📘 Lecture 23 — Planning Process and Goal Levels
📖 Overview: This lecture explains the complete planning process in organizations, from setting goals to determining how to achieve them. It covers the hierarchy of goals (strategic, tactical, operational), types of plans, and how goals facilitate performance. Understanding this is critical for any manager who needs to translate organizational mission into actionable results.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the overall planning process including goals, plans, and the organization's mission statement. It then examines types of plans classified by breadth, time frame, specificity, and frequency of use. The nature of organizational goals is explored through their benefits and three hierarchical levels. The lecture details how goals facilitate performance through content criteria, commitment factors, and work behavior effects. Finally, it addresses strategic planning timeframes, promoting innovation through planning, and obstacles to planning with countermeasures.
📝 Lecture Summary
The overall planning process
Planning is a two-part function: setting goals and determining how to achieve them. A goal (or objective) is a future target or end result an organization wishes to achieve. A plan is the means devised for attempting to reach a goal.
An organization’s mission is its purpose or fundamental reason for existence. A mission statement is a broad declaration of the basic, unique purpose and scope of operations that distinguishes the organization from others. For managers, it serves as a benchmark to evaluate success. For employees, it defines common purpose, nurtures loyalty, and fosters community. For external groups, it provides insights into values and future directions.
🔑 Definition — Mission Statement: A broad declaration of the basic, unique purpose and scope of operations that distinguishes the organization from others of this type.
The mission statement typically defines the organization through eight attributes: Customers (who they serve), Products or services (major offerings), Location (where they compete), Technology (basic technology), Philosophy (basic beliefs and values), Self-concept (major strengths and competitive advantages), Concern for public image (public responsibilities), and Concern for employees (attitude toward employees).
Types of Plans
Plans can be described by four dimensions:
- Breadth: Strategic plans are organization-wide, establish overall objectives, and position the organization within its environment. Operational plans specify details on how overall objectives are achieved.
- Time frame: Short-term plans cover one year or less. Long-term plans extend beyond three years.
- Specificity: Specific plans are clearly defined with no room for interpretation. Directional plans are flexible plans that set out general guidelines.
- Frequency of use: Plans can be single-use or standing plans.
The Nature of Organizational Goals
Using goals has several benefits: performance can be improved, expectations can be clarified, the controlling function is facilitated for assessing progress and taking corrective action, and meeting goals increases motivation.
The three levels of goals form a hierarchy of goals, with lower-level goals forming a mean-end chain with the next level:
- Strategic goals are broadly defined targets set by top management
- Tactical goals are targets set by middle management for specific departments or units
- Operational goals are targets set by lower management addressing specific, measurable outcomes
🔑 Definition — Mean-End Chain: A hierarchy where lower-level goals become the means for achieving higher-level goals.
How Goals Facilitate Performance
The content of goals should meet five criteria (SMART-R):
- Challenging goals usually lead to higher performance
- Attainable goals (not impossible) improve performance
- Specific and measurable goals make achievement clear
- Time-limited goals give them meaning
- Relevant goals enable employees to see purpose and devise ways to meet them
- (Measurable) means performance and targets can be measured after an interval
Goal commitment is one's attachment to, or determination to reach, a goal. Without commitment, goals have little impact on performance. Managers can foster commitment through: supervisory authority, peer and group pressure, expectations of success (improved by coaching), incentives (offered during goal-setting) and rewards (upon achievement), and participation in the goal-setting process.
Work behavior is affected by four factors influenced by goal content and commitment:
- Direction — goals channel attention and action toward related activities
- Effort — committed goals boost energy mobilization
- Persistence — maintaining direction and effort until the goal is reached
- Planning — goal setting leads to planning if goals are appropriately challenging
Additional process components influencing performance: Job knowledge and ability, Task complexity, Situation constraints (proper tools, materials, equipment), and Knowledge of results/feedback about progress.
Strategic plans typically involve time periods of 5 years or more, though the time frame depends on industry stability.
💡 Why this matters: The planning process can promote innovation in organizations through: the mission statement (encouraging innovation), the goals component (translating mission to support innovation), and the plans component (providing actual plans for innovative outcomes).
