📝 Lecture Summary
Contract of Guarantee
A contract of guarantee is defined under Section 126 of the Contract Act as "a contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default". The person who gives the guarantee is called the surety; the person in respect of whose default the guarantee is given is called the principal debtor; and the person to whom the guarantee is given is called the creditor. A guarantee may be either oral or written.
🔑 Definition — Contract of Guarantee: A contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default.
Objects of a Contract of Guarantee
There are three main objects for which a guarantee is required:
- To avail loan — e.g., Mr. Aslam availed a loan of Rs. 1 million from XYZ Bank, and the bank asked him to furnish a guarantee from a credit-worthy party (Mr. Akram). In case of default by Mr. Aslam, Mr. Akram shall be liable to pay the amount in default.
- To make credit purchases — e.g., AQ Brothers make credit supplies to Hilton Enterprises, which furnished guarantee of Mr. Suhail. Mr. Suhail shall be liable to make payments in case of default.
- To get employment — e.g., M/S XYZ Bank hired Mr. Salman as cashier and asked him to furnish a guarantee of Rs. 100,000 to the employer.
Parties in a Contract of Guarantee
- Surety/Guarantor: The person who gives the guarantee
- Creditor: The person in whose favor the guarantee is given
- Principal Debtor: The person who primarily incurs liability/debt
Nature of Contracts in a Contract of Guarantee
- Primary Contract: There is a primary contract between the Principal Debtor and the Creditor.
- Secondary Contracts:
- The contract between surety and creditor
- The contract between surety and principal debtor
Essentials of a Contract of Guarantee
- Consideration — must be present
- No misrepresentation — there must be no misrepresentation
- Writing not necessary — guarantee may be oral or written
📌 Example: M/S XYZ Bank hired Mr. Salman as cashier and asked him to furnish a guarantee of a third party amounting to Rs. 100,000 so as to recover any loss suffered by the employer due to the employee's act. Mr. Salman furnished the guarantee of Mr. Asad — this is a contract of guarantee.
Comments on Legal Principles
- There can be no contract of guarantee unless there is a principal debtor; the surety's obligation must be substantially dependent on a third person's default.
- A promise to be primarily and independently liable is not a guarantee, though it may be an indemnity.
- The surety undertakes his obligation at the request, express or implied, of the principal debtor.
- The mere transfer by a debtor of his property to a trustee for the benefit of creditors (the trustee not undertaking personal liability) does not constitute the relation of principal and surety.
- A person may become a surety without the knowledge and consent of the principal debtor.
- "Liability" means a liability enforceable at law — a surety is not liable on a guarantee for payment of a debt barred by the law of limitation.
- Time for repayment of loan extended within stipulation — surety could not take plea that time was extended without his knowledge and consent.
- Deed of guarantee executed jointly — a person signing as guarantor would be deemed to be guarantor for all intents and purposes; plea of signing in official capacity has no effect if the guarantor did not testify accordingly.
- Liabilities of sureties and principal debtor are distinct — liability of surety arises immediately on failure of principal debtor; creditor cannot be compelled to first exhaust remedy against principal debtor before suing surety.
- No principal debtor in existence — loans granted to fictitious persons — guarantor cannot be sued for recovery of debt. If there never was a principal debtor, there cannot be a guarantee.
Kinds of Guarantee
Specific Guarantee (Ordinary Guarantee)
This guarantee is restricted to a specific transaction or engagement, for example, availing a loan from a bank.
Continuing Guarantee
Such guarantee covers a series of transactions. For example, a guarantee furnished to a supplier for making supplies to a particular person/business during a specified period, say one year.
🔑 Definition — Continuing Guarantee: A guarantee that covers a series of transactions.
📌 Illustration (a): A promises B (in consideration that B will employ C in collecting rents) to be responsible up to Rs. 5,000 for the due collection and payment by C of those rents. This is a continuing guarantee.
📌 Illustration (b): A guarantees payment to B (tea-dealer) to the amount of Rs. 100 for any tea supplied to C. B supplies tea above Rs. 100; C pays. Afterwards B supplies tea of Rs. 200; C fails to pay. A is liable to B to the extent of Rs. 100 because it was a continuing guarantee.
📌 Illustration (c): A guarantees payment to B for five sacks of flour delivered to C, to be paid in a month. B delivers five sacks; C pays. Afterwards B delivers four sacks; C does not pay. A is not liable because this was NOT a continuing guarantee.
💡 Why this matters: Whether a guarantee is continuing or specific determines the scope and duration of the surety's liability.
