๐ Lecture 26 โ Conflict and Negotiation
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the complex nature of conflict in organizations, challenging the assumption that all conflict is harmful. It examines how conflict can be either constructive or destructive, presents a five-stage conflict process model, and provides practical guidelines for managing conflict at individual, group, and organizational levels to achieve optimal performance outcomes.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and types of conflict (task, relationship, process), the nature of organizational conflict including functional vs. dysfunctional conflict, various forms of conflict in organizations (interorganizational, intergroup, interpersonal, intrapersonal, interrole, intrarole, person-role), the five-stage conflict process model with antecedents (communication, structure, personal variables), cognition, intentions, behavior, and outcomes, transitions in conflict thought (traditional, human relations, interactionist), causes of conflict (vertical, horizontal, line-staff), and conflict management techniques at individual, group, and organizational levels including negotiation and the three outcomes of conflict resolution (lose-lose, win-lose, win-win).
๐ Lecture Summary
Overview
Many people automatically assume conflict is related to lower group and organizational performance, but this assumption is frequently incorrect. Conflict can be either constructive or destructive to the functioning of a group or unit. Levels of conflict can be either too high or too low, and either extreme hinders performance. An optimal level of conflict prevents stagnation, stimulates creativity, allows tensions to be released, and initiates seeds for change, yet is not so much as to be disruptive or deter coordination of activities.
Inadequate or excessive levels of conflict can hinder effectiveness, resulting in reduced satisfaction, increased absence and turnover rates, and lower productivity. When conflict is at an optimal level, complacency and apathy should be minimized, motivation enhanced through a challenging environment, and there should be enough turnover to rid the organization of misfits and poor performers.
๐ Definition โ Conflict: The process in which one party perceives that its interests are being opposed or negatively affected by another party. "A process which begins when one party perceives that the other is frustrated, or is about to frustrate, some concern of his (or her)."
Key characteristics:
- Perceived by the parties
- Parties are in opposition to one another
- At least one party is blocking the goal attainment of the other party
- Goals can be tangible or psychological (money, task achievement, happiness)
Types of Conflict
Three distinct types of conflict exist in organizations:
- Task conflict: Conflict over content and goals of the work
- Relationship conflict: Conflict based on interpersonal relationships
- Process conflict: Conflict over how work gets done
Nature of Organizational Conflict
Conflict is defined as any situation in which incompatible goals, attitudes, emotions, or behaviors lead to disagreement or opposition between two or more parties.
๐ Definition โ Functional Conflict: A healthy, constructive disagreement between two or more people that supports the goals of the group and improves its performance.
๐ Definition โ Dysfunctional Conflict: An unhealthy, destructive disagreement between two or more people that hinders group performance.
Forms of Conflict in Organizations
Conflict manifests at multiple levels within and between organizations:
- Interorganizational Conflict: Conflict that occurs between two or more organizations
- Intergroup Conflict: Conflict that occurs between groups or teams in an organization
- Interpersonal Conflict: Conflict that occurs between two or more individuals
- Intrapersonal Conflict: Conflict that occurs within an individual
- Interrole Conflict: A person's experience of conflict among the multiple roles in his/her life
- Intrarole Conflict: Conflict that occurs within a single role, such as when a person receives conflicting messages from role senders about how to perform a certain role
- Person-role Conflict: Conflict that occurs when an individual is expected to perform behaviors in a certain role that conflict with his/her personal values
The Conflict Process (Five Stages)
Stage I: Potential Opposition or Incompatibility
Three general categories create conditions for conflict to arise:
-
Communication: Represents opposing forces arising from semantic difficulties, misunderstandings, and "noise" in communication channels. Semantic difficulties result from differences in training, selective perception, and inadequate information. The potential for conflict increases when either too little or too much communication takes place. The channel chosen for communicating can influence stimulating opposition.
-
Structure: Includes variables such as size, degree of specialization, jurisdictional clarity, member-goal compatibility, leadership styles, reward systems, and degree of dependence. The larger the group and more specialized its activities, the greater the likelihood of conflict. Greater ambiguity in responsibility increases conflict potential. Diversity of goals among groups is a major source of conflict. A close style of leadership and too much reliance on participation may stimulate conflict. Reward systems create conflict when one member's gain is at another's expense.
