π Lecture Summary
Lesson 40 β WTO Ministerial Conferences
The apex body of WTO, the Ministerial Conferences, has a mandate to meet at least once every two years to strengthen political guidance and enhance prominence and credibility of WTO rules. Four conferences had been held at the time, with the fifth scheduled for September 10-14, 2003.
First Ministerial, held in Singapore 1996, declared information technology tariff-free until the year 2000. It emphasized regional trade agreements and discussed further liberalization of services, but was unable to resolve controversies on issues like the link between trade and labour standards.
Second Ministerial, held in Geneva, discussed the US and EU demand of making E-Commerce tariff-free.
Third Ministerial, held in Seattle, was disrupted by violent protests by anti-globalization organizations and the conference failed to follow its proposed agenda.
Fourth Ministerial, convened at Doha in 2001, agreed to launch a new round of talks under the 'Doha Development Agenda' to take into account areas of interest of developing countries.
Fifth Ministerial, held in CancΓΊn, Mexico from 10-14 September 2003, was tasked with taking stock of progress in negotiations under the Doha Development Agenda.
Sixth Ministerial Conference was held in Hong Kong, China, 13-18 December 2005. In general, Ministerial Conferences are the WTO's highest decision-making body, meeting at least once every two years and providing political direction for the organization.
Doha Development Agenda
The Doha Round of negotiations includes critical issues such as production subsidies to Agriculture, TRIPs/Geographical Indications, access to generic medicines in case of public health crisis, requests/offers for services sector, antidumping agreement, revision and dispute settlement negotiations, market access to non-agricultural products, and Special and Differential treatment of developing countries.
Though deadlines for reaching agreement on modalities for negotiations on most issues have been missed, hopes remain alive and these matters would be taken up at the forthcoming Ministerial in Cancun, Mexico.
Pakistan and WTO
Pakistan, being a founding member of GATT, the predecessor of WTO, accepted all the Uruguay Round agreements and is in the process of implementing them. It is modifying its domestic legal and administrative rules to make them consistent with WTO rules. Under these agreements, Pakistan must open its market for full-blown foreign competition, must have stringent enforcement of Intellectual Property laws, and maintain international quality standards.
Pakistan committed to bind 33% of its tariff lines. Approximately 81% of agricultural import tariffs are bound, most at the ceiling rate of 100%. Tariffs on Tea, wheat, maize and sugar are bound at ceiling rate of 150%. For industrial products, tariffs are bound at 25% of its tariff, most at ceiling rate of 40-50%. For these products, tariff reductions were to take place in five equal installments beginning in July 1995. For products like leather items, travel goods, wood products, some textiles and certain equipment, tariffs are bound at ceiling rates of 22 to 30 percent. Tariff reduction on textiles and clothing are scheduled in 10 equal installments.
The textile sector, which contributes 67 percent to Pakistan's total exports, would in 2005 face severest competition from major suppliers like China, Hong Kong, Thailand, India and Bangladesh. Some progress has been made in facing the post-quota era to take textile production upwards in the value chain. It is apprehended that the MFA phase-out will start another era of non-tariff barriers (including social standards, child labour, environment, quality standards, anti-dumping duties etc.). With the phasing out of quotas, textile manufacturers in industrialized and some quota-free countries may decide to relocate; Government should notify policies providing incentives to ensure they relocate in Pakistan.
The country urgently needs to build a strong network of Anti-dumping and countervailing duties to protect local industry against unfair foreign competition. The Trade Policy 2003-04 envisages enhancement of capabilities of the National Tariff Commission (NTC). It is recommended that NTC be restructured and converted into an autonomous body employing private sector professionals with its chairman from the judiciary.
To enhance product credibility, Pakistan needs to adopt international quality standards including certifications of ISO-9000, ISO-14000 and other standards. The country needs to set up accredited testing laboratories for conformity assessment. Pakistan is committed to fulfilling TRIPs obligations, for which five laws have been promulgated. The Government announced establishment of PIPRO as an umbrella organization for improving administration and enforcement, but necessary legislation for PIPRO to start functioning is still pending.
Pakistan has done well by undertaking liberalization measures relating to communication and financial sectors under GATS. Pakistan, in collaboration with other LDCs, is pressing for further progress on movement of natural persons, which is an unfinished agenda of GATS. While Pakistan has paid great attention to exporting its own services, this needs rectification. Pakistan still lacks institutional and technical capabilities to develop, advocate and formulate standards and legislation to meet WTO requirements. While WTO offers technical assistance to developing countries, Pakistan has not tapped into these opportunities well. It is time to take full advantage of technical assistance and capacity building programs of WTO and other multilateral agencies.
