π Lecture 5 β Individual vs Group Behavior
π Overview: This lecture examines the fundamental concepts of individual, group, and team behavior in organizational settings. It explores how understanding individual differences, group dynamics, and team processes enables managers to predict and shape employee behavior toward organizational goals. The lecture emphasizes practical strategies for managing individuals, building effective groups, and transforming them into high-performing teams.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers three main areas: first, individual behavior focusing on biographical characteristics, ability-job fit, and learning principles; second, group behavior including types of groups, reasons for joining groups, group roles, and characteristics of effective groups; and third, teams including types of teams (self-managed, cross-departmental, quality circles, virtual, and process teams), team building, and strategies for turning individuals into team players through selection, training, and rewards.
π Lecture Summary
A. Individual
Why to Focus on Individuals: Individuals are the fundamental units of any organization. Understanding individual behavior allows managers to predict outcomes and manage behaviors in desirable directions. Three critical individual variables are biographical characteristics, ability, and learning.
Biographical characteristics are readily available from employee files. Key findings show that age has no relationship to productivity; older workers and those with longer tenure are less likely to resign; and married employees have fewer absences, less turnover, and higher job satisfaction than unmarried employees. This information helps managers make choices among job applicants.
Ability directly influences an employee's performance and satisfaction through the ability-job fit. Managers can improve this fit through several methods: (1) an effective selection process using job analysis to test and evaluate applicants; (2) ensuring promotion and transfer decisions reflect candidates' abilities; (3) fine-tuning jobs to better match incumbent abilities, such as changing equipment or reorganizing tasks; and (4) providing training to keep abilities current or develop new skills.
Learning is evidenced by any observable change in behavior. Positive reinforcement is a powerful tool for modifying behaviorβby identifying and rewarding performance-enhancing behaviors, management increases their likelihood of repetition. Research shows reinforcement is more effective than punishment. Although punishment eliminates undesired behavior more quickly than negative reinforcement, punished behavior tends to be only temporarily suppressed rather than permanently changed. Punishment may produce unpleasant side effects such as lower morale, higher absenteeism, turnover, and resentment toward the punisher. Managers should use reinforcement rather than punishment. Additionally, managers should expect employees to look to them as modelsβmanagers who are late, take long lunches, or use company supplies for personal use should expect employees to model their behavior accordingly.
π Definition β Biographical Characteristics: Personal data contained in an employee's file, including age, tenure, and marital status. π Example: A manager reviewing applicant files finds that married candidates typically have lower turnover rates. This information helps in making hiring decisions, though it should not be the sole determinant.
π Definition β Ability-Job Fit: The degree to which an employee's abilities match the requirements of their job position. π Formula: Ability-Job Fit = Employee Abilities β Job Requirements β Performance & Satisfaction π Example: A factory worker with strong mechanical skills but weak computer skills is assigned to equipment maintenance rather than data entry. The job is fine-tuned by providing updated tools that match their mechanical strengths.
π Definition β Positive Reinforcement: A behavioral tool where rewarding desired behaviors increases the likelihood they will be repeated. π Example: A sales manager praises and rewards an employee who submits reports on time consistently. The employee continues this behavior because it leads to positive recognition.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding individual differences helps managers predict employee responses, reduce turnover, and increase productivity by matching people to appropriate roles and using reinforcement rather than punishment.
B. Group
A group is defined as two or more interacting and interdependent individuals who come together to achieve particular objectives.
Types of Groups: a. Formal groups are work groups established by the organization with designated work assignments and established tasks directed toward organizational goals. b. Informal groups are natural social formations that tend to form around friendships and common interests.
Why Do People Join Groups? There are six primary reasons:
- Security β Strength in numbers; the group helps individuals feel stronger, have fewer self-doubts, and be more resistant to threats.
- Status β Prestige from belonging to a particular group; inclusion in an important group provides recognition and status.
- Self-esteem β Membership can raise feelings of self-worth through acceptance into a highly valued group.
- Affiliation β Groups fulfill social needs; work groups significantly contribute to friendships and social relations.
- Power β What cannot be achieved individually becomes possible through group action; power may protect members from unreasonable demands; informal groups provide opportunities to exercise power.
