๐ Lecture 19 โ Group Decision Making
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the dynamics of group decision making, focusing on how group performance can fall short of potential due to process losses like social loafing, and how it can be enhanced through process gains and group cohesiveness. It explores various group problem-solving techniques and provides guidelines for when to use teams effectively. Understanding these concepts is critical for optimizing team performance and aligning group goals with organizational objectives.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the factors that influence group and organizational effectiveness, including process losses and gains, group cohesiveness, and the decision of when to use a team. It details the advantages and disadvantages of group decision making and compares several group problem-solving techniques such as consensus, brainstorming, the nominal group technique, the Delphi technique, and computer-aided decision making. The lecture also defines and explains social loafing and social facilitation, two critical behavioral phenomena in group settings.
๐ Lecture Summary
Deciding When to Use a Team
Effective management requires knowing when to assign a task to a team versus an individual. Teams should be used when many perspectives are needed, acceptance of the decision is critical, the problem is complex or unstructured, individual judgments are unreliable, individuals are unwilling to take necessary risks, or the goal is to develop team membersโ skills. Conversely, caution is advised when the issue is unimportant, individuals donโt want to participate, individual risk preferences are too high, time is of the essence, or group norms are unacceptable.
Guidelines for Dealing with Problem Behaviors
To mitigate problems within teams, managers should choose team members carefully, offer training, provide clear goals, and clearly define member responsibilities. Using peer evaluations and rewarding superior performance are also crucial. It is important not to let social considerations overwhelm the concern with the task. Finally, removing problem team members should be a last resort.
Group Decision Making
Group decision making involves the pooling of resources to make a choice, which has both advantages and disadvantages.
- Advantages: Groups have more knowledge through the pooling of group resources, and decisions see increased acceptance and commitment from members due to their voice in the process. There is also greater understanding due to involvement in decision stages.
- Disadvantages: Groups can experience pressure to conform, domination by one forceful member or a dominant clique, and the decision-making process requires a significant amount of time, as groups are slower than individuals.
Group Problem Solving Techniques
Several structured techniques can improve group problem solving by reducing the drawbacks of traditional interacting groups.
- Consensus: This involves presenting opinions and gaining agreement to support a decision, relying on face-to-face interaction.
- Brainstorming: A process to generate a large quantity of ideas. A group leader states the problem, and members "free-wheel" as many alternatives as possible without criticism. One idea stimulates others, encouraging creative "thinking the unusual."
- Nominal Group Technique (NGT): A structured process to generate ideas and evaluate solutions. It restricts discussion initially. Members independently write down ideas, each presents one idea in turn, the group discusses for clarity, and then members independently rank-order the ideas. The idea with the highest aggregate ranking is the final decision. Its chief advantage is that it permits formal meetings without restricting independent thinking.
- Delphi Technique: A process for physically dispersed experts. The leader distributes a topic, each member responds, the leader collects responses and sends them back to the team for feedback. This process is repeated until a resolution is reached, without face-to-face meetings.
- Computer-Assisted Group (Electronic Meeting): This blends the nominal group technique with computer technology. Up to 50 participants type their responses onto computer screens, with comments and votes displayed on a projection screen. ๐ก Why this matters: Its major advantages are anonymity, honesty, and speed.
๐ Definition โ Brainstorming: a process to generate a quantity of ideas, meant to overcome pressures for conformity. ๐ Formula: Process: (1) State Problem โ (2) Free-wheel ideas โ (3) No criticism โ (4) Record all ideas. ๐ Example: A half dozen to a dozen people sit around a table. The leader states, "How can we improve employee morale?" Members then rapidly suggest ideas like "flexible hours," "team outings," and "recognition awards" without any criticism, building on each other's suggestions.
