ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the communication model's impact on credibility, including source credibility definitions and components, commercial source credibility factors such as past performance and brand equity, spokesperson credibility and synergy requirements, endorser credibility for sales personnel, message credibility and positioning considerations, the effect of time on source credibility, and the role of mood in message decoding.
π Lecture Summary
Credibility of the source
Source credibility is defined as the positive characteristics of the encoder which positively affect the decoder's acceptance of the communicated message (Ohanian 1991). It is used to determine the persuasiveness of a message (Petty and Cacioppo 1986). Marketers seek sources with good reputation in the market. The source of the message is normally the organization, but there is a source person who transmits the message to customers. Organizations use other objects to send the message to the target audience.
π Definition β Source Credibility: The positive characteristics of the encoder that positively affect the decoder's acceptance of the communicated message.
π‘ Why this matters: The credibility of the source directly determines whether consumers will accept or reject a marketing message, making it a foundational element of persuasive communication.
Credibility of the Commercial Source
Commercial source means the information conveyed through media by advertisements. The credibility of the commercial source rests on several factors:
- Past performance: The organization's past performance has significant impact on the credibility of the information
- Reputation in terms of known quality: Perceived quality is a major construct in building brand equity
- Quality and image of other products: Not only the promoted product but also other products create credibility
- Brand equity: Defined as "value added by a brand name to a product" (Keller, 1993), with four dimensions: brand awareness, brand perceived quality, brand associations, and brand loyalty
- Image or attractiveness of spokesperson/brand ambassador: Personality impacts brands significantly. For example, Ali Zafar as brand ambassador for Mobilink Jazz positively impacts brand credibility
- Type of outlet used for selling/retailing: A good outlet design and environment adds to positive brand credibility
- Taking a position of social responsibility in communication improves credibility
π Definition β Commercial Source: Information conveyed through media by advertisements, whose credibility depends on organizational factors like past performance, reputation, and brand equity.
π Definition β Brand Equity: The value added by a brand name to a product, consisting of four dimensions: brand awareness, brand perceived quality, brand associations, and brand loyalty.
Spokes Person Credibility
A spokes person is the one who speaks positively about the brand, such as a public relations manager. Marketers must be very careful in selecting spokespersons as the effectiveness of the spokesperson related to the message speaks to the credibility of the brand. For example, if your message is technical in nature or about a technical product and the spokesperson selected is a cricketer, people know this person is not technically expert and will not rely on him. Hence, the message and spokesperson must be congruent.
Synergy between endorser and product
There must be synergy between endorser and product. For example, toothpaste endorsed by a dentist demonstrates synergy between the endorser and the product. Attractiveness relates to physically attractive models but does not suit every product category. For instance, when buying a camera, a good photographer is more relevant to endorse the product than a model, as consumers are more conscious about the quality of results.
Synergy between endorser and target market
Synergy between endorser and target market is also important. For example, if Shahid Afridi endorses Pakistan Railways, there is no synergy between them; however, synergy of Shahid Afridi and Pepsi is acceptable.
Synergy between endorser and ad vs. corporate and brand
A spokes person cannot replace a corporate brand. For example, if a corporate brand is well known, an attractive person may not contribute to credibility as people already know the brand.
Synergy between words and product
For example, a tennis star might talk about pain killer/relieving gel and how effective it is on pain, but cannot be believed if he gives the chemical details of the gel.
π Definition β Spokes Person Credibility: The effectiveness of a spokesperson related to the message that speaks to the credibility of the brand, requiring congruence between the message and spokesperson.
Endorser Credibility
Quality and credibility of the sales person is also critical. Even the way a sales person approaches the customer has an effect. Therefore, sales persons should be credible. For example, when selling a car or motorcycle, the sales person's credibility raises questions for the customer about whether to choose the product. Therefore, sometimes sales persons are given good dress to create an impact on credibility.
π Definition β Endorser Credibility: The quality and credibility of sales personnel, where their approach and presentation affect customer perceptions and purchase decisions.
