π Lecture Summary
Background
The institution of budget originated in the West as a tool for representative government to control the monarchy's spending. The principle "No budget without representation" established that the executive must produce a complete plan of income and expenditure annually for parliament's approval. This budget is a document of future government plans addressing public needs, requiring public representatives to approve public expenditure.
Performance Budgeting
After World War II, performance budgeting was introduced following the first Hoover Commission (USA), which noted that the 1949-1950 budget contained 1,625 pages but lacked clarity on work to be completed. The commission recommended the budget should indicate "functions, activities, and projects" to be completed. In 1949, the US Parliament approved an amendment to the National Security Act allowing performance budgeting in the Defense Department.
π‘ Why this matters: Performance budgeting shifted focus from simply listing items to showing what work would be accomplished, but it failed to take off because proposed expenditures still lacked justification for why certain purposes were chosen over others.
π Definition β Performance Budget: A budget in which the activities and functions of a project are separately shown and for each activity an amount is allocated.
Planning-Programming-Budgeting (PPB)
Planning-Programming-Budgeting (PPB) was an innovation of the 1960s attempting to integrate budgeting with overall government planning. Unlike performance budgeting, which emphasized work plans within existing agency objectives, PPB focused on reconsidering goals and determining policies through comprehensive, long-range planning. PPB advocates argued that previous budgeting was disjointed, with little attention to weighing alternative goals, programs, and projects. PPB originated in industry (General Motors, 1924) and was later developed by the Rand Corporation for the US Department of Defense during the 1950s.
π Definition β Planning-Programming-Budgeting: Budget and overall plan are integrated into a single rational system.
Zero-Base Budgeting (ZBB)
Zero-Base Budgeting (ZBB) was introduced in the 1970s, developed by Peter A. Phyrr at Texas Instruments Company. Its characteristics include: (1) consideration of a reduced level of expenditure below the current level, and (2) alternative levels of expenditure for decision units (the lowest-level program or organizational entity for which budgets are prepared).
In conventional budgeting, the next period's budget is prepared by increasing a percentage of the existing budget. In ZBB, the budget for next year is presumed to be zero, and estimates are worked fresh from the beginning.
π Example: If the previous year's budget was Rs. 200,000, when preparing next year's budget, all items are presumed to be at minimum or zero level, and new estimates are worked out from there.
Incremental Budget
An incremental budget is based on the last year's actual expenditure figures, which are increased and included in the next year's budget figures.
π Example: Last year expenditure = 100,000. Current year budget with 10% increase in oil price = 110,000. The incremental budget reflects an increase in the price of goods and services at a percentage included in the next year's budget.
Medium Term Budgetary Framework (MTBF)
Medium Term Budgetary Framework (MTBF) is based on medium-term projection of expenditure, usually three years. All government departments must give three-year projections of expenditure, creating a framework for which income and expenditure are worked out. This type of budget is very useful where there is political and economic stability.
The Federal Consolidated Fund
The Federal Consolidated Fund is the Fund of the federal government that contains all revenues received, all loans, and all money received in repayment of loans. Article 78 of the Constitution of Pakistan explains the Federal Consolidated Fund. The payment of money into the fund, withdrawal, and custody are regulated by the Act of Parliament. All expenditures are incurred only with parliamentary approval.
Annual Budget Statement
The Annual Budget Statement is prepared every year by the Federal Government, showing estimated receipts and expenditure. The statement separately shows: a) 'Charged expenditure' β sums required to meet expenditure described by the Constitution as expenditure charged upon the Federal Consolidated Fund. These include the salary of the President, expenditures relating to his office, salaries of Judges, Chief Election Commissioner, Chairman and Deputy Chairman Senate, and repayment of loans. Charged expenditures are discussed in the Assembly but not voted by the Assembly. b) The sums required to meet other expenditure proposed from the Fund.
Budget Preparation
The major responsibility for preparing the Annual Budget rests with the Ministry of Finance. In October every year, the Ministry asks ministries/departments/autonomous bodies to submit their estimates for the following year. The financial year begins 1st July and ends 30th June. All budget estimates are finalized before 30th May, and the Budget is presented to the National Assembly by the Finance Minister in the middle of June.
The 'Budget Call' requires separate estimates for:
- Receipts of the organization
- Non-development expenditure
- Development expenditure
Details required about receipts include: main heads of revenue, capital receipts, foreign aid, and debt/deposits/remittances.
Development expenditure is expenditure on new projects and equipment. Non-development expenditure is recurring expenditure including salaries, utilities, and day-to-day running costs.
