๐ Lecture 6 โ Moral Responsibility and Blame
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the concept of moral responsibility in business contexts, examining when individuals and organizations can be held morally accountable for wrongful actions. It introduces key excusing conditions that eliminate responsibility and mitigating factors that diminish it, while also presenting utilitarianism as a framework for ethical decision-making using real-world cases like Ford Pinto and apartheid-era Caltex.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with defining moral responsibility and blame, then examines excusing conditions (ignorance and inability) and mitigating factors that affect moral responsibility. It uses the Caltex South Africa case to illustrate real moral debates in business, followed by a detailed exploration of utilitarianism as a moral framework, including its foundations, application through cost-benefit analysis, and the Ford Pinto case as a practical example.
๐ Lecture Summary
Moral Responsibility and Blame
Moral responsibility is directed not only at judgments concerning right or wrong but also at determining whether a person or organization is morally responsible for having done something wrong. Moral responsibility is incurred only when a person knowingly and freely acts in an immoral way or fails to act in a moral way. A judgment about a personโs moral responsibility for a wrongful injury is a judgment about the extent to which the person deserves blame or punishment, or should pay restitution for the injury. For example, if an employer deliberately injures the health of her employees, we would judge the employer morally responsible for those injuries and say the employer is to blame and should compensate the victims.
๐ Definition โ Moral Responsibility: Responsibility incurred when a person knowingly and freely acts in an immoral way or fails to act in a moral way.
๐ Example: An employer who deliberately injures employee health is morally responsible and deserves blame, punishment, and must compensate victims.
Ignorance and Inability as Excusing Conditions
Ignorance and inability are two conditions, called excusing conditions, that completely eliminate a person's moral responsibility for causing wrongful injury. However, when one deliberately keeps oneself ignorant to escape responsibility, that ignorance does not excuse the wrongful injury. A person is morally responsible for an injury or a wrong if: (1) The person caused or helped cause it, or failed to prevent it when he could and should have; (2) The person did so knowing what he or she was doing; (3) The person did so of his own free will. Ignorance may concern relevant facts or relevant moral standards. Generally, ignorance of the facts eliminates moral responsibility because moral responsibility requires freedom. Inability eliminates responsibility because a person cannot have a moral obligation to do something over which he or she has no control.
๐ Definition โ Excusing Conditions: Conditions that completely eliminate a person's moral responsibility for causing wrongful injury, specifically ignorance and inability.
Mitigating Factors
In addition to excusing conditions, there are three mitigating factors that diminish (but do not eliminate) moral responsibility: (1) Circumstances that leave a person uncertain about what he or she is doing; (2) Circumstances that make it difficult for the person to avoid doing it; (3) Circumstances that minimize a person's involvement in an act. The extent to which these mitigating circumstances diminish an agent's responsibility depends on the seriousness of the injury. Generally, the more serious the injury, the less the mitigating circumstances will diminish responsibility.
๐ Definition โ Mitigating Factors: Circumstances that diminish moral responsibility without completely eliminating it, including uncertainty, difficulty in avoidance, and minimized involvement.
The Caltex South Africa Case
The lecture discusses apartheid-era South Africa and Caltex, an American oil company operating there. A large number of Caltex stockholders opposed the company's operations, seeing them as racist and immoral, and introduced shareholder resolutions requiring Caltex to leave South Africa. Caltex's management argued that their operations had positive effects on black workers rather than focusing on financial assistance to the government. Archbishop Desmond Tutu supported the shareholder resolutions, saying that "comfort under an immoral regime was not preferable to freedom, even at the cost of economic hardship." This example shows how real moral debates in business appeal to four basic types of moral standards: utilitarianism, rights, justice, and caring. The shareholders' argument referred to unjust policies and violated civil rights, while Caltex's management made utilitarian arguments about caring for workers' best interests.
๐ก Why this matters: This case demonstrates that business decisions involve complex moral trade-offs where different ethical frameworks can lead to conflicting conclusions.
Utilitarianism: Weighing Social Costs and Benefits
Utilitarianism (or consequentialism) characterizes the moral approach taken by Caltex's management. The Ford Pinto case demonstrates how closely cost-benefit analysis can be applied. Ford knew the Pinto would explode when rear-ended at only 20 mph, but fixing the problem would cost $137 million. Since they would only have to pay $49 million in damages to victims, they calculated it was not right to spend the money when society set such a low price on lives and health.
