π Lecture 6 β Introduction
π Overview: This lecture completes the classification of services by examining the final two dimensions: service package and delivery method. It then synthesizes the strategic benefits of all classification types and introduces the extended marketing mix (7 Ps) for services, highlighting why traditional 4 Ps are insufficient.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the service package classification and its relationship to equipment and competitive advantage, followed by the delivery method classification concerning distribution and site decisions. It then details the comprehensive benefits of each classification type for strategic management, concluding with an introduction to the extended services marketing mix of seven Ps focusing specifically on the People variable.
π Lecture Summary
Service package
The service package is the number of goods and services or a combination of both offered to customers. It can be one service and one good, multiple services and one good, multiple services and multiple goods, or any combination. The important dimension is what is delivered as standard individual products versus what is lumped together as more than standard.
A service package has a bearing on the kind of equipment needed to support the service, equipment's strength, its quality and maintenance. Equipment offers advantages in terms of reducing the variability of service offerings.
π Definition β Service Package: The number of goods and services or a combination of both that is offered to customers.
In a fast food restaurant, equipment quality has a direct bearing on the quality of food and accompanying services. A cola drink fountain provides for diet drinks and different dispensers have provisions for sauces of different tastes. A car manufacturer offering free service on a model without the right equipment to effectively service it will be at an extreme disadvantage.
In a health club, if the club cannot support the package with requisite quality equipment, the package has no meaning. Service package lets the differentiated feature come to the limelight. This classification takes business managers into the realm of product development that can be stand-alone products or extensions of existing ones with the objective of creating a sustainable competitive advantage.
Delivery method
Delivery method is all about distribution and customer outreach. Just like goods, services must be distributed through different sites. The decision on sites may result, after considering different variables, in a single site or multiple sites. The variables could be the type of consumption and the level of need to be close to the customer.
π Definition β Delivery Method: All about distribution and customer outreach; the decision on sites for service delivery.
A banking network may want to be close to as many neighborhoods and business centers as resources allow. A fine dining restaurant may not have the same distribution strategy to keep itself exclusive. A hotel may have just one site and deal with distribution by way of reservations, made keeping in view the rate of occupancy and available capacity. This classification relates issues concerning location, facility design, and operations.
Benefits of classification
Nature of organization: Classification lets us have a clear vision translated into mission, goals, and objectives. It lets us determine strengths and weaknesses, see resource capabilities, and surface limitations to decide which service products cannot be introduced. It gives confidence of having the right people with the right training.
Nature of service: Defines the product, its reason for being, and differentiated features. It shows opportunities to introduce new features and decide on points of difference with conviction and the right position given the target audience.
Nature of service dictates the kind of training programs needed and makes it mandatory where we need high efficiency, productivity, and operational excellence. It also lets us price the service product.
Customer relationship: Lets us have the right human resource and accentuates training programs.
Nature of demand: Lets us go into pricing and promotions and actuates communication campaigns. It lets us rationalize the product line by introducing new products for new segments and expand market. It lets us optimize resources through balancing between supply and demand.
Service package: Lets us get into promotion of specific products sold as packages along with the core product. It lets us look into the need for certain equipment to maintain competitiveness and thus into capital investments.
Delivery method: Lets us get into business development and strategies of growth. Investment decisions are taken as a direct result of such strategies.
Overall, classification lets you develop the right products, position them correctly, price them smartly, distribute them effectively with operational excellence at optimal costs and decent profitability.
π‘ Why this matters: These strategic considerations boil down to one fact: marketing of services is not radically different in fundamentals. What is required is to develop an adaptable mechanism to a different environment, keeping in view services characteristics. All that is required is approaching the area in light of characteristics so that relevant additions and adaptations can be brought about.
Marketing mix of services
The traditional 4 Ps (product, price, promotion, place) have been found too limited in their application to services. The limiting factors are highlighted by the basic characteristics when analyzed in light of the classification scheme. Experts have added three variables to complete the services mix:
- People
- Physical evidence
- Processes
The fundamental elements of marketing mix of services therefore have seven Ps.
