π Lecture 23 β BRAND EXTENSION/ DIVERSIFICATION
π Overview: This lecture explores the strategic practice of brand extension, where established brand names are used to enter different product categories. It presents the compelling reasons why companies prefer brand diversification over launching entirely new brands, including cost savings, higher success rates, and long-term survival. The discussion draws on research and market examples to show how this approach has become a dominant preference for brand and business managers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture systematically examines seven key reasons for brand extension/diversification: remaining modern and up to date, higher chances of success, cost of advertising, defending a brand at risk in its basic market, defining new segments, giving access to accumulated image capital, and ensuring brand survival. It supports these points with data from consulting firms, market examples like Guard, Sufi, Sohrab, Mitsubishi, and Philips, and visual illustrations of success rates and consumer adoption processes.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture builds on the previous discussion of line extensions to explore brand extension or diversification. Brand extension involves brands establishing themselves in different fields or categories, essentially a collection of different branded products sharing a common name. Examples include Mitsubishi and Philips globally, and locally, the Guard brand which spans oil filters and packaged rice, while Sufi (originally known for soaps) has diversified into edible oil and mineral water. The lecture explores why companies prefer to go across categories using their established brand names.
Why extend/diversify the brand
1. Remaining modern and up to date
Brand extension has become necessary for survival. Branding is a game where brands must surpass themselves and consumers' expectations by being responsive. Cars, electronics, and food items are tangible examples, while banking and courier services show how services are rationally defined and delivered as products of ever-increasing standards. Brands that rely solely on communication to update their image do not perform well.
π‘ Why this matters: To stay modern, brands must stay in tune with developments in consumers' habits and practices. As habits change, brands must also change. A salt brand extends into an iodized offering; a spice brand offers a curry recipe; a yogurt brand extends by offering hi-calcium yogurt for kids. If companies do not follow these practices, they risk being left behind. Possible setbacks in one area can be compensated by prompt developments in another, making this practice essential for resourceful companies.
2. Higher chances of success
Brand extensions, due to high awareness of established brand names and other related factors, have higher chances of success at lower costs. This was confirmed by a 1990 study by the OC&C consulting firm. The study's data (Figure 27) shows that brand extensions consistently have higher success rates than new brands across 5 years (Y1 through Y5), with rates like 100% vs 50%, 100% vs 30%, and 100% vs 0% in later years.
Retailers are more receptive to an existing brand and offer shelf space more readily to extensions than to new brands, as they always suspect new brands. The impact on consumers is also significant. A separate analysis by the same firm (Figure 28) demonstrates three key advantages of brand extensions over new brands: π Definition β Brand Extension Impact on Consumer Adoption Process: The measurable effects of using an established brand name on consumer trial, conversion, and loyalty rates. π Formula: Brand Extensions generate higher trial, higher conversion rates, and higher repeat purchase rates compared to new brands. π Example: The index comparison shows brand extensions achieve higher rates of:
- Trying known brands
- Converting to known brands
- Developing loyalty for known brands
The two factors of retailers' and consumers' patronage generate a higher level of trial, conversion, and loyalty.
3. Cost of advertising
Supporting a family of different brands through advertising is very expensive. Companies are putting an end to the practice of introducing new brands every time they launch a new product. Modern business practices and brand logic are based on competition, so it must be the objective of every company to save costs.
Companies must constantly look for new points of difference and surpass their own benchmarks, requiring continuous investment and reinvestment. To recover costs, volumes must be increased across categories to achieve high productivity and economies of scale. Cost-cutting is possible in advertising by selecting a few branded products bearing the same name to give mileage to all in various categories.
4. Defends a brand at risk in its basic market
There are situations in competitive environments where an established branded product faces serious threats due to:
- Stiff competition
- Shrinking category as a whole
- The need to catch up with new technologies
The best course of action for brand managers is to develop something new based on brand awareness, loyalty, quality image, and consumer sympathy. As an example, a bicycle manufacturer may enter the motorbike market due to one or a combination of these factors. The Sohrab brand of bicycles and motorbikes is a case in point.
5. Defines new segments
Brand extension helps define new segments. If a manufacturer of safety matches decides to enter the area of disposable lighters, they are venturing into a totally different industry. What is common is the target market that cuts across two industries (match lights and lighter lights), leading to creating two segments of the same market of "lights."
