π Lecture 41 β Group Concepts, Stages of Group Development and Team Effectiveness
π Overview: This lecture examines the fundamental concepts of work groups, including their inputs (composition, roles, size) and processes (norms, cohesiveness). It then details the five stages of group development and contrasts group decision-making with individual decision-making. Finally, it explains how to turn groups into effective teams, covering team types, characteristics of effective teams, and conflict management strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Work group inputs including composition, member characteristics, roles (task roles), group size and its effects including social loafing; work group processes such as process loss, synergy, norms, and group cohesiveness with its consequences and factors; the five stages of group development (forming, storming, norming, performing, adjourning); advantages and disadvantages of group decisions along with techniques like brainstorming and nominal group technique; turning groups into effective teams including types like functional, self-directed, virtual, and cross-functional teams; characteristics of effective teams; and managing conflict in groups including causes and resolution modes.
π Lecture Summary
Work Group Inputs
Work group inputs are those necessary for the group to operate. The composition of a work group strongly influences its success. Member characteristics affecting effectiveness include task-relevant expertise, interpersonal skills, and diversity in skills and interest. Individuals may be attracted to a group due to friendships, shared values, the need for affiliation, or to fulfill objectives outside those of the group.
An input into the group is the members' assumption of roles, which are sets of behaviors expected of individuals occupying particular positions. Group task roles help a group develop and accomplish its goals. The initiator-contributor proposes goals and procedures. The information seeker asks for information and viewpoints. The information giver offers information and suggestions. The coordinator clarifies and synthesizes ideas. The orienter summarizes and points to departures from goals. The energizer stimulates the group to higher levels of work. Group leaders often assume task roles, but an informal leader may emerge from the group, having major influence without being the formal leader.
Group size is an important input. Very small groups have disadvantages: dyads (two-person) often result in conflict or extreme politeness, while three-person groups frequently lead to two-against-one situations. Even-numbered groups often lead to deadlocks. Groups of five to seven are ideal. Large groups (beyond seven, especially beyond eleven) pose difficulties: interactions become centralized to a few members, overall satisfaction declines, and interactions become too lengthy. Group performance stops rising and possibly declines as size increases due to social loafing, the tendency of individuals to expend less effort when working in groups than when alone. Free riders engage in this behavior. Individualism (personal interests stronger than group needs) leads to social loafing, while collectivists put the group's good first. To reduce social loafing, managers should assign just enough people, have each member perform different tasks, make individual work visible, provide individual feedback, have individuals work with people they respect, provide standards, make rewards contingent on individual and group performance, and design interesting tasks.
Work Group Processes
Group processes are the dynamic inner workings of groups over time. Process loss is energy diverted from the task to develop and operate the group itself. Positive synergy occurs when combined gains from group interaction (vs. individuals alone) are greater than process losses. Negative synergy occurs when process losses exceed any gains from combining forces.
Norms are expected behaviors sanctioned by a group that regulate and foster uniformity. Groups develop norms regarding production processes, informal social relationships (e.g., where to have lunch), and allocation of resources (e.g., materials, equipment). Norms develop through four mechanisms: explicit statements by supervisors/coworkers, critical events that set precedents, primacy (the first behavior pattern tends to establish expectations), and carryover behaviors from previous group experiences.
Group cohesiveness is the degree to which members are attracted to a group, motivated to remain, and mutually influenced. High cohesiveness leads to more frequent communication, greater job satisfaction, and more aid to other members (a form of organizational citizenship). However, aggression among groups may arise, and performance levels may be very high or very low depending on the group's norms. Factors positively affecting cohesiveness include similar attitudes and values, external threats, outstanding successes, difficulties encountered in joining a group, and small group size.
Stages of Groups Development
Groups progress through five stages, but may regress with changes in membership.
- Stage 1: Forming β members assess ground rules for task and interaction.
- Stage 2: Storming β members experience conflict as they resolve differences of opinion.
- Stage 3: Norming β members build group cohesion and develop consensus about norms.
- Stage 4: Performing β energy is channeled toward the task as norms support teamwork.
- Stage 5: Adjourning β members prepare for disengagement as goals are successfully completed.
These stages apply primarily to newly formed, relatively unstructured groups.