People
People: All human actors who play a part in service delivery and thus influence the buyer's perceptions: namely, the firm's personnel, the customer, and other customers in the service environment.
π Definition β People: All human actors who play a part in service delivery and thus influence the buyer's perceptions: the firm's personnel, the customer, and other customers in the service environment.
Because of intangibility, especially for pure services, people delivering services take on added significance. Their presence makes the intangible tangible. The encounter of those people with customers leaves an impression and provides signals about the nature and quality of the service. Overall behavior along with appearance affects customers seeking services.
This may not be the case for goods. Customers are interested in goods having good quality regardless of who prepared them or how they behave. For services, everything revolves around people who are the service providers. Whether it is a food outlet, bank, health care unit, or consultancy, the importance of good behavior and appearance takes hold according to perceived standards.
Since people offer solutions by selling services, they must be carefully selected and trained. Organizations invest in minimizing variability by introducing systems and procedures that ensure standardization while maintaining balance between standardization and empowerment.
Motivated employees who want to make decisions for the good of customers look forward to being empowered. Companies decide where to strike the balance between standardization and empowerment. A motivated employee may want to serve a customer by going out of the way but feel restricted by established procedural limits.
People are important not only for delivering services but also as customers affecting delivery. Intelligent and well-exposed customers can get better service. Disgruntled customers in a bank or public utility office are bound to affect perceptions of customers around them waiting to be served.
β Key Takeaways
Services must be classified according to their basic characteristics to develop appropriate strategies for differentiation, positioning, communication, promotions, productivity, efficiency, human resource solutions, supply/demand adjustment, distribution, and pricing. The service package classification links directly to equipment needs, product development, and competitive advantage. The delivery method classification addresses distribution, site decisions, and business growth strategies. The traditional 4 Ps marketing mix is insufficient for services, requiring three additional variables: People, Physical evidence, and Processes to create the 7 Ps framework. People are a critical marketing mix element because they make intangible services tangible, and their behavior, appearance, and empowerment directly influence customer perceptions and service quality.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is a service package and how does it relate to equipment and competitive advantage?
- What variables determine whether a service uses a single site or multiple sites for delivery?
- List the five strategic areas (from the diagram) that classification facilitates for managers.
- What are the three additional Ps added to the traditional marketing mix for services, and why are they needed?
- Why are "people" considered a critical element of the services marketing mix, and what is the balance that companies must strike regarding their service employees?
π Lecture 7 β Services Marketing
π Overview: This lecture completes the 7Ps framework for services marketing by exploring the final two variables: Physical Evidence and Processes. It explains how tangible cues help overcome service intangibility and how streamlined processes build customer trust, ultimately arguing why the 3 additional Ps (People, Physical Evidence, Processes) are essential and why marketing must integrate with operations and HR.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and dual forms of Physical Evidence (communication materials and servicescape), the definition and customer-focused nature of Processes with real-world examples (PIA, visa applications, cell phone companies, Bank Alfalah), the Importance of 7 Ps with reasons for the extended marketing mix, and the critical Implication for marketing β the necessary integration of marketing, operations, and HR functions due to service inseparability.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture focuses on the remaining two variables of the marketing mix for services: Physical Evidence and Processes, after having learned about People.
Physical evidence: The environment in which the service is delivered and where the firm and the customers interact, and any tangible components that facilitate performance or communication of the service
Because services are intangible, customers cannot judge them until purchase, creating high perceived risk. Companies create tangible evidence to convincingly sell intangible products. Physical evidence takes two shapes: first, it appears as brochures, signage, business cards, letterheads, and the design and colors of invoices and bills. Second, it is reflected by the physical facility where transactions take place β the βservicescapeβ.
π‘ Why this matters: Companies work hard on creating a servicescape that attracts attention and communicates company values and the right image. In Pakistan, servicescape has played a positive role in banks, courier services, cell phone companies, fast food restaurants, and retail stores. Service sellers use creative techniques from architectural designs to colors and well-trained people. Just as packaging signals the quality of a tangible good, the tangible evidence associated with a service provides service quality cues.