๐ Definition โ Nominal Group Technique (NGT): a structured form of group decision making that enables everyone to participate without hostile criticism. ๐ Formula: Process: (1) Silent idea generation โ (2) Round-robin presentation โ (3) Group discussion โ (4) Silent independent ranking โ (5) Decision based on highest aggregate ranking. ๐ Example: A team is tasked with choosing a new software vendor. Each member silently lists criteria. Then, each member shares one criterion (e.g., cost, reliability, support). The group discusses and clarifies each. Finally, each member silently ranks the criteria from most to least important. The criterion with the highest total rank is the most important factor in the decision.
๐ Definition โ Delphi Technique: a process to generate ideas from physically dispersed experts. ๐ Formula: Process: (1) Leader distributes topic โ (2) Each member responds โ (3) Leader collects and sends back responses โ (4) Repeat until resolution. ๐ Example: To predict market trends, a manager sends a questionnaire to a panel of experts worldwide. After gathering their forecasts, the manager summarizes the results and sends them back. The experts then revise their predictions based on the group's average. This process is repeated until a consensus forecast emerges.
Social Loafing
A motivation problem that leads to process losses is the tendency of individuals to exert less effort when they work in a group than when they work alone. Social loafing occurs for two main reasons: (a) individuals think they will not receive positive outcomes for high performance or negative outcomes for poor performance because individual performance cannot be easily identified, and (b) individuals think their own efforts are unimportant or not needed. The sucker effect occurs when members not inclined to social loafing reduce their own efforts because they refuse to be the "suckers" of social loafers, reflecting equity theory.
๐ Definition โ Social Loafing: the tendency of individuals to exert less effort when they work in a group than when they work alone. ๐ Example: In a team project, if one member feels their contribution to a 10-page report won't be noticed, they might only write one page, believing others will pick up the slack. This reduces the team's overall performance below its potential. If another member sees this, they might also reduce their effort, resulting in a poorly completed report.
Social Facilitation
The presence of group members can stimulate individuals, who feel that others will evaluate their performance and give them feedback. Social facilitation refers to the effects that the physical presence of others has on an individualโs performance. Audience effects are the effects of passive spectators, while co-action effects are the effects of others performing the same task. The type of effect depends on how well the task is known. For well-learned or simple tasks, the presence of others enhances performance. For difficult, novel, or complex tasks, the presence of others impairs performance.
๐ Definition โ Social Facilitation: the effects that the physical presence of others has on an individualโs performance. ๐ Example: A skilled guitarist performs flawlessly during a concert (audience effect). However, the same guitarist might make mistakes while trying to learn a new, complex piece in front of a friend. Organizations can help by providing private offices for difficult tasks and meeting rooms for tasks that benefit from the presence of others.
โญ Key Takeaways
The key concept is that group performance is not simply the sum of individual efforts; it can be either diminished by process losses like social loafing or enhanced by process gains like social facilitation. Managers must choose the right problem-solving techniqueโsuch as brainstorming for idea generation or the nominal group technique for structured evaluationโbased on the situation to minimize conformity pressures and other group drawbacks. Understanding when to use a team and how to align group goals with organizational goals through group cohesiveness is crucial for achieving high performance. Ultimately, clear member responsibilities, peer evaluations, and proper training are essential to combat social loafing and maximize team effectiveness.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key conditions under which a manager should be cautious about using a team for decision making?
- What is the fundamental difference between the nominal group technique and the Delphi technique regarding member location?
- According to the lecture, what is the primary advantage of using the nominal group technique over an unstructured interacting group?
- Explain the "sucker effect" and how it relates to social loafing and equity theory.
- Describe how the effect of social facilitation on an individualโs performance differs when they are working on a well-learned task versus a novel one.
