π Lecture 42 β POLITICAL REFORMS
π Overview: This lecture examines the political reforms, administrative structure, and financial arrangements (PFC) of the local government system in Pakistan in greater detail. It covers the electoral arrangements for the three tiers, the functions of the Union Council, and the fiscal reforms including resource sharing between federal, provincial, and local governments. Understanding this structure is critical because it explains how power is devolved to the grassroots level and how representation and resources are managed.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the political reforms including electoral arrangements for union, tehsil, and district councils, with details on direct and indirect elections, reserved seats for marginalized groups, and qualification requirements. It then explains the functions of the Union Council, the administrative structure within local government including staffing, and then proceeds to fiscal reforms covering federal-provincial and provincial-local resource transfers. Finally, it presents the weaknesses and strengths of the Devolution Plan and Local Government Ordinance 2000.
π Lecture Summary
Political Reforms
The foundation of the electoral structure for the three tiers of local government is the union council. The union is a multimember ward for the election of members of the union council; each constituency is on average 25,000 people, and each union council is composed of 21 directly elected members. The nazim and naib nazim (mayor and deputy mayor) are elected on a joint ticket. The remaining 19 seats are allocated as follows: 12 Muslim seats (4 reserved for women), 6 seats for peasants and workers (2 reserved for women), and 1 seat for minority communities.
π Definition β Joint Ticket: A system where the candidates for nazim and naib nazim run together as a pair in an election, so voters vote for them as a single unit.
Indirect Elections
The nazim of the union council becomes a member of the district council, and the naib nazim of the union council becomes a member of the tehsil council. The union councilors constitute the Electoral College for the district or tehsil councilors and for the district and tehsil nazim and naib nazim. One-third of seats are reserved for women (directly elected at union council level and elected by the Electoral College of Union Councilors at tehsil and district level). Additionally, 5 percent of district and tehsil seats have been reserved for peasants (in rural constituencies) or workers (in urban areas), and 5 percent for minorities. Thus, overall district councils and tehsil councils are made up of about 2/3 directly elected members and 1/3 indirectly elected, including nazim and naib nazim. The size of district and tehsil councils varies according to the number of union councils within the district. Each tier of local government has a term of office of 4 years, with a 2-term limit for nazimeen and naib nazimeen.
District
At the district level, there is a departure from convention; in the Devolution Plan, representation of marginalized groups is intentionally designed. Thus, there are 33% seats for women in the District Council, 5% seats for workers, and 5% for minorities. To ensure a better quality of elected representative, a condition of matriculation/secondary school qualification has been kept.
Tehsil
Likewise, for better representation of marginalized groups, the following seats are kept at the Tehsil level: 33% women seats, 5% for workers/peasants, and 5% for minorities. A qualification of at least matriculation/secondary certificate or equivalent is required. Each tier of local government has a term of office of four years, with a two-term limit for nazimeen and naib nazimeen at all levels of government.
Functions of Union Council
Union Councils are the lowest local unit in rural areas (the lowest unit in urban areas is town committee). A Union Council, with a population of 25,000, performs the following functions:
- Municipal function: sewerage and sanitation (cleanliness of area).
- Finance: managing expenditures and rousing revenues.
- Public safety: managing bridges, culverts, etc.
- Health: provision of basic preventive health care, like controlling epidemics.
- Education: provision of basic primary education.
- Literacy: literacy programmes for adults who were unable to receive primary education.
- Justice: provision of justice in civil cases through βMasalihat Councils.β
In addition, the Union Council also performs the following functions:
- Undertake development projects related to the above functions.
- Impose taxes to fund the annual development plan. The proposed revenue raising authority includes: fee for licensing of professions and vocations, fee on sale of animals in cattle market, market fee, fee for certification of births, marriages, and deaths.
- Local securities system β union guards.
- Creation of villager councils and citizen-like community boards.
π‘ Why this matters: The Union Council is the most direct point of contact between citizens and government, handling essential local services like sanitation, health, education, and justice.
Structure within local government
The executive branch of each district government has 10 to 14 departments. The DCO (District Coordination Officer), the highest-ranking civil servant in the district, heads the District Coordination department. An Executive District Officer (EDO) heads each of the remaining departments. Three groups of employees were assigned to the new district governments:
- Federal employment groups, primarily District Management Group (DMG) and the Audit and Accounts Group.
- Former rural district council employees.
- Provincial employment groups, particularly Public Health Engineering Department (PHED), Rural Development, Local Government, Health, and Education.
