π Lecture 10 β Perception
π Overview: This lecture explores how individuals interpret their environment through perception, which fundamentally shapes their behavior in organizations. It explains that people act based on their perceived reality rather than objective reality, making perception a critical factor influencing productivity, absenteeism, turnover, and job satisfaction. The lecture also covers attribution theory, social perception, and common perceptual barriers that distort decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing perception as the process by which people select, organize, and interpret sensory input to give meaning to their environment. It then examines factors influencing perception including the perceiver, target, and situation; the nature of perception and its components; internal versus external attributions of behavior; the link between perception and individual decision-making; social perception processes; and finally, barriers to social perception including selective perception, the halo effect, and stereotyping.
π Lecture Summary
Overview
Evidence suggests that what individuals perceive from their work situation will influence their productivity more than the situation itself. Whether a job is actually interesting or challenging is irrelevant; what matters is how employees perceive it. Similarly, fair pay, performance appraisals, and working conditions are not judged in a way that assures common perceptions. Absenteeism, turnover, and job satisfaction are reactions to the individualβs perceptions. Managers must understand how each individual interprets reality and eliminate distortions where significant differences exist between what is seen and what exists. Perception is the process by which individuals select, organize, and interpret sensory input. Attribution is an explanation of the cause of behavior. Perception and attribution explain how and why people behave in organizations and react to the behavior of others.
The perceiver's knowledge base is organized into schemas, abstract knowledge structures stored in memory that allow people to organize and interpret information about a given target. Schemas tend to be resistant to change and can be functional or dysfunctional. A stereotype is a dysfunctional schema because stereotypes often lead perceivers to assume erroneously that targets have a whole range of characteristics simply because they possess one distinguishing characteristic. Characteristics of the target also influence perceptionβambiguous targets are subject to more interpretation. The situation affects perception by providing the perceiver with additional information, particularly the target's salienceβthe extent to which the target stands out. Biases in person perception include primacy effects, contrast effects, halo effects, similar-to-me effects, harshness, leniency, average tendencies, and knowledge-of-predictor bias.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that perceptions, not objective reality, drive employee behavior is crucial for managers trying to influence productivity, reduce turnover, and improve job satisfaction.
What is Perception?
"A process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment."
Why is it Important?
- Because people's behavior is based on their perception of what reality is, not on reality itself.
- The world that is perceived is the world that is behaviorally important.
Factors Influencing Perception
Three factors influence perception: the perceiver, the target, and the situation.
When an individual looks at a target and attempts to interpret what he or she sees, that interpretation is heavily influenced by personal characteristics of the individual perceiver. The more relevant personal characteristics affecting perception are attitudes, motives, interests, past experiences, and expectations.
Characteristics of the target can also affect what is being perceived. This includes attractiveness, gregariousness, and our tendency to group similar things together. For example, members of a group with clearly distinguishable features or color are often perceived as alike in other, unrelated characteristics as well. The context in which we see objects or events also influences our attention, including factors like time, heat, light, or other situational factors.
The Nature of Perception
Perception is the process by which individuals select, organize, and interpret the input from their senses to give meaning and order to the world around them. The process involves the perceiver (the person making the interpretation), the target of perception (what the perceiver interprets), and the situation (in which perception takes place). The target can be an event, a situation, an idea, a noise, a group of people, or another person. Person perception, the process of perceiving another person, plays a large role in organizational behavior.
Internal and External Attributions
Causal explanations for behaviors can be either internal attributions (behavior caused by some characteristic of the target) or external attributions (behavior assigned to factors outside the individual). Common internal attributions include ability, effort, and personality. Poor performance may be attributed to lack of effort or ability, and poor relations with coworkers may be attributed to personality. Common external attributions include luck, chance, and easy tasks. A worker's accomplishment may be viewed as a stroke of luck.
Whether attributions are internal or external determines how people respond to behavior. High performance attributed to ability results in a promotion, but attributed to luck results in no promotion. The attributions people make for their own behavior influence subsequent actions. A successful worker who attributes an outcome to luck remains unaffected, whereas attributing success to ability increases confidence.
π Definition β Internal Attribution: Behavior caused by some characteristic of the target, such as ability, effort, or personality.
π Definition β External Attribution: Behavior assigned to factors outside the individual, such as luck, chance, or task difficulty.