-
Personal Variables: Include individual value systems and personality characteristics. Certain personality types lead to potential conflict. Most important is differing value systems, which are the best explanation for differences of opinion on various matters.
Stage II: Cognition and Personalization
Antecedent conditions lead to conflict only when the parties are affected by and aware of it. Conflict is personalized when it is felt and when individuals become emotionally involved. This stage is where conflict issues tend to be defined, and this definition delineates the possible settlements. Emotions play a major role in shaping perceptions. Negative emotions produce oversimplification of issues, reductions in trust, and negative interpretations of the other party's behavior. Positive feelings increase the tendency to see potential relationships among elements of a problem, take a broader view, and develop more innovative solutions.
Stage III: Intentions
Intentions are decisions to act in a given way. Why are intentions separated out as a distinct stage? Merely one party attributing the wrong intentions to the other escalates a lot of conflicts. Two key dimensions underlie conflict-handling intentions:
- Cooperativeness: "The degree to which one party attempts to satisfy the other party's concerns."
- Assertiveness: "The degree to which one party attempts to satisfy his or her own concerns."
Five conflict-handling intentions:
๐ Definition โ Competing: When one person seeks to satisfy his or her own interests, regardless of the impact on the other parties to the conflict. Use when quick, decisive action is vital (emergencies), on important issues where unpopular actions need implementing, on issues vital to the organization's welfare when you know you are right, and against people who take advantage of noncompetitive behavior.
๐ Definition โ Collaborating: When the parties to conflict each desire to fully satisfy the concerns of all parties. The intention is to solve the problem by clarifying differences rather than by accommodating. Use to find an integrative solution when both sets of concerns are too important to be compromised, when your objective is to learn, to merge insights from people with different perspectives, to gain commitment by incorporating concerns into a consensus, and to work through feelings that have interfered with a relationship.
๐ Definition โ Avoiding: A person may recognize that a conflict exists and want to withdraw from it or suppress it. Use when an issue is trivial or more important issues are pressing, when you perceive no chance of satisfying your concerns, when potential disruption outweighs benefits of resolution, to let people cool down, when gathering information supersedes immediate decision, when others can resolve the conflict more effectively, and when issues seem tangential or symptomatic of other issues.
๐ Definition โ Accommodating: When one party seeks to appease an opponent, that party is willing to be self-sacrificing. Use when you find you are wrong and to allow a better position to be heard, to learn and show reasonableness, when issues are more important to others than yourself, to build social credits for later issues, to minimize loss when outmatched, when harmony and stability are especially important, and to allow employees to develop by learning from mistakes.
๐ Definition โ Compromising: When each party to the conflict seeks to give up something, sharing occurs, resulting in a compromised outcome. There is no clear winner or loser, and the solution provides incomplete satisfaction of both parties' concerns. Use when goals are important but not worth the effort of potential disruption, when opponents with equal power are committed to mutually exclusive goals, to achieve temporary settlements to complex issues, to arrive at expedient solutions under time pressure, and as a backup when collaboration or competition is unsuccessful.
Intentions provide general guidelines for parties, but they are not fixed. They might change because of re-conceptualization or emotional reaction. However, individuals have preferences among the five conflict-handling intentions.
Stage IV: Behavior
Stage IV is where conflicts become visible. The behavior stage includes the statements, actions, and reactions made by the conflicting parties. These conflict behaviors are usually overt attempts to implement each party's intentions. Stage IV is a dynamic process of interaction; conflicts exist somewhere along a continuum. At the lower part of the continuum, conflicts are characterized by subtle, indirect, and highly controlled forms of tension. Conflict intensities escalate as they move upward along the continuum until they become highly destructive. Functional conflicts are typically confined to the lower range of the continuum.
Stage V: Outcomes
Outcomes may be functionalโimproving group performance, or dysfunctional in hindering it.