Obstacles to planning
Obstacles threatening effective planning include: rapid environmental change requiring frequent revisions, manager resistance believing planning is unnecessary, day-to-day pressures keeping managers from planning, poorly prepared managers, and staff specialists dominating the planning process.
Countermeasures organizations can take:
- Top-level managers demonstrating support for the planning process
- A planning staff — a small group assisting top-level managers in developing planning components, focusing on helping rather than taking over
- Contingency planning — developing alternative plans for use if environmental conditions evolve differently than anticipated
🔑 Definition — Contingency Planning: The development of alternative plans for use in the event that environmental conditions evolve differently than anticipated, rendering original plans unwise or unfeasible.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Planning is a two-part function combining goal-setting with developing plans to achieve those goals, starting from the organization's mission statement which defines purpose across eight key attributes. Goals exist at three hierarchical levels (strategic, tactical, operational) that form a means-end chain connecting top management vision to frontline execution. Effective goals must be challenging, attainable, specific, measurable, time-limited, and relevant to drive performance — and they only work when there is genuine goal commitment fostered through authority, peer pressure, coaching, incentives, and participation. Goals influence work behavior by providing direction, boosting effort, maintaining persistence, and encouraging planning, but obstacles like rapid change and manager resistance can derail planning unless countered by top management support, planning staff, and contingency planning. The entire planning process can also be leveraged to promote organizational innovation through mission, goals, and plans.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight attributes typically defined in a mission statement, and why is each important?
- Explain the difference between strategic, tactical, and operational goals and how they form a means-end chain.
- What five criteria must goal content meet to effectively facilitate performance, and what happens if any are missing?
- How can managers foster goal commitment, and why is commitment crucial for goal effectiveness?
- What are the main obstacles to planning, and what three countermeasures can organizations use to overcome them?
📘 Lecture 24 — Management by Objective (MBO)
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on the time span of goals and plans, the characteristics of well-designed goals, and the steps in goal setting. It then explores contingency factors in planning and two major approaches to establishing goals: traditional goal setting and Management by Objectives (MBO), including the MBO process, its strengths, and weaknesses.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the time span of strategic, tactical, and operational goals, characteristics of well-designed goals, and the five steps in goal setting. It also discusses contingency factors in planning, including manager's level, environmental uncertainty, and the commitment concept. The lecture concludes with a comparison of traditional goal setting versus Management by Objectives (MBO), detailing the MBO process, its four elements, typical steps, and its strengths and weaknesses.
📝 Lecture Summary
Time Span of Goals and Plans
Goals and plans are categorized by their time horizon, which dictates their scope and level of detail. Strategic goals and plans generally involve time periods of 3-5 years and are set by top management for the organization as a whole. Tactical goals and plans typically involve time periods of 1 to 3 years and are set by middle management for specific departments or divisions. Operational goals and plans can be for as short a period as 1 week or as long as 1 year, focusing on specific tasks and activities at the lower management levels.
Characteristics of Well-Designed Goals
For goals to be effective, they must possess specific characteristics. They should be written in terms of outcomes rather than actions, measurable and quantifiable to allow for tracking progress, and clear as to a time frame for completion. Goals should be challenging but attainable to motivate performance, be written down to ensure clarity, and be communicated to all organizational members who are responsible for achieving them.
Steps in Goals Setting—Five Steps
Setting goals follows a structured process of five steps. First, review the organization’s mission to ensure alignment. Second, ensure goals reflect what the mission statement says. Third, evaluate available resources to determine what is feasible. Fourth, determine individually, or with input from others, the goals. Fifth, write down the goals and communicate them to all who need to know. Finally, review results and whether goals are being met to assess progress and make adjustments.
Developing Plans
The process of developing plans is influenced by three contingency factors and by the planning approach followed. These factors help managers decide what type of plans to create and how detailed they should be.
