๐ Lecture 20 โ Research for Upward Communication & Relationship Marketing
๐ Overview: This lecture explores two critical strategies for closing the gap between customer expectations and management perceptions. It first examines how upward communication channels bring frontline customer insights to top management, then introduces relationship marketing as a strategic shift from transactional thinking to long-term customer retention and value creation.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with research for upward communication, detailing techniques like executive visits and listening systems. It then explains the importance of communication with intermediate and internal customers, and how employee suggestions reinforce service benchmarks. Next, it introduces relationship marketing as a paradigm shift from acquisition to retention, covering its three essential elements, primary goals, and benefits for both customers and firms.
๐ Lecture Summary
Research for Upward Communication
This is communication generated to help top management understand customers by having a firsthand feel of encounters and interactions. In larger companies, managers are constrained from direct contact, so upward communication is essential. Good companies institute practices to bring management closer to customers. Popular techniques include:
- Executives visit customers: To understand requirements and convey commitment.
- Executive Listening: Using toll-free numbers to seek information and complaints (e.g., mobile companies and banks).
- Communication with Intermediate and Internal Customers: Understanding requirements of agents, dealers, distributors (intermediate) and training, coaching, motivating employees (internal) enables them to serve end customers properly.
The service to internal employees includes flexibility on working hours and rewards, but the flow of information from frontline providers is invaluable for strategic direction. Communication is also research, and combined with customer-focused research, provides a wealth of information.
Three different directions that provide upward communication are graphically illustrated as figure 33 (Marketing research, Customer to management, Management to management).
Another factor motivating employees to communicate directly and freely depends on top management's ability to listen to and implement employees' suggestions. If employees see their suggestions implemented effectively, they become more sensitive to customers' needs and deliver service more effectively, raising their own benchmarks. This creates an organization that is a cohesive whole geared toward satisfying customers.
๐ Definition โ Upward Communication: Communication generated for understanding of customers by top management, who in larger companies are constrained to have a first-hand feel of encounters and interactions with customers.
๐ Definition โ Reinforced Benchmarks: The raising of service standards as a result of employees seeing their suggestions implemented effectively by top management, leading to more sensitive customer service.
Relationship Marketing
"Relationship marketing" is a step further than "transactional marketing". The conclusion of the commercial deal that marks transactional marketing has to be further grown and nurtured. Bringing in new customers is expensive, requiring promotions, discounts, and advertising. Relationships, if kept by continually offering quality and satisfaction, eliminate those costs and result in overall economy.
It is a paradigm shift that focuses on relationship and retention, which is a step further from acquisition and transaction. It works both for providers and customers. It demands the following three elements:
- A new mind set (retention vs. acquisition)
- A different organizational culture
- A better reward system โ Many organizations offer incentives for bringing in new customers but pay little attention to staff efforts to keep customers.
Goals of Relationship Marketing: The primary goal is to build a base of loyal and committed customers who are more profitable. Companies focus on:
- Attracting customers
- Retaining customers
- Enhancement of relationships
Once customers are attracted, they stay if offered quality consistently. Loyal customers become a growth potential source, automatically attracting new customers who can become committed. This owes to enhanced relationships resulting in better market share and profitability.
Benefits for Customers and Firms: Customers stay loyal to companies offering better value. Value is a trade-off between what customers "give" and what they "get". "Give" is the monetary side, while "get" is a function of quality, satisfaction, and other benefits. When customers think what they get outweighs what they give, they tend to stay and nurture the relationship.
๐ Definition โ Relationship Marketing: A strategic orientation that focuses on building and nurturing long-term relationships with customers, emphasizing retention over acquisition, requiring a new mindset, organizational culture, and reward system.
๐ Formula: Value = What customers "get" - What customers "give" โ Value is the trade-off where "get" combines quality, satisfaction, and benefits, while "give" is the monetary cost. When what customers receive outweighs what they pay, they remain loyal.
๐ก Why this matters: Relationship marketing reduces acquisition costs, builds loyal customer bases, and creates sustainable competitive advantage through enhanced customer value.
