๐ Lecture 28 โ Ethics and the Environment
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the ethical dimensions of environmental pollution, particularly from commercial and industrial enterprises. It explores ecological ethics (deep ecology), environmental rights arguments, and utilitarian approaches to pollution control, providing frameworks for understanding business responsibilities toward the natural environment.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the ethics of pollution control, examining how businesses have historically treated air and water as free goods. It then introduces ecological ethics or deep ecology, which argues the environment deserves preservation for its own sake beyond human interests. The lecture discusses environmental rights and absolute bans through William Blackstone's framework, then contrasts this with utilitarian approaches that address pollution through private versus social cost analysis.
๐ Lecture Summary
Ethics of Pollution Control
Businesses have historically ignored their environmental impact because economic costs were unclear, treating air and water as free goods that no one owns. Since the carrying capacity of both is large, each firm sees its pollution contribution as negligible, but combined effects are enormous. Pollution also results from consumer product use and human wasteโautomobile use is a primary air pollution source, and sewage is a primary water pollution source. The world's population grew from 1 billion in 1850 to 5.7 billion in 1995, projected to reach 10-12 billion by 2040, with urbanization creating high population densities that multiply pollution burdens.
Ecological Ethics
An ecological system is an interrelated and interdependent set of organisms and environments where the activities of one part affect all other parts, and the survival of each part depends on others. Business firms are parts of "spaceship earth," depending on natural environment for energy, material resources, and waste disposal. For example, 18th-century European beaver hat manufacturers caused wholesale destruction of beavers in the United States, leading to drying up of swamp lands created by beaver dams.
Ecological ethics or deep ecology maintains that the environment deserves preservation for its own sake, regardless of direct human benefit. Supporters formulated a platform of eight statements: i. Well-being of human and nonhuman life has value in themselves, independent of usefulness for human purposes ii. Richness and diversity of life forms are values in themselves iii. Humans have no right to reduce this richness except to satisfy vital needs iv. Human flourishing is compatible with substantial population decrease; nonhuman flourishing requires it v. Present human interference with nonhuman world is excessive and worsening vi. Policies must change, affecting basic economic, technological, and ideological structures vii. Ideological change means appreciating life quality rather than higher standard of living viii. Subscribers have obligation to participate in implementing necessary changes
๐ Definition โ Ecological ethics (deep ecology): The view that the welfare of at least some nonhumans is intrinsically valuable and deserving of respect and protection, and the environment deserves preservation for its own sake.
Several varieties exist. The most popular claims that other animals have intrinsic value. Some utilitarians claim pain is evil whether inflicted on humans or other animal speciesโit is specist prejudice to think duties to avoid inflicting pain on other species are unequal to duties toward our own species. Non-utilitarians claim every animal's life "itself has value," giving animals moral rights, particularly the right to be treated with respect. Both views imply it is wrong to raise animals for food in crowded, painful conditions or use animals in painful test procedures (e.g., testing cosmetics toxicity). Broader versions extend duties to include plants, acknowledging all living things have "an interest in remaining alive."
๐ก Why this matters: Ecological ethics challenges anthropocentric (human-centered) views, forcing businesses to consider whether nonhuman entities have moral standing that constrains commercial activities.
Environmental Rights and Absolute Bans
William T. Blackstone argued that a livable environment is not merely desirable but something to which each human being has a right. This right imposes on others the correlative duty not to interfere. A person has a moral right to something when possession is "essential in permitting him to live a human life" (fulfilling capacities as a rational and free being). This moral right should become a legal right.
๐ Definition โ Environmental right: The moral and legal right to a decent environment, which overrides people's legal property rights because without a livable environment, we lose the possibility of exercising other rights like liberty and equality.
Section 101(b) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 recognizes something like Blackstone's concept. However, the main difficulty is that this absolute rights approach fails to provide nuanced guidance on pressing environmental choices, especially when pollution removal costs are high compared to benefits.