Group Decision Making
Group decisions have advantages: they provide more complete information, generate more alternatives, increase acceptance of a solution, and increase legitimacy. Disadvantages include being time-consuming, minority domination, pressures to conform (which can lead to groupthink), and ambiguous responsibility. Group decisions tend to be more accurate and have more acceptance, but individual decisions are quicker. Group effectiveness is influenced by size (groups should not be too large), and groups are not as efficient as individual decision makers.
Techniques for improving group decision making include:
- Brainstorming: an idea-generating process that encourages alternatives while withholding criticism.
- Nominal group technique: group members are physically present but operate independently.
- Electronic meetings: decision-making groups interact via linked computers.
Turning Groups into Effective Teams
Work teams are formal groups of interdependent individuals responsible for attaining goals. All work teams are groups, but only formal groups can be work teams. Teams can vary in purpose/goal, duration (permanent or temporary), membership (functional or cross-functional), and supervision (supervised or self-managed). Popular types include:
- Functional team: composed of a manager and subordinates from a particular functional area.
- Self-directed (self-managed) team: operates without a manager and is responsible for a complete work process.
- Virtual team: uses computer technology to link physically dispersed members.
- Cross-functional team: experts in various specialties work together on organizational tasks.
Developing and Managing Effective Teams
Eight characteristics are associated with effective teams: clear goals, relevant skills, mutual trust, unified commitment, good communication, negotiating skills, appropriate leadership, and internal and external support.
Managing teams involves all management functions. In planning, teams must have clear goals accepted by every member. Organizing tasks include clarifying authority and structural issues. Leading includes determining the leader's role, handling conflict, and establishing communication processes. Controlling includes evaluating team performance and rewarding members. Gain-sharing is a popular group incentive plan that shares the gains of group efforts with members.
A team is a temporary or ongoing task group whose members work together to identify problems, form consensus, and implement actions. Teams differ from task forces: teams identify problems (rather than reacting to identified problems), and teams decide on a course of action and implement it. An entrepreneurial team is a group with diverse expertise brought together to develop and implement innovative ideas for new or improved products/services. Self-managed teams (autonomous work groups) are given responsibility for a task area without day-to-day supervision, with authority to influence group membership and behavior. Assessment of the situation is critical, as they are not successful in all situations.
Managing Conflict in Groups
Conflict is a process in which one party perceives its interests are being opposed or adversely affected. Conflict can be constructive (highlighting improvements, promoting changes, enhancing morale) or destructive (delaying projects, driving up costs, causing employee turnover).
Causes of conflict include: sequential interdependence (one party heavily dependent on another), reciprocal interdependence (mutual dependency), scarcity of resources, incompatible goals, communication failures, differences in personality/experience/values, and poorly designed reward systems that foster competition.
Managers can reduce or resolve conflict by changing conflict-producing factors or adopting one of five interpersonal modes:
- Avoidance: ignoring or suppressing the conflict.
- Accommodation: allowing the other party's desires to prevail.
- Competition: attempting to win at the other party's expense.
- Compromise: each party gives up some desired outcomes.
- Collaboration: devising solutions allowing both parties to achieve desired outcomes.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that group inputsβcomposition, roles, and size (ideal: 5-7 members)βstrongly influence group success, with social loafing being a critical risk in larger groups. Group processes, including the development of norms and cohesiveness, directly affect performance, with highly cohesive groups producing either very high or very low output depending on their norms. The five stages of group development (Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, Adjourning) provide a framework for understanding group maturation, though groups may regress with membership changes. Turning groups into effective teams requires attention to eight characteristics (clear goals, relevant skills, mutual trust, etc.), and different team types (functional, self-directed, virtual, cross-functional) serve different organizational needs. Finally, managing conflict requires understanding its causes and applying appropriate resolution modesβavoidance, accommodation, competition, compromise, or collaborationβdepending on the situation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six specific group task roles described in the lecture, and what is the main function of each?
- What is social loafing, and what eight strategies can managers use to reduce its likelihood in work groups?
- List and briefly describe the five stages of group development proposed in the lecture.
- Name four types of work teams discussed in the lecture and describe how they differ from each other.
- What are the five interpersonal modes for resolving conflict, and under what circumstances might each be appropriately used?
