π Lecture 7 β EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT
π Overview: This lecture introduces the process and purpose of an external strategic-management audit, also known as environmental scanning or industry analysis. It explains how to identify and evaluate key external forcesβeconomic, social, political, technological, and competitiveβthat create opportunities and threats for an organization, enabling managers to formulate effective strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the external strategic-management audit and its purpose, then categorizes key external forces into five broad groups. It details the nature of an external audit, including its role in the strategic-management model, and explains the step-by-step process for performing an audit, emphasizing broad participation and information gathering. The final section focuses specifically on economic forces, listing key economic variables to monitor and explaining their direct impact on strategy.
π Lecture Summary
External Strategic Management Audit
An external strategic-management audit, also called environmental scanning or industry analysis, focuses on identifying and evaluating trends and events beyond a single firm's control, such as increased foreign competition, population shifts, or technological changes. An external audit reveals key opportunities and threats confronting an organization, allowing managers to formulate strategies that capitalize on opportunities and minimize the impact of threats. The lecture presents a practical framework for gathering, assimilating, and analyzing external information.
Key External Forces
External forces can be divided into five broad categories:
- Economic forces
- Social, cultural, demographic, and environmental forces
- Political, governmental, and legal forces
- Technological forces
- Competitive forces
Changes in these external forces translate into changes in consumer demand and directly affect the types of products developed, market segmentation strategies, and choices of businesses to acquire or sell. External forces also affect suppliers and distributors. Identifying and evaluating these external opportunities and threats enables organizations to develop a clear mission, design strategies for long-term objectives, and develop policies for annual objectives.
π Definition β External Strategic Management Audit: A systematic process of scanning and analyzing the external environment to identify key trends and events (opportunities and threats) beyond the firm's control.
π‘ Why this matters: The increasing complexity of global business, with more countries competing aggressively, means that firms must systematically monitor external forces to remain competitive.
The Nature of an External Audit
The purpose of an external audit is to develop a finite list of opportunities that could benefit a firm and threats that should be avoided. It is not aimed at an exhaustive list of every possible factor, but rather at identifying key variables that offer actionable responses. Firms should respond either offensively or defensively by formulating strategies that take advantage of opportunities or minimize the impact of potential threats. The external audit is an integral part of the comprehensive strategic-management model, as it feeds information into the strategy formulation stage.
The Process of Performing an External Audit
The process of performing an external audit must involve as many managers and employees as possible, as involvement leads to understanding and commitment. The steps include:
- Gathering Information: The company must first gather competitive intelligence and information about social, cultural, demographic, environmental, economic, political, legal, governmental, and technological trends. Individuals can be asked to monitor sources like key magazines, trade journals, and newspapers and submit periodic scanning reports to a committee. The Internet, libraries, suppliers, distributors, salespersons, customers, and competitors are all vital sources.
- Assimilating and Evaluating Information: Once gathered, information must be assimilated and evaluated in a meeting or series of meetings. Managers collectively identify the most important opportunities and threats.
- Prioritizing Factors: A prioritized list of these key external factors can be obtained by asking all managers to rank them, from 1 (most important) to 20 (least important).
- Communicating the Final List: A final list of the most important key external factors should be communicated and distributed widely in the organization.
Freund emphasized that these key external factors should be:
- Important to achieving long-term and annual objectives
- Measurable
- Applicable to all competing firms
- Hierarchical (some pertain to the overall company, others are more focused)
Economic Forces
Economic forces have a direct impact on the potential attractiveness of various strategies. For example, as interest rates rise, funds for capital expansion become more costly, discretionary income declines, and demand for discretionary goods falls. As stock prices increase, equity becomes a more desirable source of capital, and consumer/business wealth expands.
π Key Economic Variables to Monitor: A list of critical variables includes:
- Shift to a service economy
- Availability of credit
- Level of disposable income
- Interest rates
- Inflation rates
- Gross domestic product (GDP) trends
- Unemployment trends
- Worker productivity levels
- Value of the dollar in world markets
- Stock market trends
- Import/export factors
- Federal government budget deficits
π Example: "As interest rates rise, then funds needed for capital expansion become more costly or unavailable. Also, as interest rates rise, discretionary income declines, and the demand for discretionary goods falls." This illustrates a direct causal link between an economic force (interest rates) and a threat (higher costs, lower demand).
