π Lecture 16 β ROLE OF COMMERCIAL BANKS
π Overview: This lecture examines the different types of investment banks and the critical role commercial banks play in the economy, particularly in money supply. It also covers the size and structure of the global banking industry, the risks that lead to banking crises, and the major challenges banks face in the modern economic environment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining three types of investment banks: investment banks, merchant banks, and venture capital firms. It then explains the fractional-reserve banking system and the bank's role in money supply. It provides data on the size of the global banking industry, including the asset share of EU, Japanese, and US banks. The lecture details the various risks (liquidity, credit, interest rate) that can cause banking crises, citing historical examples. Finally, it outlines key challenges in the banking industry, including the economic environment, growth strategies, asset management, competition, and the necessity of regulation.
π Lecture Summary
Types of investment banks
The lecture distinguishes between three key types of banks. Investment banks "underwrite" (guarantee the sale of) stock and bond issues, trade for their own accounts, make markets, and advise corporations on capital markets activities such as mergers and acquisitions. Merchant banks were traditionally banks which engaged in trade financing; the modern definition, however, refers to banks which provide capital to firms in the form of shares rather than loans. Unlike Venture capital firms, they tend not to invest in new companies.
Banks in the Economy
Role in the money supply
A bank raises funds by attracting deposits, borrowing money in the inter-bank market, or issuing financial instruments in the money market or a capital market. The bank then lends out most of these funds to borrowers. However, it would not be prudent for a bank to lend out all of its balance sheet. It must keep a certain proportion of its funds in reserve so that it can repay depositors who withdraw their deposits. Bank reserves are typically kept in the form of a deposit with a central bank. This is called fractional-reserve banking and it is a central issue of monetary policy. The lecture notes that under Basel I (and the new round of Basel II), banks no longer keep deposits with central banks, but must maintain defined capital ratios.
Size of Global Banking Industry
Worldwide assets of the largest 1,000 banks grew 15.5% in 2005 to reach a record $60.5 trillion. EU banks held the largest share, 50% at the end of 2005, up from 38% a decade earlier. The growth in Europeβs share was mostly at the expense of Japanese banks whose share more than halved during this period from 33% to 13%. The share of US banks also rose, from 10% to 14%. The US had by far the most banks (7,540 at end-2005) and branches (75,000) in the world. The large number of banks in the US is an indicator of its geography and regulatory structure, resulting in a large number of small to medium sized institutions in its banking system. Japan had 129 banks and 12,000 branches. In 2004, Germany, France, and Italy had more than 30,000 branches eachβmore than double the 15,000 branches in the UK.
π‘ Why this matters: This data illustrates how the structure of a banking system (e.g., many small banks in the US vs. a few large banks in Japan) is shaped by geography, history, and regulation.
Bank Crisis
Banks are susceptible to many forms of risk which have triggered occasional systemic crises. Risks include liquidity risk (the risk that many depositors will request withdrawals beyond available funds), credit risk (the risk that those who owe money to the bank will not repay), and Interest rate risk (the risk that the bank will become unprofitable if rising interest rates force it to pay relatively more on its deposits than it receives on its loans). Banking crises have developed many times throughout history. Prominent examples include the U.S. Savings and Loan crisis in 1980s and early 1990s, the Japanese banking crisis during the 1990s, the bank run that occurred during the Great Depression, and the recent liquidation by the central Bank of Nigeria, where about 25 banks were liquidated.
π Definition β Liquidity risk: The risk that many depositors will request withdrawals beyond available funds. π Definition β Credit risk: The risk that those who owe money to the bank will not repay. π Definition β Interest rate risk: The risk that the bank will become unprofitable if rising interest rates force it to pay relatively more on its deposits than it receives on its loans.
Challenges within the Banking Industry
Economic Environment
The changing economic environment has a significant impact on banks and thrifts as they struggle to effectively manage their interest rate spread in the face of low rates on loans, rate competition for deposits and the general market changes, industry trends and economic fluctuations.
Growth Strategies
It has been a challenge for banks to effectively set their growth strategies with the recent economic market. A rising interest rate environment may seem to help financial institutions, but the effect of the changes on consumers and businesses is not predictable and the challenge remains for banks to grow and effectively manage the spread to generate a return to their shareholders.