- Goal achievement β Some tasks require pooling talents, knowledge, or power to get a job completed.
Group Roles: A role refers to a set of expected behavior patterns attributed to someone who occupies a given position in a social unit. Individuals play multiple roles and attempt to determine what behaviors are expected of them. An individual confronted by divergent role expectations experiences role conflict.
Three types of group roles:
- Task-oriented roles: Include initiator-contributors and information seekers/providers who focus on getting work done.
- Relationship-oriented roles: Include encouragers and harmonizers who maintain group cohesion and positive interactions.
- Individual roles: Include blockers and jokers who may disrupt group progress.
Characteristics of a Well-Functioning, Effective Group: A group is considered effective if it has: a relaxed, comfortable, informal atmosphere; tasks well understood and accepted; members who listen well and participate; clear assignments made and accepted; group awareness of its operation and function; people expressing feelings and ideas; consensus decision making; and conflict and disagreement centered around ideas or methods rather than personalities.
π Definition β Group: Two or more interacting and interdependent individuals who come together to achieve particular objectives. π Example: A project team of five employees from different departments assigned by management to develop a new product is a formal group. The same employees who eat lunch together daily form an informal group based on friendship.
π Definition β Role: A set of expected behavior patterns attributed to someone who occupies a given position in a social unit. π Example: A team leader is expected to coordinate work, provide guidance, and represent the team to upper management. If the leader's supervisor demands high output while team members want slower, quality-focused work, the leader experiences role conflict.
C. Team
A team is a mature group with highly independent members who are completely committed to a common goal. All teams start out as groups, but not all groups become teams. The elements that distinguish teams from groups include: full commitment by members to a common goal and mission; interdependence; mutual accountability; shared leadership; trust and a collaborative culture; and achievement of synergy.
Differentiating Groups and Teams: All teams are groups, but a group is not always a team. A team is distinguished by members being committed to a common purpose, a set of performance goals, and an approach for which they hold themselves mutually accountable. A group is two or more persons interacting where each person influences and is influenced by each other person.
Types of Teams: Organizations use four types of teams, differing according to task complexity and membership fluidity:
-
Self-Managed Work Teams: A formal group of employees who operate without a manager and are responsible for a complete work process or segment delivering a product or service to a customer. They control their work pace, determination of work assignments, and fully self-managed teams even select their own members and evaluate performance. Supervisory positions decrease in importance or may be eliminated.
-
Cross-Departmental Teams: Teams that work on simpler tasks with highly fluid membership, meaning members come and go over time.
-
Problem-Solving Teams (Quality Circles): Simple work teams of eight to ten volunteers from a common work area who meet to find solutions to specific quality problems. They have a clear focus on quality improvement within a single work unit, meet regularly, and have limited power to implement ideas. They operate in parallel to the rest of the structure without requiring major organizational changes.
-
Virtual Teams: An extension of electronic meetings that allows groups to meet without concern for space or time. Team members use technology advances to solve problems even when geographically dispersed or in different time zones.
-
Process Teams: Teams without departmental affiliation that function independently to undertake broad organizational-level process improvements. Organizations implementing process teams may partially or totally disband traditional departments. Self-managed teams (SMTs) are process teams with full managerial control over their own work, functioning without outside supervision. A team leader provides internal facilitation to remove obstacles and obtain resources. Using SMTs requires a total change in organizational structure; lack of commitment is the common reason for failure.
Making Teams Effective Through Team Building: Team building involves activities aimed at improving internal work and relationship processes of teams, requiring attention to both task and interpersonal relationships. Organizations apply group dynamics principles to select complementary members, support more cohesion, manage stages of group development, and establish constructive norms that foster high performance. Membership is based on expertise necessary for task accomplishment. The shamrock team combines a core of permanent members with part-time members and outside subcontractors.
Turning Individuals into Teams: Productive teams require careful selection, training, and management. Guidelines include: seek employee input; establish urgent, demanding performance standards; select members for skill and skill potential; pay special attention to first meetings and actions; set clear rules of behavior; move from "boss" to "coach"; set immediate performance-oriented tasks and goals; challenge the group regularly with fresh facts and information; use positive feedback; shoot for the right team size; choose people who like teamwork; and train repeatedly.