Utilitarianism and Partial Controls
Utilitarians see environmental problems as market defects, arguing pollution should be avoided because it harms society's welfare. When markets do not take all costs into account, more of a commodity is produced than society would demand if it could measure actual costs. Producers ignore these costs and do not minimize them, violating utilitarian principles underlying the market system.
Private Costs and Social Costs
Economists distinguish between private cost (what it costs a private manufacturer to make a product) and social cost (what manufacturing that product costs society as a whole).
๐ Formula: Social Cost = Private Internal Costs + External Costs
๐ Example: An electric firm consumes fuel, labor, and equipment to produce one kilowatt of electricity. The cost of these resources is its private cost. However, burning fuel generates smoke and soot that settles on neighbors, who bear cleanup and medical costs. The sum of internal costs (firm's expenses) plus external costs (neighbors' cleanup and medical care) equals the social cost of producing one kilowatt of electricity.
Private costs and social costs do not always divergeโif a producer pays all costs involved or manufacturing imposes no external costs, then private costs and total social costs are the same.
๐ก Why this matters: The private/social cost distinction provides a framework for understanding why pollution is economically inefficient and why government intervention (e.g., pollution taxes, emission permits) may be justified to align private incentives with social welfare.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents three main ethical frameworks for environmental issues. First, ecological ethics or deep ecology argues nonhuman parts of the environment have intrinsic value and deserve preservation for their own sake, with implications for animal treatment and biodiversity. Second, Blackstone's environmental rights approach argues humans have a moral and legal right to a livable environment that should override property rights, though it lacks nuance for balancing costs and benefits. Third, the utilitarian approach frames pollution as a market defect where private costs diverge from social costs, leading to overproduction of polluting goods. Understanding the distinction between private costs and social costs is essential for analyzing why pollution is economically inefficient and how policy interventions can correct market failures. The key challenge is balancing environmental protection with economic efficiency, where absolute rights may be too rigid and pure cost-benefit analysis may ignore intrinsic environmental values.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is ecological ethics (deep ecology), and how does it differ from anthropocentric environmental views?
- According to Blackstone, why do human beings have a moral right to a livable environment, and what is the main criticism of this absolute rights approach?
- How does the utilitarian framework view pollution as a market defect?
- Using the electricity generation example, explain the difference between private cost and social cost.
- What are the eight platform statements of deep ecology, and how do utilitarian and rights arguments support duties toward animals?
๐ Lecture 29 โ The Ethics of Pollution Control
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the ethical frameworks for addressing pollution, focusing on how firms can remedy external costs. It explores utilitarian and justice-based approaches to pollution control, emphasizing the importance of internalizing costs to ensure fairness and environmental responsibility.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main remedies for pollution: internalizing external costs through compensation or pollution-control devices. It then analyzes these remedies through the lens of distributive, retributive, and compensatory justice, explaining how internalizing costs can reverse the flow of benefits from the poor to the rich and ensure those responsible for pollution bear the burden of rectifying it.
๐ Lecture Summary
Remedies: The duties of the Firm
The remedy for external costs, according to utilitarians, is to internalize them to ensure that the producer pays all of the real costs of production and uses these costs to determine the price of the commodity. To internalize the costs of pollution, a firm may be required to pay all those harmed by pollution. A problem with this way of internalizing the costs of pollution, however, is that when several polluters are involved, it is not always clear just who is being harmed and by whom.
A second remedy is for the polluter to stop pollution at its source by installing pollution-control devices. In this way, the external costs of polluting the environment are translated into the internal costs the firm pays to install pollution controls. Once the costs are internalized in this way, market mechanisms again provide cost cutting incentives and ensure that prices reflect the true costs of producing the commodity. In addition, the installation of pollution-control devices serves to eliminate the long-range and potentially disastrous worldwide effects of pollution.
๐ก Why this matters: These two remedies offer different practical and ethical paths. The first focuses on compensating victims, which can be complex when pollution is shared. The second focuses on prevention, which is often more direct and effective.
