📘 Lecture 1 — Introduction
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational concepts of Administrative Law & Accountability, focusing on the definitions of law from various legal philosophers, the nature of justice, and the constitutional framework. It matters because it establishes the core vocabulary and philosophical underpinnings needed to understand how law governs both rulers and citizens, forming the basis for the entire course.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by outlining the course objectives, including the phenomena of law, justice, and the constitution, the separation of powers, delegated legislation, and basic rights of Pakistani citizens. It then explores the meaning of philosophy and definition, defines "Law" through Austinien (John Austin) and simple definitions, distinguishes between de-jure and de-facto sovereigns, covers Aristotle’s definition of law, a classical definition of law, explains why and who makes laws, the supreme advantage of law, the concept of supreme law via the Latin maxim, provides a definition of justice, and concludes with a quote on the relationship between law and justice.
📝 Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture presents the main objectives of the entire course. Primarily, the phenomena of Law, Justice, and Constitution will be discussed. Secondly, the separation of powers between the three pillars of state, delegated legislation, and the basic rights of the citizens of Pakistan will also be covered. Before defining law, the terms "philosophy" (the art of reasoning) and "definition" (a one-sentence statement describing a thing by its properties) are clarified.
What is ‘Law’?
Austinien’s definition of law:
John Austin, a renowned 19th-century British jurist and Professor of Jurisprudence at the University of London, defined law in his book "the Province of Jurisprudence Determined" as: “Law is the command of the sovereign”
🔑 Definition — Command: order. 🔑 Definition — Sovereign: ruler. Thus, law is the order of the ruler.
Simple definition of law
“Law is the right of one, obligation of the other, maintained by law enforcing authority”
🔑 Definition — Right: sheltered and recognized interest. 🔑 Definition — Obligation: duty. 🔑 Definition — Maintained: managed. 🔑 Definition — Enforcing authority: implementing power. Thus, law is the sheltered and recognized interest of one, duty of the other, managed and controlled by law implementing power.
🔑 Definition — Kinds of sovereign: (1) de-jure sovereign: Constitutional ruler. (2) de-facto sovereign: Unconstitutional ruler. Aristotle defines a constitution as "an arrangement of office" and "a manner of life."
Aristotle’s definition of law:
“Law is the experience, developed by reason and reason, tested by experience”.
🔑 Definition — Experience: knowledge. 🔑 Definition — Reason: rationale. 🔑 Definition — Tested: checked. Thus, law is knowledge developed by rationale, and rationale checked by knowledge. 📌 Relevant quotation: "Experience is a very hard teacher; she gives the test first, the lesson afterwards."
Classical definition of law:
Law is the ‘dispassionate reason’ and its content is the same as that of morality.
🔑 Definition — Dispassionate: unemotional. 🔑 Definition — Reason: rationale. 🔑 Definition — Content: substance.
Why laws are made?
Laws are made to regulate human actions.
Who makes laws?
Laws are made by super human wisdom. In a modern political state, they are made by Parliament.
Advantage of law
The supreme advantage of law is peace and harmony. Law governs both the ruler and the ruled.
Concept of supreme law
“Salus est populi suprema lex” (Latin Maxim)
🔑 Definition — Salus: welfare 🔑 Definition — est: is 🔑 Definition — Populi: people 🔑 Definition — Suprema: supreme 🔑 Definition — Lex: law Thus, welfare of people is the supreme law.
What is justice?
Justice means every man given his legal right.
Relevant quote on relationship of law and justice
“Justice is an ideal like truth just as a sculptor tries to achieve beauty with his mallet and chisel, so law is the tool of a judge in the pursuit of justice.”