Projects included in the budget must be approved by the relevant body according to the size of project investment:
- NEC (National Economic Council)
- ECNEC (Executive Committee of the National Economic Council)
- CDWP (Central Development Working Party) β for foreign-assisted projects > 20m
- DDWP (Departmental Development Working Party) β for projects up to 20m
Expenditure Authorization
When the budget is ready, the Finance Minister presents it to the National Assembly for authorization. Expenditure authorization means the Assembly approves expenditure that can be made from the budget. This approval is for one year only. The budget is discussed in the Assembly, which gives assent to spend.
π Example: Federal Budget 2000-2001 showed:
- Revenue Receipt: 460,600
- Tax Revenue, Surcharge, Non-tax revenue: 153,793
- Capital Receipt: 44,169
- Total Internal Resources: 856,625
- External Resources: 198,063
- Total Resources: 1,054,688
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) the budget originated as a democratic control mechanism requiring parliamentary approval for all government expenditure; (2) there are five major types of budgets β Performance Budgeting (focuses on activities and functions), PPB (integrates planning with budgeting), ZBB (starts from zero each year), Incremental Budget (adds a percentage to last year's figures), and MTBF (uses three-year projections); (3) in Pakistan, the Federal Consolidated Fund holds all government revenues, and the Annual Budget Statement distinguishes between 'charged expenditure' (not voted) and other expenditure (voted by the Assembly); (4) budget preparation begins in October, with the financial year running July-June, and projects require approval from NEC, ECNEC, CDWP, or DDWP depending on investment size; and (5) expenditure authorization by the National Assembly is for one year only.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What was the key principle asserted during the struggle for representative government in England regarding the budget?
-
How does Zero-Base Budgeting (ZBB) differ from Incremental Budgeting in terms of how next year's estimates are prepared?
-
What is the difference between 'charged expenditure' and other expenditure in the context of the Annual Budget Statement?
-
Which constitutional article in Pakistan explains the Federal Consolidated Fund, and what does this fund contain?
-
Why did Performance Budgeting ultimately fail to take off in the United States, according to the lecture?
π Lecture 29 β National Finance Commission
π Overview: This lecture examines fiscal federalism and the National Finance Commission (NFC) of Pakistan. It explains how tax collection and resource distribution are structured between the federal government and provinces, covering both vertical and horizontal distribution criteria, and details the specific provisions of the 1990 NFC Award.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers fiscal federalism defined and its basic framework, the constitutional basis and composition of the National Finance Commission according to Article 160 of the 1973 Constitution, the concept of the "divisible pool" of taxes, vertical resource distribution criteria between federation and provinces, horizontal resource distribution criteria among provinces using population and multiple criteria, and a detailed breakdown of the NFC 1990 Award including provincial shares, grants, and revenue from hydro power, gas, and oil.
π Lecture Summary
Fiscal Federalism Defined
Fiscal federalism is the distribution of fiscal functions and the tax collection and distribution of resources among constituent units of a federation. It deals with which taxes are collected by the federation and which by the provinces. The federation is responsible for distributive and regulative functions, while the allocation function is devolved to constituent units.
The basic framework of federalism comprises:
- Constitutional jurisdiction of units of government must be respected, meaning the legislative list must be adhered to, with financial and administrative autonomy for federating units while certain functions are retained by the federation.
- A strong and continuous system of conflict resolution and consensus building on national issues is required to resolve differences in resource sharing among provinces.
- Sub-national governments should be involved in national decision-making processes.
- A lean federal structure β i.e., a flatter organizational structure.
Federalism is a mechanism to achieve unity within a population characterized by diversity in culture, race, size, resources, and population. It refers to the territorial organization of a political community with two or more spheres and levels of government combining self-rule and shared-rule.
π Definition β Fiscal federalism: the distribution of fiscal functions and tax collection/distribution of resources among constituent units of a federation, determining which taxes are federal and which are provincial.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding fiscal federalism explains why some taxes are shared between national and provincial governments while others are not, which directly impacts public service delivery and regional development.
National Finance Commission (NFC)
According to Article 160(1) of the Constitution of Pakistan (1973), the National Finance Commission is constituted. The NFC is a temporary body that decides the criteria on the basis of which taxes collected by the Federal Government are distributed between the Federation and Provinces and among provinces.
The Constitution states: "Within six months of the commencing day and thereafter at intervals not exceeding five years, the President shall constitute a National Finance Commission consisting of: the Minister of Finance of the Federal Government, the Minister of Finance of Provincial Governments, and such other persons as may be appointed by the President after consultation with the Governors of the Provinces."
