π Lecture 32 β Negotiation
π Overview: This lecture defines negotiation as a process for resolving disputes and reaching mutual agreements, exploring its essential qualities and outcomes. It examines two major approaches to negotiationβthe advocacy approach and the win/win approachβand outlines the negotiation process as a structured series of steps across three phases, including key tactics used by skilled negotiators.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining negotiation and its essential qualities, then introduces two major approaches: the advocacy approach and the win/win negotiator's approach. Within the advocacy approach, the concept of BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement) is explained in detail with examples. The win-win approach is traced from Mary Parker Follett through Gerard Nierenberg to the "Getting to YES" framework of Principled Negotiation. Finally, the negotiation process is broken down into six steps across three phases (before, during, and after), followed by a list of common negotiation tactics.
π Lecture Summary
NEGOTIATION
Negotiation is defined as the process whereby interested parties resolve disputes, agree upon courses of action, bargain for individual or collective advantage, and/or attempt to craft outcomes which serve their mutual interests. It is usually regarded as a form of alternative dispute resolution. The first step in negotiation is to determine whether the situation is in fact a negotiation. The essential qualities of negotiation are: the existence of two parties who share an important objective but have some significant difference(s). The purpose of the negotiating conference is to seek to compromise the difference(s).
The outcome of the negotiating conference may be a compromise satisfactory to both sides, a standoff (failure to reach a satisfactory compromise), or a standoff with an agreement to try again at a later time. Negotiation differs from "influencing" and "group decision making."
π Definition β Negotiation: The process whereby interested parties resolve disputes, agree upon courses of action, bargain for individual or collective advantage, and/or attempt to craft outcomes which serve their mutual interests.
APPROACHES TO NEGOTIATION
The advocate's approach
In the advocacy approach, a skilled negotiator usually serves as advocate for one party to the negotiation and attempts to obtain the most favorable outcomes possible for that party. In this process the negotiator attempts to determine the minimum outcome(s) the other party is (or parties are) willing to accept, then adjusts their demands accordingly. A "successful" negotiation in the advocacy approach is when the negotiator is able to obtain all or most of the outcomes their party desires, but without driving the other party to permanently break off negotiations, unless the BATNA is acceptable.
π Definition β Advocacy approach: An approach where a skilled negotiator serves as advocate for one party and attempts to obtain the most favorable outcomes possible for that party, determining the minimum outcomes the other party will accept.
Best alternative to a negotiated agreement (BATNA)
In negotiation theory, the Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA) is the course of action that will be taken by a party if the current negotiations fail and an agreement cannot be reached. If the current negotiations are giving you less value than your BATNA, there is no point in proceeding. Prior to the start of negotiations, the parties should have ascertained their own individual BATNAs.
BATNA was developed by negotiation researchers Roger Fisher and Bill Ury of the Harvard Program on Negotiation (PON), in their series of books on Principled Negotiation that started with Getting to YES. Nobel Laureate John Forbes Nash has included such ideas in his early undergraduate research.
A party should generally never accept a worse resolution than its BATNA. Care should be taken, however, to ensure that deals are accurately valued, taking into account all considerations (such as relationship value, time value of money, likelihood that the other party will live up to their side of the bargain, etc.). These other considerations are very difficult to value, since they are often based on uncertain considerations, rather than easily measurable and quantifiable factors.
π Example: If I have a written offer from CarMax to buy my car for $100 dollars, then my BATNA when dealing with other potential purchasers would be $100 since I can get $100 for my car even without reaching an agreement with such alternative purchaser.
π Examples of other offers that might or might not be better than the BATNA in the car example:
- An offer of $90 by a close relative (is the goodwill generated worth $10 or more?)
- An offer of $125 in 45 days (what are the chances of this future commitment falling through, and would my prior BATNA ($100) still be available if it did?)
- An offer from another dealer to offset $150 against the price of a new car (do I want to buy a new car right now, the offered car in particular? Also, is the probably minuscule reduction in monthly payments worth $100 to me today?)
Traditional negotiating is sometimes called win-lose because of the assumption of a fixed "pie", that one person's gain results in another person's loss. Another view is that in negotiation both parties are equals by definition and that the best possible outcome is reached when both parties agree to it. If the two parties were not equals, the stronger party would dictate the outcome and there would be no negotiation at all.