Comments on Continuing Guarantee
- Whether a guarantee is continuing is a question of intention of the parties as expressed by the language employed, looking at the relative position of the parties and surrounding circumstances.
- In construing language, the whole of the expressions must be looked to, not merely the operative words.
- A guarantee of the fidelity of a person appointed to a place of trust in a bank is not a continuing guarantee.
- A guarantee for payment by installments of a sum certain within a definite time is not a continuing guarantee.
- A guarantee relating to one transaction is not a continuing guarantee.
Revocation of Continuing Guarantee (Sec. 130)
A continuing guarantee may at any time be revoked by the surety, as to future transactions, by notice to the creditor.
📌 Illustration (a): A guarantees to B, for twelve months, the due payment of bills for C to the extent of Rs. 5,000. B discounts bills for C to Rs. 2,000. At the end of three months, A revokes the guarantee. This revocation discharges A for the Rs. 2,000 on default of C.
📌 Illustration (b): A guarantees to B (to the extent of Rs. 10,000) that C shall pay all bills B draws upon him. B draws upon C; C accepts. A gives notice of revocation. C dishonours the bill at maturity. A is liable upon his guarantee.
Comments on Revocation
- Future transactions — "future transactions" implies cases where a series of distinct and separate transactions is contemplated; it is otherwise for an entire consideration.
- Where a continuing relationship is constituted on the faith of a guarantee, the guarantee cannot be annulled during the continuance of that relationship.
- The surety's death does not relieve his estate from liability if the nature of the transaction implies a contract to the contrary under S. 131.
- Notice — mere denial of liability by the surety in a previous suit does not operate as notice under this section.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A contract of guarantee involves three parties — surety, principal debtor, and creditor — where the surety promises to fulfill the principal debtor's obligation in case of default. Guarantees can be specific (for one transaction) or continuing (covering a series of transactions), and continuing guarantees can be revoked for future transactions by notice. The liability of the surety arises immediately upon the principal debtor's default, and the creditor is not required to first sue the principal debtor. No guarantee exists if there is no actual principal debtor, and a surety is not liable for time-barred debts. The intention of the parties determines whether a guarantee is continuing, and revocation of a continuing guarantee only affects future transactions.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Define a contract of guarantee under Section 126 of the Contract Act. Who are the three parties involved?
- What is the difference between a specific guarantee and a continuing guarantee? Provide one example of each.
- Under Section 130, how can a continuing guarantee be revoked? Does the revocation affect past transactions?
- Is it necessary for a contract of guarantee to be in writing? What are the essential requirements for a valid guarantee?
- Can a surety be held liable if there is no actual principal debtor (e.g., loans granted to fictitious persons)? Explain with reference to the comments in the lecture.
📘 Lecture 20 — CONTRACTS OF BAILMENT, PLEDGE & AGENCY
📖 Overview: This lecture covers three foundational business law concepts: bailment, pledge, and agency. It explains the legal definitions, essential elements, duties, and liabilities under each contract type, using real-world examples and case law to clarify how these relationships operate in commerce and banking. Understanding these contracts is critical for managing risk and ensuring legal compliance in business transactions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture defines bailment under Section 148, including its essential elements (contract, specific purpose, delivery of goods, no change of ownership, return of goods) and explains the rights and duties of the bailee under Sections 151-163, with case law on care, mixture, and liability. It then defines pledge under Section 172 as a special form of bailment for debt security, covering the pawnor’s and pawnee’s rights. Finally, it introduces the contract of agency under Section 182, including the definition of principal and agent, and the four methods of creating agency: by consent, operation of law, estoppel, and ratification.
📝 Lecture Summary
Bailment
Bailment is defined in Section 148: “A ‘bailment’ is the delivery of goods by one person to another for some purpose, upon a contract that they shall, when the purpose is accomplished, be returned or otherwise disposed of according to the directions of the person delivering them.” The person delivering the goods is the bailor, and the person receiving them is the bailee. The Explanation clarifies that if a person already in possession of another’s goods contracts to hold them as a bailee, that relationship is created even without physical delivery.
🔑 Definition — Bailment: The delivery of goods by one person (bailor) to another (bailee) for a specific purpose, under a contract requiring the goods to be returned or disposed of as directed upon completion of that purpose.
Essentials of Bailment:
- Contract: An explicit or implied contract exists between bailor and bailee.
- Specific purpose: The bailment is always for a particular reason.
- Delivery of goods: There must be delivery of movable goods.
- No change of ownership: Only possession is transferred; ownership remains with the bailor.
- Return of goods on accomplishment of purpose: Goods must be returned in original or modified form as per the bailor's instructions.
