π Lecture 16 β Job Analysis (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of job analysis by focusing on Human Resource Planning (HRP) and the forecasting techniques used to determine future staffing needs. It also introduces the HR hiring process, beginning with recruitment, and examines the constraints, philosophy, and ethical issues that influence how organizations attract and hire employees.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Human Resource Planning and several forecasting techniques including zero-based forecasting, bottom-up approach, mathematical models, and simulation. It then addresses how to handle forecasted surpluses or shortages of workers, explains succession planning and development, and introduces the HR hiring process with a detailed focus on recruitment. Finally, it discusses constraints of the recruitment process, the philosophy of recruitment (internal vs. external), and ethical issues in recruitment.
π Lecture Summary
A. Human resource planning (HRP)
Human Resource Planning (HRP) is the process of systematically reviewing human resource requirements to ensure that the required number of employees, with the required skills, is available when they are needed. This planning helps organizations align their workforce with their strategic goals. π‘ Why this matters: Without proper HRP, a company may face sudden shortages or surpluses of workers, disrupting operations and increasing costs.
π Definition β Human Resource Planning (HRP): The process of systematically reviewing human resource requirements to ensure that the required number of employees, with the required skills, is available when they are needed.
B. HUMAN RESOURCE FORECASTING TECHNIQUES
Several techniques of forecasting human resource requirements and availability are currently used by those in the profession.
- Zero Based Forecasting: This method uses the organizationβs current level of employment as the starting point for determining future staffing needs. The key to zero-base forecasting is a thorough analysis of human resource needs.
- Bottom-Up Approach: A forecasting method in which each successive level of the organization, starting with the lowest, forecasts its employee requirements in order to, ultimately, provide an aggregate forecast of employment needs.
- Use Of Mathematical Models: Mathematical models can assist in forecasting HR requirements. The relationship between sales demand and the number of employees needed is a positive one.
- Simulation: Simulation is a technique for experimenting with a real-world situation through a mathematical model representing that situation. A model is an abstraction of the real world.
Forecasting Human Resource Requirements A requirements forecast is an estimate of the numbers and kinds of employees the organization will need at future dates in order to realize its goals.
Forecasting Human Resource Availability Determining whether the firm will be able to secure employees with the necessary skills and from what sources these individuals may be obtained is called an availability forecast.
SURPLUS OF EMPLOYEES FORECASTED When a comparison of requirements and availability indicates a worker surplus will result, restricted hiring, reduced hours, early retirements, or layoffs may be required to correct the situation.
- Restricted Hiring: When a firm implements a restricted hiring policy, it reduces the workforce by not replacing employees who leave.
- Reduced Hours: Reaction to a declining demand can also be made by reducing the total number of hours worked. Instead of continuing a 40-hour week, management may decide to cut each employeeβs time to 30 hours.
- Early Retirement: Early retirement of some present employees is another means of reducing the supply of workers.
- Layoffs: At times, the firm has no choice but to actually lay off part of its workforce.
SHORTAGE OF WORKERS FORECASTED Unemployment in the United States was at an all-time low in the summer of 2000. Faced with a shortage of workers, many organizations had to intensify their efforts to recruit the necessary people. Some actions taken included:
- Creative Recruiting: A shortage of personnel often means that new approaches to recruiting must be used. The organization may have to recruit in different geographical areas than in the past, explore new methods, and seek different kinds of candidates.
- Compensation Incentives: Firms competing for workers in a high-demand situation may have to rely on compensation incentives. Premium pay is one obvious method. However, this approach may trigger a bidding war that the organization cannot sustain. More subtle forms of rewards may be required, such as four-day workweeks, flexible working hours, telecommuting, part-time employment, and child care centers.
- Training Programs: Special training programs may be needed to prepare previously unemployable individuals for positions with a firm. Remedial education and skills training are two types of programs that may help attract individuals.
- Different Selection Standards: Another approach is the lowering of employment standards. Selection criteria that screen out certain workers may have to be altered. For instance, instead of desiring extensive work experience, a firm may be willing to hire an inexperienced worker and train them.
SUCCESSION PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
- Succession Planning: The process of ensuring that a qualified person is available to assume a managerial position once the position is vacant.