🔑 Definition — Ideal: model 🔑 Definition — Beauty: splendor or prettiness 🔑 Definition — Mallet: hammer 🔑 Definition — Chisel: shape 🔑 Definition — Tool: instrument 🔑 Definition — Pursuit: search Thus, justice is a model like truth; just as a sculptor tries to achieve prettiness with his hammer and a shape, so law is the instrument of a judge in the search of justice. 💡 Why this matters: This quote establishes the aspirational role of law as a tool for achieving justice, a core theme for the course.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that "Law" has multiple definitions, including Austin's "command of the sovereign" and Aristotle's "experience developed by reason." The simple definition of law establishes a relationship of rights and obligations enforced by authority. The welfare of the people ("Salus est populi suprema lex") is the supreme law, and justice is defined as giving every person their legal right. Finally, law is understood as a tool (like a sculptor's chisel) used by a judge to pursue the ideal of justice.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to John Austin, what is the definition of law?
- What are the two kinds of sovereign mentioned in the lecture, and how do they differ?
- State the simple definition of law, explaining its three key components: right, obligation, and enforcing authority.
- What is the Latin maxim for the supreme law, and what does it mean in English?
- How does the lecture describe the relationship between law and justice, using the sculptor analogy?
📘 Lecture 2 — What are the kinds of justice?
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental concepts of justice, its various kinds, and the nature of law. It explains the difference between natural and legal justice, and delves into the sub-categories of legal justice, including civil and criminal justice. The lecture also defines what law is, who makes it, and discusses its advantages, disadvantages, and the different kinds of law.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining two kinds of justice: natural and legal. It then divides legal justice into private and public justice, and further breaks down public justice into civil and criminal justice, detailing their differences. The discussion then shifts to who makes laws (Parliament), the definition of justice itself, and the characteristics of effective law. Finally, the lecture covers the advantages and disadvantages of law and lists the different kinds of law, including common law, equity, statute law, substantive and procedural law, private and public law, and criminal and civil law.
📝 Lecture Summary
Justice is of following two kinds: (1) Natural justice (2) Legal justice
Natural justice deals with the enforcement of rights and punishments of wrongs according to moral standards as they appeal to the mind of human beings. It stands independent of recognition by the state. Legal justice denotes justice according to what the law declares to be just (right). Legal justice can be divided into two kinds: (a) Private justice & (b) Public justice. Private or personal justice is what the person whose right is violated wants from the counter party. Public or community justice is what a plaintiff demands and receives from the community through a court if his counter parties have denied him personal justice. Private Justice is the object for which the public justice exists.
Kinds of public justice:
Following are the two kinds of public justice: (a) Civil justice (b) Criminal justice
The two kinds can be well understood by understanding their following points of difference:
| Points of Difference | Civil Justice | Criminal Justice |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Wrong | Dispensed for private wrongs (breach of right of individual). | Dispensed for public wrongs (breach of right of community). |
| Purpose | To compensate (reimburse) the aggrieved party. | To punish (penalize) the offenders (wrongdoers). |
| Procedure | Civil procedure is adopted. | Criminal procedure is adopted. |
| Nature of Court | Administered by Civil Courts. | Administered by Criminal Courts. |
| Degree of Harmfulness | Civil wrongs are relatively less harmful for the society. | Criminal wrongs are relatively more harmful. |
| Style of Titling | Titled as Bashier Hussan versus Nazier Akhtar. | Titled as State versus Bashier Hussain. |
| Relevant Procedural Code | The Civil Procedure Code, 1908. | The Criminal Procedure Code, 1898. |
| Prosecution | Government does not prosecute the case. | Government prosecutes the case. |
| Measuring the Liability | Motive, Intention, Magnitude of the offense, and Character of the offender are irrelevant. | Liability is measured by keeping Motive, Intention, Magnitude of the offense, and Character of the offender in view. |
Who makes laws?
Laws are made by super human wisdom. In modern political state they are made by Parliament of a state.
What is Parliament?
The supreme legislative body of a country. The parliament of Pakistan consists of: National Assembly, Senate and the President.
Supreme advantage of law:
The supreme advantage of law is peace and harmony. Law governs both the ruler and the ruled.
What is justice?
Justice means giving every man his legal rights. It is said that justice is the daughter of law.
What law is considered effective law?
Law that has the following characteristics is known as effective law:
- Issued by the un-commanded commander—the sovereign;
- The commands are backed by threats of sanctions; and
- The sovereign is habitually obeyed.