๐ Lecture 20 โ Communication
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the critical role of communication in organizations, defining it as the sharing of information to reach a common understanding. It examines the communication process, barriers to effective communication, and strategies for improvement, emphasizing that effective communication is fundamental to organizational effectiveness and performance.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining communication and its four major functions: providing knowledge, motivating members, controlling and coordinating efforts, and expressing emotions. It then details the communication process including encoding, channels, noise, decoding, and feedback. The discussion covers barriers such as filtering, poor listening, inappropriate feedback, and rumors, alongside methods for improvement like trust-building and active listening. The lecture further examines communication media richness from face-to-face to impersonal written communication, the impact of information technology, and concludes with work group communication networks (wheel, chain, circle, all-channel) and their relationship to task interdependence.
๐ Lecture Summary
What Is Communication?
Communication is the sharing of information between two or more individuals or groups to reach a common understanding. It has two components: sharing information and reaching a common understanding. This does not mean agreement, but rather an understanding of the message. If people do not receive the information or understand the meaning, communication has not taken place. Communication is critical for organizational effectiveness โ if people lack needed information, they cannot perform their jobs well, and if a common understanding is lacking, workers cannot coordinate their efforts to achieve organizational goals.
๐ Definition โ Communication: The sharing of information between two or more individuals or groups to reach a common understanding.
๐ก Why this matters: Communication affects virtually every aspect of organizational behavior, allowing individuals, groups, and organizations to achieve their goals and perform at a high level.
The Importance of Communication Skills
Top executives from Fortune 500 companies rate communications skills as the most important quality for business leaders. There may be no single thing more important in efforts to achieve meaningful work and fulfilling relationships than learning and practicing the art of communication.
The Communication Process
The communication process involves several components. Context includes physical (environment, distance, seating), social (nature of the relationship), historical (background of previous communication), psychological (moods and feelings), and cultural (shared beliefs, values, norms) aspects.
Participants include the sender (the individual, group, or organization that needs or wants to share information) and the receiver (the individual, group, or organization for which the information is intended). For example, a supervisor might be a sender with instructions about performing a task, and a new worker might be the receiver.
Messages are the information the sender needs or wants to share. Effective messages are clear (easily interpreted or understood) and complete (containing the information to achieve a common understanding). If a sender is vague or unsure about the message, communication is ineffective.
Encoding is translating the message into symbols or language that the receiver can understand. A supervisor sends a message about policy changes by encoding it in a memo. Senders must have basic writing and oral communication skills. Jargon, specialized language of members of a profession or occupation, affects good communication โ it facilitates communication within the group but leads to ineffective communication when receivers are outside the occupation.
๐ Definition โ Encoding: Translating the message into symbols or language that the receiver can understand. ๐ Definition โ Jargon: Specialized language used by members of a group that facilitates communication within the group and hinders communication outside the group.
Channels โ Formal vs. Informal Communication
Formal communication refers to messages that use formally established channels, following the chain of authority and command. Informal communication is more spontaneous communication occurring without regard for formal channels, known as the "grapevine."
Noise
Noise interferes with the communication process. There are three types:
- External noise: The sights, sounds, and other stimuli that draw people's attention away from the intended message.
- Internal noise: The thoughts and feelings that interfere with meaning.
- Semantic noise: Alternate meanings aroused by a speaker's symbols.
Managers should decrease noise by increasing readability and clarity of written communication or fixing broken answering machines and problematic e-mail systems.
๐ Definition โ Noise: Anything that interferes with the communication process, including external, internal, and semantic noise.
The Medium
The medium is the pathway through which an encoded message is transmitted to a receiver. Verbal communication is the sharing of information by means of words, either spoken or written, including face-to-face oral communication, telephone communication, and written communication using memos, letters, and reports transmitted electronically. It is important to choose a medium the receiver monitors and prefers, and the medium should be appropriate for the message. Certain messages (like termination or promotion) are best conveyed face-to-face; complex messages are best conveyed in written form for further reference. When a message is important, it is wise to use multiple media (e.g., face-to-face and written) to ensure receipt and understanding.