π Definition β BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement): The course of action that will be taken by a party if the current negotiations fail and an agreement cannot be reached; a party should never accept a worse resolution than its BATNA.
π‘ Why this matters: BATNA provides a critical benchmark for evaluating any proposed deal. Knowing your BATNA empowers you to walk away from unfavorable terms and strengthens your negotiating position.
The win/win negotiator's approach
During the early part of the 20th century, scholars such as Mary Parker Follett developed ideas suggesting that agreement often can be reached if parties look not at their stated positions but rather at their underlying interests and needs. During the 1960s, Gerard I. Nierenberg recognized the powerful role of negotiation in resolving disputes and published a bestselling book called The Art of Negotiation. He believes that the philosophies of the negotiators determine the direction a negotiation takes. His Everybody Wins philosophy assures that all parties benefit from the negotiation process which also yields more successful outcomes than the adversarial βwinner takes allβ approach.
In the Seventies, practitioners and researchers began to develop win-win approaches to negotiation. The publication of Getting to YES by Harvard's Roger Fisher and William Ury was a revolution in the field of negotiation. The ideas of the book are simple and important -- such as "looking behind positions for interests" and "inventing options before deciding." The book's approach, referred to as Principled Negotiation, is also sometimes called mutual gains bargaining. The mutual gains approach has been effectively applied in environmental situations as well as labor relations where the parties frame the negotiation as "problem solving."
π Definition β Principled Negotiation (mutual gains bargaining): An approach that focuses on underlying interests rather than stated positions, inventing options before deciding, and seeking outcomes that benefit all parties.
NEGOTIATION AS A PROCESS
A negotiation process can be divided into six steps in three phases:
Phase 1: Before the Negotiation
- Step 1: Preparing and Planning: First, determine what you must have and what you are willing to give (bargaining chips). Gather facts about the other party, learn about the other party's negotiating style and anticipate other side's position and prioritize issues. To ensure smooth negotiation, prepare alternative proposals and establish BATNA (the Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement). Estimate the other party's needs, bargaining chips and BATNA. The most ideal case is to get as much as you can. You may advocate "win-win" but don't count on your opponent to be so helpful. Your opponent may try to intimidate you by creating time limits, shouting and casting doubt on your motives.
Phase 2: During the Negotiation
- Step 2: Setting the Tone: You should never speak first because the other party might offer you more than you would have asked for.
- Step 3: Exploring Underlying Needs: Actively listen for facts and reasons behind the other party's position and explore underlying needs of the other party. If conflict exists, try to develop creative alternatives. If you are in a difficult situation, don't say anything. Take time out. Remember, you will not give anything away if you don't say anything.
- Step 4: Selecting, Refining, and Crafting an Agreement: Both parties present the starting proposal. They should listen for new ideas, think creatively to handle conflict and gain power and create a cooperative environment.
- Step 5: Reviewing and Recapping the Agreement: Both parties formalize the agreement in a written contract or letter of intent.
Phase 3: After the Negotiation
- Step 6: Reviewing the Negotiation: Reviewing the negotiation helps one to learn the lessons on how to achieve a better outcome. Therefore, take the time to review each element and ask yourself, "what went well?" and "what could be improved next time?"
Tactics
There are many tactics used by skilled negotiators, including:
- Analyzing the negotiation or conflict management style of your counterpart
- Setting pre-conditions before the meeting
- Volunteering to keep the minutes of the meeting
- Presenting demands
- Declining to speak first
- Deadlines
- Good guy/bad guy
- Limited authority
- Caucusing
- Walking out
- Concession patterns
- High-ball/low-ball
- Intimidation
- Getting it in your hands
- Fait accompli (what's done is done)
- Take it or leave it
- Rejecting an offer
β Key Takeaways
Negotiation is a structured process of resolving disputes where two parties share an objective but have differences, and its outcome can be a compromise, standoff, or agreement to reconvene. The advocacy approach focuses on obtaining the most favorable outcomes for one party by determining the other party's minimum acceptable outcome, with the critical concept of BATNA providing a baselineβnever accept a deal worse than your BATNA. The win-win or Principled Negotiation approach, pioneered by Fisher and Ury, shifts focus from stated positions to underlying interests, seeking mutual gains for all parties. The negotiation process follows six steps across three phasesβpreparation and planning before, setting tone, exploring needs, crafting and reviewing the agreement during, and reviewing lessons learned after. Skilled negotiators employ a variety of tactics such as setting pre-conditions, using deadlines, employing good guy/bad guy, and walking out to influence outcomes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the essential qualities that define a situation as a negotiation?
