π Lecture 20 β Guide Lines for Approaching Lenders β I
π Overview: This lecture provides essential guidelines for approaching lenders to obtain short-term credit. It explains the expectations of lending institutions from borrowers and how to reconcile the differing motivations of both parties. The lecture covers the bankβs lending criteria, the importance of preparation, and specific tips for presenting a loan request successfully.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining how to approach lenders and the differing motivations between borrower and lender. It then examines the bankβs lending criteria, including regulatory requirements from the State Bank of Pakistan and specific factors like cash flow, shareholder funds, security, expertise, reputation, and purpose. Finally, it details how to present a request for a short-term loan, with six practical tips including knowing the institution, giving prior notice, being well-prepared, seeking advice, being cautious about costs, and avoiding excessive βshopping around.β
π Lecture Summary
How to Approach Lenders
Your next step after exploring all means to improve liquidity is to decide whom to approach for short-term credit. Base this decision on financing sources available in Pakistan, their effectiveness, and your own experience and affinities. If domestic sources fail due to lack of resources or a weak financial sector, you may reach overseas institutions or private trade finance providers. Talk to your banker or a financial advisor before negotiating with customers or suppliers. The type or terms of credit should be closely linked to the method of payment you use to settle creditor invoices or that your customers use to pay you.
Your bankβs motivations differ from yours: the bank is interested in a good return on money lent and avoiding risk of non-payment, and it will not spend time evaluating your company without an adequate fee. Your aim is to get the best advice on payment mechanisms, obtain affordable credit, and be covered for all associated risks. Your bank may prefer to solve problems quickly using well-known techniques with least effort and risk, simply asking for security on fixed and current assets. However, your bank is also in competition with other institutions and will want to retain you if you are creditworthy and offer good growth potential.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these differing motivations helps you tailor your approach to align with the bankβs interests while protecting your own.
Bankβs Lending Criteria
There are no standard criteria for short-term credit; banks set their own internal rules, bound by regulations from the State Bank of Pakistan. There is usually a lending limit per customer. Banks must report any extra exposure to a customer or group of related customers beyond 30% of its unimpaired capital. As per prudential regulations, total accommodation availed by the borrower must not exceed 10 times of the total capital and reserves (free floats).
Another requirement: the debt equity ratio of the borrower may not exceed 60:40, and the ratio between current liabilities and current assets should not be less than 1:1. The bank should obtain a copy of the borrowerβs accounts for analysis and record purposes, related to the amount of financing required. Banks may sometimes invoke lending criteria or statutory regulations as a pretext for refusing a facilityβit is unwise to insist on borrowing from an unwilling lender.
Your request for short-term credit has greater chances of success if you satisfy these criteria:
- Good Cash Flow β Show positive performance and enough cash to cover all commitments.
- Adequate Shareholderβs Funds β Not over-committed to other lenders; have a reasonable proportion of your own capital.
- Adequate Security β All your assets should not already be pledged to other lenders.
- Expertise in Trading β A good record of successful trading is essential; beginners or those entering untried activities face difficulty.
- Good Reputation and Standing β References and credentials must be acceptable; backing from a reputable sponsor (well-known person, trade association, customer, or supplier) is helpful.
- Specific Purpose β Most institutions prefer loans linked to specific transactions, which must be explained in full detail, shown to be profitable, and self-liquidating (repaid from transaction proceeds).
π Definition β Self-liquidating loan: A loan where the money borrowed will be repaid from the proceeds of the transaction being financed.
π Formula: Debt Equity Ratio β€ 60:40 β This means the borrowerβs total debt (liabilities) should not exceed 60% of the total capital employed, with equity being at least 40%.
π Example: If a borrower has total assets of Rs. 10 million and the bank is considering a loan, the debt cannot exceed 60% of the capital structure. If equity is Rs. 4 million, debt can be at most Rs. 6 million. Additionally, if the borrowing companyβs current liabilities are Rs. 2 million, current assets must be at least Rs. 2 million to satisfy the 1:1 ratio.