Utilitarianism is a general term for any view that holds that actions and policies should be evaluated on the basis of the benefits and costs they will impose on society. The "right" action or policy is the one that will produce the greatest net benefits or the lowest net costs. Jeremy Bentham founded traditional utilitarianism, assuming we can measure and add quantities of benefits and subtract measured quantities of harm. For Bentham: "An action is right from an ethical point of view if and only if the sum total of utilities produced by that act is greater than the sum total of utilities produced by any other act the agent could have performed in its place."
๐ Definition โ Utilitarianism: Any view holding that actions and policies should be evaluated based on the benefits and costs they impose on society; the right action produces the greatest net benefits.
๐ Formula: Sum of utilities of Act A > Sum of utilities of any alternative act โ Act A is morally right
To determine the moral thing to do: (1) Determine what alternative actions are available; (2) Estimate direct and indirect costs and benefits for all involved in the foreseeable future; (3) Choose the alternative that produces the greatest sum total of utility.
Attractions and Applications of Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism is attractive because it matches views we hold about governmental policies and public goods. Most people agree that government should adopt projects providing the greatest benefits at the least cost. It explains why we hold certain activities like lying to be immoral due to costly long-run effects. However, traditional utilitarians deny that an action of a certain kind is always right or wrong; each action must be weighed given its particular circumstances. Utilitarian views have been highly influential in economics, with economists arguing that human beings always attempt to maximize their utility. It is also the basis of economic costโbenefit analysis, used to determine the desirability of investing in projects by figuring whether economic benefits outweigh costs. Finally, utilitarianism fits nicely with efficiency as a value that many people prize.
๐ก Why this matters: Utilitarianism provides a systematic framework for business decisions but can lead to morally questionable outcomes when human life is assigned a monetary value, as in the Ford Pinto case.
โญ Key Takeaways
For exam purposes, remember that moral responsibility requires three conditions: causing or failing to prevent injury, knowing what one was doing, and acting of free will. Ignorance and inability are complete excusing conditions, but deliberate ignorance does not excuse. Three mitigating factors (uncertainty, difficulty, minimized involvement) diminish rather than eliminate responsibility, with less effect for more serious injuries. Utilitarianism evaluates actions based on producing the greatest net benefits for all involved, using cost-benefit analysis. The Ford Pinto case exemplifies how utilitarian calculations can be problematic when human life is monetized, while the Caltex case shows how different ethical frameworks can conflict in business decisions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three conditions that must be present for a person to be morally responsible for a wrongful injury?
- When does ignorance NOT excuse a person from moral responsibility?
- What three mitigating factors diminish (but do not eliminate) moral responsibility?
- According to Bentham's utilitarianism, what makes an action morally right?
- In the Ford Pinto case, what was Ford's utilitarian calculation, and what ethical problem did it create?
๐ Lecture 7 โ Utilitarianism
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces utilitarianism as an ethical theory that evaluates actions based on their consequences, specifically by weighing social costs and benefits. It explores classical utilitarianism developed by Bentham and Mill, cost-benefit analysis as its practical application, and the strengths and weaknesses of this approach for business ethics decision-making.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the fundamental principles of utilitarianism as a teleological ethical theory, the classical formulations by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, the practical application through cost-benefit analysis, the problems of assigning monetary values to non-market goods, the value-laden nature of cost-benefit analysis, and the five major measurement problems with utilitarianism. It also distinguishes between cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis.
๐ Lecture Summary
Utilitarianism: Weighing Social Costs and Benefits
Utilitarianism is described as a powerful and widely accepted ethical theory with special relevance to business problems. It provides a straightforward decision-making process involving: developing a list of available alternatives, following the consequences of each as far into the future as possible, and selecting the alternative with the greatest balance of benefits over harms for everyone. The chapter also introduces the distinction between teleological theories (which judge actions by their consequences) and deontological theories (which judge actions by their inherent rightness or wrongness).
Classical Utilitarianism
Different parts of utilitarian doctrine were advanced by ancient Greek philosophers, but it was early nineteenth-century English reformers Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) and John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) who fashioned the various pieces into a coherent whole. Bentham's utilitarianism approves of actions that augment and disapproves of actions that diminish the happiness of the party in question. He measured pleasure or pain by a hedonistic calculus that considers factors such as intensity, duration, likelihood of occurrence, and proximity in time. According to Bentham, if this process is repeated for all individuals, the resulting sums show the good or bad tendency of an action for an entire community.