Examples of Bailment (by benefit):
- For the benefit of the bailor: Mr. Yasir hands over precious household articles to Mr. Usman for safe custody, without paying any fee.
- For the benefit of the bailee: Mr. Umer lends his car to Mr. Ahsan for a few days, without charging rent.
- For the benefit of bailor and bailee: Mr. Ahmad rents a locker from a bank, paying an annual fee of Rs. 1000.
💡 Why this matters: The nature of bailment involves a change of possession, not mere custody. A servant or guest using a host's goods is not a bailee. Constructive delivery can also create the relationship. The bailee must deal with goods according to the bailor's orders.
Rights and duties of bailee
Duty to take care of goods (Section 151): The bailee is bound to take as much care of the bailed goods as a man of ordinary prudence would, under similar circumstances, take of his own goods of the same bulk, quality, and value.
Duty not to make unauthorized use (Section 154): The bailee must not use the goods in any way not agreed upon.
Duty to return goods (Section 160): The bailee must return the goods upon the accomplishment of the purpose or at the demand of the bailor, without demand.
Duty to return increase/profit (Section 163): The bailee must return any increase or profit that has accrued from the goods.
Effect of mixture without bailor’s consent:
- When goods can be separated (Section 156): The bailee must bear the expense of separation and any resulting damage.
- When goods cannot be separated (Section 157): The bailor is entitled to be compensated for the loss of the goods.
Limitation of liability (Section 152): In the absence of a special contract, the bailee is not responsible for loss, destruction, or deterioration of the thing bailed if he has taken the care described in Section 151. However, a contract by a bailee exempting himself wholly from liability for negligence is generally considered invalid.
📐 Formula (Care Standard): Care of a man of ordinary prudence under similar circumstances → The bailee’s duty.
📌 Case Example (Theft of Goods Pledged with Bank): A document of pledge stated the borrower was responsible for loss by theft. The court held that the bailee (bank) must first explain that it took ordinary care. If it did, and the goods were still lost under the condition, the borrower's liability could not be denied.
📌 Case Example (Injury to Goods by Railway): Goods were damaged due to long delay in transit. The railway pleaded "unavoidable circumstances" but provided no evidence. The court held a presumption of want of due care would arise against the railway.
📌 Case Example (Damage to Contents of Parcel): Wooden crates were broken externally. The court held that merely because the containers were broken, it cannot be inferred that the contents were damaged. The burden of proof was on the consignor.
📌 Case Example (Buyer Rejecting Goods): A buyer rejected goods and then sold them to recover warehouse charges. The court held that a buyer who rejects goods and then sells them as his own is not a bailee under Sections 151 and 170. He has no lien and must place the goods at the seller's disposal.
Pledge
Pledge is defined in Section 172: “The bailment of goods as security for payment of a debt or performance of a promise is called ‘pledge’. The bailor is in this case called the ‘pawnor’. The bailee is called the ‘pawnee’.”
🔑 Definition — Pledge: A special type of bailment where goods are delivered as security for a debt or a promise.
Key Features of Pledge:
- The pawnee (pledgee) has actual control of the pledged goods.
- The pawnee can sell the pledged stocks by giving reasonable notice to the borrower (pawnor).
- Before disposal, the pawnee should publish notice (e.g., through newspapers).
- The pawnee does not become the owner but has a special property (possession and right to possess).
- Delivery may be actual or constructive. Any kind of goods, documents, or valuable things may be pledged.
📌 Case Example (Pledge vs. Hypothecation): Monthly statements of stocks in a godown, signed by the authorized person, showed goods pledged with a defendant bank. Debit advice vouchers showed conveyance charges paid to a godown keeper. The court held that the goods were in the defendant's possession under a pledge, not merely hypothecation.
Contract of Agency
Agency is the relationship where one person (the agent) is employed to do any act for another (the principal) or to represent the principal in dealings with third persons. This is defined in Section 182.
🔑 Definition — Agent/Principal (Section 182): An agent is a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealing with third persons. The person for whom such act is done is the principal.
Key Explanation on Agency:
- The legal relation between a merchant and a commission agent is that of principal and agent, not seller and buyer. A merchant cannot hold a commission agent liable as a vendor for failure to deliver goods.
- An agent may have discretion but is bound to follow the principal's lawful instructions.
- An agent can be a superior kind of servant, and a servant entrusted with dealings on the master's behalf is to that extent an agent.
Ways to Create Agency:
- By consent: Can be express or implied.
- Express Agency: Created by words (spoken or written), often through a written agreement.