Justice
This way of dealing with pollution (i.e., by internalizing costs) is consistent with the requirements of distributive justice. Since pollution's external costs are largely borne by the poor, pollution produces a net flow of benefits away from the poor and towards the rich. Internalizing these costs can reverse this flow. However, if a firm makes basic goods, such as food, then internalizing costs may place a heavier burden on poorer people.
Internalizing external costs is also consistent with retributive and compensatory justice, because those who are responsible for pollution bear the burden of rectifying it and compensating those who have been harmed. Taken together, these requirements imply that:
- The costs of pollution control should be borne by those who cause pollution and who have benefited from pollution activities, whereas:
- The benefits of pollution control should flow to those who have had to bear the external costs of pollution.
Internalizing external costs seems to meet these two requirements: a) The costs of pollution control are borne by stockholders and customers, both of whom benefit from the polluting activities of the firm; and b) The benefits of pollution control flow to those neighbors who once had to put up with the firm's pollution.
๐ก Why this matters: This shows that internalizing costs is not just efficient but also ethically sound, addressing fairness across income groups (distributive justice) and ensuring accountability (retributive and compensatory justice).
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents two main ethical remedies for pollution: internalizing costs by compensating victims and stopping pollution at its source through control devices. Internalizing costs is ethically justified by utilitarian principles, as it makes prices reflect true costs, and by justice principles, as it reverses the unfair flow of costs from the poor to the rich. The justice framework specifically requires that the costs of pollution control fall on those who benefit from pollution (stockholders and customers), while the benefits go to those who suffered the external costs (neighbors). A key caveat is that internalizing costs for basic goods like food could disproportionately burden the poor. For exam purposes, remember the distinction between the two remedies, the three types of justice (distributive, retributive, compensatory), and how internalizing costs satisfies each.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to utilitarians, what is the primary remedy for external costs of pollution?
- What is a key problem with internalizing pollution costs by compensating all those harmed?
- How does installing pollution-control devices help eliminate long-range worldwide effects of pollution?
- How does internalizing pollution costs reverse the flow of benefits between the rich and the poor?
- Who bears the costs of pollution control, and who receives the benefits, under the justice-based framework of internalizing external costs?
๐ Lecture 30 โ Costs and Benefits
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the ethical complexities of pollution control, focusing on the challenges of measuring costs and benefits through social audits and cost-benefit analysis. It explores environmental injustice, critiques utilitarian approaches, and introduces alternative frameworks including social ecology, eco-feminism, and the ethics of caring.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers environmental injustice and how pollution burdens the poor while benefiting stockholders. It explores cost-benefit analysis difficulties, social audit definitions and limitations, measurement challenges for pollution's uncertain effects, Thomas Klein's cost-benefit procedure, critiques of utilitarianism, and alternative approaches including absolute bans, social ecology, eco-feminism, and maximin rules.
๐ Lecture Summary
Environmental Injustice
If a firm pollutes, its stockholders benefit because their firm does not have to absorb the external costs of pollution; this leaves them with greater profits. Customers who purchase the firm's product also benefit because the firm does not charge them for all the costs involved in making the product. Therefore, the beneficiaries of pollution tend to be those who can afford to buy a firm's stock and its products. However, the external costs of pollution are borne largely by the poorโa phenomenon some have termed environmental injustice.
Cost and Benefits
The problems involved in getting accurate measurements of the benefits and costs of pollution control are illustrated by the difficulties businesses have encountered in trying to construct a social audit (a report of the social costs and social benefits of the firm's activities). How do we measure the costs and benefits of pollution control when they involve damages to human life or health? Measurement itself is also difficult when the effects of pollution are uncertain and therefore hard to predict. Getting accurate pollution measurements is sometimes nearly impossible, and the problem multiplies when there are a number of polluters in a single area. Measuring benefits is likewise difficult, which poses significant technical problems for utilitarian approaches to pollution.
Even where measurement is not a problem, another problem remains: Is it morally permissible to impose costs on unwilling or unknowing citizens? Can some unilaterally impose costs on others without their consent? Getting consent is tricky because many pollution problems involve information and risks that are extremely technical and difficult to understand. It is perhaps impossible in principle to get informed consent from a segment of the public on some complicated issues.