Functional outcomes: Conflict is constructive when it: a. Improves the quality of decisions b. Stimulates creativity and innovation c. Encourages interest and curiosity d. Provides the medium through which problems can be aired and tensions released e. Fosters an environment of self-evaluation and change
Conflict is an antidote for groupthink. Conflict challenges the status quo, furthers creation of new ideas, promotes reassessment of group goals and activities, and increases the probability that the group will respond to change. Research studies confirm the functionality of conflict. The comparison of six major decisions during four different US presidents' administrations found that conflict reduced the chance of groupthink. When groups analyzed decisions made by individual members, the average improvement among high-conflict groups was 73 percent greater than low-conflict groups. Increasing cultural diversity provides benefitsโethnically diverse groups produced more effective and feasible ideas and higher quality, unique ideas. Studies of systems analysts found that more incompatible groups were likely to be more productive. Research and development scientists have been found to be most productive where there is a certain amount of intellectual conflict.
Transitions in Conflict Thought
Four perspectives on conflict have evolved:
-
Traditional view: Conflict must be avoidedโit indicates malfunctioning with the group. This view was consistent with attitudes about group behavior in the 1930s and 1940s. Conflict was seen as a dysfunctional outcome resulting from poor communication, lack of openness and trust, and failure of managers to be responsive to employees.
-
Human relations view: Conflict is a natural and inevitable outcome in any group and need not be evil, but has the potential to be a positive force in determining group performance.
-
Interactionist approach: Conflict can be a positive force in a group but explicitly argues that some conflict is absolutely necessary for a group to perform effectively.
Functional vs. Dysfunctional Conflict
Not all conflicts are good. What differentiates functional from dysfunctional conflict depends on the type of conflict:
-
Task conflict (content and goals of work): Low-to-moderate levels are functional and consistently demonstrate a positive effect on group performance because it stimulates discussion.
-
Relationship conflict (interpersonal relationships): These conflicts are almost always dysfunctional. The friction and interpersonal hostilities increase personality clashes and decrease mutual understanding.
-
Process conflict (how work gets done): Low levels are functional and could enhance team performance. For process conflict to be productive, it must be kept low. Intense arguments create uncertainty.
Causes of Conflict
Three types of structural conflict:
- Vertical conflict: Occurs between hierarchical levels
- Horizontal conflict: Occurs between persons or groups at the same hierarchical level
- Line-staff conflict: Involves disagreements over who has authority and control over specific matters
Conflict Management Approaches
Pondy's model suggests several methods to resolve conflicts. In collaboration, each side works toward a solution to satisfy its own goals plus the goals of the other sideโboth parties are better off after conflict resolution. In compromise, both parties negotiate to reach a mutually acceptable solution, but not necessarily one that achieves their goals.
Individual-Level Conflict Management: Education and training helps resolve conflict. Sensitivity training or diversity awareness programs help employees appreciate different attitudes. Job rotation and temporary assignments help people see another perspective. Promotions, transfers, and firings remove individuals from conflict situations.
Group-Level Conflict Management: Physically separating groups or changing task relationships means they no longer interact. Contact between groups occurs through people with integrating roles. Managers develop rules, procedures, and common goals to coordinate group activities. These methods temporarily resolve conflict because underlying causes are not addressed.
Negotiation: A process in which groups with conflicting interests meet to make offers, counteroffers, and concessions to resolve differences. Negotiations may include a third-party negotiatorโan outsider skilled in handling bargaining and negotiation. The third party acts as a mediator, taking a neutral stance and helping parties reconcile differences. If no solution is reached, the third party acts as an arbiter, or judge, imposing a solution.
Two processes occur in any negotiation situation:
- Distributive bargaining: Parties decide how resources are distributed
- Attitudinal structuring: Parties try to influence their opponent's attitudes
Organizational-Level Conflict Management: Conflict can be managed by changing the organization's structure and culture to lessen conflict. Managers can clarify task and reporting relationships, change differentiation, increase integration, or use culture to create shared values and norms. These methods eliminate some conflict and increase communication.
The Issue of "Who Wins?"
Three possible outcomes of conflict:
๐ Definition โ Lose-lose conflict: Occurs when nobody gets what he or she wants. Avoidance, accommodation or smoothing, and compromise are forms of lose-lose conflict.
๐ Definition โ Win-lose conflict: One party achieves its desires at the expense and to the exclusion of the other party's desires. Competition and authoritative command are forms of win-lose conflict.