π Lecture 42 β UNDERSTANDING MANAGERIAL COMMUNICATION
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of managerial communication, which is essential for managers to get work done effectively and efficiently in organizations. It covers the interpersonal communication process, methods of communicating, barriers to effective communication and ways to overcome them, communication flow and networks, and contemporary issues associated with electronic communications. Understanding these concepts is critical because communication is a key ingredient of organizational effectiveness.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the Nature of Managerial Communication, defining communication and distinguishing between interpersonal and organizational communication, as well as verbal and nonverbal communication. It then breaks down the communication process into its key components: sender, encoding, message, medium, receiver, decoding, noise, and feedback. Following this, it examines seven major barriers to effective interpersonal communication, including filtering, selective perception, emotions, information overload, defensiveness, language, and national culture. The lecture also provides strategies for overcoming these barriers, such as using feedback, simplifying language, listening actively, and watching nonverbal cues. Finally, it discusses organizational communication, covering formal versus informal communication and the direction of communication flowβdownward, upward, lateral, and diagonal.
π Lecture Summary
The Nature of Managerial Communication
Communication is the transfer and understanding of meaning. If no information or ideas have been conveyed or transferred, communication hasnβt taken place. For communication to be successful, the meaning must be imparted and understood. Good communication does not require agreement with the message; just clear understanding of the message. Managerial communication encompasses both interpersonal communication (between two or more people) and organizational communication (all the patterns, networks, and system of communication within an organization). Communication and associated interpersonal processes are important ingredients of organizational effectiveness. Communication is the exchange of messages between people for the purpose of achieving common meanings.
Managers use two types of communication in their work. Verbal communication is the use of words to communicate, which includes written communication (letters, memoranda, reports, newsletters, policy manuals) but can be time-consuming and difficult to terminate. Nonverbal communication is communication transmitted without words. The best-known types are body language (gestures, facial expressions, and other body movements that convey meaning) and verbal intonation (the emphasis someone gives to words or phrases that convey meaning).
The Communication Process
The communication process can be analyzed into its basic components. The sender is the initiator of the message. Encoding is the process of translating the intended meaning into symbols, which include words and gestures. The senderβs choice of symbols depends upon sender encoding skills, assessments of the ability of the intended receiver to understand various symbols, judgments regarding the appropriateness of the use of certain symbols, past experience in similar situations, job status and education, and emotional state at the time of the communication attempt.
The message is the encoding-process outcome, consisting of verbal and nonverbal symbols developed to convey meaning to the receiver. The medium is the method used to convey the message to the intended receiver (e.g., telephone, meeting, formal report). Factors to consider when selecting a medium include relative speed, cost, intelligibility, convenience, timing, flow of communication, feedback options, interpersonal dynamics, and documentation.
The receiver is the person with whom the message is exchanged. Decoding is the process of translating the symbols into the interpreted message. Effective communication results in the senders and receivers achieving a common meaning. The receiver needs to consider the medium and the context of the message. Noise is any factor in the communication process that interferes with exchanging messages and achieving common meaning.
Feedback is the basic response of the receiver to the interpreted message. The receiver becomes the sender during feedback. Feedback provides preliminary information to the sender about the success of the communication. One-way communication results when the communication process does not allow for feedback. Two-way communication results when the communication process explicitly includes feedback.
Barriers to Effective Interpersonal Communication
Filtering is the deliberate manipulation of information to make it appear more favorable to the receiver. As information is communicated up through organizational levels, it's condensed and synthesized, and those doing the condensing filter communication through their personal interests and perceptions. The more organizational culture rewards style and appearance, the more managers will be motivated to filter communications in their favor.
Selective perception is when people selectively interpret what they see or hear on the basis of their interests, background, experience, and attitudes. Emotions influence how a receiver interprets a message when it is received. It's best to avoid reacting to a message when the receiver is upset because they are not likely to be thinking clearly.
Information overload happens when the information we have to work with exceeds our processing capacity (e.g., 600 waiting email messages). Receivers tend to select out, ignore, pass over, or forget information when they have too much information. Alternatively, receivers may put off further processing until the overload situation is overβstill resulting in ineffective communication.
Defensivenessβengaging in behaviors such as verbally attacking others, making sarcastic remarks, being overly judgmental, and questioning others' motivesβhappens when people feel that they're being threatened. Languageβwords mean different things to different people. Age, education, and cultural background can influence language use and definition given to words. Jargon is specialized terminology or technical language that members of a group use to communicate among themselves. National culture can affect the way a manager chooses to communicate.