Contingency Factors in Planning
Three key factors influence the planning approach. First, the manager’s level in the organization: operational planning dominates for lower-level managers, while planning becomes more strategic as managers move up. Second, the degree of environmental uncertainty: greater uncertainty calls for more directional plans with an emphasis on the short term. When uncertainty is high, plans should be specific, but flexible, and managers must be prepared to rework, amend, or abandon their plans. Third, the length of future commitments: The commitment concept means that plans should extend far enough to meet those commitments made when the plans were developed. Planning for too long or too short a time period is inefficient and ineffective.
Approaches to Establishing Goals
Goals can be established either through traditional goal setting or through management by objectives (MBO).
a. Traditional Goal Setting is defined as the process whereby goals are set at the top of the organization and then broken down into subgoals for each level. Top managers are assumed to know what’s best because they see the “big picture.” However, these goals are often largely non-operational, and specificity is achieved as each manager applies his or her own set of interpretations and biases. What often results is that objectives lose clarity and unity as they move from top to bottom. When the hierarchy of objectives is clearly defined, it forms an integrated means-end chain in which higher-level objectives (ends) are linked to lower-level objectives (means) that must be achieved to reach the higher ones.
✅ Pitfalls of Goal Setting: Setting difficult goals increases the risk they won't be reached, may increase stress, and can undermine self-confidence if they fail. Non-goal areas may be ignored, and excessive short-range thinking can be encouraged. Inappropriate goals may also lead to dishonesty and cheating.
b. Management by Objectives (MBO) is a process through which specific goals are set collaboratively for the organization as a whole and every unit and individual within it; the goals then are used as a basis for planning, managing organizational activities, and assessing and rewarding contributions.
🔑 Definition — Management by Objectives (MBO): A process where specific performance goals are jointly determined by employees and their managers, progress toward accomplishing these goals is periodically reviewed, and rewards are allocated on the basis of this progress.
MBO was first described by Peter Drucker and consists of four elements:
- Goal specificity
- Participative decision making
- Explicit time period
- Performance feedback
MBO makes objectives operational through the process by which they cascade down through the organization. The typical MBO process includes these steps:
- Organizational goals are developed based on organizational missions.
- Specific goals are established for departments, subunits, and individuals. In the top-down process, upper-level managers formulate objectives for their areas, which then enter the formulation for the next level down. In the bottom-up process, operational goals are proposed by lower-level managers and developed into tactical and strategic plans.
- Action plans are formulated, describing what is to be done, how, when, where, and by whom.
- Individuals are given the responsibility of reaching their objectives.
- Performance is appraised at the end of the goal-setting cycle, typically at one-year intervals. Praise, recognition, and rewards should be given for effective performance.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding MBO helps managers create a system of aligned, participatory goal setting that can drive motivation and coordination across the entire organization.
Strengths of MBO:
- Aids coordination of goals and plans.
- Helps clarify priorities and expectations.
- Facilitates vertical and horizontal communications.
- Fosters employee motivation.
Weaknesses of MBO:
- Tends to falter without strong, continual commitment from top management.
- Necessitates considerable training of managers.
- Can be misused as a punitive device.
- May cause overemphasis of quantitative goals.
The “spirit” of MBO is tremendous. However, in practice, MBO has been successful only about 20 to 25 percent of the time, primarily because of lack of support from top management and poor goal-setting and communication skills.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For this lecture, students must remember the three categories of goals based on time span (strategic, tactical, operational) and the six characteristics of well-designed goals (outcome-based, measurable, time-bound, challenging, written, communicated). The five steps of goal setting and the three contingency factors affecting planning (manager's level, environmental uncertainty, commitment concept) are also critical. The central distinction between traditional goal setting (top-down) and Management by Objectives (MBO, participatory) must be clear, including the four elements of MBO, its five-step process, and its key strengths and weaknesses. Finally, remember that MBO has a low success rate (20-25%) primarily due to lack of top management support.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three time spans for goals and plans (strategic, tactical, operational), and what is the typical time period for each?
- List the six characteristics of a well-designed goal.
- What are the three contingency factors that influence the planning process?
- What is the key difference between traditional goal setting and Management by Objectives (MBO) in terms of how goals are set?
- What are the four core elements of the Management by Objectives (MBO) process as first described by Peter Drucker?