Some important quotations relating law
(1) United States is the greatest law making factory the world has ever known. (2) Laws are imperative in nature. (3) Law helps the vigilante not the indolent; it means law comes to the assistance of the vigilant, not of sleepy. (4) Violence is inimical (against) to law. It means law does not like violence but peace. (5) People follow truth; truth makes public opinion; public opinion makes law.
Advantages of law
(1) Uniformity and certainty (2) Equality & impartiality (3) Protection from errors
Uniformity and certainty The first advantage is that the law imparts uniformity and certainty to the administration of justice. This advantage enables the people to know what the law is and what would be the decision of the court.
Equality and impartiality The law is made for no particular person or for no individual case and so admits no respect of person which is incompatible with justice. None can escape from the clutches of law.
Protection from errors: The law serves to protect the administration of justice from the errors of individual judgment. The establishment of the law is the substitution of the opinion and conscience of the society at large for those of the individual to whom judicial functions are entrusted. Aristotle observes: “to seek to be wiser than the laws is the very thing forbidden by good law itself.”
Disadvantages of law
The law is without doubt a remedy for greater evils, yet it brings with it the evils of its own. The evils are discussed as under:
Rigidity: The first disadvantage of law is its rigidity. Because of its rigidity, it applies without any allowance for special circumstances and without turning to the right hand or to the left. Rigidity is the failure of law to conform itself to the requirements of special circumstances.
Conservatism: Conservatism is law's failure to conform itself to those changes in circumstances and in men’s views of truth and justice. Progressive societies are in advance of law. The existing body of rules may be found inapplicable to such changed circumstances.
Formalism: Another vice of the law is formalism. This means the tendency to attribute more importance to technical requirements than to substantive rights and wrongs. In modern times, registration and attestation are examples of formalities.
Needless complexities: The fourth defect of law is undue and needless complexity. The law becomes more and more complex due to the excessive development of legal system and it becomes too difficult to understand the law.
Kinds of Law
(1) Common law (2) Equity (3) Statute law (4) Substantive law (5) Procedural law (6) Private law (7) Public law (8) Criminal law (9) Civil law
Common law: The term ‘common law’ is derived from the French law word ‘common ley’ which means ‘the body of law derived from judicial decisions, rather than from statutes or constitutions.’ It is said that reason is the life of law and the Common law itself is nothing else but a reason.
🔑 Definition: Statute: a law passed by a legislative body. 🔑 Definition: Constitution: the fundamental and organic law of a nation or state that establishes the institutions and apparatus of government, defines the scope of governmental sovereign powers, and guarantees individual civil rights and civil liberties.
Blackstone says: ‘Common law is the municipal law of England or the rule of civil conduct prescribed to the inhabitants of the kingdom.’ About common law it is also said that: ‘Common law is the experience expressed in law.’
Equity: Equity is not part of the law, but a moral virtue, which qualifies, moderates, and reforms the rigor, hardness, and edge of the Common law. Equity does not destroy the law nor create it but assists it. Underbill says: ‘Equity was originally the result of common sense against the pedantry of law and trammels of the feudal system; it became a highly artificial and refined body of legal principles and it is at the present day an amendment and modification of the Common law.” Aristotle provides a comprehensive definition, stating that equity looks to the spirit and not the letter, to the intention and not the action, and prefers arbitration to judgment.
🔑 Definition: Equitable: consistent with principles of justice and right.
Statute law A law passed by the parliament of England. (English parliament = House of Commons + House of Lords + Crown).
Substantive law The part of the law that creates, defines, and regulates the rights, duties and powers of parties.
Procedural law The body of rules governing procedures and practices.
Private law Private law is the body of law dealing with private persons and their property and relationships.
Public law The body of law dealing with the relations between private individuals and the government, and with the structure and operation of the government itself; constitutional law, criminal law, and administrative law taken together.
Criminal law The body of law defining offenses against the community at large, regulating how suspects are investigated, charged, and tried, and establishing punishments for convicted offenders. In a criminal case the state is the prosecutor because it is the community as a whole which suffers. The burden of proof to convict the accused is on the prosecution, which must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
🔑 Definition - Reasonable doubt: the doubt that prevents one from being firmly convinced of a defendant’s guilt—‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ is the standard used by a jury to determine whether a criminal defendant is guilty. 📌 Example: Crime: an act that the law makes punishable.