Message Credibility
Message has to be believable. Positioning also impacts credibility. For example, if you initially position your product to the elite class but fail in that target market, then plan to target the middle class, everyone is aware of the product's failure and no one will buy it. A sudden change in position and message can create a question mark for consumers. Similarly, the credibility of media also impacts significantly. For example, an advertisement in Dawn versus Dophair Newspaper will create a different perception in consumers' minds.
π Definition β Message Credibility: The believability of the communication, influenced by positioning consistency and the credibility of the media channel used.
Effect of Time on Source Credibility
Credibility impact is not forever; it changes over time. If information was passed two weeks ago and you purchase today, there are chances you forget some information and may not consider that brand as credible. Research shows that both positive and negative effects remain for six weeks. If due to source or person's credibility, market image becomes negative, the source or person can be changed at any time to convert negative image to positive image.
π Definition β Time Effect on Credibility: The phenomenon where credibility impact diminishes over time, with research showing positive and negative effects lasting approximately six weeks.
π‘ Why this matters: The six-week window means marketers must reinforce credibility through consistent messaging and may need to change sources to combat negative perceptions.
Mood
Mood has an impact on the decoding of the message and is an important component in marketing that helps in deciding about the message. For example, a cheerful or happy person will try to see humorous ads rather than emotional ads. Conversely, an unhappy person will consider ads accordingly. For example, ads of cosmetics, drinks, fashion, and perfumes require focusing on feelings and emotions. It is not only the ads and message moods, but also the moods of consumers that have an impact.
π Definition β Mood in Communication: The emotional state of the consumer that influences how they decode and respond to marketing messages.
β Key Takeaways
Source credibility is the positive characteristics of the encoder that affect decoder's message acceptance, determined by factors like past performance, reputation, brand equity, spokesperson attractiveness, outlet type, and social responsibility. Spokesperson credibility requires synergy between the endorser and product, target market, brand, and message content β a technical product needs a technical expert, not merely a celebrity. Message credibility demands consistency in positioning, as sudden changes can create consumer doubt, while media choice also impacts perceived credibility. The effect of source credibility diminishes over time, with research showing both positive and negative effects lasting approximately six weeks, after which marketers may need to change sources. Finally, consumer mood significantly affects message decoding, with happy consumers preferring humorous ads and unhappy consumers responding differently, requiring marketers to match message tone with emotional states.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight factors that determine the credibility of a commercial source?
- Explain the four dimensions of brand equity as identified by Keller (1993).
- Why must there be synergy between the endorser and the product? Provide an example.
- How long do the effects of source credibility typically last according to research?
- How does consumer mood affect the decoding of marketing messages? Give an example.
π Lecture 25 β Communication Strategy
π Overview: This lecture explores the barriers that hinder effective communication and discusses how marketers can measure advertising effectiveness. It then introduces the communication strategy perspective, detailing the key components and strategic decisions involved in crafting successful marketing messages.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers barriers of communication (physical, psychological, linguistic, and feedback loops), techniques for measuring advertising effectiveness (exposure, message attention, recall, and recognition), and introduces the communication strategy model. It details the sender, message, channel, receiver, and feedback components, and outlines four key strategic areas: objective, target, media, and message strategy, including positive and negative framing.
π Lecture Summary
Barriers of Communication
Barriers normally occur in communication regardless of how effective the system is. These can be caused by physical barriers like the nature of the environment, surrounding noises, poor lighting, or improper technological arrangements. Psychological barriers may result from a person's personal discomfort, such as poor listening skills, poor eyesight, or hearing difficulties. An individual's linguistic ability can also create barriers through the use of difficult or inappropriate words, poorly explained messages, or jargon.
The feedback loop is an important component in the communication process. Since the goal of communication is to create awareness and to measure whether that awareness has been achieved, marketers need to conduct research to understand customer feedback. For example, if a message about a discount offer is released, an increase in sales indicates positive feedback, while a decrease signals negative feedback. Feedback is provided through interpersonal communication and changes in sales volume. After receiving feedback, marketers must refocus their strategies to ensure the message is properly understood.
Marketers need to decrease the possibilities of barriers so the message can be properly transmitted. This is done by measuring feedback through various techniques.