π Definition β Physical evidence: The environment in which the service is delivered and where the firm and the customers interact, and any tangible components that facilitate performance or communication of the service.
Processes: The actual procedures, mechanisms, and flow of activities by which the service is delivered β the service delivery and the operating systems
Good processes serve customers with the goal of satisfying their needs and are added evidence by which customers judge a service. The level of complexity or simplicity reflects the service and organizationβs outlook. Processes should reflect the business positioning. A customer-focused process should be simple and efficient, facilitating employees to deliver efficiently and enabling customers to feel their decision was correct.
π Definition β Processes: The actual procedures, mechanisms, and flow of activities by which the service is delivered β the service delivery and the operating systems.
π Example: Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) introduced online facility for reservations and seat selection, simplifying and modernizing the process, creating further franchise for their brand. π Example: A tedious visa application process gives the impression of a difficult and unfriendly country; a simple one creates an impression of a friendly country. π Example: A cell phone company with lengthy requirements before allotting a number is perceived as complicated; Bank Alfalahβs VISA credit card success owes to its simple requirements and customer-friendly online technology support.
The basic objective of a process remains provision of a service without unnecessary bottlenecks. Streamlining the delivery of a service should take precedence over other considerations.
Importance of 7 Ps
Services use seven and not four Ps, with People, Physical evidence, and Processes being the additions. The mix is a bag of tools that marketers use to shape services through development, positioning, pricing, distributing, and promoting. The classification scheme guides identifying the variables and their intensity. Variables are further divided into a host of ingredients (e.g., promotion mix includes advertising, promotions, PR, event management). Experts concluded that any number and mixes within the traditional four Ps were not enough.
The reasons for the extended mix are:
- Existence of services is intangible
- Defining quality in services and creating/maintaining benchmarks is different
- Physical distribution is an exchange function, whereas in services, distribution (despite multiple locations) is a facilitating function β marketing and operations happen at same time and place
- The promotional difference stems from inseparability where sellers are promoters at the place of production
Implication for marketing
All variables, especially the additional ones, require marketingβs integration with operations and HR. Variables from different departments (people and processes) get integrated because production and marketing of service take place at the same place. This can only be done with the help of the additional three Ps to have the desired customer focus.
π Example: A hotel or bank manager must daily ensure sales, customer satisfaction, smooth operations, and productive/motivated employees. This spans marketing, operations, and HR which must act in an integrated way during service deliveries, highlighting inseparability and marketing's role as a facilitating function. Failure of any function immediately affects others and creates dissatisfied customers. Disgruntled customers affect others present at the servicescape.
Well-synchronized functioning leads to creating value β a two-way street where the customer also offers value if retained. This is different for tangible goods, where different departments may not need integration at the same time and place. A tangible good can be replaced at any point, signifying separation of functions. Retaining customers is the need of the time β we live in an age of relationships where customers add to companyβs revenues.
π Figure 8 β Integration for Services: Marketing, Operations, and HR all converge on the Customer at the same time and place. π Figure 9 β Integration for Manufactured Goods: Marketing, Operations, and HR each connect to the Customer separately (not integrated).
Summary
The lecture concludes three additional Ps of the marketing mix for services and highlights their importance as strategic variables. The mix should be drawn as tools most appropriate for service development and delivery in light of characteristics and classification scheme. Another important lesson is the need for marketing to integrate into operations and HR to effectively deal with inseparability. The ultimate goal is to retain customers and have them spend more in repeat purchasing.