Because of these problems, some contend that utilitarianism cannot lead our pollution control policy. Perhaps absolute bans on pollution are more adequate. Some writers suggest that when risk cannot be reliably estimated, it is best to steer clear of such projects. Others maintain that we should identify those who will bear the risks and take steps to protect them.
It holds that until patterns of hierarchy and domination are changed, we will be unable to deal with environmental crises. In a system of hierarchy, one group holds power over another and members of the superior group are able to dominate those of the inferior group. Many thinkers have argued that the environmental crises we face are rooted in the social systems of hierarchy and domination that characterize our society. This view, now referred to as social ecology, holds that until these systems (such as racism, sexism, and social classes) are changed, we will be unable to deal adequately with the environment.
Eco-feminists, a related group of thinkers, see the key form of hierarchy connected to the destruction of the environment as the domination of women by men. They believe there are important connections between the domination of women and the domination of natureโpatterns of thinking which justify and perpetuate the subordination. This logic of domination sets up dualisms (artificial and natural, male and female) where one of the pair is seen as stronger and more important. To solve our ecological problems, we must first change these destructive modes of thinking.
According to the ethics of caring, the destruction of nature that has accompanied male domination must be replaced with caring for and nurturing our relationships with nature and other living things. Nature must be seen as an "other" that must be cared for, not tamed or dominated. These approaches are still too new and undeveloped to give us specific direction.
Thomas Klein's View
Thomas Klein summarized the procedure for cost-benefit analysis as follows:
- Identify costs and benefits of the proposed program and the person or sectors incurring or receiving them. Trace transfers.
- Evaluate the costs and benefits in terms of their value to beneficiaries and donors. The standard of measure is the value of each marginal unit to demanders and suppliers ideally captured in competitive prices. Useful refinements involve: a) Incorporating time values through the use of discount rate. b) Recognizing risk by factoring possible outcomes according to probabilities and, where dependent, probability trees.
- Add up costs and benefits to determine the net social benefit of a project or program.
๐ Definition โ Social Audit: A way of measuring, understanding, reporting and ultimately improving an organization's social and ethical performance. A social audit helps to narrow gaps between vision/goal and reality, between efficiency and effectiveness. It is a technique to understand, measure, verify, report on and to improve the social performance of the organization.
Social auditing creates an impact upon governance. It values the voice of stakeholders, including marginalized/poor groups whose voices are rarely heard. Social auditing is taken up for the purpose of enhancing local governance, particularly for strengthening accountability and transparency in local bodies. The key difference between development and social audit is that a social audit focuses on the neglected issue of social impacts, while a development audit has a broader focus including environment and economic issues, such as the efficiency of a project or program.
Those who advocate that a corporation should measure and report the social impacts of its activities have been forced to "recognize that the goal of measuring all impacts of all actions on all conditions and all publics, using standard techniques and units, considerably exceeds current capabilities and that compromises and modifications are inevitable." As a result of this inability to measure benefits, so-called social audits are usually nothing more than qualitative descriptions of what a firm is doing. Without definite quantitative measurement of the benefits deriving from its attempts to reduce pollution, a firm has no way of knowing whether its efforts are cost effective from a social point of view.
๐ก Why this matters: The inability to accurately measure social benefits means businesses cannot objectively determine if their pollution reduction efforts are socially cost-effective, undermining utilitarian justifications for environmental policies.
Measurement of Costs and Benefits
Measurement is also difficult when the effects of pollution are uncertain and, consequently, difficult to predict. Perhaps the major problem involved in obtaining the measurements needed to apply cost-benefit analysis to pollution problems is the problem of estimating and evaluating risk.
Many new technologies carry with them unknown degrees of risk to present and future generations. The use of nuclear technology, for example, involves some probability of damages to health and loss of life for present and future generations. We cannot use trial and error (a usual method for learning what the probabilities of an event are) to learn the risk of a nuclear accident.
