π Lecture 1 β INTRODUCTION TO PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
π Overview: This lecture introduces the field of Production and Operations Management (POMA), tracing its evolution from Production Management and distinguishing it from Operations Research. It establishes the critical role of Operations Management in any organization and positions it as a bridge between Engineering and Management disciplines.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the evolution of POMA terminology, the course structure broken into five units, the history of scientific management pioneered by Taylor and the Gilbreths, key differences between Operations Management and Operations Research, the definition and types of organizations, the role of an Operations Manager, and the conceptual model of OM as a bridge connecting Engineering and Management islands.
π Lecture Summary
INTRODUCTION TO PRODUCTION AND OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
The field was previously called Production Management, then evolved to Production and Operations Management, and is now often simply called Operations Management. It should not be confused with Operations Research or Production Management, which are the domain of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering.
THE COURSE CONTENT
The course is divided into five units: Unit I covers Introduction and Productivity, Strategy, and Competitiveness. Unit II covers Forecasting. Unit III covers Design of Production Systems. Unit IV covers Quality. Unit V covers Operating and Controlling the System. The lecture distribution across these units is: Unit I (5 lectures), Unit II (3 lectures), Unit III (12 lectures), Unit IV (10 lectures), and Unit V (15 lectures).
History of Management
Frederick Taylor and the Gilbreths (Lillian and Frank Gilbreth) are pioneers of transforming management into a scientific domain. The field borrows a lot of information from Engineering and Management to provide an overall bigger picture of operating and managing any organization.
Difference between Operations Management and Research
Operations Research (OR) relies on mathematical modeling, while Operations Management (OM) relies on practical scenarios/industrial cases. OR is the domain and tool of Engineers, while OM is considered one of the critical tools of Managers. OR is considered more powerful for improving the whole system, whereas OM can be applied to a part of the system.
π Definition β Operations Research (OR): Relies on mathematical modeling to improve systems. π Definition β Operations Management (OM): Relies on practical scenarios/industrial cases and is applied to parts of a system.
Why Study OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT
Operations Management forms the core of any organization's senior leadership. An organization is a business entity that can work for profit or non-profit purposes to generate a value-added product or service for its customers. Whether profit or non-profit, the role of an Operations Manager is to sustain, protect, and project the company's operations side. Every organization must manage processes and operations by which processes are performed. An Operations Manager controls the processes by which value is added from conversion of inputs to outputs. Inputs include materials, inventory, services, land, energy, and human and capital resources.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the role of an Operations Manager is foundational because every organization, regardless of its profit motive, requires efficient management of its core processes to survive and succeed.
π Definition β Organization: A business entity working for profit or non-profit purposes to generate a value-added product or service for its customers.
Bridge between Management and Engineering
Operations Management uses foundations of both Engineering and Management. The lecture presents a metaphor of two islands named Engineering and Management. The OM professional acts as a bridge builder. The primary responsibility of an Operations Manager at any level is to help and facilitate building bridges. The lecture emphasizes that the strength of the chain is equal to the strength of the weakest link. If an operations manager's analysis consists of both Engineering and Management links, any weakness in either link would lead to an overall weak analysis. A balanced approach makes the best use of strengths and overcomes weaknesses. Problem solving and decision making through Production and Operations Management should utilize both Engineering and Management aspects to aim for powerful systems (overall big picture) approach.
π‘ Why this matters: This metaphor explains why an Operations Manager cannot be purely technical or purely managerial; they must be competent in both domains to create effective and robust organizational systems.
β Key Takeaways
Operations Management is distinct from Operations Research, focusing on practical industrial scenarios rather than pure mathematical modeling. Every organization, profit or non-profit, requires an Operations Manager to manage the conversion of inputs into valuable outputs. The field is built on the scientific management foundations of Taylor and the Gilbreths. Most critically, Operations Management serves as the essential bridge between Engineering and Management disciplines, and the strength of an OM professional's analysis is only as strong as the weakest link between these two domains. A balanced, systems-thinking approach is mandatory for success.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three historical names for the field now called Operations Management?