β Key Takeaways
The external audit is a critical strategic-management tool for identifying actionable opportunities and threats beyond a firm's control. The five key categories of external forces are economic, social/cultural/demographic, political/legal, technological, and competitive. The process of performing an external audit should involve a broad range of managers and employees to gather and prioritize information from diverse sources. A finite, prioritized list of key external factors must be developed and communicated across the organization to guide strategy formulation. Economic forces, such as interest rates and GDP trends, have a direct and powerful impact on the attractiveness of potential strategic alternatives.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the purpose of an external strategic-management audit, and what is the difference between identifying all possible factors versus a "finite list"?
- List the five broad categories of key external forces that organizations must monitor.
- Describe the process for performing an external audit, including how information is gathered and how factors are prioritized.
- According to Freund, what four characteristics should key external factors possess?
- Provide one concrete example from the lecture of how a specific economic force (e.g., interest rates, stock prices, inflation) can directly affect a firm's strategic options.
π Lecture 8 β Key External Factors
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the external audit as a vital part of the strategic-management process, providing a framework for collecting and evaluating key external forces. It explains how firms that fail to identify, monitor, forecast, and evaluate these forces risk missing opportunities and facing organizational decline. The lecture specifically examines economic, social, cultural, demographic, and environmental forces that shape strategic decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the framework for collecting and evaluating key external factors, divided into two main categories: Economic Forces (including foreign economic conditions, import/export factors, demand shifts, price fluctuations, monetary and fiscal policies, and policies of international organizations) and Social, Cultural, Demographic, and Environmental Forces (examining changes in population, age, ethnicity, wealth distribution, and consumer behavior with specific examples from Pakistan and the United States, along with global population trends and regional trade agreements).
π Lecture Summary
Economic Forces
Organizations must monitor key economic factors as they directly affect customer buying behaviors and strategic decisions. Price fluctuation refers to general changes in prices that affect economic factors and alter customer purchasing trendsβcustomers become more conscious of economic changes and respond accordingly. Regarding exportation of capital and labor, Pakistan has experienced tremendous labor exportation over the last 300 years, while capital exportation has left a vacuum in organizations. Monetary policies and Fiscal policies change every year, requiring businesses and non-profit organizations to constantly monitor the economic structure of countries. Tax rates are also changed by governments over time, affecting economic forces. Policies of international organizations like ECC (European policies), OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries), and LDC (Less Developed Countries) have major effects on economic factors.
π‘ Why this matters: Economic forces are constantly changing, and organizations must adapt their strategies to remain competitive in the face of these external pressures.
Social, Cultural, Demographic, and Environmental Forces
Social, cultural, demographic, and environmental changes have a major impact on virtually all products, services, markets, and customers. Small, large, for-profit, and non-profit organizations in all industries face opportunities and threats arising from these changes. The lecture provides comparative analysis between Pakistan and the United States.
For Pakistan, key factors include: population growing older, increase in younger population, ethnic balance changing due to migration from different areas, and the gap between rich and poor widening. Ethnic balance changes due to people migrating from different areas, affecting ethical behavior significantly. Since traditions and norms differ across Pakistan's regions, the behavior of migrated people affects resident populations. The increased gap between rich and poor has caused tremendous change in social behavior.
For America, key factors include: population growing older, increase in younger population, less Caucasian population, and the gap between rich and poor widening. Persons aged 65 and older will rise from 12.7% to 18.5% of the population between 1997 and 2025. By 2075, the United States will have no racial or ethnic majority. America's 76 million baby boomers plan to retire in 2011, causing concern among lawmakers and younger taxpayers about who will pay for social security, Medicare, and Medicaid. An increase in tourism worldwide is an opportunity for many firms, with France being the most visited country annually.
Global population statistics reveal the world population passed 6 billion on October 12, 1999. The United States has less than 300 million persons while Pakistan has 150-160 million, leaving billions of potential customers outside domestic markets. Remaining solely domestic is increasingly a risky strategy.
World Population Statistics (1998 to 2050):
- Asia: 3.6 billion β 5.3 billion (47.22% increase)
- Africa: 749 million β 1.8 billion (140.32% increase)
- Latin America/Caribbean: 504 million β 809 million (60.52% increase)
- Europe: 628 million β 729 million (16.08% increase)
- North America: 305 million β 392 million (28.52% increase)
- Oceania: 30 million β 46 million (53.33% increase)
The world population will reach 7 billion in 2013, 8 billion in 2028, and 9 billion in 2054.
NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) regional trade data shows: U.S. exports to Mexico increased 170%; in 2000, U.S. trade deficits were Mexico ($25 billion), China ($84 billion), and Japan ($81 billion); the 2001 recession affected the U.S. and world; 60,000 layoffs occurred along the Mexico border with the U.S. The lecture suggests considering SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation) and other regional associations.
Trends for the 2000s include significant demographic shifts. In the USA: more educated consumers, population aging, minorities more influential, local rather than federal solutions, fixation with youth decreasing, Hispanics increasing to 15% by 2021, and African Americans increasing to 14% by 2021. In Pakistan: provincial rather than federal solutions, youth getting more independent, steady change in ethnic balance, more educated consumers, higher average lifespan, increase in number of youth, and minorities having more say (including women).
Social, cultural, demographic, and environmental trends are shaping how Americans live, work, produce, and consume. New trends create different types of consumers requiring different products, services, and strategies. More American households now consist of people living alone or with unrelated people than households of married couples with children. Census data suggests Americans are not returning to traditional lifestyles.
The number of individuals aged 50 and over increased 18.5% to 76 million during the 1990s, while Americans under age 50 grew by just 3.5%. The trend toward an older America benefits restaurants, hotels, airlines, cruise lines, tours, resorts, theme parks, luxury products and services, recreational vehicles, home builders, furniture producers, computer manufacturers, travel services, pharmaceutical firms, automakers, and funeral homes. Older Americans are especially interested in health care, financial services, travel, crime prevention, and leisure. The world's longest-living people are the Japanese, with women living to 86.3 years and men to 80.1 years on average. By 2050, the Census Bureau projects the number of Americans age 100 and older to increase to over 834,000 from just under 100,000 in 2000. Americans age 65 and over will increase from 12.6% of the U.S. population in 2000 to 20.0% by 2050.
The aging American population affects the strategic orientation of nearly all organizations. Life care facilitiesβapartment complexes for the elderly with one meal a day, transportation, and utilities included in the rentβhave increased nationwide, exceeding 2 million. Companies building these facilities include Avon, Marriott, and Hyatt.
Americans are moving to the South and West (Sun Belt) and away from the Northeast and Midwest (Frost Belt). Arizona is the fastest-growing state, with Nevada, New Mexico, and Florida close behind. Wyoming is the least-populated state and California the most-populated. States losing the most people include North Dakota, Wyoming, Pennsylvania, Iowa, and West Virginia. This information is essential for successful strategy formulation, including where to locate plants and distribution centers and where to focus marketing efforts.
Americans are becoming less interested in fitness and exercise. Fitness participants declined in the United States by 3.5% annually in the 1990s. Makers of fitness products like Nike, Reebok International, and CML Group (which makes NordicTrack) are experiencing declines in sales growth.
The lecture provides a comprehensive table of Key Social, Cultural, Demographic, and Environmental Variables that represent opportunities or threats for virtually all organizations, including childbearing rates, marriages, divorces, births, deaths, immigration/emigration rates, life expectancy, per capita income, lifestyles, buying habits, ethical concerns, racial equality, education levels, government regulation, pollution control, energy conservation, social responsibility, population changes by race/age/sex/affluence, regional changes in tastes, number of women and minority workers, recycling, waste management, air/water pollution, ozone depletion, and endangered species.
β Key Takeaways
For strategic management, the external audit is vital because firms that fail to identify and monitor key external forces risk missing opportunities and pursuing ineffective strategies. Economic forces such as price fluctuations, monetary/fiscal policies, and international organization policies directly affect customer buying behavior and business operations. Social, cultural, demographic, and environmental changesβincluding population aging, ethnic balance shifts, and widening income gapsβimpact virtually all products, services, and markets globally. Global population growth and regional trade agreements like NAFTA create both opportunities for international expansion and risks for firms remaining solely domestic. Organizations must continuously track trends in consumer education, minority influence, and geographic population shifts to successfully formulate strategies for plant locations, distribution, and marketing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key economic forces that organizations must monitor according to the lecture, and how do price fluctuations affect customer buying behavior?