π Example: A manager observes an employee's high performance. If the manager makes an internal attribution (attributing it to ability), the employee receives a promotion. If the manager makes an external attribution (attributing it to luck), no promotion is given.
The Link between Perception and Individual Decision Making
Individuals in organizations make decisionsβthey make choices from among two or more alternatives. Top managers determine goals, products, services, financing, and locations. Middle- and lower-level managers determine production schedules, select new employees, and decide pay raises. Non-managerial employees make decisions including whether to come to work, how much effort to put forward, and whether to comply with requests. Many organizations have been empowering non-managerial employees with job-related decision-making authority historically reserved for managers.
There is a discrepancy between some current state of affairs and some desired state, requiring consideration of alternative courses of action. The awareness that a problem exists and that a decision needs to be made is a perceptual issue. Every decision requires interpretation and evaluation of information. Data are typically received from multiple sources, and the decision maker must determine which data are relevant and which are not. Alternatives will be developed, and the strengths and weaknesses of each will need to be evaluated.
Social Perception
"Social perception refers to the processes through which individuals attempt to combine, integrate, and interpret information about others." Social status, a target's real or perceived position in society or an organization, also affects perception. High-status targets are perceived as more credible, knowledgeable, and responsible than low-status targets. Organizations use high-status targets to make public announcements and presentations because the audience perceives that person as credible.
To ensure that women and minorities enjoy equal footing including social status, many organizations have adopted affirmative action programs. Yet these programs may perpetuate the low status of women and minorities because others perceive and treat affirmative action hires as second-class citizens. After qualified employees left the company, Monsanto realized that affirmative action initiatives must include training programs to manage diversity, eliminate bias, and avoid the second-class citizen status that minorities inadvertently acquire.
Barriers to Social Perception
1. Selective Perception Any characteristic that makes a person, object, or event stand out will increase the probability that it will be perceived. It is impossible for us to assimilate everything we seeβonly certain stimuli can be taken in.
2. Halo Effect The halo effect occurs when we draw a general impression on the basis of a single characteristic. This phenomenon frequently occurs when students appraise their classroom instructor. Students may give prominence to a single trait such as enthusiasm and allow their entire evaluation to be tainted by how they judge the instructor on that one trait.
The reality of the halo effect was confirmed in a classic study. Subjects were given a list of traits such as intelligent, skillful, practical, industrious, determined, and warm, and were asked to evaluate the person to whom those traits applied. When the word "warm" was substituted with "cold," the subjects changed their evaluation of the person. This experiment showed that subjects were allowing a single trait to influence their overall impression of the person being judged. Research suggests the halo effect is likely to be most extreme when the traits to be perceived are ambiguous in behavioral terms, when the traits have moral overtones, and when the perceiver is judging traits with which they have had limited experience.
π Definition β Halo Effect: Drawing a general impression about a person based on a single characteristic.
π Example: A student rates an instructor as excellent overall simply because the instructor is enthusiastic, ignoring other important teaching qualities like clarity or fairness.
3. Stereotyping Stereotyping means judging someone on the basis of our perception of the group to which he or she belongs. Generalization is not without advantagesβit is a means of simplifying a complex world and permits us to maintain consistency. The problem is when we inaccurately stereotype. In organizations, we frequently hear comments that represent stereotypes based on gender, age, race, ethnicity, and even weight. From a perceptual standpoint, if people expect to see these stereotypes, that is what they will perceive, whether or not they are accurate.
π Definition β Stereotyping: Judging someone based on our perception of the group to which they belong.
β Key Takeaways
Perception is the process by which individuals select, organize, and interpret sensory input to give meaning to their environment, and it is critical because people behave based on their perceived reality, not objective reality. The three components of perception are the perceiver, the target, and the situation, with the perceiver's attitudes, motives, past experiences, and expectations heavily influencing interpretation. Attributionsβwhether internal (ability, effort, personality) or external (luck, chance, task difficulty)βdetermine how people respond to behavior, such as whether high performance leads to a promotion or is dismissed as luck. Major barriers to accurate social perception include selective perception (focusing on standout characteristics), the halo effect (forming a general impression from a single trait), and stereotyping (judging based on group membership), all of which can lead to faulty decision-making in organizations.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of perception, and why is it more important than objective reality in determining employee behavior?