📘 Lecture 25 — Introduction Strategic Management -I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of strategic management, explaining why it has become essential for organizational success in today's dynamic environment. It covers the definition, importance, and core components of the strategic management process, highlighting how good strategies lead to high organizational performance.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the importance of strategic management, explaining how environmental shocks in the 1970s and 1980s forced managers to develop systematic analysis methods. It defines strategic management and its purposes, discusses competitive advantage, explains the difference between strategy formulation and implementation, and shows how strategic management encompasses all four management functions.
📝 Lecture Summary
INTRODUCTION STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT -I
Today’s business news is filled with reports of organizations making changes in their strategies for various reasons. An underlying theme of discussing strategic management is that good strategies can lead to high organizational performance. The environmental shocks during the 1970s and 1980s forced managers to develop a systematic means of analyzing the environment, assessing their organization’s strengths and weaknesses, identifying opportunities that would give the organization a competitive advantage, and incorporating these findings into their planning.
THE IMPORTANCE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Strategic management is important because it's involved in many decisions that managers make. Studies have found that companies with formal strategic management systems generally had higher financial returns than those without such systems. Strategic management has also moved beyond for-profit organizations to include all types of organizations, including not-for-profit organizations.
The Concept of Strategic Management
Strategic management is a process through which managers formulate and implement strategies geared to optimizing goal achievement, given available environmental and internal conditions. It is that set of managerial decisions and actions that determines the long-run performance of an organization. Strategic management entails all of the basic management functions—planning, organizing, leading, and controlling.
🔑 Definition — Strategic management: That set of managerial decisions and actions that determines the long-run performance of an organization, entailing all basic management functions—planning, organizing, leading, and controlling.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding that strategic management integrates all four management functions helps managers see strategy not as a separate activity but as the central framework for all organizational decisions.
Purposes of strategic management
- Strategic management is important because it's involved in many of the decisions that managers make.
- Studies show that companies with formal strategic management systems had higher financial returns than those without such systems.
- Strategic management has moved beyond for-profit organizations to include all types of organizations, including not-for-profit.
Strategic management is important to organizations because it:
- Helps organizations identify and develop a competitive advantage, a significant edge over the competition in dealing with competitive forces.
- Provides a sense of direction so that organization members know where to expend their efforts.
- Helps highlight the need for innovation and provides an organized approach for encouraging new ideas related to strategies.
🔑 Definition — Competitive advantage: A significant edge over the competition in dealing with competitive forces.
Strategies are large-scale action plans for interacting with the environment in order to achieve long-term goals. Most well-run organizations attempt to develop and follow strategies.
🔑 Definition — Strategies: Large-scale action plans for interacting with the environment in order to achieve long-term goals.
The strategic management process is made up of several components
-
Strategy formulation is the part of the strategic management process that includes: a. Identifying the mission and strategic goals. b. Conducting competitive analysis. c. Developing specific strategies.
-
Strategy implementation is the part of the strategic management process that focuses on: a. Carrying strategic plans. b. Maintaining control over how those plans are carried out.
🔑 Definition — Strategy formulation: The part of the strategic management process that includes identifying the mission and strategic goals, conducting competitive analysis, and developing specific strategies.
🔑 Definition — Strategy implementation: The part of the strategic management process that focuses on carrying strategic plans and maintaining control over how those plans are carried out.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Strategic management is a comprehensive process that determines an organization's long-run performance and integrates all four management functions—planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. Organizations with formal strategic management systems tend to achieve higher financial returns. The process has two main components: strategy formulation (identifying mission, conducting analysis, developing strategies) and strategy implementation (carrying out plans and maintaining control). Strategic management helps organizations develop competitive advantage, provides direction, and promotes innovation. Strategies themselves are large-scale action plans designed to achieve long-term goals through environmental interaction.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is strategic management, and how does it entail all four management functions?
- What were the environmental factors that forced managers to develop systematic strategic analysis in the 1970s and 1980s?
- What is a competitive advantage, and why is it important for organizations?
- What are the three components of strategy formulation?