- What is the fundamental difference between Operations Research and Operations Management in terms of their approach?
- According to the lecture, what is the primary responsibility of an Operations Manager in any organization?
- What does the "bridge between Engineering and Management" metaphor mean, and why is the "weakest link" concept important?
- Name the pioneers credited with transforming management into a scientific domain.
π Lecture 2 β Introduction to Production / Operations Management (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the introduction to Production and Operations Management by providing detailed definitions of manufacturing and service, exploring the role of services in the economy, and outlining the key responsibilities and decision areas for an operations manager. It explains the historical development of OM, current business trends, issues in Pakistan, and the relationship between operations, marketing, and finance functions within an organization.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers a recap of Lecture 1, manufacturing and service definitions, the importance of service firms and their role in the economy, service sector growth in Pakistan, key responsibilities of an operations manager, the 5W2H decision-making approach, models in OM, historical development of OM, current trends in business, the central role of operations in organizations, current issues in OM in Pakistan, production vs. service systems, transformation types, service employment statistics, stages of economic development in Pakistan, functions within an organization, operations and marketing, the finance function, and a simple product supply chain example.
π Lecture Summary
Recap of 1st Lecture
The course covers content for midterm and final exams. An organization is defined, and the three primary functions of any business are Finance, Marketing, and Operations. Productive systems include both production and service systems. Operations Management is the management of systems or processes that create goods and/or provide services. The Operation Function consists of all activities directly related to producing goods or providing services.
Manufacturing and Service Definitions
Manufacturing is the transformation of raw materials into finished goods for sale, or intermediate processes involving the production or finishing of semi-manufactures. It is a large branch of industry and of secondary production. Some industries, like semiconductor and steel manufacturers, use the term fabrication.
Service is defined either as "services are deeds, processes, and performances" or as "a service is a time-perishable, intangible experience performed for a customer acting in the role of a co-producer."
Service enterprises are organizations that facilitate the production and distribution of goods, support other firms in meeting their goals, and add value to our personal lives.
Role of Services in an Economy
Services play a significant role in any economy. In Pakistan, the growth of production and services can be attributed to the following sectors: Private, Public, Public Private, and Government.
Key Areas of Responsibility for an Operations Manager
An Operations Manager's job responsibility includes but is not limited to: Forecasting, Capacity planning, Scheduling, Inventory Management, Quality Assurance and Control, Motivating employees, and Deciding where to locate facilities.
Key Decision Areas for Operations Managers β 5W2H Approach
The 5W2H approach involves asking seven key questions:
- What: What resources/what amounts
- Why: The work is needed to be done
- When: Needed/scheduled/ordered
- Where: Work to be done
- How much: Quantity to be produced or served
- How: Designed/capacity planning
- Who: To do the work
Decision Making
Operations Managers spend most of their routine hours making decisions under certainty or uncertainty. The various tools available to an Operations Manager include: Models, Quantitative approaches, Analysis of trade-offs, and Systems approach.
Applications of Models in Operations Management
Models are beneficial and effective to an Operations Manager primarily because they are: easy to use and less expensive; require users to organize; provide a systematic approach to problem solving; increase understanding of the problem; enable "what if" questions; provide specific objectives; are a consistent tool; leverage the power of mathematics; and have a standardized format.
π‘ Why this matters: Models allow managers to simulate real-world scenarios without the cost and risk of actual implementation.
Historical Development of OM
The historical development includes: JIT (Just-In-Time) and TQC (Total Quality Control) ; the Manufacturing Strategy Paradigm; Service Quality and Productivity; Total Quality Management (TQM) and Quality Certification; Business Process Reengineering (BPR) ; Supply Chain Management; and Electronic Commerce.
Current Trends in Business
Trends in business and Operations Management that have shaped the industry include: The Internet, e-commerce, e-business; Management technology; Globalization; Management of supply chains; and Agility.
Production and Operations Management as Nucleus in the Organizations
Operations occupies the central figure in any service or manufacturing organization. A small decision can seriously affect the workings and performance output in other units such as Distribution, Purchasing, Industrial Engineering, Maintenance, Public Relations, Legal, Personnel, Accounting, and MIS (Management Information Systems) .
