π Lecture 7 β Financial Institutions
π Overview: This lecture explores the role of financial institutions as intermediaries between savers and borrowers, examines the structure of the financial industry by categorizing depository and nondepository institutions, and introduces the foundational concept of the time value of money. Understanding these institutions is critical because they reduce transaction and information costs, enable long-term lending while providing short-term liquidity, and are directly tied to the availability of money and credit.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first defines financial institutions as firms that provide access to financial markets, sitting between savers and borrowers. It explains three reasons a system without them would fail: high transaction costs, the need for credit evaluation and monitoring, and maturity mismatches. The role of financial institutions is detailed, including reducing costs, curbing information asymmetries, and providing liquid instruments. A simplified balance sheet of a financial institution is shown (assets: bonds, stocks, loans, real estate; liabilities: deposits, insurance policies). The structure of the financial industry is then divided into two broad categories: depository institutions (commercial banks, savings banks, credit unions) and nondepository institutions (insurance companies, pension funds, securities firms, government sponsored enterprises, finance companies).
π Lecture Summary
Financial Institutions
Financial institutions are firms that provide access to financial markets. They sit between savers and borrowers and are known as financial intermediaries. Examples include banks, insurance companies, securities firms, and pension funds. A system without financial institutions would not work well for three reasons: (1) individual transactions between saver-lenders and borrower-spenders would be extremely expensive; (2) lenders need to evaluate the creditworthiness of borrowers and monitor them, but individuals are not equipped to do this; (3) most borrowers want to borrow long term, while lenders favor short-term loans.
Role of Financial Institutions
Financial institutions play several critical roles:
- Reduce transactions cost by specializing in the issuance of standardized securities.
- Reduce information costs of screening and monitoring borrowers.
- Curb information asymmetries, helping ensure resources flow into their most productive uses.
- Make long-term loans but allow savers ready access to their funds.
- Provide savers with financial instruments (more liquid and less risky than individual stocks and bonds) that savers would purchase directly in financial markets.
π‘ Why this matters: By performing these roles, financial institutions enable indirect finance, where funds flow from lenders/savers through institutions (which issue deposits and insurance policies) to borrowers/spenders (who receive loans, bonds, stocks, and real estate). Without them, direct finance (savers buying bonds and stocks directly from borrowers) would be inefficient and risky.
π Definition β Indirect Finance: A system where funds flow from lenders/savers to borrowers/spenders through financial intermediaries, who transform assets (e.g., deposits into loans).
π Formula: Flow of Funds: Lenders/Savers β Financial Institutions (Deposits & Insurance Policies) β Borrowers/Spenders (Loans, Bonds, Stocks, Real Estate)
π Example: A household deposits $10,000 in a commercial bank. The bank then uses that deposit to make a $200,000 mortgage loan to a homebuyer. The household receives a liquid, low-risk deposit account, while the homebuyer gets a long-term loan.
The Simplified Balance Sheet of a Financial Institution
A financial institution's balance sheet shows how it transforms assets:
| Assets | Liabilities |
|---|---|
| Bonds | Deposits |
| Stocks | Insurance policies |
| Loans | |
| Real estate |
Assets represent what the institution owns or is owed (e.g., bonds, stocks, loans, real estate). Liabilities represent what the institution owes to its customers (e.g., deposits, insurance policies).
The Structure of the Financial Industry
Financial institutions or intermediaries can be divided into two broad categories:
Depository institutions β take deposits and make loans. Examples: Commercial banks, savings banks, and credit unions.
Nondepository institutions include:
- Insurance companies: Accept premiums, which they invest in securities and real estate in return for promising compensation to policyholders should certain events occur (e.g., death, property losses).
- Pension funds: Invest individual and company contributions into stocks, bonds, and real estate to provide payments to retired workers.
- Securities firms: Include brokers, investment banks, and mutual fund companies. Brokers and investment banks issue stocks and bonds to corporate customers, trade them, and advise clients. Mutual fund companies pool the resources of individuals and companies and invest them in portfolios of bonds, stocks, and real estate.
- Government Sponsored Enterprises: Federal credit agencies that provide loans directly for farmers and home mortgages, as well as guarantee programs that insure the loans made by private lenders. Examples: HBFC, ZTBL, Khushhali bank, SME Bank. The government also provides retirement income and medical care to the elderly (and disabled) through Social Security and Medicare.
- Finance Companies: Raise funds directly in the financial markets to make loans to individuals and firms.
π Definition β Depository Institutions: Financial intermediaries that accept deposits from savers and use those funds to make loans to borrowers (e.g., commercial banks).