- Implied Agency: Inferred from the conduct of the parties or circumstances of the case (Section 187). Things spoken or written, or the ordinary course of dealing, are considered circumstances.
- By operation of law: Agency is created by law (e.g., partnership).
- By estoppel: Agency is inferred when the principal’s conduct leads a third party to believe the agent has authority.
- By ratification: When a principal approves an unauthorized act done on his behalf, it creates agency from the date of the act.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical distinction is that in a bailment, only possession is transferred, not ownership, and the bailee must exercise the care of a man of ordinary prudence. A pledge is a specific bailment for security, giving the pawnee the right to sell the goods after reasonable notice. An agent represents a principal in dealings with third parties, and the agent must follow the principal's instructions. Agency can be created by express words, implied from conduct, by operation of law, by estoppel, or by ratification. Remember that a buyer who rejects goods does not have a bailee's lien, and the burden of proof for negligence can shift based on the facts.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five essential elements of a valid contract of bailment under Section 148?
- Under Section 151, what standard of care is a bailee required to take of the bailed goods?
- What is the legal effect if a bailee, without the bailor's consent, mixes the goods in a way that they cannot be separated (Section 157)?
- Define a "pledge" under Section 172. What is the primary difference between a pledge and a simple bailment?
- List the four ways in which a contract of agency can be created, as discussed in the lecture.
📘 Lecture 21 — CONTRACT OF AGENCY
📖 Overview: This lecture completes the discussion of how an agency relationship is created, focusing on the remaining methods beyond mutual consent. It explains agency by operation of law (emergency authority), agency by estoppel (where the principal's conduct creates apparent authority), and agency by ratification (where a principal adopts an unauthorized act). Understanding these concepts is essential for determining legal liability and rights in business transactions where agency relationships are not explicitly agreed upon.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main methods of agency creation: agency by operation of law under Section 189, focusing on an agent's authority in emergencies to protect the principal from loss; agency by estoppel, where the principal's conduct leads a third party to believe an agent has greater authority than actually given; and agency by ratification under Section 196, including its conditions, effects, and limitations, along with the resulting rights and obligations of the parties.
📝 Lecture Summary
Agency by Operation of Law:
Agent’s authority in an emergency (section 189) An agent has authority, in an emergency; to do all such acts for the purpose of protecting his principal from loss as would be done by a person of ordinary prudence, in his own case, under similar circumstances.
Illustration: Mr. Aslam, a fruit merchant, shipped fruits by truck from Lahore to DG Khan. The truck on its way to DG Khan met an accident. The truck driver could not establish contact with Mr. Aslam despite best efforts. There was danger that fruits would perish, as such the truck driver decided to sell the fruits at the market rate. The relationship of agency shall be governed under the provision of section 189.
Illustrations (a) An agent for sale may have goods repaired if it be necessary. (b) A consigns provisions to B at Karachi with directions to send them immediately to C at Quetta. B may sell the provisions at Karachi if they will not bear the journey to Quetta without spoiling.
Comments If goods are perishable and perishing, the agent may deviate from his instructions as to the time or price at which they are to be sold as has been explained through the above illustrations.
Agency by Estoppel
Agency by estoppel refers to a situation when the words or conduct of the principal creates an impression in the minds of third party that agent’s authority is greater than the authority actually vested in him. And the third party under this impression enters into an agreement with the agent.
Illustration: Due to the conduct of Mr. Aslam (principal), Mr. Salman (third party) believes that Mr. Kaleem is an agent of Mr. Aslam and under this impression Mr. Salman enters into an agreement with Mr. Kaleem.
The following situations may emerge from this scenario:
- Mr. Aslam terminated the agency relationship with Mr. Kaleem, however this was not in the knowledge of Mr. Salman and he continued his commercial dealings with Mr. Kaleem. Under the principle of estoppel, Mr. Aslam cannot claim that Mr. Kaleem is not his agent, as far as these transactions are concerned.
- Mr. Salman enters into an agreement with Mr. Kaleem. The transaction is in the knowledge of Mr. Aslam. Mr. Aslam does not intimate Mr. Salman that Mr. Kaleem is not his agent. Mr. Aslam under the principle of estoppel cannot claim that Mr. Kaleem is not his agent.
- Mr. Salman was entering into business dealings with Mr. Kaleem, treating Mr. Kaleem as an authorized agent of Mr. Aslam. Mr. Kaleem entered into some agreements which were beyond the authority vested in him by the Principal, Mr. Aslam. Mr. Salman is not aware of this fact. Mr. Aslam (Principal) under the principle of estoppel cannot claim that he cannot own the acts of his agent, Mr. Kaleem which are beyond his (agent) authority.
