๐ Lecture 18 โ Process Selection
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of process selection, which determines how an organization produces its goods or services. It covers key strategic decisions like make-or-buy, capital intensity, and process flexibility, alongside different types of production systems such as continuous, intermittent, and automated processing. Understanding process selection is vital for designing efficient operations and aligning production capacity with customer demand.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the meaning and introduction of process selection, including the three elements of process strategy: make-or-buy decisions, capital intensity, and process flexibility. It also discusses reasons for making or buying, types of operations (continuous, repetitive, intermittent, batch, job shop), automation types (CAM, NC machines, robots), flexible automation (manufacturing cells, FMS), and computer integrated manufacturing. Finally, it presents an operations strategy for process selection.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction and Meaning
Process Selection refers to the way an organization chooses to produce its goods or services. It takes into account selection of technology, capacity planning, layout of facilities, and design of work systems. Process selection is a natural extension after selection of new products and services.
An organization's process strategy includes:
- Make or Buy Decisions: The extent to which an organization will produce goods or provide services in-house as opposed to relying on an outside organization.
- Capital Intensity: The mix of equipment and labor that will be used by the organization.
- Process Flexibility: The degree to which the system can be adjusted to changes in processing requirements due to factors such as changes in product or service design, changes in volume processed, and changes in technology.
Reasons to Make or Buy
There are six reasons to decide whether to develop a competence in-house or outsource to an external organization. Outsourcing requires the provider to be honest, ethical, and competent, and the contract should be flexible yet pragmatic.
- Available Capacity: If an organization has the equipment, necessary skills, and time, it often makes sense to produce an item or perform a service in-house. The additional costs would be relatively small compared with buying or subcontracting.
- Expertise: If a firm lacks the expertise to do a job satisfactorily, buying might be a reasonable alternative.
- Quality Considerations: Firms that specialize can usually offer higher quality than an organization can attain itself. Conversely, special quality requirements or the ability to closely monitor quality may cause an organization to perform a job itself.
- Nature of Demand: When demand for an item is high and steady, the organization is often better off doing the work itself. However, wide fluctuations in demand or small orders are usually better handled by specialists who can combine orders from multiple sources.
- Cost: Any cost savings achieved from buying or making must be weighed against the preceding factors. Cost savings might come from the item itself or from transportation cost savings. Fixed costs associated with making an item that cannot be reallocated must be recognized in cost analysis.
- Risk: Outsourcing or buying services carries risk; often companies retain flexibility by carrying out certain critical activities in-house and repetitive menial activities through outsourcing.
Types of Operation
The degree of standardization and the volume of output influence how production is organized. Output can range from high volume, highly standardized, to low volume, highly customized.
- Continuous Processing
- Repetitive Processing
- Intermittent Processing
- Batch Processing
- Job Shop
- Automation
- Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM)
- Numerically Controlled (NC) Machines
- Robot
- Manufacturing Cell
- Flexible Manufacturing System (FMS)
Continuous and Semi Continuous Operations
Continuous Processing: A system that produces highly uniform products or continuous services, often performed by machines. Examples include processing of chemicals, photographic film, newsprint, and oil products.
Repetitive Processing: A production system that renders one or a few highly standardized products or services. Examples include automobiles, televisions, computers, calculators, cameras, and video equipment.
Intermittent Processing
Intermittent Processing: A system that produces lower volumes of items or services with a greater variety of processing requirements.
Batch Processing: A system used to produce moderate volumes of similar items. Examples include paint, ice cream, canned vegetables, magazines, newspapers, textbooks, and user manuals.
Job Shop: A system that renders unit or small lot production or service with varying specifications according to customer needs.
Automation
Automation: Machinery that has sensing and controlling devices that enables it to operate automatically.
- Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM): The use of computers in process control.
- Numerically Controlled (NC) Machines: Machines that perform operations by following mathematical processing instructions.
- Robot: A machine that consists of a mechanical arm, a power supply, and a controller.
Flexible Automation
Manufacturing Cell: One or a few NC machines that produce a variety of parts.
Flexible Manufacturing System (FMS): A group of machines designed to handle intermittent processing requirements and produce a variety of similar products.