These failures of measurement pose significant technical problems for utilitarian approaches to pollution. Additionally, the use of utilitarian cost-benefit analysis is sometimes based on assumptions inconsistent with people's moral rights. Advocates of utilitarian cost-benefit analysis sometimes assume that if the benefits of a certain technology or manufacturing process clearly outweigh its costs, then it is morally permissible to impose the process on unwilling citizens.
Conclusion
In view of all the problems raised by utilitarian approaches to pollution, it may be that alternative approaches are more adequate. It may be that the absolute bans on pollution that are still incorporated in many federal laws, and the rights theory on which those absolute bans rest, are, for the present at least, a more adequate approach to pollution issues than utilitarianism.
Finally, others suggest that when risks cannot be measured, the only rational procedure is to first assume that the worst will happen and then choose the option that will leave us best off when the worst happens (this is the so-called maximin rule of probability theory). It is unclear which, if any, of these alternative approaches should be adopted when utilitarian cost-benefit analysis fails.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that environmental injustice means the beneficiaries of pollution (stockholders and customers) tend to be wealthy, while external costs disproportionately burden the poor. Cost-benefit analysis faces three critical challenges: measuring uncertain pollution effects, obtaining informed consent from those affected, and quantifying social benefits through social audits. Thomas Klein's three-step cost-benefit procedure (identify, evaluate, calculate net social benefit) provides a structured framework, but its application is limited by measurement difficulties and moral concerns about imposing risks without consent. Alternative approaches include absolute bans, rights theory, social ecology (focusing on hierarchy/domination), eco-feminism (linking gender domination to nature's destruction), and the maximin rule (assuming worst-case outcomes when risks cannot be measured). Social audits currently remain largely qualitative due to the inability to measure all social impacts.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is environmental injustice, and who are the primary beneficiaries versus bearers of pollution's external costs?
- Describe Thomas Klein's three-step procedure for conducting a cost-benefit analysis.
- What are the key problems with using utilitarian cost-benefit analysis for pollution control decisions?
- According to eco-feminists, what is the relationship between the domination of women and the domination of nature?
- What is the maximin rule, and under what circumstances does the lecture suggest it should be applied?
๐ Lecture 31 โ Ethics of Care
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between social hierarchy and environmental destruction through the lens of social ecology, explores the ethics of caring as an alternative to domination, and addresses the ethical obligations present generations have toward conserving depletable resources for future generations. It critically analyzes whether future generations possess rights and what duties we have toward them.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers social ecology's argument that environmental crises stem from hierarchical social systems, the necessity of addressing social problems to solve ecological problems, the ethics of complementarity as an alternative to domination, eco-feminist critiques linking the domination of women to the domination of nature, conservation of depletable resources, and a philosophical debate about whether future generations have rights to the world's resources.
๐ Lecture Summary
ETHICS OF CARE
Social Ecology Many thinkers argue that environmental crises are rooted in social systems of hierarchy and domination. Social ecology holds that until those patterns are changed, we will be unable to deal with environmental crises. In a system of hierarchy, one group holds power over another, and members of the superior group dominate those of the inferior group. Examples include racism, sexism, social classes, property rights, capitalism, bureaucracies, and government mechanisms.
What defines social ecology as "social" is its recognition that nearly all present ecological problems arise from deep-seated social problems. Conversely, ecological problems cannot be resolved without dealing with problems within society. Economic, ethnic, cultural, and gender conflicts lie at the core of serious ecological dislocations.
The lecture cites recent examples: the Exxon oil spill at Prince William Sound, deforestation by Maxxam Corporation, and the James Bay hydroelectric project flooding Quebec's forests. These demonstrate that "the real battleground on which the ecological future of the planet will be decided is clearly a social one."
Separating ecological from social problems would misconstrue the sources of the environmental crisis. The hierarchical mentality and class relationships that permeate society give rise to the idea of dominating the natural world. Unless we realize that the present market society operates on the imperative of "grow or die," we will falsely blame technology or population growth while ignoring root causes such as trade for profit, industrial expansion, and corporate self-interest.