The Management of the Banks
The management of the banksβ asset portfolios also remains a challenge in todayβs economic environment. Loans are a bankβs primary asset category and when loan quality becomes suspect, the foundation of a bank is shaken to the core. Declining asset quality has become a big problem for financial institutions, exacerbated by a lax attitude some banks have adopted because of years of βgood times,β reducing regulatory oversight, and inadequate employee training. Banks also face a host of other challenges such as aging ownership groups and management teams, ongoing pressure by shareholders to achieve earnings and growth projections, and pressure from regulators to manage risk. Banking is also an extremely competitive industry, with the entrance of such players as insurance agencies, credit unions, check cashing services, and credit card companies. Bank regulations are a form of government regulation which subject banks to certain requirements, restrictions, and guidelines, aiming to uphold the soundness and integrity of the financial system. The amount of capital a bank is required to hold is a function of the amount and quality of its assets. Major Banks are subject to the Basel Capital Accord promulgated by the Bank for International Settlements. In addition, banks are usually required to purchase deposit insurance to make sure smaller investors are not wiped out in the event of a bank failure. Ultimately, no government can allow the banking system to fail.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture is crucial for understanding the core functions and vulnerabilities of banks. First, recall the three types of investment banks (investment, merchant, venture capital) and their distinct roles. Second, understand the concept of fractional-reserve banking and why it is central to monetary policy, but also note the shift under Basel Accords toward capital ratio requirements. Third, be prepared to identify and differentiate between the three major bank risks: liquidity, credit, and interest rate risk, and cite historical crises as examples. Fourth, know the key statistics on the global banking industry, specifically the asset shares of the EU, Japan, and the US. Finally, recognize that banks face a complex set of challenges, including managing interest rate spreads, ensuring asset quality, competing with non-bank financial institutions, and complying with strict regulations like the Basel Capital Accord and deposit insurance requirements.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between a modern merchant bank and a venture capital firm?
- Explain the concept of fractional-reserve banking and why it is a central issue of monetary policy.
- What are the three main types of risk that can trigger a banking crisis? Provide one historical example for each.
- According to the lecture, which region held the largest share of global banking assets in 2005, and which region saw its share more than halve during the preceding decade?
- List three specific challenges that banks face in managing their asset portfolios and growth strategies in the current economic environment.
π Lecture 17 β ROLE OF COMMERCIAL BANKS
π Overview: This lecture examines the role of commercial banks, beginning with public perceptions and profitability strategies. It then introduces the SWIFT international messaging network and provides a detailed analysis of commercial banking in Pakistan, using the CAMEL framework to evaluate performance indicators like capital adequacy, asset quality, and liquidity after the 1997 restructuring.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers public perceptions of banks and the rise of ethical banks and credit unions; profitability strategies including the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, risk-based pricing, and payment processing products; the SWIFT international financial messaging network and its services; and a comprehensive analysis of commercial banking in Pakistan using the CAMEL framework, covering capital adequacy, asset quality, management soundness, earnings and profitability, liquidity, sensitivity to market risk, deposit mobilization, credit extension, and banking spreads.
π Lecture Summary
Public perceptions of banks
In U.S. history, the National Bank was a major political issue during Andrew Jackson's presidency, seen as a symbol of greed antithetical to democratic ideals. Today, many people believe banking policies take advantage of customers, such as fees for ATM transactions, holding deposited funds for several days, applying withdrawals before deposits, and authorizing electronic funds transfers despite overdrafts. In response, ethical banks have emerged, making only socially-responsible investments (e.g., no arms industry) and being transparent. In the U.S., credit unions have gained popularity, and in Europe, cooperative banks are gaining market share in retail banking.