π Example: An insurance company receives a $1,200 annual premium from a homeowner. It invests that premium in corporate bonds and government securities. When the homeowner's house is damaged in a storm, the insurance company compensates them from its investment pool.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Financial institutions serve as intermediaries, reducing transaction and information costs, curbing information asymmetries, and enabling long-term lending with short-term liquidity for savers. (2) The flow of funds through institutions (indirect finance) is safer and more efficient than direct finance between individuals and borrowers. (3) The simplified balance sheet of an institution shows assets (bonds, stocks, loans, real estate) and liabilities (deposits, insurance policies). (4) Depository institutions (commercial banks, savings banks, credit unions) take deposits and make loans, while nondepository institutions (insurance companies, pension funds, securities firms, government sponsored enterprises, finance companies) perform other financial services. (5) The monetary aggregates are made up of liabilities of commercial banks, tying the financial structure directly to the availability of money and credit.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are three reasons a financial system without institutions would not work well?
- How do financial institutions reduce transaction costs and information asymmetries?
- What is the difference between depository and nondepository institutions? Provide two examples of each.
- List the assets and liabilities on a simplified balance sheet of a financial institution.
- How do insurance companies and pension funds differ in their primary functions?
π Lecture 8 β Time Value of Money
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concept of the time value of money, explaining why interest exists as compensation for opportunity cost. It provides the mathematical tools to calculate future value and present value, which are essential for making sound financial decisions in personal finance, business, and government.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture discusses the economic rationale for interest as compensation for lost opportunities, then proceeds to define and calculate future value using compound interest formulas. It demonstrates how future value grows with higher interest rates and longer time periods. Finally, it explains present value as the inverse of future value, showing how to discount future payments to their current worth.
π Lecture Summary
Time Value of Money
Credit is one of the critical mechanisms for allocating resources. Even the simplest financial transaction, like saving each month to buy a car, would be impossible without it. However, many people view interest negatively because they fail to appreciate that lending has an opportunity cost. When lenders extend a loan, they give up alternativesβneither the time the loan was outstanding nor the opportunities missed during that time can be recovered. Therefore, interest is not "the breeding of money from money," as Aristotle claimed, but rather a rental fee that borrowers pay to compensate lenders for lost opportunities.
Interest rates are enormously important to individuals, businesses, and governments. They link the present to the future, allowing us to compare payments made on different dates. Interest rates also tell us the future reward for lending today and the cost of borrowing now and repaying later. To make sound financial decisions, we must learn how to calculate and compare different rates on various financial instruments.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the time value of money is the foundation for all financial decision-making, from personal savings to corporate investment analysis.
Future Value
Future Value (FV) is the value on some future date of an investment made today. To calculate future value, we multiply the present value by the interest rate and add that amount of interest to the present value.
π Formula: FV = PV + PVi = PV(1+i)
- PV = Present Value
- FV = Future Value
- i = interest rate (as a decimal, e.g., 5% = 0.05)
π Example: $100 invested today at 5% interest for one year FV = $100 + $100(0.05) = $105
The higher the interest rate (or the amount invested), the higher the future value.
When investments have interest payments made for more than one year, we must consider compound interestβthe fact that interest will be paid on interest.
π Formula for compound interest: FVn = PV*(1+i)^n where n is the number of years into the future
π Example: $100 invested at 5% annual interest for two years FV = $100 + $100(0.05) + $100(0.05) + $5(0.05) = $110.25
- Present Value of Initial Investment
- Interest on initial investment in 1st year
- Interest on initial investment in 2nd year
- Interest on the interest from 1st year in 2nd year
π Example: Computing Future Value of $100 at 5% annual interest rate
| Years | Computation | Future Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 100(1.05)^1 | $105.00 |
| 2 | 100(1.05)^2 | $110.25 |
| 3 | 100(1.05)^3 | $115.76 |
| 4 | 100(1.05)^4 | $121.55 |
| 5 | 100(1.05)^5 | $127.63 |
| 10 | 100(1.05)^10 | $162.89 |
Note: Both n and i must be measured in the same time units. If i is annual, then n must be in years. For example, the future value of $100 in 18 months at 5% is: FV = $100*(1.05)^1.5
π Example: Saving $1,000 per year into a bank at 4% interest for 40 years The accumulated amount would be $98,826βmore than twice the $40,000 invested. This works because:
- First $1,000 deposited for 40 years: $1,000 x (1.04)^40 = $4,801.02
- Second $1,000 deposited for 39 years: $1,000 x (1.04)^39 = $4,616.37
- And so on...up to the $1,000 deposited in the 40th year
- Adding all future values gives $98,826
Present Value
Present Value (PV) is the value today (in the present) of a payment that is promised to be made in the future. It is the amount that must be invested today in order to realize a specific amount on a given future date.