Social ecology calls for transforming our prevailing mentality of domination into one of complementarity, where we see our role in the natural world as creative, supportive, and appreciative of nonhuman life. A truly natural spirituality centers on humanity's ability to function as moral agents in diminishing suffering, engaging in ecological restoration, and fostering aesthetic appreciation of natural evolution.
๐ก Why this matters: The lecture argues that personal spiritual transformation alone is insufficientโcollective action and major social movements are needed to challenge the social sources of ecological crisis.
๐ Definition โ Social Ecology: The view that environmental crises are rooted in social systems of hierarchy and domination, and that ecological problems cannot be resolved without addressing social problems.
๐ Definition โ Ethics of complementarity: An ethical outlook where human beings complement nonhuman beings with their own capacities to produce a richer, creative, developmental wholeโnot as a dominant species but as a supportive one.
Eco-feminists see the key form of hierarchy connected to environmental destruction as the domination of women by men. They believe there are important connections between the domination of women and the domination of natureโpatterns of thinking that justify and perpetuate subordination. This logic of domination sets up dualisms (artificial/natural, male/female) where one is seen as stronger and more important.
According to the ethics of caring, the destruction of nature accompanying male domination must be replaced with caring for and nurturing relationships with nature. Nature must be seen as an "other" that must be cared for, not tamed or dominated.
The Ethics of Conserving Depletable Resources
Conservation refers to the saving or rationing of natural resources for later use. Conservation looks primarily to the futureโto limiting consumption now to have resources available for tomorrow.
Pollution control can be seen as a form of conservation, since pollution consumes air and water. However, most forms of pollution affect present generations, while the depletion of scarce resources lies far in the future. Consequently, our concern over resource depletion is primarily a concern for future generations.
๐ Definition โ Conservation: The saving or rationing of natural resources for later use, focusing on limiting present consumption to ensure future availability.
Rights of Future Generations
It might appear that we have an obligation to conserve resources for future generations because they have an equal right to limited resources. If future generations have an equal right, then by depleting resources, we are violating their rights.
Three main reasons are advanced against the claim that future generations have rights:
First: Future generations do not now exist and may never exist. We cannot hit, punish, injure, or treat them wrongly. Imaginary entities cannot be acted upon except in the imagination. Because future generations may never exist, they cannot "possess" rights.
Second: If future generations had rights, we might be led to the absurd conclusion that we must sacrifice our entire civilization. If each infinite number of future generations had an equal right to the world's oil supply, we would have to divide it equally among them allโour share being a few quarts at most. We would be put in the absurd position of shutting down Western civilization so each future person might possess a few quarts of oil.
Third: Someone has a certain right only if we know they have a certain interest that right protects. The purpose of a right is to protect the interests of the right holder, but we are virtually ignorant of what interests future generations will have.
John Rawls argues that while it is unjust to impose heavy burdens on present generations for the sake of the future, it is also unjust for present generations to leave nothing for the future. We should ask what we can reasonably expect they might want and, putting ourselves in their place, leave what we would like them to have left for us.
๐ Definition โ Rawls's principle of intergenerational justice: Justice requires that we hand over to our children a world in no worse condition than the one we received ourselves.
โญ Key Takeaways
Social ecology argues that environmental crises cannot be solved without addressing the underlying social hierarchies of racism, sexism, and class domination that create a mentality of domination over nature. The ethics of complementarity calls for transforming this mentality into one where humans act as supportive rather than dominant species, and eco-feminists specifically link the domination of women to the domination of nature. Conservation concerns the saving of depletable resources for future generations, but whether future generations have rights is debatedโcritics argue they don't exist, can't possess interests, and would lead to absurd sacrifices of civilization. John Rawls provides a balanced view: while present generations shouldn't bear crushing burdens, justice requires leaving a world no worse than the one we received.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main reasons critics give for denying that future generations have rights to the world's resources?
- According to social ecology, what is the relationship between social hierarchies and environmental destruction?
- What does John Rawls argue about the duties of present generations toward future generations?