๐ Definition โ Win-win conflict: Both parties achieve their desires. Collaboration or problem solving are forms of win-win conflict.
โญ Key Takeaways
Conflict is not inherently bad; it can be functional or dysfunctional depending on its type, level, and management. The optimal level of conflict prevents stagnation and stimulates creativity while avoiding disruption. Task and process conflicts can be productive at low-to-moderate levels, but relationship conflict is almost always dysfunctional. The five-stage conflict process (potential opposition, cognition, intentions, behavior, outcomes) provides a framework for understanding how conflict develops and escalates. Managers must select appropriate conflict-handling intentions (competing, collaborating, avoiding, accommodating, compromising) based on the specific situation. Effective conflict management occurs at individual, group, and organizational levels, with win-win outcomes achieved through collaboration being the most desirable but not always feasible.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of conflict in organizations, and which ones can be functional versus dysfunctional?
- What are the five conflict-handling intentions, and in what situations should each be used?
- Describe the five stages of the conflict process and explain how conflict escalates through these stages.
- What is the difference between the traditional, human relations, and interactionist views of conflict?
- What are the three possible outcomes of conflict resolution (lose-lose, win-lose, win-win), and which conflict-handling intentions lead to each outcome?
๐ Lecture 27 โ Conflict and Negotiation
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the dual nature of conflict in organizationsโhow it can be either constructive or destructive depending on its levelโand provides a comprehensive framework for understanding, managing, and resolving conflict. It then introduces negotiation as a primary tool for conflict resolution, covering different approaches, processes, styles, and cultural considerations that managers need to navigate effectively.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by examining the optimal level of conflict for organizational performance, then defines conflict and its types (task, relationship, process conflict). It identifies sources of conflict and five conflict management styles (avoiding, accommodating, competing, compromising, collaborating). The lecture then introduces negotiation as a joint process for resolving complex conflicts, distinguishes between distributive and integrative bargaining approaches, outlines the five-step negotiation process, and concludes with third-party negotiations and important issues including personality traits, gender differences, and cultural differences in negotiations.
๐ Lecture Summary
Overview
Many people assume conflict always lowers group and organizational performance, but this is frequently incorrect. Conflict can be either constructive or destructive. As shown in Exhibit 14-8, levels of conflict can be too high or too low, and either extreme hinders performance. An optimal level is where there is enough conflict to prevent stagnation, stimulate creativity, allow tensions to be released, and initiate seeds for change, yet not so much as to be disruptive or deter coordination of activities.
Inadequate or excessive conflict can hinder effectiveness, resulting in reduced satisfaction, increased absence and turnover rates, and lower productivity. When conflict is at an optimal level, complacency and apathy are minimized, motivation is enhanced through a challenging environment, and there is enough turnover to rid the organization of misfits and poor performers.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding that conflict is not inherently bad allows managers to diagnose whether their team has too little, too much, or just the right amount of conflict for peak performance.
For managers facing excessive conflict, no single conflict-handling intention is always best. Guidelines include:
- Use competition when quick, decisive action is vital; on important issues requiring unpopular actions; on issues vital to organizational welfare when you know you are right; and against people who take advantage of noncompetitive behavior.
- Use collaboration to find an integrative solution when both sets of concerns are too important to be compromised; when your objective is to learn; to merge insights from different perspectives; to gain commitment through consensus; and to work through feelings that have interfered with a relationship.
- Use avoidance when an issue is trivial or more important issues are pressing; when you perceive no chance of satisfying your concerns; when potential disruption outweighs benefits; to let people cool down; when gathering information supersedes immediate decision; when others can resolve the conflict more effectively; and when issues seem tangential.
- Use accommodation when you find you are wrong and to allow a better position to be heard; when issues are more important to others; to build social credits for later issues; to minimize loss when outmatched; when harmony and stability are important; and to allow employees to learn from mistakes.
- Use compromise when goals are important but not worth potential disruption; when opponents with equal power have mutually exclusive goals; to achieve temporary settlements; to arrive at expedient solutions under time pressure; and as a backup when collaboration or competition is unsuccessful.
Definition - Conflict
๐ Definition โ Conflict: "a process which begins when one party perceives that the other is frustrated, or is about to frustrate, some concern of his (or her)."