🔑 Definition — Agency by Estoppel: A situation where the principal's words or conduct leads a third party to reasonably believe the agent has authority, thereby preventing the principal from later denying that authority.
Agency by Ratification:
Concept of ratification is contained in Sec. 196 Sec. 196- Right of person as to acts done for him without his authority: where acts are done by one person on behalf of another, but without his knowledge or authority, he may elect to ratify or to disown such acts. If he ratifies them, the same effects will follow as if they had been performed by his authority.
Illustration: Mr. Fahad, an agent of Mr. Salman lends Rs 100,000 to Mr. Kaleem. Mr. Kaleem is paying monthly profits to Mr. Fahad, who has rendered accounts in this respect to the principal, Mr. Salman. By accepting the profits, Mr. Salman’s conduct implies a ratification of the amount of loan provided by his agent, although without his authority.
Conditions of ratification:
"On behalf of another" — Ratification must be by the person for whom the agent professes to act. Where A does an act as agent for B without any communication with C, C cannot, by afterwards adopting that act, make A his agent and thereby incur any liability, or take any benefit, under the act of A. Ratification is applicable only to acts done on behalf of the ratifier. Ratification can be express or implied from conduct.
A ratification of the unauthorised contract of an agent can only be effectual when the contract has been made by the agent avowedly for, or on account of, the principal, and not when it has been made on account of the agent himself.
A man cannot adopt by ratification an act which was not authorised by him at the time and did not purport to be done on behalf of any principal.
Since ratification is in law equivalent to a previous authority, a person not competent to authorise an act cannot give it validity by ratifying it.
Ratification must be by an existing person on whose behalf the contract might have been made at the time. Thus a newly-formed company cannot ratify an act done in its name before it was incorporated. And where a time is limited for doing an act, and A does it on behalf of B, but without his authority, within that time, B can ratify it only before the time has expired.
The person on whose behalf an act purports to be done need not be individually known to the agent; it is enough if he is ascertainable as owner of specified property or the like.
"Acts done without knowledge or authority" — An act done by an agent in excess of his authority may also be ratified. However, ratification of a particular act done in excess of authority does not confer general power to do similar acts in future.
Retrospective effect — Ratification, if effective at all, relates back to the date of the act ratified. The rule goes so far that if A makes an offer to B which Z accepts in B's name without authority, and B afterwards ratifies the acceptance, an attempted revocation of the offer by A in the time between Z's acceptance and B's ratification is inoperative.
💡 Why this matters: The retrospective effect of ratification means that a principal can adopt and validate an unauthorized act, and the third party gets exactly what they bargained for, even if the agent originally intended to keep the contract for themselves.
What acts cannot be ratified — A transaction which is void ab initio cannot be ratified. A forged signature cannot be ratified; but a person whose signature has been forged may be estopped from denying that a signature is his, if by his conduct he induced the holder to alter their position.
Ratification would be effective though it is made subsequently — Ratification validates act already performed. It relates back to time of inception of transaction and carries a complete retrospective efficacy.
Principal — Ratification of acts by — Principle of law enunciated in S. 196 applies equally to acts of attorney if ratified by principal.
Only the civil liability created by act of an agent acting for his principal is ratified and not a criminal liability. A guarantee being a forged document — no ratification therefore permissible this being a criminal liability.
Principle of ratification of contract — Scope of — Acts done by one person on behalf of another without such person's knowledge or authority — principal might ratify or disown acts done by agent on his behalf. Exception to such ratification was where right or interest of third person was involved.
Agent bidding at auction for his principal without duly executed power of attorney — Principal ratifying act of agent — auction is valid and effective. If the principal is named and accepts the action of his agent, even though the same was not covered by a duly executed power of attorney at the time of the auction, the matter would be fully covered by the doctrine of ratification, as embodied in section 196.
Servants, unauthorised acts of — May be ratified by Master. These sections are not limited to acts of agents but lay down general principles equally applicable to a servant who is generally his master's agent for some purpose.
Unauthorised act of agent when implied ratification by conduct is presumed — To constitute implied ratification by conduct of acts previously unauthorised, the conduct of the principal must be such as to lead to the necessary inference that there was an unqualified and binding adoption of those acts by him. Where the board categorically declined to approve of the alleged contract, there can be no implied ratification by conduct.
🔑 Definition — Ratification: The adoption by a principal of an act done by an agent without the principal's prior authority, which then has the same legal effect as if the act had been originally authorized.