Current Issues in OM
The recent wave of telecom sector infrastructure consolidation and deregulation in Pakistan has led to foreign investors aggressively seeking new Pakistani partners. Current issues in OM in Pakistan include:
- Effectively consolidating operations resulting from mergers
- Developing flexible supply chains to enable mass customization of products and services
- Managing global supplier, production and distribution networks
- Increased "commoditization" of suppliers
- Achieving the "Service Factory"
- Enhancing value added services
- Making efficient use of Internet technology
- Achieving good service from service firms
What is a Production and Productive System?
A productive system is defined as a user of resources to transform inputs into some desired outputs (products as well as services), whereas a production system refers specifically to only desired output in the form of products or manufactured goods. It is important to understand that productive system reflects both production as well as services systems.
Important transformations through which raw material is converted to a value-added end product or service include:
- Physical β manufacturing
- Location β transportation
- Exchange β retailing
- Storage β warehousing
- Physiological β health care
- Informational β telecommunications
π‘ Why this matters: The statement that "Services never include goods and goods never include services" can never be true. Workers working for creation of a product in manufacturing units are simultaneously working to create a service.
Production of Goods vs. Delivery of Services
- Production of goods β tangible output
- Delivery of services β an action and reaction between the provider/deliverer of services and the demander of services (e.g., bank teller, hair stylist)
- Service job categories include: Government, Wholesale/retail, Financial services, Healthcare, Personal services, Business services, and Education
Percent Service Employment for Selected Nations
The table shows service employment percentages for selected nations over time:
| Country | 1980 | 1987 | 1993 | 2000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| United States | 67.1 | 71.0 | 74.3 | 74.2 |
| Canada | 67.2 | 70.8 | 74.8 | 74.1 |
| Pakistan | 13.3 | 16.0 | 18.0 | 23.9 |
| Japan | 54.5 | 58.8 | 59.9 | 72.7 |
| France | 56.9 | 63.6 | 66.4 | 70.8 |
| Italy | 48.7 | 57.7 | 60.2 | 62.8 |
| Brazil | 46.2 | 50.0 | 51.9 | 56.5 |
| China | 13.1 | 17.8 | 21.2 | 40.6 |
Stages of Economic Development in Pakistan
The stages are classified as:
Pre-industrial: Predominant activity is Agriculture; uses raw human labor; unit of social life is extended household; standard of living measure is survival; structure is routine; technology is simple.
Industrial (1947 to 1960): Predominant activity is Industrial Mining (coal, salt); uses goods muscle power with hand tools; unit of social life is machine household (Joint Families) and individual; standard of living measure is quantity; structure is traditional authoritative and bureaucratic; technology includes machines.
Industrial (1960 to date): Predominant activity is production tending of goods; uses hierarchical structure; unit of social life is individual; standard of living measure is quantity.
Post-industrial (Future): Predominant activity is Services; uses artistic, creative, intellectual labor; unit of social life is community; standard of living measure is quality of life in terms of health, education, recreation; structure is interdependent global; technology is information.
Source of Service Sector Growth
Pakistan is facing changes in demographics, economics, and social norms which have been the source of service sector growth. Key sources include:
Innovation: Push and Pull theory (e.g., Cash Management); Services derived from products (e.g., CD/Automobile/Video Rental); Information driven services (e.g., finance brokerage services).
Social Trends: Aging of the population; Increase in life expectancy; Two-income families (both males and females working); Growth in number of single people.
Home as sanctuary.
Functions within an Organization
The Operations function consists of all activities that are directly related to production of a good or service. Operations functions exist in services like healthcare, Police, Traffic, transportation, consultancy, food handling, restaurants, etc. The Operations function forms the core of all businesses.
Operations and Marketing
Value addition refers to conversion of raw materials to finished goods or services. Value added often refers to the difference between the cost of the raw material and the price of the finished good. The revenues from selling goods are used for betterment of existing products/services, R&D, or investment in new facilities and equipment. Weeding out or eliminating non-value adding operations (e.g., storage of goods produced ahead of schedule increases storage and inventory costs; reducing storage cost reduces transformation cost and increases value addition).