- How does the "ethics of complementarity" differ from the "logic of domination" described by eco-feminists?
- Why does social ecology argue that focusing on technology or population growth as causes of environmental problems is misguided?
๐ Lecture 32 โ Ethics of Care-Utility and Conservation
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the moral obligations of present generations toward future generations, focusing on justice, utilitarian reasoning, and conservation. It critically evaluates market mechanisms for resource allocation and explores the influential warnings from the Club of Rome about environmental limits to growth, highlighting the tension between economic growth and sustainability.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers John Rawls' justice-based arguments for leaving the world no worse than we found it, utilitarian perspectives including Robin Attfield's Lockean principle, six market failures that undermine conservation for future generations, the Club of Rome's "Limits to Growth" predictions and their limitations, and contemporary debates about resource consumption disparities between wealthy and poor nations.
๐ Lecture Summary
Justice to Future Generations
John Rawls argues that it is unjust both to impose heavy burdens on present generations for the sake of the future AND for present generations to leave nothing for the future. Rawls proposes we ask what we can reasonably expect future generations might want, putting ourselves in their place and leaving what we would like them to have left for us. Justice requires handing over to our children a world in no worse condition than the one we received ourselves.
This method of ascertaining what earlier generations owe to later generations leads to the conclusion that justice demands merely that we hand to the next generation a situation no worse than we received from the generation before us.
๐ก Why this matters: Rawls' "veil of ignorance" approach applied across generations creates a clear baseline obligationโnot unlimited sacrifice, but maintenance of environmental quality.
Utilitarian Reasoning on Conservation
Rawls' conclusion is supported by utilitarian reasoning. Robin Attfield, a utilitarian, argued that utilitarianism favors the Lockean principle that "each should leave enough and as good for others." Attfield interpreted this to mean each generation must leave for future generations a world whose output capacity is no less than that generation received from previous generations.
๐ Definition โ Output Capacity: A generation must leave the world no less productive than it found, which does not necessarily mean leaving the same resources. Maintaining output can be achieved through conservation, recycling, or technological innovation.
Other utilitarians argue each generation has a duty to maximize future beneficial consequences and minimize future harmful consequences. Future consequences should be "discounted" in proportion to their uncertainty and distance in the future. These principles imply we have an obligation to avoid practices where harmful consequences for the immediate next generation certainly outweigh beneficial consequences for our own generation. Our responsibility for more distant futures is limited because we don't know what needs or technology they will have.
Market Failures in Conservation
We cannot rely on market mechanisms to ensure adequate conservation for future generations because the needs of future generations are so heavily discounted by markets they hardly affect prices at all.
Six reasons conspire to bring this about:
- Multiple access โ If several separate extractors can use a resource, shared access leads to depletion too fast (like several people with straws in one milkshake where each owner's private interest is taking it out as fast as possible).
- Time preferences and myopia โ Firms often have short time horizons under commercial competition, under-representing legitimate interests of future generations.
- Inadequate forecasting โ Present users may fail to foresee future developments due to lack of research interest and ability to discern future changes.
- Special influences โ Specific taxes and incentive devices may encourage overly rapid resource use.
- External effects โ Important externalities exist in resource use, so private users ignore major pollution and other external costs.
- Distribution โ Private market decisions are based on existing distribution of wealth and income; market demand more strongly reflects interests of the wealthy.
Conservation Shortfalls and Global Inequality
Many observers believe conservation measures are falling short. Some maintain future generations will have a much lower quality of life than our own. Industrialized nations may need to convert from growth-oriented technologies to more labor-intensive ones. Our entire economic system may have to abandon the goal of steadily increasing production because continual economic growth promises to degrade the quality of life for future generationsโdemand for depletable resources will continue to rise until resources simply run out, then living standards will decline sharply.
The Club of Rome predicted a catastrophic collapse of goods and services at some point in the middle of this century; by 2100 the world's population might drop below 1900 levels. The Worldwatch Institute concluded that even if the Club of Rome's timetables were off, their conclusions were substantially correct.