- How are the demographic trends in Pakistan and the United States similar, and how do they differ regarding ethnic balance and population age structure?
- What is the projected percentage increase in population for Africa and Asia between 1998 and 2050, and why is remaining solely domestic considered a risky strategy?
- Why is the aging American population significant for strategic decision-making, and which industries benefit most from this trend?
- What is a "life care facility," and name three well-known companies involved in building these facilities.
π Lecture 9 β EXTERNAL ASSESSMENT (KEY EXTERNAL FACTORS)
π Overview: This lecture covers the critical process of external assessment in strategic management, focusing on identifying and monitoring key external factors that can significantly impact an organization's strategy. It emphasizes the importance of understanding political, governmental, and legal forces, as well as the increasing global interdependence among economies and markets, to formulate effective competitive strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining key external factors such as racial equality, education, and environmental concerns, then moves to political, governmental, and legal forces, including government regulation and antitrust legislation. It continues by examining the impact of political variables on strategy formulation and implementation, explores the globalization of industry, and concludes with a detailed list of political, governmental, and legal variables that represent key opportunities or threats.
π Lecture Summary
Key External Factors
A major responsibility of strategists is to ensure the development of an effective external-audit system, which includes using information technology to devise a competitive intelligence system. The external-audit process is typically more informal in small firms, but the need to understand key trends and events is equally important. Key external factors include a wide range of social and environmental elements such as racial equality, average level of education, government regulation, attitudes toward customer service and product quality, energy conservation, social responsibility, and the value placed on leisure time. The increase in leisure time has led to a growth in recreational activities and the leisure industries.
Environmental factors are also critical, including recycling, which has become an important part of economic activity; for instance, the increasing need for stationery is often met through recycled materials. Waste management involves solid waste and other waste, as the accumulation of vegetable, stationery, and fuel waste in cities significantly affects the environment. Air and water pollution from these wastes impact the health of people and animals and must be constantly monitored. Ozone depletion allows harmful effects of sunlight to reach the earth's surface, primarily affecting skin and eyes. Additionally, many species have become endangered. All these factors should be monitored as key economic variables.
Political, Governmental, and Legal Forces
Government Regulation
Government regulations create both key opportunities and key threats. Examples include antitrust legislation (as seen with Microsoft), which aims to ban monopolies; changes in tax rates; lobbying efforts to pass favorable legislation; and patent laws and intellectual property rights.
Federal, state, local, and foreign governments are major regulators, deregulators, subsidizers, employers, and customers of organizations. Political, governmental, and legal factors can represent key opportunities or threats for both small and large organizations. For industries and firms that depend heavily on government contracts or subsidies, political forecasts can be the most important part of an external audit. Changes in patent laws, antitrust legislation, tax rates, and lobbying activities can significantly affect firms. In the political world, deeply divisive issues such as assisted suicide, genetic testing, genetic engineering, cloning, and abortion have great ramifications for companies in many industries, ranging from pharmaceuticals to computers.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the impact of government regulation is crucial because changes in laws and policies can create entirely new markets, dismantle existing ones, or significantly alter the competitive landscape for any organization.
Increasing Global Interdependence
The increasing global interdependence among economies, markets, governments, and organizations makes it imperative that firms consider the possible impact of political variables on the formulation and implementation of competitive strategies. Strategists in a global economy must be able to forecast political climates, possess legalistic skills, and understand diverse world cultures.
Political forecasting is especially critical and complex for multinational firms that depend on foreign countries for natural resources, facilities, or customers. Modern strategists must possess skills to deal more legalistically and politically than previous ones, whose attention was more on economic and technical affairs. They now spend more time anticipating and influencing public policy actions, meeting with government officials, attending hearings, and giving public speeches. Before entering or expanding international operations, strategists need a good understanding of the political and decision-making processes in those countries. For example, the republics that made up the former Soviet Union differ greatly in wealth, resources, language, and lifestyle.
Globalization of Industry
There is a worldwide trend toward similar consumption patterns, creating a market of global buyers and sellers. This is facilitated by e-commerce and the instant transmission of money and information across continents. An example of this trend is the Declaration of Rio of 1999, a sweeping agreement signed by nearly fifty European and Latin American heads of state to liberalize trade, which enhanced economic development and trade between those continents as well as the United States.