โญ Key Takeaways
You must remember that upward communication is vital for top management to get firsthand customer insights, especially in large organizations where direct contact is limited. The three techniquesโexecutive visits, listening systems, and communication with intermediate/internal customersโall work simultaneously. Relationship marketing represents a fundamental paradigm shift from transactional thinking to retention-focused strategy, requiring a new mindset, culture, and reward system. Value is the key driver of customer loyalty, defined as the trade-off between what customers give (money) and what they get (quality, satisfaction, benefits). Finally, when employees see their suggestions implemented, they reinforce service benchmarks, creating a cycle of continuous improvement.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three popular techniques for achieving upward communication, and how does each help close Gap 1?
- Explain the concept of "reinforced benchmarks" and how employee suggestions contribute to higher service standards.
- What are the three essential elements required for implementing relationship marketing, and why is a reward system specifically important?
- What is the primary goal of relationship marketing, and what three focus areas help achieve it?
- How is value defined in relationship marketing, and why does it determine whether customers stay loyal?
๐ Lecture 21 โ The lecture continues with the benefits of relationship marketing both for the customer and the firm.
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the multifaceted benefits of relationship marketing for both customers and firms, establishing that such relationships yield confidence, social, and special treatment benefits for customers, while providing firms with lower costs, free advertising, and retained staff. It then lays the foundational prerequisites for building these relationships, focusing on core service quality, segmentation, and the strategic understanding needed to identify and target the right customer segments.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture first details the benefits of relationship marketing, distinguishing between advantages for customers (confidence, social, and special treatment benefits) and for organizations (lower costs, free advertising, and retained staff). It then transitions to the foundations of relationship building, emphasizing the critical role of core service quality, segmentation, and the monitoring of relationships. A significant portion is dedicated to understanding segmentation, including its bases, requirements for authenticity, criteria for evaluation, and the process of selecting compatible target segments. The concept of "segment of one" is introduced as a conclusion to the discussion on segmentation versus customization.
๐ Lecture Summary
Benefits of relationship marketing for customers and firms
For customers
Some of the benefits are explained in detail hereunder:
- Confidence Benefits
- Social Benefits
- Special Treatment benefits
Confidence benefits are the feelings of trust customers have. They realize they are in safe hands; the level of anxiety remains low while comfort goes higher. Owing to this confidence, they donโt want to invest time into looking for other vendors. They know new vendors will take time in understanding them and their needs, which is time taking and tedious.
Social benefits let the customers enjoy a social relationship with their business partners, which bring in more loyalty to the relationship. In certain situations, providers become part of the social support system of the customers. Take the example of event management, school systems, and medical services in which suppliers have a relationship with families and not just one customer.
The flip side of this relationship is that companies tend to lose business when a good employee with relationships leaves them for competition. Employees having good relationship with customers always offer them special treatment. Special treatment benefits could range from price to special offers and special solutions based on the intensity of the relationship. This works both ways; the more business customers bring to the firms, the more intense is the relationship and hence more special benefits.
For organizations
Lower costs: Committed customers do more business with firms and owing to repeat purchases become the source of larger revenues. In addition to increased revenues, the marketing and administrative costs related to retained customers also go lower. The costs pertain to advertising, discounts, and promotional offers. Lower costs tend to elevate margins.
Free advertising: Owing to loyalty with the service brand, positive word-of-mouth generates which is a great benefit accrued over time by the organizations. Services rich in credence are:
- referral-dependent and
- endorsement-dependent
Such referrals and endorsements come to the companies automatically if it has loyal customers.
Retained staff: Satisfied customers make staff stick to the company. Staff gets confidence by dealing with such customers. Staff understands their customersโ requirements even better and the two complement each other in ways more than one.
Companies focus on customersโ lifetime contribution to their businesses. They work out the numbers by employing sophisticated accounting techniques. The contributions are made by way of looking into customers for:
- Buying for the lifetime.
- Giving referrals and attracting more customers and hence the resultant additional revenue generated by them.
- Keeping the costs of bringing in new customers low.