Advertising Effectiveness Research
Marketers need to conduct research about the effectiveness of advertising. One way is by comparing pre-ad sales with post-ad sales. If there is a positive difference, the advertising was effective. For example, ads for 'seasonal clearance sales' are easier to evaluate; if the material is sold immediately, it shows the advertisement's effectiveness.
Measure of exposure involves two areas: how many saw the ad and who saw the ad. To determine this, marketers need audience profiles including demographics and segments. This detail helps find out consumer choices so strategies can be devised accordingly.
Message attention is one of the important objectives of advertisement. Marketers need to create content that captures consumer attention. Different methodologies are used, including:
- Eye Tracking β store shelf placements have become a science for catching eyes. Cameras track where consumers' eyes stay, and that specific place is considered important for product placement.
- Movement of facial muscles β facial expressions reveal consumer feelings when watching advertisements. Facial Electromyography is used to observe these feelings about the message.
- Message Recall and Recognition β these aspects measure product awareness in customers. Recall is measured by asking consumers to remember the commercials they have watched. If a person remembers advertisements but cannot recall yours, you need to pay more focus on the advertisement's content, design, and features. Recognition involves showing consumers cues and asking them to identify what the cues relate to.
π Definition β Facial Electromyography: A technique used to observe consumer feelings by measuring facial muscle movements when they watch advertisements. π‘ Why this matters: Marketers use these research methods to move beyond guesswork and empirically verify whether their communication strategies are actually reaching and influencing their target audience.
Communication Strategy
The communication model is now discussed through a communication strategy perspective. The sender can send a message through a commercial or non-commercial channel. The message can be verbal, non-verbal, one-sided or two-sided, and based on facts or emotions. Whatever the type, the message should be based on facts and figures and communicated properly. It passes through a specific channel which can be paid or non-paid, broadcasted or electronic. If the channel is appropriate, the likelihood of proper communication is high. The receiver will decode the message. Positive feedback is expected if the decoder receives the message appropriately; if the message is miscomprehended, feedback will be inappropriate.
Four key points should be clear when communicating:
- Objective of communication β Since the objective is to create awareness, proper focus on the model should be given to create awareness correctly.
- Select Target Strategy β For good communication, marketers need to focus on the target market and select a strategy accordingly. This requires examining demographics and other important components related to the target market to create an understandable message.
- Select Media Strategy β Choosing an appropriate media is very necessary. For example, if the target market is in a rural area with no electricity, TV would not be an appropriate channel.
- Select Message Strategy β This requires focusing on framing of the message. In positive framing, the positive benefits that can be secured are shown in the advertisement. In negative framing, the negative things that can occur from not using the product are shown.
π Definition β Framing: The way a message is presented to the audience, which can be either positive (showing benefits of using the product) or negative (showing consequences of not using the product). π Formula: Communication Strategy = Objective + Target Strategy + Media Strategy + Message Strategy β A comprehensive plan ensuring the right message reaches the right audience through the right channel.
β Key Takeaways
For an exam, a student must remember that communication barriers include physical, psychological, and linguistic factors, and that the feedback loop is critical for measuring communication success. Advertising effectiveness can be measured through pre/post-sales comparison, exposure metrics, and attention-measuring techniques like eye tracking and facial electromyography. The communication strategy model includes sender, message, channel, receiver, and feedback, with the message needing proper framing. Finally, the four strategic decisionsβobjective, target, media, and message strategyβmust be aligned to ensure effective communication.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main categories of communication barriers discussed in the lecture, and give one example of each?
- Describe two methodologies used to measure "message attention" in advertising effectiveness research.
- What is the difference between message recall and message recognition?
- In the communication strategy model, what determines whether feedback will be positive or inappropriate?
- Explain the difference between positive framing and negative framing in message strategy, and give a potential example of each.