Increasing global competition accents the need for accurate political, governmental, and legal forecasts. Mass communication and high technology are creating similar patterns of consumption in diverse cultures worldwide, meaning many companies may find it difficult to survive by relying solely on domestic markets. In an industry that is or is rapidly becoming global, the riskiest possible posture is to remain a domestic competitor. The domestic competitor will watch as more aggressive companies capture economies of scale and learning, and will then be faced with an attack using different (and possibly superior) technology, product design, and marketing approaches. For instance, Hewlett-Packard's manufacturing chain reaches from skilled engineers in California to low-wage assembly workers in Malaysia, and General Electric has survived as a manufacturer of inexpensive audio products by centralizing its world production in Singapore.
Several political variables have an impact on government regulations. These include government regulation/deregulation, tax law changes, special tariffs, Political Action Committees (PACs), voter participation rates, the number of patents, and changes in patent laws. Many companies have altered or abandoned strategies because of political or governmental actions. For example, many nuclear power projects have been halted and many steel plants shut down due to pressure from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Other key federal regulatory agencies include the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the National Highway Traffic and Safety Administration (NHTSA), the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
Some Political, Governmental, and Legal Variables A summary table lists key variables that can represent key opportunities or threats, including government regulations, changes in tax laws, special tariffs, political action committees, environmental protection laws, levels of defense expenditures, antitrust legislation, import-export regulations, and political conditions in foreign countries. The lecture emphasizes that whether the issue is related to world oil, currency, or labor markets, they should all be monitored as key external variables.
β Key Takeaways
The external assessment process is critical for strategists, who must establish an effective system to monitor key external factors including social, environmental, and political trends. Government regulation, through bodies like the EPA and FDA, along with changes in tax and patent laws, presents both major opportunities and threats that can drastically alter a company's strategy. The increasing global interdependence of economies and the trend toward similar consumption patterns mean that firms can no longer rely solely on domestic markets and must understand diverse political climates. Political forecasting has become a central responsibility for strategists, who must now engage more with government officials and public policy than in the past. All external variables, from lobbying activities to world oil markets and terrorist activities, must be systematically monitored as part of a comprehensive external audit.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is it important for firms to develop a competitive intelligence system as part of their external audit?
- List three environmental factors (e.g., recycling, ozone depletion) that are identified as key external factors requiring monitoring.
- Give two examples of how political or governmental actions have forced companies to alter or abandon strategies.
- What is the "riskiest possible posture" for a company in an industry that is rapidly becoming global, according to the lecture?
- Name three specific U.S. federal regulatory agencies (other than the EPA) that can have a major impact on organizational strategies.
π Lecture 10 β TECHNOLOGICAL FORCES
π Overview: This lecture examines the revolutionary impact of technological forces on organizational strategy, including specific technologies like the Internet and XML. It also introduces competitive analysis frameworks for evaluating rival firms, emphasizing the importance of systematic intelligence gathering for strategic management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers revolutionary technological forces (Internet, XML, UWB communications), how the Internet changes opportunities and threats, capitalizing on Information Technology through CIOs and CTOs, technology-based issues underlying strategic decisions, competitive forces identification, key questions about competitors, characteristics of competitive companies, and competitive intelligence programs.
π Lecture Summary
Revolutionary technological forces
Revolutionary technological changes and discoveries such as superconductivity, computer engineering, thinking computers, robotics, miracle drugs, lasers, cloning, satellite networks, fiber optics, biometrics, and electronic funds transfer are having a dramatic impact on organizations. Superconductivity advancements alone, which increase the power of electrical products by lowering resistance to current, are revolutionizing business operations, especially in transportation, utility, health care, electrical, and computer industries.
The Internet is acting as a national and even global economic engine spurring productivity, a critical factor in improving living standards. The Internet is saving companies billions of dollars in distribution and transaction costs. The familiar Hypertext Markup Language (HTML) is being replaced by Extensible Markup Language (XML). XML is a programming language based on "tags" whereby a number represents a price, an invoice, a date, a zip code, or whatever. XML is forcing companies to make a major strategic decision: whether to open their information to the world in the form of catalogs, inventories, prices, and specifications, or attempt to hold their data closely to preserve some perceived advantage. XML is reshaping industries, reducing prices, accelerating global trade, and revolutionizing all commerce. Microsoft has reoriented most of its software development around XML.