β Key Takeaways
Physical evidence (communication materials and servicescape) provides tangible cues that reduce customer risk and signal service quality. Processes must be simple, efficient, and customer-focused to build trust and reflect business positioning. The 7Ps framework (adding People, Physical Evidence, and Processes to the traditional 4Ps) is essential because of service intangibility, unique quality benchmarks, the facilitating nature of service distribution, and inseparability. Most critically, marketing must be integrated with operations and human resources functions because service production and consumption happen simultaneously; failure in any function immediately impacts customer satisfaction. The ultimate goal of this integrated approach is customer retention through relationship marketing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main forms of Physical Evidence in services marketing?
- Why is a simple, customer-focused process important for customer retention?
- List the four reasons why the 7Ps extended marketing mix is necessary for services.
- Explain why marketing must integrate with operations and HR in a service firm. What service characteristic drives this need?
- Using a real example (e.g., a bank or hotel), describe how a failure in one function (e.g., operations) can immediately affect other functions and customer satisfaction.
π Lecture 8 β The Gap Model in Services Marketing
π Overview: This lecture focuses on understanding why a gap exists between what customers expect from a service and what they actually experience. It introduces the "provider gap" model with four distinct levels and explains how these gaps lead to the "customer gap." The lecture also explores the continuum of evaluation, explaining how consumers assess goods versus services using search, experience, and credence qualities.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the provider gap and its four levels: the gap between consumer expectations and management perceptions, between management perceptions and service quality standards, between standards and delivery, and between delivery and communicated promises. It then introduces the customer gap as the overall outcome of provider gaps. Finally, it discusses the continuum of evaluation, differentiating goods and services based on search, experience, and credence qualities and how these affect consumer evaluation processes.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
The main objective is to understand the gap between customer expectations and perceptions (experiences). Customers develop expectations, evaluate the service they experience, and often find a gap between the two. Zeithaml and Bitner call this the "provider gap." There are four levels of this gap, all explaining why service firms fail to deliver the quality customers expect.
The provider gap and its levels
Level 1 β Gap between consumer expectation and management perception: Management does not always correctly perceive what customers expect. For example, an insurance company may perceive customers want lower premiums, while customers actually expect quick settlement of claims. This shows the company's inability to position its service product as customers want it.
π Definition β Provider Gap Level 1: The gap between what customers expect and what management thinks customers expect.
Level 2 β Gap between management perception and service quality standards: Management may correctly perceive customer wants but fails to specify the right standards to deliver the service accordingly. A fast food restaurant may not standardize procedures or train employees to deliver a uniform product everywhere. Variability in delivering the right, standardized product causes this gap.
π Formula: Correct perception + Failure to set standards β Level 2 Gap
Level 3 β Gap between service quality standards and delivery: Even with correct standards, employees may not translate them into desired actions. This can happen because of not hiring the right personnel, not training them appropriately, or because employees are not motivated to follow laid-down standards.
π Example: A restaurant has a standard procedure for greeting customers within 30 seconds, but employees ignore this because they are not motivated or properly trained. The standard exists but is not delivered.
Level 4 β Gap between service delivery and communicated promises: This gap emerges when everything seems in place β understanding of expectations, standards, and procedures β yet delivery falls short of what was promised. Companies should under no circumstances promise more than they can deliver.
π‘ Why this matters: Even if delivery meets internal standards, exaggerated external promises create a perception of failure in customers' minds.
π Example: An insurance company claims it settles claims within 24 hours, but actually settles them in 48 hours. Though still faster than competitors, the company falls short on its promise, creating a negative gap.
The customer gap
The provider gap automatically leads to the "customer gap." Closing this gap is the central challenge of services marketing. The closer customer evaluation is to expectation, the narrower the gap. If evaluation matches expectation exactly, there is no gap β but this requires 100% perfect delivery, which is rarely achieved. Services must be designed with their unique characteristics in mind to minimize the customer gap.
π Definition β Customer Gap: The difference between customer expectations and their perceptions of the service actually delivered. It is the overall gap that results from the four provider gaps.
Search qualities, Experience qualities, Credence qualities
To understand why the customer gap exists, we must understand differences in how consumers evaluate goods versus services. These differences are based on three types of product properties:
Search qualities: These relate to tangible goods and allow consumers to easily evaluate attributes before purchase. Attributes include looks, colors, feel, smell, size, and variations. Tangible goods are high in search qualities β for example, evaluating a bottle of juice, a television set, or a car before purchase.