Critics charge that Bentham's conception of pleasure is too crude to constitute the sole good for human beings. Mill modified Bentham's utilitarianism by proposing that actions are right inasmuch as they promote happiness and wrong inasmuch as they promote the opposite of happiness, where happiness is pleasure and the absence of pain. Mill stipulated that pleasures differ in their quality, so that humans enjoy higher pleasures than animals. One can argue that Mill saves hedonism from the charge of crudeness because the higher pleasures enjoyed by a few with elevated tastes are unlikely to outweigh the total sum of base pleasures enjoyed by most. However, Mill gives no guidance for comparing the quality with the quantity of pleasure. In other writings, Mill seems to claim that the development of our critical faculties and the capacity for autonomous action are ends in themselves.
๐ Definition โ Bentham's Utilitarian Principle: "An action is right from an ethical point of view if and only if the sum total of utilities produced by that act is greater than the sum total of utilities produced by any other act the agent could have performed in its place."
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Bentham's idea of a precise quantitative method for decision making is most fully realized in cost-benefit analysis. In this approach, monetary units are used to express the benefits and drawbacks of various alternatives in a decision-making process. The chief advantage of cost-benefit analysis is that the prices of many goods are set by the market, which eliminates the need to have knowledge of people's pleasures or preference rankings.
Because of its narrow focus on economic efficiency in the allocation of resources, cost-benefit analysis is not commonly used as a basis for personal morality. It cannot determine such moral questions as the rights of consumers in matters of product safety or environmental protection but can be used only to determine appropriate levels of both product safety and environmental protection.
A distinction is made between cost-benefit analysis (used to select both the means to an end and the end itself) and cost-effectiveness analysis (which assumes we already have an agreed-upon end, and the only question regards the most efficient means of achieving it).
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the difference between cost-benefit and cost-effectiveness analysis helps business professionals know when they are choosing goals versus just choosing methods.
The Problems of Assigning Monetary Values
Not all costs and benefits have an easily determined monetary value; examples include the enjoyment of family and friends, peace and quiet, police protection, and freedom from the risk of injury and death. Moreover, the market price of a good does not always correspond to its opportunity cost. For example, the fact that a yacht costs more than a college education does not mean that consumers value yachts more highly than education.
One can attempt to overcome these problems through shadow pricing, which enables a value to be placed on goods that reflects people's market and non-market behavior. For example, by comparing the prices of houses near airports with the prices of similar houses elsewhere, it is possible to infer the value that people place on peace and quiet. But there are limitationsโsomeone who buys a house near an airport may be unable to afford comparable housing elsewhere or simply may not mind the noise.
๐ Example: Comparing house prices near airports versus similar houses elsewhere to infer the monetary value people place on peace and quiet. Limitation: The buyer may simply not mind noise or cannot afford alternatives.
Should All Things Be Assigned a Monetary Value?
Some argue that placing a dollar value on certain goods actually lessens their perceived value, since they are valued precisely because they cannot be bought or sold. Friendship, love, and life itself are examples of such goods. The lecture notes that such arguments are "beside the point" because cost-benefit analysis requires that a value be placed on goods only for the purposes of calculation.
Other Values in Cost-Benefit Analysis
Though cost-benefit analysis purports to be value-free, critics claim that it is heavily value-laden because analysts cannot entirely disengage their own values from the analysis. Before such an investigation begins, the analyst must make several value-laden decisions:
- The range of alternatives to be considered in the analysis
- What constitutes a cost and a benefit as well as whose values determine this
- What counts as a consequence of a particular act
- The number of "spillover effects" or externalities that are included
- The distance into the future that the consequences are calculated
In the end, cost-benefit analysis is only as good as the analyst who performs it and is not intended to be the sole means for arriving at important decisions we make as a society. Only one action can have the lowest net costs and greatest net benefits.