Nonverbal communication is the sharing of information by means of facial expressions, body language, and even dress. People have less control over nonverbal communication โ it is difficult to conceal insincerity nonverbally. For example, a sender says "Congratulations!" but their tone of voice, facial expression, or gestures may convey resentment. Nonverbal communication communicates support, acceptance, and a sense of camaraderie. Studies show that touch is necessary for psychological well-being.
๐ Definition โ Medium: The pathway through which an encoded message is transmitted to a receiver. ๐ Definition โ Verbal communication: The sharing of information by means of words, either spoken or written. ๐ Definition โ Nonverbal communication: The sharing of information by means of facial expressions, body language, and even dress.
Feedback
The receiver responds, starting the feedback loop. A variety of responses are possible: acknowledging receipt, ignoring receipt, responding with requested information, or asking for clarification. The receiver encodes the message, choosing a medium the sender monitors. The sender decodes the response and determines if the receiver properly interpreted the message. If so, the process is complete; if not, the process continues until both parties reach an understanding.
Barriers to Effective Communication and Ways to Improve Communication
There are four communications problems in organizations:
- Filtering and information distortion: Filtering occurs when senders withhold part of a message because they think the receiver does not need or want the information. Supervisors filter information by not telling subordinates details about downsizing. Withholding negative information can result in disasters โ investigations into airline crashes revealed that junior crew members were reluctant to transmit important information to the captain that could have prevented the crash.
- Poor listening
- Lack of or inappropriate feedback
- Rumors
Additional barriers include:
- Selective Perception: Receivers selectively see and hear based on their needs, motivations, experience, background, and other personal characteristics.
- Defensiveness: When individuals interpret another's message as threatening, they often respond in ways that retard effective communication.
- Language: Words mean different things to different people.
Ways to improve communication include:
- Improve Sending Messages: Clarify ideas before communicating, motivate the receiver, communicate feelings as well as facts, be aware of nonverbal behavior, and obtain feedback.
- Effective Listening: Make eye contact, exhibit affirmative head nods and appropriate facial expressions, avoid distracting actions or gestures, ask questions, avoid interrupting the speaker, don't overtalk, and make smooth transitions between the roles of speaker and listener.
๐ก Why this matters: These barriers can lead to real or potential disasters, such as airline crashes, when important information is not transmitted effectively.
โญ Key Takeaways
Communication is the sharing of information between two or more individuals or groups to reach a common understanding, not necessarily agreement. The communication process involves encoding, selecting a medium, decoding, and feedback, with noise (external, internal, semantic) as a constant barrier. Jargon facilitates communication within groups but hinders it outside; filtering, selective perception, defensiveness, and language differences are key barriers. Face-to-face communication is the richest medium, while written communication is best for complex messages requiring reference. Finally, work group communication networks (wheel, chain, circle, all-channel) vary with task interdependence โ the wheel for pooled interdependence, the chain for sequential, and the all-channel for reciprocal interdependence.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four major functions of communication in organizations, and why is reaching a common understanding important even without agreement?
- List and describe the three types of noise that interfere with the communication process, and give an example of each.
- How does jargon both facilitate and hinder communication, and what is the role of filtering in communication breakdowns?
- Compare and contrast face-to-face communication with written communication in terms of information richness and appropriate use cases.
- Explain the relationship between task interdependence (pooled, sequential, reciprocal) and the type of communication network (wheel, chain, all-channel) used in work groups.
๐ Lecture 21 โ Communication
๐ Overview: This lecture defines communication and its critical role in organizational effectiveness. It explores the communication process, its core functions, and various methods for sharing information, including an analysis of information richness. The lecture also details different interpersonal communication types, formal and informal communication networks, and provides practical guidelines for effective speaking and active listening.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and principles of communication, its four main functions within organizations (information, motivation, control/coordination, emotional expression), and the concept of information richness across different media. It then examines the three types of interpersonal communication (oral, written, nonverbal) and describes four small group communication networks (wheel, chain, circle, all-channel) along with their effectiveness criteria. The lecture concludes with practical guidelines for effective speaking and active listening.