π Definition β National Finance Commission (NFC): a temporary constitutional body that decides the criteria for distributing taxes collected by the federal government between the federation and provinces and among provinces.
Article 160(2) specifies the following taxes as part of the "divisible pool": i) Taxes on income, including corporation tax, but not including taxes on income consisting of remuneration paid out of the Federal Consolidated Fund ii) Taxes on the sales and purchases of goods imported, exported, produced, manufactured or consumed iii) Export duties on cotton, and such other export duties as may be specified by the President iv) Such duties of excise as may be specified by the President v) Such other taxes as may be specified by the President
The Fourth Schedule, Article 70(4) of the 1973 Constitution gives the Federal Legislative list. Items 43 to 54 delineate all federal taxes. Notably, more taxes have been included in the divisible pool over time, such as general sales tax (formerly provincial) and octroi tax (formerly a district tax).
The two lists β Federal Legislative list and Concurrent list β define functions performed by the Federal Government alone and functions performed by both Federal and Provincial Governments.
Criteria of Vertical Resource Distribution
From the Divisible Pool, resources are shared between Federation and provinces. This is called vertical resource distribution β the distribution of resources from the federal government to provincial governments from the divisible pool.
Vertical distribution is based on three factors: defence, debt servicing, and social action programme. Using these criteria, the Federal Government gives 37.55% to the provinces and retains the rest for running its expenditure.
π Definition β Vertical resource distribution: the sharing of resources from the divisible pool between the federal government and provincial governments.
π Example: Using vertical distribution criteria (defence, debt servicing, social action programme), the federal government allocates 37.55% of the divisible pool to provinces and retains the remainder for federal expenditures.
Criteria of Horizontal Resource Distribution
Horizontal resource distribution is the distribution of the 37.55% provincial share amongst the provinces. The criteria used is 'Population'. However, the use of this single criterion is debatable, and there is a general lack of agreement on it.
π Definition β Horizontal resource distribution: the distribution of the provincial share of the divisible pool among the individual provinces.
Multiple Criteria
Since population is the sole criterion for horizontal distribution, Balochistan, NWFP, and Sindh disagree because Punjab has the largest population and therefore gets maximum advantage. It is suggested that multiple criteria should be used instead.
The proposed multiple criteria are:
- Population
- Distance of per capita income
- Area
- Index of infrastructure
- Tax effort
Countries with federal structures typically use multiple criteria.
π‘ Why this matters: Single-criterion distribution based on population favors larger provinces. Multiple criteria ensure a more equitable distribution, considering factors like poverty, area, and infrastructure needs.
NFC 1990
After every five years, the NFC is constituted by the Federal government and announces an "Award" β i.e., how resources should be shared. According to the 1990 Award, the Divisible Pool comprised:
- Divisible Pool: a) Income and Corporate Tax b) Sales Tax c) Export Duty on Cotton d) Excise Duty on Tobacco & Tobacco manufactures e) Excise Duty on Sugar
It was announced that the Divisible Pool be distributed between the Federation and Provinces in the ratio of 20:80 β 20% retained by Federation and 80% divided amongst provinces.
The Provincial Shares were:
- Punjab: 57.88%
- Sindh: 23.28%
- N.W.F.P: 13.54%
- Baluchistan: 5.30%
-
According to NFC 1990, a Special Annual Grant of Rs. 700 million and Rs. 1000 million was given to Sindh and Punjab respectively. Subventions to N.W.F.P. and Baluchistan for three years at the rate of Rs. 200 and Rs. 100 million respectively.
-
Net Profit on generation of Hydro Power Stations located in the provinces would be guaranteed by the Federal Government, meaning profits from hydro power generation go to the province where the power generation house is located.
-
Net Proceeds of Gas Development Surcharge on production basis at well heads after deduction of 2% collection charges.
-
The royalty and excise duty on oil and gas according to production.
-
The practice of giving deficit grants and picking surpluses was discontinued.
-
Sales tax at retail level was entrusted to the Provinces.
π Example: Under NFC 1990 Award, from the divisible pool (income/corporate tax, sales tax, export duty on cotton, excise duty on tobacco and sugar), 80% went to provinces. Punjab received 57.88% of that 80% shareβthe highest due to its larger populationβwhile Balochistan received only 5.30%.