Key characteristics:
- Perceived by the parties
- Parties are in opposition to one another
- At least one party is blocking the goal attainment of the other party
- Goals can be tangible or psychological (money, task achievement, happiness)
Types of Conflict
- Task conflict: Conflict over content and goals of the work
- Relationship conflict: Conflict based on interpersonal relationships
- Process conflict: Conflict over how work gets done
Sources of Conflict
Sources include organizational hierarchy, competition for scarce resources, self-image and stereotypical views of others, differing goals and objectives, failures and resultant blame fixing, and poor coordination of activities.
Conflict Management Styles
Five conflict management styles exist along two dimensions: assertiveness and cooperativeness.
- Avoiding: deliberate decision to take no action on a conflict or to stay out of a conflict
- Accommodating: concern that the other party's goals be met but relatively unconcerned with getting own way
- Competing: satisfying own interests; willing to do so at other party's expense
- Compromising: each party gives up something to reach a solution
- Collaborating: arriving at a solution agreeable to all through open and thorough discussion
What is Negotiation?
๐ Definition โ Negotiation: a "process in which two or more parties exchange goods or services and attempt to agree upon the exchange rate for them." The terms negotiation and bargaining are used interchangeably.
Negotiation permeates the interactions of almost everyone in groups and organizations:
- Labor bargains with management
- Managers negotiate with employees, peers, and bosses
- Salespeople negotiate with customers
- Purchasing agents negotiate with suppliers
- A worker agrees to answer a colleague's phone in exchange for a benefit
Negotiation is a joint process of finding a mutually acceptable solution to a complex conflict. It is useful under these conditions:
- Two or more parties
- Conflict of interest between the parties
- Parties are willing to negotiate
- Parties prefer to work together rather than fight openly, give in, break off contact, or take the dispute to a higher authority
Approaches to Negotiation
There are two general approaches to negotiation: distributive bargaining and integrative bargaining.
Distributive bargaining operates under zero-sum conditionsโany gain one party makes is at the other's expense. The most widely cited example is labor-management negotiations over wages.
In distributive bargaining:
- Each party has a target point that defines what they would like to achieve
- Each also has a resistance point, which marks the lowest acceptable outcome
- The area between these points makes up each one's aspiration range
- As long as there is overlap between the two aspiration ranges, there exists a settlement range where each one's aspirations can be met
- Tactics focus on getting the opponent to agree to one's specific target point or as close as possible
๐ Example: Buying a carโthe owner states an asking price, you do not want to pay that much, and you negotiate over the price. Any gain you make (lower price) is at the seller's expense (less profit).
Integrative bargaining operates under the assumption that there exists one or more settlements that can create a win-win solution. It is preferable to distributive bargaining because it builds long-term relationships, facilitates working together in the future, bonds negotiators, and allows each party to feel victorious. Distributive bargaining leaves one party a loser, builds animosities, and deepens divisions.
๐ Example: A sales rep calls in an order but is told the firm cannot approve credit due to a past slow-pay record. The sales rep and credit manager meet to discuss the problemโthey want to make the sale but avoid uncollectable debt. After open discussion, they agree the sale will go through with a bank guarantee ensuring payment if not made in 60 days.
Conditions necessary for integrative bargaining to succeed:
- Parties who are open with information and candid about their concerns
- A sensitivity by both parties to the other's needs
- The ability to trust one another
- A willingness by both parties to maintain flexibility
The Process of Negotiation
The negotiation process consists of five steps:
1. Preparation and planning: Do your homework. What is the nature of the conflict? What is the history? Who is involved? What are their perceptions? What do you want? What are your goals? Prepare an assessment of what you think the other party's goals are. When you can anticipate your opponent's position, you are better equipped to counter their arguments. Once you gather information, develop a strategy. Determine your and the other side's Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA). Your BATNA determines the lowest value acceptable to you for a negotiated agreementโany offer higher than your BATNA is better than an impasse.
2. Definition of ground rules: Who will do the negotiating? Where will it take place? What time constraints apply? To what issues will negotiation be limited? Will there be a specific procedure if an impasse is reached? During this phase, parties exchange their initial proposals or demands.