Profitability
Large U.S. banks are among the most profitable corporations. In the past 10 years, banks have taken measures to remain profitable. First, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act allows banks to merge with investment and insurance houses, enabling cross-selling of products for "one-stop shopping." Second, they expanded risk-based pricing from business to consumer lending, charging higher interest rates to higher credit risk customers, offsetting bad loan losses and lowering prices for those with better credit. Third, they increased payment processing methods like debit cards, pre-paid cards, smart-cards, and credit cards, which make transactions convenient but also increase the risk of consumer mismanagement and excessive debt. Banks earn from card products through interest, fees, and transaction fees. Main obstacles to increasing profits are regulatory burdens, new government regulation, and competition from non-traditional financial institutions.
Society for Worldwide Inter-bank Financial Transactions (SWIFT)
SWIFT operates a worldwide financial messaging network for secure and reliable message exchange between banks. It markets software and services and its ISO 9362 bank identifier codes are known as "SWIFT codes." As of April 2006, SWIFT linked almost 8,000 financial institutions in 205 countries. SWIFT does not facilitate funds transfer; financial institutions need a corresponding banking relationship for transactions. SWIFT is a cooperative society under Belgian law, owned by its member institutions, with headquarters in La-Hulpe, Belgium. It was founded in Brussels in 1973 by 239 banks in 15 countries, establishing common standards, a data processing system, and a worldwide communications network. The first message was sent in 1977. SWIFT services fall into four key areas: Securities, Treasury & Derivatives, Trade Services, and Payments & Cash Management.
COMMERCIAL BANKING IN PAKISTAN
The banking sector in Pakistan has undergone comprehensive restructuring since 1997 to make institutions financially sound and forge links with the real sector for savings, investment, and growth. Commercial banks have withstood pressures including multipronged reforms by the central bank, freezing of foreign currency accounts, economic stagnation, and drives for accountability and loan recovery, bringing behavioral change among borrowers and lenders.
Commercial banks in Pakistan are divided into four categories: 1) Nationalized Commercial Banks (NCBs), 2) Privatized Banks, 3) Private Banks, and 4) Foreign Banks. The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) uses the CAMEL supervisory framework, analyzing six indicators: Capital Adequacy, Asset Quality, Management Soundness, Earnings and Profitability, Liquidity, and Sensitivity to Market Risk.
Capital adequacy
To protect depositors and shareholders, SBP introduced a risk-based capital adequacy system in late 1998. Banks must maintain an 8% capital to risk-weighted assets (CRWA) ratio. The minimum paid-up capital requirement was raised to Rs 500 million by December 31, 1998, and to one billion rupees by January 1, 2003. The ratio deteriorated after 1998 due to economic sanctions after nuclear tests and a shift in SBP policy on securities investment. However, most banks maintained above the desired ratio and directed investment toward productive private sector advances. Higher provisioning against non-performing loans (NPLs) also contributed to the decline, which is considered a positive development.
π Definition β CAMEL: A supervisory framework used by the State Bank of Pakistan involving analysis of Capital Adequacy, Asset Quality, Management Soundness, Earnings and Profitability, Liquidity, and Sensitivity to Market Risk to reflect the financial health of financial institutions.
Asset quality
Asset quality is measured by the level and severity of non-performing assets (NPLs), recoveries, adequacy of provisions, and asset distribution. The banking system is infected with a large volume of NPLs, but severity has stabilized. The rise in NPLs was due to more vigorous loan classification standards and improved reporting by SBP. For NCBs, improvement is more pronounced given their share in total NPLs. For privatized and private banks, the ratio went up considerably. The level of infection in foreign banks is the lowest and closest to constant. The ratio of net NPLs to net advances has declined, with marked improvement in bank recovery efforts, especially for NCBs.
Management soundness
Management soundness is difficult to judge from financial accounts alone. The ratios of total expenditure to total income and operating expenses to total expenses help gauge management quality. Pressure on earnings caused expenditure-to-income ratios for foreign and private banks to rise in 1998, then taper down as they adjusted portfolios. An across-the-board increase in administrative expenses to total expenditure is visible from 1999. Privatized banks are the worst performers due to high salaries and allowances.