Lastly, regionalism has assumed great importance in this era of globalization. It is high time to make SAARC and ECO more proactive to spur up intraregional trade to ward off the risk of being marginalized.
General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS)
Pakistan has participated in GATS negotiations but did not undertake extensive commitments. Pakistan signed the second protocol to GATS pertaining to financial services, applying to insurance, banking and other financial services. Pakistan also provided offers in negotiations on Basic Telecommunications which were completed on February 15, 1997.
Pakistan's schedule of specific commitments consists of both:
- Sector-specific commitments
- Horizontal commitments
Sector-Specific Commitments
The Sector-Specific Commitments cover 47 activities within business, communications, construction/engineering, health, financial and tourism/travel services. The GATS agreement recognizes 12 main sectors for classification of services:
- Communication
- Financial
- Construction/Engineering
- Health
- Tourism/Travel
- Distribution
- Education
- Environment
- Recreation/Culture
- Sporting
- Transport
- Others
Pakistan has so far made commitments in only the first six sectors: business services, financial services, communication services, health and related services, construction and related engineering services, and tourism and travel related services.
Pakistan also submitted two lists of MFN Exemptions β one relating to telecommunications on April 11, 1997, and the second relating to banking and other financial services on February 26, 1998. Under Article II of GATS, Pakistan maintains MFN exemptions for four financial services/activities with a view to presenting reciprocal requirements for:
- Islamic financing transactions
- Joint ventures among ECO countries
Pakistan also maintains exemptions in two identical communication services in favour of countries/operators signatories of bilateral agreements on rates with PTCL. Maintenance of Article II exemption is not unusual: 79 member countries have maintained 390 MFN exemptions. However, such exemptions should not exceed a period of ten years (beginning from 1995) and shall be subject to negotiation in subsequent trade liberalization.
The activity or Industry-Specific Commitments have been made under:
- Article XVI (Market Access)
- Article XVII (National Treatment)
MFN exemptions on the other hand originate from Article II of the GATS.
π Definition β MFN (Most Favoured Nation): A principle requiring that any advantage, favour, privilege or immunity granted to any country must be immediately and unconditionally given to all other WTO members.
Horizontal Commitments of Pakistan
The Horizontal Commitments of Pakistan β commitments that apply to all sectors β relate to "commercial presence" or "presence of natural person". Pakistan's commitments regarding commercial presence are subject to incorporation in Pakistan with maximum foreign equity of 51% unless different percentage is inscribed against a particular sector or sub-sector. All expenses of representative offices must be met by foreign remittances. A foreign undertaking is allowed to hire up to 50% of its total executive and specialist staff from abroad.
Acquisition of real estate by non-Pakistani entities and/or persons is subject to authorization on a case-by-case basis considering the purposes and location of the undertaking.
A study on Trade in Services commissioned by Ministry of Commerce, Government of Pakistan (March 2003) brought forth the following important findings:
-
Pakistan, like a large majority of countries, was rather cautious in its approach to GATS commitments. While it paid great attention to inward flow of foreign investment and technology, it did not view GATS as a means of expanding export of its services. The central lesson is that Pakistan should increase its objectives from inward investment and importation of foreign technology to expansion of its exports, including attraction of foreign investment, increased importation of modern technology, and promotion of exports of services.
-
Pakistan has already liberalized substantially at least 16 of its major services.
-
Pakistan should extend its interest to all four modes of supply instead of focusing on politically difficult one or two modes such as Mode 4 (movement of natural persons).
-
Government institutions concerned with the 12 sub-sectors of Services should prepare strategies aimed at promotion of their exports.
-
Pakistan should notify to the WTO Secretariat its own Enquiry and Contact point.
-
The Ministry of Education, in collaboration with the Engineering Council, needs to create a specialized institution to deal with issues relating to "mutual recognition" and pursue in particular the right conferred on member countries by Article 7 of the GATS.
-
The study recommends that Pakistan may undertake partial or full commitment at least in respect of those liberalization policies that have remained in force for five to seven years after proper evaluation of their impact.