Marketing relates to selling of a good or service of the organization through advertising and pricing decisions. The Marketing department assesses the customer's needs and communicates it to the operations people on a short-term basis and to design people on a long-term basis. Operations people need information about demand over a short range to purchase raw materials, manage inventory, or schedule production plans, whereas design people need information to redesign or design new products/services. Marketing provides valuable information about competitors and customers' needs.
Finance
The Finance function focuses on activities that relate to securing resources at favorable prices and then allocating these resources throughout the organization. Finance and Operations personnel exchange information and expertise in the following ways: Budgets, Economic analysis of investment proposals, and Provision of funds.
Historical Evolution of Operations Management
The historical evolution includes:
- Industrial revolution (1770's)
- Scientific management (1911) β including mass production, interchangeable parts, and division of labor
- Human relations movement (1920-60)
- Decision models (1915, 1960-70's)
- Influence of Japanese manufacturers
Simple Product Supply Chain
A Supply Chain is a sequence of activities and organizations involved in producing and delivering a good or service.
Applying this concept to a loaf of bread on the breakfast table:
Suppliers' Suppliers β Direct Suppliers β Producer β Distributor β Final Consumer
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that operations management is the core function of any organization, whether manufacturing or service-based. Students must understand that services and goods are not mutually exclusiveβmany products include service components and vice versa. The key responsibilities of an operations managerβforecasting, capacity planning, scheduling, inventory, quality, and location decisionsβare critical for organizational success. The lecture emphasizes the growing importance of the service sector in Pakistan's economy, with service employment rising from 13.3% (1980) to 23.9% (2000). Finally, the 5W2H decision-making framework and the use of models are essential tools for operations managers to make systematic, effective decisions under certainty or uncertainty.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a "productive system" and a "production system" as defined in this lecture?
- List four of the seven types of transformations through which raw materials become value-added outputs (e.g., physicalβmanufacturing).
- According to the 5W2H approach, what are the seven questions an operations manager must ask when making decisions?
- What was Pakistan's service employment percentage in 2000, and how did it compare to the United States in the same year?
- Name at least three current issues in OM that are relevant to Pakistan, as discussed in this lecture.
π Lecture 3 β COMPETITIVENESS, STRATEGY AND PRODUCTIVITY
π Overview: This lecture explores the core concepts of competitiveness, strategy, and productivity as foundational pillars of production and operations management. It explains how organizations compete through price, quality, differentiation, flexibility, and time, and examines the critical role of operations strategy in gaining a competitive advantage. The lecture also covers common reasons for organizational failure and the hierarchical relationship between mission, strategy, and tactics.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by revisiting the definitions of competitiveness, strategy, and productivity. It then details the five common ways organizations compete against each other (price, quality, product differentiation, flexibility, and time). Next, it formally defines competitiveness and introduces the value equation as a mathematical tool for understanding customer value (Value = Performance/Cost). The lecture then explores how organizations gain competitive advantage through marketing, finance, and operations-based strategies. A list of common reasons why organizations fail is provided. Finally, the lecture explains the hierarchical relationship between mission, strategy, and tactics, including planning and decision-making processes, and concludes with examples of strategies.
π Lecture Summary
Meanings of Competitiveness, Strategy and Productivity
We are already familiar with these three terms; for the sake of easy reference, let us revisit their definitions. Competitiveness refers to an aggressive willingness to compete. Strategy is an elaborate and systematic plan of action with defined resources. Productivity refers to the ratio of the quantity and quality of units produced to the labor per unit of time, or simply the ratio of output to input.