Civil law Civil law deals with disputes over the rights and obligations of persons dealing with each other. It is a form of private law. In civil proceedings, the case is proved on the balance of probability. The claimant must convince the court that it is more probable than not that their assertions are true.
🔑 Definition - Balance of probabilities: the greater weight of the evidence, not necessarily established by the greater number of witnesses testifying to a fact but by evidence that has the most convincing force.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For an exam, you must first be able to distinguish between natural and legal justice and then clearly differentiate between civil and criminal justice based on all nine points. Second, remember the definition of an effective law (issued by sovereign, backed by sanctions, habitually obeyed) and the supreme advantage of law (peace and harmony). Third, master the three advantages of law (uniformity and certainty, equality and impartiality, protection from errors) and the four disadvantages (rigidity, conservatism, formalism, needless complexities). Fourth, you must be able to define and distinguish between the nine kinds of law, with special attention to the definitions of Common law, Equity, Substantive law, Procedural law, Private law, Public law, Criminal law, and Civil law. Finally, understand the key differences in the burden of proof (beyond reasonable doubt for criminal, balance of probabilities for civil) and the role of the state (prosecutor in criminal, not in civil).
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between natural justice and legal justice?
- List four key differences between civil justice and criminal justice regarding their purpose, nature of wrong, how liability is measured, and prosecution.
- According to the lecture, what three characteristics define an "effective law"?
- Explain the four main disadvantages of law as discussed in the lecture (rigidity, conservatism, formalism, and needless complexity).
- What is the difference between "beyond a reasonable doubt" and "on the balance of probability," and to which kind of justice (civil or criminal) does each standard apply?
📘 Lecture 3 — Court System of Pakistan
📖 Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive overview of the hierarchical structure of Pakistan's court system, ranging from the Supreme Court at the apex down to the lowest tiers of civil and magistrate courts. It explains the jurisdiction, composition, and key functions of each court, including specialized tribunals, making it essential for understanding the legal framework of Pakistan.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a list of all courts in Pakistan, from the Supreme Court to Civil Judge courts. It then details the Supreme Court of Pakistan as the final arbiter, followed by the Federal Shariat Court's role in scrutinizing laws against Islamic injunctions. The High Courts of Pakistan are discussed with their constitutional jurisdiction under Article 199 of the Constitution. The lecture concludes with District & Sessions Courts, Civil Judge Cum Judicial Magistrates' Courts, and a list of Special Tribunals and Boards.
📝 Lecture Summary
Court system of Pakistan
The court system of Pakistan consists of courts diverse in echelons of legal superiority and jurisdiction. The hierarchy includes the Supreme Court of Pakistan, Federal Shariat Court of Pakistan, High Courts of Pakistan (one in each province and in the Federal Capital), District Courts of Pakistan (one in each district), Judicial Magistrate Courts (with power of Section 30 of Cr.PC only in criminal trials), Judicial Magistrate Courts (in every town and city), Executive Magistrate Courts (summary trial court), and Courts of Civil Judge (judges with power of 1st class and 2nd class cases).
The Supreme Court of Pakistan
The Supreme Court stands at the top of Pakistan's judicial hierarchy; it is the final arbiter of legal and constitutional disputes. It has 17 permanent judges and a permanent seat in Islamabad. It has its Branch Registries in Lahore, Peshawar, Quetta, and Karachi. Besides exercising appellate and constitutional jurisdiction and suo moto power, the court has also established itself as a de facto check on military power.
The Federal Shariat Court of Pakistan
The Federal Shariat Court was established by the Presidential Order in 1980 to scrutinize all laws of Pakistan which are repugnant to Islamic injunctions. Repugnant means contrary. If a law is found repugnant, the Court is bound to provide notice thereof to the government. Thereof means of that. The court also exercises jurisdiction to examine any decision of any criminal court relating to application of Islamic Hudd penalties. Jurisdiction means a court’s power to decide a case.