A large majority of district staff formerly belonged to the provincial employment group, particularly education. Most are in grades 1-15 (90% of district staff in NWFP and 83% in Sindh). The Tehsil Municipal Administration (TMA) inherited staff from the former urban council and rural district council, and also some provincial PHED staff where these have been devolved.
Fiscal Reforms
Areas of expenditure responsibility of the federal and provincial governments are set out in the Constitution of Pakistan. The Constitution is silent on the remaining functions and assumes by default that these remaining functions are to be performed by sub-national (provincial or local) governments. The federal government is responsible for foreign affairs, defense, banking and currency, postal service, and transportation (ports, airports, railways), while the main provincial responsibilities are police services, justice, roads, education, and health. The Constitution accepts that vertical fiscal imbalances will arise between federal and provincial governments, which are resolved through revenue sharing. The National Finance Commission (NFC) is the institution assigned the task of determining appropriate revenue sharing arrangements among federal and provincial governments.
Table β 1 shows the responsibilities of province, District, and Tehsil governments:
- Province: Education, Health, Agriculture, Irrigation, Police, Mines and mineral development, Industrial and labor regulation.
- District: Education, Health, Agriculture extension, On-farm management, Soil conservation, Fisheries, Forests, Water supply and sanitation, Sewerage transport, Inter tehsil road, Parks and playgrounds, Municipal regulation.
- Tehsil/Taluka/Town: Water supply and sanitation, Sewerage, Street lighting, Parks and playgrounds, Municipal regulation.
Under the Devolution Plan, there were no shifts of responsibility from the federal to the provincial governments. The initial attempt was to bring about changes that would not require any constitutional amendment. Significant functional transfers did occur from provincial to local governments.
Federal-Provincial Transfers
In Pakistan, revenue sharing is the dominant form of federal-provincial fiscal relations. The main source of provincial revenues is a transfer based on a share of federal tax collections. The decision on the list of taxes (the βdivisible poolβ), the ratio of the provincial-federal share of the pool, and the formula for its distribution to the provinces is fixed at least once every five years by the National Finance Commission (NFC).
Provincial-Local Transfers
All four provincial governments share resources with district governments. Just as there is a Federal Divisible Pool, there is a Provincial Divisible Pool. This pool comprises: transfers from the federal divisible pool, straight transfers from the federal government, and provincial tax revenue. For example, the Sindh PFC estimates the shares of provincial and district governments for both current and development expenditure. The Sindh PFC decided that for current expenditure, the Provincial Divisible Pool comprises: federal divisible pool transfers, federal straight transfers, and provincial tax revenue. The transfers to districts were based on the gap between district expenditure and revenue, with transfers from provincial government to districts based on population, tax collection, and a backwardness index of districts.
Weaknesses of the Local Government System
- An attempt to undermine provincial autonomy. Provinces now have to systematically evolve a mechanism to share resources. Prior to this system, provinces were autonomous and had a centralized system; people from remote areas had no access to provincial headquarters.
- Violation of a fundamental structure of the Constitution. The Constitution does not provide a local government structure.
- Resistance of bureaucracy against the system. The power of bureaucracy has weakened, and at the district level, the DCO is answerable to the elected nazim.
- Role of members of legislative assembly. Members of the legislature have a greater role in the development of the area and are more answerable to people.
Strengths of the Local Government System
- The unleashed horse of bureaucracy has been bridled. The office of DC has now been brought under the control of the elected representative.
- Elimination of urban-rural division. An attempt has been made to reduce the gap between urban and rural areas.
- Formula-based division of financial resources. The PFC now has to share resources under a formula that is logical and appropriate.
- Grass root organizations. The local government system has established grass root organizations like Citizen Community Boards to oversee the working of government organizations.
- Enhanced representation of women.
- Political linkage.
- Autonomy of local representatives.
Conclusions
The lecture examined the local government structure and functions in greater detail, as well as the weaknesses and strengths of the local government system.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the local government system is built on union councils with 21 directly elected members, from which nazims and naib nazims are elected on a joint ticket and then become members of higher councils through indirect elections. The system intentionally ensures representation for marginalized groups with 33% seats for women, 5% for workers/peasants, and 5% for minorities, and requires a matriculation qualification for candidates. The Union Council is the key service delivery unit responsible for sanitation, health, education, literacy, and civil justice. Financially, the Provincial Finance Commission (PFC) allocates resources to districts based on population, tax collection, and a backwardness index using a Provincial Divisible Pool. Finally, while the system has strengths like curbing bureaucratic power and enhancing womenβs representation, it faces weaknesses including constitutional ambiguity and resistance from the bureaucracy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How many directly elected members compose a Union Council, and how are the seats allocated among Muslims, peasants/workers, and minorities?
