π Lecture 18 β INTERNATIONAL LAW ON TERRORISM
π Overview: This lecture examines the complex and controversial topic of terrorism within public international law. It explains why terrorism remains undefined in international law, explores the relationship between terrorism and concepts like self-determination and use of force, and surveys key international conventions that address specific terrorist acts. Understanding this topic is essential because terrorism poses one of the most serious threats to international peace and security, yet its legal treatment remains fragmented and contested.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining why terrorism is such a complicated legal issue due to two competing approaches (political scientist and extensive approach). It then examines three issues related to terrorism: self-determination, use of force, and international humanitarian law. The lecture proceeds to list the major international conventions that define specific acts of terrorism (from aircraft hijacking to financing terrorism), and concludes by discussing UN Security Council resolutions 1373 and 1566, along with the three elements that lead to an act of terrorism.
π Lecture Summary
INTERNATIONAL LAW ON TERRORISM
The law on terrorism is a very controversial topic. Although much progress has been made, it remains elusive for the annals of humanity and international law alike. Terrorism has not been defined or described yet by international experts. The problem behind defining a concept is that it does not only stagger its growth but also limits the very scope of it. On the other hand, non-describing of a concept leaves room for its growth and keeps it flexible enough for future deliberations.
The reason for terrorism being such a complicated issue is because of the following two approaches. The first approach is the political scientist approach which examines terrorism on political basis, losing sight of its legal connotations and implications. The second approach is the extensive approach and it sees the acts of terrorism in isolation and as a struggle with no regard to the political issues.
Law on terrorism is more of a sector oriented law rather than a complete law in itself. A particular act of terror results in a convention dealing specifically with that act or any other acts incident to it, but does not address the issue of terrorism as a whole by defining it comprehensively. However, the Sixth Committee of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) is undergoing its 3rd reading and is trying to negotiate on ways to resolve the complexities involved, but the major hindrance remains the definition and the preamble.
There are, however, ways to actually describe what acts are often dubbed as terrorism, which to a certain extent help in defining terrorism as well: self-determination, use of force, and international humanitarian law.
SELF DETERMINATION
Self-determination is actually the foundation of the United Nations Charter. It is defined as a right of people to determine and to choose their own state and its territorial boundaries. For this purpose, a UN trusteeship system was established. States which were not able to run themselves were entrusted to the UN and were given total independence. In other words, people were empowered to determine their own destiny by their own will.
π Definition β Self-determination: a right of people to determine and to choose their own state and its territorial boundaries.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Art 1 (ICCPR), International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), Universal Declaration on Human Rights (UDHR), United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) and United Nations Security Council (UNSC) β all these conventions were based on the concept of self-determination. Self-determination is undisputedly a norm of jus cogens (the highest rules of international law that must be strictly adhered to at all times).
Self-determination is accepted as a right, but it coexists with the law relating to terrorism. In order to obtain independence, a lot of strikes would take place which would lead to property being damaged, and this clash further creates ambiguity and confusion on terrorism.
π‘ Why this matters: Self-determination is a fundamental right under international law, yet actions taken in its name can blur the line between legitimate struggle and terrorism, creating legal complexity.
USE OF FORCE
Use of force was introduced by the UN Charter and is resorted to secure the right of self-determination, e.g., in Kashmir, Palestine, and areas under occupation. In some areas, use of force is permissible and therefore legal under the UN Charter, e.g., self defence and reprisal. However, under humanitarian law, sanction is imposed for the use of force, and it also prohibits the use of force against territorial integrity.
INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW (IHL)
The third issue regarding terrorism is International Humanitarian Law (IHL), often referred to as the law of armed conflict. It prohibits certain actions such as water contamination, torture, usage of certain chemicals, biological weapons, and bullets which cause unnecessary suffering or superfluous injuries to civilian and non-civilian entities. It further forbids the killing or injuring of an enemy who has surrendered. This area has been codified by the Geneva Convention, Additional Protocols, and the Hague Convention.