- What are the three factors that influence perception, and what personal characteristics of the perceiver affect how they interpret a target?
- Distinguish between internal and external attributions, providing examples of each and explaining how they affect responses to performance.
- What is the halo effect, and under what conditions is it most likely to be extreme?
- What are the three barriers to social perception discussed in this lecture, and how can each lead to inaccurate judgments?
π Lecture 11 β Perception, Attitudes, and Personality
π Overview: This lecture explores how people interpret sensory input to give meaning to their world, focusing on perception and attribution processes in organizations. It explains why accurate perceptions and attributions are critical for decision-making, performance evaluation, and managing diverse employees. The lecture also covers common biases and shortcuts that distort judgment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers perception as a process with perceiver, target, and situation components; schemas and stereotypes; biases in person perception including primacy, halo, and similar-to-me effects; attribution theory distinguishing internal and external causation; fundamental attribution error and self-serving bias; frequently used shortcuts in judging others like selective perception and stereotyping; specific applications in employment interviews, performance expectations, performance evaluation, and employee effort; rater errors including leniency, harshness, and central tendency; and the concept of misperception.
π Lecture Summary
Perception, Attitudes, and Personality
Perception is the process by which individuals select, organize, and interpret sensory input to give meaning and order to the world around them. The three components of perception are the perceiver, the target, and the situation. Accurate perceptions are necessary to make good decisions, motivate workers, be fair and equitable, and act ethically. Attribution is an explanation of the cause of behavior. Perception and attribution explain how and why people behave in organizations and react to others' behavior.
The perceiver's knowledge base is organized into schemas β abstract knowledge structures stored in memory that allow people to organize and interpret information about a given target of perception. Schemas tend to be resistant to change and can be functional or dysfunctional. A stereotype is a dysfunctional schema because it leads perceivers to assume erroneously that targets have a range of characteristics simply because they possess one distinguishing characteristic (e.g., race, age, or gender). The perceiver's motivational state and mood also influence perception.
Characteristics of the target influence perception. Ambiguous targets are subject to a lot of interpretation; the more ambiguous the target, the more likely perceivers differ in their perceptions. The target's social status also affects perception. Through impression management, targets can actively try to manage the perceptions others have of them. The situation affects perception by providing additional information. Salience β the extent to which the target stands out in a group β is particularly important.
Biases and problems in person perception include primacy effects, contrast effects, halo effects, similar-to-me effects, harshness, leniency, average tendencies, and knowledge-of-predictor bias. Inaccurate perceptions from these biases can lead to faulty decision making.
Attributes
Attributes β The process through which individuals attempt to determine the causes of others' behavior.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how people explain behavior determines how organizations respond to performance β attributing success to ability leads to promotion, while attributing it to luck leads to no change.
Attribution Theory
Attribution theory describes how people explain the causes of their own and other people's behavior. To the extent that attributions are accurate, better organizational decisions can be made. Supervisors make attributions for high or low performance. If a supervisor attributes high performance to exceptional ability, challenging work is assigned; if attributed to luck, no change in assignment is made. Incorrect attributions result in over-challenging or under-challenging assignments.
π Definition β Attribution Theory: People try to make sense of a situation by explaining its cause; this explanation is an attribution.
Internal and External Attributions
Causal explanations for behaviors can be either internal attributions (behavior caused by some characteristic of the target) or external attributions (behavior assigned to factors outside the individual). Common internal attributions include ability, effort, and personality. Common external attributions include luck, chance, and easy tasks.
Whether attributions are internal or external determines how people respond to behavior. High performance attributed to ability results in a promotion; attributed to luck results in no promotion. The attributions people make for their own behavior influence subsequent actions β a successful worker who attributes an outcome to luck remains unaffected, whereas attributing success to ability increases confidence.
Our perceptions of people differ from perceptions of inanimate objects because we make inferences about actions of people that we don't make about inanimate objects. People have beliefs, motives, or intentions. Our perception and judgment of a person's actions are influenced by these assumptions.
Attribution theory suggests that when we observe an individual's behavior, we attempt to determine whether it was internally or externally caused. That determination depends on three factors:
- Distinctiveness: Shows different behaviors in different situations
- Consensus: Response is the same as others to same situation
- Consistency: Responds in the same way over time
π Definition β Internally caused behaviors: Behaviors believed to be under the personal control of the individual. π Definition β Externally caused behavior: Behavior seen as resulting from outside causes; the person is forced into the behavior by the situation.