π Lecture 26 β Marketing Communications and Ethics
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on communication strategies, focusing on how messages are delivered to target consumers through media selection, and how messages are structured, framed, and presented. It provides a detailed exploration of message strategy components, including resonance theory, message framing, one-sided vs. two-sided arguments, comparative advertising, order effects, repetition, and various advertising appeals. These concepts are essential for designing effective marketing communications that persuade target audiences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the remaining steps of communication strategies: selecting a media strategy based on target market and media characteristics; selecting a message strategy, including the structure and presentation using resonance theory, message framing (positive vs. negative), one-sided vs. two-sided messages, comparative advertising, order effects (primacy and recency), repetition, and advertising appeals (fear, humor, and abrasive). Each topic is explained with examples and their impact on consumer behavior.
π Lecture Summary
Select Media Strategy
Media strategy is concerned with how messages will be delivered to the target consumers. For a good marketing strategy, marketers need to identify the characteristics of the target market, and characteristics of the media that can be used to deliver the message to the target market. Different channels of media can be used to deliver the message to the target audiences like advertising on TV, radio, print media like billboards, newspaper, magazines, and internet etc. For this purpose, advertisers need to develop profiles of their target customers including specific media they read or watch and then decide which mode can be the best to use. Decision about the selection depends on the product/service and the marketing objective.
Select Message Strategy
Message is an idea, thought, attitude, image or other information that senders want to convey to the receiver or the target market. Sender must know what is to be said and how it is to be said. Message will be different for different target markets, for example, the message which is communicated to the business manager will be obviously different than the message for students. Similarly, message for rural area target market must be different than the one which is for urban target market. Important thing is that the message should also match the characteristics of the product. An important thing to know is about how we persuade the message so that they can decide about the product. For this purpose, we have an elaboration likelihood model where we need to focus on high involvement (central route to persuasion) and low involvement (peripheral route of persuasion).
- Structure and Presentation
When we talk about the structure of the message and its presentation, we need to pay little attention to the concept of Resonance Theory. It is normally used for visual creation so that the message can be recalled. For example, when you are sitting on a bus to have a long travel, there are chances of vomiting and when you take the seat belt, you observed that the shape of buckle is like a tablet used for vomit protection. Hence you recalled the medicine. In resonance theory, we normally create some interesting scenario so that the specific message could be recalled.
- Message Framing
You can frame the message by giving the positive things as well as negative things. Positive frame means that all the arguments which you give in are desirable for your target audience. Negative frame would be when you say what the person will lose if you do not use them. For example, you send a message to the target audience about the negative effects of Cigarette by saying Cigarette will destroy your health. Again it depends on the type of individual, consumer attitude and product characteristics. If an individual think about his self image, he will perceive positive frame and will look what are the things that can give him benefits. But negative frame will be quite dominant for them who are looking to the external factors. While talking about the time, research suggest that if there is more processing time then we go positive frame whereas if there is less processing time then we go for negative frame.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice of positive or negative framing directly influences how a consumer processes the message and can significantly affect the persuasiveness of the communication.
- One sided vs. two sided
This concept talk about whether we communicate only one thing which talks about the positive characteristics or we can talk about the negative sides as well. Two sided means the situation where customer can see the counter claim. It is suggested that if customers can counter claim your message then both positive and negative frames can be used and you can balance out the information. For example, hair oil making company who promoted their oil by saying that our oil will grow the hairs. Result show that 60% customers say they felt growth in hairs, 34 % observed small growth and 16% observed no growth. Here, actually company presented the negative frame also by saying that this oil is useful for every body and if any competitors make the counter statement that there are some customers who didn't get any advantage, then this will be very dangerous for oil making company.
- Comparative Advertisement
Some people donβt like this advertisement. But there are certain advantages of using comparative advertising. By using this advertising, it is easy to get compete on basis of positioning. It also helps in selecting the target market. For example, you suggest the things which are not advertised by the competitors. Negative thing is most of the people say that using competitive advertising is recalling the customers about your competitors so it is not good. It also say that comparative advertising mislead the customers. For example, if you say βwe are number oneβ. So it is hard to say number one without significant proof and customers know it very well who is number one in that specific product category. So these types of statements will negatively impact on your brand.
- Order effects
It means whether you place your ad in the beginning, in the middle or at the end. Each area has its own effectiveness. Normally it is considered that ads in the first page or last page are very good because people often see these pages more carefully. First page ad is considered as Primacy effect and last page ad is considered as Regency effect which says that last ad will have more effect. So we need to take care of these issues in order to place our advertisement in the right place.
