π Lecture 44 β National Industrial Relations Commission
π Overview: This lecture examines the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC) as the primary federal forum for adjudicating industrial disputes in Pakistan. It details the commission's composition, functions, powers, and procedures, including its role in registering industry-wide trade unions and determining collective bargaining units. Understanding the NIRC is crucial for grasping how labour disputes of national importance are resolved under the Industrial Relations Ordinance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the statutory provisions governing the National Industrial Relations Commission under Sections 49 to 56 of the Industrial Relations Ordinance. It details the commission's constitution by the Federal Government, its nine broad functions including adjudication and registration of industry-wide unions, bench composition and procedures, additional powers including contempt and inspection, appeal mechanisms to the Full Bench, finality of commission orders, determination of collective bargaining units, and regulation-making powers.
π Lecture Summary
Forums for Adjudication of disputes available under the ordinance:
The National Industrial Relations Commission is constituted under section 49 of the Ordinance. The Federal Government establishes this commission with up to eight members including a Chairman and members appointed by the Federal Government, with qualifications and service terms determined by the Federal Government.
The Commission has nine key functions: (a) to adjudicate industrial disputes involving industry-wise trade unions or federations, and disputes of national importance referred by the Federal Government; (b) to register industry-wise trade unions, federations of such trade unions, and national-level federations, and conduct ratings of their standing and representative character; (c) to determine collective bargaining agents among these unions and federations; (d) to try offences under section 65 (except subsections 1 and 5) and related provisions concerning industry-wise trade unions and national federations; (e) to deal with unfair labour practices under sections 63 and 64, whether committed individually or collectively, and take preventive measures as prescribed under section 55 regulations.
(f) to advise government and unions on worker education regarding trade unionism rights and obligations; (g) to promote healthy trade unionism across establishments within or across provinces; (h) to facilitate formation of national-level federations; and (i) to exercise other powers as assigned by the Federal Government via official Gazette notification.
The Commission may, on application or its own motion, initiate prosecution, trial or proceedings regarding its functions, and may withdraw from a Labour Court any application or appeal relating to unfair labour practice. For handling unfair labour practice cases, the Commission may proceed directly, ask the registrar to investigate and report, or refer the case to the Labour Court for report or disposal. The Labour Court must then enquire and either forward a report or dispose of the case as if originally commenced before it.
π Definition β Industry-wise trade unions: A trade union whose membership extends to establishments in more than one Province. π Definition β Federation at the national level: A federation of trade unions whose membership extends to registered trade unions in more than one Province.
No Registrar or Labour Court shall take any action regarding matters within the Commission's jurisdiction, except as provided in subsections (6) and (7). However, nothing excludes a Labour Court's jurisdiction to entertain unfair labour practice cases, provided that no court shall entertain a case already being dealt with by the Commission.
Benches of the Commission:
The Chairman exercises general superintendence over Commission affairs. For efficient functioning, the Chairman constitutes: (a) a Full Bench of not less than three members; and (b) as many other Benches consisting of one or more members as deemed fit.
Benches have dual functions: (a) regarding unfair labour practices, trial of offences, or enforcement of rights, they perform functions and exercise powers of a Labour Court; (b) regarding industry-wise trade unions, federations, and referred cases, they perform functions of a Registrar or Labour Court, and references to "Registrar" or "Labour Court" are deemed references to the appropriate Bench.
If a member is absent, proceedings may continue and decisions remain valid despite such absence. If Bench members differ in opinion: (a) majority opinion prevails if there is a majority; (b) if equally divided, the point is referred to the Chairman for hearing by one or more other members, and decided according to majority of those who heard the case. If the Chairman is a member and votes are equally divided, the Chairman's opinion prevails.
π‘ Why this matters: This ensures decisions can be made even with absent members and provides a clear mechanism for resolving deadlocks.
Any order, decision, award or proceedings by any Bench is deemed to be by the Commission itself. The expression "Chairman of the Commission" includes a Senior Member nominated by the Federal Government to perform the Chairman's functions during absence.