β Key Takeaways
Fiscal federalism is the constitutional framework for dividing taxing powers and distributing resources between the federation and provinces. In Pakistan, the National Finance Commission is constituted under Article 160 of the 1973 Constitution every five years to determine the Award for resource sharing. The divisible pool includes federal taxes like income tax, sales tax, and excise duties, which are shared vertically (20% federation, 80% provinces based on defence, debt servicing, and social action criteria) and horizontally among provinces using population as the primary criterion. The 1990 Award gave Punjab 57.88%, Sindh 23.28%, NWFP 13.54%, and Balochistan 5.30% of the provincial share, plus additional special grants and subventions. There is ongoing debate about moving from a single population-based criterion to multiple criteria (including area, poverty, infrastructure, and tax effort) for more equitable distribution.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is fiscal federalism and what are the four components of its basic framework?
- Under which Article of the 1973 Constitution is the NFC constituted, and what taxes are included in the divisible pool?
- What is the difference between vertical resource distribution and horizontal resource distribution?
- According to the NFC 1990 Award, what was the distribution ratio between Federation and provinces, and what were the provincial percentage shares?
- Why do smaller provinces like Balochistan and NWFP disagree with using population as the sole criterion for horizontal distribution, and what multiple criteria have been suggested as alternatives?
π Lecture 30 β Administrative Control
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of administrative accountability and the mechanisms through which public officials are held responsible for their actions. It distinguishes between internal and external controls, explaining how hierarchy, budgets, legislatures, and courts ensure that government administration operates within established legal and procedural frameworks. Understanding these controls is essential for grasping how democratic systems maintain checks on executive power.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining administrative accountability as the formal location of responsibility vested in public officials, and distinguishes it from the more personal and moral concept of responsibility. It then explains control as a process of ensuring activities conform to standards, using a four-step cycle. The main body details internal control mechanisms (hierarchy, annual confidential reports, budgetary control, and administrative leadership) and external control mechanisms (legislative control through questions, resolutions, debates, and committees, as well as executive control methods). The lecture concludes with judicial control and the two systems of legal remedies: the Rule of Law system and the Administrative Law system.
π Lecture Summary
Administrative Accountability
According to Leonard D. White, accountability is 'the sum total of constitutional, statutory, administrative and judicial rules and precedents and the established practices by means of which public officials may be held accountable for their official actions'. It refers to the formal and specific location of responsibility vested in a person. While responsibility has personal and moral connotations and is not necessarily related to formal status and power, accountability is also defined as the answerability of a person in an organization.
The Meaning of Control
Accountability is a kind of management control. Control is the process of ensuring that actual activities conform to established standards and laid down procedures. Control helps managers to monitor the effectiveness of managers.
Figure 1 shows the basic control process, which is essential to accountability. Before the control process is initiated, standards and methods are established against which performance is measured. Then performance is measured or assessed to see if it matches the laid down standard. If it matches, performance is satisfactory; but if it does not match, corrective actions are taken. This is a general process of control and accountability that can be adapted to any work situation.
π Definition β Control: a process of ensuring the actual activities conform to established standards.
Types of Accountability
There are two types of accountability mechanisms that make organizations continue to achieve goals:
- Internal Control: is exercised either by superior over the subordinates within the chain of hierarchy or by other parallel agencies in the executive branch of government. It consists of directing, regulating, supervising, advising, inspecting and evaluating. It should be continuously done, without being felt. This mechanism of accountability has positive results also.
- External Control: is fitted outside the administrative machinery and works within the general constitutional framework of the system. It is exercised by external bodies such as legislature and judiciary.
(A) Internal Control Methods
i) Administrative Process: In a parliamentary system, the cabinet stands at the apex of the executive. The Prime Minister directs the ministers, who are in-charge of their respective departments and are responsible for efficient working to the cabinet and Prime Minister. The whole working of the departments is reviewed by the Prime Minister and his Cabinet.
ii) Hierarchical Order: Every administrative department is arranged on a scalar pattern and executives are organized in hierarchical order. Executives are linked with superior-subordinate-relationship with clear authority and responsibility. They are accountable to their respective superiors for their actions and dealings. Thus, hierarchy itself is a powerful instrument for monitoring subordinate behavior and for enforcing accountability.
iii) Annual Confidential Reports: The superior officers prepare annual confidential reports (ACRs) of their subordinates every year. The work of the whole year of each public servant is assessed.
iv) Budgetary Control: A budget is not only a complete policy statement of the total activities of the government but also reflects the aspiration of the people. The Ministry of Finance prepares the budget and operations of the budgetary sanctions and appropriations.
v) Administrative Leadership: This is another means of internal control. Leadership motivates and inspires employees for efficiency. The morale and motivation of employees depends upon leadership. The effective leader sets examples of high standards of integrity and performance for his followers. He inspires them for work and instills in them a pride in work. A good leader is objective-oriented and always tries to help his subordinates achieve that objective.