- What is BATNA, and why should a party generally never accept a deal worse than their BATNA?
- How does the win-win (Principled Negotiation) approach differ from the traditional win-lose (advocacy) approach?
- List the six steps of the negotiation process and identify which phase each step belongs to.
- Name at least five tactics used by skilled negotiators that were mentioned in the lecture.
π Lecture 33 β SALES FORCE MANAGEMENT
π Overview: This lecture explores Sales Force Management Systemsβinformation systems that automate sales and management functions. It details the advantages of these systems for sales personnel, sales managers, and marketing managers, and concludes with the strategic competitive advantages they can provide. Understanding these systems is crucial for leveraging technology to improve sales productivity, management control, and overall business strategy.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and core function of Sales Force Management Systems. It then details the specific advantages these systems offer to sales people (e.g., time savings, improved training, better communication), to the sales manager (e.g., automated analysis, tracking productivity), and to the marketing manager (e.g., market and competitor understanding, strategy development). The lecture concludes by outlining the strategic advantages these systems can create for a company.
π Lecture Summary
Sales Force Management
Sales Force Management Systems are information systems used to automate sales and sales force management functions. They are frequently combined with a marketing information system and are often called customer relationship management (CRM) systems.
π Definition β Sales Force Management System: Information systems used in marketing and management that automate some sales and sales force management functions.
Advantages to Sales People
These systems can improve the productivity of sales personnel. Key advantages include:
- Saving time by filling in prepared e-forms instead of writing reports, and transmitting them via the company intranet instead of printing and delivering them.
- Providing access to real-time information like product inventory data and sales prospect lists, which is useful when answering prospectsβ questions and objections in the field.
- Improving sales staff morale by reducing record-keeping and potentially increasing the rate of closing sales, creating a beneficial cycle.
- Serving as an effective training device by providing product information and sales technique training without time wasted at seminars.
- Facilitating successful team selling through better communication and cooperation between sales personnel.
- Increasing the sales personβs ratio of selling time to non-selling time (non-selling activities include report writing, travel, internal meetings, training, and seminars).
Advantages to the Sales Manager
Sales force automation systems also provide substantial benefits to sales management.
- Automated presentation of results in easy-to-understand tables, charts, or graphs, saving the manager time previously spent gathering and tabulating call sheets.
- More frequent information flow (e.g., activity reports, orders booked) allows the manager to respond more directly with advice, product verifications, and price discount authorizations, providing more hands-on control. π‘ Why this matters: This allows managers to intervene in the sales process while the information is still actionable.
- Sophisticated analysis using statistical techniques, providing useful information for:
- Providing current and useful sales support materials to staff.
- Providing marketing research data: demographic, psychographic, behavioral, product acceptance, product problems, and detecting trends.
- Providing market research data: industry dynamics, new competitors, products, and promotional campaigns, and macro-environmental scanning.
- Coordinating with production and finance.
- Identifying the most profitable and problem customers.
- Tracking sales force productivity using performance measures like revenue per sales person, revenue per territory, margin by product/customer, calls per day, cost per call, orders-to-calls ratio, new/lost customers per period, and more. More complex models like the PAIRS model (by Parasuraman and Day) and the Call Plan model (by Lodish) can also be used.
Advantages to the Marketing Manager
The system gives the marketing manager valuable information for strategic activities:
- Understanding the economic structure of the industry and identifying market segments.
- Identifying your target market and best customers.
- Doing marketing research to develop customer profiles (demographic, psychographic, and behavioral).
- Understanding competitors and their products, and establishing environmental scanning mechanisms.
- Auditing customers' full experience of your brand.