Additional powers of the Commission:
Under section 51, the Commission has two additional powers: (a) power to punish contempt β any person who obstructs or abuses its process, disobeys orders, prejudices a party's case, or brings the Commission into hatred or contempt may be fined up to forty thousand rupees; (b) power of entry and inspection β the Chairman or any member may, between sunrise and sunset and after reasonable notice, enter any building, factory, workshop or premises to inspect work, machinery, appliances, or interrogate any person regarding matters before the Commission.
Appeals to the Commission:
Under section 52, any person aggrieved by an award, decision, sentence or order (other than by a Full Bench) may appeal to the Commission within thirty days. The appeal is disposed of by the Full Bench, which has power to confirm, set aside, vary or modify such award, decision, sentence or order.
Finality of order:
Under section 53, no court shall entertain any plea regarding the Commission's jurisdiction or the legality of anything done by the Commission or its Benches. No order, decision, judgment or sentence may be called in question in any manner before any court or authority.
Determination of collective bargaining unit:
Under section 54, the Commission may, on application by a trade union or federation, or on reference by the Federal Government, determine one or more collective bargaining units where it is satisfied that this is necessary, just and feasible for safeguarding workers' interests. The Commission considers: distribution of workers, existing boundaries, communication facilities, general convenience, sameness of economic activity, and other cognate factors.
The Commission may: (a) determine and certify one or more collective bargaining units; (b) specify modifications regarding registration of affected trade unions, Shop Stewards, and workers' representatives; (c) specify dates from and periods for which changes take effect (but not within three years of a certified collective bargaining agent under section 20); (d) issue directions to the Registrar; and (e) determine and certify a collective bargaining agent for each unit if it relates to more than one Province, or direct the Registrar if it relates to only one Province.
After certification of a collective bargaining unit: no trade union shall be registered except for the whole unit; no proceedings for determining a collective bargaining agent shall take place for a part of a unit. The Commission's order under this section has effect notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Ordinance.
Power to make regulations:
Under section 55, the Commission may, with prior approval of the Federal Government, make regulations relating to its procedure and functions. These may provide for: (a) registration of industry-wise trade unions and national federations; (b) determination of collective bargaining units; (c) determination of collective bargaining agents; (d) procedure for adjudication of industrial disputes; (e) procedure for trial of offences; (f) procedure for dealing with unfair labour practices; (g) superintendence by the Chairman; (h) forms of registers and returns.
Raising of industrial dispute by a federation:
Under section 56, a federation of industry-wise trade unions or a national-level federation may, if it is a collective bargaining agent, raise an industrial dispute affecting all employers or workers of the establishments it represents. The Commission's decision shall be binding on all such employers and workers. No collective bargaining agent shall, while a Commission decision is effective, be entitled to raise a demand relating to the same matter.
β Key Takeaways
The National Industrial Relations Commission is a federal body of up to eight members with exclusive jurisdiction over industry-wise trade unions (spanning more than one province), disputes of national importance, and registration of national-level federations. Its nine core functions include adjudication, registration of unions, determination of collective bargaining agents, trial of offences, and dealing with unfair labour practices. The Commission operates through Full Benches and other Benches, with the Chairman's opinion prevailing in case of a tied vote. Appeals against non-Full Bench decisions must be filed within 30 days to the Full Bench. Critically, under section 53, no court can question the Commission's orders or jurisdiction, and after certification of a collective bargaining unit, no trade union can be registered for less than the whole unit.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How many members can the National Industrial Relations Commission consist of, and who appoints them?
- What is the difference in jurisdiction between the Commission and a Labour Court regarding unfair labour practices?
- If members of a Bench are equally divided on a point and the Chairman is a member, whose opinion prevails?
- Under section 51, what is the maximum fine the Commission can impose for contempt?
- What restrictions apply after the certification of a collective bargaining unit under section 54?