- Repetition
Recall and repetition is linked together. Therefore, you need to float the message again and again so that the message could be easily recalled by the target audience.
- Advertising appeals
We can use different types of appeals in our advertising like fear appeal, humor appeal or the abrasive appeal. Now we will discuss each one in detail.
- Fear: In fear, we can produce two different sides one can be mild fear which means touching the scarce areas of the personβs life and other is strong appeal. And it is considered that if you pay focus too much then people will start rejecting. Sometimes people take immunity types of personal disaster where they strongly believe that this cannot happen to me. Another situation where people use diffusion to satisfy themselves. For example, if any one asks a chain smoker not to use cigarette and he replies that I am using filters. So here, he is trying to use diffusion to satisfy his inner feelings. This kind of approach helps the person to avoid dissonance.
- Humor: Humor is considered more persuasive appeals and is more effective than fear. In Pakistan, mostly ads are humorous which vary from audience to audience.
- Abrasive: Abrasive is the one when you show unpleasant kind of scenes such as showing insects or showing inside of stomachs for heartburns, clogged nose etc. These are not appealing advertisements so are not exciting for the customers.
β Key Takeaways
A marketer must choose a media strategy by matching the target market's media consumption habits with the characteristics of available channels. The message itself must be carefully crafted using resonance theory to aid recall, and framed positively or negatively based on consumer self-image and processing time. To build credibility and defend against competitor counterclaims, two-sided messages that acknowledge potential drawbacks can be highly effective. Comparative advertising can help position a brand but risks reminding consumers of competitors or being perceived as misleading. Finally, advertising appeals like fear, humor, and abrasive styles each have distinct effects on consumer persuasion and must be chosen carefully to avoid rejection or disinterest.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of media strategy in marketing communications?
- How does resonance theory help in designing the structure and presentation of a message?
- According to the lecture, when is a negative frame more effective than a positive frame for a message?
- What is the key advantage of using a two-sided message, as illustrated by the hair oil company example?
- List the three types of advertising appeals discussed in the lecture and briefly describe the potential pitfall of using a strong fear appeal.
π Lecture 27 β INFLUENCE
π Overview: This lecture covers communication, ethics, and reference groups in consumer behavior. It explains how reference groups influence consumer decisions and examines the ethical considerations marketers must observe in their communications. Understanding these concepts is crucial for developing effective marketing strategies that respect societal norms.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a discussion of ethics in marketing communications, then defines groups and reference groups (normative and comparative). It explores factors affecting reference group influence (information/experience, credibility/attractiveness/power, conspicuousness of product), group influence mechanisms, and six selected consumer-related reference groups: friendship, shopping, work, virtual, brand communities, and consumer action groups.
π Lecture Summary
Marketing Communications and Ethics
It is very important to consider ethics while making communication. Marketers need to take care of things that are useful for the society. For example, late night packages offered by phone companies are spoiling educational activities, making it an unethical exercise. Marketers must also be careful in using language that should not directly impact individuals or groups' character.
π‘ Why this matters: Ethical communication builds trust and protects the brand's long-term reputation.
Reference Groups and their Influence on Consumer Behavior
First, we need to define what a group is. A group consists of two or more people who interact whether in an intimate setting or in a formal work place. There are one-sided groups (e.g., models in advertising communicating with customers on a one-sided basis where customers can see the message but cannot respond) and two-sided groups. These groups in the later stage become reference groups.
A reference group is the person or group which serves as a point of comparison for attitudes and values or guides behaviors. Researchers interpret reference group as any group that individuals use as a standard for evaluating themselves and their own behavior. These groups are of two types:
- Normative Group: The group that affects behaviors directly, like family in food or dress code, and influences the development of basic behavior.
- Comparative Group: The group to whom you compare your lifestyle, see the difference, and then try to adopt the things you do not have. For example, a neighbor whose lifestyle is admirable and worthy of imitation in furnishing, so you also try to adopt the same things.