This involves multiple diverse efforts like making investment into a new plant and creating an appeal for a sub-segment of smokers from within the overall segment of users of lights. While it is an extension of an existing brand into a new industry, it is also an effort to define new segments within a market. The need may arise due to stiff competition or shrinking categories. Brand extension thus has the ability to draw fine lines within segments and define them by taking the lead.
6. Brand extension gives access to an accumulated image capital
Part of the high prices negotiated during takeovers of companies with established brands is the acquirer's intention to extend the brand immediately after the takeover, reaping profits from the image capital of the brand. Many companies internationally are known as good acquisition targets because they have established brands.
π Definition β Accumulated Image Capital: The stored brand value, awareness, and positive associations built over time that can be leveraged for new product categories.
Some brands have such high awareness that customers perceive them to be in categories where they are not present. A famous maker of jams may be perceived to be in the market of chutneys and pickles. Realizing this perception, companies feel obliged to enter those categories. This phenomenon is two-way (illustrated in Figure 29):
- On one hand, it motivates managers to acquire from the image capital of the acquired brand
- On the other hand, it lets extensions add to the cumulative image
The graphic (Figure 29) shows a cycle where:
- Existing Image Capital β Brand Extension
- Brand Extension adds to Accumulated Image Capital
- The Accumulated Image Capital is Reinforced
- This creates a reinforcing loop where the brand both draws from and contributes to its image capital
7. Essential for brand survival
It is absolutely essential to break away from the mono product to survive. All products have a life-cycle and are bound to decline. Before a product faces the implications of the law of obsolescence, companies must introduce another product as a strategic move into a diversified area. The product gains from the brand name yet remains independent, having its own meaning.
β Key Takeaways
Brand extension is a strategic necessity, not just an option, for modern brand survival because it allows companies to remain responsive to changing consumer habits while defending against market threats. The most compelling advantage is the higher rate of success at lower costsβconfirmed by OC&C research showing brand extensions achieve dramatically higher trial, conversion, and loyalty rates compared to new brand launches. Economically, extension saves substantial advertising costs by leveraging one brand name across multiple categories and enables economies of scale. Brand extension also provides access to and reinforces accumulated image capital, creating a virtuous cycle where the brand both draws from and contributes to its stored value. Finally, extension is essential for breaking free from the single-product trap, as all products have life cycles and will eventually decline unless the brand diversifies into new territories.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven key reasons for brand extension discussed in this lecture?
- According to the OC&C consulting firm study, what three consumer adoption metrics are higher for brand extensions compared to new brands?
- How does brand extension help a company defend a brand that is at risk in its basic market?
- What is "accumulated image capital" and how does brand extension create a reinforcing cycle with it?
- Why is breaking away from a mono-product strategy essential for long-term brand survival?
π Lecture 24 β POSITIONING β THE BASE OF EXTENSION
π Overview: This lecture explains how positioning serves as the foundation for brand extensions. It covers the three components of positioning that guide extensionsβtarget market, business definition, and point of differenceβand discusses the strategic deliberations that must occur before undertaking extensions. The lecture also addresses common mistakes to avoid, such as having a narrow vision or extending against brand essence.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers positioning as the key for brand extension, including extending the target market, extending the definition of business, extending the point of difference, and extending the entire positioning for brand diversification. It then discusses when to extend a brand, focusing on consistency with brand vision, upholding the overall brand picture, and consistency with overall positioning. Finally, it addresses additional deliberations such as avoiding narrow vision, ensuring awareness and reputation of the parent brand, and ensuring brand essence is applicable.
π Lecture Summary
Positioning as the key for extension
Positioning is central to brand strategy and lies at the core of extensions. The three components of positioningβthe definition of business, the target market, and the point of differenceβserve as guidelines for positioning. Any extensions being considered must stem from one or a combination of these three fundamental components.
Extending your target market
This extension involves defining new segments that will be served by a product with features differentiated from the basic product. A bicycle manufacturer getting into mountain bikes is extending the target market. A jeans manufacturer getting into comfortable and fashionable dress pants is again extending its target market of jeans. The emphasis here is on understanding the rationale for such extensions.
π Definition β Extending target market: Defining new customer segments to be served by a product with differentiated features from the basic product.
π Example: A bicycle manufacturer adding mountain bikes to its product line is extending its target market beyond regular bicycle users.
Extending the definition of business
Extension of segments or target market automatically leads you to extend your business definition. You now want to operate in more than one segment, which requires extending the definition of your business. Getting into more segments means redefining the scope of the market within which the company plans to operate to satisfy more than one need with more than one offering. Extending the target market cannot be viewed in isolation of extending the overall business.