๐ Lecture Summary
Overview
Communication is defined as the sharing of information between two or more individuals or groups to reach a common understanding. It has two essential components: the sharing of information and the reaching of a common understanding. This understanding does not necessarily mean agreement, but rather a shared interpretation of the message. If people do not receive the information or cannot understand its meaning, then communication has not taken place. Communication is critical for organizational effectiveness, as it affects most aspects of organizational behavior, including coordinating groups, motivating workers, and achieving goals. The functions of communication include providing knowledge, motivating members, controlling and coordinating efforts, and expressing feelings.
๐ Definition โ Communication: the sharing of information between two or more individuals or groups to reach a common understanding.
Communication Principles
The lecture outlines seven core principles of communication. Communication has a purpose, is continuous, and messages vary in their level of conscious encoding. It is relational, culturally bound, has ethical implications, and is a learned behavior.
Functions of Communication
Communication serves four primary functions within an organization. The Information function provides knowledge to organizational members to perform their jobs effectively and achieve goals. This knowledge is critical for newcomers to learn expectations and for experienced employees as tasks and policies change. The Motivation function plays a central role in encouraging employees, as theories like expectancy theory and goal-setting theory show that motivation depends on what managers communicate. The Control and Coordination function involves groups exerting control by communicating roles, rules, and norms, and helps coordinate individual efforts, especially as task interdependence increases. The Emotional Expression function allows people to express feelings and emotions, helping coworkers understand each other and work together more effectively.
Information Richness
Media differ in information richnessโthe amount of information they carry and how much they enable senders and receivers to reach a common understanding. Media high in information richness transmit more information and are better at generating a common understanding. Face-to-face communication is the medium highest in information richness because receivers get both verbal and nonverbal messages, and senders receive instant feedback to clarify ambiguous information. The next-highest medium is verbal communication electronically transmitted over the phone, which conveys tone and hesitations but not body language, and still allows for instant feedback.
๐ Definition โ Information Richness: the amount of information a communication medium carries and how much it enables senders and receivers to reach understanding. ๐ Formula: Medium Richness Hierarchy โ (Highest to Lowest) Face-to-face > Telephone/Electronic Verbal > Written ๐ Example: A manager explaining a new, complex procedure to a team would achieve the best understanding using face-to-face communication, as they can see confused facial expressions and immediately clarify ambiguous points. A simple announcement of an upcoming meeting date could be effectively communicated via a written email.
Interpersonal Communication
The lecture describes three types of interpersonal communication. Oral Communication has the advantages of speed and feedback, but a disadvantage is the potential for distortion of the message. Written Communication has the advantages of being tangible and verifiable, but disadvantages include being time-consuming and lacking immediate feedback. Nonverbal Communication has the advantage of supporting other communications and providing observable expression of emotions, but a key disadvantage is the potential for misperception of body language or gestures to influence the receiver's interpretation.
Communication Networks
In work groups, several types of communication networks can develop. In a wheel network, most information travels through one central member. This is common when tasks have pooled interdependence, and members work independently. In a chain network, communication flows sequentially from one member to the next, typical for sequential task interdependence like an assembly line. In a circle network, members communicate with those adjacent to them, based on physical proximity or similarity. In an all-channel network, every member communicates with every other member, which occurs in reciprocal task interdependence to coordinate complex tasks.
The effectiveness of these networks varies by criteria. The wheel and all-channel networks are fastest in speed. The wheel is most accurate. The chain has high accuracy. The all-channel has high member satisfaction. A leader emerges most clearly in the wheel network. Organizational communication networks are formally determined by reporting relationships, but actual communication patterns often differ, flowing around issues and projects rather than strictly through the chain of command.
๐ Definition โ Communication Networks: the patterns of information flow among members of a group or organization.
Guidelines for Effective Speaking
The lecture provides guidelines for effective speaking: determine the purpose of your communication, consider issues of time and space, adapt to your listeners, use appropriate vocabulary, practice voice control, use appropriate gestures, and organize your presentation.