According to IHL, civilians should not be attacked, whereas in a terrorist attack mostly civilians are targeted, thus creating a conflict between terrorism and IHL. It is important to observe that IHL prohibitions should be identified and followed as their violations/breach may be considered as terrorism. In the event of a violation, the procedure to redress or rectify such breach with regards to IHL is dealt by a permanent court, the International Criminal Court (ICC). A conflict between IHL and terrorism also arises regarding Non-International Armed Conflict (NIAC), e.g., the Kashmir situation.
Therefore, self-determination, use of force, and IHL are all related to the law on terrorism.
CONVENTIONS ON TERRORISM
There are certain conventions which have defined specific acts that constitute an act of terrorism:
- Convention on Offences on Board Tokyo Aircraft 1963: relates to hijacking.
- Unlawful Seizure of Aircraft in Hague 1973: relates to different stages of hijacking and states certain crimes that have universal jurisdiction.
- Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Civil Aviation 1971
- Protocol for Acts of Violence against Airports 1988: e.g., where three planes were destroyed and civil aviation was also damaged, so after this case separate rules on aviation were adopted.
- Convention on Crimes against Internationally Protected Person 1973
- Convention against Physical Protection of Nuclear Material 1979
- Protocol on Safety of Platform and Continental Shelf 1988
- Convention against Taking of Hostages 1980: states that no one shall be made hostage. Pakistan's Anti-Terrorism Act, 1998 has successfully managed to cover most of the provisions of this convention and states that if anyone breaches it, they would have to face sanction and can be tried under the statute.
- Convention against Recruitment and Financing of Mercenaries 1978: concerns hiring and training of civilians and involving them in crimes, classifying it as an act of terrorism.
- Convention on Safety of UN and Safety Personnel 1979: states that protection shall be available to people associated with the UN.
- Convention against Suppression of Terrorism Bombing 1997
- Convention against Suppression and Financing of Terrorism 1999: Article 2 states that any person commits an offence if they directly or indirectly, unlawfully and willfully, provide or collect funds with the intention that they be used to carry out:
- (a) An act which constitutes an offence within the scope of one of the treaties listed in the annex; or
- (b) Any other act intended to cause death or serious bodily injury to a civilian, or to any other person not taking an active part in hostilities in an armed conflict, when the purpose is to intimidate a population, or to compel a government or an international organization to do or abstain from doing any act.
UN SECURITY COUNCIL AND TERRORISM
UNSC has also declared incitement as an offence. The interpretation of terrorism formulated by the UNSC is alarming in terms of speed and nature. Before 9/11, there were very few resolutions which related to Afghanistan only, but after 9/11 UNSC has passed a number of resolutions relating to terrorism and condemned certain behaviour.
Two very important resolutions which have had a great impact on the description of terrorism are:
- Resolution 1373: "underlines the obligation on States to deny financial and all other forms of support and safe haven to terrorists and those supporting terrorism."
- Resolution 1566: "which declares terrorism to be one of the most serious threats to peace and security and calls upon countries to prevent terrorism and to punish or extradite those who participate in terrorist activities, as well as their supporters."
THREE ELEMENTS OF TERRORISM
There are further three things which lead to an act of terrorism: the motive, the event itself, and the results to be achieved. The better interpretation is that focus should be on the event alone, thus ignoring the motive and the result to be achieved, and this form would help in explaining the complexity of terrorism.