- Designed to handle intermittent processes
- Offers reduced labor costs and consistent quality
- Higher flexibility compared to hard automation
Disadvantages of FMS:
- Requires longer time for planning and development
- Can handle only a narrow range of parts variety
Computer Integrated Manufacturing
The lecture repeats the same content under Computer Integrated Manufacturing as was listed under Flexible Automation, describing Manufacturing Cell and Flexible Manufacturing System with identical advantages and disadvantages. ๐ก Why this matters: This suggests that Computer Integrated Manufacturing builds upon or incorporates the concepts of flexible automation to create a fully integrated production environment.
Operations Strategy with respect to Process Selection
Operations strategy can be fine-tuned when discussing new ideas. A process selection-based operations strategy includes:
- Hire and Promote Managers who have both Technical and Managerial Skills: As engineers fail in managerial decisions and managers end up relying on engineers who create "WHITE ELEPHANTS" (costly, underutilized investments).
- Flexibility as a competitive strategy to be incorporated at all levels.
- Judicious use of Automation: Unnecessary automation causes an increase in cost and a subsequent increase in product and inventory.
โญ Key Takeaways
Process selection is a critical strategic decision that determines how an organization produces goods or services, encompassing make-or-buy decisions, capital intensity, and process flexibility. The choice between in-house production and outsourcing depends on factors like available capacity, expertise, quality needs, demand nature, cost, and risk. Production systems range from continuous and repetitive processing (high volume, standardized) to intermittent processing like batch and job shop (lower volume, customized). Automation includes CAM, NC machines, and robots, while flexible automation through manufacturing cells and FMS offers reduced costs and consistent quality but requires longer planning. A sound operations strategy emphasizes hiring managers with both technical and managerial skills, prioritizing flexibility, and using automation judiciously to avoid unnecessary costs.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three elements of an organization's process strategy?
- List the six reasons for deciding whether to make or buy a product or service.
- What is the difference between continuous processing and repetitive processing?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of a Flexible Manufacturing System (FMS)?
- Why should automation be used judiciously according to the operations strategy?
๐ Lecture 19 โ Facilities Layouts
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of facilities layout, which is the configuration of departments, work centers, and equipment with a focus on the movement of goods or services. It explains the four basic layout typesโproduct, process, fixed position, and hybridโand provides a detailed comparison of product and process layouts, including their characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages. This matters because poor layout design can lead to operational inefficiencies, long waiting times, and high costs, making it a critical responsibility for operations managers.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining facilities layout and illustrating its importance with real-world examples like airports. It then categorizes the four basic layout types: Product/Service layout, Process layout, Fixed Position layout, and Hybrid/Combination layout. The Product Layout is explored in detail, including its characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages. A U-Shaped Production Line is introduced as an alternative to straight lines for improved teamwork and space efficiency. Finally, the Process Layout is discussed, contrasting its advantages and disadvantages with the product layout.
๐ Lecture Summary
Facilities Layouts
Facilities layout corresponds to the configuration of departments, sections, work centers, and equipment with the focus being on movement of goods or services or workers. A traveler making use of a railway platform, bus station, or airport is a good example of work being moved through a facility. Often, poor design of the productive system can result in poor design of the facilities layout. After 9/11, most airports in the western world have shown that they are poorly designed to handle air traffic, and passengers end up paying a heavy price in the form of long waiting hours. The reason is that no attention was paid at the time of design or construction to separate the boarding lounge from the ticketing counter or lobby. Such shortcomings plague organizations, and itโs the task of the operations manager to ensure that product as well as service layouts match the organizationโs short as well as long-term plans.
Basic Layout Types
The common basic layout types are:
- Product/Service layout: A layout that uses standardized processing operations to achieve smooth, rapid, high-volume flow.
- Process layout: A layout that can handle varied processing requirements.
- Fixed Position layout: A layout in which the product or project remains stationary, and workers, materials, and equipment are moved as needed.
- Hybrid/Combination: A layout that makes use of the combination of Product, Process, or Fixed Position Layout.
Product Layout Characteristics
- Product layouts are used to achieve a smooth and rapid flow of large volumes of goods and customers through a system.
- The work is divided into a series of standardized tasks, permitting specialization of both labor and equipment.
- The large volumes handled by these systems make it pertinent to invest in equipment and job design.
- Layouts should be arranged to make the best use of technological processing abilities.
- In manufacturing environments, the lines are referred to as production lines or assembly lines, depending on the type of activity involved.
- In services, the word "line" may or may not be used, like a Healthcare/Hospital Services line, Carwash, or Cafeteria Line.
- Without standardization, many of the benefits of repetitive processing are lost.
- Product layouts achieve a high degree of labor and equipment utilization, which tends to offset their high equipment costs.