Turning Individuals into Team Players:
-
Introduction: Some individuals prefer recognition for individual achievements. In some organizations, only the "strong" survive, creating resistance to teams. Teams fit well with countries that score high on collectivism.
-
Management Challenges: Employees' success in teams depends on how well the team as a whole performed. Team members must communicate openly and honestly, confront differences, resolve conflicts, and place lower priority on personal goals for the team's good. The challenge is greatest where national culture is highly individualistic and teams are introduced into established organizations that historically valued individual achievement (e.g., AT&T, Ford, Motorola). The challenge is less demanding where employees have strong collectivism values (e.g., Japan, Mexico) or in new organizations using teams as their initial work structure.
-
Team Member Roles: High-performing work teams match people to various roles. Nine potential roles include:
- Creator-innovators: Imaginative, initiate ideas/concepts, independent, prefer working at their own pace
- Explorer-promoters: Take new ideas and champion their cause, good at finding resources but lack implementation patience
- Assessor-developers: Strong analytical skills, best when evaluating several options before decisions
- Thruster-organizers: Set up operating procedures, goals, plans, organize people, establish systems to meet deadlines
- Concluder-producers: Concerned with results, insist on deadlines and commitments, take pride in producing regular output
- Controller-inspectors: High concern for establishing and enforcing rules, examine details, ensure accuracy
- Upholder-maintainers: Strong convictions about proper procedures, defend the team, provide team stability
- Reporter-advisers: Good listeners, don't press their point of view, encourage seeking additional information, discourage hasty decisions
- Linkers: Overlap other roles, understand all views, coordinators and integrators, dislike extremism, build cooperation
Most individuals can perform any role but have two or three preferred roles. Managers should select members based on appropriate mix of strengths and allocate work assignments fitting each member's preferred style.
-
Shaping Team Behavior: The three most popular ways include proper selection, employee training, and rewarding appropriate team behaviors.
-
Role of Selection: When hiring team members, ensure applicants can fulfill team roles. If team skills are woefully lacking, don't hire that candidate. Candidates with basic team skills needing refinement can be hired on probation and required to undergo training.
-
Training for Team Players: Performing well in a team involves learnable behaviors. People raised on individual accomplishment can be trained to become team players. Training specialists conduct exercises allowing employees to experience teamwork satisfaction. Workshops cover team problem solving, communications, negotiations, conflict resolution, and coaching skills. Outside consultants provide learning environments for practical team skills.
-
Role of Rewards: The reward system should encourage cooperative rather than competitive efforts. For example, Lockheed Martin's Space Launch Systems rewards teams by returning a percentage increase in the bottom line based on achievement of team performance goals. Promotions, pay raises, and recognition should be given for collaborative team effectiveness, balancing individual contribution with selfless contributions. Managers cannot forget inherent rewards from teamworkβcamaraderie, excitement, and satisfaction from being part of a successful team.
-
Reinvigorating Mature Teams: Effective teams can become stagnantβinitial enthusiasm can give way to apathy, time can diminish diverse perspectives as cohesiveness increases, and teams don't automatically stay at the "performing" stage. Mature teams are prone to groupthink and early successes may have come from easy tasks. Four suggestions for managers: (1) Prepare members to deal with team maturity problems; (2) Remind members they are not unique; (3) Offer refresher training in communication, conflict resolution, and team processes; (4) Offer advanced training in problem-solving, interpersonal, and technical skills. Encourage teams to treat development as a constant learning experience, approaching their own development as part of continuous improvement.
π Definition β Team: A mature group with highly independent members who are completely committed to a common goal. π Example: A product development team of 12 members who have worked together for 2 years, share leadership responsibilities, hold each other accountable for results, and are fully committed to launching the product by the deadlineβthis is a team, not merely a group.
π Definition β Team Building: Activities aimed at improving the internal work and relationship processes of teams, requiring attention to both task and interpersonal relationships. π Example: A department manager organizes a two-day workshop where team members participate in trust exercises, communication drills, and joint problem-solving activities to improve cooperation and reduce conflicts.