π Lecture 45 β Labour Laws
π Overview: This lecture covers unfair labour practices by employers and workmen under the Industrial Relations Ordinance, along with penalties. It then introduces the Workmenβs Compensation Act, 1923, defining key terms like disablement, dependents, and employer liability for compensation. Finally, it presents the Factories Act, 1934, covering definitions, inspector powers, and worker health/safety provisions, along with a brief overview of the Employeesβ Social Security Ordinance, 1965.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by detailing unfair labour practices on the part of employers (Section 63) and workmen (Section 64), including penalties for such practices. It then shifts to the Workmenβs Compensation Act, 1923, defining key concepts like minor, wages, employer, partial/total disablement, dependent, and workman, followed by employer liability for personal injury and occupational diseases. The lecture then covers the Factories Act, 1934, defining factory, worker, occupier, and related terms, along with the powers of the Provincial Government, Inspectors, and Certifying Surgeons, and provisions for worker health and working hours. It concludes with an overview of the Employeesβ Social Security Ordinance, 1965, and a revisit of all course modules.
π Lecture Summary
Unfair Labour Practices:
Unfair labour practices are defined for both employers and workmen under the Industrial Relations Ordinance. These are actions that violate the rights of workers to organize, bargain collectively, or work in a safe, non-coercive environment. The law specifies penalties for contravening these sections.
Unfair Labour practices on the part of employer: It has been defined in section 63 of the Ordinance. No employer shall: (a) impose any condition in a contract of employment seeking to restrain the rights of a person to join or continue membership of a trade union. (b) refuse to employ or continue to employ any person on the ground that such person is or is not a member or office-bearer of a trade union. (c) discriminate against any person in regard to any employment, promotion, condition of employment or working condition on the ground that such person is or is not a member or office-bearer of a trade union. (d) dismiss, discharge, remove from employment or transfer a workman or injure him in respect of his employment by reason that the workman is or proposes to become a member or office-bearer of a trade union, or participates in its activities. (e) induce any person to refrain from becoming, or to cease to be a member or office-bearer of a trade union, by conferring or offering to confer any advantage. (f) compel or attempt to compel any office-bearer of a collective bargaining agent to arrive at a settlement by using intimidation, coercion, pressure, threat, confinement, physical injury, or disconnection of utilities. (g) interfere with or in any way influence the balloting provided for in section 20. (h) recruit any workman during a period of notice of strike or during a strike which is not illegal, except where a Conciliator permits temporary employment to prevent serious damage to machinery. (i) close down the whole of an establishment in contravention of Standing Order 11A. (j) commence, continue, instigate or incite others to take part in, or expend or supply money in furtherance or support of an illegal lock-out.
Unfair Labour practices on the part of workmen: It has been defined in section 64 of the Ordinance. No workman or trade union of workmen shall: (a) persuade a workman to join or refrain from joining a trade union during working hours. (b) intimidate any person to become, or refrain from becoming, or to continue or cease to be a member or office-bearer of a trade union. (c) induce any person to refrain from becoming, or cease to be a member or office-bearer of a trade union by intimidating or conferring an advantage. (d) compel or attempt to compel the employer to accept any demand by using intimidation, coercion, pressure, threat, confinement, dispossession, assault, physical injury, or disconnection of utilities. (e) compel or attempt to compel any member of a bipartite or tripartite body to accept any demand by using similar coercive methods. (f) commence, continue, instigate or incite others to take part in or support an illegal strike or adopt go-slow measures. (g) carry any arms or weapons within the premises of an employer without any legal authority.
π Definition β go slow: An organized, deliberate and purposeful slowing down of normal output, or the deterioration of the normal quality, of work by a body of workmen acting in a concerted manner. π Formula: [Not applicable] π Example: A group of factory workers collectively and deliberately reduces their production speed by 50% to pressure the employer, while still claiming to be working. This is a "go slow" measure and an unfair labour practice.
(2) It shall be an unfair labour practice for a trade union to interfere with a ballot held under section 20 by undue influence, intimidation, impersonation or bribery.
Penalty for unfair labour practices:
- Whoever contravenes the provisions of section 63 (employer's unfair practices) shall be punishable with fine which may extend to thirty thousand rupees.