As energy supplies diminish, moral concerns intensify: the U.S. has only 6% of the world's population but consumes 25% of its energy, while 50% of the world's people get along with only 8%. Some seriously question whether high-consuming nations can be justified in using nonrenewable resources that others are too weak or frugal to use themselves.
The Limits to Growth Debate
In 1999, petrol prices were the lowest in over two decades with large oil reserves stored by governments and corporations, contrasting sharply with warnings from the early 1970s about a worldwide environmental crisis and resource shortages.
"Limits to Growth" (1972) sold twelve million copies in 37 languages. It stated that if world consumption patterns and population growth continued at the same high rates, the earth would strike its limits within a century. The message was that this outcome was not inevitableโpeople could change their policies, and the sooner the better.
The book was very controversial, jarring with the optimism of the 1950s and 1960sโa period of immense economic growth in both Western and Communist worlds with low unemployment. There was a general belief that another 1930s-type Depression could be avoided through government intervention, and that a standard Western formula for economic growth could apply throughout the Third World.
Very little attention had been paid to environmental consequences of economic growth. Capitalists believed the market would solve environmental problems (if resources were used too rapidly, prices would rise and usage would fall). Marxist dogma assured Communists that technology could solve all problems. Both systems regarded environmental criticism as nonsense.
Although "Limits to Growth" sold well, government policy-makers ignored much of the warning's essence. First ministries of the environment were established and tougher environmental laws introduced, but both political systems remained committed to the idea that growth was good and environmental consequences could be solved by administrative, legal and technological measures.
The Club of Rome's Origins and Methodology
The Club of Rome, a think-tank of scientists, economists, businesspeople, international civil servants, and politicians from five continents, began at the behest of Aurelio Peccei, an Italian businessperson based in Rome. In 1965, Peccei gave a speech on dramatic changes in the world relating to science and technology. Alexander King, a British scientist at OECD who had similar concerns, decided to meet Peccei to explore how these ideas could be followed up.
Peccei and King were not confident that either the market or technology could function as a way of solving environmental problems. They asked computer experts at MIT to examine what would happen if people continued to consume such high amounts of resourcesโthis study became the basis of "Limits to Growth."
The study had limitations stemming from the use of computer modeling, the first time it had been used for such an ambitious exercise. Success depends on both data quality and computer capabilities. In 1970, data collection methods were still rudimentaryโmany countries did not know their true population sizes. Even today, we are far from getting all the data needed for accurate models. Additionally, the model was limited by available computer technology and could only use a low number of equations. Computer modeling has become more sophisticated but still leaves much to be desired, as evident from government failures to predict economic growth.
๐ Definition โ Computer Modeling: A method using mathematical equations and data to simulate real-world scenarios; success depends on data quality and computational capability.
โญ Key Takeaways
The central ethical obligation to future generations requires leaving the world in no worse condition than we found itโa standard supported by both Rawlsian justice and utilitarian reasoning. Markets systematically fail to protect future interests due to six structural reasons including multiple access, short time horizons, and unequal distribution of wealth. The "Limits to Growth" debate remains unresolved despite technological improvements in modelingโthe fundamental question of whether the earth is approaching its carrying capacity persists. Significant global inequality in resource consumption (U.S. consuming 25% of energy with 6% of population) raises additional moral concerns about fair distribution. Students must understand that maintaining output capacity for future generations can be achieved through conservation, recycling, OR technological innovationโnot necessarily preserving the same resources.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What does John Rawls argue justice requires from present generations to future generations, and what specific method does he propose for determining this obligation?
- According to Robin Attfield's interpretation of the Lockean principle, what exactly must each generation leave for future generations, and what three methods can achieve this?
- List and briefly explain three of the six reasons why market mechanisms fail to ensure adequate conservation for future generations.
- What did the Club of Rome's "Limits to Growth" (1972) predict would happen if consumption patterns and population growth continued at their then-current rates, and when did they predict this would occur?
- What were the two main limitations of the computer modeling used in the "Limits to Growth" study, and why did these affect the credibility of its predictions?