How Organization Compete against each other
Businesses since the beginning of time have competed against each other. On the basis of competition, various types of market exist for nearly all lines of products and services. We already know that absolute monopoly and perfect competition type of markets are not that pervasive, yet businesses try to avoid perfect competition and strive to go for absolute monopoly so they can enjoy no competition and exploit customer sentiments for buying. We can identify the following common and widespread ways in which organizations can compete against other organizations: Price, where a lower price attracts more customers; Quality, which involves superior raw materials and high skill to offer something extra; Product Differentiation, which refers to special features like a GPS system in an automobile; Flexibility, which is the ability to respond to changes; and Time, which refers to the period required to provide a product or service from order booking to delivery.
A. Competitiveness
Competitiveness is how effectively an organization meets the needs and requirements of customers relative to other organizations (competitors) that offer similar goods or services. The key to successfully competing is to answer these two questions diligently: I. What do the Customers Want? II. How can our business deliver the required Value to the customers? The first question begets a logical answer: customers want Value. The second question asks for the ways organizations would deliver value to the customer. If an organization can understand that Value is always the tradeoff between performance and cost, then it can adopt various means to provide value to the customer.
π Definition β Competitiveness: How effectively an organization meets the needs and requirements of customers relative to other organizations that offer similar goods or services.
Mathematically speaking, value equals the performance (of the product or service) divided by cost. Most organizations have different measurement rules attached in measurement of quality, speed and flexibility.
π Formula: Value = Performance / Cost = (Quality + Speed + Flexibility) / Cost (Eq. 1)
The equation above also captures the product differentiation concept, which in reality is an important dimension of quality. We can also say that the customer is measuring performance with the help of Quality, Speed and Flexibility for the price or cost he is willing to pay. The point worth noting is that in most cases the three factors of performance would not be weighed equally. We can thus make use of an important concept of assigning weights so the equation changes to:
π Formula: Value = (w1 x Quality + w2 x Speed + w3 x Flexibility) / Cost (Eq. 2)
Where w1, w2 and w3 are different weights and if they all have the same value, then equation 2 reduces to equation 1 again. In other words, equation 2 is not only generic but more reflective of performance measurement of an organization. Different organizations assign different means to obtain the value of these weights by developing an in-house or consultant-derived Performance Measurement Model (PMM). This can be used to obtain an overall performance score by measuring the success of a manufacturing company in its operational activities. The developed PMM measures a company's level of performance in critical dimensions and combines these performance scores to obtain a ranking score.
How Organizations can gain Competitive Advantage
As Students of Organization Management, we can look at value in terms of the three important functions of any organization to see how organizations can gain competitive advantage: Marketing, Finance, and Operations.
-
A. Businesses Gain Competitive Advantage by using Market-based strategies:
- Identifying consumer wants and needs
- Pricing
- Advertising and promotion
-
B. Businesses Gain Competitive Advantage by using Finance-based strategies:
- Identifying sources of funds and applications of funds.
- Capital and Financial Investments.
- Financial Leverage (Debt to Equity).
- Capital structure.
-
C. Businesses Gain Competitive Advantage by using Operations-based strategies:
- Product and service design: The design is not only the starting point but allows certain features to be added which makes your product or service favorable to the customer.
- Cost or Cost Leadership: Offers the product or service at an economical price.
- Location: Refers to the convenient point of sales, such as a petrol pump with an attached convenience store.
- Quality: Should always match the price and service.
- Quick response: Also known as Agility; an organization on this basis is often known as an Agile Organization.
- Flexibility: For example, changing the car model from sedan to coupe based on marketing division's inputs.
- Inventory management: Maintain safety stocks and critical spares.
- Supply chain management: Develop and sustain an active and strong chain between suppliers and end customers.
- Service: After-sales service, owning the customer's issue as your own.
Throughout the semester our aim would be to identify and understand different types of strategies which have been exploited to the fullest by various organizations and adopted religiously as their actual Operational strategies.
Common Reasons why Organizations Fail
We can identify certain familiar reasons why Organizations fail to achieve a competitive advantage and end up losing out to their competitors. These reasons are universal in nature and find the same footing in Pakistan as well as any other place in the world:
- Too much emphasis on short-term financial performance.
- Failing to take advantage of strengths and opportunities.
- Failing to recognize competitive threats.