π Definition β Extending definition of business: Redefining the scope of the market to operate in more than one segment, satisfying multiple needs with multiple offerings.
π Example: A jeans manufacturer moving into dress pants must redefine its overall business to include both casual and formal apparel markets.
Extending your point of difference
To make extensions meaningful, improved features with convincing benefits must be offered to customers. Small improvements are taken for granted by customers, who expect you to keep making those for the sake of contemporariness. Meaningful improvement addressing a different need justifies an extension of the existing product. Every time you come up with a new formula of packaged yogurt (fat-free, high-calcium, or fruit formula), you are improving the point of difference and deserve to extend the brand. Improvement can also be in package size to suit customer needs at different occasionsβthis refers to "brand for when" and "brand for whom". Each time a chip maker comes out with a faster chip, it extends the benefit and hence the point of difference.
π Definition β Extending point of difference: Offering extra benefits to customers through improved features that address different needs.
π Example: A yogurt brand introducing fat-free, high-calcium, or fruit formula variants is improving the point of difference and justifying brand extension.
Extending the entire positioning
Extending the brand on the basis of extension of the target market, overall business, and the point of difference relates to line extension. When we consider extending (diversifying/stretching) the brand into new areas, we extend the entire positioningβthis is new position. The examples of an oil filters manufacturer getting into rice husking, or a shoe company getting into foods explain this concept. It is risky, but if done with the right strategic deliberations, it can make a company follow the true portfolio approach to managing its brands. What bears importance is the need to add to image capital and not diminish it. Diversification must give the brand strength and supplement the overall brand picture.
π Definition β Extending entire positioning (brand extension): Diversifying or stretching the brand into new, unrelated areas by redefining the entire brand position.
π Example: An oil filters manufacturer getting into rice huskingβthis is a brand extension that changes the entire brand position.
π‘ Why this matters: Extending the entire positioning is the most risky form of extension but can be highly rewarding if aligned with strategic goals.
When should you extend your brand?
Brand extension is a very sensitive area that takes on highly strategic proportions. An extension should come by only with a strategic rationale supporting it. It must be undertaken to add strength and value to the brand and not diminish those. Before undertaking an extension, we must make strategic deliberations relating to three factors. We must make sure that the extension:
- Is consistent with the brand vision.
- Upholds the overall brand picture.
- Is consistent with overall positioning.
1. Consistency with brand vision
Vision tells you where you are and where you want to reach. You are clear about the financial gap that you have to fill. New introductions must be undertaken in that light keeping in view the bases of positioning. It was during development of the company vision and brand vision that you determined any related (line extension) or unrelated (brand extension) areas that you planned to enter. That vision must lay the foundation for decisions relating extensions.
π Definition β Consistency with brand vision: Ensuring that any extension aligns with the long-term direction and goals defined by the brand vision.
π Example (Fast food brand XYZ): If the vision is about restricting to the lunch market, extensions would stay within related segments. If the vision calls for getting into fast food targeting the lunch market as a starting point, extensions could include related lines like fried chicken.
π Example (Razor blades and shave market): A company in the shaving blades market defining its business as blades only must translate a vision of getting into shave creams, balms, and related products into creating brand extensions consistent with that vision.
2. Extension must uphold and strengthen brand picture
We know the image of our brand and the contract it fulfills and also where our brand stands against competition. Knowing this picture, we should not go wrong in extending our brand. If we have created the right brand picture, it almost guarantees the right kind of extendibility.
π Definition β Upholding brand picture: Ensuring that any extension reinforces the existing brand image and fulfills the brand contract with customers.
3. Consistency with overall positioning
The price, the target audience, the distribution, and the quality factors must form a position that offers extendibility possibilities. Any abuse of one or more factors amounts to deviating from the original position of the brand. To ensure consistencies, extensions must not:
- Detract customers from what the parent brand stands for
- Confuse the customers in making their choice (meaningful differences)
- Cannibalize your current brand
π Definition β Consistency with overall positioning: Ensuring that extensions maintain alignment with the brand's price, target audience, distribution, and quality factors.
A few more deliberations
These refer to things that should be avoided:
1. Not to have a narrow vision
Some companies keep the brand locked up by defining its scope in too narrow-minded a way. They forget that brands are broad-minded creatures with a caring character that like to respond to changing needs. The result is that the brand's real potential never bloomsβit becomes static or declines. The vision should not be narrow to the point that the future becomes hostage to too much focus on the past. The present must be given importance to determine brand's potential to stay up-to-date. The vision should also not be broad to the point that a company stretches it in all directionsβa brand cannot be everything to everybody.