It is a matter of great concern that exports in services sectors have grown marginally in Pakistan, while they grew four-fold in India and five-fold in China during the decade of the 1990s. The share of export and import of services in total exports and imports of Pakistan fell during the decade. Pakistan has done well by undertaking autonomous liberalization measures relating to communications and financial sectors, well over and beyond its commitments under GATS. Policies regarding telecommunication and banking are examples of 'autonomous liberalization', bringing technology and investment to these sectors.
Pakistan did not upgrade its commitments to the level of its higher actual liberalization partly because it was too early to bind its hands, partly because of lack of time-tested regulatory framework for services, but mainly because industrialized countries did not offer sufficiently attractive export opportunities for its service sector. These liberalization measures have not been translated into internationally binding commitments. Binding will provide an assured and relatively stable environment for investment for foreigners and overseas Pakistanis. The Government can offer to commit these policies as bargaining chips and seek credit for them. Attempts are made to obtain commercial quid pro quo.
Pakistan has received offers from 20 countries for talks for concluding Most Favoured Nation (MFN) treaties. It has not made any request for concessions because it has adopted a wait and see posture to see what concessions are announced at Cancun for developing countries.
π‘ Why this matters: Pakistan's cautious approach to binding its service sector liberalization commitments under GATS represents both a missed opportunity for securing stable investment environments and a strategic bargaining position that can be leveraged in future negotiations for better market access for its service exports.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that WTO Ministerial Conferences provide critical political direction for global trade governance, with the Doha Development Agenda representing a pivotal shift toward addressing developing country interests through negotiations on agriculture subsidies, TRIPs, and special and differential treatment. Pakistan faces the dual challenge of fulfilling WTO obligations including tariff bindings (33% of tariff lines, with agricultural tariffs at 100-150% ceiling rates) and TRIPs implementation while protecting domestic industry through anti-dumping mechanisms and quality standard certifications. The textile sector, contributing 67% of exports, confronts severe post-MFA competition from Asian rivals, necessitating value chain upgrading and relocation incentives. Under GATS, Pakistan has liberalized substantially in communications and financial services but failed to translate autonomous liberalization into binding commitments, missing opportunities to attract stable foreign investment and expand service exports. The critical strategic recommendation is that Pakistan must proactively utilize WTO technical assistance, pursue mutual recognition agreements, extend commitments across all four modes of supply, and leverage SAARC and ECO for intraregional trade to avoid marginalization in the global economy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What were the main outcomes and failures of each of the first five WTO Ministerial Conferences from Singapore (1996) through CancΓΊn (2003)?
-
What percentage of Pakistan's tariff lines are bound, and what are the specific ceiling rates for agricultural products (including tea, wheat, maize, and sugar) and industrial products?
-
What are the six sectors among the twelve GATS classification sectors in which Pakistan has made commitments, and what are the two Articles under which Industry-Specific Commitments are made?
-
What is the maximum foreign equity allowed under Pakistan's horizontal commitments for commercial presence, and what percentage of executive/specialist staff can be hired from abroad?
-
According to the Ministry of Commerce study (2003), why did Pakistan fail to upgrade its GATS commitments to match its actual liberalization levels, and what four strategic recommendations were made for improving Pakistan's services sector exports?
π Lecture 41 β WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION (WTO) PAKISTAN & WTO β I
π Overview: This lecture examines Pakistan's obligations and challenges as a WTO member, focusing on the Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement. It covers Pakistan's legislative framework for IPR protection, enforcement issues, and the proposed Pakistan Intellectual Property Rights Organization (PIPRO), along with Trade Related Investment Measures (TRIMs) and the Agreement on Textiles and Clothing (ATC).
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers TRIPS obligations and Pakistan's five promulgated IPR laws, enforcement mechanisms under TRIPS, the weak enforcement scenario and proposed PIPRO, international treaties Pakistan has joined, Pakistan's viewpoint on TRIPS provisions, TRIMs agreement and the deletion programme phase-out, and the ATC including back-loading concerns, safeguard actions, and textile sector preparedness for the post-quota era.
π Lecture Summary
Trade Related aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)
As a WTO member, Pakistan is committed to fulfilling TRIPS obligations. Copyrights piracy is considered very high, affecting imported computer software, videos, films, and textile designs. Pakistan, like developing countries, was given a deadline of January 1, 2000 (a five-year period) to bring its laws into conformity with WTO commitments, but Pakistan is not yet fully ready to implement its commitment.