Overcoming the Barriers to Effective Interpersonal Communication
Managers can overcome barriers by using feedback (verbal or nonverbal), simplifying language, and listening actively. Listening is an active search for meaning, whereas hearing is passive. Active listening is listening for full meaning without making premature judgments or interpretations, and demands total concentration. Active listening is enhanced by developing empathy with the senderβplacing yourself in the sender's position. Regarding emotions, the simplest answer is for a manager to refrain from communicating until they have regained composure. Managers should also watch nonverbal cues, as actions speak louder than words.
π‘ Why this matters: Active listening is a critical managerial skill that distinguishes effective managers from ineffective ones. Without it, even the clearest message can be misunderstood, undermining organizational coordination and trust.
ORGANIZATIONAL COMMUNICATION
Formal versus Informal Communication Formal communication refers to communication that follows the official chain of command or is part of the communication required to do one's job. Informal communication is organizational communication that is not defined by the organization's structural hierarchy. Informal communication systems permit employees to satisfy their needs for social interaction and can improve an organization's performance by creating alternative, and frequently faster and more efficient, channels of communication.
Direction of Communication Flow Downward communication flows from a manager to employees and is used to inform, direct, coordinate, and evaluate employees. Upward communication flows from employees to managers and can be used to keep managers aware of how employees feel about their jobs, their coworkers, and the organization in general. The organizational culture influences the extent of upward communication; a climate of trust, respect, and participative decision making will encourage considerable upward communication, while a highly mechanistic and authoritarian environment will severely limit it.
Lateral communication takes place among employees on the same organizational level. Diagonal communication is communication that cuts across both work areas and organizational levels. The increased use of e-mail facilitates diagonal communications. Diagonal communication has the potential to create problems if employees don't keep their managers informed.
β Key Takeaways
Communication is the transfer and understanding of meaning, and it does not require agreementβonly clear understanding. The communication process involves a sender encoding a message through a medium to a receiver who decodes it, with noise potentially interfering and feedback enabling two-way communication. Managers must be aware of seven major barriersβfiltering, selective perception, emotions, information overload, defensiveness, language/jargon, and national cultureβand actively overcome them through feedback, simplified language, active listening, and attention to nonverbal cues. Organizational communication flows in multiple directions (downward, upward, lateral, and diagonal), and both formal and informal channels are essential for organizational effectiveness. The choice between one-way and two-way communication depends on whether feedback is explicitly included in the process.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between communication that has occurred and communication that has not occurred?
- Identify and explain the five core components of the communication process as described in this lecture.
- What is the difference between one-way communication and two-way communication, and why is feedback critical?
- List and briefly describe four of the seven barriers to effective interpersonal communication discussed in this lecture.
- How does active listening differ from passive hearing, and what specific techniques enhance active listening?
π Lecture 43 β Communication Networks and Channels Effect of ICT on Managerial Communication
π Overview: This lecture examines the patterns and structures of organizational communication, including centralized and decentralized networks, as well as formal and informal communication channels. It also explores how modern information and communication technologies (ICT) such as email, teleconferencing, and wireless systems have transformed managerial communication, highlighting both benefits and psychological drawbacks.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five major communication network structures (wheel, chain, Y, circle, star) and their effectiveness for different tasks, then details organizational communication channels including vertical (downward and upward), horizontal, and informal (grapevine) communication. The second half examines how technology affects managerial communication through networked systems (email, voice mail, teleconferencing, videoconferencing, EDI, intranet, extranet) and wireless capabilities, concluding with the organizational impacts of information technology.
π Lecture Summary
Organizational communication network
The organizational communication network is defined as the pattern of information flow among task group members. Five major network structures have been identified, divided into centralized and decentralized types.
Three centralized networks require most messages to flow through a pivotal person:
- In the wheel network, all messages must flow through the individual at the center of the wheel.
- In the chain network, some members can communicate with more than one member, but the individual in the center tends to control messages.
- In the Y network, the member at the fork of the βYβ usually becomes the central person.
Two decentralized networks permit freer communication:
- In the circle network, each member can communicate with the individual on either side.
- In the star network, each member can communicate with any other member.
General differences between centralized and decentralized networks:
- Effective performance depends on the type of network and type of tasks. Centralized networks were usually faster and more accurate at performing simple, routine tasks. Decentralized networks were usually faster and more accurate at performing complex tasks.