π Example (Maggi at Nestle, Switzerland): Managers thought Maggi's image was old and launched new introductions with little connection to Maggi. By disassociating new introductions, they only reinforced Maggi's old image. They forgot that brands prove modernity by creating and offering new modern products.
π Example: A manufacturer of spark plugs staying too focused on the existing line cannot grow beyond a certain point by not going into other accessories. However, the same manufacturer should avoid getting into foods.
2. Awareness and reputation of the parent
Awareness and reputation always provide an advantage and must be present at the same time. Absence of one may harm the brand.
π Example (Levi's): Despite having high awareness, Levi's reputation for blue jeans did not transfer into formal clothing. The lesson is to be sensitively careful about extendibility if one factor does not seem to be working in favor of the brand. Do not do it if you are not 100% confident.
3. Brand essence should be applicable
Extension of overall business in certain situations stems from a common denominator.
π Example (Bic): Bic's brand essence is all about small disposable items like ballpoint pens, disposable lighters, and disposable razors. The denominator is disposability that gives Bic a position of similarity across categories. When Bic got into perfumes, it failedβthe character of perfumes did not have the element of disposability. Do not go against the essence of your brand, especially if the essence is very strong.
π Definition β Brand essence: The core, unchanging characteristic that defines a brand across different product categories.
β Key Takeaways
The three components of positioningβtarget market, business definition, and point of differenceβserve as the bases for line extensions, while extending the entire positioning leads to brand diversification. Before undertaking any extension, managers must ensure consistency with brand vision, that the extension upholds and strengthens the brand picture, and that it remains consistent with overall positioning regarding price, audience, distribution, and quality. Common mistakes to avoid include having a narrow vision that locks the brand's potential, extending into areas where the parent brand lacks both awareness and reputation simultaneously, and going against the brand's core essence as demonstrated by Maggi and Bic failures. Extensions must always add strength and value to the brand, not diminish them.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of positioning that serve as guidelines for extensions?
- How does extending the target market differ from extending the definition of business?
- What three strategic deliberations must be made before undertaking a brand extension?
- Explain the Maggi exampleβwhat mistake did managers make regarding brand vision?
- Why did Bic fail when it entered the perfume market, and what lesson does this teach about brand essence?
π Lecture 25 β Developing the Model of Brand Extension
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of strategic deliberations about what not to do regarding brand extensions, covering expertise transferability, perceived difficulty of manufacture, and complementarity. It then develops a three-step model for brand extension, explores the limitations of extensions, and introduces the concept of multi-brand portfolios, including how and why companies build them and the question of optimal portfolio size.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture reviews three final strategic factors for extensions (expertise and know-how transferability, perceived difficulty of manufacture, and complementarity/fit), then develops a model for brand extension with three steps: exploring opportunity areas, generating brand-based product ideas and analysis, and developing a brand extension strategy. It covers the limitations of extensions and introduces multi-brand portfolios, explaining how companies acquire multiple brands through growth and acquisitions, and the need for a smaller, more manageable portfolio.
π Lecture Summary
Continued Strategic Deliberations
The lecture continues with point 4 of strategic deliberations about what not to do regarding brand extensions. These factors help determine whether a brand extension is advisable.
4. Expertise and know-how transferability The brand must be believable in the new field. Customers should feel comfortable with the level of know-how the company is known for. For example, Sony can be trusted to undertake any electronics project, whereas a company in foods or fertilizers may not be believed to undertake such a venture. You may not extend unless you have the expertise and are perceived in the market for having the know-how to transfer to the new field.
5. Perceived difficulty of manufacture Consumers have a perception of how difficult or not difficult the manufacturing process is relating to an extension. If the process is perceived as difficult, a strong brand will benefit. If it is perceived as not so difficult, a strong brand may not have that big an advantage. You may not get into extension unless your existing brand is very strong and manufacturing of the new process is perceived difficult. Customers in that situation give complements by saying that only a reputable company with strong expertise could undertake such a challenging introduction.
6. The factor of "complementarity" or "fit" This means how comfortable the new product is with the old one. If there are emotional associations that run across the same kind of customers, the effort may be more fruitful. An accurate example could be a fashion clothing company getting into perfumes. Fashion clothing and perfumes have a lot of commonalities and associations among the target market. In the absence of such a fit, you may consider extendibility with apprehension.