Effect of Ratification: Sec. 199
Effect of ratifying unauthorized act forming part of a transaction: A person ratifying any unauthorized act done on his behalf ratifies the whole of the transaction of which such act formed a part.
It is obvious that a man cannot at his own choice ratify part of a transaction and repudiates the rest. The only possible exception is in the case of the part repudiated being wholly for the principal's benefit, which is not likely to occur. The general rule is that, where ratification is established as to a part, it operates as a confirmation of the whole of that particular transaction of the agent.
Rights and Obligations of different parties as a result of Ratification:
Parties to a contract of agency have the following rights and obligations:
- Principal may sue the third party and third party can also sue the principal.
- No liability shall be incurred by the agent to third party.
- Agent not liable for exceeding his authority.
- Principal is required under law to pay reasonable remuneration to the agent.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The four ways to create an agency are by consent, operation of law, estoppel, and ratification. Agency by operation of law under Section 189 allows an agent to take emergency actions to protect the principal from loss, deviating from instructions if necessary to save perishable goods. Agency by estoppel prevents a principal from denying an agent's authority when the principal's conduct led a third party to reasonably believe in that authority. Agency by ratification under Section 196 allows a principal to adopt an unauthorized act, with the effect that it is treated as if it had been originally authorized, and this ratification relates back to the date of the act. Crucially, ratification must be of the whole transaction, cannot apply to void or illegal acts like forgery, and creates rights and obligations between the principal and third party while protecting the agent from liability.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Under Section 189, what two conditions must exist for an agent to have authority in an emergency?
- In agency by estoppel, what must the principal do (or fail to do) to be prevented from denying the agent's authority?
- According to Section 196, what are the two choices a principal has when an act is done on their behalf without authority?
- What is the legal effect of ratification in terms of time — when does the ratified act take effect?
- Can a principal ratify only part of a transaction while disowning the rest? Explain with reference to Section 199.
📘 Lecture 22 — Contract of Agency
📖 Overview: This lecture completes the discussion of agency law by classifying agents and detailing their duties and rights. It is essential for understanding the legal obligations between an agent and principal, including standards of skill, accounting, and liability for misconduct.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture classifies agents into public, private, general, special, and co-agents. It then exhaustively covers the agent’s duties under sections 211-218 of the Contract Act, including duty to follow instructions, skill and diligence, accounting, communication, and prohibition against dealing on own account. It also covers the agent’s rights to remuneration, indemnity, and compensation, followed by the principal’s liability for agent’s misrepresentations and the scope of the principal’s duties.
📝 Lecture Summary
Contract of Agency
The lecture continues from previous lessons on agency, covering additional aspects of the contract of agency.
Types of Agent:
Agents are classified into five types: Public Agents (representatives of a State), Private Agents (represent individuals or companies), General Agents (pertain to a business, vocation, or profession), Special Agents (appointed for a specific transaction), and Co-Agents (act along with the Principal).
Duties of the Agent:
Duties of the agent are contained in sections 211 to 218 of the Contract Act. Important duties include: to follow principal’s instructions, to show required skill and diligence, to render proper accounts, and to pass on any benefits derived by the agent.
🔑 Definition — Agent’s duty in conducting principal’s business (sec. 211): An agent is bound to conduct the principal’s business according to the principal’s directions, or if no directions, according to the prevailing custom of similar business. If the agent acts otherwise, any loss must be made good to the principal, and any profit must be accounted for.
📌 Examples (sec. 211):
- An agent engaged in carrying on a business for B, where it is custom to invest idle money at interest, omits to make such investments. A must make good to B the interest usually obtained.
- A broker, whose business custom is not to sell on credit, sells goods of A on credit to C (who was solvent at the time). C becomes insolvent. B must make good the loss to A.
- An agent instructed to warehouse goods at a particular place warehouses a portion at another place where they are destroyed without negligence. He is liable for the value of the destroyed goods.
- An agent instructed to insure goods neglects to do so. He is liable for their value if they are lost.
- A broker entrusted with goods for sale sells them by auction at an inadequate price, not having estimated value per trade custom. He must make good the loss.
- An auctioneer, contrary to custom, takes a bill of exchange in payment. He is liable for the amount if the bill is dishonoured.
- An agent bound to keep proper books omits to scrutinize his subordinates’ accounts, who then commit fraud. The agent is liable for the loss.
💡 Why this matters: The explanation clarifies that an agent is not bound to obey unlawful instructions. If an auctioneer is instructed not to sell below a certain price but accepts the highest bona fide bid (even if lower), he is not liable. The measure of damages for selling below the limit is the actual loss sustained, not the difference between sale price and the limit. If an agent parts with goods without payment (against instructions), the measure of damages is the value of the goods.