- Group morale in decentralized networks was consistently higher than in centralized, regardless of task assignment.
π Definition β Organizational communication network: The pattern of information flow among task group members.
Organizational communication channels
Communication channels are various patterns of organizational communication flow that represent potential established conduits through which managers and other organization members can send and receive information.
A. Vertical communication flows from a higher level to one or more lower levels, or vice versa.
- Downward communication is vertical communication that flows from a higher level to one or more lower levels. Most downward communication involves five categories:
- Job instructions related to specific tasks
- Job rationales explaining task relationships
- Procedures and practices of the organization
- Feedback on individual performance
- Efforts to encourage mission and dedication
Downward communication is prone to distortion due to:
- Faulty message transmission from sender carelessness, poor skills, or difficulty encoding for multiple receivers
- Overuse of one-way communication methods, giving managers no feedback
- Filtering of communication through withholding, screening, or manipulating information to enhance personal power
Effectiveness can be increased by using multiple channels, repeating the message, and encouraging feedback.
- Upward communication is the vertical flow from a lower level to higher levels. Forms include individual/group meetings with superiors, memos, reports, suggestion systems, grievance procedures, and employee attitude surveys. Information typically pertains to:
- Progress of current projects
- Serious unsolved problems needing help
- New developments affecting the work unit
- Employee attitudes, morale, and efficiency
Upward communication can be distorted because subordinates filter information, and managers do not expend enough effort to encourage it. Management by wandering around (MBWA) is a practice whereby managers frequently tour areas, talk to employees, and encourage upward communication.
π‘ Why this matters: MBWA is a practical technique to overcome the natural distortion in upward communication, improving manager-subordinate information flow.
π Definition β Management by wandering around (MBWA): A practice where managers frequently tour areas they are responsible for, talk to various employees, and encourage upward communication.
C. Horizontal communication is lateral or diagonal message exchange either within work-unit boundaries (among peers reporting to the same supervisor) or across work-unit boundaries (involving individuals reporting to different supervisors). It takes the form of meetings, reports, memos, telephone conversations, and face-to-face discussions, usually relating to task coordination, problem solving, information sharing, conflict resolution, and peer support.
Three impediments to necessary horizontal communication:
- Rivalry among individuals or work units causing information hiding
- Specialization causing concern only for one's own unit
- Lack of motivation when horizontal communication is not encouraged or rewarded
D. Informal communication (the grapevine) takes place without regard to hierarchical or task requirements. It differs from formal communication (vertical and horizontal communication following paths specified by the official hierarchy), which relates to position, while informal communication depends on personal relationships.
Grapevine configurations:
- Single-strand chain: Communication moves serially from person A to B to C
- Gossip chain: Person A seeks out and tells others
- Probability chain: Person A spreads the message randomly
- Cluster chain (most predominant): Person A tells three selected individuals, then one tells three others
Grapevines are fast, with data 50 to 90 percent accurate. They are most harmful when carrying false rumors and gossip but can serve positive purposes: transmitting organizational rules/values/morals, disseminating traditions/history, reinforcing formal messages, testing new proposals, obtaining feedback, and fostering innovation.
π Definition β Formal communication: Vertical and horizontal communication that follows paths specified by the official hierarchical organization structure and related task requirements.
How Technology Affects Managerial Communication
Two developments having the most significant impact: networked computer systems and wireless capabilities.
Networked Systems:
-
Electronic mail system: Allows high-speed exchange of written messages through computerized text-processing and communication networks.
- Advantages: Time-saver, leads to information exchanges among managers who previously did not communicate, provides new types of information
- Disadvantages: Eliminates nonverbal cues, allows easy venting of anger/frustrations, leads to excess irrelevant mail
-
Voice mail: Recording systems enabling senders to leave messages by telephone. Some nonverbal cues (voice quality and tone) are sent. Particularly suited for short messages requiring no further discussion or feedback.
-
Teleconferencing: Simultaneous communication among a group by telephone or via computer using specially designed software (groupware). Meetings can be held while members are not in same location, each member has linked computer, messages are anonymous, most communication is through computers, with incredibly high speeds and high success rates.
-
Videoconferencing: Holding meetings with individuals in two or more locations by means of closed-circuit television. It is synchronous (send and receivers engage in simultaneous communication like face-to-face conversation) and fast.