π Definition β Search qualities: Attributes that consumers can evaluate before purchasing a product. These are dominant in tangible goods.
Experience qualities: These qualities cannot be determined unless the consumer actually experiences the service. Services are high in experience qualities β for example, you cannot evaluate a restaurant or hotel service until you experience it.
π Definition β Experience qualities: Attributes that can only be evaluated during or after consumption of the service.
Credence qualities: These are attributes that cannot be easily evaluated even after buying and consuming the service. Consumers may not be able to technically assess the service long after it was rendered. Examples include repair and maintenance of industrial equipment, household goods, medical diagnosis, and consultancy.
π Definition β Credence qualities: Attributes that consumers find difficult to evaluate even after experiencing the service.
π‘ Why this matters: The more intangible a product, the more it is dominated by experience and credence qualities, making evaluation more difficult and increasing the risk of a customer gap.
Continuum of Evaluation
Zeithaml and Bitner present a continuum of evaluation showing how different products are evaluated. On the left are products high in search qualities (clothing, furniture, houses, autos) which are easy to evaluate. In the middle are products high in experience qualities (restaurant meals, vacations). On the far right are products high in credence qualities (insurance, television repair, consultancy, auto repair, medical diagnosis) which are difficult to evaluate. As consumers move from left to right, they need to experience the product to assess it, and for far-right products, they must wait even after experiencing to arrive at an evaluation.
π Formula: Tangible goods β High in search qualities β Easy to evaluate Intangible services β High in experience & credence qualities β Difficult to evaluate
β Key Takeaways
The gap model explains why service quality often falls short of customer expectations through four distinct provider gaps: misperception of expectations, failure to set correct standards, failure to deliver according to standards, and over-promising in communications. These four gaps together create the overall customer gap, which is the central challenge for services marketing. The continuum of evaluation shows that services, being intangible, rely more on experience and credence qualities than search qualities, making them harder for consumers to evaluate before purchase. Understanding these evaluation processes is essential for designing services that minimize the gap between expectations and perceptions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four levels of the provider gap according to Zeithaml and Bitner?
- How does the level 2 gap differ from the level 3 gap?
- What is the customer gap and how does it relate to the provider gaps?
- Explain the difference between search qualities, experience qualities, and credence qualities with an example of each.
- Why are services more difficult to evaluate than tangible goods, according to the continuum of evaluation?
π Lecture 9 β SERVICES MARKETING
π Overview: This lecture examines the complete purchase process customers go through when buying services, which is more complex than for goods. It explains the three phasesβpre-purchase, service encounter, and post-purchaseβfocusing on the factors influencing decision-making and the risks customers perceive. Understanding this process is critical for marketers to close the customer gap and deliver satisfying service experiences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces the three-phase purchase process for services: pre-purchase phase (internal factors, external factors, firm-produced factors, and perceived risks), the service encounter phase (interaction, quality, and satisfaction), and the post-purchase phase. It details seven types of perceived risks (performance, financial, time loss, opportunity, psychological, social, and physical) and explains the role theory and script theory as factors underlying service encounter quality.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction - The purchase process of services
To understand the customer gap and the evaluation process of services, we must first understand the phases of the purchase process customers go through for services, which is more complex than for goods. The process comprises three phases: pre-purchase phase, service encounter, and post-purchase phase.
Pre-purchase phase
This phase lays the foundation for the primary decision about purchasing a service. The decision is influenced by four categories of factors: internal factors, external factors, firm-produced factors, and perceived risks.
π Internal factors β relate to a customer's past experience with a particular service, references from others, and exposure to promotional materials. Good past experience automatically lays a positive ground for re-purchasing; negative experience does the opposite.