π Definition β Complementarity/Fit: The degree of comfort and shared emotional associations between a new product and an existing product within a brand's portfolio.
π‘ Why this matters: Extensions should strengthen the brand and not weaken it. Incoherent and illogical extensions have the potential to diminish brand's value. Any company that may want to extend its brand must know where its brand stands vis-Γ -vis competition. It is the vision and the image parts coupled with the identification of customer needs (customer model) that help a company pinpoint when and where to extend. It is this strategic process that helps the company find the fit between the vision and the extension.
Developing the Model
With the understanding of the two well-explained concepts of extensions along with the fundamentals that lay the ground for extensions, we are now all set to developing a model for brand extension.
1. Explore opportunity areas This reflects looking into areas of unmet or not-well-met needs. You must identify the reasons why there are gaps in the market. Do the gaps exist due to distribution difficulties inherent in the product character? Or, most of the players have not had the requisite technology? Or, they have been plagued by shortage/absence of the quality human resource. If the company is able to address the unmet needs by outsmarting limitations of competitors, then it can assume the role of a leader in the segment.
2. Generate brand-based product ideas and analysis This step should not offer any difficulty in handling it, for you have identified the area of opportunity. You must come up with a few ideas that have a fit with the situation and your brand vision. Go through a process of screening, analyze the situation and select the best one in light of the consumer needs. A well-crafted concept must explain the features, attributes, and benefits of the product and how it is envisioned to be different from the existing one and from the competition. That will also address the positioning that you envisage for the product and the purchasers. You will also know to what extent the new entry will enhance the value of the brand.
3. Develop a brand extension strategy It defines the role the brand extension is going to play toward filling the financial growth gap in terms of revenues and other financial goals. It also explains the strategic marketing role the extension is going to play and hence how it will strengthen the overall brand's strength - the market share and position in the market. You explain the new product in all its forms including packaging, its reason for being, and the need it is going to satisfy. You must be very careful in deciding whether to go upwards or downwards in price, for both have their implications. You must take into account the differentiation factor in terms of distribution, if any. Explain the extensive role extension is going to play.
Limitations
Despite all the favorable factors for extensions, the concept has limitations. Not all the time extensions can fill all the gaps in the markets. In the words of a marketing expert, "there is a tremendous opportunity cost that we pay by going through extensions; by not creating a new brand; unfortunately, that cost is unquantifiable." By getting into the extension, it was a strong brand that was not created, says the author.
Multi-brand portfolio
In other words, this expert calls for introduction of new brands whenever the company has the right rationale to go for them. It is risky, more expensive, requires more time and energy, but most certainly offers a strong and a bright future to the company. The new brand can offer better coverage of the market and penetrate new, young, and emerging markets that could bring meaningful growth to the company.
The question of portfolio size
This author also goes on to say that we should not get into a large portfolio of brands by being too ambitious about brands' power and value. He advocates having a few brands within a portfolio for promotions to gain a significant market share. Marketing people always are addressing the question of how many brands should there be in a portfolio. There is no hard and fast rule to that. What is important to understand first is how does a company own so many different brands?
Owing to growth During periods of growth, companies like to introduce new brands each time they get into new segments and distribution channels. This is done to multiply the effect of existing and added channels and to make sure there is no conflict between the new and the old channels and the new and the old segments. They like to keep the conflict of interest away. The concept of having two different brands in two different value pyramids applies here. If you go back to the example of Toyota and Lexus, the concept becomes clear.
Owing to acquisitions Another reason for the growth of portfolios has been acquisitions and mergers, which brought more and more brands to companies β a discussion that took place earlier in relation to company's strategy to acquire strong brands. Although it was on purpose (an assortment of powerful brands in markets across geographic boundaries), it did present the senior marketing and other managers with a challenge they now have to face.
Need to have a small portfolio Bringing all the brands into public limelight is difficult, for that can come only through meaningful communication, which is expensive. Generally, the need is to manage a portfolio with a few brands, which is manageable in line with a company's resources. With competition increasing, there is a dire need to achieve productivity gains and cost efficiencies. You cannot do that with a big portfolio. Production and research facilities are being regrouped to save costs (pharmaceuticals in particular). It is the same factories producing different brands with features different. But, there should be a limit to variations coming from the same factories. With brands becoming international and having international appeal, they are no longer meant for certain territories within national borders. This leads one to believe that one should be having a few in a portfolio thus making it manageable. The investment required for a large international presence is massive to handle a large portfolio, and, hence, a smaller one. The question of how many brands should be retained in a portfolio is to be answered by looking carefully into the strategic roles assigned to and played by different brands. This implies that it must be linked to an analysis of the brands' functions in their respective markets.