To calculate present value, we invert the future value calculation. We divide future value by one plus the interest rate to find the present value of a payment to be made one year from now.
π Formula: PV = FV / (1+i)
π Example: $100 received in one year, with i=5% PV = $100 / (1+0.05) = $95.24
Verification: FV = PV*(1+i) = $95.24*(1.05) = $100
For payments to be made more than one year from now, we divide future value by one plus the interest rate raised to the nth power, where n is the number of years.
π Formula: PV = FV / (1+i)^n
π Example: Present Value of $100 received in 2.5 years with an interest rate of 8% PV = $100 / (1.08)^2.5 = $82.50
Verification: FV = $82.50 * (1.08)^2.5 = $100
β Key Takeaways
The time value of money is the most fundamental concept in financeβinterest compensates lenders for the opportunity cost of not using their money elsewhere during the loan period. Future value calculations (FV = PV*(1+i)^n) show how money grows over time with compound interest, meaning interest earns interest. Present value calculations (PV = FV/(1+i)^n) allow us to determine what a future payment is worth today, which is essential for comparing financial options. Both n and i must be measured in the same time units for accurate calculations. Mastering these basic formulas enables sound financial decisions about saving, borrowing, and investing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is interest considered a "rental fee" rather than "breeding money from money"?
- What is the future value of $500 invested for 3 years at 6% annual interest?
- What is the present value of $1,000 to be received in 5 years at a 4% interest rate?
- If you deposit $200 every year for 30 years at 5% interest, what concept explains why your total savings would be more than $6,000?
- Why must both n and i be measured in the same time units when using the future value formula?
π Lecture 9 β Application of Present Value Concepts
π Overview: This lecture explores practical applications of present value concepts in finance, including how changes in future value, time, and interest rates affect present value calculations. It introduces the Rule of 72 for quick estimation, compound annual rates for comparing growth over different periods, and key applications like internal rate of return and bond pricing that are fundamental to financial decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers important properties of present value including the effects of future value size, payment timing, and interest rates on present value. It introduces the Rule of 72 for estimating doubling time, explains compound annual rates and average annual rates, distinguishes between interest rates and discount rates, and demonstrates applications through internal rate of return and bond pricing.
π Lecture Summary
Important Properties of Present Value
Present Value is higher when the future value of the payment is larger, the time period until payment is shorter, and the interest rate is lower. The size of the payment directly affects present value proportionally β doubling the future value (FV) without changing time or interest rate doubles the present value. For example, at 5% interest rate, a $100 payment has a PV of $90.70, while doubling it to $200 doubles the PV to $181.40. Any percentage change in FVβ changes PV by the same percentage in the same direction.
The time until payment is made has an inverse relationship with present value. Using the example of $100 at 5% interest over 0 to 30 years, the PV starts at $100 if paid immediately and gradually declines to $23 for a payment made in 30 years.
The Rule of 72
For reasonable rates of return, the time it takes to double money is approximately given by t = 72 / i%. At a 10% interest rate, the time for an investment to double is t = 72 / 10 = 7.2 years. This rule applies fairly well to discount rates in the 5% to 20% range.
π‘ Why this matters: The Rule of 72 provides a quick mental calculation for estimating investment growth without needing complex formulas.
The Interest Rate (i)
Higher interest rates are associated with lower present values, regardless of the size or timing of the payment. At any fixed interest rate, increasing the time until a payment is made reduces its present value. The lecture provides a comprehensive table showing present value of a $100 payment at various interest rates and time periods. For instance, at 1% interest, a $100 payment due in 1 year has PV of $99.01, while at 10% interest the same payment has PV of $90.91. At 20 years, the values range from $81.95 at 1% to $6.11 at 15%.
Compound Annual Rates
Comparing changes over different time periods is difficult without standardization. The solution is to turn monthly growth rates into compound-annual rates. An investment growing 0.5% per month from 100 to 100.5 represents a monthly return of 0.5%. However, computing a 12-month compound rate requires the formula: FVβ = PV(1+i)βΏ = 100(1.005)ΒΉΒ² = 106.17, representing a 6.17% increase β greater than the 6% obtained by simply multiplying 0.5% by 12. The difference between these two answers grows as the interest rate grows; at 1% monthly rate, the 12-month compounded rate is 12.68%.
To compute the average annual rate when an investment grows over multiple years, we use the same formula. For an investment increasing 20% from 100 to 120 over 5 years, the average annual rate is not simply 20%/5 = 4% (which ignores compounding). Instead: 120 = 100(1+i)β΅, solving for i = [(120/100)ΒΉ/β΅ - 1] = 0.0371 or 3.71%. Five consecutive annual increases of 3.71% result in an overall increase of 20%.