Three Considerations for Moral Decision-Making
To determine what the moral thing to do on any particular occasion might be, there are three considerations:
- You must determine what alternative actions are available
- You must estimate the direct and indirect costs and benefits the action would produce for all involved in the foreseeable future
- You must choose the alternative that produces the greatest sum total of utility
Utilitarianism is attractive to many because it matches the views we tend to hold when discussing governmental policies and public goods. Most people agree, for example, that when the government is trying to determine on which public projects it should spend tax monies, the proper course of action would be to adopt those projects that objective studies show will provide the greatest benefits for members of society at the least cost. It also fits with intuitive criteria that many employ when discussing moral conduct.
Utilitarianism can explain why we hold certain types of activities, such as lying, to be immoral: it is because of the costly effects it has in the long run. However, traditional utilitarians would deny that an action of a certain kind is always either right or wrong. Instead, each action would have to be weighed given its particular circumstances.
Utilitarian views have been highly influential in economics. A long line of economists, beginning in the 19th century, argued that economic behavior could be explained by assuming that human beings always attempt to maximize their utility and that the utilities of commodities can be measured by the prices people are willing to pay for them.
Utilitarianism is also the basis of the techniques of economic cost-benefit analysis, used to determine the desirability of investing in a project (such as a dam, factory, or public park) by figuring whether its present and future economic benefits outweigh its present and future economic costs. To calculate these costs and benefits, discounted monetary prices are estimated for all effects the project will have on the present and future environment and on present and future populations.
Utilitarianism fits nicely with a value that many people prize: efficiency, which for many means operating in such a way that one produces the most one can with the resources at hand.
Five Major Problems with Utilitarian Measurement
Though utilitarianism offers a superficially clear-cut method of calculating the morality of actions, it relies upon accurate measurement, and this can be problematic. There are five major problems with the utilitarian reliance on measurement:
- Comparative measures of the values things have for different people cannot be madeโwe cannot get into each others' skins to measure the pleasure or pain caused
- Some benefits and costs are impossible to measureโhow much is a human life worth, for example?
- The potential benefits and costs of an action cannot always be reliably predicted, so they are also not adequately measurable
โญ Key Takeaways
Utilitarianism evaluates actions based on their consequences, specifically by selecting the alternative that produces the greatest balance of benefits over harms for all affected parties. The classical formulations by Bentham (quantitative hedonistic calculus) and Mill (qualitative higher pleasures) provide the foundation, though Mill's approach struggles with comparing quality versus quantity of pleasure. Cost-benefit analysis applies utilitarian principles using monetary units, but faces significant challenges including assigning values to non-market goods, the value-laden nature of analyst decisions, and fundamental measurement problems such as the impossibility of comparing utilities across different people. Students must remember that while utilitarianism provides an intuitive and seemingly straightforward decision-making framework, its practical application is limited by these measurement difficulties and by the fact that it cannot determine moral questions about rights.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between Bentham's and Mill's versions of utilitarianism regarding pleasure?
- How does cost-effectiveness analysis differ from cost-benefit analysis?
- What are the three steps in the utilitarian decision-making process for determining the moral thing to do?
- List at least three of the five value-laden decisions an analyst must make before conducting a cost-benefit analysis.
- What are the three measurement problems with utilitarianism mentioned in the lecture?
๐ Lecture 8 โ Utilitarianism (Contd.)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the critique of utilitarianism by examining its measurement problems and inability to address rights and justice. It introduces rule utilitarianism as an alternative, then shifts to moral rights, contractual rights, and Kantโs categorical imperative as foundational ethical frameworks. Understanding these limitations is critical for evaluating ethical decisions in business contexts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture examines eight key objections to utilitarian measurement, including the impossibility of comparing values across individuals and measuring intangibles like human life. It then presents utilitarian defenses using common-sense criteria and monetary equivalents. Rule utilitarianism is introduced as a response to criticisms about rights and justice. The discussion of rights covers moral vs. legal rights, negative vs. positive rights, contractual rights and duties, and four ethical rules governing contracts. Finally, Kantโs first formulation of the categorical imperative is explained with the criteria of universalizability and reversibility.
๐ Lecture Summary
4. Comparative measures of the values things have for different people cannot be madeโwe cannot get into each others' skins to measure the pleasure or pain caused.
5. Some benefits and costs are impossible to measure. How much is a human life worth, for example?
6. The potential benefits and costs of an action cannot always be reliably predicted, so they are also not adequately measurable.
7. It is unclear exactly what counts as a benefit or a cost. People see these things in different ways.
8. Utilitarian measurement implies that all goods can be traded for equivalents of each other. However, not everything has a monetary equivalent.
