📘 Lecture 6 — The Development of SMEs in Pakistan
📖 Overview: This lecture explores Pakistan's industrial history, which was dominated by large-scale enterprises, and the economic and political consequences of that strategy. It argues for a paradigm shift towards an SME-based industrial system, detailing the factors that make SMEs suitable for Pakistan's current situation and the necessary pre-requisites for their development. The lecture emphasizes that SME development offers a path to more equitable wealth distribution, technological progress, and sustainable economic growth.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the industrial history of Pakistan, highlighting the dominance of large-scale enterprises and the fallout of that strategy, including political rebellion and nationalization. It then outlines the factors for adopting an SME-based system, such as low overheads and employment generation. The pre-requisites for SME development are discussed, focusing on an infrastructure with a customized banking system and a one-window operation. Finally, the lecture details the benefits of SME development, including just distribution of wealth, technological advancement, and the dignity of work, using examples from the auto sector and developed economies like Japan and Italy.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Industrial History of Pakistan
Pakistan’s industrial history was dominated by a single-minded emphasis on large-scale enterprises culminating from a policy adopted in the 1960-1965 plan. This led to large industrial holdings where a few families controlled a vast portion of the country’s assets. The resulting political rebellion contributed to the dismemberment of the eastern part of the country, with economic issues being the primary cause. This upheaval led to a parallel economic thought advocating for nationalization of economic assets to ensure social justice. The fallout of nationalization was two-pronged: inefficient labor and shaken business confidence.
In the early 1980s, the policy reverted to the Ayubian model, characterized by:
- Promotion of large-scale units.
- Expansion of large-scale enterprises.
- A banking sector that catered to large loans.
The subsequent recession, pushed by poor recovery rates of huge borrowings and IMF conditions, led to a rethinking of economic strategy. This dis-involvement with large industry brought Medium and Small-scale Enterprises (SMEs) to the attention of stakeholders.
Factors for Adopting an SME Based Industrial System
The development of SMEs suits the current situation due to the following factors:
- Low overhead cost, low level of financing
- Lesser pressure on the banking system
- Employment generation
- Entrepreneurial development
- Vendor-based development
- Development of large-scale industry on a firm basis
- A more just distribution of resources and profits
The pre-requisites for this development rest heavily on an infrastructure tuned to support it, including: a banking system customized for SME development and a one window operation. Currently, the banking system remains a "large sector banker," and in the absence of a customized setup, SME development has been evolutionary, not conscious.
An enabling environment, including a one-window operation culture, is a pre-requisite for all economic activity. A conscious effort by the state to reform the banking setup and the attitude of government functionaries and bureaucracy is needed to change the development strategy priorities.
The Mechanics of SME Development
SME development does not depend on the expansion of family enterprises; rather, it is the outcome of the initiative of a single individual. An SME does not seek to control the market but identifies its place and sustains it. For example, vendors in the auto sector maintain their share as sustainable vendors, not blocking the market for new entrants.
The small overheads involved in a SME unit mean each unit does not need excessive financing, allowing a large section of society to benefit. Money circulates in a way that people can derive the needed benefit, preventing wealth accumulation in a few hands. The availability of resources means the opportunity to develop is not confined to a restricted section of society; anyone with an idea and plan can create a place for themselves. The success of venture capital in the US, and stories like Yahoo, Hotmail, Microsoft, and Linux, are indicative of the SME as a vehicle for equal opportunity and technological development. Bill Gates was not a Kennedy scion, but the opportunity to develop from an SME allowed him room.
💡 Why this matters: The SME model can create a more egalitarian economy where success is not predetermined by family background but by an individual's idea and effort, as seen in the IT sector which allowed professionals to prosper without being part of large enterprises.
Social and Economic Benefits
The recipe of SME development does two things:
- Processes are developed at a grassroots level. Vendors are identified and the production process takes off. Profits are naturally divided according to contribution, preventing the appearance of new big families.