Thus, there is no law which can justify terrorism. However, UNSC has successfully come up with laws to deal with terrorism, and with the help of the theory of self-determination, use of force, and IHL, has tried to resolve the complexities pertaining to an act of terrorism. But the problem persists regarding the definition and description of terrorism, which further leads to controversy and complexities.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that terrorism remains undefined in international law, and is instead addressed through sector-specific conventions that criminalize particular acts (hijacking, hostage-taking, bombing, financing). The three interrelated concepts of self-determination, use of force, and international humanitarian law are crucial for understanding the legal context of terrorism. The UN Security Council, particularly through resolutions 1373 and 1566, has played a significant role in responding to terrorism post-9/11 by imposing obligations on states to deny support and safe haven. Finally, the most effective legal approach focuses on the event itself rather than the motive or intended result.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why has terrorism not been defined in international law, and what are the two competing approaches to studying terrorism?
- What is self-determination, and why is it considered a norm of jus cogens?
- Under what circumstances is the use of force permissible under the UN Charter, and how does IHL restrict it?
- Name any four international conventions that address specific acts of terrorism and briefly state what each covers.
- What obligations do UN Security Council Resolutions 1373 and 1566 impose on states regarding terrorism?
π Lecture 20 β LAW OF REFUGEES
π Overview: This lecture defines and distinguishes between asylum seekers and refugees under international law. It covers the key international instruments governing refugee protection, the role of UNHCR, and the special challenges faced by refugees, including those with criminal backgrounds. Understanding refugee law is critical for grasping state obligations and humanitarian protections in international relations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture defines refugees and asylum seekers, explains the key international legal instruments (1951 Convention, 1967 Protocol, UNHCR), distinguishes between refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs), discusses Islamic customary practice on refugee protection, and outlines when refugee status is denied due to criminal activity or universal jurisdiction crimes.
π Lecture Summary
Definition of a Refugee
Millions of people migrate annually due to persecution for their religious, socio-political beliefs, seeking favorable living conditions. When their own governments fail to protect their rights, people have the right to move to a country that will protect them. These migratory people are known as refugees.
π Definition β Refugee: Under international law, individuals who are outside their country of nationality or habitual residence; have a well-founded fear of discrimination because of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion; and are unable or unwilling to avail themselves of that country's protection or return there for fear of persecution (Art 6, Statute of UNHCR 1959).
π Example: During the partition of the Indian sub-continent in 1947, the largest cross-border movement in history occurred. Pakistan, a newly born country with no legislative structure, faced great difficulties in making sustainable laws for refugees. A second example: the Soviet Union's invasion of Afghanistan (1979-1992) forced more than six million Afghan refugees to flee to Pakistan and Iran. At the peak, nearly seven million Afghan refugees sought refuge in Pakistan, making it the host of the largest refugee population in history.
Asylum Seeker vs. Refugee Distinction
Until a request for refuge is accepted, the person is an asylum seeker. Only after recognition does the person officially become a refugee with refugee status, carrying certain rights and obligations under the receiving country's laws.
π Definition β Asylum seeker: A person who has applied for asylum under the 1951 Refugee Convention, claiming that if returned to their country of origin, they have a well-founded fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political belief, or membership in a particular social group. They remain an asylum seeker while the application or appeal is pending.
π Definition β Refugee: An asylum seeker whose application has been successful. In its broader concept, it also means a person fleeing civil war or natural disaster, but not necessarily fearing persecution as defined by the 1951 Convention.
π Key Distinction: It is not mandatory for an asylum seeker to return to their country, whereas a refugee can return home if they want. Unfortunately, the terms "asylum seeker" and "refugee" are frequently conflated, causing confusion.
International Legal Instruments for Refugee Protection
Refugee law encompasses the following key international legal instruments:
-
The 1951 United Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (Geneva Convention): A treaty. Signatory countries have an obligation to provide asylum or refuge to people fleeing persecution.
-
The 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees: A treaty that expanded the concept of a refugee and binds its signatories.
-
United Nations High Commission on Refugees (UNHCR): A resolution passed by the UN General Assembly (UNGA). Its provisions are binding only on states that have ratified it. UNHCR is an organization of UNGA. Refugee status is determined by UNHCR and the state itself. The law remains confused on refugee status if the state has not ratified UNHCR. In Pakistan, there is no law on refugees; delegated legislation makes decisions through notifications.