- Succession Development: It is the process of determining a comprehensive job profile of the key positions and then ensuring that key prospects are properly developed to match these qualifications.
C. HR Hiring Process:
The HR hiring process involves the activities that are required to make the workforce or staff available to fill and keep filled different positions in the organization. This process includes the following steps:
- Recruitment: It is the process of attracting individuals on a timely basis, in sufficient numbers and with appropriate qualifications, and encouraging them to apply for jobs with an organization.
- Selection: The process of making a βhireβ or βno hireβ decision regarding each applicant for a job.
- Socialization: The process of orienting new employees to the organization or the unit in which they will be working.
Recruitment: It is the process of attracting individuals on a timely basis, in sufficient numbers and with appropriate qualifications, and encouraging them to apply for jobs with an organization.
a. Goals of Recruitment: Mainly there are two recruitment goals. b. To attract qualified applicants: The recruiting process is used to create the pool of qualified applicants. By qualified applicants we mean those applicants who have abilities that are a perfect match with the job requirements. c. To discourage non qualified applicants: The second goal is to avoid nonqualified applicants. When recruiting is based upon careful designing of the job description and job specification, most applicants with irrelevant qualifications are eliminated, making the process more effective.
π Definition β Recruitment: The process of attracting individuals on a timely basis, in sufficient numbers and with appropriate qualifications, and encouraging them to apply for jobs with an organization.
D. Constraints of Recruitment Process:
Different factors in internal or external environment can influence the effectiveness of the recruiting process in a negative manner. They mainly include:
I. Image of the Organization: If employees believe that their employer deals with them fairly, the positive word-of-mouth support they provide is of great value. The image is assessed by its performance, salary, benefits, potential opportunities to excel, and respect. A positive image in the market helps attract a reasonable number of applicants.
II. Attractiveness of the job: This mainly depends upon its contribution towards achievement of organization's objectives, challenging assignments, and its contribution in the career development of the job holder. Benefits and salary also play an important role. Jobs with challenging assignments, career orientation, and good remuneration can attract the best applicants.
III. Government Influence: The recruitment process is influenced by the laws provided by the government. Organizations are required to work according to these laws.
IV. Labor Market Influence: The recruitment process is influenced by labor market conditions. When the economy is growing rapidly and unemployment levels are very low, recruiting is extremely difficult. However, when the economy is stagnant and unemployment levels are high, organizations can obtain a large applicant pool with very little effort.
V. Recruiting Costs: Companies bear very high costs while performing the recruitment process, especially when the recruitment is external. Organizations can perform this function only if they have sufficient resources.
VI. Global Issues: When staffing is performed at the international level or across national boundaries, policies of the host country regarding employment also influence the recruitment process. These can include basic labor laws regarding quality of work life, EEO, and remuneration packages.
Diversity through Recruiting Efforts: To offset past discrimination, firms must resort to additional recruitment approaches. A recruitment program designed to specifically attract women and minorities is referred to as affirmative recruitment. To ensure a nondiscriminatory program, the firm must analyze its procedures and train recruiters in objective, job-related standards. Organizations engaged in affirmative recruitment should develop contacts with minority, women's, and other community organizations.
E. Philosophy of the Recruitment:
A major decision in performing the recruitment process is selection of sources from the available sources: Internal Recruitment and External Recruitment. Both have pros and cons. To have the best pool of applicants, it is suggested that a multiple approach should be used instead of depending upon any single source.
F. Ethical Issues in Recruitment:
- Performs recruiting and employment activities for off-site locations, providing qualified candidates in a cost-effective and timely manner while ensuring adherence to the corporate job posting procedure.
- Verifies that all job offers to internal and external candidates are within company policy and that any unusual questions regarding employment are referred to the Manager in order to ensure fair and equitable treatment of all job candidates.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are that Human Resource Planning (HRP) ensures the right number of skilled employees are available when needed, and forecasting techniques like zero-based forecasting and bottom-up approaches help predict both requirements and availability. Understanding how to manage a forecasted surplus (through restricted hiring, reduced hours, early retirement, or layoffs) and a shortage (through creative recruiting, compensation incentives, training, or different selection standards) is essential for responding to labor market conditions. The HR hiring process has three key stepsβrecruitment, selection, and socializationβand the recruitment process specifically aims to attract qualified applicants while discouraging unqualified ones. Finally, recruitment is constrained by factors like organizational image, job attractiveness, government laws, labor market conditions, and costs, and ethical practices must ensure fair and nondiscriminatory treatment of all candidates.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of Human Resource Planning (HRP)?