- Neglecting operations strategy: This is definitely the most important reason of failure; organizations often end up employing non-productive techniques which lead to inconsistent and failed operations.
- Too much emphasis on product and service design and not enough on improvement.
- Neglecting investments in capital and human resources.
- Failing to establish good internal communications.
- Failing to consider customer wants and needs.
Mission/Strategy/Tactics
Most organizations tend to answer the question of how mission, strategies, and tactics relate to their decision making and attaining distinctive competencies. Organizations over the years have mastered the art and technique of developing a vision and a mission statement, which helps them to come with functional strategies and practical tactics.
- Mission is the reason for existence for an organization.
- Mission Statement answers the question βWhat business are we in?β
- Strategies are Plans for achieving organizational goals.
- Goals provide detail and scope of mission.
- Tactics are the methods and actions taken to accomplish strategies.
Concept of Strategy for a Pakistani Automobile manufacturer:
- Mission: To provide BEST AUTOMOBILES to individuals as well as BUSINESS organizations of Pakistan.
- Mission Statement: βTo give you safe wheels to move aroundβ.
- Goals: To provide utility and heavy equipment mobiles.
- Tactics: Consist of employing TQM methods to accomplish strategies.
Planning and Decision Making
Planning and decision-making concepts make use of setting a mission, goal, strategy, and achieving the end result through some effective and practical tactic. In hierarchical order, the organization first makes or develops a mission and employs tactics by developing operating procedures.
Strategy Example: You are a business student at Virtual University of Pakistan. You would like to have a career in business, have a good job, and earn enough income to live comfortably.
- Mission: Live a good life
- Goal: Successful career, good income
- Strategy: Obtain a Business Degree from VU.
- Tactics: Select a business field of your interest and high market value
- Operations: Register, buy books, take courses, Study, graduate, apply & get job
Examples of Strategies
Examples of strategies include: Low cost (Cost Leadership/Economical), Scale-based strategies (Critical Value), Specialization (Specific characteristics), Flexible operations (To change production design of products on the same infrastructure), High quality (exceeds customer requirements and satisfactions), and Service (meets minimum standard specifications). The special attributes or abilities that give an organization a competitive edge are: Price, Quality, Time, Flexibility, Service, and Location.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is the strategic importance of operations in achieving competitive advantage, moving beyond just marketing and finance. The value equation (Value = Performance/Cost) is a fundamental framework for understanding customer needs, where performance is measured by quality, speed, and flexibility, and can be weighted to reflect different priorities. A key reason for organizational failure is neglecting operations strategy, which underscores that consistent and productive operations are essential for long-term success. Finally, the hierarchical link between mission, strategy, and tactics is crucial; a clear mission guides the strategy, which is then executed through specific tactics and operating procedures.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five common ways in which organizations compete against each other?
- What is the mathematical formula for Value, and what are its key components?
- List three specific operations-based strategies that a business can use to gain a competitive advantage.
- According to the lecture, what is the single most important reason why organizations fail?
- Explain the hierarchical relationship between an organization's mission, its strategies, and its tactics.
π Lecture 4 β DISTINCTIVE COMPETENCIES
π Overview: This lecture explains the fundamental competitive edge that organizations can achieve through special attributes like price, quality, time, flexibility, service, and location. It introduces operations strategy and its alignment with organizational strategy, providing a detailed framework for strategy design in both manufacturing and service organizations, including the critical concepts of order qualifiers and winners.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the six distinctive competencies that give an organization a competitive edge. It explains the operations strategy design process for manufacturing and services, the relationship between operations and organizational strategy, and the steps in developing a strategy. It then details service organization strategies including strategic service vision, operating strategy, service delivery system, competitive service strategies, and the specific case of online banking in Pakistan, concluding with quality and time-based strategies.
π Lecture Summary
DISTINCTIVE COMPETENCIES
The special attributes or abilities that give an organization a competitive edge are: Price, Quality, Time, Flexibility, Service, and Location. These are the fundamental building blocks of a competitive advantage.
A. Operations Strategy
Operations strategy is the approach, consistent with organization strategy, that is used to guide the operations function.