β Key Takeaways
The strategic factors of expertise transferability, perceived manufacturing difficulty, and complementarity must all be favorable for a brand extension to strengthen rather than weaken the brand. The three-step brand extension model requires first exploring unmet opportunity areas, then generating and screening brand-based product ideas with a well-crafted concept, and finally developing a clear extension strategy covering financial goals, marketing role, pricing direction, and distribution differentiation. Extensions have limitations and carry an opportunity cost of not creating a new strong brand, which justifies developing multi-brand portfolios when rationale exists. Companies often build large brand portfolios through organic growth into new segments and channels or through acquisitions and mergers. Despite this, the trend is toward smaller, more manageable portfolios driven by cost efficiencies, internationalization, and the need for focused communication and resource allocation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "complementarity" or "fit" factor in brand extension, and can you provide an example?
- What are the three steps in the model for developing a brand extension?
- What is the "opportunity cost" of brand extension mentioned by Kapferer?
- What are two primary ways companies come to own multiple brands in their portfolio?
- Why is there a need to maintain a small brand portfolio?
π Lecture 26 β Brand Portfolio
π Overview: This lecture explains why companies often need multiple brands rather than relying solely on line and brand extensions. It covers the logic behind brand portfolios, how they correspond to market segmentation, the specific reasons for having different brands, and the constraints that must be managed for a successful multi-brand strategy.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing the concept of brand portfolios as a solution to the limitations of extensions, using a hotel chain example to illustrate segmentation needs. It then explains the relationship between segment variance and the necessity of different brand names, followed by a detailed list of seven reasons that make different brands necessary, including collective market play, market coverage, and protecting the main brand image. Finally, it covers key constraints such as maintaining clear meanings and managing costs, concluding with steps for developing a multi-brand portfolio model.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
Due to the limitations inherent in line and brand extensions, companies must often develop a portfolio of brands. Portfolios offer significant advantages but also come with disadvantages. This lecture discusses both sides of this strategic approach.
Brand portfolio and segmentation
Every market can be segmented by product, customer expectation, or type of customer. For example, a hotel chain may have three-, four-, and five-star hotels. Each segment addresses different customer needs:
- Three-star customers are economy-oriented, seeking neat accommodation with no frills at affordable pricing in a middle-class area.
- Five-star customers desire high comfort, pampering, sophisticated ambience, and high status.
- Four-star customers fall in between.
This variance makes it obvious that a company should not sell its services through three kinds of hotels under the same brand name. Using one name would confuse customers: five-star guests would feel degraded, while three- and four-star guests would expect upgraded service at lower prices. The company must use different brand names for the simple reason that all three products relate to a particular set of corporate objectives through segmentation and differentiation.
The decision on the number of brands depends on corporate objectives, the degree of competition, and the companyβs resources. This is a multi-stage process driven by a historical study of the segments. All strategies flow out of segmentation and differentiation, which owe to the external growth factor of the total category. To address differentiation, you cannot successfully have just one brand do all the jobs.
Segment variance
If the variance in terms of segments is too broad (like the hotel example), one brand will work at cross purposes. You must have different brands. If the variance is narrow, you may go for an extension, though you may still need a distinction in name that signifies differentiation (e.g., calling one "economy" and the other "executive").
By competing at the bottom of the top segment, you are defining new boundaries, repositioning the competition, and keeping it off-limits to your top-of-the-line offering. The variance in segmentation corresponds to different positions on the positioning grid, which necessitate different brand names. A multiple brand policy corresponds to a segmented market where various expectations in each segment are not only different, but also seen as incompatible by consumers.
Customers in an upscale segment will never accept the same brand name unless there is differentiation between their brand and the one perceived as inferior.
As a comparison:
- Brand extensions correspond to a strategy of domination and competitive advantage via low costs.
- Multi-brand strategy is a logical consequence of a differentiation strategy and cannot coexist with low costs due to reduced scale economies, technical specialization, specific sales networks, and necessary advertising budgets.
However, this does not mean companies are prepared to spend unlimited sums. The objective to cut costs never escapes managersβ attention. They try to offer differentiation at the end of the production process, making brands appear different while achieving productivity gains via fragmentation of the assembly line. This kills two birds with one stone: achieving differentiation and reaping the benefits of the learning curve. Most multi-brands of cars (e.g., Toyota models like "Altis") make use of such productive gains.