Guidelines for Active Listening
The lecture provides guidelines for active listening: control the physical environment, be alert, be mentally prepared, be emotionally prepared, be attentive, read nonverbal cues, distinguish among facts, inferences, and value judgments, and offer and solicit feedback.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that communication is a two-part process requiring both the sharing of information and the reaching of a common understanding. The four primary functions of communicationโinformation, motivation, control/coordination, and emotional expressionโare all essential for organizational effectiveness. The concept of information richness is critical for choosing the right medium; face-to-face is richest for complex or ambiguous messages. Different interpersonal communication methods (oral, written, nonverbal) have distinct advantages and disadvantages, and one must be aware of the potential for misperception with nonverbal cues. Finally, understanding different communication networks (wheel, chain, circle, all-channel) and their impact on speed, accuracy, member satisfaction, and leader emergence is key for analyzing group dynamics.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two essential components that must be present for communication to have taken place?
- Which communication medium has the highest information richness, and why?
- What are the four functions of communication in an organization?
- In which type of communication network does every member communicate with every other member, and what type of task interdependence does it typically support?
- List two advantages and two disadvantages of written communication.
๐ Lecture 22 โ Leadership Theories
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the central role of leadership in understanding group behavior and achieving organizational goals. It covers the evolution of leadership theories from trait-based approaches to behavioral models, emphasizing that effective leadership depends on both personal characteristics and specific behaviors. Understanding these theories is crucial for improving group performance and selecting or training effective leaders.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining leadership and distinguishing it from management, then examines the importance of studying leadership. It explores the distinctions between managers and leaders, the roles of leadership and followership, and sources of leader power. The core theories covered include Trait Theories of Leadership, the Behavior Approach with Consideration and Initiating Structure, Leader Reward and Punishing Behavior, the Ohio State Studies, University of Michigan Studies, and the Managerial Grid.
๐ Lecture Summary
Overview
Leadership plays a central part in understanding group behavior, for it is the leader who usually provides the direction toward goal attainment. Therefore, a more accurate predictive capability should be valuable in improving group performance. The original search for a set of universal leadership traits failed. At best, individuals who are ambitious, have high energy, a desire to lead, self-confidence, intelligence, hold job-relevant knowledge, are perceived as honest and trustworthy, and are flexible are more likely to succeed as leaders. The behavioral approach narrowed leadership into task-oriented and people-oriented styles, but no one style was found effective in all situations. A major breakthrough came with the recognition of contingency theories that included situational factors like task structure, stress, group support, leader intelligence and experience, and follower characteristics.
Definition
John Kotter feels that management is about coping with complexity, bringing order and consistency through formal plans, rigid structures, and monitoring. Leadership is about coping with change, establishing direction by developing a vision, aligning people, and inspiring them to overcome hurdles. Robert House concurs that managers use authority from formal rank to obtain compliance, while management consists of implementing vision and strategy. We define leadership as โthe ability to influence a group toward the achievement of goals.โ The source of influence may be formal (position-based) or non-sanctioned (arising outside formal structure). Not all leaders are managers, nor are all managers leaders. Organizations need strong leadership and strong management for optimum effectiveness.
What Is Leadership?
There is no universally agreed-upon definition, but it involves influencing the attitudes, beliefs, behaviors, and feelings of other people. Most agree it is important. Leadership is an interpersonal process where influence is exercised in a social system for achieving organizational goals by others. Researchers agree on two characteristics: first, leadership involves exerting influence over others; second, it involves helping a group achieve its goals. A leader helps others achieve organizational goals and influences perceptions and behaviors like attitudes, learning, motivation, stress, performance, and turnover. Leader effectiveness is the extent to which a leader helps a group or organization achieve its goals.
Why Study Leadership?