The Strategy Design Process involves understanding customer needs, which feed into the corporate strategy, which then informs the operations strategy. This leads to decisions on processes and infrastructure. An example is: customer need for "More Product" β corporate strategy to "Increase Organization Size" β operations strategy to "Increase Production Capacity" β decision to "Build New Factory".
The Strategy Design Process for Services uses a Strategy Map with four perspectives: Financial Perspective (Desired Results like improving shareholder value), Customer Perspective (Customer Value Proposition), Internal Perspective (Build-Increase-Achieve), and Learning and Growth Perspective (A Motivated and Prepared Workforce).
Relationship between Operations and Organizational Strategy
Organizational strategy is the overall big picture for the whole organization. It is longer in time horizon, less detailed, and broader in scope.
Operational strategy is narrower in scope and in more detail, prepared by middle management. It should be in line with the organization strategy.
If designed and implemented successfully, operational strategy can make an organization more successful. Organizations started focusing on operational strategies in the early 1990s; before that, organizations focused on financial and marketing strategies. Operational strategies mostly function on two dimensions: quality management and service/manufacturing strategy.
An operations manager should avoid SUBOPTIMIZATION, meaning their operational strategy for the department and divisions' goals should not harm the overall Organizational strategy. They should opt for a systems approach or a big picture approach, strictly basing their operations strategy on Organizational strategy.
Operations Strategy for Service Organizations
Service Organizations in Pakistan function with a very detailed and elaborative Operations Strategy. Service Organizations are busy carrying out detailed environmental scanning and also periodically carry out SWOT Analysis.
Order qualifiers are those significant characteristics that service customers perceive as minimum standards of acceptability to be considered as a potential purchase. Order winners are the characteristics of an organizationβs services that cause it to be perceived as better than the competitorsβ services. For example, a bank offering 10 percent return on customersβ holdings would be an order qualifier, but if the same service has an added feature like availability of interest-free loans for a car or home, then the bank's service becomes an order winner.
Steps in Developing a Manufacturing/Service Strategy
- Segment the market according to the product/Service group.
- Identify product/Service requirements, demand patterns, and profit margins of each group.
- Determine order qualifiers and winners for each group.
- Convert order winners into specific performance requirements.
Key External Factors
β’ Economic conditions should include both Micro and Macro Economics. β’ Political conditions require the organization to carry out PEST analysis. β’ Legal environment relates to government regulations for investor protection. β’ Technology: Gap Analysis focusing on market leaders. β’ Competition: expect no free lunches or no monopolies. β’ Markets are always free markets till proven otherwise.
Key Internal Factors
β’ Human Resources include trained, skilled, and qualified employees. β’ Facilities and equipment are a good source for motivation and obtaining competitive advantage. β’ Financial resources: a higher Free cash flow makes a company outperform its competitors. β’ Customers include repeat customers as well as Customer Relationship Management. β’ Products and services relate to how the organization values whether it provides products or services that add value. β’ Technology: Legacy Systems or Technology that is competitive and has the potential to gain competitive advantage. β’ Suppliers: Companies use effective Supply Chain Management Strategies or vertical or horizontal integration techniques.
Strategic Service Vision
The Service Concept includes: β’ Service Levels refer to the important elements of the service to be provided, usually stated in terms of results produced for customers. β’ Perception corresponds to the elements perceived by the target market segment, by the market in general, by employees, and by others. β’ Delivery focuses on efforts in terms of the manner in which the service is designed, delivered, and marketed.
Operating Strategy
β’ Focus Area includes important elements of the strategy: operations, financing, marketing, organization, human resources, and control. β’ Central Operations to control quality and costs, improve measures, incentives, and rewards. Expected results should be evaluated in terms of quality of service, cost profile, productivity, and morale/loyalty of servers.
Service Delivery System
β’ Important features include role of people, technology, equipment, layout, and procedures. β’ The capacity to provide at peak levels. β’ It helps insure quality standards, differentiate the service from competition, and provide barriers to entry by competitors. β’ Characteristics: Relatively Low Overall Entry Barriers, Economies of Scale Limited, High Transportation Costs, Erratic Sales Fluctuation, No Power Dealing with Buyers or Suppliers, Product Substitutions for Service, High Customer Loyalty, and Exit Barriers.