π External factors β include competitive offerings available to a potential customer, word-of-mouth communications, and social context. Social context comes into play when customers make decisions keeping societal influences and pressures in view (e.g., choosing a fast food restaurant for a quick lunch versus one to entertain someone in style).
π Firm-produced factors β include pricing, promotions, and distribution (service availability). Close proximity of the point of sale and hours of operation add to the impact of good pricing and promotions. ATMs by banks offer benefits of multiple locations and liberty of hours for cash withdrawal.
π Perceived risk β the exposure of the consumer to some kind of loss, damage, or injury. Seven types of risks affect consumer decision-making:
- Performance risk: The risk that the service may not perform and offer the benefit for which it is purchased. Example: A catering service claiming to sell high quality Chinese food may offer food not having the typical Chinese taste and looks.
- Financial risk: Monetary loss incurred by the purchaser of a service. Example: A logistics company failing to arrange transportation, causing the buyer huge losses for not being able to distribute merchandise on time.
- Time loss risk: The risk associated with inactivity or belated activities on the buyer's side as a consequence of seller's inefficiencyβtime lost because of service failure.
- Opportunity risk: Arises when a customer chooses one opportunity over another and the chosen one turns out to be a failure. Example: A traveler opting for a well-publicized train service instead of air travel may regret the loss of opportunity.
- Psychological risk: The chance that the service bought does not fit into the self-concept of an individual. Example: A bride feeling frustrated at not getting beauty enhancement from a beautician.
- Social risk: Involved in getting a service that may not get the approval of others. Example: A catering company not managing a wedding event well, leading to disapproval from friends and relatives.
- Physical risk: Occurs when buying a service that may be prone to offering physical danger to one's life. Example: Getting a major operation.
π‘ Why this matters: All seven risks can be present simultaneously. Service marketers must develop strategies to minimize each type of risk during the pre-purchase phase.
The service encounter
This is the second phase where actual encounter takes place between the buyer and the service provider. The buyer gets to the point of sale (physical evidence) and interacts with the provider to have the service completed. During the encounter, production and marketing happen simultaneously, and the characteristic of inseparability comes into play.
Interaction, Quality, and Satisfaction relationship (Figure 14): The quality of interaction between the customer and the provider defines the quality of service rendered. The higher the level of interaction quality, the higher the customer satisfaction. It is a sliding scaleβhigher interaction quality leads to higher satisfaction and vice versa.
π‘ Why this matters: Encounters can be full of variability. Service providers seek technology support (ATMs, automated voice-assisted systems) to handle high volumes, maintain consistency, and fulfill the interaction process.
Factors underlying encounter quality:
- Role theory: Both buyer and seller must understand their roles. The seller must be fully competent, and the buyer should be intelligently aware of the solution they seek. Example: A client must be able to explain to the market research company why they want a particular research design; the seller must be professional enough to present a study worthy of the client's expectations.
π Example: A client who has clear understanding of their problems and has defined the hypothesis can be effective in getting the best out of the serving research company. The quality of service and ensuing evaluation of satisfaction determine service quality.
- Script theory: An extension of role theory that accentuates the best way roles should be played by both service provider and customer. Scripts are detailed actions played by both parties, derived from a series of behavioral experience and communication. Scripts should be so clear that both parties understand their roles, and it is the responsibility of the service seller to script the roles for both provider and customer.
π Example: In a fast food restaurant, providers must make first-time customers comfortable without customers asking what to do to place the order. The script of the provider results from standardized procedures that become routine activities executed automatically and instinctively.
π‘ Why this matters: Any change in the provider's script must be done with a view to a subsequent change in the customer's script. Required numbers of new personnel must be placed at the facility to guide customers without causing embarrassment.
β Key Takeaways
The purchase process for services has three distinct phasesβpre-purchase, service encounter, and post-purchaseβeach requiring different marketing strategies. Seven types of perceived risk (performance, financial, time loss, opportunity, psychological, social, and physical) dominate the pre-purchase phase and must be minimized by sellers. The service encounter phase is defined by interaction quality, which directly determines customer satisfaction in a sliding scale relationship. Role theory emphasizes that both buyer and seller must understand and competently perform their roles for quality service. Script theory extends this by requiring that service providers develop standardized, routinized procedures that clearly script the behavior of both provider and customer, ensuring comfortable and consistent service delivery.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three phases of the purchase process for services, and why is this process more complex than for goods?