π Definition β Hierarchical order: a type of internal control in which individuals are supervised by superiors.
(B) External Control Methods
-
Legislative Control: The major instrument of public accountability is the authority of the legislature to empower, limit, investigate and censure the executive branch. The legislature enacts laws, authorizes administrators to engage in quasi-legislative and quasi-judicial activities, appropriates funds for all administrative programmes, and determines the general outlines of administrative organization and procedure.
-
Questions: The first hour of every day's sitting of the legislature is known as the question-hour. This time is allotted for asking and answering questions. Every legislator, after giving due notice, is entitled to put questions and supplementary questions to the ministers about the state of public administration. The ministers are bound to answer these questions. The purpose of questions is to elicit information on the working of administrative departments.
-
Resolutions and Motions: Resolutions and motions are of two kinds: first, those whose object is to censure a particular minister or government as a whole (which leads to dismissal of the government or ministry); second, those which recommend some course of action to be adopted (these are recommendatory and may or may not be accepted by the government). Members of parliament are entitled to pass resolutions on matters of general public interest.
-
Debates and Discussions: Debates or discussions in the House constitute another important means for controlling the executive. Discussion takes place over every point of a bill or budget. The inaugural address of the President, the budget speech, introduction of a bill for amendment, introduction of new law, or introduction of motion or resolution provide opportunities for debates and discussions.
-
Committees of Legislature: Legislatures are unwieldy bodies and cannot meet for the whole year. Hence, they appoint committees of their own members who are specialists in their sphere of activity and keep constant watch over administration. Examples include the Public Accounts Committee, Committee on Subordinate Legislation, Petitions Committee, and Committee on Public Service. These committees gather a lot of material, hear expert evidence, and frame conclusions in the form of recommendations. Such recommendations correct the tone of administration by improving efficiency and quality of work. The civil service responds immediately to the recommendations of such committees because they know their opinions are from experts and backed by the full house.
π Definition β Legislative control: the control exercised by the legislature through the system of question hours, resolutions and motions, debates and discussions.
Methods of Executive Control
The executive exercises control over administration through the following methods: i. Policy-Making: The chief executive along with his cabinet controls the administration through policy-making. All important policy-decisions are taken by the cabinet in every country. The departments carry on their day-to-day business within the policies laid down by cabinet. ii. Budgetary System: It is the main responsibility of the chief executive to prepare the budget and present it to the legislature. After approval by the legislature, the chief executive implements it through the allocation of funds among various departments and controls it by proper utilization of funds. iii. Recruitment System: The third system of executive control works through recruitments of public personnel. This is usually placed in the hands of an independent recruiting agency like the Public Service Commission.
Judicial Control
The judiciary is one of the important external agencies that exercises control over administration. By judicial control means the power of courts to keep the decisions and acts of administrative officials within the bounds of law. L.D. White explains the importance of judicial control: βThe system of formal external control officials and their acts falls primarily into two divisions β that exercised by the legislative bodies and that imposed by the courts.β The main purpose of judicial control is to determine the constitutionality and legality of administrative acts of public administrators, and thus to protect the rights and liberty of citizens from the wrongful acts of government officials.
Types of Remedies
There are two systems of legal remedies against the unlawful acts of government officials.
(a) Rule of Law System: Theoretically it means that everybody, high or low, official or private, is subject to the same law. The public administrator is not above the law while performing official duties. Ordinarily, the aggrieved party shall have all those legal remedies against the offending officials which are known as prerogative writs. This system prevails in the USA, England, and Commonwealth countries including Pakistan.
(b) Administrative Law (Droit Administratif): This system prevails chiefly in France, Germany, and Sweden.
β Key Takeaways
Accountability is the formal answerability of public officials, enforced through a control process of establishing standards, measuring performance, and taking corrective action. Internal controls operate within the executive branch through hierarchy (superior-subordinate relationships), annual confidential reports (ACRs), budgetary control, and administrative leadership. External controls come from the legislature (through question hour, resolutions, debates, and expert committees like the Public Accounts Committee) and from the judiciary (through judicial review of administrative actions). The executive also controls administration through policy-making, the budgetary system, and independent recruitment agencies like the Public Service Commission. Ultimately, citizens are protected from unlawful administrative acts by legal remedies, with the Rule of Law system prevailing in Pakistan, which subjects all officials to the same laws and provides prerogative writs as legal remedies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between accountability and responsibility as defined in the lecture?
- What are the four basic steps in the control process, and how do they ensure accountability?