Distinctiveness refers to whether an individual displays different behaviors in different situations. If the observed behavior is unusual, the observer is likely to give it an external attribution. If the action is not unusual, it will probably be judged as internal.
Consensus occurs if everyone faced with a similar situation responds the same way. If consensus is high, you would give an external attribution; if other employees responded differently, your conclusion would be internal.
Consistency in a person's actions β does the person respond the same way over time? The more consistent the behavior, the more the observer is inclined to attribute it to internal causes.
Fundamental Attribution Error
Fundamental Attribution Error β There is substantial evidence that we have a tendency to underestimate the influence of external factors and overestimate the influence of internal or personal factors.
Self-serving bias β There is a tendency for individuals to attribute their own successes to internal factors such as ability or effort while putting the blame for failure on external factors such as luck. This suggests feedback provided to employees will be distorted by recipients.
π Definition β Fundamental Attribution Error: The tendency to underestimate external factors and overestimate internal factors when explaining others' behavior. π Definition β Self-serving bias: The tendency to attribute successes to internal factors and failures to external factors.
Are these biases universal across different cultures? Korean managers tended to accept responsibility for group failure, contrary to the self-serving bias. Attribution theory was developed based on experiments with Americans and Western Europeans. The Korean study suggests caution in making attribution theory predictions in non-Western societies, especially in countries with strong collectivist traditions.
Frequently Used Shortcuts in Judging Others
- Selective Perception β People selectively interpret what they see based on their interest, background, experience, and attitudes.
- Halo Effect β A general impression about an individual is based on a single positive characteristic.
- Contrast Effects β Evaluations of a person's characteristics affected by comparisons with other people recently encountered who rank higher or lower on the same characteristics.
- Projection β Attributing one's own characteristics to other people.
- Stereotyping β Judging someone based on the group to which he/she belongs.
Specific Applications in Organizations
1. Employment Interview Evidence indicates that interviewers make perceptual judgments that are often inaccurate. Agreement among interviewers is often poor β different interviewers see different things in the same candidate. Interviewers generally draw early impressions that become quickly entrenched. Studies indicate most interviewers' decisions change very little after the first four or five minutes of the interview. Because interviews usually have little consistent structure, judgments of the same candidate can vary widely.
2. Performance Expectations Evidence demonstrates that people will attempt to validate their perceptions of reality, even when those perceptions are faulty. Self-fulfilling prophecy or Pygmalion effect characterizes the fact that people's expectations determine their behavior β expectations become reality. A study with 105 soldiers in the Israeli Defense Forces taking a fifteen-week combat command course randomly divided soldiers and identified them as having high potential, normal potential, or potential not known. Instructors got better results from the high potential group because they expected it, confirming the self-fulfilling prophecy effect.
3. Performance Evaluation An employee's performance appraisal is very much dependent on the perceptual process. Although the appraisal can be objective, many jobs are evaluated in subjective terms. Subjective measures are, by definition, judgmental. To the degree that managers use subjective measures, what the evaluator perceives to be good or bad employee characteristics or behaviors will significantly influence the outcome.
4. Employee Effort An individual's future in an organization is usually not dependent on performance alone. An assessment of an individual's effort is a subjective judgment susceptible to perceptual distortions and bias.
Perception and Performance Appraisal
Higher in the organizational hierarchy, it becomes more difficult to find objective measures or quantifiable evidence to measure performance. Therefore, organizations rely on subjective measures of effectiveness provided by managers.
Rater Errors
Sometimes individuals make similar judgments even though job performance is varied. Some supervisors are overly harsh, others overly lenient, and others rate everyone as average. High performers don't receive the rewards they deserve, and low performers don't improve. Biases make it difficult to compare employees rated by different supervisors.
- Leniency β The tendency to perceive the job performance of ratees as especially good.
- Harshness β The tendency to perceive the job performance of ratees as especially ineffective.
- Central tendency β The tendency to assign most ratees to middle-range job performance categories.