π Definition β Self-Managed Work Team: A formal group of employees who operate without a manager and are responsible for a complete work process or segment delivering a product or service to an external or internal customer. π Example: A team of eight assembly line workers who schedule their own shifts, assign tasks among themselves, order materials, and evaluate each other's performance without a supervisor.
π Definition β Quality Circle: A simple work team of eight to ten volunteers from a common work area who meet to find solutions to specific problems about the quality of work processes, products, or services. π Example: Ten volunteers from the customer service department meet weekly to identify common customer complaints and propose solutions, though they must get management approval to implement changes.
π Definition β Groupthink: A phenomenon where mature teams become prone to conformity pressure, suppressing dissenting viewpoints and critical thinking. π Example: A long-standing team consistently agrees on decisions without debate, ignoring warnings from one member about potential flaws in their plan because they want to maintain harmony.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that individuals, groups, and teams form a developmental continuumβindividuals are the basic unit, groups form when individuals interact for objectives, and teams are mature groups with full commitment to common goals where synergy is achieved. The lecture emphasizes that managers must understand biographical characteristics and ability-job fit to predict individual behavior, and should use positive reinforcement rather than punishment for behavior modification. For groups, managers must recognize why people join (security, status, self-esteem, affiliation, power, goal achievement), understand role expectations and potential role conflicts, and foster characteristics of effective groups including consensus decision making and task-focused conflict. Teams require careful selection, training, and rewards that encourage cooperation over competition, with nine distinct team member roles (creator-innovator, explorer-promoter, assessor-developer, thruster-organizer, concluder-producer, controller-inspector, upholder-maintainer, reporter-adviser, and linker) that managers must match to individual strengths. Finally, students should note that mature teams can become stagnant and require refresher training, advanced training, and a continuous improvement approach to avoid groupthink.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the differences between formal groups and informal groups, and why do people join each type?
- Explain the four methods managers can use to improve the ability-job fit for employees.
- List and describe the nine potential team member roles identified in the lecture, and explain which role serves as a coordinator and integrator.
- What distinguishes a team from a group, and what are the five types of teams organizations use?
- Why is positive reinforcement more effective than punishment in shaping employee behavior, and how can managers reinvigorate a mature team suffering from stagnation?
π Lecture 6 β Personnel Management to Human Resource Management
π Overview: This lecture traces the evolution from traditional personnel management to modern Human Resource Management (HRM). It explains the historical development of HRM departments, the conceptual shift in managing people from a cost to a strategic asset, and the key stages and goals that define this transformation. Understanding this shift is critical because it frames how organizations today leverage their workforce for competitive advantage.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining Personnel Management and its historical roots, showing that many modern HR practices have early origins. It then explores the History of Personnel Management, detailing how organizations evolved to view people management strategically, with three core goals: integration, securing commitment, and achieving flexibility. Finally, it covers the Shifting from Personnel Management to HRM, outlining five fundamental attitudinal changes and three distinct stages of transformationβRecords and Administration, Accountability Regulations, and Competitive Advantage.
π Lecture Summary
A. The Concept of Personnel Management
The terms Personnel Management and Human Resource Management (HRM) refer to the same core processes. HRM is a modern term that emerged during the 1970s and gained final acceptance in 1989. While formal HR departments didn't generally exist until the 1940s, many HR practices and programs we see today have roots in earlier times. HRM deals with the formal system for managing people within an organization, and many companies now aim to transform their workforce into a source of competitive advantage.
HR managers have many concerns regarding their workers. These concerns include how to manage layoffs, address reduced employee loyalty, create a well-trained, highly motivated workforce that can deliver higher quality and productivity, manage and increase a diverse workforce, and contain healthcare costs. HRM has been undergoing significant transformation. In the 1970s, the job of the HR manager was to keep companies out of court and in compliance with increasing regulations. In the 1980s, HR managers had to address staffing costs related to mergers, acquisitions, and downsizing. The 1990s were characterized by economic issues related to an increasingly global and competitive workplace.
π Definition β Personnel Management: The historical term for what is now known as Human Resource Management; it refers to the formal system for managing people within an organization.