π Definition β Group: Two or more people who interact, whether in an intimate setting or a formal workplace. π Definition β Reference Group: A person or group that serves as a point of comparison for attitudes and values or guides behaviors. Used as a standard for evaluating oneself and one's own behavior. π Definition β Normative Group: A reference group that affects behaviors directly and influences the development of basic behavior (e.g., family). π Definition β Comparative Group: A reference group to whom you compare your lifestyle and try to adopt things you do not have (e.g., an admirable neighbor).
Factors that affect influence
Researchers have elaborated three components which influence the influence of reference groups on consumer behavior:
-
Information and Experience: If we have experience of using the product or service, then we don't need to get information from anyone. But if we haven't experienced the product or service yet, then we need to get information from any individual or group who has experience with that specific product or service.
-
Credibility, Attractiveness and Power: Credibility plays a very important role in building behavior. If the reference group itself is credible, customers will tend to be more influenced, but if the group is not reliable, it will have a negative impression of the product/service on consumers' behavior. Therefore, marketers need to investigate the groups, their credulity, and the customer's perception about these groups before relying on them.
-
Conspicuousness of the Product: Conspicuousness means the visibility of the product or brand we are using or promoting. If our product is very conspicuous, and we want to associate it with a particular group, then that group's behavior will have a strong influence on our behavior, and the group's choice will become our choice. For example, a Land Rover is a car normally used for trips and thrill. Since this product is more conspicuous, we will be more influenced by the behavior of the group using this car. On the other side, if we use the product privately, we will not be so concerned about the group. For example, shaving cream is something very personal; in such a case, we will not be concerned about any group.
π Definition β Conspicuousness: The visibility of a product or brand being used or promoted. Higher conspicuousness leads to stronger reference group influence.
π Example: A Land Rover is a conspicuous product used for trips and thrill. Because it is visible, buyers are more influenced by the group using this car. In contrast, a shaving cream is a private product, so group influence is minimal.
Group Influence
For example, if we send a message to the consumer about a car that progressive managers use this car, anyone who would like to be progressive and show themselves as progressive will try to use that specific car. Marketers need to see how strong the group is. Certain factors are involved:
- They should be able to inform and make the consumer aware about the product.
- They should be able to provide opportunity to the individual to compare his thinking with the attitude and behavior of the group.
- There should be some influence on the individual to adopt attitude and behavior consistent with norms of the group.
- Decision should be legitimized to use the same product. For example, in a club where the requirement is to use a black tie, the individual needs to be informed in advance so that he/she can use the same. He/she must adopt the rules of that specific group to be allowed in. This group has a strong influence on the behavior of members who want to go into the club.
- A new brand may go the other way and ask not to follow the crowd but to be individualistic.
- Market leaders attempt to use reference groups to ensure conformance. For example, a mobile company will try to show itself as the market leader so customers stay with them, but new entrants will act as challengers and try to get consumers to break tradition. It is the norm of the industry that leaders always try to keep customers with them, but market challengers try to break this habit.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding group influence helps marketers decide whether to position a brand as conforming to a group or as individualistic, depending on whether they are a market leader or challenger.
Selected Consumer Related Reference Groups
There are six types of groups that we normally have:
-
Friendship groups: These are unstructured, informal, and lack authority levels. They are most likely to influence purchase behavior. They are important for brands, for example, in selecting clothing, jewelry, and snack foods. This group has a direct effect on consumer behavior.
-
Shopping groups: These groups normally perform very important functions. They are normally offshoots from family and friends and go for shopping. They have social get-togethers where they can have fun with shopping. These groups reduce risk and operate defensive mechanisms for us if we don't know about the product. Other than this, there are some customer referral programs where members get members and receive their commission, which is also called multilevel marketing.
-
Work groups: Work groups have two categories: the formal work group and the informal group. The formal group is the one we meet in the organization and discuss official things with. These groups influence behaviors through regular contact. Informal groups are normally formed during tea breaks, lunch breaks, or in smoking rooms. These groups also have an influence on behaviors. In these groups, there are more chances of sharing information about products.
-
Virtual groups and communities: These are websites and online social networks where people get together based on their areas of interest and share information. Communities are defined as a set of social relations among people, and virtual communities are online groups. For example, on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, etc., groups share information about products and business, and hence their behavior is influenced by these groups.