- Name and explain three methods of internal control used within administrative organizations.
- What is the purpose of the "question hour" in a legislature, and how does it serve as an external control mechanism?
- What are the two systems of legal remedies against unlawful acts of government officials, and which system prevails in Pakistan?
π Lecture 31 β AUDIT
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of audit as a specialized area of financial management and control, focusing on its application in government. It explores the definitions of audit, the constitutional role of the Auditor General of Pakistan, and the critical distinction between traditional financial audit and Performance Audit. The lecture emphasizes the "value for money" framework and its three core componentsβeconomy, efficiency, and effectivenessβexplaining how public money should be managed prudently.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining audit and its role in government, citing Article 169 of the Constitution regarding the Auditor General's functions. It then explains the use of public money and the fundamental principle of spending it carefully. The core of the lecture is an in-depth exploration of Performance Audit and "value for money," providing formal definitions and dissecting the three key dimensions: economy, efficiency, and effectiveness, with illustrative examples. Finally, it outlines the primary and secondary objectives of performance audit.
π Lecture Summary
Concept of Audit & Audit in Government
Audit is a specialized area of financial management whose instruments of control are government rules, regulations, and procedures which must be adhered to when making financial transactions. It is an examination and verification of financial and accounting records by a professional. This formal examination of an organization's accounts may also include compliance checks with applicable award terms, laws, regulations, and policies. The examination covers documents, records, reports, systems of internal control, accounting procedures, and other evidence to determine the propriety, legality, and mathematical accuracy of transactions, to ascertain whether all have been recorded, and to ensure they are accurately reflected in accounts per accepted accounting principles.
π Definition β Audit: The examination of documents, records, reports, systems of internal control, accounting procedures, and other evidence for purposes including determining the propriety, legality, and mathematical accuracy of transactions; ascertaining if all transactions are recorded; and determining if transactions are accurately reflected in accounts.
Article 169 of the Constitution gives the functions of the Auditor General, who heads the Audit & Accounts organization of the Government of Pakistan. Under the Audit & Accounts Order 1973, this organization ensures that public money is spent and transactions are made in accordance with financial rules. The accounts of the federation and provinces must be kept according to the principles and methods given in the order and must be submitted to the President (for federation) or Governors (for provinces), who will place them before the respective assemblies.
Use of Public Money
Public money is the money from tax and non-tax revenue and borrowed money. This money must be spent according to laid-down procedures (the Drawing and Disbursing Handbook). The fundamental principle of spending public money is to spend it in a manner as one would spend one's own money.
π‘ Why this matters: This principle underscores the fiduciary duty of public officials and the ethical foundation of government financial management.
Definition of Performance Audit and Value for Money
While traditional audit is like a "post mortem," verifying whether rules were adhered to after a transaction has taken place, in Performance Audit the whole working of the organization is analyzed. Performance audits are value for money audits, examining the use of resources by public sector organizations in relation to achievement of goals. This can apply to activities involving considerable resources, projects at risk of failing, and issues of concern to Parliament or the Public Accounts Committee (a parliamentary committee that reviews accounts of all government organizations yearly).
π Definition β Performance Audit: "An objective and systematic examination of a public sector organizationβs programme, activity, function or management systems and procedures to provide an assessment of whether the entity, in the pursuit of predetermined goals, has achieved economy, efficiency and effectiveness in the utilization of its resources."
The term "value for money" refers to the way resources (financial, human, or physical) have been allocated and utilized by the entity.
Economy
Economy is concerned with minimizing the cost of resources used (staff, materials, and equipment) for an activity in the pursuit of its objectives, in accordance with sound administrative principles and practices. An economical organization acquires its input resources of the appropriate quality and quantity at the lowest cost. In summary, economy means spending economically, whilst maintaining qualityβi.e., minimizing the cost of resources used for an activity, having regard to quality.
π Example 1: Where standard items such as school or hospital supplies of a given quality are purchased at the best possible price. π Example 2: Cost of a vehicle in comparison with another model of similar quality.
Efficiency
Efficiency is concerned with the relationship between goods and services produced (the outputs) and the resources used to produce them (the inputs). An efficient entity produces the maximum output from any given set of inputs, or alternatively requires minimum input. This is reflected in increased productivity and lower unit costs. In summary, efficiency means spending wellβensuring that maximum output of goods and services has been gained from the resources used in their production.
π Example 1: Efficiency has improved when the unit cost of teaching children or providing hospital treatment has been reduced over time; or where more children have been taught or hospital beds provided, without additional resources. π Example 2: Reduction in repairs and maintenance cost of equipment (e.g., vehicles, computers, photocopiers) is a measure of efficiency.