- How does strategy implementation differ from strategy formulation in the strategic management process?
📘 Lecture 26 — Strategic Management - II
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of strategic management by detailing the eight-step strategic management process, from defining the mission to evaluating results. It also explains the critical role of competitive analysis, particularly the SWOT analysis, in formulating effective strategies that give an organization a competitive advantage.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the eight-step strategic management process, which includes identifying mission and objectives, analyzing the external and internal environments, identifying opportunities, threats, strengths, and weaknesses, and then formulating, implementing, and evaluating strategies. It also delves into the role of competitive analysis in strategy formulation, specifically through a SWOT analysis, explaining how internal and external factors are assessed.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Strategic Management Process
The strategic management process is an eight-step process that encompasses strategic planning, implementation, and evaluation. The first step is identifying the organization’s current mission, objectives, and strategies, where the mission defines the organization’s purpose. Step two involves analyzing the external environment because it defines management’s strategic options. A successful strategy aligns well with the environment, and this step is complete when managers understand important external trends.
The third step is identifying opportunities and threats. Opportunities are positive external environmental factors, while threats are negative external environmental factors. Step four is analyzing the organization’s resources through an internal analysis, where managers look at the organization’s specific assets, skills, and work activities. Managers look for core competencies, which are an organization’s major value-creating skills, capabilities, and resources that determine its competitive advantage. This step forces managers to realize that every organization is constrained by its resources and skills.
Step five is identifying strengths and weaknesses. Strengths are activities the firm does well or the unique resources it controls. Weaknesses are activities the firm doesn’t do well or the resources it needs but doesn’t possess. A crucial area often overlooked is the analysis of the organization’s culture, which is the organization’s personality. The strength of the culture is a result of how much employees understand and support the shared values. A strong culture makes it easy to convey distinctive competencies but can be difficult to change if needed. Strategic choices are influenced by the culture’s tolerance of risk and innovation and how performance is rewarded. The merging of steps 3 and 5 results in a SWOT analysis, an analysis of an organization’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. It brings together internal and external analyses to identify a strategic niche the organization might exploit. In light of the SWOT analysis, managers need to reevaluate the organization’s current mission and objectives.
🔑 Definition — Mission: Defines the purpose of the organization and its reason for being in business. 🔑 Definition — Core Competencies: An organization’s major value-creating skills, capabilities, and resources that determine its competitive advantage. 🔑 Definition — SWOT Analysis: An analysis of an organization’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. 📐 Formula: Strategic Management Process → Identify mission/objectives → Analyze external environment → Identify opportunities/threats → Analyze internal resources → Identify strengths/weaknesses → Formulate strategies → Implement strategies → Evaluate results.
Step six is formulating strategies, which need to be established at the corporate, business, and functional levels to give the organization a competitive advantage. Step seven is implementing strategies, as they are only as good as their implementation. The eighth and final step is evaluating results to determine how effective the strategies have been and what corrections are necessary.
💡 Why this matters: This step-by-step process provides a structured framework for managers to systematically plan, execute, and assess their organization's direction, ensuring alignment between internal capabilities and external market realities.
The Role of Competitive Analysis in Strategy Formulation
Before an effective strategy to gain a competitive advantage can be formulated, the organization’s competitive situation needs careful analysis. A SWOT ANALYSIS is one method for doing so, involving the assessment of organization strengths (S) and weaknesses (W), as well as environmental opportunities (O) and threats (T). Strengths and weaknesses apply to internal characteristics. A strength is an internal characteristic that has the potential of improving the organization’s competitive situation. A weakness is an internal characteristic that leaves the organization potentially vulnerable to strategic moves by competitors. Opportunities and threats are found in the external environment. An opportunity is an environmental condition that offers significant prospects for improving an organization’s situation relative to competitors. A threat is an environmental condition that offers significant prospects for undermining an organization’s competitive situation.
🔑 Definition — Strength: An internal characteristic that has the potential of improving the organization’s competitive situation. 🔑 Definition — Weakness: An internal characteristic that leaves the organization potentially vulnerable to strategic moves by competitors. 🔑 Definition — Opportunity: An environmental condition that offers significant prospects for improving an organization’s situation relative to competitors. 🔑 Definition — Threat: An environmental condition that offers significant prospects for undermining an organization’s competitive situation.