The court consists of 8 Muslim judges including the Chief Justice. The Judges are appointed by the President of Pakistan in consultation with the Judicial Committee consisting of the Chief Justice of Pakistan (Federal Shariat Court) and the Chief Justice of Pakistan.
The Federal Shariat Court, on its own motion or through petition by a citizen or a government, has the power to examine and determine as to whether or not a certain provision of law is repugnant to the injunctions of Islam. Against the orders or decisions of the Federal Shariat Court, an appeal may be preferred to the Shariat Appellate Bench of the Supreme Court. Preferred means filed.
The court also exercises revisional jurisdiction over the criminal courts that decide Hudood cases. The decisions of the court are binding on the High Courts and subordinate judiciary.
Following are High courts in Pakistan
The High Courts in Pakistan include the Lahore High Court, Lahore, Punjab; Sindh High Court, Karachi, Sindh; Peshawar High Court, Peshawar, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa; Balochistan High Court, Quetta, Balochistan; and Islamabad High Court, Islamabad, ICT.
The High Courts are the appellate courts for all civil and criminal cases in each respective province. The High Courts' jurisdiction is mentioned in the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, Article 199.
🔑 Definition — Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973: Jurisdiction of High Court. (1) Subject to the Constitution, a High Court may, if it is satisfied that no other adequate remedy is provided by law,- (a) on the application of any aggrieved party, make an order- (i) directing a person performing, within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court, functions in connection with the affairs of the Federation, a Province or a local authority, to refrain from doing anything he is not permitted by law to do, or to do anything he is required by law to do; or (ii) declaring that any act done or proceeding taken within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court by a person performing functions in connection with the affairs of the Federation, a Province or a local authority has been done or taken without lawful authority and is of no legal effect; or (b) on the application of any person, make an order- (i) directing that a person in custody within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court be brought before it so that the Court may satisfy itself that he is not being held in custody without lawful authority or in an unlawful manner; or (ii) requiring a person within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court holding or purporting to hold a public office to show under what authority of law he claims to hold that office; or (c) on the application of any aggrieved person, make an order giving such directions to any person or authority, including any Government exercising any power or performing any function in, or in relation to, any territory within the jurisdiction of that Court as may be appropriate for the enforcement of any of the Fundamental Rights conferred by Chapter 1 of Part II. (2) Subject to the Constitution, the right to move a High Court for the enforcement of any of the Fundamental Rights conferred by Chapter 1 of Part II shall not be abridged. (3) An order shall not be made under clause (1) on application made by or in relation to a person who is a member of the Armed Forces of Pakistan, or who is for the time being subject to any law relating to any of those Forces, in respect of his terms and conditions of service, in respect of any matter arising out of his service, or in respect of any action taken in relation to him as a member of the Armed Forces of Pakistan or as a person subject to such law. (4) Where- (a) an application is made to a High Court for an order under paragraph (a) or paragraph (c) of clause (1), and (b) the making of an interim order would have the effect of prejudicing or interfering with the carrying out of a public work or of otherwise being harmful to public interest or State property or of impeding the assessment or collection of public revenues, the Court shall not make an interim order unless the prescribed law officer has been given notice of the application and he or any person authorized by him in that behalf has had an opportunity of being heard and the Court, for reasons to be recorded in writing, is satisfied that the interim order- (i) would not have such effect as aforesaid; or (ii) would have the effect of suspending an order or proceeding which on the face of the record is without jurisdiction.
An interim order made by a High Court on an application made to it to question the validity or legal effect of any order made, proceeding taken or act done by any authority or person, which has been made, taken or done or purports to have been made, taken or done under any law which is specified in Part I of the First Schedule or relates to, or is connected with, State property or assessment or collection of public revenues shall cease to have effect on the expiration of a period of six months following the day on which it is made: Provided that the matter shall be finally decided by the High Court within six months from the date on which the interim order is made. (4B) Every case in which, on an application under clause (1), the High Court has made an interim order shall be disposed of by the High Court on merits within six months from the day on which it is made, unless the High Court is prevented from doing so for sufficient cause to be recorded. (5) In this Article, unless the context otherwise requires,- "person" includes any body politic or corporate, any authority of or under the control of the Federal Government or of a Provincial Government, and any Court or tribunal, other than the Supreme Court, a High Court or a Court or tribunal established under a law relating to the Armed Forces of Pakistan; and "prescribed law officer" means (a) in relation to an application affecting the Federal Government or an authority of or under the control of the Federal Government, the Attorney-General, and (b) in any other case, the Advocate-General for the Province in which the application is made.