In Pakistan, five laws/amendments have been promulgated to provide intellectual property protection under WTO standards:
- Patents Ordinance, 2002
- Trade Marks Ordinance, 2001
- Copyrights Amendments Ordinance, 2000
- Industrial Designs Ordinance, 2000
- Registration of Layout Designs of Integrated Circuits Ordinance, 2000
In industrial economies, intellectual property laws are regulated under a single umbrella organization to reduce regulatory impediments that discourage entrepreneurs from compliance. In Pakistan, all three areas (Copyrights, Trade Marks, and Patents) are managed separately by different federal ministries: Ministry of Education (Copyrights), Ministry of Commerce (Trademarks), and Ministry of Industries & Production (Patents). There is urgency for enforcement of laws regarding infringement of IPRs, for which necessary rules should be framed and notified on a priority basis.
General enforcement obligations under TRIPS
Pakistan's IPR legislation follows TRIPS standards by providing for civil and criminal remedies and broader measures for enforcement of IPRs. For all forms of intellectual property, civil remedies are available against infringement. All decisions of lower courts (district courts) are appealable in the High Court. Due process such as timely service of notice, right of being heard, production of evidence, etc., is available in IPR cases as in any other legal action in Pakistan. In any suit for infringement of IPR, in addition to provisional and border measures, courts may order remedies that act as effective deterrents to infringements of intellectual property.
Enforcement of IPRs
The enforcement of IPRs is a weak area in Pakistan, and this state of affairs makes Pakistan vulnerable not only to criticism but potentially also to trade retaliatory measures from trading partners. Pakistani manufacturers need to be very careful about infringement of IPRs to avoid possible trade sanctions. The American Business Council has suggested setting up an IPR Task Force.
WTO and Pakistan Intellectual Property Rights Organization (PIPRO)
To improve the administrative and enforcement scenario, the Government of Pakistan has approved the establishment of an umbrella organization called "Pakistan Intellectual Property Rights Organization" (PIPRO). As per Trade Policy 2003-04, necessary legislation will come soon so that PIPRO can start functioning. This organization is intended to fill much-needed gaps in IPR policy articulation, legal and enforcement issues, research and development, upgrading of outdated systems and procedures, coordination, and human resource development. Reportedly, the United States has offered technical assistance for the establishment of PIPRO. The importance of IPRs is further underscored by the fact that these are directly linked with signing of a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between USA and Pakistan.
International Treaties
Among the WIPO Conventions, Pakistan has joined the Universal Copyright Convention and is in the final stage of acceding to the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property.
Pakistan's Viewpoint
- All provisions of the TRIPS agreement must strike a balance between private rights and public policy objectives.
- Technical assistance for development and transfer of technology.
- In Geographical Indication, additional protection should be extended to products like Wine & Spirit.
- TRIPS Agreement to be made compatible with the Convention on Biodiversity β patents inconsistent with the convention must not be granted.
- Harmonization of the Convention on Bio-diversity and TRIPS Agreement on protection of traditional knowledge, Folklore, and Plant Breeders Rights.
- Maximum flexibility to adopt measures for public health and access to medicines.
- The Agreement should be reviewed to ensure how developmental objectives can be taken into account.
Trade Related Investment Measures (TRIMs)
Under the TRIMs Agreement, WTO members agreed not to apply any TRIMs inconsistent with GATT national treatment and quantitative restriction provisions, subject to exemptions permitted under GATT 1994.
Pakistan is committed to phasing out the "Deletion Programme" for automobiles, electronics, electrical products, and engineering items, which were to be phased out within five years of the entry into force of the agreement. However, the transition period could be extended on request of individual developing/LDCs if there are difficulties in eliminating them. Pakistan, along with six other developing countries, received an extension through the end of 2001, and in November 2001, further extensions were granted up to end-2003. Instead of the seven-year extension demanded by Pakistan, the WTO Council for Trade in Goods (CTG) granted only a two-year extension up to December 2003 for implementation of the deletion program. Reportedly, consideration of one further request for extension on the transition period is pending.
Textile and Clothing (ATC)
One of the principal objectives of Pakistan in the Uruguay Round (UR) was not only to achieve elimination of the Multi-Fibre Agreement (MFA) but full integration of textile and clothing into GATT to secure greater access to international markets.