- Explain the process of indirect elections for the district and tehsil councilsβwho constitutes the Electoral College?
- List at least four of the seven main functions of a Union Council as discussed in the lecture.
- What is the Provincial Divisible Pool, and what three components does it include according to the Sindh PFC?
- State two weaknesses and two strengths of the Devolution Plan and Local Government Ordinance 2000.
π Lecture 43 β New Public Management (NPM)
π Overview: This lecture examines the shift from traditional public administration to New Public Management (NPM), a managerial approach that emerged in the 1980s and 1990s. It explores how "administration" (following instructions) evolved into "management" (achieving results), focusing on efficiency, flexibility, and market-based reforms in the public sector.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the emergence of New Public Management as a response to traditional administration's inadequacies, the five key points of NPM, the meaning of management compared to administration, Allison's three main functions of general management (strategy, managing internal components, managing external components), the beginning of the management approach in the public sector from the 1950s onward, and the 1968 Fulton Report in the UK as a starting point for management reforms.
π Lecture Summary
New Public Management (NPM)
The 1980s and 1990s saw the emergence of a new managerial approach in the public sector, in response to the inadequacies of the traditional model of administration. The new managerial approach was the revival of the idea that the private sector is more efficient. Administration was understood as static β it was the implementation of policies and programmes of government. The concepts of efficiency were not the domain of "administration". Management was understood as dynamic and applicable to the private sector where efficiency was the criterion of operations and task.
The various names for New Public Management reflect differing views of what is happening in organizations, but they have several points in common:
- It represents a major shift from traditional public administration, with far greater attention paid to the achievement of results and the personal responsibility of managers.
- There is an expressed intention to move away from classic bureaucracy to making organizations, personnel, and employment terms and conditions more flexible rather than rigid.
- Organizational and personal objectives are to be set out clearly so that achievement or results are measured.
- Senior staff is more likely to be politically committed to the government of the day and hence would implement the agenda of the government.
- Government functions are more likely to face market tests, such as contracting out, or reducing government functions through privatisation. This is the most important facet of NPM, whereby the role of government as provider of service is reducing and more services are being provided by the private sector (e.g., city transport once provided by government is now provided by private sector).
New public management may offer a more realistic approach than the traditional model, but managerialism has been controversial. The main argument against NPM is that it has attempted to take the place of traditional public administration.
π‘ Why this matters: NPM fundamentally redefines the role of government from a direct service provider to an overseer or purchaser of services, shifting focus from process to results.
π Definition β New Public Management (NPM): A managerial approach in the public sector emphasizing efficiency, results, flexibility, market mechanisms, and private sector techniques. π Definition β Managerialism: The application of private sector management principles and practices to the public sector.
The Meaning of Management
Administration means following instructions and management means the achievement of results. Public management has semantic origins that imply taking things in "hand", suggesting firmness and efficiency. Unlike an administrator, a manager has greater control over determining goals, objectives, and strategy in achieving results. Allison suggests there are three main functions of general management:
1. Strategy
- Establishing objectives and priorities for the organisation based on forecasts of external environments and organizational capacity.
- Devising operational plans to achieve these objectives.
2. Managing Internal Components
- Organizing and staffing: In organizing, managers establish structure (position, authority, and responsibility are assigned). In staffing, selection of the right man for the right job is done.
- Directing personnel and human resource management system: The capacity of organization is in its members and their skills and knowledge. HRM recruits, selects, trains people to build capacity.
- Controlling performance: Various management information systems (budgeting, accounts, reports, performance appraisal) help managers make decisions and achieve objectives.
3. Managing External Components
- Dealing with external units of the organisation subject to common authority (e.g., geographically dispersed units).
- Dealing with independent organizations: agencies from other branches or level of government, interest groups, or private enterprise that affect the organization's ability to achieve its objectives.
- Dealing with press and public whose action or approval and agreement is required.
Traditional public administration required little conception of strategy, as that was presumed to be "given" by politicians. Public servants simply carried out instructions. Managerialism, on the other hand, aims at the longer term and the relationship between the organization and the external environment. Politicians now demand that agencies involve themselves in matters of strategy.
Traditional public administration also focused on HRM but not to the fullest. NPM focuses on internal environment and on HRM policies to measure performance. Under the traditional model, concepts of public service anonymity and neutrality declined. Public servants are now much freer to deal with press, public, and other organizations. There is far greater focus on external environment in NPM.
π Definition β Strategy: The function of establishing objectives and priorities for an organization and devising operational plans to achieve them.