Earnings and profitability
Strong earnings and profitability reflect a bank's ability to absorb losses, finance expansion, pay dividends, and build capital. The best indicator is return on assets (ROA); net interest margin is also used. NCBs have a large share in the banking sector, so their performance overshadows others. Profit earned by NCBs resulted in positive ROA for the banking sector in 2000 despite losses by ABL. Pressure on earnings was most visible for foreign banks in 1998. Despite SBP steps to improve liquidity, liquid assets and earning assets ratios declined. T-Bill portfolios declined as they became less remunerative. Foreign currency deposits became less attractive due to rising forward cover charges. Banks reduced return on deposits to maintain spread but could not contain the decline in ROA due to declining stock and remuneration of earning assets.
π Definition β Return on Assets (ROA): The best and most widely used indicator of a bank's earnings and profitability, reflecting the ability to absorb losses, finance expansion, pay dividends, and build capital.
Liquidity
Liquidity indicators show a painful adjustment process since 1997. The ratio of liquid assets to total assets has constantly declined due to SBP monetary policy changes after 1998. Both the cash reserve requirement (CRR) and the statutory liquidity requirement (SLR) were reduced in 1999, reinforced by declines in SBP's discount rate and T-Bill yields to help banks manage rupee withdrawals and meet private sector credit requirements. Foreign banks adjusted more quickly, with steeper declines in liquid assets and rises in loan-to-deposit ratios. The most painful part of adjustment is over, reflected in accelerating deposit growth in 2000.
Sensitivity to market risk
Rate-sensitive assets have diverged from rate-sensitive liabilities in absolute terms since 1997, with the negative gap widening. A negative value indicates higher risk sensitivity toward the liability side, while a decline in interest rates may prove beneficial.
Deposit Mobilization
Deposit mobilization dwindled after 1997, with deposits as a share of GDP declining. Growth slowed but reversed in 2000. Foreign banks were affected most due to heavy reliance on foreign currency deposits, experiencing 14% erosion in 1999 but achieving over 2% growth in 2000. Private banks showed similar recovery. NCBs' deposit mobilization waned after discontinuing rupee deposit schemes linked with lottery prizes, but they still control a large share of total deposits. Private banks showed aggressive deposit mobilization in 2000, with growth from 1.9% in 1999 to 21.7% in 2000, increasing their share to over 14%. Due to policy shifts, banks are no longer required to place foreign currency deposits with SBP. Growth in foreign currency deposits increases the deposit base but does not add to rupee liquidity. The increasing share of foreign currency deposits is worrying, so SBP mandated that foreign currency deposits not exceed 20% of rupee deposits from January 1, 2002.
Credit extension
Most bank advances are for working capital, which is self-liquidating. Due to easing SBP policy, credit extension has exceeded deposit mobilization, with advances growing at 12.3% in 1999 and 14% in 2000. Three distinct features are: 1) foreign banks curtailed lending, 2) NCBs continued dominance, and 3) private banks followed an aggressive approach, maintaining double-digit growth and pushing it to over 31% in 2000, surpassing foreign banks in share of total advances.
Banking spreads
There has been a declining trend in both lending and deposit rates. The downward trend in lending rates was due to SBP policy, achieved with lags following sharp reductions in T-Bill yields in 1999. The downward trend in deposit rates was almost inevitable; banks could not maintain or increase deposit rates during times of eroding balance sheets. Banks tried creative ways to mobilize deposits at low rates. However, due to inefficiencies of large banks, the spread has remained high.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that commercial banks face significant public scrutiny and use strategies like risk-based pricing, cross-selling, and payment processing products to maintain profitability. The SWIFT network is a critical messaging system for international inter-bank communication but does not facilitate actual funds transfer. For Pakistan, the CAMEL framework is the central tool for evaluating bank performance, with capital adequacy (8% CRWA), asset quality (NPL levels), and liquidity (CRR and SLR) being key indicators. The 1997 restructuring led to improved recovery and classification standards, but challenges remain in foreign currency deposit management and maintaining spreads. Understanding how each bank group (NCBs, privatized, private, foreign) responds to pressures differently is crucial for exam questions on comparative performance analysis.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four categories of commercial banks operating in Pakistan, and how did each perform in deposit mobilization and credit extension after 1997?
- Explain the CAMEL framework and describe how the "Capital Adequacy" indicator is measured, including the minimum CRWA ratio.