However, the results of the UR Agreement on Textile and Clothing were disappointing for Pakistan. Almost half (49%) of the products of textile and clothing were left to be integrated in the final year of the 10-year integration period. This "back loading" suggests that meaningful full integration will take place in the final stage, and at that time developed countries may either impose new restrictions or impose Anti-dumping or other Safeguard measures to restrict market access.
In mid-1996, Pakistan presented to the WTO Goods Council a paper on behalf of WTO members arguing that developed importing countries were not living up to the liberalizing spirit of the Agreement. The exporters raised concerns that most of the commercially meaningful items were being left until the last stage of integration.
Developed countries were using transitional safeguard measures to protect their industries on the plea that surges of imports of specific products were causing serious damage to their industries. In the first year of ATC, two transitional safeguard actions were taken by the USA to restrict textile imports from Pakistan. The US government adopted delaying tactics for fulfillment of 3-year quota restrictions imposed in October 1999 on imports of combed cotton yarn from Pakistan.
Although the Textile Monitoring Body (TMB) gave its decision in favour of Pakistan, the US government did not pay any attention. The Government of Pakistan initiated proceedings with the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) and received a favourable decision, whereupon the US filed an appeal with the DSB for review. Finally, Pakistan received a decision in its favour, but the damage was already done.
π‘ Why this matters: The ATC experience demonstrates that even when a developing country wins a WTO dispute, the time taken for resolution can still allow significant economic damage to occur.
Pakistan's exports in 2005 would face severest competition from major suppliers like China, Hong Kong, Thailand, and Bangladesh. Potential growth of Pakistani exports depends on the ability of producers to improve the quality of their exports, improvements in productivity, and restructuring of the domestic industry.
The textile sector, which contributes 67% to total exports, has made some headway in facing the post-quota era after January 2005. Under Textile Vision 2005, the industry planned to invest 6 billion dollars in a phased program to take production of textile goods upwards in the value chain. In the last four years, the textile sector has invested US$ 2 billion for BMR (Balancing, Modernization, and Replacement) to bring their production at par with world quality. There has been a quantum jump in exports of value-added textiles during 2002-03: three more value-added items β knitwear, bedwear, and ready-made garments β have joined fabrics in the elite club of billion dollars in export of textile goods.
However, pressure is mounting on the textile industry from foreign buyers for compliance with social, labour, health, hygienic, and environment standards. This needs to be addressed on top priority basis.
It is apprehended that the implementation of WTO and the MFA phase-out will start another era of non-tariff barriers by developed countries. These non-tariff barriers consist of a long list of social standards and social issues, including child labour, environment, and other quality standards.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Pakistan faces significant challenges in implementing TRIPS obligations due to fragmented IPR administration across three separate ministries, weak enforcement mechanisms, and the pending establishment of PIPRO as a unified umbrella organization. The TRIMs agreement required phasing out Pakistan's deletion programme, with extensions granted only up to 2003 rather than the requested seven years. Under the ATC, Pakistan experienced "back-loading" where developed countries left 49% of textile integration until the final year, faced US safeguard actions on combed cotton yarn that required DSB intervention, and now confronts new non-tariff barriers related to social and environmental standards. The textile sector invested US$2 billion in BMR and achieved quantum jumps in value-added exports, but must prepare for intense post-2005 competition. Pakistan's official TRIPS position emphasizes balancing private rights with public policy, protecting traditional knowledge, ensuring access to medicines, and linking IPRs with biodiversity conventions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five IPR laws promulgated by Pakistan to comply with WTO TRIPS standards, and which federal ministries manage each area of IPR?
- Why was Pakistan's enforcement of IPRs considered weak, and what was the proposed solution through PIPRO?
- What was the "deletion programme" under TRIMs, and how did Pakistan's experience with transition period extensions unfold?
- What does "back-loading" refer to in the context of the Agreement on Textiles and Clothing, and how did it affect Pakistan?
- What was the outcome of Pakistan's DSB case against the USA regarding combed cotton yarn, and what lesson does this teach about WTO dispute resolution?
π Lecture 42 β World Trade Organization (WTO) Pakistan & WTO β II
π Overview: This lecture examines Pakistan's engagement with WTO trade remedies, particularly anti-dumping measures, and their impact on domestic industry. It also covers customs valuation reform, agricultural trade liberalization challenges, and Pakistan's struggle to protect its exporters while building institutional capacity for trade defense.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture addresses anti-dumping definitions and antidumping duties under GATT Article 6, Pakistan's experience with anti-dumping cases against its textile exports, the National Tariff Commission's role in implementing anti-dumping laws, procedural issues with customs valuation under the GATT code, and the mixed effects of WTO agriculture agreements on Pakistan's exports of rice, wheat, fruits, and cotton.