🔑 Definition — Skill and diligence required from agent (sec. 212): An agent must conduct the agency business with as much skill as is generally possessed by persons engaged in similar business (unless the principal knows of the agent’s lack of skill). The agent must always act with reasonable diligence and use the skill he possesses. He must compensate the principal for direct consequences of his neglect, want of skill, or misconduct, but not for indirect or remote consequences.
📌 Examples (sec. 212):
- A has agent B in London who receives money on A’s account with orders to remit. B retains the money for a considerable time; A becomes insolvent. B is liable for the money, interest from the due date, and any further direct loss (e.g., by exchange rate variation), but not further.
- An agent for sale, having authority to sell on credit, sells to B on credit without making proper inquiries as to B’s solvency. B is insolvent. A must compensate his principal for the loss.
- An insurance broker omits to see that the usual clauses are inserted in a policy. The ship is lost; nothing can be recovered from underwriters. The broker must make good the loss to B.
- A directs B (his agent at Karachi) to send 100 bales of cotton by a certain ship. B omits to do so. The ship arrives safely in England; the price of cotton rises. B must make good the profit A could have made at the time of the ship’s arrival, but not any profit from a subsequent rise.
💡 Why this matters: A clearing agent who fails to conduct work with the required skill and reasonable diligence is liable for the principal’s loss.
🔑 Definition — Agent's accounts (sec. 213): An agent is bound to render proper accounts to his principal on demand.
💡 Why this matters: This duty is elementary and enforceable. It is not discharged by merely delivering written accounts without attending to explain them and produce vouchers. However, if the principal keeps the accounts for a length of time, they are considered stated and settled and will not be reopened unless fraud is proved. If an agent neglects to keep proper accounts, everything consistent with established facts will be presumed against him. Where an agent mixes his moneys with the principal’s moneys, the onus is on the agent to prove which moneys are his own. The legal representative of a deceased agent cannot be called upon to render accounts in the same sense; the principal’s remedy is to sue the representative for loss from the agent’s negligence or misconduct.
A suit for accounts lies only when: a) the person has received property not belonging to himself; b) the person seeking the liability is the owner or has some title to the property; c) the defendant received the property in his possession and control; and d) there is a fiduciary relationship between plaintiff and defendant.
🔑 Definition — Agent's duty to communicate with principal (sec. 214): In cases of difficulty, the agent must use all reasonable diligence in communicating with his principal and seeking to obtain his instructions.
📌 Example (sec. 215): An agent must consult the principal in a “difficult” situation to avoid repudiation of his action.
🔑 Definition — Right of principal when agent deals on his own account in business of agency without principal's consent (sec. 215): If an agent deals on his own account in the agency business without first obtaining the principal’s consent and disclosing all material circumstances, the principal may repudiate the transaction if any material fact was dishonestly concealed or if the agent’s dealings were disadvantageous to the principal.
📌 Examples (sec. 215):
- A directs B to sell A’s estate. B buys the estate for himself in the name of C. A, on discovering this, may repudiate the sale if he can show dishonest concealment or that the sale was disadvantageous.
- A directs B to sell A’s estate. B finds a mine on the estate (unknown to A). B informs A he wishes to buy the estate but conceals the mine’s discovery. A allows B to buy in ignorance. A may later repudiate or adopt the sale at his option.
💡 Why this matters: An agent must not act for the other party at the same time, take a secret commission, or settle a claim on exorbitant terms to increase his own profit. The principal who seeks to set aside such a transaction must do so within a reasonable time after becoming aware of the circumstances.
🔑 Definition — Principal's right to benefit gained by agent dealing on his own account in business of agency (sec. 216): If an agent, without the principal’s knowledge, deals in the agency business on his own account, the principal is entitled to claim any benefit that resulted to the agent from the transaction.
📌 Example (sec. 216): A directs B (his agent) to buy a certain house. B tells A it cannot be bought but buys the house for himself. A may compel B to sell the house to A at the price B gave for it.
💡 Why this matters: A person in a fiduciary position who makes a profit without full disclosure must account for that profit, even if the principal suffered no injury. The principal can recover secret profits (e.g., commission from the buyer’s agent) and also recover damages for any loss sustained. Recovery from the agent does not bar an action against the third person for further damages. An agent who wrongfully deals on his own account is not entitled to commission, even if the principal adopts the transaction. The principal’s ratification must be based on full disclosure of all material facts. An agreement between an agent and a third person that puts the agent’s interest in conflict with his duty is unenforceable unless the principal ratifies it.