According to one research, by just retaining 5% more customers the increase in profitability is in the range of 35% to 95%.
Foundations of relationship building
There are certain prerequisites to developing good relationships that are not just based on selling personnelโs socializing skills. The following explains what it takes to doing the needful.
- Quality service of the core product,
- segmentation, and
- monitoring of relationships
Segmentation Challenges and Opportunities
Quality as expected by customers is the basic denominator of the relationship. As we have learnt that satisfaction is a function of quality, no relationship can be built in the absence of good quality. A referral to the quality-satisfaction relationship and the need to develop loyal customers will help us grasp and appreciate the importance of quality as the prime foundation for developing relationships.
Segmentation: We know from our fundamental marketing knowledge that segments can be viewed as groups of people having similar wants and needs and yet not exhibiting two different buyers having very similar needs. This holds true particularly in services. Experts suggest that marketers develop flexible products and offer standard and optional packages to address different needs.
There are two broad categories of services, one with just one consistent appeal for the service like in the case of power, gas, and phone etc. The only consideration for differentiating the service is by way of the quantity consumed and purchased by customers. The other broad category is the one that dictates customization, for every customer having their specific sets of needs and requirements. In other words, there are two extremes โ โsegment of allโ and the other as โsegment of oneโ.
Understanding segmentation
There are different steps that providers must take into understanding the segments.
Identify the bases of segmentation: The identification is done on demographic, geographic, psychographic, and behavioral bases.
Demographic factors relate age, sex, income group, occupation, and religion; geographic factors are about a geographical area divided into sub-areas, further divided into sections etc; psychographic factors are social class, life style, or personality characteristics; while behavioral factors are divisions on customersโ opinions, attitudes, and responses on the basis of benefits, occasions, usage rate, loyalty and attitude etc.
Requirements for segmentation: there are certain requirements that bring authenticity into segmentation as we look into those through the abovementioned bases. These are measurability, accessibility, sustainability, and actionability.
Measurability dictates that a segment must be measurable by the size and purchasing power of customers; accessibility requires that the segment must be accessible; sustainability necessitates that the segment must offer good prospects for sustainability and hence profitability; while actionability involves offering opportunities to design good compatible programs for attracting and serving the customers.
Criteria for evaluating segments: In broad terms, this calls for determining the size and attractiveness of the segment in line with companyโs objectives. The three criteria are:
- Segment size and growth: This basically calls for determining the size of the segment and its rate of growth to establish segmentโs future shape and form.
- Structural attractiveness: This clarifies that the segment is not over-crowded by suppliers, meaning the number of competitors. This also ensures the power of buyers and that of sellers.
- Company objectives and resources: According to this criterion, the segment should be compatible with objectives and the availability of resources. Getting into segments that are attractive but not compatible with the resources at companyโs disposal is something this criterion restricts.
If the providers do not find too many differences, then they may not have a great chance to offer variances and, hence, customized benefits. Providersโ smartness lies in identifying such variances to the benefit of the organization and the customer. The real benefits of segmentation, therefore, lie in revealing various segments.
Develop measures of segment attractiveness: An extension of the previous step, the providers must be able to evaluate the true level of purchasing power of the segment to see if the investment is worth the marketing effort.
Providers must see the size of the segments in relation to their growth potential and the possibility of new entrants etc. Existing competitors with their strengths and weaknesses should be studied and seen where relationship building is more effective.
A good understanding on that front enables the providers to commit resources in terms of investments to the right segments and then develop relationships.
Select the target segment: Based on the attractiveness and market realities, link the right segment with companyโs resource capabilities.
Ensure that the target segments are compatible: This refers to providerโs capability of keeping identical segments together, away from those that may have different needs and are subject to a different price. A hotel offering similar discounts to certain groups of customers is dealing with one identical segment. The same hotel dealing with business customers with pre-established contract pricing is dealing with another segment. The two segments in such a scenario are not compatible.
The difference in price may occur due to varying timeframes of customer buying. Customers buying in lean period and paying less should not interact with those who bought the same service during peak period. Such an interaction can be termed as incompatible.