- How does SWIFT differ from actual funds transfer, and what are the four key service areas it covers in the financial marketplace?
- What strategies have large U.S. banks used to maintain profitability, and what are their main obstacles to increasing profits?
- Describe the trends in banking spreads (lending and deposit rates) in Pakistan after 1997, and explain why the spread remained high despite the downward trend in both rates.
π Lecture 18 β Role of Commercial Banks
π Overview: This lecture examines the evolving asset composition of Pakistan's banking sector, particularly the decline of Nationalized Commercial Banks (NCBs) and the rise of private banks. It details the central bank's role in managing problem banks and outlines the major challenges facing the sector. Finally, it provides a comprehensive review of the extensive banking sector reforms undertaken to improve soundness, governance, and outreach.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the declining asset composition of banks as a percentage of GDP, with a focus on the shrinking share of NCBs and foreign banks. It discusses the central bank's authority in supervising and taking action against problem banks like Indus Bank and Prudential Commercial Bank. The outlook for commercial banks is assessed, highlighting pre- and post-9/11 challenges such as high NPLs, bureaucratic inefficiency, and underserved sectors. The core of the lecture is a detailed breakdown of eleven banking sector reform areas including privatization, corporate governance, capital strengthening, and new regulations for consumer, SME, and micro-financing.
π Lecture Summary
Asset composition
The total assets of the banking sector, measured as a percentage of GDP, have been declining. This slowdown was accompanied by a shift in the market share among different banking groups. The negative growth in the assets of foreign banks during 1998 and 1999 was a primary reason for the overall decline. The share of NCBs has been decreasing since 1992 when private banks were allowed to operate. Currently, private banks are now as large as foreign banks in terms of asset share.
Problem bank management
The central bank (State Bank of Pakistan, SBP) is the sole authority responsible for supervising, monitoring, and regulating financial institutions and safeguarding the interests of depositors and shareholders. Lately, SBP took actions against two private banks that became a threat to the financial systemβs viability: Indus Bank and Prudential Commercial Bank. Based on detailed investigations, the license of Indus Bank was cancelled on September 11, 2000. After successful negotiations, the management and control of Prudential Bank was handed over to the Saudi-Pak group.
Outlook
Commercial banks have been restructuring, with efforts to reduce lending rates. The SBP has been successful in implementing its policies, and most banks have adapted to the new working environment. The proposed increase in the capital base will provide further impetus to the financial system. In the post-September 11 era, GoP borrowing from SBP and commercial banks was expected to decrease substantially, while private sector borrowing was expected to increase. However, a temporary decline in borrowersβ repayment ability was expected to increase provisioning for 2001, with improvement expected in 2002. Unless banks shrink the spread (the difference between lending and deposit rates), depositors will not get returns matching inflation. Privatization of NCBs was expected to be delayed, but this presents an opportunity for banks to clean their slate.
The lecture lists several specific problems faced by Pakistanβs banking sector:
- Most assets/deposits were held by NCBs which suffered from bureaucracy, overstaffing, unprofitable branches, and poor customer service.
- NCBs and specialized banks had a high ratio of non-performing loans (NPLs).
- The industry faced a high tax rate affecting profitability and attractiveness for new entrants.
- There was a proliferation of undercapitalized, poorly managed banks with a scanty distribution network.
- Agriculture, SMEs, and Housing sectors were underserved, and the middle/low-income groups had limited access to credit.
- Banks focused on trade and corporate financing with a narrow product range, not diversifying into consumer and mortgage financing.
- Poor quality of human resources, weak internal controls, non-merit-based recruitments, high administrative costs, and undue union interference affected public sector banks' performance.
BANKING SECTOR REFORMS
Banking sector reforms aimed to address these constraints. Substantial progress has been made to improve the health of the banking sector, and overall, it is much stronger today.
1. Privatization of NCBs
The privatization of NCBs is reducing their domination from almost 100% in 1991 to about 20% by December 2003. MCB shares are all in the private sector, and United Bank was sold to a consortium. Privatization of Habib Bank Ltd. was underway, and 23.5% of National Bank shares were floated on the stock market. NCBs have been restructured with professional management working under independent Boards of Directors from the private sector.