π Lecture Summary
Anti-Dumping
In economics, dumping can refer to any kind of predatory pricing. However, the word is now generally used only in the context of international trade law, where dumping is defined as the act of a manufacturer in one country exporting a product to another country at an unfairly low price.
π Definition β dumping: the act of a manufacturer in one country exporting a product to another country at an unfairly low price.
Antidumping Duty
An antidumping duty is a penalty charge on imports to protect domestic industry against disruptive pricing practices by foreign firms. An antidumping duty is supposed to be set equal to the margin of dumping, defined as the difference between fair value and the actual sales price. GATT Article 6 permits members to levy antidumping duties, while the GATT Antidumping Code attempts to standardize and discipline importing governments' activities in this area.
π Definition β antidumping duty: a penalty charge on imports to protect domestic industry against disruptive pricing practices by foreign firms. π Formula β margin of dumping = fair value β actual sales price β this difference determines the antidumping duty amount. π Example: Pakistan's exports of textile and clothing have been subjected to anti-dumping and safeguard measures in Japan, EU, and USA. The EU is presently investigating a dumping case against Pakistan bed-linen exporters.
There is prima facie evidence that cases of imposition of Anti Dumping Duties (ADDs) against different sub-sectors of the textile industry have been registered in order to protect jobs of textile industries of developed countries. This is seriously impacting on Pakistan's economy. Even in cases where investigations do not lead to eventual imposition of definitive ADDs, trade is disrupted in the interim period and valuable customers are lost.
Given the backdrop of increasing anti-dumping measures against our exports, we need to implement anti-dumping measures to protect domestic industry against the onslaught of unfair competition. In this context, following ordinances have been promulgated in Pakistan:
- Anti dumping law 2000
- Countervailing Duties Ordinance 2001
- Safeguard ordinance 2002
National Tariff Commission (NTC), with the assistance of CBR, has been assigned the task to implement these ordinances in Pakistan. Since the promulgation of Anti-dumping law, NTC has levied 27.33% anti-dumping duty for a period of 5 years on Tinplates of thickness of less than 0.5 mm and width of 600mm or more imported from South Africa. It has also imposed provisional anti-dumping duty at the rate of 96.50% on Roquette Freres of France and 91.12% on P.T. Sornini Corporation of Indonesia, for allegedly dumping Sorbitol 70% Solution, a sweetener of pharmaceuticals.
π‘ Why this matters: Pakistan has resorted to anti-dumping measures only twice in the eight years of WTO regime, as against 100 occasions by India. The country urgently needs to build a strong network of ADDs and CDs to protect the local industry. The Trade Policy 2003-04 envisages enhancement of capability of National Tariff Commission in the sphere of anti-dumping and countervailing duties and safeguards measures.
Dispute Settlement Body
The developing countries including Pakistan are facing problems of hiring law firms to advise and represent them in WTO related cases. Exorbitant fees of these law firms ranging from US$ 200 to US$ 600 an hour restrict the developing countries from seeking relief. This underscores the need to train local lawyers with WTO expertise.
π Example: Law firm fees of US$ 200 to US$ 600 per hour make it difficult for developing countries like Pakistan to pursue WTO dispute cases.
Customs Valuation
After availing the grace period of 5 years, the Finance Act 1999-2000 amended the Section 25 of the Customs Act 1969 to accommodate the necessary changes for adoption of GATT code of valuation based on transaction value.
There is, however, a general complaint that rules and regulations are not being observed by customs officials with respect to customs valuation. Instead of observing the transactional value system, they apply various procedures including the fixation of ITP on the basis of weak evidences, loading of the declared value with or without any evidence, or any other method devised by the assessing officer on case-to-case basis.
Agriculture
It is expected that under UR Agreement, market forces would result in domestic prices rising to world prices, which would stimulate domestic production. Tariffs in developed countries were reduced by 36% on fruits and vegetables, and 48% for such non-traditional products as flowers, providing Pakistan improved export opportunities.