π‘ Why this matters: A state's ratification of UNHCR is not automatic, leading to gaps in legal protection for refugees in non-ratifying states.
Categories Protected by UNHCR
UNHCR provides protection and assistance not only to refugees but also to other categories of displaced or needy people:
- Asylum seekers
- Refugees who have returned home but still need help rebuilding their lives
- Local civilian communities directly affected by refugee movements
- Stateless people
- Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs)
π Definition β Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs): Civilians who have been forced to flee their homes but have not reached a neighboring country. Unlike refugees, IDPs are not protected by international law and may find it hard to receive any form of assistance.
Islamic Customary Practice and Arab Declaration
The State practice of Muslims is more advanced regarding refugee protection; it is a customary practice in Muslim civilization to give protection to refugees. A Declaration on the Protection of Refugees and Displaced Persons in the Arab World was established, based on humanitarian principles (Art 2). Art 5 deals with all situations not covered under the 1951 Convention and 1967 Protocol by relying on humanitarian principles of asylum in Islamic law and Arab values.
Denial of Refugee Status for Criminal Activity
The status of an asylum or refugee is not granted if the person claiming to be a refugee has a criminal record and is trying to evade criminal prosecution.
Certain crimes have universal jurisdiction. States claim criminal jurisdiction over persons whose alleged crimes were committed outside state boundaries, regardless of nationality, country of residence, or any other relation with the prosecuting country. The state justifies this because the crime is considered a crime against all, which any state is authorized to punish, as it is too serious to tolerate jurisdictional arbitrage.
π Examples of universal jurisdiction crimes: Piracy, hijacking, terrorism, genocide, and war crimes.
π‘ Why this matters: Even if a person meets the refugee definition, involvement in universal jurisdiction crimes bars them from refugee status, ensuring international law does not shelter serious criminals.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture distinguishes between asylum seekers (those with pending applications) and refugees (those whose applications are successful). The 1951 Refugee Convention and 1967 Protocol are the core treaties, while UNHCR is a UNGA resolution whose provisions bind only ratifying states. Crucially, IDPs are not protected by international law unlike refugees. Finally, refugee status is denied to individuals with criminal records or those who have committed universal jurisdiction crimes (e.g., genocide, war crimes), and Islamic customary law provides broader refugee protections beyond these instruments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the legal definition of a "refugee" under Article 6 of the Statute of UNHCR?
- What is the key difference between an "asylum seeker" and a "refugee" in terms of application status and return to their home country?
- What are the three main international legal instruments governing refugee protection, and which one is a resolution (not a treaty)?
- Who are "Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs)" and why are they not protected by international law unlike refugees?
- Under what condition is refugee status denied to a person claiming to be a refugee, and what are examples of universal jurisdiction crimes?
π Lecture 21 β Use of Force and UN Charter
π Overview: This lecture examines the law concerning use of force in international law, which is a contentious area. It explains how the UN Charter fundamentally changed the legal landscape from pre-modern times where forceful occupation was accepted to the modern prohibition of force. The lecture focuses on Article 2(4)'s prohibition, the exceptions allowing legal use of force through self-defense and regional arrangements, and the ongoing controversies surrounding these provisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical evolution from pre-modern forceful occupation to modern legal restrictions under the UN Charter. It examines Article 2(4) as the fundamental prohibition of force, including the distinction between "use of force" and "war." The lecture then explores the two main exceptions to this prohibition: self-defense under Article 51 and regional arrangements under Article 52. Key controversies discussed include anticipatory self-defense, preemptive strikes, and the distinction between armed attack and use of force.
π Lecture Summary
The UN Charter and Article 2(4)
The UN Charter is a treaty that has three types of treaty features: it is a law making treaty, a codifying treaty, and a constituent instrument treaty. It introduced new laws, codified previous laws, and established new organizations to implement the laws enacted under it. Article 2(4) of the UN Charter is the most important provision prohibiting the use of force. It states that the use of force against any other territorial boundary should be considered as a violation and breach of international peace and security.