2. Corporate governance
Strong corporate governance is essential for transparent operations and protecting depositors. The SBP implemented several measures:
- License Cancellation: For the first time in Pakistanβs history, the banking license of a commercial bank found in violation of regulations was cancelled, a decision upheld by the Peshawar High Court.
- Ownership/Management Change: Ownership and management were changed at two private banks for unauthorized fund transfers.
- Referral to NAB: Cases of willful defaulters were referred to the National Accountability Bureau for legal action and recovery.
- Fit and Proper Test: Appointments of Board members, CEOs, and key executives are screened to ensure they meet SBPβs fit and proper criteria.
- Family Representation Limit: Family representation on Boards is limited to 25 percent of total membership.
- Conflict of Interest Rules: Directors, executives, and traders from Brokerage companies can no longer serve on bank Boards.
- Auditor Evaluation: External auditors are evaluated annually and classified. Two large audit firms were debarred from auditing banks.
- Board Guidelines: Detailed guidelines for Boards to oversee management and develop policies were issued, along with a training course on corporate governance.
- Disclosure Requirements: Banks must prepare annual statements in accordance with International Accounting Standards and publish quarterly/half-yearly accounts.
- Institutionalized Decision Making: Banks must formulate policies on credit, investment, recovery, HR, audit, and risk management.
- Risk Management Guidelines: A detailed set of guidelines was issued for identifying, measuring, monitoring, and controlling risks.
3. Capital Strengthening
Capital requirements must be adequate relative to risk-weighted assets, conforming to the Basle Accord. The minimum paid-up capital requirement was raised from Rs 500 million to Rs 1 billion by January 1st, 2003. This led to mergers and consolidation, weeding out weaker banks.
4. Improving Asset quality
The stock of non-performing loans (NPLs) was tackled in several ways. Gross NPLs are Rs 252 billion (22% of advances), but aggressive provisioning has been done. Over 60% of NPLs are fully provided for, bringing the net NPLs to net advances ratio to less than 10%. The Corporate & Industrial Restructuring Corporation (CIRC) and the Committee on Revival of Sick Units (CRSU) are working to reduce this further. The quality of new loans disbursed since 1997 has improved, with a recovery rate of 95 percent.
5. Liberalization of foreign exchange regime
Pakistan further liberalized its foreign exchange regime, ensuring partial Capital Account Convertibility by allowing foreign exchange companies to operate and the Pakistani corporate sector to acquire equity abroad.
6. Consumer Financing
The State Bank removed restrictions on NCBs for consumer financing. The positive experience of auto financing creates hope that the middle class will have access to consumer durables (TVs, ACs, etc.) through banks. Credit and Debit Cards are also gaining popularity, with the number of card holders doubling in the last two years.
7. Mortgage Financing
Incentives were provided to encourage mortgage financing. The upper limit was raised from Rs 5 million to Rs 10 million. Tax deduction on interest payments on mortgages is allowed up to Rs. 500,000. A new recovery law expedites repossession. Banks can raise long-term funds through rated and listed debt instruments like TFCs (Term Finance Certificates) to match long-term mortgage assets with liabilities.
8. Legal Reforms
Legal difficulties and time delays in recovery were addressed by the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001. It ensures expeditious recovery through the right of foreclosure and sale of mortgaged property, with automatic transfer of cases to execution proceedings. A Banking Laws Reforms Commission is reviewing, revising, and consolidating banking laws and drafting new ones like a bankruptcy law.
9. Prudential Regulations
The SBP, in consultation with stakeholders, developed a new set of prudential regulations catering to the separate needs of corporate, consumer, and SME financing. These will enable banks to expand their scope of lending and customer outreach.
10. Micro financing
The licensing and regulatory environment for Micro Credit and Rural financial institutions has been relaxed. Unlike commercial banks, these can be set up at district, provincial, and national levels with varying capital requirements. Khushali Bank and the First Microfinance Bank are already working under this framework. Khushali Bank has reached a customer base of 125,000, mainly in poorer districts, with a recovery rate above 95 percent.