- Operations are so closely tied up that a mechanical failure or high absenteeism would increase the vulnerability of the systems.
- We can prevent breakdowns by religiously following preventive maintenance schedules, inspection, and replacement of worn parts.
Advantages of Product Layout
- High rate of output.
- Low unit cost.
- Labor specialization.
- Low material handling cost.
- High utilization of labor and equipment.
- Established routing and scheduling.
- Routing accounting and purchasing.
Disadvantages of Product Layout
- Creates dull, repetitive jobs.
- Poorly skilled workers may not maintain equipment or quality of output or service.
- Fairly inflexible to changes in volume.
- Highly susceptible to shutdowns.
- Needs preventive maintenance.
- Individual incentive plans are impractical.
A U-Shaped Production Line
Straight line designs are often not practical because of space constraints. A U-shaped Production Line is more compact and requires often half the length of a straight production line. U-shaped layouts are a must for teamwork where communication is necessary. They allow flexibility in work assignments as workers can handle adjacent stations as well as stations on opposite ends. Sometimes, a U-shaped production line interferes with the cross travel/movement of workers and mobile equipment. Highly automated processes that do not require teamwork or communication, or where noise or contamination factors exist, do not require U-shaped production lines.
๐ก Why this matters: The U-shape layout is a practical solution to space constraints and is specifically designed to facilitate teamwork and communication, offering flexibility that straight lines cannot.
Process Layout (Functional)
A Process Layout is used for intermittent processing, such as in a job shop or batch production. In this layout, departments are grouped by function (e.g., all drilling machines in one area, all painting in another). Products move from one department to another as needed for processing.
Advantages of Process Layouts
- Can handle a variety of processing requirements.
- Not particularly vulnerable to equipment failures.
- Equipment used is less costly.
- Possible to use individual incentive plans.
Disadvantages of Process Layouts
- In-process inventory costs can be high.
- Challenging routing and scheduling.
- Equipment utilization rates are low.
- Material handling is slow and inefficient.
- Complexities often reduce the span of supervision.
๐ก Why this matters: Process layouts offer flexibility but at the cost of higher inventory and more complex management, making them suitable for varied, low-volume production.
โญ Key Takeaways
The primary takeaway is that facilities layout is a critical design decision that directly impacts flow, cost, and efficiency. The four basic layout typesโProduct, Process, Fixed Position, and Hybridโeach serve different production strategies, with Product layouts suited for high-volume, standardized output and Process layouts for varied, low-volume production. A U-shaped Production Line is a key variation of the product layout that enhances teamwork and saves space. For exams, students must memorize the characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages of both Product and Process layouts, understand the specific benefits of U-shaped lines, and recognize that layout failure can lead to severe operational bottlenecks, as seen in airport examples.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary focus of facilities layout, and what real-world example illustrates the consequences of poor layout?
- List the four basic layout types and briefly describe the key difference between a Product layout and a Process layout.
- What are three advantages and three disadvantages of a Product layout?
- Why is a U-Shaped Production Line often preferred over a straight production line?
- Under what circumstances would a U-Shaped Production Line NOT be required?
๐ Lecture 20 โ Facilities Layouts (Contd.)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on facilities layouts, focusing on cellular production and group technology as alternatives to functional layouts. It also covers service layouts (warehouse, retail, office), the importance and need for layout decisions, and introduces the concept of line balancing for designing product layouts. The lecture emphasizes how layout decisions impact cost, efficiency, and competitive advantage.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers cellular layouts and group technology, comparing them to functional layouts using a detailed table. It then discusses service layouts (warehouse, retail, office), the importance of layout decisions, and common reasons that necessitate layout redesign. Finally, it introduces line balancing for product layouts, explaining cycle time, maximum output, minimum workstations, precedence diagrams, and line balancing rules.
๐ Lecture Summary
Cellular Layouts
Cellular production is a layout where machines are grouped into a cell that can process items with similar processing requirements. Group technology is the grouping into part families of items with similar design or manufacturing characteristics. Cellular production always represents the layout of machines, while group technology reflects the collection of items needing the same manufacturing requirements. Both concepts greatly influence process and operations improvements. Organizations that opt for cellular manufacturing follow a lean production strategy, which focuses on high-quality processes, elimination of waste, and effective use of available resources.