- List four techniques used for forecasting human resource requirements.
- What are the four actions an organization can take if a surplus of employees is forecasted?
- What is the difference between succession planning and succession development?
- Name the three steps in the HR hiring process and the two main goals of recruitment.
π Lecture 17 β Sources of Recruitment
π Overview: This lecture introduces recruitment as the first step in the staffing function, explaining how organizations attract potential job applicants. It covers the two main sources of recruitment (internal and external), various recruitment methods, alternatives to recruitment, and how to evaluate the recruitment process. Understanding these concepts is essential for building an effective workforce.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining recruitment and the recruitment process, including yield ratios. It then explores internal recruitment sources (promotion from within, job posting, contacts and referrals) with their advantages and disadvantages, followed by external recruitment sources (schools, colleges, competitors, unemployed, etc.) and external recruitment methods (advertising, agencies, recruiters, internships, cyber recruiting, etc.). The lecture concludes with alternatives to recruitment, an applicant's perspective, and evaluation of the recruitment process.
π Lecture Summary
A. Recruitment:
Recruitment refers to the process of attracting potential job applicants from the available labor force. Every organization must attract enough candidates with the abilities and aptitudes needed to achieve its objectives. The effectiveness of employee selection is limited by the effectiveness of the recruiting processβoutstanding candidates cannot be selected if they are not in the applicant pool. The recruitment process interacts with other HR functions like performance evaluation, compensation, training, and employee relations.
In planning recruitment, organizations must know how many applicants to recruit. Since some applicants may be unsatisfactory and others may reject offers, organizations must recruit more applicants than they expect to hire. Yield Ratios help organizations decide how many employees to recruit for each job opening. These ratios express the relationship between the number of people at one step of the recruitment process relative to the number who will move to the next step.
π Definition β Recruitment: The process of attracting potential job applicants from the available labor force.
π Definition β Yield Ratios: Ratios that help organizations decide how many employees to recruit for each job opening by expressing the relationship between people at one step of the recruitment process relative to those moving to the next step.
B. Source of Recruitment:
Organizations have two main sources of recruitment:
- I. Internal Recruitment
- II. External Recruitment
Vacancies in upper-level management can be filled either by hiring from outside or by promoting lower-level managers. Both strategies have advantages and disadvantages.
I. Internal Recruiting Sources: When job vacancies exist, the first place to look is within the organization. Present employees feel they deserve promotion opportunities due to their service and commitment. Organizations can examine employees' track records and estimate who would be successful. Recruiting internally is less expensive than external recruiting. Major forms include:
1. Promotion from within: Promoting entry-level employees to more responsible positions is one of the best ways to fill vacancies. Organizations with HR planning systems use succession plans and replacement charts to identify and prepare individuals for upper-level positions. Skills inventories help identify individuals with advancement potential. A promotion-from-within policy is intrinsic to career development and HR planning, stimulating employee motivation and improving morale.
2. Job posting: Organizations notify present employees about job openings through bulletin boards, company publications, or personal letters. The purpose is to communicate that a job opening exists. Guidelines for effective job posting include: postings should be prominent; clear job specifications should be communicated so applicants can assess eligibility; and once a decision is made, all applicants should be informed.
3. Contacts and Referrals: Employees may actively solicit applications from friends and associates. Employee referrals are relatively inexpensive and usually produce quick responses. However, concerns include favoritism and cliques from hiring friends and relatives.
