Lange theory, followed by the Cannon-Bard theory, the Schachter-Singer cognitive labeling theory, and other important theories such as the cognitive appraisal theory by Richard Lazarus, Magda Arnold's cognitive theory, the opponent-process theory by Solomon and Corbit, Lindsley's activation theory, and Albert Ellis's theory of emotions.
📝 Lecture Summary
Physiological Changes during Emotions
Psychologists believe that emotions can be measured quantitatively by observing different physiological responses of the individual, which act as indicators of emotions. They also propose that these physiological responses themselves constitute different emotional states. The major physiological changes that occur during emotions are:
1. Respiratory Changes The most apparent and obvious change during emotions is an increase in respiration, which also occurs when a person is happy or excited. However, as the process of respiration increases, the production and secretion of saliva decreases.
2. Pupillometrics Darwin was the first to identify this phenomenon. The pupil of the eye is very responsive during emotions, dilating at a favorable stimulus and contracting at an unfavorable stimulus. Our pupil is also responsive to favorable and unfavorable sounds and tastes.
3. Changes in Blood Pressure and heart rate Variations in blood pressure occur during emotions, usually increasing during an emotional state. Heartbeat also increases during emotions. Increased blood pressure and heightened heart rate for prolonged periods may lead to coronary heart disease.
4. Glandular Responses During strong emotional states such as anger or fear, excessive amounts of hormones adrenaline and noradrenaline are secreted into the blood stream. Due to this secretion, the liver secretes excessive amounts of glucose directly into the blood stream, which causes the blood to clot rapidly in case of injury or damage. Blood pressure and sugar level rise, pulse becomes fast, air passages of the lungs enlarge, pupils enlarge, sweat appears, and skin temperature rises. Noradrenaline helps to constrict the blood vessels, making blood available to other parts of the body in case of injury. Pituitary and thyroid glands are also responsive to emotional states. All glandular responses help to cope physically with emotional as well as emergency situations.
5. Gastrointestinal Function The stomach and intestines are very responsive to emotional states, either starting to work at a very high rate or stopping entirely. During strong emotional arousal, their working speed decreases, and blood flow is more towards the brain and skeletal muscles rather than these organs.
6. Neural Reactions Besides affecting visceral organs, emotions also bring changes in neural/nerve activity. The autonomic division of the P.N.S. is more effective in this regard, where sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems work successively.
7. Galvanic Skin Response When perspiration appears during emotions, two important changes occur in the skin’s electrical stimulation: rapid generation of electromotive energy and a change in the electrical resistance of skin. These changes can be measured through a measurement of "Galvanic Skin Response (GSR)," formally called "Psycho Galvanic Response (PGR)." The galvanic skin response, in combination with respiration and blood pressure, is used for lie detection with people who are supposed to be guilty of some crime.
8. Emotional Intensity and State of Arousal Most of the time we are aware of our emotional states such as being angry, excited, or afraid. In all these states, the physiological conditions are the same (e.g., heart beat increases, face blushes or becomes pale). That is why we are unable, at times, to differentiate between different emotions and the associated arousal. 💡 Why this matters: This similarity in physiological arousal across different emotions is a key reason why cognitive interpretation of the situation is so important for determining the specific emotion we feel.
Other Common Bodily Changes during Emotions Other common bodily changes include dryness of throat and mouth, muscle tension, weakness or fainting, trembling, and a sinking feeling in the heart or stomach.
Theories of Emotions
Psychologists have attempted to define and explain emotional arousal and the physiological conditions that accompany them. A number of theories have been developed, but the most famous ones are the James-Lange theory, the Cannon-Bard theory, and the Schachter-Singer theory (Cognitive Labeling Theory/Two Factor Theory). Other important theories include the Cognitive Appraisal Theory by Richard Lazarus, the Cognitive Theory by Magda Arnold, the Opponent-Process Theory by Solomon and Corbit, the Activation Theory by Lindsley, and the Theory of Emotions by Albert Ellis.
1. James- Lange Theory of Emotions This is the earliest theory of emotion, now considered the classical approach, given by American psychologist William James and Danish psychologist Carl Lange in the 19th century. The theory states that emotional experience occurs in reaction to instinctive bodily events that take place as a result of an external situation: "...we feel sorry because we cry, angry because we strike, afraid because we tremble" (James, 1890). Physiological changes create specific sensations, and our brain interprets these sensations as different emotions. The theory asserts that awareness of the physiological responses determines our emotional arousal.
Sequence of Events in James-Lange Model:
- Experience of an emotion-involving situation (e.g., find oneself in a waiting room before first job interview).
- Physiological responses take place; visceral bodily changes are activated (e.g., pounding heart, sweaty palms, increased respiration).
- Brain interprets these physiological changes as an emotional experience (e.g., fear).
🔑 Definition — James-Lange Theory: The theory that emotional experience is the result of the brain interpreting physiological (visceral) changes that occur in response to an emotion-inducing event. We feel an emotion because of our bodily reactions.
Criticism against James-Lange model:
- On most emotional occasions we experience the emotion quite immediately after a triggering stimulus (e.g., hearing a loud bang and being startled). Are our visceral responses that fast? Many times we don’t have enough time for this intermediate part.
- The most basic criticism is that emotional experience (fear) results from physiological responses after evaluating the situation.
- On many occasions we experience physiological changes but no emotion (e.g., patients with hypertension or joggers with a pounding heart). A key question remains: how do the same physiological changes create different emotional experiences?
2. Cannon- Bard Theory of Emotions Given by Walter Cannon and Philip Bard in the 1920s, this theory assumes that emotional states and physiological reactions work independently but are triggered by the same nerve impulse simultaneously.