🔑 Definition — Agent's right of retaining out of sums received (sec. 217): An agent may retain, out of sums received on the principal’s account, all moneys due to himself for advances made or expenses properly incurred, and also his remuneration.
🔑 Definition — Agent's duty to pay sums received for principal (sec. 218): Subject to such deductions, the agent must pay to his principal all sums received on his account.
Rights of the Agent:
🔑 Definition — When agent’s remuneration becomes due (sec. 219): In the absence of a special contract, payment for performance of an act is not due until completion of the act. However, an agent may detain moneys received for goods sold even if the whole consignment is not yet sold or the sale is not actually complete.
🔑 Definition — Agent to be indemnified against consequences of lawful acts (sec. 222): The employer of an agent must indemnify the agent against consequences of all lawful acts done by the agent in exercise of the conferred authority.
📌 Examples (sec. 222):
- B at Singapore, under instructions from A of Quetta, contracts with C to deliver goods. A does not send the goods, and C sues B. A authorizes B to defend the suit. B is compelled to pay damages, costs, and expenses. A is liable to B for these.
- B, a broker at Quetta, by A’s orders, contracts with C for the purchase of oil for A. A refuses to receive the oil, and C sues B. A repudiates the contract. B defends unsuccessfully and pays damages, costs, and expenses. A is liable to B.
🔑 Definition — Agent to be indemnified against consequences of acts done in good faith (sec. 223): Where one person employs another to do an act, and the agent does the act in good faith, the employer is liable to indemnify the agent against the consequences, even if it injures the rights of third persons.
🔑 Definition — Compensation to agent for injury caused by principal's neglect (sec. 225): The principal must compensate his agent for injury caused by the principal’s neglect or want of skill.
📌 Example (sec. 225): A employs B as a bricklayer in building a house and puts up the scaffolding himself. The scaffolding is unskillfully put up, and B is hurt. A must make compensation to B.
🔑 Definition — Enforcement and consequences of agent's contracts (sec. 226): Contracts entered into through an agent and obligations from acts done by an agent may be enforced in the same manner and have the same legal consequences as if the contracts were entered into and the acts done by the principal in person.
📌 Examples (sec. 226):
- A buys goods from B knowing B is an agent for their sale but not knowing the principal. B’s principal is entitled to claim the price from A, and A cannot set off a debt due from B to A.
- B is A’s agent with authority to receive money on his behalf. B receives from C a sum of money due to A. C is discharged of his obligation to pay that sum to A.
🔑 Definition — Principal’s liability for agreements caused by misrepresentation or fraud by agent (sec. 238): Misrepresentations or frauds committed by agents acting in the course of their business for their principals have the same effect on agreements as if made or committed by the principals. However, misrepresentations or frauds in matters not within the agent’s authority do not affect the principals.
📌 Examples (sec. 238):
- A, B’s agent for the sale of goods, induces C to buy them by a misrepresentation he was not authorized to make. The contract is voidable at C’s option.
- A, the captain of B’s ship, signs bills of lading without having received the goods on board. The bills of lading are void as between B and the pretended consignor.
Scope of duties of Principal:
The scope of the principal’s duties includes: payment of remuneration to the agent; not preventing the agent from performing the duties/acts assigned under the contract; and indemnifying the agent for any legitimate expenses incurred in the course of performance of his duties.
⭐ Key Takeaways
- An agent must follow the principal's instructions (or custom) and is liable for any loss from failure to do so; they must also account for all profits.
- The agent must exercise the skill generally possessed by persons in similar business and act with reasonable diligence, liable only for direct consequences of neglect or misconduct.
- An agent must render proper accounts, communicate with the principal in cases of difficulty, and must not deal on his own account in the agency business without full disclosure.
- If an agent secretly deals on his own account, the principal may repudiate the transaction or claim all benefits gained by the agent.
- The agent has rights to retain sums due for advances, expenses, and remuneration; to be indemnified for lawful acts done in good faith; and to compensation for injury from the principal's neglect.
- The principal is liable for the agent's misrepresentations and frauds committed within the scope of the agent's authority.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Under section 211, what is an agent’s duty in conducting the principal’s business, and what happens if the agent acts otherwise?
- What standard of skill and diligence is required from an agent under section 212, and what loss must the agent compensate for?
- When is a principal entitled to repudiate a transaction under section 215, and what is the principal’s right under section 216 if the agent deals on his own account?
- What are an agent’s rights regarding retention of sums (sec. 217) and indemnity for lawful acts (sec. 222)?
- Under section 238, what is the principal’s liability for an agent’s misrepresentation or fraud?