Halo effect β The rating of an individual on one trait or characteristic tends to color ratings on other traits or characteristics. A halo effect occurs when the perceiver's general impression of a target distorts perception of the target on specific dimensions. Halo effects can be positive or negative. A subordinate viewed positively may be rated high on work quality though the work is full of mistakes β the subordinate will not receive the necessary feedback to improve performance. A negative impression may lead the supervisor to perceive the subordinate as uncooperative.
Similar-to-me effect β A rater gives more favorable evaluations to people who are similar to the rater in terms of background or attitudes. People tend to perceive those similar to themselves more positively than those dissimilar. The similar-to-me effect can adversely affect women and minorities trying to climb the corporate ladder. Members of an organization must be on guard for this bias when interacting with people from other cultures.
Misperception
Misperception is the cognitive process by which an individual selects and organizes, but misinterprets, environmental stimuli.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that perception is a selective and interpretive process shaped by the perceiver's schemas, the target's characteristics, and the situation. Attribution theory explains how people determine causes of behavior using distinctiveness, consensus, and consistency, with errors like fundamental attribution error and self-serving bias distorting judgment. Common shortcuts in judging others include selective perception, halo effect, contrast effects, projection, and stereotyping β all of which can lead to faulty decisions in hiring, performance evaluation, and employee development. Rater errors such as leniency, harshness, central tendency, halo effect, and similar-to-me effect undermine the fairness and accuracy of performance appraisals. Organizations must actively promote accurate perceptions through top management commitment to diversity, diversity training, and awareness of perceptual biases to make better organizational decisions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of perception, and how does each influence how we perceive others?
- What three factors determine whether we make an internal or external attribution for someone's behavior?
- What is the fundamental attribution error, and how does it differ from the self-serving bias?
- How does the halo effect distort performance evaluations, and what negative consequences can it cause?
- Explain the self-fulfilling prophecy (Pygmalion effect) and provide an example from the lecture of how it operates in organizations.
π Lecture 12 β Perception and Decision Making
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical link between perception and individual decision-making in organizations. It examines how decision makers' perceptions influence every stage of the decision process, from problem identification to alternative selection. The lecture contrasts the rational decision-making model with more realistic approaches like bounded rationality and intuitive decision-making, and discusses decision-making styles, organizational constraints, cultural differences, and ethical frameworks.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers: the link between perception and individual decision making; the rational decision-making model with its six steps and assumptions; bounded rationality as a more realistic model of decision making; intuitive decision-making as an unconscious process; four decision-making styles (directive, analytic, conceptual, behavioral); organizational constraints on decision makers including performance evaluation, reward systems, and time pressures; cultural differences in decision making; ethics in decision making using utilitarian, rights, and justice criteria; and two critical decision-making phases of problem identification and alternative development.
π Lecture Summary
The Link between Perception and Individual Decision Making
Individuals in organizations constantly make decisions β choices from among two or more alternatives. Top managers determine organizational goals, products, financing, and plant locations. Middle- and lower-level managers determine production schedules, select employees, and allocate pay raises. Non-managerial employees decide whether to come to work, how much effort to put forward, and whether to comply with boss requests. Many organizations now empower non-managerial employees with job-related decision-making authority historically reserved for managers.
Decision-making occurs as a reaction to a problem β a discrepancy between some current state of affairs and some desired state, requiring consideration of alternative courses of action. The awareness that a problem exists and that a decision needs to be made is a perceptual issue. Every decision requires interpretation and evaluation of information. Data come from multiple sources; the decision maker must determine which data are relevant and which alternatives' strengths and weaknesses need evaluation.
π Definition β Problem: A discrepancy between some current state of affairs and some desired state. π Definition β Decisions: The choices made from among two or more alternatives.
π‘ Why this matters: Perception filters the information a decision maker attends to, making it the foundation of every organizational decision, from strategic to operational.
Rational Decision-Making Model
The Rational Decision-Making Model describes how individuals should behave in order to maximize some outcomes. The optimizing decision maker is rational, making consistent, value-maximizing choices within specified constraints.
Six Steps in the Rational Decision-Making Model:
- Define the problem: A problem is a discrepancy between an existing and a desired state of affairs. Many poor decisions can be traced to the decision maker overlooking a problem or defining the wrong problem.
- Identify the decision criteria: The decision maker determines what is relevant in making the decision. Any factors not identified are considered irrelevant. This brings in the decision maker's interests, values, and personal preferences.
- Allocate weights to the criteria: Give the criteria correct priority in the decision.