- List and briefly explain the seven types of perceived risk that affect consumer decision-making during the pre-purchase phase.
- How does the relationship between interaction, quality, and satisfaction work during the service encounter?
- What is the difference between role theory and script theory in the context of service encounter quality?
- Why is it the responsibility of the service seller to script the roles for both the provider and the customer, and what happens if scripts change?
π Lecture 10 β Introduction
π Overview: This lecture continues the encounter phase of the customer's evaluation process and then delves into the third, final phase of post-purchase. It completes the behavioral model of evaluation and introduces the next important model of consumer behavior that relates to customer expectations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the encounter phase, focusing on factors like the service environment, service personnel, and support services. It then explains the post-purchase phase, including evaluation of service quality, customer satisfaction, the attribution theory, and future behavior. The lecture concludes by introducing the model of consumer expectations, detailing ideal, desired, adequate, and predicted service levels.
π Lecture Summary
Encounter
A few factors customers consider seriously to assess the quality of their interaction with the company are as follows.
-
The service environment: This deals with the tangible side of the service, meaning the evidence in the form of the facility, its atmosphere, presence of other customers, their behaviors, equipment, and office decor. All the elements of the environment have an impact on the customerβs way of evaluating the service during the purchase and after the purchase.
-
Service personnel: Businesses should hire the right personnel, train them well according to standardized scripts for them to interact with customers qualitatively. Incentives and compensation systems should be introduced to achieve this goal.
-
Support services: Support services basically are the ones required to make the final service to customers a quality product. Support comes not only through procedures, but also equipment. The personnel handling equipment (restaurant equipment, information technology equipment, janitorial or electrical) must be fully trained to keep their equipment in the highest order of quality. Also, it is the responsibility of the service seller to provide their support staff with all the necessary tools and equipment.
Post-purchase phase
During the post-purchase phase, customers evaluate their experiences after receiving the service. If their expectations were met, they would rate the service as quality service; if the expectations were not met, leaving a customer gap, then they would rate the service as having poor quality. Good quality service brings satisfaction, strengthens loyalty to the firm, elicits positive word-of-mouth and referrals; poor quality service draws negative word-of-mouth, switching of seller, and dissatisfaction.
There are a few factors that come into play while customers evaluate the post-purchase phase:
-
Evaluation of service quality: Customers evaluate a service from two different angles. They look at it from the result point of view, which is the technical evaluation. If the result is what the customer wanted, then technically the service is sound. They also evaluate a service from the standpoint of how well they were treated during the delivery of service, which is the functional evaluation. A restaurant offering high quality food with unfriendly service is high on technical score, but low on the functional side. According to Clow and Kurtz, a deficiency on either of the two components results in poor evaluation of the service received. π Definition β Technical evaluation: Evaluation based on the result or outcome of the service for the customer. π Definition β Functional evaluation: Evaluation based on how well the customer was treated during the service delivery.
-
Customer satisfaction: According to Clow and Kurtz, satisfaction or dissatisfaction is an episodic measure, for it relates to the last experience with the service. They go on to say that service quality is a global evaluation of all the past experiencesβthe cumulative effect of them all. An episodic experience carries importance in that it has the potential to alter the global evaluation. In case of a negative experience by a customer, the company must try to compensate that negativity in some form β a discount, free offer, or some inducement for future to improve the episodic measure. π Definition β Episodic measure: An evaluation based on the customer's most recent (single) experience with the service. π Definition β Service quality: A global evaluation based on the cumulative effect of all past experiences. π‘ Why this matters: A single bad experience (episodic) can damage an established positive reputation (global), making recovery efforts crucial.