The critics of utilitarianism contend that these measurement problems undercut whatever claims utilitarian theory makes towards providing an objective basis for determining normative issues. These problems have become especially obvious in debates over the feasibility of corporate social audits.
Utilitarian defenders argue that though ideally they would like accurate measurements of everything, they know this is largely impossible. Therefore, when measurements are difficult or impossible to obtain, shared or common-sense judgments of comparative value are sufficient.
There are two widely used common-sense criteria. One relies on the distinction between intrinsic goods and instrumental goods. Intrinsic goods are things that are desired for their own sake, such as health and life. These goods always take precedence over instrumental goods, which are things that are good because they help to bring about an intrinsic good. The other common-sense criterion depends on the distinction between needs and wants. Goods that bring about needs are more important than those that bring about wants. However, these methods are intended to be used only when quantitative methods fail.
The most flexible method is to measure actions and goods in terms of their monetary equivalents. If someone is willing to pay twice as much for one good than for another, we can assume that the former is twice as valuable for that person. Many people are made uncomfortable by the notion that health and life must be assigned a monetary value. Utilitarian point out that we do so every day, however, by paying for some safety measures but not for those measures that are considered more expensive.
๐ Definition โ Intrinsic goods: things desired for their own sake (e.g., health, life) that always take precedence over instrumental goods.
๐ Definition โ Instrumental goods: things that are good because they help bring about an intrinsic good.
๐ก Why this matters: These measurement defenses show that utilitarianism, while imperfect, can still function practically using common sense and monetary proxies, even when exact quantification is impossible.
The major difficulty with utilitarianism, according to some critics, is that it is unable to deal with two kinds of moral issues: those relating to rights and those relating to justice.
If people have rights to life, health, and other basic needs, and if there is such a thing as justice that does not depend on mere utility, then utilitarianism does not provide a complete picture of morality. Utilitarianism looks only at how much utility is produced in a society and fails to take into account how that utility is distributed among the members of society.
Rule Utilitarianism
Largely in response to these concerns, utilitarians have devised an alternative version, called rule utilitarianism. In this version, instead of looking at individual acts to see whether they produce more pleasure than the alternatives, one looks only at moral rules at actions of a particular type. If actions of a kind tend to produce more pleasure or have lower costs, then they are the moral types of actions. Just because an action produces more utility on one occasion does not show it is right ethically.
However, rule utilitarianism may not completely answer all of the objections raised by critics. A rule may generally produce more utility and still be unjust: consider rules that would allow a large majority to take unfair advantage of a smaller minority.
The theory of the rule utilitarian has two parts, summarized in the following two principles:
- An action is right from an ethical point of view if and only if the action would be required by those moral rules that are correct.
- A moral rule is correct if and only if the sum total of utilities produced if everyone were to follow that rule is greater than the sum total utilities produced if everyone were to follow some alternative rule.
Thus, according to the rule-utilitarian, the fact that a certain action would maximize utility on one particular occasion does not show that it is right from an ethical point of view. The two major limits to utilitarianismโdifficulties of measurement and the inability to deal with rights and justiceโremain, though the extent to which they limit utilitarian morality is not clear.
๐ Definition โ Rule utilitarianism: an ethical theory that judges actions by whether they conform to moral rules that, if followed by everyone, would produce the greatest total utility, rather than judging individual acts.
๐ Formula: An action is right โ the action is required by rules that, if universally followed, produce greater total utility than any alternative rule.
Rights
A person has a right when that person is entitled to act in a certain way or is entitled to have others act in a certain way toward him or her. The "right to work", many argue, is a right that all human beings possess. Such rights, which are called moral rights or human rights, are based on moral norms and principles that specify that all human beings are permitted or empowered to do something or are entitled to have something done for them. Moral rights, unlike legal rights, are usually thought of as being universal insofar as they are rights that all human beings of every nationality possess to an equal extent simply by virtue of being human beings.
The most important moral rights are rights that impose prohibitions or requirements on others and which thereby enable individuals to choose freely whether to pursue certain interests or activities. Moral rights are tightly correlated with duties. My moral right to worship as I choose, for example, can be defined in terms of the moral duties other people have to not interfere in my chosen form of worship. Duties, then, are generally the other side of moral rights. Moral rights impose correlative duties on others, either duties of non-interference or duties of positive performance.