Presenting Your Request for a Short-Term Loan
The way you approach a bank or lending institution is all-important. These tips are guided by elementary rules of courtesy and openness.
1. Know Whom You Are Dealing With Unless you are already a customer, find out all you can about the institution beforehand. Ask about othersβ experiences, seek advice from your trade association, chamber of commerce, or association of industry. Try to obtain a copy of the institutionβs annual report to see its affiliations, shareholders, and directors. Brochures and annual reports tell you about structure, organization, and services. Banks should also indicate their lending rates and provide a schedule of charges and fees.
2. Give Prior Notice of Your Intentions Always call for an appointment, or better still, write a letter or fax briefly stating who you are, what you do, how much you need to borrow, and why. It is usually preferable to meet the person in charge of short-term commercial lending or trade finance. If the institution is far away, be particularly careful about how you introduce yourself and what information you provide.
3. Be Well Prepared Your banker is busy; come quickly to the point. State who you are, what you do, how much money you need, and what you need it for. Be prepared to hand over a copy of your annual report or financial statements (balance sheet, profit and loss account, budget, etc.) as well as a brochure on your companyβs activities or products. Clearly state what you intend to do with the funds. If financing the purchase of goods or services for export, tell the whole story: whom you are buying from, whom you are selling to, how you intend to pay and get paid. Speak to your bank about these matters before signing contracts or making payment arrangements.
4. Seek Advice Experienced bankers can guide you on the risks and dangers of various payment methods, the most suitable way to finance transactions, and the security you should provide as a guarantee for borrowings. Remember to ask about hedging possibilities to cover or reduce risks of currency and price fluctuations.
5. But Be Cautious Resist borrowing more than you need, for too long, or at too high an interest rate. Banks sometimes propose credits or payment methods most familiar to them or that present the least risk to them. Ask about all costs: front-end fees (payments deducted from the loan at disbursement to cover evaluation and risk assessment costs), back-office fees (on each disbursement), and costs for foreign exchange or opening a documentary credit. Most institutions have standard or sliding scale rates; ask for a copy and seek guidance on how rates will affect your transactions. Obtain clarification on legal costs (lawyerβs fees, loan contracts, registering charges on assets) before committing to any obligation.
π Definition β Front-end fee: A fee deducted from the loan at the time of disbursement to cover the lenderβs cost of evaluating the request, assessing risk, or opening the loan account.
6. While Avoiding βShopping Aroundβ Bankers dislike the idea of you visiting several institutions and making comparisons. If you tell them you have found a better deal elsewhere after they have spent hours on your case, they will feel you wasted their time. There is nothing wrong with knowing the banking sector and wanting the best deal, but avoid giving the impression you are talking to others after negotiations are virtually finalized. The success of a good borrower-lender relationship is built largely on trust, developed over time through positive experience. The banker may first offer small, well-secured loans on a very short-term basis to see how it works. The cheapest lender may not, in the long run, prove the best.
β Key Takeaways
A successful approach to lenders requires understanding that banks are motivated by return and risk minimization, while borrowers seek advice, affordable credit, and risk coverage. The bankβs lending criteria include good cash flow, adequate shareholder funds, available security, trading expertise, good reputation, and a specific, self-liquidating purpose. When presenting your request, always know the institution, give prior notice, be thoroughly prepared with financial statements, seek advice, be cautious about hidden costs like front-end fees, and avoid excessive shopping around that damages trust. Building a long-term relationship based on trust is more valuable than finding the cheapest deal.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six key criteria a bank considers when evaluating a short-term loan request?
- Explain the difference between the borrowerβs and the lenderβs motivations when approaching a credit facility.
- What are the prudential regulations concerning the debt equity ratio and the ratio of current liabilities to current assets?
- Why is it important to βgive prior notice of your intentionsβ before meeting a lender, and what should the notice include?