-
Attribution theory: The process of deciding the cause of a service failure is called βattribution theoryβ. Customers evaluate the reasons for failure and then attribute those to the failure. If they think that the failure was beyond the control of the seller (e.g., bad weather disturbing flight schedule), then they attribute the failure to uncontrollable circumstances. However, if they think that the cause was well within controllable limits and could have been averted, then they attribute the failure to the seller. π Definition β Attribution theory: The process customers use to decide the cause of a service failure.
-
Future behavior: Future behavior is a function of satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Of high significance is empirical evidence that dissatisfied customers are more prone to talk about the poor quality of service to many more people than satisfied ones who refer a good quality service only to a few people. The lesson for service sellers is to make sure that nothing should go wrong in delivering the service. The compound effect of the negative word-of-mouth communication results in a lot more lost customers than one can imagine. Satisfied customers, on the other hand, come back for the service, show their loyalty, give referrals, and keep the service alive for future business.
The three phases of purchase behavior (pre-purchase, encounter, post-purchase) reveal that the process of consumer decision about whether or not to buy a service is complex. Tangible goods, because of their physical attributes, make it easy for consumers to make a decision; intangible services present many challenging considerations before a decision is made. Customers evaluate a service during the encounter and decide whether to continue or discontinue, and the evaluation continues even after consumption, which is the most serious stage of evaluation.
The model of consumer expectations
Expectations are defined as βpretrial beliefs consumers have about the performance of a service that are used as the standard or reference against which service performance is judgedβ. There are different levels of expectations of consumers:
π Definition β Expectations: Pretrial beliefs consumers have about the performance of a service, used as a standard or reference against which service performance is judged.
-
Ideal service level: This is the level of expectation that customers wish for. Wishfulness always carries elements of improbable occurrences. Therefore, customers know that a service may not come up to this idealistic level. Example: A courier service delivering business documents at sharp 9:00 AM every morning.
-
Desired service level: A level below the idealistic point is what customers consider as the desired level of service. This is the level that customers want performed by a service seller while they buy a service. Example: The courier may deliver packages daily between 9:00 and 10:00 AM, and that is the time you want them delivered.
-
Adequate service level: This level of service is the minimum level that consumers tolerate from a service seller. Any service performed below this level is not acceptable. Example: You may accept the service delivering your packages latest until 11:00 AM, beyond which time you may consider changing the service seller.
-
Predicted service level: This level of service is the one that customers expect from the seller. Therefore, this varies between the ideal service and adequate service levels. The reason for variation stems from the level of demand a service is enjoying at a particular point in time. Example: A power utility company will fix an outage more quickly in pleasant weather than in peak summer months. What is clear is that no service should be beyond the two levels of ideal service level and adequate service level.
π Concept: The Zone of Tolerance is the range between the desired service level and the adequate service level, where customers are willing to accept variations in service performance.
Figure 16 illustrates the hierarchy: Ideal service level β Desired service level β (Zone of Tolerance) β Adequate service level β Predicted service level.
β Key Takeaways
The post-purchase phase is crucial as it determines customer satisfaction or dissatisfaction, which directly influences loyalty, word-of-mouth, and future purchases. Service quality is evaluated on two dimensions: technical (the outcome) and functional (how the customer was treated). Satisfaction is an episodic measure based on the last experience, while service quality is a global measure of all experiences. The attribution theory explains how customers assign blame for service failures, whether to the seller or uncontrollable circumstances. Finally, customer expectations exist at four levelsβideal, desired, adequate, and predictedβwith the zone of tolerance being the acceptable range between desired and adequate service.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five factors customers consider during the encounter phase of service evaluation?
- In the post-purchase phase, what is the difference between technical evaluation and functional evaluation?
- According to Clow and Kurtz, what is the difference between customer satisfaction (episodic measure) and service quality (global evaluation)?
- Explain the attribution theory and how a customer's belief about the cause of a failure affects their future behavior.
- What are the four levels of consumer expectations, and what does the "zone of tolerance" represent?