Advantages of Internal Recruitment:
- Provides greater motivation for good performance
- Provides greater opportunities for present employees
- Provides better opportunity to assess abilities
- Improves morale and organizational loyalty
- Enables employees to perform new jobs with little lost time
Disadvantages of Internal Recruitment:
- Creates narrowing thinking and stale ideas
- Creates pressures to compete
- Creates homogeneous workforce
- May miss good outside talent; requires strong management development programs, especially for technology training
II. External Recruiting Sources: A variety of methods are available for external recruiting. Organizations should assess the kinds of positions to fill and select appropriate methods. External recruitment is used for: filling entry-level jobs, acquiring skills not possessed by current employees, and obtaining employees with different backgrounds for new ideas.
a. High Schools and Vocational Schools: Used for recruiting clerical and entry-level operative employees.
b. Community Colleges: Many are sensitive to local labor market needs and graduate sought-after students with marketable skills.
c. Colleges and Universities: A major source for potential professional, technical, and management employees.
d. Competitors and other Firms: Important for positions where recent experience is highly desired.
e. Unemployed: Regardless of the reason, unemployed individuals provide a valuable recruitment source.
f. Older Individuals: Older workers, including retirees, comprise a valuable employee source.
g. Military Personnel: These individuals typically have proven work history and are flexible, motivated, and drug-free.
h. Self-Employed Workers: Source for jobs requiring technical, professional, administrative, or entrepreneurial expertise.
III. EXTERNAL RECRUITMENT METHODS Recruitment methods are specific means through which potential employees are attracted to the firm.
a. Advertising: Communicating employment needs to the public through media such as radio, newspaper, television, industry publications, and the Internet. Blind advertisements provide no company identification. Reasons for blind ads include: keeping recruitment low profile, poor company reputation, or test marketing to gauge applicant supply.
b. Employment Agencies: Organizations that help firms recruit employees and aid individuals in locating jobs. Two types: Public Employment Agencies and Private Employment Agencies. Both coordinate between organizations and applicants, charging a fee. Some agencies specialize in areas like engineering, HR, or computer programming.
c. Recruiters: Most commonly used with technical/vocational schools, community colleges, colleges, and universities.
d. Special Events: A single employer or group of employers attracts a large number of applicants for interviews.
e. Internships: A special form of recruiting placing a student in a temporary job. No obligation for permanent hire by the company or acceptance by the student. Internship programs represent an excellent means of recruiting outstanding employees.
f. Executive Search Firms: Called HEAD HUNTERS, these are specialized private employment agencies that place top-level executives and experienced professionals. They seek the most qualified executive for a specific position and are retained by the company.
g. Professional Associations: Associations in business professions (finance, marketing, IT, HR) provide recruitment and placement services. They have newsletters, annual meetings, and trade publications advertising job openings.
h. Unsolicited Walk-In Applicants: Organizations with good reputations may attract applicants without extensive recruitment efforts.
i. Open Houses: Firms pair potential hires and managers in a warm, casual environment encouraging on-the-spot job offers.
j. Event Recruiting: Attending events where sought-after people gather.
k. Virtual Job Fairs: Individuals meet recruiters face-to-face in interviews over special computers with lenses transmitting head-and-shoulder images.
l. Cyber Recruiting: Using websites and internet sources to recruit; applications, tests, interviews, and other activities can be performed online.
Advantages of External Recruitment:
- Provides new ideas and new insights
- Provides greater diversity and helps achieve EEO goals through affirmative action
- Provides opportunities to handle rapid organizational growth
- Opportunities to get people with up-to-date knowledge, education, and training
Disadvantages of External Recruitment:
- More expensive and time-consuming
- Destroys incentives of present employees to strive for promotion
- More chances of hiring mistakes due to difficult applicant assessment, leading to resource wastage
π Definition β Advertising: A way of communicating employment needs within the firm to the public through media such as radio, newspaper, television, industry publications, and the Internet.
π Definition β Internal Recruiting Sources: When job vacancies exist, the first place an organization should look for placement is within itself.
π Definition β Internships: A special form of recruiting that involves placing a student in a temporary job.
C. ALTERNATIVES TO RECRUITMENT
Adding personnel is a significant financial investment. Recruitment and selection costs are high, especially for professional, technical, and managerial employees. Before recruiting, organizations should consider alternatives:
I. Outsourcing: The process of transferring responsibility for an area of service and its objectives to an external service provider instead of internal employees.
II. Contingent Workers: Also known as part-timers, temporaries, and independent contractors; the fastest-growing segment of the economy.