๐ Definition โ Cellular Production: Layout in which machines are grouped into a cell that can process items that have similar processing requirements. ๐ Definition โ Group Technology: The grouping into part families of items with similar design or manufacturing characteristics.
Primary Differences between Functional and Cellular Layouts
| Dimension | Functional | Cellular |
|---|---|---|
| Number of moves between departments | many | few |
| Travel distances | longer | shorter |
| Travel paths | variable | fixed |
| Job waiting times | greater | shorter |
| Throughput time | higher | lower |
| Amount of work in process | higher | lower |
| Supervision difficulty | higher | lower |
| Scheduling complexity | higher | lower |
| Equipment utilization | lower | higher |
๐ก Why this matters: Functional layouts are conventional but require more space, rigid plans, specialized workforce, and continuous supervision. Cellular layouts offer significant advantages by reducing movement, waiting times, and work-in-process while improving throughput and equipment utilization.
Service Layouts Important service layouts include warehouse and storage layouts, retail layouts, and office layouts. Retail configurations are human-friendly, allowing movement of goods through small trolleys for customers, with light loads and easy transportation. Retail layouts are properly illuminated, ventilated, and maintained at human comfort temperature, with vinyled floors designed for less stressful customer movement. In contrast, warehouse and storage layouts require heavy loads and transportation using heavy vehicles and loaders, with different illumination and security arrangements (CCTV cameras to electric barbed wires).
Importance of Layout Decisions
Operations managers must know the importance of layout decisions in terms of money:
- Layout decisions require substantial investments of money and effort.
- Layout decisions involve long-term commitments.
- Layout decisions have significant impact on cost and efficiency of short-term operations.
The Need for Layout Decisions
The need for layout planning arises both in designing new facilities and redesigning existing facilities. Common reasons include:
- Inefficient Operations (High Cost/Bottlenecks)
- Accidents or Safety Hazards
- Changes in design of products or services
- Introduction of new products or services
- Changes in volume of output or mix of outputs
- Changes in Methods or equipment
- Changes in Environmental and Legal requirements
- Morale Problems (e.g., lack of face-to-face contact between supervisor and worker or senior and junior management)
Design Product Layouts: Line Balancing
Line Balancing is the process of assigning tasks to workstations in such a way that the workstations have approximately equal time requirements. The objective is to obtain equal time requirements at the majority of workstations, which shortens manufacturing time and reduces idle time. Industry uses cycle time to represent the time in which organizational resources are engaged to complete a process, and idle time to represent the time resources are left unused.
๐ Definition โ Line Balancing: The process of assigning tasks to workstations so that workstations have approximately equal time requirements.
Cycle Time Cycle time is the maximum time allowed at each workstation to complete its set of tasks on a unit. If CT represents cycle time and D represents desired output: ๐ Formula: Cycle Time = CT = OT / D (Where OT = Operating Time, D = Desired Output)
Maximum Output If OC is Output capacity, OT is Operating Time, and CT is Cycle time: ๐ Formula: Output Capacity = OC = OT / CT ๐ Example: If an automobile manufacturer works for 8 hours and requires 4 hours to complete its cycle, then the output capacity would be 8/4 = 2 automobiles.
Minimum Number of Workstations Required If D is desired output, t is time required for a specific task, and OT is Operating Time: ๐ Formula: N = (D ร ฮฃt) / OT (Where ฮฃt = sum of task times)
Precedence Diagram ๐ Definition โ Precedence diagram: Tool used in line balancing to display elemental tasks and sequence requirements.
![A Simple Precedence Diagram showing tasks a(0.1min), b(0.7min) โ c(1.0min) โ d(0.5min) โ e(0.2min)]
Line Balancing Rules โข Assign tasks in order of most following tasks โ Count the number of tasks that follow. โข Assign tasks in order of greatest positional weight โ Positional weight is the sum of each task's time and the times of all following tasks.
Designing Process Layouts require certain information:
- List of departments
- Projection of work flows
- Distance between locations
- Amount of money to be invested
- List of special considerations
- Location of key utilities
โญ Key Takeaways
Facilities layout decisions are critical because they require substantial investment, involve long-term commitments, and significantly impact operational costs and efficiency. Cellular production and group technology offer substantial advantages over functional layouts by reducing travel distances, throughput time, work-in-process, and scheduling complexity while increasing equipment utilization. Line balancing is essential for product layouts to assign tasks to workstations with approximately equal time requirements, using cycle time, maximum output calculations, and precedence diagrams as key tools. The need for layout decisions arises from multiple factors including inefficiencies, safety hazards, product/service changes, and morale problems. Service layouts (retail, warehouse, office) require different design considerations based on human movement, load requirements, and security needs.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between cellular production and group technology?