What makes it necessary to have different brands?
1. Collective play One brand cannot develop the market alone. It is the collective positions and communication campaigns of different players that educate customers about different features. When players collectively promote their respective differences, it promotes the market collectively and improves the whole category. Multiplication of players becomes essential.
2. Market coverage Multiple players automatically strengthen the concept of segmentation, as they opt for different segments by positioning themselves uniquely. This leads to coverage of the market that is not possible with just one brand. Different Price-Quality-Indexes (PQIs) emerge, and one brand revolving around all PQIs is bound to lose its identity.
3. Effective fight to competition You can introduce a new brand to position it right below established competitorsβ pricing. You do not do this with the original brand, as that would cut its pricing and hurt its image. This allows you to create the territory of marketing battle away from your original brand.
4. Fills the market and keeps the competition out This offers an opportunity in line with the fundamental that multiplication of players is important. A strong player can take on the role of a multi-supplier by having different brands, thus keeping competition out.
5. Protects the main brand image If the new entry is not successful, it does not hurt the original brand.
6. Responsive to retailersβ needs A multi-brand policy fulfills the needs of different retailers who cater to different levels of clientele. The identity of retailers is defined by the selection of different brands they carry and specialize in selling.
7. Takes over where extensions feel limited A multi-brand policy emerges from the limitation of extensions to look after all segments. A sophisticated market is bound to be confused by an extension of one brand if it addresses different quality and needs-fulfilling criteria. Electronics offer a perfect example, where Japanese companies offer more than one brand to be sensitive to different psychographics:
- Customers who buy on technical innovation and don't care about price.
- Customers who buy on basic need-fulfillment and are economy-oriented.
- Customers who buy on reliability and durability.
Constraints
1. Clear meanings In multi-brand portfolios, each brand must have its clear meaning. If the differential between brands is minimal and not meaningful, both customers and sales people will feel confused and offended.
2. Cost management Costs always remain a prime objective. Companies try to keep common features, but must not expose these to the point of undesirability. If consumers perceive commonalities as unappealing or offending, managing costs for the sake of keeping them low can endanger the brandβs image capital. Businesses must maintain a balance between cost management and image capital.
Developing the model β multi-brand portfolio
Just like brand extensions, the process follows these steps:
- Look for opportunities and growth areas.
- Analyze and assess the potential each opportunity offers in targeting customers in each segment.
- Go for the brand strategy that explains its positioning, its reason for being, and the strategic framework for execution of tactics.
β Key Takeaways
A brand portfolio is necessary when market segments are too diverse for a single brand to serve effectively without causing confusion or brand dilution. Multiple brands allow a company to cover the market, fight competition effectively, protect the main brand from failure or price cuts, and meet the needs of different retailers and customer psychographics. However, each brand in a portfolio must have a clear, meaningful point of difference, and companies must carefully balance cost savings from shared components against the risk of damaging a brand's image capital.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why would a hotel chain use different brand names for its three-star, four-star, and five-star properties instead of using one name?
- What is the key difference in strategic objective between a brand extension strategy and a multi-brand strategy?
- List four reasons that make it necessary for a company to have multiple brands in its portfolio.
- What are the two main constraints or risks that companies must manage when implementing a multi-brand portfolio?
- Describe the three initial steps for developing a multi-brand portfolio model.
π Lecture 27 β BRAND ARCHITECTURE
π Overview: This lecture explains how brands within a company do not operate in isolation but form a structured system called brand architecture. It explores the different branding strategies companies use to name, organize, and manage their product portfolios. Understanding these strategies is critical for managing brand complexity and creating coherent market offerings.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces the concept of brand architecture and then examines six distinct branding strategies: the Product Brand Strategy (PBS), the Line Brand Strategy (LBS), the Range Brand Strategy, and the Umbrella Brand Strategy. Each strategy is analyzed for its definition, benefits, and drawbacks, with examples provided for each.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
All brands, regardless of their origin (stand-alone, line extension, or diversification), do not work in isolation. They are linked through corporate strategies and managed as a portfolio. The relationships between brands often create hybrid forms, making it difficult to draw clear boundaries between them. This complexity requires a formal system for management.
Brand architecture
There is a close relationship between brands and products; brands distinguish products and indicate their origin. To manage this, companies need a system to name and organize their products. This system, driven by company branding policies, is known as brand architecture.