π Definition β Compound Annual Rate: The annual growth rate that accounts for compounding over multiple periods, calculated using FVβ = PV(1+i)βΏ. π Formula: FVβ = PV(1+i)βΏ β The future value equals the present value multiplied by (1 plus the interest rate) raised to the number of periods. π Example: $100 invested at 0.5% monthly for 12 months: FV = 100(1.005)ΒΉΒ² = $106.17, giving a compound annual rate of 6.17%.
Interest Rate and Discount Rate
The interest rate used in present value calculation is often called the discount rate because it involves discounting or reducing future payments to their equivalent value today. Another term used is yield. Saving behavior can be understood through an individual's personal discount rate β people with a low rate are more likely to save, while those with a high rate are more likely to borrow. Everyone has a discount rate that describes the rate at which they need to be compensated for postponing consumption and saving income. If the market offers an interest rate higher than an individual's personal discount rate, that person will likely save (and vice versa). Higher interest rates generally mean higher saving.
Applying Present Value
To use present value in practice, we examine sequences or streams of payments whose present values must be summed. Present value is additive, meaning the PV of a stream of payments equals the sum of the PVs of each individual payment.
π Definition β Additive Property of Present Value: The present value of a stream of multiple future payments equals the sum of the present values of each individual payment.
Internal Rate of Return
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is the interest rate that equates the present value of an investment with its cost. It is the interest rate at which the present value of the revenue stream equals the cost of the investment project. In the calculation, we solve for the interest rate (i).
For a machine costing $1,000,000 that generates $150,000 per year for 10 years, we solve: $1,000,000 = $150,000/(1+i) + $150,000/(1+i)Β² + ... + $150,000/(1+i)ΒΉβ°
Solving for i gives i = 0.0814 or 8.14%.
The internal rate of return must be compared to the interest rate that represents the cost of funds for the investment. These funds could come from retained earnings or borrowing β in either case there is an interest cost. An investment is profitable if its internal rate of return exceeds the cost of borrowing.
π Definition β Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The interest rate that makes the present value of an investment's future revenue stream equal to its initial cost. π Formula: Cost = Ξ£ [Revenueβ/(1+IRR)α΅] for t = 1 to n β The initial cost equals the sum of discounted future revenues. π Example: Machine costing $1,000,000 with $150,000 annual revenue for 10 years has IRR = 8.14%. If borrowing cost is less than 8.14%, the investment is profitable.
β Key Takeaways
Present value is directly proportional to future value but inversely related to both time until payment and the interest rate β understanding these relationships is essential for all financial valuation. The Rule of 72 (t = 72/i%) provides a quick estimation tool for doubling time that works well for interest rates between 5% and 20%. Compound annual rates must be calculated using the formula FVβ = PV(1+i)βΏ rather than simple multiplication, and the difference becomes more significant at higher interest rates. The internal rate of return is the critical measure for investment decisions β an investment is profitable only when its IRR exceeds the cost of funds. Present value is additive, allowing us to value streams of payments by summing individual present values, which is fundamental to bond pricing and other financial instruments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What three factors determine present value, and how does each affect the present value amount?
- Using the Rule of 72, approximately how many years will it take to double an investment earning 8% annually?
- Why is the compound annual rate for 0.5% monthly growth (6.17%) higher than simply multiplying 0.5% by 12 (6%)?
- How would you calculate the average annual rate for an investment that grew from $500 to $750 over 4 years?
- What condition must be satisfied for an investment to be considered profitable when using internal rate of return analysis?
π Lecture 10 β Bond Pricing & Risk
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental principles of bond pricing, including how to value both principal and coupon payments using present value calculations. It then shifts to understanding real versus nominal interest rates through the Fisher equation, and introduces the concept of risk, its characteristics, and basic measurement using probability and expected value. Understanding bond pricing and risk is crucial for making informed investment decisions and assessing financial market instruments.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers bond pricing mechanics (valuing principal payment, coupon payments, and the total coupon bond), real and nominal interest rates explained through the Fisher equation and illustrated with historical data, and an introduction to risk including its definition, characteristics (quantifiable, future-oriented, investment-specific, time-bound, benchmark-relative), and measurement using probability distributions and expected value calculations with examples.
π Lecture Summary
Bond Pricing
A bond is a promise to make a series of payments on specific future dates. It is a legal contract issued as part of an arrangement to borrow money. The most common type is a coupon bond, which makes annual payments called coupon payments. The percentage rate is called the coupon rate. The bond also specifies a maturity date (n) and has a final payment (F), which is the principal, face value, or par value of the bond. The price of a bond is the present value of its payments. To value a bond, we need to value the repayment of principal and the payments of interest.