Segment of one โ an interesting conclusion
It is interesting to note that both strategic directions of customization and segmentation lead toward the segment of one. Segmentation is a means to achieving customization. Even generic services are customized, because they consider the whole segment as one individual. The question raised in figure 35 rests well answered through an understanding of segmentation as a means to customization.
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that the benefits of relationship marketing are reciprocal, with customers gaining confidence, social bonds, and special treatment, while firms achieve lower costs, free word-of-mouth advertising, and better staff retention. The foundation for any successful relationship is a quality core service, effective segmentation, and ongoing monitoring. Segmentation must be strategically approached by identifying its bases (demographic, geographic, psychographic, behavioral), ensuring segments meet the requirements of measurability, accessibility, sustainability, and actionability. Critically, segments must be evaluated for size, structural attractiveness, and compatibility with company objectives and resources to be viable and profitable. The ultimate goal of segmentation is to move towards customization, which is the logical conclusion for both strategies, effectively treating a "segment of one."
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Name the three specific types of benefits customers receive from a relationship with a service firm, as detailed in the lecture.
- According to the lecture, what is one significant "flip side" risk for a company when an employee has a very strong social relationship with customers?
- What are the four main bases for identifying market segments, and briefly define one of them.
- List the four requirements that segmentation must meet to be considered authentic and effective.
- Explain the concept of "segment compatibility" as it relates to target segment selection.
๐ Lecture 22 โ Service Marketing: Segmentation and Relationship Strategies
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how careful segmentation allows service providers to customize offerings for maximum mutual benefit. It also examines the dual nature of service heterogeneity as both a challenge and an opportunity for customization. The lecture then shifts focus to the critical task of monitoring customer relationships to retain profitable customers while avoiding difficult or unprofitable segments, and outlines four key relationship bonding strategies to increase customer loyalty.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing segmentation as a tool for customization and notes that service heterogeneity can be both a curse and a blessing. It then details the importance of monitoring customer relationships through surveys and databases. A key section discusses when to "fire the customer," covering the wrong segment, unprofitable segments, and difficult customers. The lecture introduces the concept of profitability segments, including the Platinum, Gold, Iron, and Lead tier classification. Finally, it explains four levels of relationship strategies: Financial Bonds, Social Bonds, Customization Bonds, and Structural Bonds.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
Careful segmentation is done to get maximum leverage for the benefit of both the company and the customer. The company benefits from offering services with varying features as per customer expectations, while customers benefit from having a supplier that fulfills their needs. Another dimension of segmentation is managers' efforts to divide a bigger segment into smaller ones toward customization. Owing to the variability in services, heterogeneity can be both โa curse and a blessing,โ referring to both difficulties and opportunities. Heterogeneity therefore becomes an attractive basis for customization and, if pursued purposefully, can bring attractive returns to the company.
๐ก Why this matters: This highlights that the inherent variability of services is not a flaw but a strategic asset for differentiation and personalization.
Monitoring relationships
Customers should be surveyed with the help of marketing research to find out their preferences, their levels of satisfaction, and the value they perceive getting from the company. Comparisons should be drawn with competitors. Complete information on customers with names, demographics in relation to segmentation, and the revenue they generate over a period of time are the elements of an effective database.
๐ Definition โ Database: A structured collection of customer data that enables providers to retain their best customers and enjoy the benefits of retention.
๐ก Why this matters: A robust database is the foundation for all subsequent segmentation and relationship management efforts.
Do not assume that the customer is always right
There are situations in which customers become a burden on the organization. The provider should not choose:
- The wrong segment: The provider must ensure total compatibility between the service specialty and the nature of service demanded. An architectural firm specializing in housing should avoid designing commercial buildings.
- Unprofitable segment: Providers should look into segmental attractiveness by way of its size and potential for sustainability toward profits. If the cost of doing business and maintaining relationships exceeds the revenue generated, such segments should be avoided. Providers must be sensitive to customers' history and should also avoid customers who consume most of the provider's service time at the cost of other customers.