π Definition β Article 2(4): The UN Charter provision that prohibits states from using force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any other state.
The Charter used the term "use of force" instead of "war" intentionally. There have been examples where states may not recognize each other but still maintain a relationship of war, such as the state of affairs between Arab and Israel. During 1965, arbitration handled the dispute between India and Pakistan and stated it to be a situation of armed conflict rather than war, thus still considering the treaties to be valid between them.
π Definition β Armed conflict: A term preferred over "war" in modern international law, as calling a conflict "war" would acknowledge it as an illegal activity according to Article 2(4).
π Example: Israel's attack on Saddam's Kuwait illustrates a violation of Article 2(4).
π‘ Why this matters: The distinction between "war" and "armed conflict" is crucial because states now avoid using the term "war" to avoid acknowledging that they are engaging in illegal activity under Article 2(4).
The ambiguity remains as to whether the term threat mentioned under Article 2(4) should include and expand economic threat or not.
Exceptions to Article 2(4): Self-Defense under Article 51
Article 2(4) not only condemns the use of force but also allows it to be used in certain circumstances. There are two events under which the use of force becomes legal: through regional arrangements and self-defense. Article 51 of UN Charter allows the use of force on the ground of self-defense in case of armed attack. In other words, Article 51 is an exception to Article 2(4).
π Definition β Article 51: The UN Charter provision that allows states to use force in self-defense if an armed attack occurs, and this right exists only until the UN Security Council has taken measures to remedy the situation.
This leads to the determination of the term armed attack. Writers have expanded the definition of "armed attack" and state it to be different and distinct from the terms "use of force" or "threat" under Article 2(4).
π Formula: Armed attack β Use of force β Threat under Article 2(4) β These are distinct legal concepts with different thresholds for triggering self-defense rights.
Anticipatory Self-Defense and Preemptive Strikes
The controversy regarding the use of self-defense is the anticipatory self-defense. Those with a restrictive view state that it no longer exists, as opposed to the permissive view. The anticipatory self-defense did achieve recognition; it states that lawful force can be applied. According to UK and USA, in situations where the threat of attack is eminent and overwhelming, the use of force is allowed and legal.
π Definition β Anticipatory self-defense: The doctrine that lawful force can be applied in situations where the threat of attack is imminent and overwhelming, even before an actual armed attack occurs.
The issue regarding whether preemptive strike takes place in a political sense or a legal sense is debatable. It is presumed that a preemptive strike is actually an anticipatory self-defense. Article 51 relates to self-defense if armed attack occurs and to a certain extent justifies the right of self-defense. However, the right of self-defense is only alive until the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has not taken measures to remedy or to rectify the situation.
π Example: Israel branded the attacks on Iraq as pre-emptive, which led to a controversy and, thus, their argument was turned down. The cumulative self-defense on the other hand was not given importance and acceptability.
π‘ Why this matters: The controversy lies in state practice. It is argued that if state practice is to use the right of self-defense in case of an imminent threat, then it will, despite any measures taken by UNSC, follow this practice. Article 51 imposes an obligation on states to report to the UNSC in order to maintain peace and security.
Regional Arrangements under Article 52
The second way of using force legally is through Article 52 which relates to collective action. It states that after the Security Council, it is the responsibility of the regional set ups to address the issue.
π Definition β Article 52: The UN Charter provision that allows the use of force through regional arrangements and organizations.
π Example: NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) is an example of a regional arrangement that can address security issues under Article 52.
The use of force also becomes legal where UNSC and United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) specifically authorize it.