- Whoever contravenes the provisions of section 64 (workmen's unfair practices), other than clause (d), shall be punishable with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees.
Rights of Employer:
- Right to manage, control and carry on business according to his discretion.
- Right to use the available resources for the benefit and in the interest of business.
Duties of Employer:
- To act according to law to protect the rights of workers.
- To take necessary steps for the welfare of workers.
- To create healthy environment leading to the efficiency of labour and production.
Rights of Workers:
- To perform the job/duties for which they are hired.
- To receive agreed wages.
- To avail benefits.
- Right to form a trade union or be a member of one.
- To be a collective bargaining agent.
Duties of Workers:
- Perform duties as per agreement.
- Maintain discipline.
- Extend cooperation to the employer.
THE WORKMENβS COMPENSATION ACT, 1923
Compensation to Workmen: The laws relating to Workmenβs Compensation are governed by the Workmenβs Compensation Act, 1923, which extends to the whole of Pakistan. This Act provides for the payment of compensation to workmen (and their dependents) for personal injury and occupational diseases arising out of and in the course of employment.
Some Important Definitions: βMinor" means a person who has not attained the age of 18 years. βWagesβ includes any privilege or benefit which is capable of being estimated in money, other than a traveling allowance, traveling concession, employer contribution to a pension or provident fund, or a sum to cover special expenses of employment. βEmployer" includes any body of persons, a managing agent of an employer, and the legal representative of a deceased employer. When a workman's services are temporarily lent to another person, that other person is the employer while the workman works for him. βPartial disablement" means, where temporary, such disablement as reduces the earning capacity of a workman in any employment he was engaged in at the time of the accident. Where permanent, such disablement as reduces his earning capacity in every employment he was capable of undertaking. βTotal disablement" means such disablement, whether temporary or permanent, as incapacitates a workman for all work which he was capable of performing at the time of the accident. Permanent total disablement is deemed to result from injuries specified in Part I of Schedule I or from a combination of injuries in Part II where the aggregate loss of earning capacity is 100% or more. βDependent" means specific relatives of a deceased workman, including (i) a widow, minor legitimate or adopted son, unmarried legitimate or adopted daughter, or a widowed mother; (ii) if wholly dependent, an infirm son or daughter over 18; (iii) if wholly or partly dependent, a widower, parent, minor illegitimate son, unmarried illegitimate daughter, minor brother/sister, widowed daughter-in-law, minor child of a pre-deceased son/daughter, or paternal grandparent. βWorkman" means any person (other than a person of casual employment not for the employer's trade or business) who is a railway servant, a seaman, a crew member of an aircraft, a driver/helper of a motor vehicle, or employed in any capacity specified in Schedule II. It does not include members of the Armed Forces.
Employers Liability for Compensation: The employer is liable to pay compensation to a workman for personal injury and occupational disease arising out of and in the course of employment. Personal Injury: An employer is liable if personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of employment. Out of employment: The injury must have resulted from some risk incidental to the duties of the service, and at the time of injury, the worker must have been engaged in the employerβs business, not doing something for personal advantage. In the course of employment: This refers to the time during which employment continues. It covers the whole time a workman is carrying out his duties, including the time he is at a place where he would not be but for his employment. Occupational diseases: Contracting an occupational disease inherent to certain occupations is deemed to be an injury by accident.
Employer not Liable: The employer is not liable for compensation in the following cases: (a) for any injury which does not result in total or partial disablement for a period exceeding three days. (b) for any injury, not resulting in death or permanent total disablement, caused by an accident directly attributable to: (i) the workman being under the influence of drink or drugs, (ii) the willful disobedience of the workman to an order or rule expressly for safety, (iii) the willful removal or disregard by the workman of any safety guard or device.