Valuing the Principal Payment is a straightforward application of present value where n represents the maturity of the bond. Valuing the Coupon Payments requires calculating the present value of the payments and then adding them; remember, present value is additive. Valuing the Coupon Payments plus Principal means combining the above. Payment stops at the maturity date (n). A payment is for the face value (F) or principle of the bond. Coupon Bonds make annual payments called, Coupon Payments (C), based upon an interest rate, the coupon rate (i_c), C = i_c * F.
For a bond that has a $100 principle payment in n years, the present value (P_BP) of this is now: P_BP = F / (1 + i)^n
If the bond has n coupon payments (C), where C = i_c * F, the Present Value (P_CP) of the coupon payments is: P_CP = C * [1 - (1/(1+i)^n)] / i
Present Value of Coupon Bond (P_CB) = Present value of Yearly Coupon Payments (P_CP) + Present Value of the Principal Payment (P_BP) P_CB = P_CP + P_BP
π Definition β Coupon Bond: A bond that makes annual payments called coupon payments based upon a coupon rate. π Formula: P_CB = P_CP + P_BP β The total price of a coupon bond is the sum of the present value of its coupon payments stream and the present value of its principal repayment. π‘ Why this matters: The value of the coupon bond rises when the yearly coupon payments rise and when the interest rate falls. Lower interest rates mean higher bond prices and vice versa. The value of a bond varies inversely with the interest rate used to discount the promised payments.
Real and Nominal Interest Rates
So far we have been computing the present value using nominal interest rates (i) , or interest rates expressed in current-dollar terms. But inflation affects the purchasing power of a dollar, so we need to consider the real interest rate (r) , which is the inflation-adjusted interest rate. The Fisher equation tells us that the nominal interest rate is equal to the real interest rate plus the expected rate of inflation.
π Definition β Fisher Equation: The nominal interest rate is equal to the real interest rate plus the expected rate of inflation. π Formula: i = r + Ο^e or r = i - Ο^e β The nominal interest rate compensates for both the real return and expected inflation; the real rate is what remains after subtracting expected inflation. π‘ Why this matters: A graph of US data from 1979 to 2003 shows that nominal interest rates and inflation move together over time. A second graph plotting inflation vs. nominal interest rates for various countries (including the US, UK, Turkey, Brazil, Russia, South Africa) shows a positive relationship, with points clustering near a 45-degree line, confirming the Fisher effect across different economies.
Risk
Every day we make decisions that involve financial and economic risk: how much car insurance should we buy, should we refinance the home loan now or a year from now, should we save more for retirement or spend the extra money on a new car. Interestingly enough, the tools we use today to measure and analyze risk were first developed to help players analyze games of chance. For thousands of years, people have played games based on a throw of the dice, but they had little understanding of how those games actually worked. Since the invention of probability theory, we have come to realize that many everyday events, including those in economics, finance, and even weather forecasting, are best thought of as analogous to the flip of a coin or the throw of a die. Still, while experts can make educated guesses about the future path of interest rates, inflation, or the stock market, their predictions are really only thatβguesses. And while meteorologists are fairly good at forecasting the weather a day or two ahead, economists, financial advisors, and business gurus have dismal records. So understanding the possibility of various occurrences should allow everyone to make better choices. While risk cannot be eliminated, it can often be managed effectively. Finally, while most people view risk as a curse to be avoided whenever possible, risk also creates opportunities. The payoff from a winning bet on one hand of cards can often erase the losses on a losing hand. Thus the importance of probability theory to the development of modern financial markets is hard to overemphasize. People require compensation for taking risks. Without the capacity to measure risk, we could not calculate a fair price for transferring risk from one person to another, nor could we price stocks and bonds, much less sell insurance. The market for options didn't exist until economists learned how to compute the price of an option using probability theory. We need a definition of risk that focuses on the fact that the outcomes of financial and economic decisions are almost always unknown at the time the decisions are made.
π Definition β Risk: A measure of uncertainty about the future payoff of an investment, measured over some time horizon and relative to a benchmark.
Characteristics of risk
- Risk can be quantified.
- Risk arises from uncertainty about the future.
- Risk has to do with the future payoff to an investment, which is unknown.
- Our definition of risk refers to an investment or group of investments.
- Risk must be measured over some time horizon.
- Risk must be measured relative to some benchmark, not in isolation.
- If you want to know the risk associated with a specific investment strategy, the most appropriate benchmark would be the risk associated with other investing strategies.
Measuring Risk
Measuring Risk requires:
- List of all possible outcomes
- Chance of each one occurring
The tossing of a coin is a simple example. What are possible outcomes? What is the chance of each one occurring? Is the coin fair?