- Develop the alternatives: Generate possible alternatives that could succeed in resolving the problem.
- Evaluate the alternatives: Rate each alternative on each criterion. Critically analyze and evaluate each alternative. The strengths and weaknesses become evident as they are compared with the criteria and weights.
- Select the best alternative: Compute the optimal decision by evaluating each alternative against the weighted criteria and selecting the alternative with the highest total score.
Assumptions of the Rational Model:
- Problem clarity: The decision maker has complete information regarding the decision situation.
- Known options: The decision maker is aware of all possible consequences of each alternative.
- Clear preferences: Criteria and alternatives can be ranked and weighted to reflect importance.
- Constant preferences: Specific decision criteria are constant and weights are stable over time.
- No time or cost constraints: The decision maker can obtain full information about criteria and alternatives.
- Maximum payoff: The decision maker will choose the alternative that yields the highest perceived value.
π‘ Why this matters: The rational model provides an ideal standard but rarely reflects how real decisions are made due to human cognitive limitations.
Bounded Rationality
When faced with complex problems, most people respond by reducing the problem to a level at which it can be readily understood. This is because the limited information-processing capability of human beings makes it impossible to assimilate and understand all the information necessary to optimize. Instead, people satisfice β they seek solutions that are satisfactory and sufficient.
How does bounded rationality work? Once a problem is identified, the search for criteria and alternatives begins. The decision maker identifies a limited list of the more conspicuous choices β those easy to find, highly visible, and representing familiar criteria and previously tried-and-true solutions. Once this limited set is identified, the decision maker reviews it, starting with alternatives that differ only slightly from the current choice. The first alternative that meets the "good enough" criterion ends the search. The order in which alternatives are considered is critical in determining which is selected. Alternatives that depart the least from the status quo are the most likely to be selected.
π Definition β Bounded Rationality: A process of making decisions by constructing simplified models that extract the essential features from problems without capturing all their complexity.
π‘ Why this matters: Bounded rationality explains why managers often choose "good enough" solutions rather than perfect ones, especially under time pressure.
Intuitive Decision-Making
Intuitive decision-making is an unconscious process created out of distilled experience. It operates in complement with rational analysis. Some consider it a form of extrasensory power or sixth sense; others believe it is a personality trait.
Research on chess playing shows how intuition works: the expert's experience allows recognition of patterns in a situation and draws upon previously learned information to quickly arrive at a decision choice. The result is that the intuitive decision maker can decide rapidly with what appears to be very limited information.
Eight conditions when people are most likely to use intuitive decision making: a. When a high level of uncertainty exists b. When there is little precedent to draw on c. When variables are less scientifically predictable d. When "facts" are limited e. When facts do not clearly point the way to go f. When analytical data are of little use g. When there are several plausible alternative solutions with good arguments for each h. When time is limited and there is pressure to come up with the right decision
Although intuitive decision making has gained respectability, people in North America, Great Britain, and other cultures where rational analysis is approved often do not acknowledge using it because rational analysis is considered more socially desirable.
Decision-Making Styles
Research has identified four different individual approaches to making decisions. People differ along two dimensions: way of thinking (logical/rational vs. intuitive/creative) and tolerance for ambiguity (low need to minimize ambiguity vs. able to process many thoughts simultaneously).
The four decision-making styles:
- Directive: Low tolerance for ambiguity, seeks rationality. Efficient and logical. Decisions made with minimal information and few alternatives assessed. Decisions made fast, focusing on the short-run.
- Analytic: Greater tolerance for ambiguity. Desire for more information and consideration of more alternatives. Best characterized as careful decision makers with ability to adapt to or cope with new situations.
- Conceptual: Tend to be very broad in outlook and consider many alternatives. Focus is long range, very good at finding creative solutions.
- Behavioral: Works well with others. Concerned with achievement of peers and subordinates, receptive to suggestions from others, relies heavily on meetings for communicating. Tries to avoid conflict and seeks acceptance.
Most managers have characteristics that fall into more than one style. It is best to think in terms of a manager's dominant style and backup styles. Business students, lower-level managers, and top executives tend to score highest in the analytic style. Focusing on decision styles helps understand how two equally intelligent people with access to the same information can differ in how they approach decisions and the final choices they make.