District & Sessions Courts
District courts exist in every district of each province, and have civil and criminal jurisdiction. In each District Headquarters, there are numerous Additional District & Session Judges who usually preside over the courts. The District & Sessions Judge has executive and judicial power all over the district under his jurisdiction. The Sessions court is also a trial court for heinous offences such as Murder, Rape (Zina), Haraba offences (armed robbery where a specific amount of gold and cash is involved), and is also an appellate court for summary conviction offences and civil suits of lesser value. Each town and city now has a court of Additional District & Sessions judge, which possesses equal authority over its jurisdiction. When hearing criminal cases, it is called the Sessions Court, and when it hears civil cases, the District Court. Executive matters are brought before the relevant District & Sessions Judge.
Civil Judge Cum Judicial Magistrates' Courts
In every town and city, there are numerous Civil and Judicial Magistrates' Courts. A Magistrate with the powers of Section 30 of the Criminal Procedure Code has the jurisdiction to hear all criminal matters other than those which carry the death penalty such as attempted murder, dacoity, robbery, extortion, etc., but may only pass a sentence of up to seven years' imprisonment. If the court thinks the accused deserves more punishment than seven years in jail, then it has to refer the matter to a higher court, with its recommendations to that effect. Every Magistrate’s Court is allocated a local jurisdiction, usually encompassing one or more Police Stations in the area. Trial of all non-bailable offences, including police remand notices, accused discharges, arrest and search warrants, and bail applications, are heard and decided by Magistrate Courts. Most Judicial Magistrates may hear civil suits as well. If they do so, they are usually called a Civil Judge Cum Judicial Magistrate.
Special Tribunals and Boards
The following are the special tribunals in Pakistan: Banking Courts, Services Tribunals, Income Tax Tribunals, Anti Corruption Courts, Anti Narcotics Courts, Anti terrorist Courts, Labor Relations Court, Board of Revenue, Special Magistrate courts, and Consumer Courts - drug courts.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The court system of Pakistan is a strict hierarchy, with the Supreme Court at the top possessing final appellate and constitutional jurisdiction. The Federal Shariat Court has the unique power to examine laws for repugnancy to Islamic injunctions, with appeals going to the Supreme Court's Shariat Appellate Bench. The jurisdiction of the High Courts is constitutionally defined in Article 199, which allows them to issue orders for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights and act as the primary appellate courts for their provinces. The District & Sessions Judge has both executive and judicial authority over a district, while Civil Judge Cum Judicial Magistrates handle most routine criminal and civil matters, with a sentencing limit of seven years.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the highest court in Pakistan and what are its main functions?
- What is the primary purpose of the Federal Shariat Court, and what happens if it finds a law repugnant?
- Under which Article of the Constitution is the jurisdiction of a High Court defined?
- What is the sentencing limit for a Magistrate with powers under Section 30 of the Criminal Procedure Code?
- Name the trial court for heinous offenses like murder and rape in a district.
📘 Lecture 4 — Sources of Law & Delegated Legislation in Pakistan
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the two primary sources of law in Pakistan: legislation and judicial precedent. It details the legislative process for ordinary and money bills in Parliament and explores the concept of delegated legislation, including its types, advantages, disadvantages, and controls. The lecture also provides a comprehensive analysis of judicial precedent, its binding authority, kinds, and how it is applied or disregarded.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining "sources of law" and introducing legislation as a primary source, detailing parliamentary sovereignty in Pakistan and the procedure for ordinary and money bills, including their key distinctions. It then transitions to delegated legislation, explaining its definition, various types (Orders, Regulations, Rules, Directions, Byelaws), and its advantages and disadvantages, along with parliamentary and judicial controls. The final major section addresses judicial precedent, covering its definition, the doctrine of stare decisis, kinds of precedent, the concepts of ratio decidendi and obiter dicta, how to read law reports, and the circumstances that affect a precedent's authority.