- Developing marketing strategies for each product using the marketing mix (price, product, distribution, promotion).
- Coordinating the sales function with other parts of the promotional mix (advertising, sales promotion, PR).
- Creating a sustainable competitive advantage and providing an empirical basis for writing marketing plans.
Strategic Advantages
Sales force automation systems can create a competitive advantage in several ways:
- Increased productivity for both sales staff and managers, which can create an advantage by reducing costs, increasing sales revenue, and increasing market share.
- Improved agility as field staff send information more frequently (e.g., after every sales call), providing management with current, valuable information and enabling a much faster response time. The company becomes more alert and agile.
- Increased customer satisfaction, if used wisely. By using the data to create products that meet expectations and to service customers more expertly, companies can achieve customer loyalty, reduced acquisition costs, lower price elasticity, and increased profit margins.
β Key Takeaways
Sales Force Management Systems (often integrated as CRM) are pivotal for automating sales tasks and improving efficiency. For salespeople, the primary gain is increased selling time through automation of administrative tasks and better access to information. For managers, these systems provide powerful tools for real-time monitoring, sophisticated analysis of performance metrics, and better coordination across the organization. The strategic benefits are significant, leading to increased productivity, greater organizational agility, and the potential for higher customer satisfaction and loyalty. Ultimately, these systems enable a more data-driven, responsive, and effective sales and marketing operation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the primary time-saving advantages of Sales Force Management Systems for sales personnel?
- How does a sales manager benefit from the automated analysis and presentation of sales data?
- List three types of marketing research data that a marketing manager can obtain from a sales force automation system.
- Explain how a Sales Force Management System can create a competitive advantage by making a company more "alert and agile."
- Describe the link between using a sales force automation system with wisdom and achieving increased profit margins.
π Lecture 34 β PUBLICITY, PUBLIC RELATION & CORPORATE IMAGE
π Overview: This lecture explores the concepts of publicity and public relations as critical tools for managing communications between an organization and its publics. It distinguishes publicity as a component of the promotional mix that relies on external entities for awareness, while public relations is the broader management of all organizational relationships. The lecture also examines how corporate image must align with product positioning to avoid confusing customers and ensure credibility.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining publicity and explaining the role of publicists, then details the basic tools and news-creation techniques used by publicists, and lists the advantages and disadvantages of publicity. It covers key themes that publicity draws upon and discusses the theory of effectiveness. The summary then shifts to define public relations and provide examples of its use by corporations, non-profits, and politicians. Finally, it addresses corporate image and product positioning, emphasizing the need for consistency and believability.
π Lecture Summary
PUBLICITY--- DEFINITION
Publicity is the means of using an external entity (celebrities, people from the media, etc) to increase the awareness levels of the product, company, goods etc amongst the public and/or buying segment. It is defined as "the deliberate attempt to manage the public's perception of a subject".
π Definition β Publicist: "A person whose job is to generate and manage publicity for a product, public figure, especially a celebrity, or for a work such as a book or movie. Publicists usually work at large companies handling multiple clients".
The subject of publicity includes people (for example, politicians and performing artists), goods and services, organizations of all kinds, and works of art or entertainment. From a Marketing perspective, publicity is one component of promotion. The other elements of the promotional mix are advertising, sales promotion, and personal selling. Promotion is one component of marketing.
Publicity is a tool of public relations. Whereas public relations are the management of all communication between the client and selected target audiences, publicity is the management of product- or brand-related communications between the firm and the general public. It is primarily an informative activity (as opposed to a persuasive one), but its ultimate goal is to promote the client's products, services, or brands.
A publicity plan is a planned program aimed at obtaining favorable media coverage for an organization's products - or for the organization itself, to enhance its reputation and relationships with stakeholders.
Basic TOOLS of the Publicist are:
- Press Release
- Telephone press conferences
- In-studio media tours
- Multi-component video news releases (VNRβs)
- Newswire stories
But the publicist cannot wait around for the news to present opportunities. They must also try to create their own news. Examples of this include:
- Contests, Art exhibitions, Event sponsorship, Arrange a speech or talk, Make an analysis or prediction, Conduct a poll or survey, Issue a report, Take a stand on a controversial subject, Arrange for a testimonial, Announce an appointment, Celebrate an anniversary, Invent then present an award, Stage a debate, Organize a tour of your business or projects, Issue a commendation
The advantages of publicity are:
- Low cost
- Credibility (particularly if the publicity is aired in between news stories like on evening TV news casts)
The disadvantages are lack of control over how releases will be used, and frustration over the low percentage of releases that are taken up by the media.