- What are front-end fees and back-office fees, and why should you be cautious about them when negotiating a loan?
π Lecture 21 β Guide Lines for Approaching Lenders β II
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on how small business owners should approach lenders for financing. It focuses on the specific information and documents banks need to assess a loan request, including general credentials, personal and business profiles, and financial statements. The lecture emphasizes transparency, proper documentation, and the importance of presenting a credible case to secure funding.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main areas: general credentials required by lenders (including letters of introduction, personal profiles, business brochures, bank references, and proof of company ownership); a detailed checklist for preparing a career profile or curriculum vitae; the financial situation expected by lenders including balance sheets, profit-and-loss accounts, and cash-flow statements; prudential regulations for loan amounts below and above Rs. 2 million; and the need for current budgets and projected revenues based on firm orders rather than wishful thinking.
π Lecture Summary
What a Bank Needs to Know About You
This section discusses the information lenders may need before they can assess your request for finance. It is good policy to be as open and transparent with your bankers or financial advisers as you can. This will enable them to grasp the full situation and to give you appropriate advice. To withhold important information, such as your possible liabilities with other lenders or the fact that you have already pledged your assets, may cause difficulties at a later stage.
General Credentials
If the lender does not already know you well enough, it is best to have some general background information ready. This may include the following:
1. Letters of introduction β If you are relatively new in business and not yet known in your business community, you may seek the sponsorship of someone respected by other business people. A short letter setting out your achievements and testifying to your good character and integrity is a traditional method of introduction. Its effect will be positive if the referee is a person well regarded in the business community.
2. Your Profile β This is a resume or curriculum vitae setting out your educational achievements, professional training, qualifications and experience, and your employment record and achievements. If you are a newcomer to the business community, your profile will help your bank to assess your capacity for conducting trade, producing goods and services for export, and managing people. You may also attach any certificate or reference from former employers if this will help show your experience and capacities.
3. Brochure on your business β Your company brochure should state what business you are in, what your products are, and how long you have been trading. A list of clients or customers will be very helpful. If the list is confidential, you should say so when you give it to your banker. If you are in partnership or have directors in your company, state who they are and draw up a brief resume on each.
4. Bank and other references β If you are approaching an institution that is not your current bank, it is important to provide bank references that will enable the person you are discussing with to check your credentials, particularly regarding regularity of payments, past borrowing record, and general standing. You may also give the names of your accountants and lawyers if helpful.
5. Proof of company ownership or registration β You may be asked to provide evidence that the company belongs to you or has been duly registered. You may also be required to provide a sworn list of assets and liabilities in the absence of audited or approved accounts. Always try to find out beforehand whether there are any particular eligibility criteria for which you need to produce documents or statements.
Checklist for a Career Profile or Curriculum Vitae
Keep the profile or CV short β one to two pages at the most. Focus on significant information. Avoid too much detail. Your professional experience is the most important part of the profile. Present your profile in the order suggested below.
Name: Your given and family names.
Personal Details: Address, telephone and fax numbers; marital status; date of birth; nationality, or residence or work-permit status if you are an expatriate; state whether you are a home-owner; list your other significant assets (property, land, interest in other companies, etc.).
Education and qualifications: Start with your most recent qualifications, stating where obtained and in what year. Include relevant courses and seminars. There is no need to go back to your primary schooling. If you do not have valid qualifications or little educational background, leave this section out altogether. Your professional experience will be your best qualification.
Professional experience: This is the most important part of your presentation. Start with your most recent experience. For each firm you worked with, state the starting and ending dates (year or month and year), its name (if the firm is your own, say so), your job title, and your main area of responsibility. Very briefly, state your principal achievements in each job held. Examples would be: "exported US$ 450,000 worth of cotton garments yearly to Australia over a period of four years;" "managed the firm's assembly plant which employed 20 skilled workers and produced 850 components a month for export."