Branding strategies
This system can be understood by looking at how companies develop the brand-product relationship, giving each brand a separate role. A study has revealed six different strategies.
1. The product brand strategy β PBS
This strategy involves assigning one particular name to one particular product. Each name reflects just one positioning and is restricted to that positioning. A new position requires a new brand name. P&G has adopted this as its brand management philosophy, with different brands for different positions in detergents and soaps.
π Definition β Product Brand Strategy (PBS): A strategy where each product is given a unique brand name with its own exclusive positioning and identity, operating independently of others.
π Example: P&G markets one soap for skin-enhancing properties, another for energy, another for family use, and a medicated one. Similarly, one detergent is positioned as best for stain removal, another for overall neatness, and another for best value for money.
The benefits are:
- Resourceful companies create a multiplication-of-supplier-effect, energizing the category with multiple brands.
- A big manufacturer can occupy and dominate all functional segments, consolidating market share.
- Different products help customers identify differences better than extensions with external similarities.
- The company name may not be highlighted, so the failure of one brand does not affect others.
Drawbacks of the product brand strategy:
- Each brand launch is expensive due to communication costs.
- Retailers resist stocking new products, skeptical of their success.
- Multiplication of brands in narrow segments demands quick return on investment, only possible in new markets.
- A new brand cannot benefit from the success of another within the portfolio.
- Distributors give the brand little patronage despite company reputation.
2. The line brand strategy β LBS
This strategy deals with extensions. Meaningful success of a brand can motivate extending the line. The objective is to offer coherent products under the same brand name.
π Definition β Line Brand Strategy (LBS): A strategy that extends a successful brand into complementary products that have emotional appeal across the same clientele, staying close to the central theme.
π Example: Upon the success of a lipstick brand, the manufacturer gets into complementing products like mascara and cleansing cream, exploiting the success of the concept.
The benefits are:
- Marginal costs linked to distribution and packaging.
- Reinforces the selling power of the brand and the image.
- Leads to ease of distribution.
- Reduces launch costs.
The drawback is:
- You must stay very close to the existing product.
3. Range brand strategy
This strategy offers one brand name through a single promise for a range of products belonging to the same area of competence.
π Definition β Range Brand Strategy: A strategy where a single brand name with a unique concept is used for a range of products within the same area of competence.
π Example: Common among food items (soups, sauces) and the luggage industry (suitcases, briefcases, attaches).
4. The umbrella brand strategy
When the same brand supports several products in different markets, it is known as the umbrella brand.
π Definition β Umbrella Brand Strategy: A strategy where a single brand name supports products in multiple, different markets, capitalizing on the core brand's strength and reputation.
π Example: Yamaha (bikes, pianos, guitars), Philips (bulbs, shavers, televisions), Mitsubishi (banks, shipbuilding, cars, foods).
The main benefits are:
- Capitalizes on the strength of one product and gains scale economies in other markets.
- Instantaneous goodwill can be generated if the brand is well-known and enjoys great reputation.
- Firms of great reputation can save a lot on communications when entering new markets.
- The core brand gains strength from associations in new areas, reinforcing its image capital.
The drawbacks are:
- Each division must compete against a specialist brand in its segment, needing to prove it matches or excels in quality.
- They must prove the relevance of each product; mere awareness doesn't work. π‘ Why this matters: Since the umbrella strategy stretches into uncharted categories, there should be a limit. Beyond a certain point, the brand weakens and loses force. This is called the rubber effect.
β Key Takeaways
Brand architecture is the formal system for naming and organizing products. The Product Brand Strategy (PBS) allows for precise positioning and risk isolation but is expensive and requires new launches. The Line Brand Strategy exploits a successful concept through complementary products with lower costs. The Range Brand Strategy uses one brand name and promise for a category of similar products. The Umbrella Brand Strategy uses a single brand across different markets for economies of scale but risks the "rubber effect" if stretched too far. For the exam, you must be able to define each strategy, state its benefits and drawbacks, and provide a clear example.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between a Product Brand Strategy and a Line Brand Strategy?
- Describe two benefits and one major risk associated with an Umbrella Brand Strategy.
- What is the "multiplication-of-supplier-effect" and which branding strategy does it benefit?
- In the Range Brand Strategy, what is communicated to all product subjects, and how does it differ from the Line Brand Strategy's communication?
- Explain the "rubber effect" in relation to the Umbrella Brand Strategy.