🔑 Definition — Cannon-Bard Theory: The theory that an emotion-inducing stimulus simultaneously triggers both a physiological (visceral) response and the subjective experience of emotion, with the thalamus playing a key role in sending messages to both the autonomic nervous system and the cerebral cortex.
Sequence of Events in Cannon-Bard Theory:
- Perception of the emotion-inducing stimulus.
- Thalamus is activated.
- Thalamus sends messages to two sites: a) The Autonomic nervous system, producing a visceral response. b) The cerebral cortex, receiving a message regarding the nature of the emotion being experienced.
Major drawback: Research has shown that it is the hypothalamus and the limbic system that are responsible for emotional experience, and not the thalamus!
3. Cognitive Labeling Theory/ Two Factor Theory of Emotions Pioneered by Stanley Schachter and Jerome Singer (1962), this theory proposes that emotions result from both physiological arousal and cognitive appraisal (evaluation) of the situation. Arousal comes first and is general in nature. Two forces jointly determine emotional experience: a non-specific kind of physiological arousal, and the interpretation of the experience based on environmental cues. Both of these factors jointly determine the title/label of the emotion and the meaning of one’s reaction. We observe the environment and compare ourselves with others, and this helps us identify our emotion.
Schachter’s-Singer Model:
- Stimulus elicits perception (e.g., incoming car).
- This leads to physiological arousal (e.g., pounding heart/perspiration).
- The stimulus is also interpreted via cognitive appraisal/label (e.g., "I am afraid/going to be hurt").
- The combination of physiological arousal and cognitive label determines the felt emotion (e.g., fear).
🔑 Definition — Schachter-Singer Two-Factor Theory: The theory that emotional experience is determined by two factors: a general, non-specific state of physiological arousal and a cognitive interpretation or label for that arousal based on environmental cues. 💡 Why this matters: This theory is prominent for explaining how the same physiological arousal can be interpreted as different emotions (e.g., fear, excitement, anger) depending on the context and our cognitive evaluation of that context.
Labeling of the emotional experience is entirely dependent on the experiencing individual’s own evaluation. The theory believes that physiological arousal determines the intensity of emotions and includes physiological, cognitive, and social psychology to investigate the nature of emotions.
4. Cognitive Appraisal Theory: Richard Lazarus Given by Richard Lazarus and his colleagues in 1968, this theory maintains that emotional experience cannot be understood solely on its own; understanding the environment is to be evaluated. Appraisal involves cognition, bodily responses, and memory. Richard Lazarus gave two basic types of appraisal:
- i. Primary appraisal: Evaluate whether the situation is threatening or not.
- ii. Secondary appraisal: Involve alternatives in order to deal with the perceived threat.
- iii. Reappraisal: Includes re-evaluating the situation and alternatives to see whether the judgment is true or not.
5. Cognitive Theory: Magda Arnold Given in 1966, this is one of the first theories to use the concept of cognition in emotional states. The model is known as the "Sequential model." The steps involved in emotions are:
- Perception; how the situation is being perceived.
- Appraisal; whether the stimulus is beneficial or harmful to ourselves.
- Determining emotions with regard to the prevailing situation.
- Expressing emotions; also accompanying physiological responses.
- Finally, they all work to give an idea of whether to approach a situation or withdraw from it.
6. Opponent- Process Theory: Solomon and Corbit Given by Richard Solomon and John Corbit in 1974, this theory maintains that every emotional arousal has an opposite. When one type of emotion is elicited, an opposite emotion is there to suppress or cancel it. In this way, the emotional arousal remains at some baseline.
Baseline → State A (primary emotion) → State B (opponent process) → Baseline
7. Activation Theory: Lindsley (1951, 1957) This theory is based on the observation that the reticular system activates the cortex region in the brain, which ultimately arouses/excites the organism. The theory believes that emotional arousal activates the reticular part of the brain present in the brain stem, which sends impulses to the thalamus and cortex and brings about emotional arousal. If the reticular part is at rest, then the emotional state is calm and relaxing.
8. Theory of Emotions: Albert Ellis Given by American psychologist Albert Ellis, this theory proposes that emotions do not result from a single cause but originate from three different ways:
- First, sensory-motor; involves brain and muscles.
- Second, biochemical stimulation; functions to mediate processes of ANS, hypothalamus, and sub-cortical regions.
- Third, cognitive and thinking processes. To Ellis, emotions do not exist independently but involve several stages in order to take place.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must understand that emotions are accompanied by distinct physiological changes, such as changes in respiration, pupil dilation, heart rate, and galvanic skin response, which can serve as measurable indicators. The central debate among theories of emotion revolves around the sequence and relationship between physiological arousal and the subjective feeling of emotion. The James-Lange theory argues that we feel emotion because of our physiological reactions, while the Cannon-Bard theory posits that both occur simultaneously and independently. The most complex theory is Schachter and Singer's Two-Factor Theory, which integrates both physiological arousal and cognitive labeling based on the environment. Finally, be able to distinguish the key proponents and core criticisms of each of these three major theories, as well as the main ideas of the supplementary theories like Lazarus's Cognitive Appraisal and Solomon and Corbit's Opponent-Process theory.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to the James-Lange theory of emotion, if you are trembling, what specific emotion will you feel?
- What is the primary structure in the brain that the Cannon-Bard theory mistakenly identified as being crucial for emotional experience?
- In Schachter and Singer's Two-Factor Theory, what two factors must be present for an emotional experience to occur?
- What is a "primary appraisal" according to Richard Lazarus's Cognitive Appraisal Theory?
- The "Opponent-Process Theory" by Solomon and Corbit proposes what happens to emotional arousal after the primary emotion is experienced?