β Key Takeaways
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter is the fundamental prohibition on the use of force in international law, creating an obligation on states to refrain from using force against other states' territorial boundaries. The Charter deliberately uses "use of force" instead of "war" to avoid the legal consequences that would arise from acknowledging a state of war. There are two main exceptions where force becomes legal: self-defense under Article 51 (in case of armed attack) and regional arrangements under Article 52 (collective action through organizations like NATO). The concept of anticipatory self-defense remains controversial, with restrictive views arguing it no longer exists while permissive views (supported by UK and USA) allow force when threats are imminent and overwhelming. The right of self-defense under Article 51 is temporary and exists only until the UN Security Council takes measures to address the situation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of treaty features that the UN Charter possesses?
- What is the difference between "war" and "armed conflict" under international law?
- Under Article 51, what condition must be met for a state to use force in self-defense?
- What is the controversy surrounding anticipatory self-defense, and which countries support the permissive view?
- According to Article 52, who is responsible for addressing security issues after the Security Council has considered the matter?
π Lecture 22 β Use of Force (Unlawful)
π Overview: This lecture examines the use of force in international law, distinguishing between lawful and unlawful applications. It focuses on the UN Charter framework, particularly Article 2(4)'s prohibition and Article 51's self-defense exception, while exploring various forms of unlawful force including war, aggression, intervention, and the controversial concept of hot pursuit.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the categorization of use of force into lawful and unlawful types under international law. It examines Article 2(4) and Article 51 of the UN Charter, Chapter 6Β½ as a peacekeeping mechanism, the Uniting for Peace Resolution of 1950, reprisal and retortion as lawful force, and unlawful force including war, aggression, intervention, hot pursuit, and terrorist camp attacks. It concludes with exceptions for self-determination and weapons of mass destruction.
π Lecture Summary
Use of Force (Unlawful)
The use of force is a controversial and complicated issue at international level. The United Nations (UN) Charter declared it unlawful to occupy territory by use of force. Article 2(4) forbids all UN members from the threat or use of force in their international relations. However, Article 51 states that use of force may be resorted to in case of self-defence, thereby allowing force to a certain extent.
Use of force is categorized into two types: lawful and unlawful. Article 51 makes it lawful under self-defence; states may use force if an attack is anticipated. Chapter VII creates an obligation on states to abide by its rules and empowers the UN, making force legal in such circumstances. Collective security also legitimizes force via regional organizations like NATO.
π Definition β Article 2(4): The UN Charter provision that forbids all member states from the threat or use of force in their international relations. π Definition β Article 51: The UN Charter provision that permits use of force in case of self-defence by a state. π Formula: Article 2(4) prohibits force β Article 51 (self-defence) + Chapter VII (UN authorization) = lawful exceptions π Example: Collective security via NATO allows member states to use force lawfully when acting under regional security arrangements.
Chapter 6Β½ and UN Mechanisms
The UN Charter talks about maintaining peace and security, but has no provision to authorize and maintain peace. To address this omission, the UN initiated a speculative chapter called Chapter 6Β½, which is not part of the UN Charter but is presumed associated with it. It authorizes peacekeeping missions and lies between Chapter 6 (which directs mechanisms to maintain peace) and Chapter 7 (which enforces peace). Thus, Chapter 6Β½ provides steps to maintain peace and order.
The UN has an observer mission, such as the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), to maintain peace and check violations. The UN comprises six organs: the General Assembly, Security Council, Secretariat, International Court of Justice, Trusteeship Council, and Economic and Social Council. Member states have veto power that can paralyze the UNSC.
The UNGA discussed that if member states use their veto power, paralyzing the UNSC, then the UNGA will step in and take over. This led to the Uniting for Peace Resolution in 1950, which requires that if the Security Council cannot discharge its primary responsibilities due to the veto, the General Assembly will consider the matter immediately.
π Definition β Chapter 6Β½: A speculative, unofficial chapter of the UN Charter that authorizes peacekeeping missions, bridging Chapter 6 (peaceful settlement) and Chapter 7 (enforcement). π Definition β Uniting for Peace Resolution (1950): A UN General Assembly resolution allowing the GA to consider matters of international peace and security if the Security Council is paralyzed by a veto. π‘ Why this matters: These mechanisms allow the UN to act even when permanent members block Security Council action, ensuring continuity in peacekeeping.