-
Brand communities: Brand communities are now becoming a very important area in marketing. Marketers know that when you put individuals in a community and target your brand accordingly, there are more chances of getting things done in a positive way for your brand. For example, Harley Davidson creates a brand community where interested people try to put themselves by using the motorbikes of this brand.
-
Consumer action groups: These groups normally protect consumers from things which are not useful for them. For example, if you got a product which is not good for you, then you will try to protect your friends, family, and the group to whom you belong from using harmful products.
π Definition β Brand Community: A community of individuals formed around a specific brand, where marketers target the brand accordingly to achieve positive outcomes.
π Example: Harley Davidson creates a brand community where interested people join by using the motorbikes of this brand.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: ethics in marketing communications is essential, as harmful practices like late-night phone packages can damage society. Reference groups are divided into normative (affecting behavior directly, like family) and comparative (used for lifestyle comparison, like neighbors). Three factors affect reference group influence: information/experience, credibility/attractiveness/power, and product conspicuousness. Marketers use group influence to ensure conformance or encourage individuality, depending on their role as market leaders or challengers. The six key consumer-related reference groups are friendship, shopping, work, virtual, brand communities, and consumer action groups.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a normative group and a comparative group?
- List the three factors that affect the influence of reference groups on consumer behavior.
- Provide an example of a conspicuous product and explain how reference group influence differs for a private product.
- Name the six selected consumer-related reference groups discussed in the lecture.
- How do market leaders and market challengers use reference groups differently in their marketing strategies?
π Lecture 28 β MESSAGE STRATEGIES AND APPEALS
π Overview: This lecture explores the different types of appeals used in advertising to influence consumer behavior, including celebrity, expert, common man, and trade character appeals. It then examines the crucial role of the family in consumer decision-making, covering family structures, socialization processes, and the various decision-making roles family members play. Understanding these appeals and family dynamics is essential for marketers to create effective strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing different kinds of appeals: celebrity appeals (with types like testimonial, endorsement, actors, and spokesperson), expert appeals, the common man appeal, trade or spokes character appeals, and respected retailer appeals. It then moves to the influence of the family, defining family types (nuclear, extended, single-parent), and covering consumer socialization of children, adult socialization, and intergenerational socialization. Finally, it details the various family decision-making roles, including influencers, gatekeepers, deciders, users, preparers, maintainers, and disposers.
π Lecture Summary
Different kinds of appeals
The lecture introduces several types of appeals that impact consumer behavior. These include celebrity appeals, expert appeals, common man appeals, trade and spokes character appeals, and respected retailer appeals.
1. Celebrity appeals
Celebrity appeals are powerful because celebrities represent an ideal lifestyle. Companies spend huge amounts on celebrity endorsements. In the USA, around 25% of commercials use celebrities. For example, Michael Jordan has a contract with Nike until 2023, and David Beckham had a $68 million contract with Gillette.
Types of appeals:
- Testimonial: The celebrity verifies that they have personally used the product and guarantees its good quality.
- Endorsement: Using the celebrity's pictures in the advertisement, also called celebrity endorsement.
- Actors: The celebrity promotes the product on television, using their own credibility and character to relate themselves with the brand.
- Spokesperson: Spokespersons have a long-term contract with the brand and are normally called brand ambassadors. For example, Ali Zafar is the spokesperson of Mobilink Jazz.
Issues in Appeals:
- Characteristics of the product: Not every product needs a celebrity endorsement. For example, a computer may not benefit, while a shampoo can have a strong impact.
- Characteristics of the celebrity: The celebrity should be famous, talented, credible, and have charisma, as consumer perception is based on the endorser's credibility.
- Number of products endorsed: A celebrity promoting many products at once, like Shahid Afridi endorsing both Cheeta Shoes and PEPSI, can create credibility issues.
- Endorsers have a positive impact on word of mouth: Research shows endorsers create strong positive word-of-mouth. For instance, women athletes in ads create positive word-of-mouth among women, who spread more word-of-mouth than men.