11. SME Financing
Access to credit for Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) was a major constraint. An SME Bank was established to develop new products (e.g., program loans), credit appraisal techniques, and skills that can be transferred to other banks. The new Prudential regulations for SMEs do not require collateral but use the asset conversion cycle and cash flow generation as the basis for loan approval. The State Bank is also contemplating capacity building for SME lending among select banks.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the major problems plaguing Pakistan's banking sector pre-reform (dominance of inefficient NCBs, high NPLs, poor governance, and underserved sectors like agriculture and SMEs). The core of the reforms targeted these issues through eleven specific measures, including the privatization of NCBs, raising minimum capital requirements to Rs. 1 billion (which forced mergers), and implementing strong corporate governance rules (like the fit-and-proper test and limiting family board representation). The shift in lending philosophy is critical: new prudential regulations were created for consumer and SME financing, and for microfinance, moving away from collateral-based lending to cash-flow-based lending for SMEs. Finally, reforms in legal recovery (the new ordinance) and asset quality improvement (aggressive provisioning and the 95% recovery rate on new loans) were crucial for cleaning up bank balance sheets.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the primary reasons for the decline in the banking sector's asset growth during 1998 and 1999?
- What specific actions did the State Bank of Pakistan take against Indus Bank and Prudential Commercial Bank under "Problem bank management"?
- List four major problems faced by Pakistan's banking sector before the reforms, as detailed in the lecture.
- What was the new minimum paid-up capital requirement for banks, and by when was it required to be met? What was the primary outcome of this requirement?
- According to the new Prudential regulations for SMEs, what is the basis for loan approval, instead of requiring collateral?
π Lecture 19 β Role of Commercial Banking
π Overview: This lecture examines key reforms in Pakistan's commercial banking sector, including legal, tax, agricultural credit, e-banking, human resources, credit rating, and supervisory changes. It then explores the theoretical concept of commercial banking in a free society, discussing how banks might operate without heavy regulation. Understanding these reforms and the free-market perspective is crucial for grasping the evolution and potential future of banking.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers twelve main topics: legal reforms for loan recovery, taxation changes for banks, revamping of agriculture credit schemes, the surge in e-banking and ATMs, merit-based human resource recruitment, mandatory credit rating disclosures, strengthening of SBP supervision and regulatory capacity, improvements to payment systems like RTGS, and a theoretical discussion of commercial banking in a free society, including private deposit insurance and the rule of law.
π Lecture Summary
12. Legal Reforms
Legal difficulties and time delays in recovering defaulted loans were addressed through The Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001. This new law ensures expeditious recovery of stuck-up loans by granting the right of foreclosure and sale of mortgaged property with or without court intervention, and by automatically transferring cases to execution proceedings. A Banking Laws Reforms Commission is reviewing, revising, and consolidating banking laws and drafting new ones, such as a bankruptcy law.
π‘ Why this matters: These legal reforms were designed to strengthen creditor rights and reduce the burden of non-performing loans on the banking system.
13. Taxation
Previously, corporate tax rates on banks in Pakistan were exorbitantly high, which adversely affected their profitability and attractiveness for investment and new equity. The Government reduced the tax rate from 58 percent to 44 percent over the last three years, with a plan to gradually reduce it further to bring it at par with the standard corporate tax rate of 35 percent. This reduction is expected to help lower the spread between the deposit rate and lending rate, benefiting financial savers.
14. Agriculture Credit
The Agriculture Credit Scheme was completely revamped with the help of commercial banks. Its scope, previously limited to production loans for inputs, was broadened to cover the entire value chain of the agriculture sector. The SBP included financing for silos, godowns, refrigerated vans, agro-processing, and distribution under this scheme. This broadening of scope enabled commercial banks to increase their lending for agriculture by four times compared to FY 1999-00, mainstreaming agriculture lending as part of their corporate business.
15. E-Banking
Banks are being encouraged to move towards Electronic banking, leading to a surge in technology upgrades and online banking services. This resulted in a large expansion of ATMs, with about 500 ATMs working nationwide. A decision mandating banks to join one of two available ATM switches in the country will provide a further boost. It was expected that by 2004, a majority of bank branches would be online or automated. The lecture notes that a banking transaction through an ATM costs one-fourth as much as an over-the-counter transaction, and a similar transaction over the internet costs a mere fraction of traditional teller costs.