- List five dimensions where cellular layouts outperform functional layouts according to the comparison table.
- What formula is used to calculate cycle time, and what does each variable represent?
- What are the two line balancing rules for assigning tasks to workstations?
- What information is required when designing process layouts?
๐ Lecture 21 โ DESIGN OF WORK SYSTEMS
๐ Overview: This lecture covers the systematic design of work systems, which bridges Production and Operations Management with Human Resource Management. It explains two fundamental approaches to job designโefficiency through specialization and behavioral approachesโalong with methods analysis, motion study, work measurement, and compensation. Understanding these concepts is essential for creating productive, efficient, and worker-satisfying work environments.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers work system design including job design, specialization versus behavioral approaches to job design, teams, methods analysis and its procedure, motion study techniques including therbligs, working conditions, work measurement including stopwatch time study with formulas and examples, development of time standards (observed time, normal time, standard time), predetermined time standards (MTM), and compensation systems including time-based and output-based incentive plans.
๐ Lecture Summary
Design of Work Systems Introduction
Work System Design consists of job design, work measurement and establishment of time standards and worker compensation. Decisions in other areas of design (like product/service design or layout) can affect work design systems, and vice versa. It is thus logical to ensure a SYSTEMS approach is followed so a decision in one part is equally replicated and acceptable to all parts of the system.
Job Design
Job design involves specifying the content and methods of jobs, with the goal of creating a work system that is both productive and efficient. Job designers are concerned with: what will be done, who will do the job, how the job will be done, where the job will be done, and ergonomics. A successful job design must be carried out by experienced personnel, consistent with organizational goals, documented, understood and agreed by both management and employees, and shared with new employees.
Factors that affect job design include: lack of knowledge of employees, lack of management support, lack of documented job design, and two approachesโthe Efficiency School (based on Frederick W. Taylor's Scientific Management principles, popular in 1950s) and the Behavior School (a newer concept focused on eliminating worker dissatisfaction and incorporating feelings of control).
Specialization
Specialization refers to work that concentrates on some aspect of a product or service, with jobs having a narrow scope (e.g., assembly lines, medical specialties, MBA courses). Specialization jobs tend to yield high productivity, low unit costs, and lead to high standards of living in industrial nations.
Behavioral Approaches to Job Design
To make jobs more interesting and meaningful, job designers consider:
- Job Enlargement: giving a worker a larger portion of the total task by horizontal loading
- Job Rotation: workers periodically exchange jobs
- Job Enrichment: increasing responsibility for planning and coordination tasks by vertical loading
Motivation
These behavioral approaches have the potential to increase the motivational power of jobs by increasing worker satisfaction through improved quality of work life. Motivation always influences quality and productivity, while Trust influences productivity and employee-management relations.
Teams
Organizations adopt teams to exploit benefits including higher quality, higher productivity, and greater worker satisfaction. Self-directed teams are groups empowered to make certain changes in their work process.
Methods Analysis
Methods analysis deals with analyzing how a job gets done, beginning with overall analysis and moving to specific details like changes in tools/equipment, product design, materials/procedures, or other factors (accidents, quality problems).
The Methods Analysis Procedure:
- Identifies the operation to be studied
- Gets employee input
- Studies and documents the current method
- Analyzes the job
- Proposes new methods
- Installs new methods
- Follows up to ensure improvements have been achieved
Operations to study are selected based on: high labor content, frequent repetition, unsafe/tiring/unpleasant conditions, quality problems, or scheduling bottlenecks.
Flow process chart: A chart used to examine the overall sequence of an operation by focusing on movements of the operator or flow of materials. Worker-machine chart: A chart used to determine portions of a work cycle during which an operator and equipment are busy or idle.
Experienced job design analysts develop checklists asking questions about delays, travel distances, material handling, workplace rearrangement, grouping similar activities, improved equipment, and worker suggestions.
Installing the Improved Method
Successful implementation requires convincing management of the new method's desirability and obtaining worker cooperation. If the worker was consulted, installation is easier; if there is a paradigm change (major change), implementation may take longer. Follow-up is required to ensure changes have been incorporated.
Motion Study and Motion Study Techniques
Motion study is the systematic study of human motions used to perform an operation, with the purpose of eliminating unnecessary motions and identifying the best sequence for maximum efficiency. It is based on Frank Gilbreth's bricklaying trade in the early 20th century.