Ultra-wideband (UWB) wireless communications sends information on tiny wave pulses and may soon replace continuous radio waves, allowing ever-smaller devices to do vastly more powerful wireless communications. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is slow to approve UWB fearing disruption of existing wireless communication, but UWB technology has the potential to permanently change the way all individuals and businesses communicate worldwide.
π‘ Why this matters: These technologies represent fundamental shifts that alter entire competitive landscapes, making awareness of them essential for strategic planning.
Internet changes the nature of opportunities and threats
The Internet is changing the very nature of opportunities and threats by altering the life cycles of products, increasing the speed of distribution, creating new products and services, erasing limitations of traditional geographic markets, and changing the historical trade-off between production standardization and flexibility. The Internet is altering economies of scale, changing entry barriers, and redefining the relationship between industries and various suppliers, creditors, customers, and competitors.
Capitalizing on Information Technology (IT)
To effectively capitalize on information technology, many organizations are establishing two new positions: chief information officer (CIO) and chief technology officer (CTO). This trend reflects the growing importance of information technology in strategic management. A CIO and CTO work together to ensure that information needed to formulate, implement, and evaluate strategies is available where and when needed. These persons are responsible for developing, maintaining, and updating a company's information database. The CIO is more a manager, managing the overall external-audit process; the CTO is more a technician, focusing on technical issues such as data acquisition, data processing, decision support systems, and software and hardware acquisition.
Technology-based issues
Technological forces represent major opportunities and threats that must be considered in formulating strategies. Technological advancements can dramatically affect organizations' products, services, markets, suppliers, distributors, competitors, customers, manufacturing processes, marketing practices, and competitive position. Technological advancements can create new markets, result in a proliferation of new and improved products, change relative competitive cost positions in an industry, and render existing products and services obsolete. Technological changes can reduce or eliminate cost barriers between businesses, create shorter production runs, create shortages in technical skills, and result in changing values and expectations of employees, managers, and customers. Technology-based issues will underlie nearly every important decision that strategists make.
In practice, critical decisions about technology are too often delegated to lower organizational levels or made without understanding their strategic implications. Firms not managing technology to ensure their futures may eventually find their futures managed by technology. Technology's impact reaches far beyond "high-tech" companies. Not all sectors of the economy are affected equally; the communications, electronics, aeronautics, and pharmaceutical industries are much more volatile than the textile, forestry, and metals industries.
Some technological advancements expected soon include computers that recognize handwriting, voice-controlled computers, gesture-controlled computers, picture phones, and defeat of heart disease, AIDS, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis, leukemia, and lung cancer.
Competitive Forces
"Collection and evaluation of information on competitors is essential for successful strategy formulation." Competition in virtually all industries can be described as intense. An important part of an external audit is identifying rival firms and determining their strengths, weaknesses, capabilities, opportunities, threats, objectives, and strategies.
The lecture provides a table showing the top five U.S. competitors in four industries (Aerospace, Forest Products, Computers, Publishing) with their 1999 sales, percentage change from 1998, profits, and percentage change from 1998. For example, in Aerospace, Boeing had $57,993 million in sales with a +3% change and $2,309 million in profits with a +106% change.
Collecting and evaluating information on competitors is essential for successful strategy formulation. Identifying major competitors is not always easy because many firms have divisions that compete in different industries. Most multidivisional firms do not provide sales and profit information on a divisional basis, and privately held firms do not publish financial or marketing information. Information can be found in publications such as Moody's Manuals, Standard Corporation Descriptions, Value Line Investment Surveys, Ward's Business Directory, Dun's Business Rankings, Standard & Poor's Industry Surveys, and business magazines. Many businesses use the Internet to obtain most competitor information because it is fast, thorough, accurate, and increasingly indispensable.
The lecture provides twelve key questions about competitors, including: their strengths and weaknesses, their objectives and strategies, how they respond to external variables, their vulnerability to alternative strategies, product positioning relative to competitors, entry and exit of firms, key factors for current position, sales and profit rankings over time, nature of supplier and distributor relationships, and the threat of substitute products.
Key Questions About Competitors
- What are the major competitors' strengths?
- What are the major competitors' weaknesses?
- What are the major competitors' objectives and strategies?
- How will major competitors respond to current trends affecting the industry?
- How vulnerable are major competitors to alternative company strategies?