📝 Lecture Summary
Sources of Law & Delegated Legislation in Pakistan
The terms ‘sources’ and ‘law’ respectively mean ‘a point that something comes from’ and ‘rule’. Thus the phrase: ‘sources of law’ means the point where rules come from. Legislation and Precedent are the two main sources of law.
Legislation
The term ‘legislation’ has its etymology in the Latin words: ‘Legis’ & ‘Latum’, respectively meaning ‘law’ & ‘to make’. Thus, ‘legislation’ means ‘to make law’. In Pakistan, the legislative sovereignty belongs to Parliament, meaning only the National Assembly, Senate, and the President can pass, amend, or repeal laws. The constitution provides the legislative procedure in part III, chapter 2. Articles 70-89 of the constitution empower Parliament to make laws. A bill is a proposal for a new law or for amending or repealing an old one.
There are three kinds of bills: (i) Public Bill: Relates to the public at large. (ii) Private Bill: Relates to the interest of private individuals. (iii) Money Bill: Relates to finance matters.
🔑 Definition — Bill: A proposal for a new law for amending or repealing an old one.
I. Legislative procedure for ordinary and non-money bill: (i) Introduction of Bill: May be introduced in either of the two houses. If introduced by a government minister, it is a government bill; otherwise, it is a private bill. (ii) First Reading: The member who introduces the bill explains the causes of its presentation. (iii) Reference to committee: The bill is examined in detail. The committee hears evidence from experts and any objections from interested persons. (iv) Second reading: The bill is discussed clause by clause, and amendments may be made. (v) Third reading: After the second reading, it is read a third time and sent to the other house, where the same procedure is adopted. If passed in a joint sitting by a majority vote of the total membership, it is presented to the president for assent. (vi) President's assent to bills: If passed, it shall be presented to the president for assent.
📌 Example: Relevant case law: P.L.D. 2001. Kar. 415 — It was held that a bill would become law when assented to by the president or the governor, as the case may be.
II. Legislative procedure in money bill: Article 73 of the constitution states that a money bill shall originate in the National Assembly. After being passed by the National Assembly, without being transmitted to the Senate, it is presented to the president, who will assent within thirty days; otherwise, the bill is deemed to have been assented to and becomes law.
(a) Features of money bill: A bill or amendment is deemed a money bill if it contains provisions dealing with the following matters: (a) imposition, abolition, remission, alteration of any tax; (b) borrowing of money or giving any guarantee by the Federal Govt; (c) custody of the Federal Consolidated Fund; (d) imposition of a charge upon the Federal Consolidated Fund; (e) receipt of money on account of the public accounts of the federation; (f) audit of the accounts of the Federal Govt; (g) any matter incidental to any of the specified matters.
(b) Dispute regarding determination of money bill: If any question arises whether a bill is a money bill or not, the decision of the Speaker of the National Assembly shall be final.
7. Distinction between money bill and ordinary bill: (i) As to Nature: Money bill relates to finance matters; ordinary bill relates to the interest of private or public persons. (ii) As to origin: Money bill can be originated only in the National Assembly; ordinary bill can be originated in either house. (iii) As to transmission: Money bill is not transmitted to the other house; ordinary bill is transmitted to the other house when passed by one house.
Delegated Legislation in Pakistan
In Pakistan, delegated legislation is legislation that is passed otherwise than an Act of Parliament. An enabling Act or the parent Act confers a power to make delegated legislation on a Government Minister or another person or body. For example, section 506 of the Companies Ordinance 1984 confers delegated powers on the federal government to make relevant rules. Delegated legislation can be used for a wide variety of purposes, from fixing the date an Act comes into force to filling in the detail of how an Act will be implemented in practice.
🔑 Definition — Enabling Act or Parent Act: A law that creates new powers, especially a statute conferring powers on an executive agency to carry out various delegated tasks.