Lawful Use of Force: Reprisal and Retortion
The use of reprisal is categorized under lawful use of force. It is a counter-action taken by a state to protect itself after an attack by another state. Three requirements must be fulfilled:
- The reprisal must be made immediately.
- Use of force by the victim state must be in proportion to the force applied by the other state.
- Use of force must be used against a military target.
π Example: During the Iraq-Iran war, sea mines were spread and accidentally damaged a US merchant ship. In retaliation, the US destroyed an oil rig. This was internationally regarded as an example of reprisal.
Retortion refers to the threat of the use of reprisal, not the actual use of force.
π Definition β Reprisal: A counter-action taken by a state to protect itself immediately after an attack, in proportion to the attack, and directed at a military target. π Definition β Retortion: The threat of using reprisal, rather than actual use of force.
Unlawful Use of Force
Several notions are regarded as unlawful use of force:
- War is categorized as unlawful.
- Use of force in situations of aggression is unlawful.
- Use of force for occupying a territory is unlawful under the UN Charter.
- Intervention by one state into the affairs of another is prohibited in international law.
Intervention is further categorized into three elements:
- Hot pursuit
- Attack on terrorist camps
- Self-determination assistance
The alleged right of hot pursuit is used to justify armed incursions into neighbouring states' territory to destroy military bases of guerrillas who have launched or will launch attacks. However, hot pursuit is actually a concept from the law of the sea, not applicable on land.
π Example: India's entry into Kashmir was regarded as hot pursuit, but this concept is fallacious when applied on land because it belongs to maritime law.
π Example: The UK destroyed Harib Fort in Yemen, arguing terrorists resided there and posed a threat. The UNSC passed a resolution condemning the UK, stating it violated international law as an unlawful use of force.
π Definition β Hot pursuit: A legal concept from the law of the sea allowing pursuit of a vessel into another state's territorial waters; incorrectly used to justify land incursions against guerrilla bases.
Exceptions: Self-Determination and Weapons of Mass Destruction
The right of self-determination amounts to an exception: when fighting for self-determination, a state can render assistance from a third country. Intervention for the purpose of weapons of mass destruction is considered lawful. Similarly, steps taken to rescue someone living abroad can involve third country assistance and would be regarded as legitimate use of force.
Any methods or means to use force outside the UN Charter are unlawful and constitute non-compliance with international obligations under the UN system.
π Definition β Self-determination assistance: The lawful right of a state to receive third country assistance when fighting for self-determination, constituting an exception to the prohibition on intervention. π‘ Why this matters: These exceptions create crucial legal pathways for humanitarian intervention and decolonization struggles while maintaining the general prohibition on unlawful force.
β Key Takeaways
The UN Charter fundamentally prohibits the use of force under Article 2(4), with only narrow exceptions for self-defence under Article 51 and UN-authorized action under Chapter VII. Lawful force includes reprisal (immediate, proportional, against military targets) and retortion (threat of reprisal), while unlawful force encompasses war, aggression, occupation, and intervention. The Uniting for Peace Resolution (1950) allows the General Assembly to act when the Security Council is paralyzed by veto, and Chapter 6Β½ enables peacekeeping missions. Hot pursuit is a maritime concept misapplied to land, and self-determination assistance creates a lawful exception to intervention prohibitions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary prohibition under Article 2(4) of the UN Charter, and what are its two main exceptions?
- What are the three requirements for a reprisal to be considered lawful use of force?
- What is Chapter 6Β½, and why was it created despite not being part of the UN Charter?
- Explain the Uniting for Peace Resolution of 1950 and when it applies.
- Why is hot pursuit considered an unlawful justification for land incursions, and what example illustrates this?