- Difficult customers: These put a lot of economic and emotional stress on the employees of the company, such as those who use a service as a test case free of cost and place unrealistic demands on the company.
Fire the customer
When providers feel that some customers are difficult and less loyal, they should follow a strategy of circumspectionโbeing realistic about whether to develop a relationship. Companies can cut down on the number of customers they serve due to their unattractiveness and make more profits by focusing on those they can serve better. The best customers may not always bring more profits; they could also be the ones who give good ideas to bring about improvements in your services.
Profitability Segments
Differentiation among apostles, indifferent customers, and terrorists must be made to identify segments of profitability. Traditional indications like frequency of purchases, the services bought, the price paid, and the level of being demanding or easy are some parameters for gauging profitable vs. unprofitable customers. In services, it is seen that 20% of the customers generate 80% of business. Providers make distinctions among customers by way of the following tiers:
- Platinum: Most loyal and profitable; heavy users, willing to try new offerings, not price sensitive.
- Gold: A little less loyal and profitable; look for price discounts on heavy purchases and tend to buy across more suppliers.
- Iron: Provide the volume needed to fill company's selling capacity; their loyalty level does not qualify for special treatment.
- Lead: Cost the company more than they bring; tie up resources and are problem customers.
The basic idea of this tier classification is to make an effort for increased purchases by all in relation to the tiers they fall in.
Relationship Strategies
There are four levels of strategies that bring customers closer to the business. Execution of strategy at every level creates a bond that can be strengthened by executing the next level.
Financial Bonds
Providers create these bonds in three ways:
- Volume-based rewards: Offering rewards on volume purchases made with great frequency (e.g., frequent flyer points, credit card points). The more you use, the more rewards you get, translating into better pricing.
- Cross-selling and bundling: Customers get benefits when they buy other products offered by the provider with incentives (e.g., using accumulated credit card points for hotel rooms or travel at a discount).
- Stable pricing: Offering stable pricing to loyal customers by not increasing prices or by increasing them on a nominal basis.
Social Bonds
This second level of bonding works in the presence of the financial bonds. Providers develop interpersonal social relationships, exemplified in both B-to-C and B-to-B situations (e.g., accounting and law firms). Another facet is customer-to-customer relationships, which bind all customers more to the providerโs business, as seen in social and fitness clubs, private schools, and training institutes.
Customization Bonds
This is a step further from financial and social bonds. The underlying assumption is that intimate knowledge of customers leads to good customization strategies by developing one-to-one solutions. Customization is about flexible processes and organizational structures to produce varied and often individually customized products at the price of standardized, mass-produced products. It involves little effort to bring about a few changes to meet customers' individual requirements.
Structural Bonds
These bonds are created by offering services that are built into the delivery system of a customer. These services are created through integration of efforts by two organizations, are mostly technology based, and require a distinct set of expertise. Examples include systems that enable banks to send SMS alerts upon card-based transactions or airlines using such systems for reservations. The rationale is building and integrating such services into systems, enabling them to deliver services more efficiently. Hard to imitate, these strategies could be better placed than financial, social, and customization bonds.
๐ Formula: Structural Bonds > Customization Bonds > Social Bonds > Financial Bonds (in terms of strength and difficulty of imitation)
โญ Key Takeaways
Accurate segmentation is crucial for maintaining compatibility between a service providerโs offerings and customer desires. While service heterogeneity offers a prime opportunity for customization, providers must avoid unprofitable or difficult segments, even if it means โfiring the customer.โ The 80/20 rule is a key principle, and tiering customers into Platinum, Gold, Iron, and Lead helps focus retention efforts. Finally, to build lasting loyalty, providers must implement a progression of relationship strategies, starting with financial bonds and advancing to social, customization, and finally structural bonds, which are the hardest to imitate.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three situations in which a provider should consider "firing" a customer?
- Explain the 80/20 rule as it applies to customer profitability in services.
- List the four tiers in the customer profitability classification (Platinum, Gold, etc.) and state the key characteristic of the "Lead" tier.
- What is a "social bond" and give one example of it in a B-to-B context?
- How does a "structural bond" differ from a "customization bond"?