- How vulnerable are alternative strategies to successful counterattack?
- How are products positioned relative to major competitors?
- To what extent are new firms entering and old firms leaving the industry?
- What key factors resulted in the present competitive position?
- How have sales and profit rankings changed over recent years?
- What is the nature of supplier and distributor relationships?
- To what extent could substitute products be a threat?
Seven characteristics describe the most competitive companies in America
- Market share matters; the 91st share point is more important than the 90th, and nothing is more dangerous than falling to 89th
- Understand and remember precisely what business you are in
- Whether it's broke or not, fix itβmake it better; not just products, but the whole company if necessary
- Innovate or evaporate; particularly in technology-driven businesses, nothing quite recedes like success
- Acquisition is essential to growth; most successful purchases are in niches that add a technology or related market
- People make a difference
- There is no substitute for quality and no greater threat than failing to be cost-competitive on a global basis
Competitive Intelligence Programs
Every organization must have an intelligence program. It should be a systematic and ethical process for gathering and analyzing information about the competition's activities and general business trends to further a business's own goals.
π Definition β Competitive Intelligence Program: A systematic and ethical process for gathering and analyzing information about the competition's activities and general business trends to further a business's own goals.
β Key Takeaways
Technological forces like the Internet, XML, and UWB are revolutionizing business operations and must be monitored strategically. The Internet alters product life cycles, distribution speed, market limitations, economies of scale, and entry barriers. Organizations need CIOs and CTOs to manage information technology strategically. Competitive analysis requires identifying rival strengths, weaknesses, objectives, and strategies through ethical intelligence programs. The seven characteristics of competitive companies emphasize market share, innovation, quality, and cost-competitiveness.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are three revolutionary technological forces discussed, and how does each impact organizations?
- How does the Internet change the nature of opportunities and threats for businesses?
- What are the distinct roles of a CIO versus a CTO in an organization?
- What are the twelve key questions that should be asked about competitors during an external audit?
- What are the seven characteristics that describe the most competitive companies in America?
π Lecture 11 β Industry Analysis
π Overview: This lecture focuses on industry analysis using Porter's Five-Forces Model and the External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix. It explains how to systematically evaluate external opportunities and threats, and introduces the Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM) for comparing a firm's strategic position against its competitors. These tools are essential for effective strategic management and decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers competitive intelligence programs and the five forces that shape industry competition: rivalry among competing firms, potential entry of new competitors, potential development of substitute products, and the bargaining power of suppliers and consumers. It then discusses the global challenges faced by Pakistani firms, followed by a detailed explanation of the five-step process for constructing an External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix, including an illustrative example for UST, Inc. The lecture concludes with the Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM), its differences from the EFE Matrix, and a sample CPM analysis.
π Lecture Summary
Competitive Intelligence Programs and competitive analysis
Competitive intelligence is defined as a systematic and ethical process for gathering and analyzing information about the competitionβs activities and general business trends to further a businessβs own goals. The central point is the rivalry among competing firms, focusing on how they compete and to what extent. The potential entry of new competitors can be a threat to some and an opportunity for others, while the potential development of substitute products also increases competition, especially if the substitute offers higher quality. The collective bargaining power of suppliers and consumers is influenced by market dynamics; if vendors are fewer than buyers, supplier demand increases, and vice versa. These five components form the basics of competitive analysis and are illustrated in Porterβs Five-Forces Model.
π Definition β Competitive Intelligence: Systematic and ethical process for gathering and analyzing information about the competitionβs activities and general business trends to further a businessβ own goals.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these five forces helps a firm anticipate changes in its competitive environment and formulate strategies to defend its position.
Global challenge
Pakistani firms face two key international challenges. The first and bigger challenge is how to gain and maintain exports to other nations, which requires research on market retention as competition increases. The second challenge is how to defend domestic markets against imported goods, which also depends on research and compliance with export laws.
Industry Analysis: The External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix
An External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix allows strategists to summarize and evaluate economic, social, cultural, demographic, environmental, political, governmental, legal, technological, and competitive information. The EFE matrix is developed through a five-step process.
Five-Step Process:
- List key external factors (10-20): Include both opportunities and threats affecting the firm and its industry. List opportunities first, then threats. Be specific, using percentages, ratios, and comparative numbers.