3. Clarification and justification: When initial positions have been exchanged, explain, amplify, clarify, bolster, and justify your original demands. This need not be confrontational. You might provide the other party with documentation that supports your position.
4. Bargaining and problem solving: The essence of the negotiation processโthe actual give and take in trying to hash out an agreement. Concessions will undoubtedly need to be made by both parties.
5. Closure and implementation: Formalizing the agreement that has been worked out and developing any procedures necessary for implementation and monitoring. Major negotiations require hammering out specifics in a formal contract. For most cases, closure is nothing more formal than a handshake.
Mapping the Negotiation involves: describing the problem, identifying the people involved, using empathy to analyze the situation, and recording participants' needs and fears about the problem.
Conducting the Negotiation involves: using an appropriate negotiation style, suitable language, effective responding and listening techniques, identifying needs and wants, setting up the negotiation, creating the non-verbal environment, starting the negotiation, dealing with conflict during the negotiation, and achieving a negotiated outcome.
Third-party Negotiations
When individuals or group representatives reach a stalemate and are unable to resolve differences through direct negotiations, they may turn to a third party.
A mediator is a neutral third party who facilitates a negotiated solution by using reasoning and persuasion, suggesting alternatives, and the like. Mediators are widely used in labor-management negotiations and civil court disputes. Their settlement rate is approximately 60 percent, with negotiator satisfaction at about 75 percent.
๐ Key to success: The conflicting parties must be motivated to bargain and resolve their conflict, intensity cannot be too high, and the mediator must be perceived as neutral and non-coercive.
Issues in Negotiation
The role of personality traits in negotiation: Personality traits have no significant direct effect on either the bargaining process or negotiation outcomes. Overall assessments find personality is not a reliable predictor of negotiating tactics.
Gender differences in negotiations: Men and women do not negotiate differently. The stereotype that women are more cooperative, pleasant, and relationship-oriented is not supported by evidence. Comparisons between experienced male and female managers find women are neither worse nor better negotiators, neither more cooperative nor open, and neither more nor less persuasive or threatening. The belief that women are "nicer" is probably due to confusing gender with the lack of power typically held by womenโlow-power managers, regardless of gender, attempt to placate opponents and use softly persuasive tactics. However, women's attitudes toward negotiation differ: managerial women demonstrate less confidence in anticipation of negotiating and are less satisfied with their performance despite achieving similar outcomes as men. Women may unduly penalize themselves by failing to engage in negotiations when such action would be in their best interests.
Cultural differences in negotiations: Negotiating styles vary across national cultures. Key examples include:
- The French: Like conflict, gain recognition by thinking and acting against others, take a long time in negotiations, and are not overly concerned about whether opponents like them.
- The Chinese: Draw out negotiations because they believe negotiations never end. Just when you think you have reached a final solution, the Chinese executive might smile and start over. Like the Japanese, they negotiate to develop a relationship and commitment to work together.
- Americans: Known for their impatience and desire to be likedโastute negotiators often turn these characteristics to their advantage.
A study comparing North Americans, Arabs, and Russians found:
- North Americans persuade by relying on facts and appealing to logic, make small concessions early to establish relationships, reciprocate concessions, and treat deadlines as very important.
- Arabs persuade by appealing to emotion, counter arguments with subjective feelings, make concessions throughout the process, almost always reciprocate, and approach deadlines very casually.
- Russians base arguments on asserted ideals, make few if any concessions, view any opponent concession as weakness and almost never reciprocate, and tend to ignore deadlines.
A second study of verbal and nonverbal negotiation tactics found:
- Brazilians said "No" 83 times on average compared to 5 times for Japanese and 9 times for North Americans
- Japanese displayed more than 5 periods of silence lasting longer than 10 seconds (North Americans: 3.5; Brazilians: none)
- Brazilians interrupted opponents 2.5 to 3 times more often than Japanese and North Americans
- Brazilians touched each other almost 5 times every half-hour during negotiations, while Japanese and North Americans had no physical contact except handshaking
๐ก Why this matters: Cultural awareness in negotiations prevents misunderstandings and allows negotiators to adapt their approach for more effective outcomes, especially in cross-border business dealings.