Motion study techniques incorporate four types:
- Motion study principles - guidelines for designing motion-efficient work procedures
- Analysis of therbligs - basic elemental motions into which a job can be broken down
- Micro motion study - use of motion pictures and slow motion to study motions too rapid to analyze
- Charts
Motion study principles are divided into three categories: principles for the use of body, arrangement of workplace, and design of tools and equipment.
Developing Work Methods
Operations managers aim for motion efficiency through: elimination of unnecessary motions, combination of various activities, reduction in fatigue, improvement in workplace arrangement, and improvement in tool/equipment design.
Therblig Techniques: Basic elemental motions include Search (hunting for an item), Select (choosing from a group), Grasp (taking hold of an object), Hold (retention of grasped object), Transport load (movement after hold), Release load (depositing the object), and other common therbligs like Inspect, Position, Plan, Rest, and Delay.
Work Measurement
Work measurement determines how long it should take to do a job. Standard time is the amount of time it should take a qualified worker to complete a specified task, working at a sustainable rate, using given methods, tools, equipment, raw materials, and workplace arrangements.
Common work measurement techniques:
- Stopwatch time study
- Historical times
- Predetermined data
- Work sampling
Stopwatch Time Study
Stopwatch time study develops a time standard based on observations of one worker taken over a number of cycles, then applied to others performing the same work.
Basic steps:
- Define the task to be studied and inform workers
- Determine the number of cycles to observe
- Time the job and rate the worker's performance
- Compute the standard time
The number of cycles to time is a function of: variability of observed times, desired accuracy, and desired level of confidence interval.
๐ Definition โ Desired accuracy: expressed as a percentage of the mean of the observed time.
๐ Formula: N = (zs / a xฬ)ยฒ Where:
- Z = number of normal standard deviations needed for desired confidence
- S = sample standard deviation
- a = desired accuracy percentage
- xฬ = sample mean
๐ Example: A mechanical engineer presents: assembly workers take mean time of 120 minutes to assemble a single car with standard deviation of 5 minutes. Confidence limit is 95%. The operations manager needs how many observations if desired maximum error is ยฑ5%?
Solution: Given: S = 5 minutes, Z = 1.96 (since 95% CI), xฬ = 120 minutes, a = 5%
N = [(1.96)(5) / (0.05)(120)]ยฒ N = [9.8 / 6]ยฒ N = (1.6333)ยฒ N = 2.67 studies = 3 studies
Development of a Time Standard
Development involves Observed Time (OT), Normal Time (NT), and Standard Time (ST).
- Observed Time (OT) = ฮฃ X / n (just the average of recorded times)
- Normal Time (NT) = OT ร PR (observed time adjusted for worker performance; the length of time a worker should take to perform a job)
- Standard Time (ST) = NT ร AF (normal time plus allowance for delays like getting water, restroom breaks)
Predetermined Time Standards
Predetermined Time Standards are published data based on extensive research to determine standard elemental times. A common system is Methods Time Measurement (MTM). Analysts must be trained and certified before using MTM.
MTM Advantages:
- Based on large numbers of workers under controlled conditions
- Analyst not required to rate performance
- No disruption of operation
- Standards can be established before a job is done
Compensation
Operations managers encounter two types of compensation:
- Time-based system: compensation based on time an employee has worked during a pay period
- Output-based (incentive) system: compensation based on the amount of output an employee produces during a pay period
Characteristics and Form of Incentive Plan
An effective incentive plan must be: accurate, easy to apply, consistent, easy to understand, fair, and provide compensation.
Types of Individual Incentive Plans
Pakistani organizations employ various types:
- Group Incentive Plans
- Knowledge-Based Pay System
- Management Compensation
Operations managers should identify advantages and disadvantages of each type.
โญ Key Takeaways
The importance of work design links Operations Management with Human Resource Managementโoperations managers must understand both the efficiency approach (specialization, methods analysis, motion study) and behavioral approaches (job enlargement, rotation, enrichment, teams) to job design. Work measurement techniques, particularly stopwatch time study with the formula N = (zs/a xฬ)ยฒ, provide the basis for establishing standard times, which are essential for personnel planning, cost estimation, budgeting, scheduling, and worker compensation. The three tiers of time standardsโObserved Time, Normal Time (adjusted by performance rating), and Standard Time (adjusted by allowance factor)โform a sequential process that operations managers must master. Compensation systems can be time-based or output-based (incentive), and each has distinct characteristics that affect worker motivation and organizational productivity.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic concerns of job designers when specifying job content and methods?