Publicity draws on several key themes including birth, love, and death. These are of particular interest because they are themes in human lives which feature heavily throughout life. In television serials several couples have emerged during crucial ratings and important publicity times, as a way to make constant headlines. Also known as a publicity stunt, the pairings may or may not be truthful.
EFFECTIVENESS OF PUBLICITY
The theory that "any press is good press" has been coined to describe situations where bad behaviour by people involved with an organization or brand has actually resulted in positive results, due to the fame and press coverage accrued by such events.
π‘ Why this matters: This theory explains why even negative publicity can sometimes benefit an organization by increasing overall awareness and visibility.
PUBLIC RELATIONS
Public Relations is defined as "the art and science of building relationships between an organization and its key publics. It is concerned with communications management".
Examples include:
- Corporations use marketing public relations (MPR) to convey information about the products they manufacture or services they provide to potential customers to support their direct sales efforts. Typically, they support sales in the short and long term, establishing and burnishing the corporation's branding for a strong, ongoing market.
- Corporations also use public-relations as a vehicle to reach legislators and other politicians, seeking favorable tax, regulatory, and other treatment, and they may use public relations to portray themselves as enlightened employers, in support of human-resources recruiting programs.
- Non-profit organizations, including schools and universities, hospitals, and human and social service agencies, use public relations in support of awareness programs, fund-raising programs, staff recruiting, and to increase patronage of their services.
- Politicians use public relations to attract votes and raise money, and, when successful at the ballot box, to promote and defend their service in office, with an eye to the next election or, at careerβs end, to their legacy.
CORPORATE IMAGE AND PRODUCT POSITIONING
A corporate image should be consistent with the POSITIONING OF THE COMPANY'S PRODUCT, PRODUCT LINE, and OR BRAND. Any incongruence between the overall corporate image and the positions of individual product offerings will be confusing to potential customers and will tend to reduce sales revenue.
π Example: An oil company that has the image of being environmentally unfriendly will not be successful selling products that they try to position as "green". A company in such a situation should either: withdraw from the "green market", invest in promotional activities that will recast their corporate image in a greener hue, and/or follow a more environmentally friendly path.
A good overall corporate image can be seen as the sum of all the images associated with the firm's individual product positions.
The corporate name and logo must also be consistent with the overall corporate image. Likewise with advertising themes and distribution partners; they must also be consistent with your overall corporate image.
π Example: If you wish to create a luxury/high-end corporate image, you should not distribute your products through Wal-Mart nor use slapstick advertising themes.
A successful corporate image must also be believable. That is, the image must be relatively close to your actual behaviors to be credible.
π‘ Why this matters: Consistency between corporate image and all marketing elements (name, logo, advertising, distribution) is critical for building customer trust and avoiding confusion that reduces sales.
β Key Takeaways
Publicity is a low-cost, credible promotional tool that uses external entities and media coverage to increase awareness, but it offers little control over how messages are used. Public relations is broader, focusing on managing all communications to build relationships with key publics including customers, legislators, and employees. The theory of "any press is good press" suggests even negative publicity can yield positive results through increased fame. A corporate image must be consistent with product positioning, advertising themes, distribution partners, and corporate name/logo to avoid customer confusion. Finally, a corporate image must be believableβit must closely match the organization's actual behaviors to maintain credibility.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between publicity and public relations?
- List the basic tools of a publicist and give two examples of how a publicist can create their own news.
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of using publicity?
- How should a corporation handle a situation where its corporate image is inconsistent with its desired product positioning?
- Why must a corporate image be believable, and what happens if there is incongruence between the corporate image and individual product positions?