- Credibility of the celebrity: Credibility depends on two things: the perception of expertise of the celebrity and the trustworthiness of the celebrity.
2. Expert appeals
Expert appeals involve using an expert in a specific area for your brand. For example, using a dentist for toothpaste who shares technical attributes. This makes people rely on the product more.
3. The Common Man
Most consumers are common people. Using common people in ads helps other consumers relate to the product.
a. The Executive or Employee: Sometimes executives are used for promotion. For example, Karegar uses its owner for promotion appeals.
4. Trade or Spokes Characters Appeal
Sometimes registered cartoons are used for promotion. For example, McDonald's uses a cartoon for promotion.
5. Respected Retailers Appeal
Sometimes retailers are used as spokespersons who keep your product on the prominent shelf.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice of appeal must align with the product and target audience. A wrong appeal can damage the brand's credibility.
Influence of Family
A family is defined as two or more persons related by blood, marriage, or adoption who reside together. Families may be households, but households are not necessarily families.
Types of families:
- Nuclear Family: A husband, wife, and their children living together.
- Extended Family: When a grandparent lives with the nuclear family.
- Single Parent Family: Only either a father or mother living with the child, due to divorce or death.
Marketers must understand changing family patterns. As children grow and become parents, their buying choices and lifestyles change. Marketers need to understand family values and religious values when making strategies.
d. Consumer socialization of children
Consumer socialization of children is the process by which children acquire the skills, knowledge, and attitudes to be consumers. For example, when a family goes shopping, they control the child's behavior. However, this is not generalizable, as culture impacts behavior.
e. Adult Consumer Socialization
Adult socialization changes over time. Adults behave differently in teenage, university age, and after marriage. Marketers need to understand these changes.
f. Intergenerational Socialization
Many families pass specific brands to the next generation. For example, a mother advising her daughter to use Habib Cooking Oil means a specific brand is passed from one generation to the next.
g. Economic wellbeing
Families advise their children on economic stability. For example, in Pakistan, advising children to go to developed countries for economic strength makes children behave in that framework.
h. Emotional Support
Parents putting pressure on children in their studies impacts their personalities later in life.
Family Decision Making Roles
Each family has its own decision-making process, depending on several factors.
- a. Influencers: Initiators who provide information to other members about a product. For example, one person gives information about an HP Laptop and advises the family to purchase it.
- b. Gatekeepers: Persons who control the flow of information. They may encourage influencers to bring more information. For example, a son is an influencer saying an HP Laptop is good, but his elder brother (gatekeeper) asks for more information about warranty and technical specifications.
- c. Deciders: The person who finalizes the decision to buy or reject the brand. For example, the father decides whether to buy the HP Laptop.
- d. Users: The person who will finally use the product. For example, the father buys the laptop for his daughter, making her the user.
- e. Preparers: This category prepares the product. For example, a child buys bread, and the mother prepares a sandwich.
- f. Maintainers: Persons responsible for maintaining the product, keeping it clean, and repairing it when damaged.
- g. Disposers: Persons who carry out and dispose of the product, such as throwing it in the dustbin, recycling, or selling it second-hand.
π‘ Why this matters: All these roles are important for marketers, who have an opportunity to influence each person's behavior.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the five main types of advertising appeals: celebrity, expert, common man, trade/spokes characters, and respected retailer. For celebrity appeals, understand the four types (testimonial, endorsement, actor, spokesperson) and the key issues like product fit, celebrity credibility, and the risk of over-endorsement. The family is a critical consumer unit, and marketers must understand its structure (nuclear, extended, single-parent) and the processes of consumer socialization in children and adults. Finally, the seven distinct family decision-making roles (influencer, gatekeeper, decider, user, preparer, maintainer, disposer) provide multiple points for marketing influence.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four types of celebrity appeals, and what is the difference between a testimonial and a spokesperson?
- List at least three issues a marketer must consider before using a celebrity appeal.
- Define the three main types of families discussed in the lecture.
- What is "intergenerational socialization," and why is it important for brand loyalty?
- In a family decision, a child asks for a specific cereal, the parent checks the sugar content, and another parent makes the final purchase. Which three family decision-making roles are being played?