- Explain the difference between job enlargement, job rotation, and job enrichment, and identify which uses horizontal versus vertical loading.
- An analyst observes a mean time of 80 minutes with a standard deviation of 4 minutes at 95% confidence. How many observations are needed for ยฑ5% accuracy? (Z = 1.96)
- What is the formula for Standard Time, and what does the allowance factor (AF) account for?
- Compare and contrast time-based compensation systems with output-based (incentive) systems, listing one advantage of each.
๐ Lecture 22 โ Location Planning and Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the strategic importance of location decisions for organizations. It covers criteria for selecting locations for both manufacturing and service facilities, examines the impact of globalization on operations, and introduces key analytical tools like Cost-Volume Analysis and the Transportation Model for evaluating location alternatives.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the importance of location planning across organizational departments, the impact of globalization and its disadvantages, the need for location decisions, the nature of strategic location choices, steps for making location decisions, regional and site-specific factors, dominant factors for service locations, cost-profit-volume analysis with a solved example, and the transportation model as a quantitative evaluation method.
๐ Lecture Summary
Importance of Location
Location decisions are not limited to one-time strategic planning for new facilities but are often needed for capacity expansion through new or extended locations. Its importance spans various departments: Accounting prepares cost estimates, Distribution seeks efficient warehouse layouts, Engineering considers product/service impact, Finance performs investment analysis, Human Resources hires and trains for new locations, Management Information Systems links operations across locations, Marketing assesses customer appeal, and Operations Management finalizes locations that create and sustain the best organizational performance.
๐ก Why this matters: Location planning is an integral part of any organizationโs strategic planning process and directly impacts costs, revenues, and customer service. Examples include new airports in Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad catering to increased traffic.
Globalization and Geographic Dispersion of Operations
Globalization has led many Multi-National Corporations (MNCs) to disperse their operations. The lecture highlights the philosophy behind MNCs choosing not to operate in certain regions due to the disadvantages of globalization, which include:
- Handing over proprietary technology to host countries.
- Political risks.
- Poor employee (manager and worker) skills.
- Slow customer response time.
- Difficulty in effective communication between interfaces.
Managing Global Operations
When organizations become global, they face complex managerial challenges, including:
- Host country languages.
- Host country norms and customs.
- Workforce management.
- Unfamiliar laws and regulations.
- Unexpected cost mix.
Need for Location Decisions
The need for location decisions typically focuses on:
- Marketing Strategy
- Cost of Doing Business
- Growth
- Depletion of Resources
Nature of Location Decisions
Location decisions are primarily strategic in nature with clear objectives and options.
- Strategic Importance: They involve long-term commitment/costs, impact investments, revenues, and operations, and affect supply chains.
- Objectives: They aim for profit potential, though no single location may be superior; the goal is to identify several strong alternatives.
- Options: Organizations can expand existing facilities, add new facilities, or move.
Making Location Decisions
- Decide on the criteria.
- Identify the important factors.
- Develop location alternatives.
- Evaluate the alternatives.
- Make selection.
Location Decision Factors
Regional Factors:
- Location of raw materials
- Location of markets
- Labor factors
- Climate and taxes
Community Considerations:
- Quality of life
- Services
- Attitudes
- Taxes
- Environmental regulations
- Utilities
- Developer support
Site Related Factors:
- Land
- Transportation
- Environmental
- Legal
Multiple Plant Strategies
- Product plant strategy
- Market area plant strategy
- Process plant strategy (usually a mix of all three)
Factors Affecting Location Decisions
For Manufacturing:
- Favorable labor climate
- Proximity to markets
- Quality of life
- Proximity of suppliers and resources
- Proximity to parent companyโs facilities
- Utilities, taxes, and real estate costs
- Other factors (expansion, construction costs, location near highways/railways)
Dominant Factors in Services
For service locations, the dominant factors include:
- Proximity to customers
- Transportation costs and proximity to markets
- Location of competitors
- Site specific factors
Trends in Locations
- Foreign producers locating in different host countries
- Currency fluctuations
- Just-in-time manufacturing techniques
- Micro-factories
- Information Technology
Evaluating Locations: Cost-Profit-Volume Analysis
This method determines the best location by calculating total costs.