π Definition β Probability: A measure of likelihood that an event will occur. Its value is between zero and one. The closer probability is to zero, less likely it is that an event will occur. No chance of occurring if probability is exactly zero. The closer probability is to one, more likely it is that an event will occur. The event will definitely occur if probability is exactly one. Probabilities can also be expressed as frequencies.
A Simple Example: All Possible Outcomes of a Single Coin Toss
| Possibilities | Probability | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | 1/2 | Heads |
| #2 | 1/2 | Tails |
We must include all possible outcomes when constructing such a table. The sum of the probabilities of all the possible outcomes must be 1, since one of the possible outcomes must occur (we just don't know which one). To calculate the expected value of an investment, multiply each possible payoff by its probability and then sum all the results. This is also known as the mean.
π Formula: Expected Value = Sum of (Probability Γ Payoff)
Case 1: An Investment can rise or fall in value. Assume that an asset purchased for $1000 is equally likely to fall to $700 or rise to $1400.
Investing $1,000: Case 1
| Possibilities | Probability | Payoff | Payoff Γ Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 1/2 | $700 | $350 |
| #2 | 1/2 | $1,400 | $700 |
| Expected Value | $1,050 |
π Example: Expected Value = Β½ ($700) + Β½ ($1400) = $1050
Case 2: The $1,000 investment might pay off $100 (prob=.1), or $2000 (prob=.1), or $700 (prob=.4), or $1400 (prob=.4).
Investing $1,000: Case 2
| Possibilities | Probability | Payoff | Payoff Γ Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 0.1 | $100 | $10 |
| #2 | 0.4 | $700 | $280 |
| #3 | 0.4 | $1,400 | $560 |
| #4 | 0.1 | $2,000 | $200 |
| Expected Value | $1,050 |
Investment payoffs are usually discussed in percentage returns instead of in dollar amounts; this allows investors to compute the gain or loss on the investment regardless of its size. Though both cases have the same expected return, $50 on a $1000 investment, or 5%, the two investments have different levels or risk. A wider payoff range indicates more risk.
β Key Takeaways
A bond's price is the present value of its future payments, including both the stream of coupon payments and the final principal repayment, and this price varies inversely with market interest rates. The Fisher equation (i = r + Ο^e) demonstrates that nominal interest rates incorporate both a real return and compensation for expected inflation, and historical data across countries confirms this relationship. Risk is defined as quantifiable uncertainty about an investment's future payoff measured over a specific time horizon relative to a benchmark, and it cannot be eliminated but can be managed. To measure risk, one must identify all possible outcomes and their probabilities, then calculate the expected value as the probability-weighted average of all possible payoffs. Investments with the same expected return can have vastly different risk levels, with a wider range of possible payoffs indicating greater risk for the investor.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for the present value of the principal payment on a bond?
- According to the Fisher equation, how is the nominal interest rate (i) related to the real interest rate (r) and expected inflation (Ο^e)?
- What is the relationship between a bond's price and prevailing market interest rates?
- What are the three required elements for measuring risk?
- If an investment of $1,000 has a 60% chance of paying $1,200 and a 40% chance of paying $800, what is its expected value?
π Lecture 11 β Measuring Risk
π Overview: This lecture introduces formal methods for quantifying financial risk, moving beyond intuition to mathematical measurement. It explains variance and standard deviation as measures of outcome spread, value at risk for worst-case assessment, and the critical concepts of risk aversion and risk premium that drive investor behavior and market pricing.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers measuring risk through variance and standard deviation, which calculate the spread of possible outcomes around the expected value. It then introduces Value at Risk (VAR) as a measure of the worst possible loss. Finally, it explains risk aversionβthe human tendency to avoid uncertaintyβand the risk premium, which is the extra return required to compensate for taking on risk.
π Lecture Summary
Measuring Risk
Most people have an intuitive sense of risk: the wider the range of possible outcomes, the greater the risk. A risk-free investment has a future value known with certainty, and its return is the risk-free rate of return. For example, if the risk-free return is 5%, a $1000 risk-free investment will pay exactly $1050βits expected valueβwith certainty. If there is any chance the payoff will be more or less than $1050, the investment is risky. Risk can be measured by the spread among an investmentβs possible outcomes using two main tools: Variance and Standard Deviation (which measure spread) and Value at Risk (VAR) (which measures riskiness of the worst case).
Variance
The variance is defined as the probability-weighted average of the squared deviations of the possible outcomes from their expected value. To calculate variance: (1) Compute the expected value; (2) Subtract the expected value from each possible payoff; (3) Square each result; (4) Multiply each by its probability; (5) Add up the results. For an investment with a Β½ chance of $1400 and a Β½ chance of $700: π Definition β Variance: The probability-weighted average of squared deviations from the expected value. π Formula: Variance = Ξ£ [Probability Γ (Payoff β Expected Value)Β²] π Example: Expected value = ($1400 Γ Β½) + ($700 Γ Β½) = $1050. Deviations: $1400β$1050 = $350; $700β$1050 = β$350. Squared deviations: ($350)Β² = 122,500; (β$350)Β² = 122,500. Weighted average: Β½(122,500) + Β½(122,500) = 122,500 (dollars)Β². So variance = 122,500 (dollars)Β².