π Example: While a formal "HR Department" didn't exist in the 1940s, activities like hiring, paying, and scheduling workers were still performed, showing that the function existed even if the formal department did not.
B. History of Personnel Management
A group of people becomes an organization when they cooperate to achieve common goals. Communication is vital, but people have individual motivations that often differ from corporate goals. An effective organization succeeds in getting people to accept that cooperating to achieve organizational goals also helps them achieve their own goals, provided they are adequately rewarded through extrinsic and intrinsic rewards. This is achieved primarily through leadership and motivation. Employers increasingly view HRM from a strategic perspective, as a means to narrow the chasm between organizational and individual goals. HRM has three basic goals that contribute to achieving management objectives.
The first goal is integration, in two senses: integrating HRM into an organization's corporate strategy, and ensuring an HRM view in the decisions of line managers. For example, a strategy of innovation may require a pay system that rewards creativity, while a cost reduction strategy may lead to pay rates strongly influenced by market levels. The second goal is securing commitment through building strong cultures. This involves uniting employees through a shared set of values like quality, service, or innovation. The third goal is to achieve flexibility and adaptability to manage change and innovation in response to rapid globalization. Relevant HRM policies include training, multi-skilling, and reorganization of work.
π‘ Why this matters: The three goals of HRM (integration, commitment, flexibility) are not just theoretical. They directly impact how a company designs its pay systems, training programs, and overall culture to execute its business strategy effectively.
C. Shifting from Personnel Management to HRM
The shift from Personnel Management to HRM reflects a transformation from concentrating on employee welfare to managing people in a way that matches organizational and individual goals. There are five fundamental attitudinal shifts that characterize this transformation.
First, HRM earlier reacted piece-meal to problems. Effective HRM seeks to link HRM issues to the overall strategy of the organization. The HRM policies for recruitment, training, etc., must be internally consistent and consistent with business strategies. Second, building strong cultures unites employees through shared values. However, a strong culture can create tension with the need to adapt to change. IBM's rigid beliefs about mainframes made it difficult to shift to personal computers when the market demanded it. Third, the attitude that people are a variable cost is replaced by the view that people are a resource and social capital that can be developed for competitive advantage. This makes training and development the central pillar of HRM. Fourth, the view that employee and management interests are divergent is giving way to a view that a commonality of interests can be promoted. For example, training enhances employee security while also increasing their value to the enterprise. Fifth, top-down communication with controlled information flow is giving way to a sharing of information and knowledge, which facilitates trust, commitment, and makes knowledge more productive.
The shift of personnel management to HRM took place in three stages:
- Records and Administration: The primary activities were administrative, such as planning company picnics, scheduling vacations, and enrolling workers for healthcare coverage.
- Accountability Regulations: A framework of rules and regulations emerged. In the 1970s, the focus was on legal compliance. In the 1980s, the focus was on staffing costs related to mergers and downsizing.
- Competitive Advantage: The aim shifted from securing compliance to winning commitment. The employee resource becomes worth investing in, and training and development assume a higher profile. What separates HRM from traditional personnel is the integration of HRM into strategic management.
π Definition β Social Capital: The view that people are not just a variable cost but a resource that can be developed and can contribute to a company's competitive advantage.
π Formula/Concept: Hard HRM vs. Soft HRM β The 'hard' version emphasizes the quantitative, calculative, and business-strategic aspects of managing headcount. The 'soft' version traces its roots to the human-relations school and emphasizes communication, motivation, and leadership.
π Example (IBM Case): IBM had a very strong culture with firmly-held beliefs about mainframe computers and customized systems. This "strong culture" made it difficult for the company to adapt quickly when the market demanded a radical shift to personal computers. This illustrates the tension between a strong culture and the need for flexibility.
β Key Takeaways
The key takeaway is that HRM evolved from a purely administrative, reactive function (Personnel Management) into a proactive, strategic partner in achieving organizational goals. This evolution is defined by three distinct stages: from basic records and administration, through an era of legal compliance and accountability, to the current focus on leveraging human resources for competitive advantage. Central to this shift are three critical goals: integrating HRM with corporate strategy, building strong cultures to secure employee commitment, and fostering flexibility to manage change. Finally, the lecture emphasizes a fundamental philosophical change: moving from viewing employees as a variable cost to treating them as valuable social capital worthy of investment, which is a cornerstone of modern HRM.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three basic goals of Human Resource Management according to this lecture?