III. Professional Employer Organization (Employee Leasing): A firm terminates some or most of its employees. A leasing company hires them at the same salary and leases them back to the former employer (client).
IV. Overtime: The most commonly used method for meeting short-term fluctuations in work volume.
π Definition β Outsourcing: The process of transferring responsibility for an area of service and its objectives to an external service provider instead of internal employees.
π Definition β Contingent Workers: Also known as part-timers, temporaries, and independent contractors; comprise the fastest-growing segment of our economy.
D. Recruitment - An applicant perspective:
- Applicants should be provided necessary information about the organization, job, and remuneration package.
- If rejection is communicated, it should be done tactfully.
E. Evaluating the Recruitment Process:
The recruitment process can be evaluated by two factors:
1. Quantity of the Applicants: Greater numbers of applications increase the chance to select the best people from the available pool.
2. Quality of the Applicants: Effectiveness is estimated by the quality of applicants, assessed by education, skills, capabilities, and competencies.
Yield Ratios: The effectiveness of the recruitment process also depends on the acceptability of the yield ratio.
β Key Takeaways
Recruitment is the process of attracting potential applicants, and its effectiveness directly limits selection outcomes. Organizations must recruit more applicants than needed due to yield ratiosβthe relationship between applicants at each stage. Internal recruitment (promotion from within, job posting, referrals) is cheaper, boosts morale, and allows better ability assessment, but can create stale ideas and homogeneous workforces. External recruitment (from schools, competitors, agencies, cyber recruiting) brings new ideas and diversity but is more expensive and can demotivate current employees. Before recruiting, organizations should consider alternatives like outsourcing, contingent workers, employee leasing, and overtime to save costs. Finally, recruitment evaluation depends on both the quantity and quality of applicants.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are yield ratios, and why are they important in the recruitment process?
- List three internal recruitment sources and explain two key advantages and two disadvantages of internal recruitment.
- What is the difference between a blind advertisement and a regular job advertisement, and why might a company use a blind ad?
- Describe four alternatives to recruitment that an organization should consider before hiring new employees.
- How can an organization evaluate the effectiveness of its recruitment process, and what are the two main evaluation factors?
π Lecture 18 β SELECTION
π Overview: This lecture explains the complete employee selection process, from initial screening to final hiring decisions. It covers the environmental factors that influence how organizations select candidates and details the sequential steps in the selection process. Understanding selection is critical because hiring the right person for the right job directly impacts organizational performance and legal compliance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an overview of the selection process as choosing the best-fit candidate from a group of applicants. It then examines seven environmental factors affecting selection: legal considerations, speed of decision making, organizational hierarchy, applicant pool, type of organization, probationary period, and selection criteria. Finally, it details the eight steps in the selection process: initial screening, application blank, pre-employment testing, interview, background checks, conditional job offer, medical exam/drug tests, and final selection decision.
π Lecture Summary
A. SELECTION PROCESS
Selection is the process of choosing from a group of applicants those individuals best suited for a particular position. Most managers recognize that employee selection is one of their most difficult and most important business decisions. This process involves making a judgment β not about the applicant, but about the fit between the applicant and the job by considering knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics required to perform the job. Selection procedures are not carried out through a standard pattern; steps in this process can vary from organization to organization. Some steps performed and considered important by one organization can be skipped by another organization.
π Definition β Selection Process: The process of choosing from a group of applicants those individuals best suited for a particular position.
π‘ Why this matters: A poor hiring decision wastes resources and can damage team morale and productivity, while a good selection decision builds organizational capability.
B. ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS AFFECTING THE SELECTION PROCESS
A permanent, standardized screening process could greatly simplify the selection process. However, development of such a process β even if it were possible and desirable β would not eliminate deviations to meet the unique needs of particular situations.
Legal Considerations: Legislation, executive orders, and court decisions have a major impact on human resource management. It is important for hiring managers to see the relationship between useful and legally defensible selection tools.
Speed of Decision Making: The time available to make the selection decision can have a major effect on the selection process. Closely following selection policies and procedures can provide greater protection against legal problems; however, there are times when the pressure of business will dictate that exceptions be made.
Organizational Hierarchy: Different approaches to selection are generally taken for filling positions at different levels in the organization.