Organizational Constraints on Decision Makers
Organizations constrain decision makers through policies, regulations, and time constraints.
- Performance evaluation: Managers are strongly influenced by the criteria by which they are evaluated. Their performance reflects expectation.
- Reward systems: The organization's reward system influences decision makers by suggesting which choices are preferable in terms of personal payoff.
- Programmed routines: Organizations create rules, policies, procedures, and formalized regulations to standardize behavior. By programming decisions, organizations get individuals to achieve high performance without paying for years of experience.
- System-imposed time constraints: Organizations impose deadlines on decisions. Decisions must be made quickly to stay ahead of competition and keep customers satisfied. Almost all important decisions come with explicit deadlines.
- Historical Precedents: Decisions have a context. Individual decisions are more accurately characterized as points in a stream of decisions. Decisions made in the past are ghosts that continually haunt current choices. The largest determining factor of any given year's budget is last year's budget.
Cultural Differences in Decision Making
The rational model makes no acknowledgment of cultural differences. The cultural background of the decision maker can significantly influence: selection of problems; depth of analysis; importance placed on logic and rationality; and whether organizational decisions should be made autocratically by an individual manager or collectively in groups. Cultures differ in terms of time orientation, importance of rationality, belief in people's ability to solve problems, and preference for collective decision making.
Ethics in Decision Making
Three ethical criteria guide decision making:
1. Utilitarian criterion: Decisions made solely on the basis of their outcomes or consequences. The goal is to provide the greatest good for the greatest number. This view tends to dominate business decision making.
2. Focus on rights: Calls on individuals to make decisions consistent with fundamental liberties and privileges (e.g., Bill of Rights). Emphasizes respecting and protecting basic rights such as privacy, free speech, and due process.
3. Focus on justice: Requires individuals to impose and enforce rules fairly and impartially. There is an equitable distribution of benefits and costs.
Advantages and liabilities:
- Utilitarianism: Promotes efficiency and productivity, but can result in ignoring rights of some individuals, particularly minority representatives.
- Rights: Protects individuals from injury and is consistent with freedom and privacy, but can create an overly legalistic work environment that hinders productivity and efficiency.
- Justice: Protects interests of the underrepresented and less powerful, but can encourage a sense of entitlement that reduces risk taking, innovation, and productivity.
Decision makers tend to feel safe and comfortable using utilitarianism, but many critics argue this perspective needs to change. Increased concern about individual rights and social justice suggests the need for managers to develop ethical standards based solely on non-utilitarian criteria.
Two Important Decision-Making Phases
A. Problem Identification: Problems that are visible tend to have a higher probability of being selected than ones that are important. Visible problems are more likely to catch a decision maker's attention. Additionally, if a decision maker faces a conflict between selecting a problem important to the organization and one important to the decision maker, self-interest tends to win out.
B. Alternative Development: Since decision makers seek a satisfying solution, there is minimal use of creativity in the search for alternatives. Efforts tend to be confined to the neighborhood of the current alternative. Evidence indicates decision-making is incremental rather than comprehensive. Decision makers make successive limited comparisons, taking small steps toward their objective.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that perception fundamentally shapes every stage of decision making β from recognizing a problem exists to developing and evaluating alternatives. The rational decision-making model provides an ideal framework with six steps (define problem, identify criteria, weight criteria, develop alternatives, evaluate alternatives, select best alternative) but is rarely fully achievable due to human cognitive limits. Most real-world decisions are characterized by bounded rationality where people satisfice (choose "good enough" solutions) rather than optimize, and by intuitive decision-making that draws on distilled experience especially under uncertainty. Decision-making styles vary along dimensions of thinking (logical vs. intuitive) and tolerance for ambiguity, producing four styles (directive, analytic, conceptual, behavioral). Ethical decisions must balance utilitarian, rights, and justice criteria, and decision makers face organizational constraints including performance evaluation, reward systems, programmed routines, time pressures, and historical precedents.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six steps of the rational decision-making model, and why is this model considered unrealistic for most organizational decisions?
- Define bounded rationality and explain how satisficing works in the decision-making process.
- Under what eight conditions are people most likely to use intuitive decision-making?
- Describe the four decision-making styles (directive, analytic, conceptual, behavioral) and the two dimensions that define them.
- What are the three ethical criteria for decision making, and what are the advantages and liabilities of each?