- It fosters the dignity of work. Economies increasingly modeled on SME development, like Japan and Italy, are characterized by dignity of work, not for the sweat shed, but for the rewards which are ensured. This setup is linked to peace and the absence of militant trends.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents a strong case for shifting Pakistan’s economic strategy from a large-scale focus to an SME-based model. The primary drivers for this shift are historical failures of the large-scale approach (wealth concentration, political instability) and the SME model's inherent strengths (low capital requirement, employment generation, and just wealth distribution). The success of this model critically depends on a supportive infrastructure, specifically a customized banking system and a one-window operation for investors. Ultimately, the SME model is presented not just as an economic strategy but as a vehicle for social justice, technological development, and the dignity of work, with lessons drawn from successful economies like Japan and Italy.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What were the two main fallouts of the nationalization policy implemented after the 1960s?
- List four of the seven factors that make the development of SMEs suitable for Pakistan's current situation.
- What are the two critical pre-requisites for the development of the SME sector mentioned in the lecture?
- How does the lecture contrast the "modus operandi" of a typical SME with that of a large family-owned enterprise?
- Give two examples from the lecture (one from Pakistan and one from the US) that illustrate how SMEs can serve as a vehicle for equal opportunity and technological development.
📘 Lecture 8 — The ROLE Of NGOs
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the vital role of Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) in the socio-economic development of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs). It also introduces SMEDA (Small and Medium Enterprises Development Authority) as Pakistan’s premier institution for SME policy and development. Understanding these support structures is crucial for grasping how SMEs are fostered through external facilitation and government policy.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining NGOs and explaining their business models, including fair trade cooperatives and direct subcontracting roles. It then introduces SMEDA, covering its establishment, mission statement, objectives, and its role as a policy-advisory body and facilitator. Key concepts like NGO funding, stakeholder accountability, and SMEDA's policy formulation are examined.
📝 Lecture Summary
The ROLE Of NGOs
Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) are privately owned organizations registered under the social welfare act. They work on the socio-economic development of SMEs, operating through grants, aids, or donation-based finances. They are having a very constructive role in SME development, with a special property of gender development. At some places, they have tried to replicate the Grameen banks model.
🔑 Definition — NGO (Non-Governmental Organization): A non-for-profit agency not affiliated with any government or private sector entity, devoted to managing resources and implementing projects with the goal of addressing social problems. It may receive some public funding. An NGO is a community-based organization with its own management structure. The organization may receive some or all of its operating funds through a government department known as the funder; however, it is accountable or answerable to its stakeholders — the people who stand to benefit or lose by its actions. The funder is one of those stakeholders.
💡 Why this matters: NGOs play a vital role in reducing poverty and creating awareness, especially among women in rural areas, to develop small businesses in their own premises.
The NGO Business
Non-governmental Organizations have become involved in international trade in two different ways:
- Establishing fair trade cooperatives to facilitate the export of goods from developing to industrialized countries directly from the producers. Their underlying operating principle is to ensure that more of the profits from the sales of diverse products go to the producer and less to middlemen. Often these products are slightly more expensive than similar goods in the market, and these businesses rely on the social conscience of its customers to ensure a steady market for their products.
- Taking on the role of designer, marketer, and distributor of specific products. The NGO works with particularly disadvantaged groups, primarily women, as sub-contractors who are taught to produce the goods that the NGO sells. Thus, the NGO, in effect, becomes a private sector actor. How they differ from standard private sector producers is in their selection of subcontractors and the fact that all profits are invested back into the organization to ensure organizational sustainability and to expand their base of sub-contractors. Their subcontracting role also serves to empower their sub-contractors, as opposed to setting up an exploitative piecework arrangement. It provides a viable means for poor women to set up their own home-based enterprises. The key to the success of this particular strategy is the fact that the NGO takes on the responsibility for the development of the international market for the product produced.
SMEDA (Small and Medium Enterprises Development Authority)
Introduction SMEDA is the premier institution of the Government of Pakistan under the Ministry of Industries, Production & Special Initiative. It was established in October 1998 to take on the challenge of developing Small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in Pakistan. With a futuristic approach and professional management structure, it has focus on providing an enabling environment and business development services to small and medium enterprises. SMEDA is not only an SME policy-advisory body for the government of Pakistan but also facilitates other stakeholders in addressing their SME development agendas. Its goal is the growth of globally competitive SME sector through a conducive and facilitating environment and support services as an engine of growth and sustainability to the national economy.
Mission Statement To function as the promoter & facilitator of the SME sector in Pakistan by creating a conducive and facilitating environment as well as providing and facilitating service delivery to SMEs for enhancing their capabilities and competitiveness.