- Describe the five fundamental attitudinal shifts that characterize the transition from Personnel Management to HRM.
- What are the three stages in the shift from Personnel Management to HRM, and what was the primary focus of each stage?
- What is the distinction between the "hard" and "soft" versions of HRM?
- Using the IBM example from the lecture, explain the potential downside of having a "strong organizational culture" in a rapidly changing market.
π Lecture 7 β HRM in a Changing Environment
π Overview: This lecture examines the external and internal forces that shape modern human resource management. It explains how managers must navigate environmental, organizational, and individual challenges to effectively manage people. These challenges, ranging from globalization to brain drain, determine whether firms outperform their competitors.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three levels of HR challenges: environmental challenges (rapid change, workforce diversity, globalization, legislation, technology, evolving work and family roles, skill shortages and the rise of the service sector), organizational challenges (competitive position, restructuring, decentralization, downsizing, shared services, outsourcing, line managers), and individual challenges (productivity, empowerment, brain drain, ethics and social responsibility, job insecurity, matching people and organizations). It also discusses new workplace trends including flextime, compressed workweeks, QWL, TQM, and diversity management.
π Lecture Summary
A. HRM in a Changing Environment: The Challenges
Todayβs organizations face challenges on three levels: environmental, organizational, and individual. These challenges determine how effectively firms manage their human resources.
i. Environmental Challenges
Environmental challenges refer to forces external to the firm that are largely beyond managementβs control but influence organizational performance. They include: rapid change, the internet revolution, workforce diversity, globalization, legislation, evolving work and family roles, and skill shortages and the rise of the service sector.
a) Rapid Change β Many organizations face a volatile environment in which change is nearly constant. To survive and prosper, they need to adapt to change quickly and effectively. Human resources are almost always at the heart of an effective response system.
b) Work Force Diversity β All these trends present both a significant challenge and a real opportunity for managers. Firms that formulate and implement HR strategies that capitalize on employee diversity are more likely to survive and prosper.
c) Globalization β One of the most dramatic challenges facing firms entering the twenty-first century is how to compete against foreign firms, both domestically and abroad. Weak response to international competition may result in upwards layoffs every year. Human resources can play a critical role in a business's ability to compete head-to-head with foreign producers.
Key implications include: Worldwide company culture β some firms try to develop a global company identity to smooth over cultural differences between domestic employees and those in international operations. For instance, the head of HR at Colgate Palmolive notes, "We try to build a common corporate culture. We want them all to be Colgateβs." Global alliances β some firms engage in international alliances with foreign firms or acquire companies overseas to take advantage of global markets. For instance, Phillips became the largest lighting manufacturer in the world by establishing a joint venture with AT&T and making several key acquisitions.
d) Legislation β Much of the growth in the HR function over the past three decades may be attributed to its crucial role in keeping the company out of trouble with the law. Most firms are concerned with potential liability from personnel decisions that may violate laws. How successfully a firm manages its human resources depends on its ability to deal effectively with government regulations. Many firms now develop formal policies on sexual harassment and establish internal administrative channels to deal with alleged incidents before employees file lawsuits. Legislation often has a differential impact on public- and private-sector organizations. Some legislation applies only to public-sector organizations; for instance, affirmative action requirements are typically limited to public organizations and those that do contract work for them.
e) Technology β Technological change is occurring so rapidly that individuals may have to change their entire skills three or four times in their career. The advances being made affect every area of a business including human resource management.
f) Evolving Work and Family Roles β The proportion of dual-career families is increasing every year. Women face the double burden of working at home and on the job, devoting 42 hours per week on average to the office and an additional 30 hours at home to children, compared to 43 hours working in the office and only 12 hours at home for men. More companies are introducing "family-friendly" programs that give them a competitive advantage in the labor market. These programs include child-care and eldercare referral services and alternative scheduling.
g) Skill Shortages and the Rise of the Service Sector β Service, technical, and managerial positions requiring college degrees will make up half of all jobs. Unfortunately, most available workers will be too unskilled to fill those jobs. Many companies complain that the supply of skilled labor is dwindling and that they must provide their employees with basic training to make up for the shortcomings of the public education system.