โญ Key Takeaways
Conflict is not inherently destructiveโit becomes problematic only at excessive or inadequate levels, while an optimal level stimulates creativity, prevents stagnation, and improves performance. Managers must diagnose their team's conflict level and select the appropriate conflict-handling style (competition, collaboration, avoidance, accommodation, or compromise) based on the specific situation. Negotiation is the primary tool for resolving conflicts, with distributive bargaining operating under zero-sum conditions and integrative bargaining seeking win-win solutions; integrative bargaining is preferable as it builds long-term relationships. The five-step negotiation process (preparation, ground rules, clarification, bargaining, closure) should always begin with determining your BATNAโthe minimum acceptable agreement. Finally, personality traits and gender do not significantly predict negotiation outcomes, but cultural differences in communication styles, use of silence, physical contact, and attitudes toward deadlines and relationships are critical factors that managers must understand and adapt to.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of conflict, and how do they differ from one another?
- Explain the difference between distributive bargaining and integrative bargaining, including the conditions necessary for integrative bargaining to succeed.
- List and briefly describe the five steps in the negotiation process.
- What is a BATNA, and why is it important to determine it before entering negotiations?
- How do cultural differences affect negotiation styles, and what specific behaviors distinguish North American, Arab, French, Chinese, Japanese, Brazilian, and Russian negotiators?
๐ Lecture 28 โ REVIEW OF PART-II
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive review of Part-II of Organizational Behavior, covering key concepts related to groups and teams, communication, leadership, power and politics, and conflict and negotiation. It serves as a consolidated reference of definitions and core principles essential for understanding how people interact and behave within organizational settings.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture systematically reviews key terms from five major areas: Groups and Teams (including group dynamics, cohesiveness, roles, norms, and types of teams); Communication (perceptual model, styles, channels, and technology); Leadership (trait, behavioral, situational, transactional, and transformational theories); Power and Politics (social power bases, empowerment, and organizational politics); and Conflict and Negotiation (functional vs. dysfunctional conflict, programmed conflict techniques, and negotiation processes).
๐ Lecture Summary
Group
A group is defined as "Two or more freely interacting people with shared norms and goals and a common identity." Groups can be formal, formed by the organization, or informal, formed by friends or those with common interests. Group Cohesiveness is a "we feeling" binding group members together. Roles are expected behaviors for a given position, which can lead to role overload (others' expectations exceed one's ability), role conflict (others have conflicting or inconsistent expectations), or role ambiguity (others' expectations are unknown). Norms are shared attitudes, opinions, feelings, or actions that guide social behavior. Task roles are task-oriented group behavior, while maintenance roles are relationship-building group behavior. Groupthink is Janis's term for a cohesive in-group's unwillingness to realistically view alternatives. Social loafing is a decrease in individual effort as group size increases.
Team
A team is a "Small group with complementary skills who hold themselves mutually accountable for common purpose, goals, and approach." Team viability refers to team members being satisfied and willing to contribute. Trust is reciprocal faith in others' intentions and behavior. Propensity to trust is a personality trait involving one's general willingness to trust others. Cohesiveness (a sense of "wane") helps the group stick together. It can be socio-emotional cohesiveness (sense of togetherness based on emotional satisfaction) or instrumental cohesiveness (sense of togetherness based on mutual dependency needed to get the job done). Various team types include quality circles (small groups of volunteers who strive to solve quality-related problems), virtual teams (information technology allows group members in different locations to conduct business), self-managed teams (groups of employees granted administrative oversight for their work), and cross-functionalism (teams made up of technical specialists from different areas). Team building is experiential learning aimed at better internal functioning of groups. Self-management leadership is the process of leading others to lead themselves.