SMEDA Objectives
- Policy formulation to encourage the growth of SMEs in the country and to advise the Government on fiscal and monetary issues related to SMEs.
- Facilitation of Business Development Services to SMEs.
- Facilitate the development and strengthening of SME representative bodies, associations, and chambers.
- Set up and manage a service provider’s database including machinery and supplier for SMEs.
- Conducting sector studies and analysis for sector development strategies.
- Facilitation of SMEs in securing financing.
- Strengthening of SMEs by conducting and facilitating seminars, workshops, and training programs.
- Donor assistance for SME development through programs and projects.
- Assist SMEs in getting international certifications (such as UL, CE, DIN, JIS, ASME, KS, etc.) for their products and processes.
- Identification of service opportunities based on supply/demand gap.
⭐ Key Takeaways
NGOs are non-profit, community-based organizations that play a critical role in SME development through social welfare projects, often focusing on women empowerment and poverty reduction. Their business involvement includes fair trade cooperatives (ensuring producers get more profit) and acting as direct marketers/designers who subcontract disadvantaged groups, with all profits reinvested for sustainability. SMEDA, established in 1998, is Pakistan’s key government body for SME development, acting as a policy advisor and facilitator of business development services, financing, training, and international certifications. Students must remember the distinct roles of NGOs (socially driven, grant-funded) versus SMEDA (government policy body) in the SME ecosystem.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of an NGO, and who are its key stakeholders?
- What are the two main ways NGOs have become involved in international trade?
- How does the NGO's role as a subcontractor differ from a standard private sector arrangement?
- In what year was SMEDA established, and under which ministry does it operate?
- List any three objectives of SMEDA.
📘 Lecture 9 — Issues and Policy Development for SME – I
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the obstacles and issues faced by policymakers when forming an SME policy for Pakistan, covering both long-term and short-term challenges. It explains why SMEs have been historically neglected despite being central to the economy, and outlines the key areas that must be addressed—business environment, delivery of assistance, and monitoring—to develop a coherent national SME policy.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of Pakistan’s SME sector, including its current status and economic significance, the government’s socio-economic strategies and their limited focus on SMEs, and the critical lack of coordination among institutions such as SMEDA and other ministries. It presents three major short-to-medium term issue areas: creating a favorable business environment, improving delivery of assistance and access to resources, and monitoring SME development. The need for a cross-departmental stakeholder consultation to draft Pakistan’s first coherent SME policy is emphasized.
📝 Lecture Summary
Issues and Policy Development
Pakistan’s economy is fundamentally an economy of SMEs. Past policies have provided only a general perspective, defining broad macro-environment parameters, but efforts have focused on large enterprises, neglecting the SME sector that lies at the heart of the economy. Our SMEs suffer from a variety of weaknesses that have constrained their ability to adjust to economic liberalization measures and take advantage of rapidly expanding global markets. Despite their importance, SMEs are mentioned in some socio-economic strategies and policy documents, but measures are not specified or prioritized, so there is no coherent SME policy or approach. The SME Sector Development Program seeks to improve this by inviting all concerned stakeholders to draft Pakistan’s future SME policy.
SME promotion is an important issue for many government departments and central offices. However, there is an existing lack of coordination and regular information exchange among institutions, which constrains their ability to deliver in the SME development process. The responsibility for facilitating SME policy development lies with SMEDA, attached to the Ministry of Industry and Production. A major reason for the lack of coordination is that SMEDA has not been provided with a mechanism to initiate, coordinate, monitor, and evaluate SME development initiatives outside its own scope of activities. Therefore, cross-departmental and stakeholder consultations resulting in the preparation of our national SME policy are the key to success. A network of institutions stimulating the growth of SMEs is also being proposed. The issues highlighted in this lecture give a retrospective view while presenting a current picture of the SME business environment in Pakistan. Some issues can only be solved in the long term, while others can be addressed in the short to medium term. Short to medium term issues revolve around three major topics:
Business Environment — Creating a favorable business environment for SMEs in Pakistan’s economy and eliminating unnecessary obstacles that obstruct their development. This concerns the relationship between Government and SMEs, as well as specifically taxation and labor issues.