- Steps:
- Determine fixed and variable costs.
- Plot total costs.
- Determine the lowest total cost location.
- Assumptions:
- Fixed costs are constant.
- Variable costs are linear.
- Output can be closely estimated.
- Only one product is involved.
๐ Example 1: Cost-Volume Analysis Given a quantity of 10,000 units and the following costs for four locations:
| Location | Fixed Cost | Variable Cost per Unit |
|---|---|---|
| A | Rs 250,000 | Rs 11 |
| B | Rs 100,000 | Rs 30 |
| C | Rs 150,000 | Rs 20 |
| D | Rs 200,000 | Rs 35 |
Solution:
- Calculate total costs:
- Location A: Rs 250,000 + Rs 11(10,000) = Rs 360,000
- Location B: Rs 100,000 + Rs 30(10,000) = Rs 400,000
- Location C: Rs 150,000 + Rs 20(10,000) = Rs 350,000
- Location D: Rs 200,000 + Rs 35(10,000) = Rs 550,000
- Conclusion: For 10,000 units, Location C has the lowest total cost (Rs 350,000) and is selected.
Evaluating Locations: Transportation Method
The Transportation Method is a quantitative, linear programming-based approach to solve multiple facility location problems. It determines the allocation pattern that minimizes the cost of shipping products from multiple plants/sources to multiple warehouses/destinations.
๐ Definition โ Transportation Method: A method that finds the optimal shipping pattern between plants and warehouses for a given set of plant locations and capacities. It does not solve all location problems but helps evaluate different location-capacity combinations.
- Process Steps:
- Set up the initial matrix/tableau with a row for each plant and a column for each warehouse.
- Add a column for plant capacities and a row for warehouse demands.
- Insert unit shipping costs in the upper right corner of each shipping route cell.
- Requirement: The sum of shipments in a row must equal plant capacity, and the sum in a column must equal warehouse demand.
๐ Example: Pakistan Cellular Mobile Company A company plans to build a 5000-unit plant in Islamabad. The tableau shows unit costs for shipping from Lahore (existing) and Islamabad (new) to three warehouses.
Initial Tableau:
| Plant | Warehouse 1 | Warehouse 2 | Warehouse 3 | Capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lahore | 500.0 | 600.0 | 5500 | 5000 |
| Islamabad | 700.0 | 4500 | 6000 | 5000 |
| Requirements | 2500 | 4500 | 3000 | 10000 |
Dealing with Imbalance (Dummy Plants or Warehouses):
- If capacity exceeds demand, add a dummy warehouse with a demand equal to the surplus and shipping cost of Rs. 0 (represents unused capacity).
- If demand exceeds capacity, add a dummy plant with a supply equal to the deficit and a shipping cost of Rs. 0 (can represent stock-out costs).
Optimal Solution Tableau (with Dummy):
| Plant | W1 | W2 | W3 | Dummy | Capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lahore | 1.0 | 6.0 | 1.0 | 0 | 5000 |
| 2500 | 2500 | ||||
| Islamabad | 7.0 | 2.0 | 6.0 | 0 | 5000 |
| 4500 | 500 | ||||
| Dummy | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Requirements | 2500 | 4500 | 3000 | 0 | 10000 |
Total Transportation Cost Calculation: The optimal allocation costs: = 2500(1.0) + 4500(2.0) + 2500(1.0) + 500(6.0) = 2500 + 9000 + 2500 + 3000 = Rs 17,000
โญ Key Takeaways
Location planning is a strategic, long-term decision that impacts an organization's costs, revenues, and competitiveness. For manufacturing, key factors include labor climate, proximity to markets and suppliers, and utilities; for services, the dominant factor is proximity to customers. The Cost-Volume Analysis is a quantitative tool that compares total costs (fixed + variable) to identify the most economical location for a given output level, with the assumption that costs are linear. The Transportation Model uses linear programming to minimize total shipping costs between plants and warehouses, and it requires the sum of capacities to equal the sum of demands, a condition satisfied by introducing dummy plants or warehouses. Finally, understanding the disadvantages of globalization and the challenges of managing global operations is critical when making international location decisions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main options an organization has when making a location decision?
- List four dominant factors in selecting a location for a service business.
- What are the two primary assumptions of the Cost-Volume Analysis for location evaluation?
- In the Transportation Model, what does a "dummy warehouse" represent, and what is its shipping cost?
- According to the lecture, what is the first step in making a location decision?