💡 Why this matters: A systematic SWOT analysis forces managers to be objective about their organization's capabilities and the environment, preventing strategic blind spots and enabling the exploitation of a strategic niche.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The strategic management process is a comprehensive eight-step cycle covering planning, implementation, and evaluation. A key component is the SWOT analysis, which merges internal analysis (strengths and weaknesses) with external analysis (opportunities and threats) to find a strategic niche. An organization's culture is a critical internal factor that can either promote or hinder strategic actions. Strategies must be formulated at corporate, business, and functional levels, but their success depends entirely on effective implementation and subsequent evaluation. The ultimate goal of this entire process is to achieve a competitive advantage.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight steps of the strategic management process?
- What is the difference between an opportunity and a threat in a SWOT analysis?
- What are core competencies, and what role do they play in a firm's competitive advantage?
- Why is an organization's culture considered a critical component of an internal analysis?
- What is the purpose of the eighth and final step in the strategic management process?
📘 Lecture 27 — Levels of Strategies, Porter’s Model and Strategy Development (BCG) and Implementation
📖 Overview: This lecture covers the three distinct levels of strategy development within organizations—corporate, business, and functional. It explains Porter’s Five Competitive Forces Model for analyzing industry competition and details major strategy formulation tools like the BCG matrix and grand strategies, concluding with the essential process of strategy implementation and strategic control.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining corporate, business, and functional-level strategies and their coordination. It then explains Porter’s Five Forces Model for competitive analysis and the resource-based strategic view for internal assessment. Corporate-level strategy formulation is explored through grand strategies (growth, stability, defensive) and portfolio approaches like the BCG growth-share matrix. Business-level strategy covers Porter’s generic strategies (cost leadership, differentiation, focus), and the lecture concludes with functional-level strategy and the implementation phase, including technology, human resources, reward systems, decision processes, organizational structure, and strategic control.
📝 Lecture Summary
Levels of Strategies
Many organizations develop strategies at three different levels. These three different and distinct levels of strategy are corporate, business, and functional.
Corporate-level strategy is developed by top-level management and the board of directors. The corporate-level strategy seeks to determine what businesses a corporation should be in or wants to be in. Two popular approaches for answering the question of what business(es) should we be in are the grand strategies framework and the corporate portfolio matrix. These strategies address what business the organization will be coordinated to strengthen the organization’s competitive position, how the strategies of those businesses will be coordinated, and how resources will be allocated among businesses.
Business-level strategy concentrates on the best means of competing within a particular business while also supporting the corporate-level strategy. The distinction between corporate-level and business-level strategy applies only to organizations with separate divisions that compete in different industries. A strategic business unit (SBU) is a distinct business, with its own set of competitors that can be managed reasonably independently of other businesses within the organization.
Functional-level strategy focuses on action plans for managing a particular functional area within a business in a way that supports the business-level strategy. Functional areas include operations, marketing, finance, human resources management, accounting, research and development, and engineering. Functional strategies are usually developed by functional managers and are typically reviewed by business unit heads. Coordinating strategies across these three levels is critical in maximizing strategic impact.
The Role of Competitive Analysis in Strategy Formulation and Implementation
Porter’s Forces Model: Michael E. Porter, a noted strategy expert, has devised the five competitive forces model as an approach for analyzing the external environment for both the nature and the intensity of competition in a given industry in terms of five major forces.
- The model provides an environmental assessment of strategically significant elements of the organization’s task environment.
- Rivalry is the extent to which competitors use tactics to lower the profits of their competitors.
- The bargaining power of suppliers is the extent to which suppliers can exert power over business in an industry by threatening to raise prices or reduce the quality of goods and services they provide.
- The bargaining power of buyers depends on factors such as number of customers in the market, customer information, and the availability of substitute which determine the amount of influence that buyers have in an industry.
- The threat of new entrants is the threat of a price war if new competitors can enter the market.