References: You should give the names of persons who can vouch for your professional capabilities as well as your integrity in business matters. Avoid naming senior government or civil service officials.
Financial Situation
A lender will most probably expect you to produce up-to-date financial information on your business. The standard financial reports you should have ready are:
Balance Sheet, Profit-and-Loss account, and Cash-Flow Statements:
According to the prudential regulations, if the loan amount is less than Rs. 2 million, financial accounts of the business signed by the borrower are required. The borrower and internal auditor of the bank, or a chartered accountant must sign the accounts where the loan amount exceeds Rs. 2 million. Accounts signed by a practicing Chartered Accountant, or by a practicing Cost and Management Accountant in case of a borrower other than public limited company (which is a subsidiary of a public company).
π Definition β Prudential Regulations: Banking rules that specify documentation requirements for different loan amounts to ensure proper financial oversight.
π Formula for Loan Documentation: Loan β€ Rs. 2 million β borrower-signed accounts required | Loan > Rs. 2 million β accounts signed by practicing Chartered Accountant or Cost and Management Accountant required
π Example: If a small business owner applies for a loan of Rs. 1.5 million, only the borrower's signature on financial accounts is needed. If applying for Rs. 3 million, the accounts must be signed by a practicing Chartered Accountant.
The size of your balance sheet and the amount of equity in your business are significant, but by no means the determining factor in your banker's decision to grant you short-term credit. Your banker may be far more concerned with the transactions that the facility will finance.
If your audited accounts are more than three months old (that is, if the closing date of the accounts goes back three months or more), you should also have with you a recent operating statement and cash flow statement.
Budget for the Current and Coming Year
This document should show your projected sales and revenues for the current period or the coming year, as well as your operating costs and overheads. You should also have a separate paper showing your planned capital expenditure, if any. Your budgeted (or estimated) revenue should be sufficiently detailed to be creditable. In other words, the figures must not be simply wishful thinking but based on firm and tentative orders to which you may add orders anticipated on the basis of past performance.
π‘ Why this matters: Lenders evaluate the credibility of your projections. If your budget appears unrealistic or unsupported by actual orders, it signals poor business planning and increases the likelihood of loan rejection.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical lesson from this lecture is that transparency with lenders is essential β withholding information about liabilities or pledged assets will cause problems later. Students must remember the five categories of general credentials needed: letters of introduction, personal profile/CV, company brochure, bank references, and proof of company ownership. For the CV, professional experience is the most important section and must be presented with specific achievements and quantifiable results. Regarding financial documentation, the prudential regulations specify that loans under Rs. 2 million require borrower-signed accounts, while loans above that threshold require signatures from practicing accountants. Finally, budgets and revenue projections must be based on firm orders and past performance β not wishful thinking β to be considered credible by lenders.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the five types of general credentials a lender may ask for when you approach them for financing?
-
What is the prudential regulation regarding who must sign financial accounts for a loan amount exceeding Rs. 2 million?
-
According to the lecture, what is the most important part of a career profile or curriculum vitae, and how should it be organized?
-
Why is it important to have a recent operating statement and cash flow statement if your audited accounts are more than three months old?
-
What does the lecture mean when it says budgeted revenue must be based on "firm and tentative orders" rather than "wishful thinking"?
π Lecture 22 β Guide Lines for Approaching Lenders β III
π Overview: This lecture details the essential prerequisites that every small and medium-scale industry owner must know before approaching a lender. It covers the critical importance of presenting commercial information, a formal business plan, and a feasibility study to secure credit, emphasizing preparation and credibility with financial institutions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture is organized around three main prerequisites for approaching lenders: preparing and presenting Commercial Information (including details of orders booked and the importance of not signing contracts before discussing credit with the bank), developing a comprehensive Business Plan (outlining its key components for a working capital facility), and conducting a detailed Feasibility Study (for medium- to long-term projects, including a checklist and note on its similarity to a business plan).