π‘ Why this matters: Environmental challenges are largely beyond management's control, but how a firm responds through its HR strategies determines its survival and competitive success.
ii. Organizational Challenges
Organizational challenges refer to concerns that are internal to the firm but are often a byproduct of environmental forces. Managers can usually exert much more control over organizational challenges than over environmental challenges. These challenges include the need for a competitive position and flexibility, downsizing, restructuring, self-managed work teams, small businesses, organizational culture, technology, and outsourcing.
An organization will outperform its competitors if it effectively utilizes its workforce's unique combination of skills and abilities to exploit environmental opportunities and neutralize threats. HR policies can influence an organization's competitive position by:
a) Controlling costs β A compensation system that uses innovative reward strategies to control labor costs can help the organization grow. Other factors include: better employee selection, training employees to make them more efficient and productive, attaining harmonious labor relations, effectively managing health and safety issues, and structuring work to reduce time and resources needed.
b) Improving quality β Many companies implement total quality management (TQM) initiatives, which are programs designed to improve the quality of all processes that lead to a final product or service. In a TQM program, every aspect of the organization is oriented toward providing a quality product or service.
c) Creating Distinctive Capabilities β The third way to gain a competitive advantage is to utilize people with distinctive capabilities to create unsurpassed competence in a particular area (for example, 3M's competence in adhesives, Carlson Corporation's leading presence in the travel business, and Xerox's dominance of the photocopier market).
d) Restructuring β A number of firms are changing the way functions are performed. This restructuring often results in a shift in terms of who performs each function. The traditional human resource manager continues to be in place in most organizations, but some organizations are also using shared service centers, outsourcing, and line managers to assist in the delivery of human resources.
Key restructuring elements include:
- The Human Resource Manager β An individual who normally acts in an advisory or staff capacity, working with other managers to help them deal with human resource matters.
- Shared Service Centers β Take routine, transaction-based activities that are dispersed throughout the organization and consolidate them in one place.
- Outsourcing Firms β The process of transferring responsibility for an area of service and its objectives to an external provider. The main reason was to reduce transaction time, but other benefits include cost reductions and quality improvements.
- Line Managers β Line managers, by the nature of their jobs, are involved with human resources. In certain firms, they are being used more to deliver HR services.
- Decentralization β Transfers responsibility and decision-making authority from a central office to people and locations closer to the situation that demands attention.
- Downsizing β Periodic reductions in a company's workforce to improve its bottom line. Even firms once legendary for their "no layoff" policies (AT&T, IBM, Kodak, Xerox) now use downsizing.
iii. Individual Challenges
Human resource issues at the individual level address decisions most pertinent to specific employees. These almost always reflect what is happening in the larger organization. There is a two-way relationship between organizational and individual challenges. The most important individual challenges today involve:
a) Productivity β A measure of how much value individual employees add to the goods or services the organization produces. Two important factors that affect individual productivity are ability and motivation. Ability can be improved through hiring, placement, training, and career development. Motivation refers to a person's desire to do the best possible job or exert maximum effort. A growing number of companies recognize that employees are more likely to choose a firm and stay if they believe it offers a high quality of work life (QWL).
b) Empowerment β The process of transferring direction from an external source (normally the immediate supervisor) to an internal source (the individual's own desire to do well). It entails providing workers with the skills and authority to make decisions traditionally made by managers. The goal is an organization consisting of enthusiastic, committed people who perform work because they believe in it (internal control), as opposed to compliance to avoid punishment (external control).
c) Brain Drain β The loss of intellectual property that results when competitors lure away key employees. High-tech firms are particularly vulnerable. To combat this, some firms craft anti-defection devices. For example, Compaq Computer revokes bonuses to key executives if they take other employees with them when they quit. Micron Technology staggers key employees' bonuses; they lose un-awarded portions when they leave.