-
Electronic data interchange (EDI): A way for organizations to exchange standard business transaction documents (invoices, purchase orders) using direct computer-to-computer networks.
-
Intranet systems: Organizational communication networks using Internet technology, accessible only by organizational employees.
-
Extranet systems: Organizational communication networks using Internet technology, allowing authorized inside users to communicate with certain outsiders such as customers and vendors.
π Definition β Teleconferencing: Simultaneous communication among a group by telephone or via computer using specially designed software, often called "groupware."
Wireless Capabilities: Wireless communication depends on signals sent through air or space without any physical connection, using microwave signals, satellites, radio waves/antennas, or infrared light rays.
How Information Technology Affects Organizations
- Communication and information exchange are no longer constrained by geography or time.
- However, managers must address psychological drawbacks: the cost of an employee being constantly accessible, pressure to "check in" during off hours, and the separation of work lives and personal lives.
π Definition β Synchronous communication: Communication where senders and receivers can engage in simultaneous communication of the type associated with face-to-face conversation.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the five network structures (wheel, chain, Y for centralized; circle, star for decentralized) and that centralized networks are faster for simple tasks while decentralized networks are faster for complex tasks and yield higher morale. For communication channels, vertical communication includes downward (often distorted) and upward (can be improved by MBWA), while horizontal communication faces rivalry, specialization, and motivation impediments. The grapevine is fast, 50-90% accurate, and can serve positive functions despite being harmful with false rumors. Technology has revolutionized managerial communication through networked systems (email, teleconferencing, videoconferencing, EDI, intranets, extranets) and wireless capabilities, but managers must address psychological drawbacks like constant accessibility and blurring of work-personal life boundaries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five major communication network structures, and which are centralized versus decentralized?
- Why are centralized networks faster for simple tasks while decentralized networks are faster for complex tasks?
- What is the difference between downward and upward communication, and what are two common causes of distortion in downward communication?
- What is the grapevine, and what are the four configurations of grapevine communication?
- What are four types of networked communication technologies discussed, and what is a key psychological drawback of information technology affecting organizations?
π Lecture 44 β Controlling as a Management Function
π Overview: This lecture introduces controlling as one of the four major management functions (POLCA), explaining its role in regulating organizational activities to ensure actual performance conforms to expected standards and goals. It covers the control process, types of controls, control mechanisms, and how managers can design effective control systems to cope with uncertainty, detect irregularities, and decentralize authority.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers controlling as a management function, including its definition and importance, the five roles of controls, how control responsibilities differ at strategic, tactical, and operational levels, the seven-step control process, approaches to deciding what to control (including resource dependence and strategic control points), a revisited three-step control process (measuring, comparing, taking action), and three designing approaches for control systems (market control, bureaucratic control, and clan control). It also addresses the timing of controls (feed forward, concurrent, feedback), cybernetic vs. non-cybernetic systems, and potential dysfunctional aspects of control systems.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction and Overview of Controlling
Regardless of thorough planning, a program may still be poorly implemented without a satisfactory control system. Controlling is the process of regulating organizational activities so that actual performance conforms to expected organizational goals and standards. A special relationship exists between planning and controlling: planning sets goals and the means to reach them, while controlling lets managers know if the organization is on track. A well-developed plan provides benchmarks used in the control process.
Controls help managers cope with uncertainty, detect irregularities, identify opportunities, handle complex situations, and decentralize authority. Control responsibilities parallel planning responsibilities at the strategic, tactical, and operational levels.
π Definition β Controlling: The process of regulating organizational activities so that actual performance conforms to expected organizational standards and goals.
The basic control process steps are: determining areas to be controlled, establishing appropriate standards, measuring performance, comparing performance against standards, recognizing performance or taking corrective actions, and adjusting standards/measures as necessary. Managers need to consider controls mainly in areas where they depend on others for resources. Four conditions for using controls are: high dependence on the resource, high expectation of unacceptable resource flows without controls, feasibility of instituting controls, and acceptable total control process costs.
Timing differentiates control systems: feed forward controls, concurrent controls, and feedback controls. Cybernetic controls involve little human discretion and are self-regulating (automatically monitor and take corrective action). Non-cybernetic controls rely on human discretion.