Delivery of Assistance and Access to Resources — Improving the delivery mechanism for assistance and access to resources for SMEs in Pakistan, including finance, business development services, qualified human resources, and technology, so as to improve their productivity and capacity for employment generation. Market-driven support programs are important to attain substantiality, maximize potential for cooperation with the private sector, and minimize distortions in the economy. Yet the structures for such a system still need to be mutually agreed and implemented in Pakistan.
Monitoring Developments — Harmonizing enterprise size categories for Pakistan (what constitutes micro, small, medium, and large enterprises). Furthermore, establishing a sound mechanism by which the development of the SME sector and the effectiveness of assistance provided to SMEs can be monitored. The risk is that we forego the benefits of learning from one another to continuously improve our support structures to meet the needs of the target groups. There is also ample scope to make use of SME promotion channels to achieve major aims related to equitable and sustainable socio-economic development which we have not yet exploited. Cases in point are gender development and environmental issues.
Implementing change requires the formulation of a policy for SME development and assigning specific responsibilities for its implementation and continuous improvement. A fair number of countries have opted for legislation on SME promotion. The appropriate format of the SME policy for Pakistan is to be decided by the Task Force.
💡 Why this matters: Without a coherent policy addressing these three major areas—business environment, access to resources, and monitoring—Pakistan’s SME sector cannot realize its potential for employment generation and economic growth.
Background of Basic Situation of SME and Their Support Structures
Current Status of SME
It is fair to say that our economy is an economy of SMEs. The significant role of SMEs is clearly indicated by research and statistics:
- Enterprises employing up to 99 persons constitute about 90% of all private enterprises in the industrial sector.
- SMEs employ some 78% of the non-agriculture labor force.
- They contribute over 30% to GDP, PKR 140 billion to exports, and 25% of manufacturing export earnings.
- They share 35% in manufacturing value added.
Stability of policy is a necessary condition for achieving and sustaining high levels of economic development. A desirable mix of various other policies can ensure stability. In Pakistan, past policies have given a general perspective, direction, and broad parameters of activity within the macro environment framework. However, efforts have remained limited, focusing on large enterprises, neglecting SMEs which are at the heart of the economy. For example, institutions established to facilitate business activity, like the Board of Investment (BOI), Export Promotion Bureau (EPB), and Central Board of Revenue (CBR), have been concentrating their efforts on large-scale industry.
The adverse influences of legal and regulatory frameworks affect all economic agents, but evidence suggests that small firms are discriminated against relatively to large firms. While large enterprises and established holding structures possess the necessary economic and human resource potential to cope with these difficulties, SMEs, due to their size and resulting peculiarities, are far less capable of adjusting and carrying on successful businesses. While spared direct statutory or administrative discrimination, SMEs remain subject to unequal treatment, which distorts the competitive environment for business. The economic significance of this bias is apparent: such an environment does not cater well to innovative activities from newly founded small firms, and the new job creation potential of the economy is thus constrained while the informal sector tends to grow. SMEs suffer from a variety of weaknesses that have constrained their ability to adjust to economic liberalization measures and to take full advantage of rapidly expanding world markets. But SMEs have significant potential to enhance their growth through appropriate regulations and promotion.
More recently, the importance of SMEs has been realized, with the Government’s efforts focusing on the hitherto neglected informal sector. The reason behind the increased stress on the SME sector is that SMEs promote entrepreneurial culture, create a wider base for employment generation, and are a primary vehicle for poverty eradication.
🔑 Definition — SME (in Pakistan’s industrial context): Enterprises employing up to 99 persons, constituting about 90% of all private industrial enterprises, employing 78% of non-agriculture labor, contributing over 30% to GDP, PKR 140 billion to exports, 25% of manufacturing export earnings, and 35% of manufacturing value added.
Government’s Socio-economic Strategies and SME
SMEs are a distinct pillar of the economy that needs to be given due attention. The sector requires specific policy and regulatory space to turn SMEs into an effective tool for driving the economy and increasingly contributing to economic growth and employment. The Government of Pakistan has developed a number of strategies for socio-economic development:
- Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP)
- Micro Finance Sector Development Program
- SME Sector Development Program
- Education Sector Reforms 2001-05
- Reform of Financial Sector
- Reforms in Tax Administration
While SMEs are mentioned in some of these important socio-economic strategies and policy documents, including even very specific measures for their promotion, these measures are not sufficiently specified and prioritized for us to be able to speak of any coherent SME policy or approach. The SME Sector Development Program seeks to improve this situation by inviting all concerned stakeholders to draft Pakistan’s future SME policy. Although SME policy is a sector-specific policy, it should be noted that the task of formulation is not a simple exercise. SMEs are a cornerstone of our economy, and many changes in existing legislation may have direct or indirect effects on SMEs, e.g., in labor law, financial law, export regulations, banking system regulations, and tax regulation. SME promotion therefore comes close to a crosscutting issue. Furthermore, the environment for SMEs is constantly changing, in particular with increased exposure to world markets due to the opening up of the economy. Therefore, SME policy within a socio-economic development strategy cannot be a one-off exercise. Only a process of regular review linked with predictable behavior by all stakeholders will ensure successful outcomes in the long run.