Moral rights provide individuals with autonomy and equality in the free pursuit of their interests. The gains of others do not generally justify interference with a person's pursuit of an interest or an activity when that pursuit is protected by a moral right. Moral rights provide a basis for justifying oneโs actions and for invoking the protection or aid of others.
Negative and Positive Rights
Negative rights are distinguished by the fact that they can be defined only in terms of the duties others have to not interfere in certain activities of the person who holds a given right. Positive rights are all rights that go beyond non-interference to also impose a positive duty of providing people with something when they are unable to provide it for themselves.
Positive rights, as we know them today, were not emphasized until the 20th century when society increasingly took it on itself to provide its members with the necessities of life that they were unable to provide for themselves.
Much of the debate over moral rights has concentrated on whether negative or positive rights should be given priority. "Conservative" writers have claimed that government efforts should be limited to enforcing negative rights and not expended on providing positive rights. "Liberal" authors hold that positive rights have as strong a claim to being honored as negative rights and that, consequently, government has a duty to provide both.
Privacy is an example of a negative right; the rights to food, life, and health care are positive. In general, more liberal theorists hold that society should guarantee positive as well as negative rights; conservatives wish to limit government to enforcing negative rights.
๐ Definition โ Negative rights: rights defined by others' duties to not interfere (e.g., privacy).
๐ Definition โ Positive rights: rights that impose a positive duty on others to provide something when the holder cannot provide it for themselves (e.g., right to food, healthcare).
Rights and Duties
The discussion of rights and duties begins with a case: Walt Disney and Chinese companies. On March 3, 2004, executives of Walt Disney were confronted with stockholders concerned about the company's human rights record in China. Disney merchandise manufactured in China faced reports of poor worker rights, including no independent trade unions, harassment of workers seeking redress, child labor, and forced prison labor as reported by the Congressional-Executive Commission on China and the U.S. State Department.
In general, a right is a person's entitlement to something; one has a right to something when one is entitled to act a certain way or to have others act in a certain way towards oneself. An entitlement from laws is called a legal right. Entitlements from moral standards are called moral rights or human rights.
In ordinary discourse, the term "right" covers three situations:
- The mere absence of prohibitions against pursuing some interest or activity.
- A person is authorized or empowered to do something to secure the interests of others or one's own interests.
- The existence of prohibitions or requirements on others that enable the individual to pursue certain interests or activities.
The most important rights impose requirements or prohibitions on others, enabling people to choose whether or not to do something. Moral rights have three important features:
- Closely correlated with duties.
- Provide individuals with autonomy and equality in the free pursuit of their interests.
- Provide a basis for justifying one's actions and invoking the aid of others.
Moral judgments based on rights differ substantially from those based on utility. First, rights are based on the individual, whereas utilitarianism is based on society as a whole. Second, rights limit the validity of preferring numbers and social benefits to the individual. However, rights do not always override utilitarian standardsโin times of war, civil rights are commonly restricted for the public good.
Contractual Rights and Duties
Contractual rights, sometimes called special rights and duties or special obligations, are those most closely connected to business activity. These rights attach only to specific individuals, and the duties they give rise to attach only to specific individuals. They arise out of specific transactions between parties and depend upon a pre-existing public system of rules. If I contract to do something for you, then you are entitled to my performance: you acquire a contractual right to whatever I promise, and I have a contractual duty to perform as I promised. Contractual rights and duties depend on a publicly accepted system of rules that define the transactions that give rise to those rights and duties.
Contractual rights and duties also provide a basis for the special duties or obligations that people acquire when they accept a position or a role within a legitimate social institution or organization. Married parents have a special duty to care for the upbringing of their children.
What are the ethical rules governing contracts?
- Both parties must have full knowledge of the nature of the agreement they are entering.
- Neither party must intentionally misrepresent the facts of the contractual situation to the other party.
- Neither party must be forced to enter the contract under duress or coercion.
- The contract must not bind the parties to an immoral act.
Generally, a contract that violates one or more of these conditions is considered void.
๐ Definition โ Contractual rights: rights that attach only to specific individuals, arising from specific transactions and depending on a pre-existing public system of rules.
Utilitarianismโs Problem with Rights and Justice
The major difficulty with utilitarianism, according to some critics, is that it is unable to deal with two kinds of moral issues: those relating to Rights and those relating to Justice. The utilitarian principle implies that certain actions are morally right when in fact they are unjust or violate people's rights.