Three basic approaches for implementing controls are bureaucratic controls (rules, policies, supervision, budgets), clan controls (values, beliefs, traditions, corporate culture, shared norms), and market controls (market mechanisms to regulate prices). Potential dysfunctional aspects of control systems include behavioral displacement, game playing, operating delays, and negative attitudes. Effective control systems should be future-oriented, multidimensional, cost-effective, accurate, realistic, timely, monitorable, acceptable, and flexible.
π Definition β Cybernetic controls: Self-regulating systems that, once put into operation, can automatically monitor the situation and take corrective action without human discretion. π Definition β Non-cybernetic controls: Control systems that rely on human discretion as a basic part of their process.
Control as a management process
A. Controlling is one of the four major functions of POLCA management. It regulates organizational activities so actual performance conforms to expected organizational standards and goals.
- Controlling ensures individual behavior contributes to reaching organizational goals.
- Controls encourage wanted behaviors and discourage unwanted behaviors. B. A control system is a set of mechanisms designed to increase the probability of meeting organizational standards and goals. C. Controls play five important roles:
- Cope with uncertainty: Monitor specific activities and react quickly to environmental changes.
- Detect undesirable irregularities: Such as product defects, cost overruns, or rising personnel turnover.
- Alert managers to opportunities: Highlight situations where things go better than expected.
- Handle complex situations: Enhance coordination within large organizations.
- Decentralize authority: Enable decision making at lower levels while remaining in control. D. Control responsibilities differ by managerial level:
- Strategic control (top-level managers): Monitors critical environmental factors affecting strategic plans, assesses effects of strategic actions, and ensures plans are implemented as intended. Involves long time frames.
- Tactical control (middle managers): Focuses on assessing implementation of tactical plans at departmental levels, monitoring periodic results, and taking corrective action. Involves weekly or monthly reporting cycles.
- Operational control (lower-level managers): Oversees implementation of operating plans, monitors day-to-day results, and takes corrective action. Concerned with schedules, budgets, rules, and specific individual outputs.
- Controls at all three levels must operate in concert to be effective.
π Definition β Strategic control: Monitoring critical environmental factors that could affect the viability of strategic plans, assessing effects of organizational strategic actions, and ensuring strategic plans are implemented as intended.
The Control Process
A. The basic control process has several major steps:
- Determine areas to control: It is impractical to control every aspect. Major controls are based on organizational goals developed during planning.
- Develop standards: Spell out specific criteria for evaluating performance and employee behaviors. Standards help employees understand expectations, detect job difficulties, and reduce goal incongruence.
- Measure performance: Decide how and how often to measure. MBO is a popular technique. Measurement depends on performance standards and data (units produced, quality, profits). Most organizations use combinations of quantitative and qualitative measures. The measurement period depends on goal importance, speed of change, and difficulty/cost of rectifying problems.
- Compare performance against standards: Reports summarizing planned vs. actual results are developed. Management by exception suggests managers should be informed only if data shows significant deviation from standards. Comparison can also be through personal observation or 360-degree feedback.
- Recognize above-standard performance: Give recognition to top performers and aid in improving performance on regular bases.
- Assess reasons for unmet standards and take corrective action.
- Adjust standards and measures as necessary: Check for relevance, decide if meeting standards is worth the cost, and recognize exceeding standards as potential opportunities. B. Approaches to deciding what to control:
- Resource dependence: Managers should consider controls mainly in areas where they depend on others for resources. Strategic control points are performance areas chosen because they are particularly important in meeting goals. They meet four conditions:
- Dependence on resource is high (important and limited availability).
- Probability of unacceptable resource flow is high (quantity, quality, or timeliness problems anticipated).
- Instituting a control system is feasible.
- Cost of instituting the control system is acceptable.
- If controls are needed but cannot be instituted, managers can develop alternatives:
- Change the dependence relationship (e.g., line up several suppliers).
- Change the nature of the dependence relationship (e.g., job simplification or vertical integration).
- Change organizational goals so the resources are no longer necessary.
π Definition β Goal incongruence: A condition in which there are major incompatibilities between the goals of an organization member and those of the organization. π Definition β Management by exception: A control principle suggesting managers should be informed of a situation only if control data show a significant deviation from standards. π Definition β Resource dependence: An approach where managers consider controls mainly in areas in which they depend on others for resources necessary to reach organizational goals. π Definition β Strategic control points: Performance areas chosen for control because they are particularly important in meeting organizational goals.