Applicant Pool: The number of applicants for a particular job can also affect the selection process. The process can be truly selective only if there are several qualified applicants for a particular position. The number of people hired for a particular job compared to the individuals in the applicant pool is often expressed as a selection ratio.
Type of Organization: The sector of the economy in which individuals are to be employed β private, governmental, or not-for-profit β can also affect the selection process.
Probationary Period: Many firms use a probationary period that permits evaluating an employeeβs ability based on performance. This may be either a substitute for certain phases of the selection process or a check on the validity of the process.
Selection Criteria: Mostly the selection of applicant depends upon the following factors or criterions:
- EDUCATION
- COMPETENCIES
- EXPERIENCE
- SKILLS AND ABILITIES
- PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS
The applicant who is best fit should be hired instead of hiring a person with extraordinary skills β it means right person for right job should be hired. A person who is over or under qualified for the particular job will not be able to adjust in the organization.
C. STEPS IN THE SELECTION PROCESS
The selection process typically begins with the preliminary interview; next, candidates complete the application for employment. They progress through a series of selection tests, the employment interview, and reference and background checks. The successful applicant receives a company physical examination and is employed if the results are satisfactory. Several external and internal factors impact the selection process, and the manager must take them into account in making selection decisions. Typically, the selection process consists of the following steps, but it is not necessary that all organizations go through all these steps β as per requirement of the organization, some steps can be skipped.
The eight steps are:
- Initial Screening
- Application Blank
- Pre-employment Testing
- General Intelligence Tests
- Aptitude Tests
- Personality and Interest Tests
- Achievement Tests
- Honesty Tests
- Interview (Structured, Unstructured, Mixed)
- Background Checks
- Conditional Job Offer
- Medical Exam/Drug Tests
- Final Selection Decision
1. Initial Screening
INITIAL SCREENING: The selection process often begins with an initial screening of applicants to remove individuals who obviously do not meet the position requirements. At this stage, a few straightforward questions are asked. An applicant may obviously be unqualified to fill the advertised position, but be well qualified to work in other open positions. The Purpose of Screening is to decrease the number of applicants being considered for selection.
Sources utilized in the screening effort: The Personal Resume presented with the job application is considered as a source of information that can be used for the initial screening process. It mainly includes information in the following areas:
- Employment & education history
- Evaluation of character
- Evaluation of job performance
Screening Interviews: Screening interviews are used to:
- To verify information provided on resume or application blank
- They are usually very short (approximately 30 minutes or so)
Advantages of Successful Screening: If the screening effort is successful, those applicants that do not meet minimum required qualifications will not move to the next stage in the selection process. Companies utilizing expensive selection procedures put more effort in screening to reduce costs.
2. APPLICATION BLANK / REVIEW OF APPLICATIONS
APPLICATION BLANK: is a formal record of an individualβs application for employment. The next step in the selection process may involve having the prospective employee complete an application for employment. The specific type of information may vary from firm to firm and even by job type within an organization. However, the application form must reflect not only the firmβs informational needs but also EEO requirements. Application forms are a good way to quickly collect verifiable and fairly accurate historical data from the candidate.
π Definition β Application Blank: A formal record of an individualβs application for employment.
β Key Takeaways
The selection process is not a rigid, one-size-fits-all procedure; organizations adapt the steps based on their unique needs, resources, and the specific job position. Environmental factors such as legal considerations, speed of decision making, organizational hierarchy, and the applicant pool significantly influence how selection is conducted. The core principle is to hire the person who is the best fit for the job β not the most qualified or overqualified candidate β because over or under qualification leads to poor adjustment. The selection criteria focus on education, competencies, experience, skills and abilities, and personal characteristics. The eight-step process moves from initial screening through testing, interviews, background checks, and medical exams to the final selection decision, with steps potentially skipped based on organizational requirements.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of the selection process, and why is it considered one of management's most important decisions?
- List any four environmental factors that affect the selection process and briefly explain how each one influences hiring decisions.
- What is the purpose of the initial screening step, and what are the two main sources used during screening?
- An applicant has extraordinary skills but is overqualified for the position. According to the lecture, why should this person not be hired?
- Name the five types of pre-employment tests mentioned in the lecture and the three types of interviews used in the selection process.