- Assign a weight to each factor (0.0 to 1.0): The weight indicates the relative importance of the factor to success in the firm's industry. The sum of all weights must equal 1.0.
- Assign a rating of 1-4 to each factor: This indicates how effectively the firm's current strategies respond to the factor, where 4 = superior response, 3 = above average, 2 = average, and 1 = poor response. Ratings are company-based, while weights are industry-based.
- Multiply each factor's weight by its rating: This produces a weighted score for each factor.
- Sum the weighted scores: This determines the total weighted score for the organization.
Interpretation of the Total Weighted Score:
- Highest possible score: 4.0 β The organization is responding outstandingly to opportunities and threats.
- Lowest possible score: 1.0 β The firm's strategies are not capitalizing on opportunities or avoiding threats.
- Average score: 2.5
π Formula: Total Weighted Score = Ξ£ (Weight Γ Rating) for each factor.
π Example: The lecture provides an EFE Matrix for UST, Inc., a smokeless tobacco manufacturer. Key opportunities included untapped global markets (weight 0.15, rating 1, weighted score 0.15) and Pinkerton's leadership in the discount market (weight 0.15, rating 4, weighted score 0.60). Key threats included the Clinton administration (weight 0.20, rating 1, weighted score 0.20) and legislation against the tobacco industry (weight 0.10, rating 2, weighted score 0.20). The total weighted score for UST was 2.10, indicating it is below average in capitalizing on external opportunities and avoiding threats.
π‘ Why this matters: A thorough understanding of the factors used in the EFE Matrix is more important than the actual weights and ratings assigned. The matrix is a tool for assimilating information.
The Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM)
The Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM) identifies a firm's major competitors and their particular strengths and weaknesses in relation to a sample firm's strategic position. While the weights and total weighted scores have the same meaning as in the EFE Matrix, there are key differences:
- Broader factors: The critical success factors in a CPM are broader, include internal and external issues, and are not grouped into opportunities and threats.
- Different ratings: Ratings refer to strengths and weaknesses, where 4 = major strength, 3 = minor strength, 2 = minor weakness, and 1 = major weakness.
- Comparative analysis: The ratings and total weighted scores for rival firms can be compared to the sample firm.
π Example: The lecture provides a sample CPM comparing Avon, L'Oreal, and Procter & Gamble. Critical success factors included Advertising (weight 0.20) and Global Expansion (weight 0.20). Avon had a total weighted score of 3.15, L'Oreal scored 3.25, and Procter & Gamble scored 2.80, making Procter & Gamble the weakest firm overall. Note: A 3.2 rating versus a 2.8 rating does not mean the first firm is 20% better; numbers reveal relative strength but their implied precision is an illusion.
π Definition β Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM): A tool that identifies a firm's major competitors and their particular strengths and weaknesses in relation to a sample firm's strategic position. π Formula: Total Weighted Score = Ξ£ (Weight Γ Rating) for each critical success factor.
π‘ Why this matters: The aim of the CPM is not to arrive at a single number but to assimilate and evaluate information in a meaningful way that aids in decision-making.
β Key Takeaways
Porter's Five-Forces Model (rivalry, new entrants, substitutes, supplier power, buyer power) provides a foundational framework for competitive analysis. The EFE Matrix is a structured five-step tool to summarize and evaluate a firm's external opportunities and threats, with a total weighted score of 4.0 being outstanding and 1.0 being poor (average is 2.5). The CPM expands on this by including both internal and external factors, allowing for a direct comparison of a firm's strategic strengths and weaknesses against its competitors, using a rating scale where 4 is a major strength and 1 is a major weakness. The most critical insight is that the thorough understanding of the factors used in these matrices is more important than the precise numerical weights and ratings assigned. Ultimately, these tools are meant to inform, not replace, good intuitive judgment in strategic decision-making.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five forces in Porter's Five-Forces Model and how do they collectively determine the intensity of industry competition?
- Describe the five steps involved in constructing an External Factor Evaluation (EFE) Matrix.
- What is the difference between a "weight" and a "rating" in an EFE Matrix, and what do they each signify (industry-based vs. company-based)?
- If a firm has a total weighted score of 3.2 on an EFE Matrix, what does this indicate about its strategic response to its external environment?
- How does the rating scale in a Competitive Profile Matrix (CPM) differ from the rating scale in an EFE Matrix, and what is the main purpose of using a CPM?