- The threat of substitute products or services is the extent to which businesses in other industries can offer substitute products, thus reducing the profit potential for the industry.
The competitive environment, in some industries, may reach the point of hyper competition—a state of rapidly escalating competition. When this happens, environments may become upward spirals of uncertainty, dynamism, and heterogeneity of players making it difficult for any organization to sustain competitive advantage.
An organizational assessment determines how organizational factors in the internal environment affect the competitive situation. The resource-based strategic view is a useful approach to internal assessment as it focuses on competitive implications of several sets of organizational resources and capabilities: financial resources (debt, equity, retained earnings), physical resources (buildings, machinery), human resources (skills, abilities, experience), and organizational resources (history, relationships, trust).
Assessing the competitive implications of these resources and capabilities relative to the environment involves answering questions about four critical factors: how much value any resource or capability adds, what degree of rareness each resource or capability has among competing firms, what is the degree of imitability by competitors, and whether the organization of the firm’s resources and capabilities achieves the best competitive advantage. Achieving sustained competitive advantage requires both development in industries where competitive forces are favorable and development of resources and capabilities that are valuable, rare, and difficult to imitate. When a firm has these, it is said to have a distinctive competence.
💡 Why this matters: Porter’s model helps managers systematically assess industry threats and opportunities, while the resource-based view explains why some firms outperform others even in unattractive industries.
Formulating Corporate-Level Strategy
A grand strategy (master strategy) provides the basic strategic direction at the corporate level of the organization. Four grand strategies have been identified.
-
Growth strategies are grand strategies that involve organizational expansion along some major dimension.
- Concentration focuses on effecting the growth of a single product or service or a small number of closely related products or services. Types include market development (gaining a larger share of a current market or expanding into new ones), product development (improving a basic product or service or expanding into closely related products or services), and horizontal integration (adding one or more similar businesses, usually by purchasing such business).
- Vertical integration involves effecting growth through the production of inputs previously provided by suppliers (backward integration) or through the replacement of a customer role (forward integration). Backward integration occurs when a business grows by becoming its own supplier; forward integration occurs when organizational growth encompasses a role previously fulfilled by a customer.
- Diversification entails effecting growth through the development of new areas that are clearly distinct from current businesses. Conglomerate diversification takes place when an organization diversifies into areas that are unrelated to its current business. Concentric diversification occurs when an organization diversifies into a related, but distinct, business.
These growth strategies can be implemented through a number of means: internal growth (expanding by building on its own internal resources), an acquisition (purchase of all or part of one organization by another), a merger (combining of two or more companies into one organization), or a joint venture (two or more organizations provide resources to support a given project or product offering).
-
A stability strategy is a second type of grand strategy that involves maintaining the status quo or growing in a methodical, but slow, manner. Small, privately owned businesses are most likely to adopt this strategy. Reasons include avoiding the risks of aggressive growth, providing the opportunity to recover after a period of accelerated growth, letting the company hold on to current market share, or occurring through default.
-
Defensive strategies (sometimes called retrenchment strategies) tend to focus on reducing organizational operations through cost reductions and/or asset reductions. Types include: harvest (minimizing investments while attempting to maximize short-run profits and cash flow), a turnaround (designed to reverse a negative trend and restore profitability), a divestiture (selling or divesting of a business or part of a business), a bankruptcy (court protection from creditors while attempting to regain financial stability), and liquidation (selling or dissolving an entire organization).
A portfolio strategy approach is a method of analyzing an organization’s mix of businesses in terms of both individual and collective contributions to strategic goals. The Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG) growth-share matrix compares various businesses in an organization’s portfolio on the basis of relative market share and market growth rate. Relative market share is determined by the ratio of a business’s market share compared to the market share of its largest rival. Market growth rate is the growth in the market during the previous year relative to growth in the economy as a whole.
The matrix defines four business groups:
- The Star has a high market share in a rapidly growing market.
- A Question Mark (problem child) has a low market share in a rapidly growing market.
- The Cash Cow has a high market share in a slowly growing market.
- A Dog has a low market share in an area of low growth.