Amount of Compensation: The amount of compensation is as follows: (a) Where death results: An amount equal to fifty per cent of the monthly wages of the deceased multiplied by the relevant factor; or fifty thousand rupees, whichever is more. (b) Where permanent total disablement results: An amount equal to sixty per cent of the monthly wages of the injured workman multiplied by the relevant factor; or sixty thousand rupees, whichever is more. (c) Where permanent partial disablement results: For injuries in Part II of Schedule I, a percentage of the compensation for permanent total disablement as specified. For other injuries, a proportionate percentage assessed by a qualified medical practitioner. (d) Where temporary disablement (total or partial) results: A half-monthly payment of twenty-five per cent of the monthly wages, payable from the sixteenth day (if disablement lasts 28 days or more) or after a 3-day waiting period (if less than 28 days), and continued during disablement or for five years, whichever is shorter. (4) If injury results in death, the employer must also deposit one thousand rupees for funeral expenses to the eldest surviving dependent.
FACTORIES ACT, 1934
The laws relating to factories are governed by the Factories Act, 1934, extending to the whole of Pakistan. It regulates working conditions, health, safety, and welfare of workers in factories.
Some Important Definitions: βAdolescentβ means a person who has completed his fifteenth but not his seventeenth year. βAdultβ means a person who has completed his seventeenth year. βChildβ means a person who has not completed his fifteenth year. βDayβ means a period of twenty-four hours beginning at midnight. βWeekβ means a period of seven days beginning at midnight on Saturday night. βPowerβ means electrical energy and any other form of mechanically transmitted energy not generated by human or animal agency. βManufacturing processβ means any process for making, altering, repairing, ornamenting, finishing, or packing any article, or for pumping oil/water/sewage, or for generating, transforming or transmitting power. βWorkerβ means a person employed, whether for wages or not, in any manufacturing process, cleaning machinery/premises, or in any work incidental to the manufacturing process. It does not include a person solely employed in a clerical capacity where no manufacturing process is carried on. βFactoryβ means any premises whereon twenty or more workers are working (or were working on any day of the preceding twelve months), and in any part of which a manufacturing process is being carried out with the aid of power. It does not include a mine under the Mines Act, 1923. βOccupierβ of a factory means the person who has ultimate control over the affairs of the factory.
Seasonal Factory (Sec 4): A factory exclusively engaged in seasonal manufacturing processes like cotton ginning, jute pressing, sugar (including gur), tea, etc., is a seasonal factory. The Provincial Government may declare a factory not to be seasonal if processes are carried on for more than 180 working days in the year.
Powers of Provincial Government (Sec 5-8): The Provincial Government can declare that provisions of the Act apply to places where a manufacturing process is carried on with ten or more workers. It can direct different departments to be treated as separate factories. It can exempt a factory where the number of workers is less than twenty and not likely to become twenty. In a public emergency, it can exempt a factory from any or all provisions.
Inspector Staff (Sec 10): The Provincial Government appoints Inspectors and a Chief Inspector for the purposes of the Act. Every District Magistrate shall be an Inspector for his district. No inspector can be interested in a factory or its business. All inspectors are public servants under the Pakistan Penal Code.
Powers of Inspector (Sec 11): An inspector has the power to: (a) enter any place which is, or is believed to be, used as a factory. (b) make examination of premises, plant, and registers, and take evidence of any person. (c) exercise such other powers as may be necessary. No one is required to answer any question or give evidence tending to criminate himself.
Certifying Surgeons (Sec 12): The Provincial Government may appoint registered medical practitioners to be certifying surgeons. They can authorize other registered medical practitioners to exercise their powers. A certificate of fitness granted by an authorized practitioner is valid for only three months unless confirmed by the certifying surgeon.
Facilities regarding health of workers required to be provided under the Act:
- Cleanliness (Sec 13): Factories must be kept clean and free from effluvia.