Understanding leadership helps organizations select the right people for leadership positions and train people in leadership positions to improve. Those who benefit include leaders, followers, and organizations.
Distinctions between Managers and Leaders
Leadership is the process of guiding and directing behavior of people in the work environment. Formal leadership is officially sanctioned leadership based on authority of a formal position. Formal leaders have authority to influence other members to achieve organizational goals. Leaders innovate, develop, inspire, take the long-term view, ask what and why, originate, and challenge the status quo. Managers administer, maintain, control, have a short-term view, ask how and when, and accept the status quo. Informal leadership is unofficial leadership accorded by other members of the organization. Informal leaders lack formal authority but sometimes exert just as much influence, based on special skills or talents. Followership is the process of being guided and directed by a leader in the work environment.
Followers Can Make a Bigger Contribution By:
Power is the capacity of a leader to influence work actions or decisions. Followers contribute by being more proactive in solving problems, becoming better skilled at โinfluencing upward,โ and staying flexible and open to opportunities.
How Leaders Interact with Followers
Leaders create environments where followersโ innovations and creative contributions are welcome, encourage growth and development, are interested in the big picture, motivate through personal and intangible factors, redefine task parameters, and change situations rather than just optimize adaptation.
Leaders and power
Sources of leader power include furniture and office arrangements, prominently displayed symbols, appearances of title and authority, choice of clothing, and presence or absence of crisis.
Theories of Leadership
Trait Theories of Leadership
Early studies identified personal characteristics and traits that distinguish leaders from followers and effective from ineffective leaders. Traits are the particular tendencies a person has to feel, think, and act in certain ways. Results from nearly 300 studies suggested the following traits have the strongest relationship to effective leadership: Intelligence, Task-relevant knowledge, Dominance (the need to exert influence and control over others), Self-confidence, Energy/activity levels, Tolerance for stress, Integrity and honesty, and Emotional maturity. However, the trait approach is limited because it is unclear whether these traits are key for becoming a leader or result from being a leader. It provides little guidance for training, as traits are stable, and fails to explain why or how effective leadership occurs.
๐ Definition โ Trait Theories: Theories that attempt to isolate characteristics that differentiate leaders from nonleaders. ๐ Key Concept: Attempts to identify traits consistently associated with leadership have been more successful than attempts to find universal traits. ๐ Example: Six traits on which leaders tend to differ from non-leaders are: Ambition and energy, Desire to lead, Honesty and integrity, Self-confidence, Intelligence, and Job-relevant knowledge. Recent research shows that people who are high self-monitors are much more likely to emerge as leaders in groups than low self-monitors.
๐ก Why this matters: The trait approach has at least four limitations: (1) no universal traits predict in all situations; (2) traits predict behavior more in โweakโ situations than โstrongโ situations (where behavioral norms, incentives, and expectations are clear); (3) evidence is unclear in separating cause from effect; (4) traits do a better job at predicting appearance of leadership than distinguishing effective from ineffective leaders.
The Behavior Approach: Consideration and Initiating Structure
Researchers using the behavior approach identified specific behaviors that contribute to leadersโ effectiveness. The Ohio State researchers measured over 1800 leader behaviors and found they involved either consideration or initiating structure. Consideration is behavior indicating that a leader trusts, respects, and values good relationships with followers. A considerate leader is friendly, treats others as equals, gives explanations, and shows concern for workersโ well-being. Initiating structure refers to a leaderโs behavior that assures work completion and subordinate performance, including assigning tasks, planning, setting goals, deciding how tasks are accomplished, and encouraging followers. Consideration and initiating structure are complementary and independentโleaders can engage in both.
๐ Definition โ Consideration: The extent to which a person has job relationships characterized by mutual trust, respect for employeesโ ideas, and regard for their feelings. ๐ Definition โ Initiating structure: The extent to which a leader defines and structures their role and those of employees in the search for goal attainment, including organizing work, work relationships, and goals.