π Lecture 35 β Distribution (Business) Distribution Channels
π Overview: This lecture explains the critical role of distribution as one of the four aspects of marketing, focusing on distribution channels that connect manufacturers to end customers. It covers types of channels, innovations in service distribution, and vital questions that must be answered to design effective channel strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining distribution business as the middleman between manufacturer and retailer or business customer. It then explores alternative channels of distribution including selling direct, mail order, retailer, wholesaler, and agent. The discussion extends to distribution of services with innovations like franchising, rental services, and service integration. The lecture concludes with vital questions covering channel selection, length, availability, exclusivity, control, relationships, advertising, electronic methods, logistics, and inventory costs.
π Lecture Summary
Distribution (Business)
Distribution is one of the four Aspects of Marketing. A distribution business is the middleman between the manufacturer and retailer or (usually) in commercial or industrial the business customer. After a product is manufactured by a supplier/factory, it is typically stored in a distribution company's warehouse. The product is then sold to retailers or customers. The other three parts of the marketing mix are product management, pricing, and promotion.
Channels
A number of alternative 'channels' of distribution may be available:
- Selling direct
- Mail order (including Internet and telephone sales)
- Retailer
- Wholesaler
- Agent (who acts on behalf of the producer)
Distribution channels may not be restricted to physical products. They may be just as important for moving a service from 'producer' to consumer in certain sectors, since both direct and indirect channels may be used. Hotels, for example, may sell their services (typically rooms) direct or through travel agents, tour operators, airlines, tourist boards, centralized reservation systems, and so on.
There have also been some innovations in the distribution of services. For example, there has been an increase in franchising and in rental services β the latter offering anything from televisions through to DIY tools. There has also been some evidence of service integration, with services linking together, particularly in the travel and tourism sector: for example, links now exist between airlines, hotels and car rental services. In addition, there has been a significant increase in retail outlets for the service sector; outlets such as estate agencies and building society offices, for example, are crowding out the traditional grocers and greengrocers from the high street.
π‘ Why this matters: Distribution channels for services have evolved dramatically, with franchising, rental models, and service integration creating new ways for consumers to access services while also changing the retail landscape.
Vital Questions....Explanation
Traditionally, distribution has been seen as dealing with logistics: how to get the product or service to the customer.
It must answer questions such as:
- Should the product be sold through a retailer?
- Should the product be distributed through wholesale?
- Should multi-level marketing channels be used?
- How long should the channel be (how many members)?
- Where should the product or service be available?
- When should the product or service be available?
- Should distribution be exclusive, selective or extensive?
- Who should control the channel?
- Should channel relationships be informal or contractual?
- Should channel members share advertising (referred to as co-op ads)?
- Should electronic methods of distribution be used?
- Are there physical distribution and logistical issues to deal with?
- What will it cost to keep an inventory of products on store shelves and in channel warehouses (referred to as filling the pipeline)?
π‘ Why this matters: These questions help marketers design a distribution strategy that balances customer access, channel member relationships, and cost efficiencyβdirectly impacting product availability and profitability.
β Key Takeaways
Distribution is a core element of the marketing mix alongside product, price, and promotion, serving as the bridge between production and consumption. Multiple channel options existβdirect, mail order, retailer, wholesaler, and agentβeach suited to different products, markets, and customer needs. Service distribution has evolved through franchising, rental services, and integration (e.g., airlines, hotels, car rentals), transforming how services reach consumers. The strategic decisions about channel length, exclusivity (exclusive, selective, or extensive), control, and advertising cooperation (co-op ads) shape the efficiency and effectiveness of distribution. Finally, logistical considerations like inventory management and "filling the pipeline" are critical to ensure products are available when and where customers want them.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four aspects of the marketing mix, and where does distribution fit?
- List at least five alternative channels of distribution mentioned in the lecture.
- How have distribution channels for services innovated beyond physical products? Give examples.
- What does "filling the pipeline" mean in the context of distribution?
- Differentiate between exclusive, selective, and extensive distribution strategies.