Strategies are suggested by the SBU’s position on the matrix: use funds from cash cows to fund stars and possibly question marks; divest dogs and less desirable question marks.
The product/market evolution matrix (sometimes called the life-cycle portfolio matrix) is a 15-cell matrix where businesses are plotted according to the business unit’s business strengths or competitive position and the industry’s stage in the evolutionary product/market life cycle.
The BCG matrix has lost much of its merit because: not every organization has found that increased market share leads to lower costs; the portfolio concept assumes that an organization’s businesses can be divided into a reasonable number of independent units; contrary to predictions, many so-called dogs have shown consistently higher levels of profitability than growing competitors; well over half of all businesses by definition fall into the dog category; and strategic implications are to “milk” cash cows, invest resources in stars, liquidate or sell dogs, and sell off or invest in question marks.
💡 Why this matters: The BCG matrix provides a simple visual tool for resource allocation, but managers must be cautious about its assumptions and use it as one input among many.
Formulating Business-Level Strategy
Michael E. Porter has developed three generic business-level strategies:
- A cost leadership strategy involves emphasizing organizational efficiency so that the overall costs of providing products and services are lower than those of competitors. The business should have a cost advantage that is not easily or inexpensively imitated. Managers should consider making those product or service innovations that are most important to customers.
- A differentiation strategy involves attempting to develop products and services that are viewed as unique in the industry. Differentiation may occur in brand image, technology, customer service, features, quality, and selection. Costs are not as important as product or service uniqueness.
- A focus strategy entails specializing by establishing a position of overall cost leadership, differentiation, or both, but only within a particular portion, or segment, or an entire market.
🔑 Definition — Generic strategies: Porter’s three widely applicable business-level strategies (cost leadership, differentiation, and focus) that provide a framework for achieving competitive advantage.
Formulating Functional-Level Strategy
Strategies at the functional level are important in supporting a business-level strategy. Functional areas develop the distinctive competencies that lead to potential competitive advantages.
Strategy Implementation
Strategy implementation includes the various management activities that are necessary to put the strategy in motion, institute strategic controls that monitor progress, and ultimately achieve organizational goals.
Managers need to synchronize major factors within an organization needed to put a chosen strategy into action:
- Technology is the knowledge, tool, equipment, and work technique used by an organization in delivering its product or service.
- Human resources are the individuals who are members of the organization.
- Reward systems include bonuses, awards, or promotions provided by others, as well as rewards related to internal experiences, such as feeling of achievement and challenge.
- Decision processes include the means of resolving questions and problems that occur in organizations.
- Organization structure is the formal pattern of interactions and coordination designed by management to link the tasks of individuals and groups in achieving organizational goals.
Managers need to be able to monitor progress through strategic control. Strategic control involves monitoring critical environmental factors that could affect the viability of strategic plans, assessing the effects of organizational strategic actions, and ensuring that strategic plans are implemented as intended. Strategic control systems include information systems that provide feedback on the implementation and effectiveness of strategic plans.
💡 Why this matters: Even the best strategy fails without proper implementation; these factors must be aligned to make strategy work in practice.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The three levels of strategy—corporate, business, and functional—must be coordinated for maximum strategic impact. Porter’s Five Forces Model provides a systematic framework for analyzing external industry competition, while the resource-based view helps assess internal capabilities leading to distinctive competence. Corporate strategy formulation involves choosing among grand strategies (growth, stability, defensive) and using portfolio tools like the BCG matrix to allocate resources across business units. Porter’s three generic business-level strategies (cost leadership, differentiation, focus) guide how to compete within a specific industry. Finally, strategy implementation requires synchronizing technology, human resources, reward systems, decision processes, and organizational structure, all monitored through strategic control systems.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three distinct levels of strategy, and who typically develops each level?
- List the five competitive forces in Porter’s model and briefly describe each one.
- What are the four categories in the BCG growth-share matrix, and what strategy is recommended for each?
- Describe Porter’s three generic business-level strategies and give one example of how each might be applied.
- What are the five major factors managers must synchronize during strategy implementation, and what is the purpose of strategic control?