π‘ Why this matters: E-banking reduces transaction costs and time for both banks and customers, enhancing efficiency and promoting E-Commerce.
16. Human Resources
Banks have recently embarked on merit-based recruitment to build up their human resource base, an area previously neglected. Private banks took the lead by holding competitive examinations and interviews to select the most qualified candidates, ending the era of appointments based on sifarish (recommendation) and nepotism. This new generation of bankers is expected to usher in a culture of professionalism and rigor in the banking industry.
17. Credit Rating
To help depositors make informed judgments, it has been made mandatory for all banks to get themselves evaluated by credit rating agencies. These ratings are disclosed to the public by the SBP and disseminated to Chambers of Commerce and Trade bodies. This public disclosure allows depositors to choose between banks based on their risk tolerance; for example, those seeking higher returns may opt for lower-rated banks (B or C), while risk-averse depositors can stick with AAA or AA rated banks.
18. Supervision and Regulatory Capacity
The banking supervision and regulatory capacity of the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) has been strengthened through merit-based recruitment, competency-enhancing training, performance-linked promotion, technology-driven processes, and a greater emphasis on values like integrity and team work. The responsibility for supervising non-bank finance companies was separated and transferred to the Securities Exchange Commission. The SBP itself was divided into two parts: one looking after central banking and the other after retail banking for the government.
19. Payment Systems
The country's payment system infrastructure is being strengthened to provide convenience in transferring payments. The Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) system will process large value and critical transactions on a real-time basis, while electronic clearing systems are to be established in all cities. These reforms, along with a vigilant supervisory regime by the State Bank, will further strengthen the banking sector.
π Definition β Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS): A system for processing large-value and critical financial transactions on an individual, real-time basis, meaning they are settled immediately without netting.
Commercial Banking in a Free Society
This section discusses what commercial banking might look like in a free society, arguing that our ignorance of the details of such a society is precisely why having one is important. The banking industry is particularly suited for this analysis, as we can look at contemporary regulation and historical records to piece together a coherent story.
Private Deposit Insurance
In a free society, banks might choose to purchase privately supplied deposit insurance to reassure customers, enter into inter-bank mutual aid agreements, or be insured through clearinghouses. Historically, before deposit insurance, banks would advertise their balance sheets and list board members to establish trustworthiness. With deposit insurance, banks no longer need to do this. It is expected that banks in a free society would use these and discover new ways to create trust.
The Rule of Law
Banks in a free society would be "literally nothing special." What makes banking so un-free today is that they are treated differently from other business enterprises. The rule of law in a free society would demand that banks be treated no differently than other firms. If they are fraudulent or use force, they face consequences. Otherwise, any voluntary arrangement banks make with customers would be allowed. The result would be a more free, efficient, safe, and productive banking system.
β Key Takeaways
The major reforms in Pakistan's banking sector addressed critical issues: legal reforms expedited loan recovery; tax reductions improved bank profitability; agricultural credit was expanded to cover the entire value chain; e-banking increased efficiency and lowered costs; merit-based recruitment improved human capital; mandatory credit rating empowered depositors; and the SBP's supervisory capacity was strengthened. The discussion on commercial banking in a free society highlights that the current regulatory environment treats banks as special, whereas a free society would subject them to the same rule of law as other firms, potentially leading to greater efficiency and innovation. The lecture emphasizes that the purpose of reforms is to strengthen the banking system, but the ultimate direction should be guided by vigilant supervision and a free-market philosophy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the key purpose of The Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001?
- Before the tax reforms, what was the high corporate tax rate on banks in Pakistan, and what was the target rate?
- How did the scope of the Agriculture Credit Scheme broaden beyond production loans for inputs?
- According to the lecture, what are the cost advantages of an ATM transaction and an internet transaction compared to a traditional over-the-counter transaction?
- In the context of a free society, how would banks establish trust with depositors in the absence of government deposit insurance?