Standard Deviation
The standard deviation is the square root of the variance. It is more useful than variance because it is measured in the same units as the payoffs (dollars, not squared dollars). The standard deviation can be converted into a percentage of the initial investment, providing a baseline to compare risk across alternative investments. Given a choice between two investments with the same expected payoff, most people choose the one with the lower standard deviation because it has less risk. π Formula: Standard Deviation = β(Variance) π Example: For the investment above, Standard Deviation = β122,500 = $350. For a second investment with variance 278,784, Standard Deviation = β278,784 β $528. The greater the standard deviation ($528 > $350), the higher the risk.
Value at Risk
Sometimes investors are less concerned with the spread of all possible outcomes than with the value of the worst outcome. For this, we use Value at Risk (VAR). Value at risk measures risk by stating the maximum potential loss under normal conditions. π Definition β Value at Risk (VAR): A measure of risk that calculates the maximum potential loss an investment could suffer, given a specific time horizon and confidence level.
Risk Aversion
Most people do not like risk and will pay to avoid it; most of us are risk averse. A risk-averse investor will always prefer an investment with a certain return to one with the same expected return but any amount of uncertainty. Buying insurance is an example of paying someone to take our risks. Therefore, if someone wants us to take on risk, we must be compensated to do so. π‘ Why this matters: Risk aversion is the fundamental psychological driver behind the trade-off between risk and return that governs all financial markets.
Risk Premium
The risk premium is the compensation investors require for holding a risky investment. The riskier the investment, the higher the risk premium. Riskier investments must therefore have higher expected returns. This creates a fundamental trade-off between risk and expected return: you cannot get a high return without taking considerable risk. π Definition β Risk Premium: The excess return (difference between expected return on a risky investment and the risk-free return) that investors require as compensation for bearing risk. π Formula: Risk Premium = Expected Return on Risky Investment β Risk-Free Return π Figure: The Trade-off between Risk and Expected Return shows that as risk (measured horizontally) increases, expected return (measured vertically) increases. The risk-free return is the baseline at zero risk. The risk premium is the vertical distance between the risk-free return and the expected return on the risky investment.
β Key Takeaways
Risk is formally measured by the spread of possible outcomes, with variance and standard deviation quantifying this spread. Standard deviation is preferred because it is in the same units as the payoff. Value at Risk (VAR) measures the worst-case loss rather than the full spread. Most investors are risk averse, meaning they require compensation to bear risk. This compensation is the risk premium, which is the extra expected return above the risk-free rate. The fundamental trade-off in finance is that higher expected returns require accepting higher risk.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Explain the steps to calculate the variance of an investment with two possible outcomes.
- Why is standard deviation more useful than variance for comparing risk across investments?
- How does Value at Risk (VAR) differ from variance as a measure of risk?
- What does it mean to be "risk averse," and how does this affect the investments people choose?
- If the risk-free return is 4% and a risky investment has an expected return of 12%, what is the risk premium?
π Lecture 12 β Evaluating Risk
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of risk evaluation and management in financial decision-making. It covers how to assess whether a risk is worth taking, distinguishes between idiosyncratic and systematic risks, and explains practical strategiesβhedging and spreadingβfor reducing risk through diversification. The lesson also touches on bonds and bond pricing as applications of these principles.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Sources of risk are classified as either idiosyncratic (unique to a small group) or systematic (affecting everyone). Risk evaluation involves listing possible payoffs, assigning probabilities, and comparing willingness-to-pay for gains versus avoidance of losses. Diversification reduces overall risk, achievable through hedging (investing in two assets with opposing risks) or spreading (investing in multiple unrelated assets). The lecture concludes with an introduction to bond and bond pricing concepts.
π Lecture Summary
Evaluating Risk
The lecture revisits an example of investing $1,000 that yields either $1,400 or $700 with equal probability. This investment offers an equal chance of gaining $400 or losing $300. Deciding whether to take the risk requires a systematic approach.