π Definition β Brain Drain: The loss of intellectual property that results when competitors lure away key employees.
d) Ethics and Social Responsibility β Corporate social responsibility refers to the extent to which companies should and do channel resources toward improving one or more segments of society other than the firm's owners or stockholders. Ethics is the bedrock of socially responsible behavior. Many firms have created codes of ethics, but these often do not meet employees' expectations. A company that exercises social responsibility attempts to balance its commitments to investors, employees, customers, other businesses, and the community. For example, McDonald's established Ronald McDonald Houses for families of sick children; Sears and GE support artists.
π Definition β Ethics and Social Responsibility: Corporate social responsibility refers to the extent to which companies should and do channel resources toward improving one or more segments of society other than the firmβs owners or stockholders. Ethics is the bedrock of socially responsible behavior.
e) Job Insecurity β In this era of downsizing and restructuring, many employees fear for their jobs. Chronic job insecurity is a major source of stress and can lead to lower performance and productivity. Though union membership has been declining, job security is now a top union priority. In return for job security, union leaders have had to make major concessions regarding pay and benefits.
f) Matching People and Organizations β HR strategies contribute to firm performance most when the firm uses them to attract and retain the type of employee who best fits the firm's culture and overall business objectives. For example, fast-growth firms perform better with managers who have a strong marketing and sales background, are willing to take risks, and have a high tolerance for ambiguity. However, these traits actually reduce the performance of mature firms interested in maintaining market share.
B. New Trends at Work Place
The past two decades have witnessed a dramatic transformation in how firms are structured. Tall organizations with many management levels are becoming flatter as companies reduce the number of people between the CEO and the lowest-ranking employee. Two-thirds of jobs eliminated in the 1990s were supervisory/middle management jobs. Mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures, alliances, and collaborations among firms represent important sources of restructuring.
a) Education β Organizations now have the opportunity of having more knowledge and skilled workers. The increase in the education level of society continuously provides a highly educated workforce.
b) Work time β Flextime is the practice of permitting employees to choose, with certain limitations, their own working hours. Compressed Workweek is any arrangement of work hours that permits employees to fulfill their work obligation in fewer days than the typical five-day workweek.
c) Standard of living β High employment rate, low inflation, and steady economic growth provide opportunity and rising living standards. Technological advance has enabled the world's population to grow with improved living standards.
d) Expectations & demand β People's expectations that their employers will behave ethically are increasing. Many firms have created codes of ethics, but these often do not meet employees' expectations of ethical employer behavior.
e) Diversity and gender issues at work place β Managing diversity means planning and implementing organizational systems and practices to manage people so that the potential advantages of diversity are maximized while its potential disadvantages are minimized. A study found that cultural diversity contributes to improved productivity, return on equity, and market performance.
f) QWL β High quality of work life is related to job satisfaction, which in turn is a strong predictor of absenteeism and turnover. Investments in improving quality of work life also payoff in better customer service.
g) TQM β Many companies implement total quality management (TQM) initiatives, programs designed to improve the quality of all processes that lead to a final product or service. In a TQM program, every aspect of the organization is oriented toward providing a quality product or service.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that HR management must address three interlocking levels of challenges: environmental (globalization, technology, legislation, diversity), organizational (cost control, quality, restructuring, downsizing), and individual (productivity, empowerment, brain drain, ethics). The most critical concept is that environmental forces are largely uncontrollable but demand effective HR responses, while organizational and individual challenges have a two-way relationship affecting each other. Students must understand the distinction between traditional HR managers, shared service centers, outsourcing, and line managers in delivering HR services. The lecture also emphasizes that matching people to organizational culture is essential for firm performance, and that trends like flextime, compressed workweeks, TQM, and diversity management are reshaping modern workplaces.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three levels of challenges facing HRM in a changing environment?
- What is the difference between environmental and organizational challenges in terms of managerial control?
- How can HR policies influence a firm's competitive position? List and explain three ways.
- Define brain drain and describe two anti-defection strategies companies use to combat it.
- What is the difference between a human resource manager, shared service center, and outsourcing firm in delivering HR services?