Revisiting Control Process
The control process can be viewed as a three-step process: measuring actual performance, comparing it against a standard, and taking managerial action.
A. Measuring is the first step.
- How to measure: Four common sources of information β personal observation, statistical reports, oral reports, and written reports. Each has advantages and drawbacks.
- What to measure is more critical than how. Both objective and subjective measures are used.
B. Comparing is the next step.
- Determines the degree of variation between actual performance and the standard.
- It is critical to determine the range of variation β the acceptable parameters of variance between actual performance and the standard.
C. Taking managerial action is the final step.
- Correct actual performance: Two alternatives:
- Immediate corrective action: Correcting an activity at once to get performance back on track.
- Basic corrective action: Determining how and why performance deviated and correcting the source of deviation. Action depends on cost/benefit analysis.
- Revise the standard: If the standard was set too high or too low, revise it.
- The manager might decide to "do nothing."
D. Summary: The control process is a continuous flow between measuring, comparing, and managerial action.
π Definition β Range of variation: The acceptable parameters of variance between actual performance and the standard. π Definition β Immediate corrective action: Correcting an activity at once in order to get performance back on track. π Definition β Basic corrective action: Determining how and why performance has deviated and correcting the source of deviations.
Designing Control Systems
There are three different approaches to designing organizational control systems:
A. Market control: An approach emphasizing the use of external market mechanisms to establish the standards used in the control system.
- Two conditions must hold:
- There must be a reasonable level of competition in the goods or service area.
- It must be possible to specify requirements clearly.
- Market controls may regulate internal operations (e.g., profit centers charging other departments) and external relations. The use of market controls is increasing, notably through outsourcing.
B. Bureaucratic control: An approach emphasizing organizational authority and relying on administrative rules, regulations, procedures, policies, standardization, well-defined job descriptions, and other administrative mechanisms to ensure employees exhibit appropriate behaviors and meet performance standards.
- Advantages:
- Does not require all requirements to be specified in advance.
- Useful for keeping recurring, predictable activities running smoothly.
- Focuses on doing the job and aids extrinsic reward systems.
- Disadvantages:
- Innovation is not encouraged.
- Needed changes may be inhibited.
- Employees tend to comply with regulations rather than committing to a course of action.
C. Clan control: An approach where employee behaviors are regulated by shared values, norms, traditions, rituals, beliefs, and other aspects of the organization's culture. It relies on values, beliefs, traditions, corporate culture, shared norms, and informal relationships.
- Differences from bureaucratic control:
- Internal motivation is emphasized.
- Duties are flexible and tasks are broadly defined.
- Influence is based on relevant information and expertise, not position in the hierarchy.
- Primary advantage: conducive to innovation.
π Definition β Market control: An approach to designing control systems that emphasizes the use of external market mechanisms to establish the standards used in the control system. π Definition β Bureaucratic control: An approach to designing control systems that emphasizes organizational authority and relies on administrative rules, regulations, procedures, policies, and other administrative mechanisms. π Definition β Clan control: An approach to designing control systems in which employee behaviors are regulated by the shared values, norms, traditions, rituals, beliefs, and other aspects of the organization's culture. π Definition β Outsourcing: Using outside vendors to perform services normally carried out within the organization.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes controlling as a critical management function that ensures organizational activities align with planned goals and standards. Students must understand the three-level control hierarchy (strategic, tactical, operational) and how each level corresponds to different managerial responsibilities and time frames. The seven-step control process (determine areas, establish standards, measure performance, compare, recognize performance, take corrective action, adjust standards) and the simplified three-step model (measure, compare, act) are essential frameworks. The three approaches to designing control systemsβmarket, bureaucratic, and clanβeach have distinct mechanisms, advantages, and disadvantages, with clan control being most conducive to innovation and bureaucratic control better suited for routine activities. Finally, the distinction between immediate and basic corrective action, the concept of management by exception, and the importance of setting appropriate ranges of variation are critical for practical application.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five important roles that controls play in organizations?
- How do strategic, tactical, and operational controls differ in terms of managerial level, time frame, and focus?
- What are the seven steps in the basic control process, and what is the purpose of each?
- What is the difference between immediate corrective action and basic corrective action?
- How do market control, bureaucratic control, and clan control differ in their approaches to regulating employee behavior?