Effectiveness
Effectiveness is concerned with achieving predetermined objectives (specific planned achievements) or goals and with actual impact (the output achieved) compared with the intended impact (the objectives). Using performance measures and indicators, an entity's effectiveness can be assessed. In summary, effectiveness means spending wiselyβensuring that the desired results, objectives, targets, or policies have been successfully achieved.
π Example 1: Where there has been an improvement in school examination results or where sickness rates have fallen as a result of medical care. π Example 2: Whether the purchased item or service provided was "fit for purpose."
The lecture provides a model (Figure 1) showing the relationship: Economy relates to plan inputs and actual input use; these resources are processed, producing actual outputs; Effectiveness measures whether those outputs achieve policy objectives; Efficiency measures the relationship between actual inputs and actual outputs during the process.
In practice, the boundaries between economy, efficiency, and effectiveness are seldom clear-cut. Examinations of Value For Money (VFM) therefore normally pursue these various aspects of performance simultaneously.
Objectives of Performance Audit
The primary objective of performance audit is to provide parliament with independent information, assurance, and opinion about economy, efficiency, and effectiveness in major fields of revenue, expenditure, and the management of resources.
A secondary objective of performance audit is to identify ways of improving value for money and to encourage and assist audit bodies to take the necessary action to improve systems and controls.
β Key Takeaways
Audit is a formal, professional examination of financial records ensuring compliance with rules, while Performance Audit goes further by analyzing an organization's entire working to assess value for money. The core distinction in Performance Audit lies in the "3 Es": economy (minimizing input cost while maintaining quality), efficiency (maximizing output from given inputs or minimizing inputs for a given output), and effectiveness (achieving predetermined objectives). The fundamental principle for using public money is to spend it as carefully as one's own. The Auditor General of Pakistan, under Article 169 of the Constitution, heads the audit organization ensuring public funds are spent according to financial rules. Parliament's role is served through the Public Accounts Committee, which reviews government accounts annually.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental principle for spending public money as stated in the lecture?
- Who heads the Audit & Accounts organization of the Government of Pakistan, and under which Article of the Constitution?
- Define Performance Audit and explain how it differs from a traditional financial audit.
- What are the three components of "value for money" in performance audit? Provide a brief definition and an example for each.
- What is the primary objective of a performance audit?
π Lecture 32 β Motivation
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of motivation in organizational settings, explaining how and why people are driven to achieve goals. It covers various psychological theories of motivation, from early classical models to modern need-based theories, emphasizing the importance of understanding human behavior for effective management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the basic concept of motivation as goal-directed behavior originating from needs, a model of motivation showing the need-drive-action-satisfaction cycle, the range of human behavior from reflexes to habits, and the importance of understanding motivation in organizations. It examines assumptions about motivation, early views including classical, human relations, and human resources models, and various need theories such as Maslow's hierarchy, Alderfer's ERG theory, and McClelland's three needs theory.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction to Motivation
In organizations, people are essential because they operate machines and equipment to achieve goals. For management, it is crucial to keep employees happy, satisfied, and motivated. In simple terms, motivation means to 'move' in a direction; it is goal-directed behavior.
π Definition β Motivation: a drive that moves an individual to meet a need and attain satisfaction.
Model of Motivation
The lecture presents a simple diagram showing that motivation originates from need. When human beings are deprived of something, a need emerges. This need creates a drive that moves the person to action (goal-directed behavior). When the need is fulfilled, the person experiences satisfaction, reducing the tension of the drive. Then another need may emerge.
π Example: A person is thirsty β need to satisfy thirst β drive moves person to act β reach out to water β drink water (goal-oriented behavior) β satisfaction. Then another need may emerge.
Range of Human Behavior
Motivation and motivating deal with conscious human behavior between two extremes:
- Reflex actions (e.g., sneeze, flutter of eyelids)
- Learned habits (e.g., brushing teeth, handwriting style)
Psychologists divide human behavior into three broad areas: reflex action, habits (acquired and difficult to change), and influenceable behavior. Psychologists worked on this third area to modify human action, finding that people can be motivated to achieve organizational goals.
Importance of Understanding Motivation
Understanding human behavior in organizations is important because it helps in handling variety of situations and dealing with people according to their personality. Every individual is different and should be motivated differently. Once we know a person's personality, strengths, and weaknesses, it becomes easier to control behavior in organizations. For managers, it is important to know how to motivate people and what motivates them.