Types of delegated legislation: (1) Orders: Made by the president on the advice of the Federal Cabinet, used for matters of constitutional significance. Orders are usually made by Ministers. Commencement Orders are used to set the date an Act comes into force. (2) Regulations: Usually made by Ministers, they are the means by which substantive and detailed law is made, e.g., regulations under the Income Tax Ordinance 2001. (3) Rules: Set out procedures, e.g., rules governing court procedures. They may be made by Ministers or a senior judge. (5) Directions: A means by which Ministers give legally binding instructions to a public body about how it exercises its functions. (6) Byelaws: Laws of limited application, usually restricted to certain places, made by local authorities or other bodies to control activities.
Advantages: Allows laws to be enacted without using scarce Parliamentary time; allows laws on technical matters to be prepared by experts; is flexible enough to deal speedily with changing circumstances and is invaluable in emergencies.
Disadvantages: Subject to less parliamentary scrutiny and can potentially be used in ways Parliament had not intended. The sheer volume of laws means there is little publicity about changes.
Controls over delegated legislation: There are both parliamentary and judicial controls. Parliamentary controls require delegated legislation to be approved by a vote of each House or be subject to a veto. Judicial control is exercised through judicial review. The courts can strike down delegated legislation if it is ultra vires (beyond the power), meaning the Government used it for a purpose not envisioned by the parent Act or if pre-conditions were not satisfied.
🔑 Definition — Ultra Vires: Beyond the power; an act by a person or body that goes beyond the legal authority given to them.
Precedent
According to Black’s law dictionary, ‘precedent is the making of law by a court in recognizing and applying new rules while administering justice’. The doctrine of judicial precedent is the rule that precedents not only have persuasive authority but also must be followed when similar circumstances arise. This is based on the principle of ‘stare decisis’, which means ‘stand by things decided’.
🔑 Definition — Stare Decisis: The principle that courts should follow the precedents established by previous decisions.
Precedents are contained in Law Reports. A precedent is a ‘considered decision’ of a court which provides a rule for the determination of an identical or similar question of law.
Kinds of Precedent: (1) Declaratory Precedent: Merely an application of an already existing rule. (2) Original Precedent: Creates and applies a new legal rule. (3) Authoritative Precedent: An applicable holding of a higher court binding upon lower courts. (4) Persuasive Precedent: Not binding but entitled to respect and careful consideration, e.g., a case from a neighboring jurisdiction. (5) Precedent of Absolute Authority: Absolutely binding, however unreasonable it may be. (6) Precedent of Conditional Authority: Binding but not absolutely.
Ratio Decidendi’: The ratio for the decision of a particular case or the principle of law on which the decision is based. Salmond defines it as the abstract ratio which alone has the force of law as regards the world at large.
Obiter dicta: Statements of law made by the court by the way that go beyond the requirements of the particular case. These are not directly connected with the case but when made by superior courts are binding on subordinate courts.
🔑 Definition — Ratio Decidendi: The principle of law on which a court's decision is based.
How to Read a Law Report Example: Best v Samuel Fox & Co. Ltd 1952 2 All ER 394
- Best = Claimant
- Samuel Fox & Co. = Defendant
- 1952 = Year of report
- 2 = Volume 2
- All = All
- ER = England Law Reports This means the report is published at page 394 of Volume 2 of All England Reports for 1952.
How is precedent disregarded? (1) It may be overruled by a court of superior jurisdiction, causing it to lose all its force with retrospective effect. (2) Circumstances lessening authority include lack of unanimity, failure to notice a contrary decision, decisions based on compromise, or decisions given in haste.
Difference between legislation and precedent:
| Points of difference | Legislation | Precedent |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Finds its source in the law-making will of the state | Derived from the ratio decidendi |
| Meaning | Enactment of a rule of law intended to apply to future cases | Making of law by the recognition and application of new rules by the courts |
| Object | To lay down a certain guide for future conduct | The decision of a particular case |
| Form of expression | Expressed in general and abstract terms | Suffers from the complexity and limitation of its particular facts |
| Rules of interpretation | Easy to interpret; given its ordinary meaning | Not so easy; ascertained by a process of induction |