The result on rice and wheat could have mixed effects. The agreement to reduce subsidies on rice and wheat maintained by developed countries could result in increased market access. The reduction on subsidies and resulting price increase would mean that total expenses of Pakistan for wheat imports, in wheat deficit years, will rise. Pakistan is not fully availing of investment subsidies generally available to agriculture and other input subsidies admissible under AoA. Besides, provision on S&DT treatment permits developing countries to use subsidies to reduce cost of making exports of agricultural products including upgrading and other processing costs and the cost of internal and external transport and freight. But GOP is not extending such subsidies to the warranted level on the pretext of budgetary constraints.
π‘ Why this matters: It is ironic that while developed countries are slow in phasing out subsidies under WTO regime, most of the reductions in farm subsidies in Pakistan so far have been made under the commitments to IMF, ADB and other international financial institutions.
According to Pakistan's WTO Representative, substantial reduction in tariffs and farm subsidies would mean greater market access to Pakistani agricultural products. Pakistan's cotton would fetch better prices for our farmers.
π Example: Tariff reductions: 36% on fruits and vegetables, 48% on non-traditional products like flowers in developed countries β providing Pakistan improved export opportunities.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that anti-dumping duties are penalty charges set equal to the margin of dumping (fair value minus sales price) under GATT Article 6, and that Pakistan has promulgated three key ordinances (Anti-dumping law 2000, Countervailing Duties Ordinance 2001, Safeguard ordinance 2002) implemented by the National Tariff Commission. Pakistan has used anti-dumping measures only twice versus India's 100 occasions, revealing weak institutional capacity for trade defense. Customs valuation under GATT code should be based on transaction value, but Pakistan faces procedural non-compliance by customs officials. In agriculture, developed countries' subsidy reductions create opportunities for Pakistani exports, but Pakistan itself fails to utilize available subsidy provisions for farmers under the AoA framework.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of "dumping" in international trade law, and how is the margin of dumping calculated?
- What three ordinances were promulgated in Pakistan regarding anti-dumping, countervailing duties, and safeguards?
- What rates of anti-dumping duty did the National Tariff Commission impose on Tinplates from South Africa and on Sorbitol 70% Solution from France and Indonesia?
- Why is Pakistan's limited use of anti-dumping measures (only twice in eight years) a concern compared to India's record?
- How would the reduction of farm subsidies by developed countries under the WTO affect Pakistan's wheat imports and cotton exports differently?
π Lecture 43 β WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION (WTO) PAKISTAN & WTO β III
π Overview: This lecture examines Pakistan's compliance with WTO Agreements on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) and Sanitary and Phytosanitary Standards (SPS). It discusses the institutional challenges Pakistan faces in meeting international standards, the role of exporters in tackling non-tariff barriers, and the impact of tariff reductions by developed countries on Pakistan's exports.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Pakistan's initiatives to strengthen technical institutions for TBT and SPS compliance, the establishment of the Pakistan National Accreditation Council (PNAC), the challenges developing countries face in meeting WTO standards, the role of exporters in overcoming non-tariff barriers through quality adherence and government cooperation, and the impact of tariff reductions by developed countries on Pakistan's key export sectors including textiles and leather products.
π Lecture Summary
WTO Agreements on TBT and SPS
To meet the requirements of WTO Agreements on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) and Sanitary and Phytosanitary Standards (SPS), Pakistan has taken several key initiatives aimed at strengthening technical institutions' capabilities in standard setting and compliance.
In Pakistan, ISO9000 and ISO14000 certification is rising, with reportedly well over 3,000 companies now ISO 9000 certified. However, for ISO 14000 certifications, out of 103 countries, Pakistan ranks 56th with only ten ISO 14001 certified firms, while India is 19th. All these companies are certified by foreign-based certification bodies.
π Definition β ISO 9000/ISO 14000: International standards for quality management (ISO 9000) and environmental management (ISO 14000) systems that organizations can be certified against to demonstrate compliance with international requirements.
The problem with foreign certification bodies is that notwithstanding the fact that they are accredited by reputable accreditation bodies, very few have been listed for surveillance audits in Pakistan. This greatly reflects on the performance of these certification bodies.
Against this backdrop, Pakistan National Accreditation Council (PNAC) was set up in 1998 in the Ministry of Science & Technology. In 1999, under the ADB-assisted Trade Export Promotion & Industry Program (TEPI) project, it launched accreditation services for ISO 9000/ISO 14000 certification bodies and ISO-17025 laboratory certification.
π Definition β PNAC: Pakistan National Accreditation Council, established in 1998 to provide accreditation services for certification bodies and laboratories in Pakistan. π Definition β ISO-17025: International standard for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories.