- Disposal of Water and Effluents (Sec 18)
- Ventilation and temperature (Sec 19)
- Overcrowding (Sec 19)
- Lighting (Sec 19)
- Drinking Water (Sec 20)
- Precautions in case of fire (Sec 25)
- Fencing of machinery (Sec 26)
- Prohibition of employment of women and children near cotton openers
- Protection of eyes (Sec 33)
Provisions regarding working hours:
- Daily hours (Sec 36)
- Weekly hours (Sec 34)
- Intervals for rest (Sec 37)
- Overtime work (Sec 47)
Provisions regarding Child Workers:
- Working hours (Sec 54)
- Fitness certificate (Sec 52)
Provisions regarding Women Workers:
- Machinery in motion (Sec 27)
- Suitable room (Sec 33)
- Working hours (Sec 36)
- Working time (Sec 45)
Provisions regarding Holidays with pay:
- Annual holidays (Sec 49B)
- Casual leave (Sec 49H)
- Sick leave (Sec 49H)
EMPLOYEESβ SOCIAL SECURITY ORDINANCE, 1965
Title of the Ordinance: It is called The (Provincial) Employeesβ Social Security Ordinance, 1965, extending to the whole of Pakistan.
Purpose of the Ordinance: To introduce a scheme of social security for providing benefits to certain employees or their dependents in the event of:
- Sickness
- Maternity
- Employment injury or death
- Ancillary matters.
Important Definitions: βContributionβ means the sum of money payable to the institution by an employer in respect of an employee. βDisablement" means a condition caused by an employment injury which permanently reduces earning capacity. It is "minor" where loss is less than 20%, "partial" where loss ranges from 21% to 66%, and "total" where loss is in excess of 66%. βEmployment injuryβ means a personal injury to a secured person caused by an accident or occupational disease arising out of and in the course of employment. βSecured personβ means a person in respect of whom contributions are or were payable under this Ordinance.
Topics covered under the Ordinance:
- Organization
- Contributions
- Finance and Audit
- Benefits
- Determination of Questions and Claims
- Offences and Penalties
Establishment and Incorporation of Employees Social Security Institution: The institution is a body corporate with power to acquire, hold and dispose of property. It has its own fund called the Employees Social Security Fund.
Management of the Institution: The institution is managed by a Governing Body with the assistance of a Commissioner.
Governing Body: Members include the Minister-in-charge of Labour, a person who is or has been a High Court Judge, a senior officer (Commissioner or Secretary), representatives from Government, employers, and secured persons, plus the Commissioner and Medical Adviser.
Benefits provided by the Social Security Institution:
- Sickness benefit (Sec 35)
- Maternity benefit (Sec 36)
- Death grant (Sec 37)
- Medical care during sickness and maternity (Sec 38)
- Injury benefits (Sec 39)
- Disablement pension (Sec 40)
- Disablement gratuity (Sec 41)
- Survivorβs Pension (Sec 42)
- Death grant in case of death while in receipt of injury benefit or total disablement (Sec 43)
- Medical care in the case of employment injury (Sec 44)
REVISIT OF MODULES:
The lecture concludes with a list of all modules covered in the course, serving as a comprehensive revision guide for the final examination.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture defines unfair labour practices separately for employers (Section 63) and workmen (Section 64), with fines of 30,000 and 20,000 rupees respectively. Under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, employers are liable for compensation for personal injury and occupational diseases arising out of and in the course of employment, with specific amounts for death, permanent total/partial disablement, and temporary disablement. The Factories Act, 1934 defines a factory as premises with 20 or more workers using power, and provides for inspector powers, worker health/safety (cleanliness, ventilation, fencing), working hours, and special provisions for child and women workers. The Employees' Social Security Ordinance, 1965 creates a social security institution providing sickness, maternity, injury, and disablement benefits funded by employer contributions. Students must master the specific definitions of partial/total disablement, dependent, workman, and factory, as well as the precise compensation formulas and employer liabilities/exceptions under these labour laws.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- List five specific unfair labour practices prohibited for an employer under Section 63 of the Industrial Relations Ordinance.
- Explain the difference between "partial disablement" and "total disablement" as defined in the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.
- What are the three exceptions where an employer is NOT liable to pay compensation for an injury that does not result in death or permanent total disablement?
- Under the Factories Act, 1934, what is the minimum number of workers required for premises to be defined as a "factory" where a manufacturing process is carried out with power? Who is an "occupier"?
- Name any four benefits provided to secured persons or their dependents under the Employeesβ Social Security Ordinance, 1965.