Assumptions about Motivation
There are certain assumptions that help managers devise good motivation plans:
- Motivation is commonly assumed to be a good thing.
- Motivation is one of several factors that go into a person's performance. Important factors also include ability, resources, and conditions under which one performs.
π Example: A student who wants an 'A' grade must be motivated, but motivation alone will not work. The student also needs books, a place to study, and food for nourishment.
- Motivation is in short supply and in need of periodic replenishment. Sometimes we feel motivated, other times we are not.
- Motivation is a tool with which managers can arrange job relationships in organizations. They can tailor job assignments and rewards to what makes people "tick."
Early Views on Motivation
Motivation was one of the earliest concepts managers and researchers studied.
The classical model is associated with Frederick Taylor and scientific management. According to this model, the most efficient way to perform repetitive tasks was determined, and workers were motivated with a system of wage incentives β output of work was linked to wage.
The human relations model is associated with Elton Mayo and his contemporaries. They found that boredom and repetitiveness of many tasks actually reduced motivation, while social contacts helped create and sustain motivation. Therefore, good relationships with supervision were important. Under this model, workers accepted management's authority because supervisors treated them with consideration and allowed them to influence the work situation.
The human resources model is often associated with Douglas McGregor. McGregor criticized the human relations model as an approach to manipulate employees. He also charged that, like the traditional model, the human relations model oversimplified motivation by focusing on just one factor, such as money or social relations.
Need Theory β Hierarchy of Needs
The hierarchy of needs developed by Abraham Maslow has probably received more attention from managers than any other theory of motivation. (This theory was examined at length in previous lectures.)
ERG Theory
Clayton Alderfer agreed with Maslow that worker motivation could be gauged according to a hierarchy of needs. However, his ERG theory (acronym for Existence, Relatedness, Growth) differs from Maslow's theory in two ways:
-
Alderfer broke needs down into three categories:
- Existence needs (Maslow's basic needs): basic needs like food, clothing, shelter
- Relatedness needs: needs for interpersonal relations; people want to relate to others, live in society, and belong
- Growth needs: needs for personal creativity or productive influence; the need to grow, develop, improve, and be creative
-
Alderfer stressed that when higher needs are frustrated, lower needs will return, even though they were already satisfied. Maslow, in contrast, felt that a need, once met, lost its power to motivate behavior.
Three Needs Theory (Atkinson and McClelland)
John W. Atkinson proposed three basic drives in motivated persons:
- Need for achievement: the need to excel and outperform; high performers looking for perfection (e.g., sport stars)
- Need for power: the need for authority; people prefer positions that give power even if paid less (e.g., police)
- Need for affiliation: the need for close association with others; preference to stay close to family and friends (e.g., refusing a transfer for higher salary)
The balance between these drives varies from person to person.
David C. McClelland's research showed that a strong need for achievement β the drive to succeed or excel β is related to how well individuals are motivated to perform their work tasks. There is considerable evidence of the correlation between high achievement needs and high performance. People who succeeded in competitive occupations were well above average in achievement motivation.
The need for affiliation has been a concern of managers since Elton Mayo and the Hawthorne experiment.
The need for power deals with the degree of control a person desires over their situation. This need can be related to how people deal with failure and success.
π‘ Why this matters: McClelland's work highlights the importance of matching the individual and the job. Employees with high achievement needs like challenging jobs, autonomy, variety, and frequent feedback. Employees with low achievement needs prefer stability, security, and predictability.
π Definition β Goal-oriented behavior: a behavior in which a person is clear about goals and acts to achieve those goals.
π Definition β Need for affiliation: the need to associate and stay close to family, friends, and social circle.
π Definition β Need for achievement: the need to excel and outperform.
β Key Takeaways
Motivation is a goal-directed behavior originating from unmet needs, following a cycle of need, drive, action, and satisfaction. There are three early models of motivation: classical (wage incentives), human relations (social contacts and good supervision), and human resources (critiquing manipulation). Need theories are central, with Maslow's hierarchy, Alderfer's ERG theory (which notes that frustrated higher needs cause lower needs to return), and McClelland's three needs (achievement, power, affiliation) being the most important. A critical insight is that individuals have different motivational profiles, so managers must match jobs to people's needs β high achievers need challenging work while others prefer stability.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is motivation, and what is the simple model that explains how it works?
- How does Alderfer's ERG theory differ from Maslow's hierarchy of needs?
- What are the three needs proposed by Atkinson and McClelland, and give an example of each?
- What are the three early models of motivation, and who is associated with each?
- According to McClelland, what type of job is best suited for an employee with a high need for achievement?