According to the Pakistan Country Report on Trade and Sustainable Development, prepared by Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI) in October 2002, the TBT and SPS agreements present both an opportunity and constraints. The two agreements seek to increase market access for exports of member countries. However, the prerequisite is that they abide by the strict rules the WTO has formulated for the development of mandatory technical regulations, voluntary standards, and conformity assessment procedures.
π‘ Why this matters: This is where developing countries like Pakistan come up short. They do not possess the institutional and technical capacity to develop, advocate, and formalize such standards in WTO fora, nor the conformity assessment and accreditation bodies to certify that domestic industries are complying with international standards. While the WTO, in principle, offers technical assistance to developing countries to develop these capabilities, the concern expressed by various stakeholders suggests that Pakistan has not tapped into these opportunities.
Role of Exporters in Tackling Non-Tariff Barriers
Some non-tariff barriers can be tackled by the exporters themselves by ensuring that they adhere to quality and standards requirements of the importing countries. For this purpose, they need to plan production and packaging methods especially for the export markets.
The manufacturing techniques must be carefully selected so as to insure that the resultant products do not cause any harm to human, animal, or plant life or health. The exporters need to carefully study the laws and regulations of the importing countries and their likely impact on the exports. Similarly, they should also carefully examine the notices or notification made by the importing countries under the Agreement on Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures and the Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade.
The exporters should maintain an effective interaction with their counterpart associations in the importing countries. Any difficulties due to technological or economic limitations must be adequately brought forward to the notice of the Government. Most of the WTO Agreements envisage special and preferential treatment to developing countries. Specific problems being faced and the favors required should therefore be identified. This may help the Government to have effective bilateral consultations with the concerned countries and to seek specific dispensation.
Since any dispute in the WTO can be raised by the Governments only, the exporters will do well to fully cooperate with their Government and to provide it with all the necessary information through their associations.
Impact of Reduction of Tariff and NTBs by Developed Countries
Developed countries committed to a 40 percent reduction in the average tariff on industrial products from 6.2 percent to 3.8 percent. While these cuts will improve access, their impact has been small because tariffs on manufactures in industrial countries were already low (except apparel).
Pakistan's exports to OECD will face average rates of 6.9 percent. However, textile and clothing products, which account for 57 percent of Pakistan's exports to OECD, received below average tariff reduction of 22 percent, meaning that developed countries will reduce tariffs from 14.6 percent to 11.3 percent. Exports of leather products and travel goods are also important to Pakistan but again received below average 18 percent tariff reduction.
After the complete phase out of quota restrictions, it is feared that developed countries would resort to use of Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs) like imposing requirements of environment and labour standards and use of child labour, etc., to protect their own interests.
π Key Data β Tariff Reductions:
- Average tariff reduction: 40% (from 6.2% to 3.8%)
- Textile tariff reduction: 22% (from 14.6% to 11.3%)
- Leather/travel goods reduction: 18%
- Pakistan's exports to OECD face average rates of 6.9%
π Example: Textile and clothing products represent 57% of Pakistan's exports to OECD countries. While the average tariff reduction across industrial products was 40%, textiles received a below-average reduction of only 22%, limiting the potential benefit to Pakistan's most important export sector.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture highlights that Pakistan faces significant challenges in complying with WTO TBT and SPS agreements due to limited institutional and technical capacity for standard setting and conformity assessment. The establishment of PNAC in 1998 was a key step, but Pakistan has not fully utilized WTO technical assistance opportunities. Exporters play a critical role in tackling non-tariff barriers through careful study of importing countries' regulations, maintaining quality standards, and cooperating with government for bilateral consultations. Tariff reductions by developed countries have provided limited benefit to Pakistan, as its key export sectors like textiles and leather received below-average tariff cuts. Going forward, there is concern that developed countries may increasingly use non-tariff barriers related to environment, labour standards, and child labour to protect their own industries after quota phase-out.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the role of the Pakistan National Accreditation Council (PNAC) and when was it established?
- Why do developing countries like Pakistan face difficulties in complying with TBT and SPS agreements?
- What three actions should exporters take to tackle non-tariff barriers according to the lecture?
- What was the average tariff reduction on industrial products by developed countries, and how did the reduction for textile products differ?
- After the phase-out of quota restrictions, what concerns exist regarding how developed countries may protect their industries?