๐ Definition โ Self-managed teams: Groups of employees granted administrative oversight for their work.
Communication
Communication is the "Interpersonal exchange of information and understanding." The perceptual model of communication is a process in which receivers create their own meaning. Noise is interference with the transmission and understanding of a message. Communication competence is the ability to effectively use communication behaviors in a given context. Communication styles include assertive style (expressive and self-enhancing, but does not take advantage of others), aggressive style (expressive and self-enhancing, but takes unfair advantage of others), and nonassertive style (timid and self-denying behavior). Nonverbal communication involves messages sent outside of the written or spoken word. Listening is actively decoding and interpreting verbal messages. Linguistic style is a person's typical speaking pattern. Gender-flex is temporarily using communication behaviors typical of the other gender. Formal communication channels follow the chain of command or organizational structure, while informal communication channels do not. Key informal channel roles include liaison individuals (those who consistently pass along grapevine information to others) and organizational moles (those who use the grapevine to enhance their power and status). Information richness is the information-carrying capacity of data. Purposeful communication distortion is purposely modifying the content of a message. Technology-based channels include the Internet (a global network of computer networks), Intranet (an organization's private Internet), Extranet (connects internal employees with selected customers, suppliers, and strategic partners), Electronic mail (uses the Internet/intranet to send computer-generated text and documents), Group support systems (using computer software and hardware to help people work better together), and Telecommuting (doing work that is generally performed in the office away from the office using different information technologies).
Leadership
Leadership is the "Process whereby an individual influences others to achieve a common goal." Leader trait refers to personal characteristics that differentiate leaders from followers. Behavioral dimensions include consideration (creating mutual respect and trust with followers) and initiating structure (organizing and defining what group members should be doing). Situational theories propose that leader styles should match the situation at hand. Key contingency factors include leader-member relations (extent that leader has the support, loyalty, and trust of work group), task structure (amount of structure contained within work tasks), and position power (degree to which leader has formal power). Contingency factors are variables that influence the appropriateness of a leadership style. Transactional leadership focuses on clarifying employees' roles and providing rewards contingent on performance, while transformational leadership transforms employees to pursue organizational goals over self-interests. Shared leadership is a simultaneous, ongoing, mutual influence process in which people share responsibility for leading.
๐ Definition โ Transformational leadership: Transforms employees to pursue organizational goals over self-interests.
Social Power
Social power is the "Ability to get things done with human, informational, and material resources." It can be socialized power (directed at helping others) or personalized power (directed at helping oneself). There are five bases of power: Reward power (obtaining compliance with promised or actual rewards), Coercive power (obtaining compliance through threatened or actual punishment), Legitimate power (obtaining compliance through formal authority), Expert power (obtaining compliance through one's knowledge or information), and Referent power (obtaining compliance through charisma or personal attraction). Empowerment is sharing varying degrees of power with lower-level employees to tap their full potential. Related concepts include participative management (involving employees in various forms of decision making), delegation (granting decision-making authority to people at lower levels), and personal initiative (going beyond formal job requirements and being an active self-starter). Organizational politics is the intentional enhancement of self-interest. A coalition is a temporary grouping of people who actively pursue a single issue. Impression management is getting others to see us in a certain manner.
Conflict
Conflict occurs when "One party perceives its interests are being opposed or set back by another party." It can be functional conflict (serves organization's interests) or dysfunctional conflict (threatens organization's interests). Personality conflict is interpersonal opposition driven by personal dislike or disagreement. Programmed conflict encourages different opinions without protecting management's personal feelings and includes two techniques: Devil's advocacy (assigning someone the role of critic) and the Dialectic method (fostering a debate of opposing viewpoints to better understand an issue). Conflict triangle occurs when conflicting parties involve a third person rather than dealing directly with each other. Negotiation is a give-and-take process between conflicting interdependent parties.
โญ Key Takeaways
This review lecture consolidates the essential vocabulary and conceptual frameworks of organizational behavior from Part-II. Students must distinguish between groups (which may not have a common purpose) and teams (which are mutually accountable for a common purpose), and understand the dynamics of cohesiveness, roles, and norms. The communication section emphasizes that meaning is created by the receiver (perceptual model) and that noise, styles, and channels all affect understanding. Leadership is not a one-size-fits-all concept; effectiveness depends on matching style to the situation (contingency factors), and the distinction between transactional and transformational leadership is critical. Finally, power can be used for self or others, and conflict can be functional or dysfunctional, with programmed conflict techniques designed to generate constructive debate.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between a group and a team regarding accountability and purpose?
- Explain the difference between role overload, role conflict, and role ambiguity.
- In the perceptual model of communication, what role does the receiver play in creating meaning?
- Compare and contrast transactional leadership with transformational leadership.
- What are the five bases of social power, and how does referent power differ from legitimate power?