π Lecture 36 β Distribution Channels (Cont....)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on distribution channels, exploring channel members, channel structure, and the internal market. It delves into critical channel decisions, management strategies including channel membership and motivation, and introduces vertical and horizontal marketing systems as modern approaches to distribution.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and levels of distribution channels, channel members from zero-level to multi-level structures, and channel structure including conventional, single transaction, and vertical marketing systems. It also explains the internal market concept, channel decisions regarding strategy and product, and channel management aspects such as membership types (intensive, selective, exclusive), motivation techniques, and monitoring. Finally, vertical marketing (corporate, contractual, administered systems) and horizontal marketing joint ventures are introduced.
π Lecture Summary
THE DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
Frequently there may be a chain of intermediaries; each passing the product down the chain to the next organization, before it finally reaches the consumer or end-user. This process is known as the 'distribution chain' or, rather more exotically, as the 'channel'. Each of the elements in these chains will have their own specific needs, which the producer must take into account, along with those of the all-important end-user.
CHANNEL MEMBERS
Distribution channels can have a number of 'levels'. Kotler defined the simplest level, that of direct contact with no intermediaries involved, as the 'zero-level' channel. The next level, the 'one-level' channel, features just one intermediary; in consumer goods a retailer, for industrial goods a distributor, say. This level, together with the zero-level, has accounted for the greatest percentage of overall volumes distributed. In the UK, a second level, a wholesaler for example, is now mainly used to extend distribution to a large number of small, neighborhood retailers.
π Definition β Zero-level channel: Direct contact between producer and consumer with no intermediaries involved. π Definition β One-level channel: A distribution channel featuring just one intermediary (retailer for consumer goods, distributor for industrial goods). π Example: In the UK, a wholesaler (second level) is used to extend distribution to small, neighborhood retailers.
CHANNEL STRUCTURE
To the various 'levels' of distribution, which they refer to as the 'channel length': β’ Conventional or free-flow - This is the usual, widely recognized, channel with a range of 'middle-men' passing the goods on to the end-user. β’ Single transaction - A temporary 'channel' may be set up for one transaction; for example, the sale of property or a specific civil engineering project. This does not share many characteristics with other channel transactions, each one being unique. β’ Vertical marketing system (VMS) - In this form, the elements of distribution are integrated.
π Definition β Channel length: The number of levels or intermediaries in a distribution channel.
THE INTERNAL MARKET
Many marketing principles applied to external customers can be just as effectively applied to each subsidiary's, or each department's, 'internal' customers. In some parts of certain organizations this may be formalized, as goods are transferred between separate parts of the organization at a 'transfer price'. This process can and should be viewed as a normal buyer-seller relationship. The fact that this is a captive market, resulting in a 'monopoly price', should not discourage the participants from employing marketing techniques. Less obvious is the use of 'marketing' by service and administrative departments to optimize their contribution to their 'customers' (the rest of the organization).
π Definition β Transfer price: The price at which goods are transferred between separate parts of the same organization, creating an internal buyer-seller relationship. π‘ Why this matters: The internal market concept shows that marketing principles apply not just to external customers but also to internal departments, helping optimize inter-departmental relationships and efficiency.
CHANNEL DECISIONS
β’ Overall strategy β’ Channel strategy β’ Product (or service) β’ Cost and Consumer location
CHANNEL MANAGEMENT
The channel decision is very important. In theory, the cost of using intermediaries to achieve wider distribution is supposedly lower. Most consumer goods manufacturers could never justify the cost of selling direct to their consumers, except by mail order. In practice, if the producer is large enough, the use of intermediaries can sometimes cost more than going direct. Many theoretical arguments about channels revolve around cost, while most practical decisions are concerned with control of the consumer. The small company has no alternative but to use intermediaries, but large companies do have the choice.
Many suppliers seem to assume that once their product has been sold into the channel, their job is finished. Yet that distribution chain is merely assuming a part of the supplier's responsibility; if he has any aspirations to be market-oriented, his job should be extended to managing all the processes involved in that chain until the product arrives with the end-user. This involves decisions on: β’ Channel membership β’ Channel motivation β’ Monitoring and managing channels
CHANNEL MEMBERSHIP
- Intensive distribution - Where the majority of resellers stock the 'product' (with convenience products, for example, and particularly the brand leaders in consumer goods markets), price competition may be evident.
- Selective distribution - This is the normal pattern (in both consumer and industrial markets) where 'suitable' resellers stock the product.