University of Michigan researchers identified employee-oriented and job-centered behaviors corresponding to consideration and initiating structure. The Managerial Grid focuses on concern for people and concern for production. The Hersey and Blanchard model also focuses on these behaviors. Studies show no consistent relationship between consideration and high job satisfaction or between initiating structure and performance.
The Behavior Approach: Leader Reward and Punishing Behavior
Leader reward behavior occurs when a leader positively reinforces subordinatesโ desirable behavior with praise, compliments, pay raises, or promotions. Reward behavior keeps workers performing at a high level. Leader punishing behavior occurs when a leader reprimands or responds negatively to subordinates who perform undesirably. Punishing is best used only to curtail undesirable behavior as it has side effects like resentment. Although reinforcement is more effective, leaders often engage in punishing behavior.
Trait theories assume leadership is basically inborn, allowing selection of right leaders. The behavioral approach suggests we can train people to be leaders by designing programs to implant behavioral patterns.
The Ohio State Studies
The most comprehensive behavioral theories resulted from Ohio State University research in the late 1940s. Researchers narrowed over a thousand dimensions into two: initiating structure and consideration. A leader high in initiating structure โassigns group members to particular tasks,โ โexpects workers to maintain definite standards of performance,โ and โemphasizes the meeting of deadlines.โ A leader high in consideration helps employees with personal problems, is friendly and approachable, and treats all employees as equals. Leaders high on both dimensions tended to achieve high employee performance and satisfaction, but this โhigh-highโ style did not always result in positive consequences. High initiating structure led to greater grievances, absenteeism, and turnover, and lower job satisfaction for routine tasks. High consideration was negatively related to performance ratings by superiors.
University of Michigan Studies
Conducted simultaneously with Ohio State studies with similar objectives, researchers discovered two dimensions: employee-oriented and production-oriented. Employee-oriented leaders emphasized interpersonal relations, took personal interest in employee needs, and accepted individual differences. Production-oriented leaders emphasized technical or task aspects, viewing group members as means to an end. Michigan researchers strongly favored employee-oriented leaders, as they were associated with higher group productivity and higher job satisfaction. Production-oriented leaders were associated with low group productivity and lower job satisfaction.
The Managerial Grid
Blake and Mouton proposed a managerial grid based on โconcern for peopleโ and โconcern for production,โ representing Ohio Stateโs consideration and initiating structure or Michiganโs employee-oriented and production-oriented. The grid has nine possible positions along each axis, creating 81 different positions. It shows dominating factors in a leaderโs thinking regarding getting results. Based on findings, managers performed best under a 9,9 style (Team Management), contrasted with a 9,1 style (Authority-Obedience) or 1,9 style (Country Club Management). The grid offers a better framework for conceptualizing leadership style than presenting tangible new information.
โญ Key Takeaways
Leadership is defined as the ability to influence a group toward goal achievement, and it is distinct from managementโleaders innovate and challenge the status quo while managers administer and maintain it. The trait approach identifies several characteristics (ambition, desire to lead, honesty, self-confidence, intelligence, job-relevant knowledge) that increase the likelihood of leadership success, but no universal traits guarantee effectiveness in all situations. The behavioral approach, particularly the Ohio State and Michigan studies, identifies two key dimensions: consideration (concern for relationships) and initiating structure (concern for tasks), though no single behavioral style is universally effective. The Managerial Grid conceptualizes leadership styles along these two dimensions, with the 9,9 team management style considered most effective. Understanding these theories helps organizations select, train, and develop effective leaders by recognizing that leadership involves both personal traits and learned behaviors.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key distinction between a manager and a leader according to John Kotter?
- List the six traits that consistently differentiate leaders from non-leaders.
- What are the two dimensions of leader behavior identified in the Ohio State Studies, and how do they differ?
- What is the difference between leader reward behavior and leader punishing behavior?
- According to the Managerial Grid, which leadership style (identified by its coordinates) is considered most effective, and what is it called?