The great benefits a system may have for the majority does not justify the extreme burdens that it imposes on a small group. The shortcoming of utilitarianism is that it allows benefits and burdens to be distributed among the members of society in any way whatsoever so long as the total amount of benefits is maximized. Utilitarianism looks only at how much utility is produced in a society and fails to take into account how that utility is distributed among the members of society.
Considerations of Justice (which look at how benefits and burdens are distributed among people) and Rights (which look at individual entitlements to freedom of choice and to well-being) seem to be ignored by analysis that looks only at the costs and benefits of decisions.
A Basis for Moral Rights: Kant
Utilitarianism and Kantian ethics have different views about lives being of equal moral value and about moral considerabilityโthe certain traits that give a being personhood. When applied to issues like abortion, Kantian ethics focuses on whether a person is a living, breathing being of moral value, regardless of quality of life. Kantian Ethics appears more sound because it recognizes that a person is a person who can contribute to society, whereas utilitarianism, despite claiming concern for welfare, takes value and importance out of human beings.
Kantโs theory of morality is the most feasible in determining a personโs duty in a moral situation. The basis for his theory is acting morally because doing so is the right thing to do. The process Kant describes of converting maxims to universal laws to test their moral beliefs provides a useful guide and system of ethics.
The First Formulation of Kantโs Categorical Imperative
Kantโs first formulation of the categorical imperative is as follows: โI ought never to act except in such a way that I can also will that my maxim should become a universal law.โ A maxim for Kant is the reason a person in a certain situation has for doing what he or she plans to do. A maxim would "become a universal law" if every person in a similar situation chose to do the same thing for the same reason.
Kantโs first version of the categorical imperative comes down to the following principle:
โAn action is morally right for a person in a certain situation if, and only if, the person's reason for carrying out the action is a reason that he or she would be willing to have every person act on, in any similar situation.โ
An example: Suppose I am trying to decide whether to fire an employee because I do not like the employeeโs race. According to Kantโs principle, I must ask myself whether I would be willing to have an employer fire any employee whenever the employer does not like the race of his or her employee. In particular, I must ask myself whether I would be willing to be fired myself should my employer not like my race. If I am not willing to have everyone act in this way, even toward me, then it is morally wrong for me to act in this way toward others.
A personโs reasons for acting must be โreversibleโ: one must be willing to have all others use those reasons even against oneself. There is an obvious similarity between the categorical imperative and the golden rule: โDo unto others as you would have them do unto you.โ
The first formulation of the categorical imperative incorporates two criteria for determining moral right and wrongโuniversalizability and reversibility.
๐ Definition โ Categorical Imperative (First Formulation): An action is morally right if and only if the person's reason for acting is one they would be willing to have every person act on in any similar situation.
๐ Formula: Action is morally right โ the maxim (reason) for the action can be universalized (willed as a universal law) and is reversible (one would accept it even against oneself).
๐ Example: Deciding whether to fire an employee based on race. Ask: Would I be willing for every employer to fire employees based on race? Would I be willing to be fired for my race? If not, the action is morally wrong.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes eight major measurement problems with utilitarianism, including the inability to compare values across individuals, measure intangibles like human life, or reliably predict outcomes. Utilitarians defend their approach using common-sense criteria (intrinsic vs. instrumental goods, needs vs. wants) and monetary equivalents. Rule utilitarianism attempts to address criticisms about rights and justice by focusing on universal rules rather than individual acts, though it may still permit unjust rules benefiting majorities at the expense of minorities. Moral rights are distinguished from legal rights, with negative rights (non-interference) and positive rights (duty to provide) forming a key philosophical debate. Kant's categorical imperative provides an alternative ethical foundation emphasizing universalizability and reversibility, directly contrasting with utilitarian focus on aggregate utility.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the eight measurement problems critics raise against utilitarianism, and how do utilitarians defend against them using common-sense criteria?
-
How does rule utilitarianism differ from act utilitarianism, and what are its two core principles?
-
What is the distinction between negative rights and positive rights, and which examples are given for each?
-
What are the four ethical rules governing contracts, and what happens when a contract violates one or more?
-
According to Kant's first formulation of the categorical imperative, what two criteria must a reason for action satisfy to be morally right, and how does the golden rule relate to this principle?