Table: Evaluating the Risk of a $1,000 investment
- A. The Gain: Payoff +$400 with probability Β½; $0 with probability Β½
- B. The Loss: Payoff $0 with probability Β½; -$300 with probability Β½
π Deciding if a risk is worth taking involves these steps:
- List all possible outcomes or payoffs
- Assign a probability to each possible payoff
- Divide the payoffs into gains and losses
- Ask how much you would be willing to pay to receive the gain
- Ask how much you would be willing to pay to avoid the loss
- If you are willing to pay more to receive the gain than to avoid the loss, you should take the risk
Sources of Risk
Risk is everywhere and comes in many forms. Regardless of the source, risks can be classified into two types:
- Idiosyncratic (unique) risks: Affect only a small number of people. For example, higher oil prices would affect specific industries or companies.
- Systematic risks: Affect everyone. For example, changes in general economic conditions impact the entire economy.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding this classification helps investors and policymakers decide whether a risk can be diversified away (idiosyncratic) or must be managed at a macro level (systematic).
Reducing Risk through Diversification
Risk can be reduced through diversification, the principle of holding more than one risk at a time. Holding several different investments reduces the overall risk an investor bears. A combination of risky investments is often less risky than any one individual investment. There are two ways to diversify:
- Hedging risks
- Spreading risks among many investments
Hedging Risk
Hedging is the strategy of reducing overall risk by making two investments with opposing risks. When one investment does poorly, the other does well, and vice versa. While the payoff from each investment is volatile, together their payoffs are stable.
Table: Payoffs on Two Separate Investments of $100
| Possibility | ABC Electric | XYZ Oil | Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oil price rises | $100 | $120 | 1/2 |
| Oil price falls | $120 | $100 | 1/2 |
Let's compare three strategies for investing $100:
- Invest $100 in ABC Electric
- Invest $100 in XYZ Oil
- Invest half in each company β $50 in ABC and $50 in XYZ
Table: Results of Possible Investment Strategies: Hedging Risk Initial Investment = $100
| Investment Strategy | Expected Payoff | Standard Deviation |
|---|---|---|
| ABC Only | $110 | $10 |
| XYZ Only | $110 | $10 |
| Β½ and Β½ | $110 | $0 |
π Example: By investing $50 in ABC and $50 in XYZ, the standard deviation drops to $0, meaning the combined payoff is perfectly stable despite each individual investment being risky. This is because the two investments move in opposite directions.
Spreading Risk
Investments don't always move predictably in opposite directions, so you can't always reduce risk through hedging. You can lower risk by simply spreading it around and finding investments whose payoffs are completely unrelated. The more independent sources of risk you hold, the lower your overall risk. Adding more and more independent sources of risk reduces the standard deviation until it becomes negligible.
Consider three investment strategies: a. ABC Electric only b. EFG Soft only c. Half in ABC and half in EFG
The expected payoff on each of these strategies is the same: $110. For the first two strategies ($100 in either company), the standard deviation is still 10. For the third strategy ($50 in ABC and $50 in EFG), the analysis is more complicated because there are four possible outcomes.
Table: Payoffs from Investing $50 in each of two Stocks Initial Investment = $100
| Possibilities | ABC | EFG Soft | Total Payoff | Probability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | $60 | $60 | $120 | ΒΌ |
| #2 | $60 | $50 | $110 | ΒΌ |
| #3 | $50 | $60 | $110 | ΒΌ |
| #4 | $50 | $50 | $100 | ΒΌ |
Table: Results of Possible Investment Strategies: Spreading Risk Initial Investment = $100
| Investment Strategy | Expected Payoff | Standard Deviation |
|---|---|---|
| ABC | $110 | $10 |
| EFG Soft | $110 | $10 |
| Β½ and Β½ | $110 | $7.1 |
π Example: Spreading the investment between ABC and EFG Soft reduces the standard deviation from $10 to $7.1, showing that even without perfect hedging, diversification lowers risk.
Bond and Bond Pricing
(The lecture outline mentions this topic, but the provided text does not contain detailed content on bond and bond pricing.)
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that diversification is a powerful tool for reducing investment risk without sacrificing expected returns. Risk must first be classified as idiosyncratic (affecting few) or systematic (affecting everyone) to determine the appropriate management strategy. Hedging is possible only when two investments have perfectly opposing payoffs, while spreading risk across many unrelated investments steadily reduces standard deviation. The decision to take a risk depends on comparing your willingness to pay for potential gains versus your willingness to pay to avoid potential losses. Finally, standard deviation is a key measure of risk that can be dramatically reduced, but not eliminated, through diversification.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two classifications of sources of risk, and how do they differ in terms of who they affect?
- List the six steps for deciding whether a risk is worth taking.
- What is the difference between hedging and spreading as strategies for diversification?
- In the hedging example, why did the standard deviation become $0 when investing half in ABC Electric and half in XYZ Oil?
- In the spreading risk example, why did the standard deviation drop from $10 to $7.1 even though the two stocks' payoffs were not perfectly opposed?