- Exclusive distribution - Only specially selected resellers (typically only one per geographical area) are allowed to sell the 'product'.
π Definition β Intensive distribution: A strategy where the majority of resellers stock the product, typically used for convenience goods and brand leaders, often leading to price competition. π Definition β Selective distribution: A strategy where only 'suitable' resellers are chosen to stock the product, common in both consumer and industrial markets. π Definition β Exclusive distribution: A strategy where only specially selected resellers (often one per geographical area) are allowed to sell the product.
CHANNEL MOTIVATION
It is difficult enough to motivate direct employees to provide the necessary sales and service support. Motivating the owners and employees of independent organizations in a distribution chain requires even greater effort. The most usual device is 'bribery': the supplier offers a better margin to tempt the owners in the channel to push the product rather than its competitors; or a competition is offered to the distributors' sales personnel. At the other end of the spectrum is the almost symbiotic relationship that the supplier in the computer field develops with its agents, where the agent's personnel are trained to almost the same standard as the supplier's own staff.
Monitoring and managing channels
In much the same way that the organization's own sales and distribution activities need to be monitored and managed, so will those of the distribution chain. In practice, many organizations use a mix of different channels; in particular, they may complement a direct sales force, calling on the larger accounts, with agents, covering the smaller customers and prospects.
VERTICAL MARKETING
This relatively recent development integrates the channel with the original supplier - producers, wholesalers, and retailers working in one unified system. This may arise because one member of the chain owns the other elements (often called 'corporate systems integration'); a supplier owning its own retail outlets, this being 'forward' integration. It is perhaps more likely that a retailer will own its own suppliers, this being 'backward' integration. (For example, MFI, the furniture retailer, owns Hygena which makes its kitchen and bedroom units.) The integration can also be by franchise (such as that offered by McDonald's hamburgers and Benetton clothes) or simple co-operation (in the way that Marks & Spencer co-operates with its suppliers).
Alternative approaches are 'contractual systems', often led by a wholesale or retail co-operative, and 'administered marketing systems' where one (dominant) member of the distribution chain uses its position to co-ordinate the other members' activities. This has traditionally been the form led by manufacturers. The intention of vertical marketing is to give all those involved 'control' over the distribution chain, removing one set of variables from the marketing equations. Other research indicates that vertical integration is a strategy best pursued at the mature stage of the market; at earlier stages it can actually reduce profits.
π Definition β Corporate systems integration: One member of the distribution chain owns other elements, either forward (supplier owning retail outlets) or backward (retailer owning suppliers). π Example: MFI, the furniture retailer, owns Hygena which makes its kitchen and bedroom units (backward integration). π Example: McDonald's hamburgers and Benetton clothes use franchise-based vertical integration. π Definition β Contractual systems: A vertical marketing approach led by a wholesale or retail co-operative. π Definition β Administered marketing systems: A vertical marketing approach where one dominant member of the distribution chain coordinates the activities of other members.
HORIZONTAL MARKETING
A rather less frequent example of new approaches to channels is where two or more non-competing organizations agree on a joint venture - a joint marketing operation - because it is beyond the capacity of each individual organization alone. In general, this is less likely to revolve around marketing synergy.
π Definition β Horizontal marketing: Two or more non-competing organizations agree on a joint marketing operation because it is beyond the capacity of each individual organization alone.
β Key Takeaways
The distribution channel is a chain of intermediaries that moves products from producer to end-user, with levels ranging from zero-level (direct) to multi-level channels. Channel decisions involve overall strategy, product, cost, and consumer location, while channel management includes choosing membership types (intensive, selective, exclusive), motivating intermediaries through margins or training, and monitoring performance. Vertical marketing integrates the channel through corporate ownership, franchise, or administered systems to gain control, while horizontal marketing involves joint ventures between non-competing organizations. The internal market concept applies marketing principles to inter-departmental relationships, and suppliers must manage the entire distribution chain, not just the initial sale into the channel.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of channel structure discussed in the lecture?
- What is the difference between intensive, selective, and exclusive distribution?
- What are the three approaches to vertical marketing systems?
- Explain the concept of the internal market and transfer price.
- What is horizontal marketing, and under what circumstances is it used?