Coordination and Institutional Support
The role of government as a facilitator of business and its interaction with business support institutions is imperative for the establishment of a mutually beneficial relationship for the growth of the sector. SME promotion is an important issue for many government departments and central offices. For example:
- The Ministry of Labor plays an important role in shaping the labor market policy.
- The Federal Bureau of Statistics, the Ministry of Finance, and the Planning Division are pivotal for gathering information on the health of the SME population.
- The Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development and the Ministry of Science & Technology also influence the situation of SMEs.
- Provincial and local governments also take their share in responsibility.
However, there is an existing lack of coordination and regular information exchange mechanism among institutions, which constrains their collective ability to deliver in the SME development process. As a result of the Government’s recent efforts, two institutions—Small and Medium Enterprise Development Authority (SMEDA) and the SME Bank—were created. The responsibility for facilitating SME policy development now lies with SMEDA, which is attached to the Ministry of Industry and Production (MOIP). SMEDA is responsible for creation and coordination of Government policy for the SME sector. Parliament is responsible for monitoring policy and its implementation.
One of the major reasons for the lack of coordination is that SMEDA has not been provided with a formal mechanism to initiate, coordinate, monitor, and evaluate initiatives undertaken for SME development which fall outside its own scope of activities. Therefore, cross-departmental and stakeholder consultations, resulting in the preparation of our national SME policy, are the key to success. Regular information exchange mechanisms and networking need to be developed amongst our public and private sector institutions. There is a strong need to devise such an information exchange mechanism and redefine the role of institutions, specifying their functions in order to avoid duplication of efforts and allow the best possible usage of resources.
Under the SME Sector Development Program, it is expected that SMEDA:
- Prepares Government documents on policy regarding SME.
- Drafts relevant laws and regulations.
To form a collective view of all stakeholders, the SME Task Force has been established at MOIP, and SMEDA will serve as its secretariat. A network of institutions stimulating the growth of SMEs is being proposed. The institutions in this network cover all stakeholders involved in SME promotion: Regional Development Agencies, Business Support Centers, Chambers of Commerce, as well as other organizations established as initiatives of local communities.
🔑 Key Term — MOIP: Ministry of Industries and Planning (the ministry to which SMEDA is attached). 🔑 Key Term — Retrospective: Having effect in the past; looking back on past events.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Pakistan’s economy is fundamentally an SME economy, with enterprises employing up to 99 persons constituting about 90% of all private industrial enterprises and employing 78% of the non-agriculture labor force, yet past policies have neglected this sector in favor of large enterprises. The three critical short-to-medium term policy issues are: creating a favorable business environment (especially taxation and labor), improving delivery of assistance and access to resources (finance, business services, technology), and establishing monitoring mechanisms with harmonized enterprise size categories. The core institutional problem is the lack of coordination among government bodies, as SMEDA has not been given a formal mechanism to coordinate initiatives outside its own scope, making cross-departmental stakeholder consultations the key to formulating a coherent national SME policy. Finally, SME policy cannot be a one-off exercise—it requires a process of regular review and must address crosscutting issues including gender development and environmental sustainability.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What percentage of all private industrial enterprises in Pakistan are SMEs (employing up to 99 persons), and what percentage of the non-agriculture labor force do they employ?
- What are the three major short-to-medium term issue areas that should become the focus of Pakistan’s SME policy?
- Why has SMEDA been unable to effectively coordinate SME development initiatives across different government departments?
- Name at least four government socio-economic strategies that mention SMEs but have not led to a coherent SME policy.
- What is the role of the SME Task Force established at MOIP, and which institution serves as its secretariat?