π Lecture Summary
Commercial Information
If you are requesting credit to fulfill a large or profitable new contract, it is advisable to have all relevant documents ready for discussion. This includes all documents, correspondence, quotations from suppliers, draft contracts with buyers and suppliers, and your own costing and calculations. This is especially important for export orders, as the credit facility from your bank will need to tie in with the payment methods used with your suppliers or stipulated by your overseas buyers. You are strongly advised not to sign any firm contract with suppliers or customers before you have discussed credit and payment methods with your bank. The reason is simple: most import-export contracts stipulate the form of payment and credit terms, and once the contract is signed, it may be too late to alter these terms, which could seriously limit the facilities your banker can offer.
Business Plan
If you have an up-to-date business plan for your company, showing intended capital investments and forecast revenue and expenditure for the coming three to five years, this is an excellent document to produce during discussions with your banker or financial adviser. If you do not have such a plan, you may find it useful to draw one up. It will be of great value to you personally and will also add to your credibility when discussing your credit request with lenders. You should be able to prepare such a plan yourself, with the assistance of your qualified staff, or you may ask an outside accountant or consultant to prepare it. An outline of a short, simple but effective business plan for a working capital facility includes:
- The business: Presentation of sponsors, shareholders; background and history; performance to date; and brief outline of objectives, strategy, and policies.
- Review of past turnover and future trading prospect: Analysis of past yearβs turnover; analysis of orders received and customer creditworthiness.
- The Market: Survey of the market for traded products.
- Production or procurement: Summary of production techniques or procurement procedures.
- Inputs: Raw materials required; sources, suppliers, costs.
- Organization and Management: Internal management structure; ordering, invoicing, back-office procedures.
- Financial data, projected results, economic justification: Planned capital and working capital expenditure; requirements for short-term credit; cash flow; projected profit-and-loss and balance sheets; economic benefits.
Feasibility Study
Feasibility studies are usually carried out in connection with medium- or long-term projects and are prepared, among other reasons, as an aid to raising medium- to long-term project loan finance. You will need to produce a feasibility study for such projects for presentation to your banker during your discussions. You should also give your banker copies of draft or actual loan agreements with other lending institutions. These are important because loan agreements may stipulate that you cannot borrow from another leader unless the loan is subordinated to them, which may mean you cannot pledge assets or can only provide a second charge. In many respects, the feasibility study is not dissimilar in its presentation to the business plan.
The checklist for a feasibility study includes:
- The Business: Same as a business plan.
- The export programme and equipment required: Detailed description of the proposed programme; details of equipment required, sources and costs.
- The Market: Summary of the market for traded products.
- Production or procurement: Summary of production techniques or procurement procedures.
- Inputs: Raw Material required; sources, suppliers, cost.
- Organization and management: Internal management structure; ordering, invoicing, back-office procedures.
- Eligibility for export incentives, promotional schemes: Benefits the business is entitled to.
- Financial data, projected results, economic justification: Planned capital and working capital expenditure; finance required; cash flow; projected profit-and-loss and balance sheets; economic benefits.
β Key Takeaways
For exam purposes, a student must remember that the three critical prerequisites for approaching a lender are commercial information, a business plan, and a feasibility study. Commercial information emphasizes having all contract documents ready and never signing a contract before discussing credit with the bank. A business plan is crucial for credibility, especially for short-term working capital, and should cover the business, market, operations, and financials. A feasibility study is required for medium-to-long-term project loans and is structurally similar to a business plan but includes a specific focus on equipment and export programs. Finally, any existing loan agreements must be disclosed as they can restrict further borrowing or asset pledging.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the most critical recommendation regarding signing a contract before discussing credit with a bank?
- List the eight key sections required in an outline of a business plan for a working capital facility.
- For what type of financial request is a feasibility study typically prepared?
- Why is it important to provide your banker with copies of draft or actual loan agreements from other lending institutions?
- How does the lecture describe the relationship between a feasibility study and a business plan?