Competitive Service Strategies (Overall Cost Leadership)
β’ Seeking Out Low-cost Customers β’ Standardizing a Custom Service β’ Reducing the Personal Element in Service Delivery (promote self-service) β’ Reducing Network Costs (hub and spoke) β’ Taking Service Operations Off-line
Competitive Service Strategies (Differentiation)
β’ Making the Intangible Tangible (memorable) β’ Customizing the Standard Product β’ Reducing Perceived Risk β’ Giving Attention to Personnel Training β’ Controlling Quality
π‘ Why this matters: Differentiation in service means being unique in brand image, technology use, features, or reputation for customer service.
Customer Criteria for Selecting an online Banking Service Provider in Pakistan
Service is checked for Availability (24 hour ATM or online financial transaction), Convenience (site location from any internet equipped computer), Dependability (on-time performance and correct information), Personalization (know customerβs name and ID), Price (fee customer pays), Quality (reflected in service), Reputation (word-of-mouth and audited by neutral bodies), Safety (customer data safe from others and hackers), and Speed (avoid excessive waiting).
Online banking service providers are often checked for: β’ Anti-competitiveness: whether they are not allowing other providers to enter by constructing barriers to entry. β’ Fairness: indicates the concept of Yield management, meaning the bank provides the same return as promised. β’ Invasion of Privacy: making use of Micro-marketing concepts, often making the customer feel their privacy is compromised. β’ Data Security: financial records not accessed by unauthorized personnel. β’ Reliability: service is reliable, safe, and usable by customers.
Service Purchase Decision
β’ Service Qualifier: A certain level must be attained on the competitive dimension to be taken seriously. Examples are cleanliness for a fast food restaurant or safe aircraft for an airline. β’ Service Winner: The competitive dimension used to make the final choice among competitors. Example is price of airline ticket or bus fare. β’ Service Loser: Failure to deliver at or above the expected level for a competitive dimension. Examples are failure to repair auto (dependability), rude treatment (personalization), or late delivery of package (speed).
Using Information to Categorize Customers (For Call Centers in Pakistan)
β’ Coding grades customers on how profitable their business is. β’ Routing is used by call centers to place customers in different queues based on customer code. β’ Targeting allows choice customers to have fees waived and get other hidden discounts. β’ Sharing data about your transaction history with other firms is a source of revenue.
Quality and Time Strategies
Quality-based strategies focus on maintaining or improving the quality of an organizationβs products or services, including quality at the source.
Time-based strategies focus on reduction of time needed to accomplish tasks. There are 6 time-based strategies:
- Planning Time: The time required to react to a competitive threat, adopt new technologies, or approve changes to an existing facility.
- Products/Service Design Time: The time needed to develop or market new or redesigned products or services.
- Processing Time: The time required to produce goods or services, including repairing equipment, quality training, and inventory.
- Changeover Time: The time needed to change from producing one type of product or service to another (e.g., new model, new insurance/health service).
- Delivery Time: The time needed to fill orders.
- Response Time for complaints: The time required to improve model or service features according to customer inputs and improving employee working conditions.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture is foundational for understanding how operations contribute to competitive advantage. You must remember the six distinctive competencies and the critical distinction between order qualifiers (minimum standards to be in the market) and order winners (the factor that makes a customer choose you). The strategy design process and the relationship between organizational and operational strategy must be clear, along with the need to avoid suboptimization. Finally, you should be able to differentiate between quality-based and time-based strategies and recall the six specific time-based strategies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- List the six distinctive competencies that give an organization a competitive edge.
- What is the difference between an order qualifier and an order winner? Provide a specific example for a service organization.
- What does the term "suboptimization" mean in the context of operations strategy?
- Describe the Strategy Design Process and its four key perspectives.
- Name three of the six time-based strategies and briefly explain what each one measures.