Beginning of Management Approach
For much of the twentieth century, there was little difference in management structures or style between private and public management. Large companies were hierarchical and Weberian as any government department. It was only from the 1950s or 1960s that the problems of bureaucratic rigidity became evident in the private sector. It was realized that division of labour and working manuals for all management functions had limitations β someone needed to take responsibility to achieve results.
The apparent success of managers in the private sector led to concerns that the public sector had fallen behind. One starting point for management is the 1968 Fulton Report in the United Kingdom. This report noted concerns with the management capability of public service. It recommended that the system be opened up, outsiders be employed at all levels, and the rigid hierarchical structure with barriers at several points be removed.
Reforms in the public sector in developed countries like the USA and Australia were introduced, questioning if the public service had the management tools, flexibility, and capacities to meet the challenges of changing external environments.
π Definition β Fulton Report (1968): A UK report that recommended opening up the public service system, employing outsiders at all levels, and removing rigid hierarchical barriers. π Example: The shift from government-provided city transport to private sector provision illustrates the NPM principle of contracting out or privatisation.
Conclusions
From the traditional model of public administration (emphasizing hierarchical structure, dichotomy of policy formulation and implementation, neutrality of public servants) to more flexible organization structures, the concept has evolved and generated new controversy.
NPM is driven by market and by the concepts of measuring individual and organizational performance to achieve results. NPM encompasses the concepts of general management functions, whereby strategy, internal components, and external components must be understood well to achieve results. NPM evolved in developed countries after recommendations made by Reform Committees in the UK and USA.
β Key Takeaways
The shift from traditional public administration to New Public Management represents a fundamental change from following instructions to achieving results, with far greater emphasis on managerial responsibility, flexibility, and performance measurement. The five key features of NPM include results-orientation, flexibility away from classic bureaucracy, clear objective-setting, political commitment of senior staff, and market testing through privatisation and contracting out. Allison's three general management functions β strategy, managing internal components, and managing external components β are essential for understanding the managerial role in NPM, with strategy being a new focus compared to traditional administration where politicians set policy. The movement toward management began in the 1950s-60s due to bureaucratic rigidity, with the 1968 Fulton Report in the UK as a key milestone in pushing for management reforms in the public sector. NPM remains controversial because it challenges the traditional role of government as direct service provider, shifting toward a market-driven model that prioritizes efficiency and results.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five key points that New Public Management models have in common?
- How does Allison define the three main functions of general management?
- What was the significance of the 1968 Fulton Report for the beginning of management approach in the public sector?
- What is the main argument against New Public Management (NPM)?
- How does the concept of "strategy" differ between traditional public administration and New Public Management?
π Lecture 44 β Managerial Programme Agenda β I
π Overview: This lecture examines the reasons behind public sector reforms in developed countries and introduces the concept of the "managerial programme agenda." It explains why reforms were necessary, the key features of managerialism, and the seven main points of New Public Management (NPM) as articulated by scholars like Massey and Hood. Understanding this lecture is crucial for grasping how modern public administration shifted from traditional bureaucracy to a performance-driven, results-oriented model.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the reasons for public sector reforms in developed countries (such as resource constraints, political leadership, and the large size of government), followed by an in-depth look at the managerial programme (managerialism) including its main features like performance pay, staff involvement, and contracting out. It then discusses Masseyβs five goals of new managerialism and concludes with Hoodβs seven main points of NPM, including hands-on professional management, performance measures, output controls, disaggregation, and competition.
π Lecture Summary
Reasons for Reforms
The Fulton Report in the UK recommended result-based management in public service. In the USA, the Civil Service Reform Act of 1978 aimed for greater responsibility for results, including merit pay for middle management and the establishment of Senior Executive Services. In Australia (1982), the need to improve public service capacity was also felt.
More particular reasons for reforms included:
- Severe resource constraints as tax revenues declined. Politically, it was felt that more services should be provided with lesser staff.
- Political leadership brought reforms, especially during the late 70s and 80s when governments changed in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
- Link between improving public sector management and re-structuring the national economy β during difficult economic times, the business community and government both had to improve management.
- The size of government was becoming large and inefficient, creating a need to reduce it.
Managerial Programme
There were several ideas about what constitutes NPM. A more focused view, similar to general management functions, was called managerialism. Countries bringing reforms were trying to make the public sector more managerial.
The main features of managerialism were: (i) To improve human resources, including performance pay β pay should increase according to performance. (ii) To involve staff in decision-making. (iii) To relax controls, but impose performance targets. (iv) To use information technology (IT). (v) Service to clients β the customer or user should be considered important. (vi) User charges β services should not be free, but users should pay. (vii) Contracting out β to reduce the size of government, services should be contracted out instead of provided directly.
π Definition β Managerialism: A set of ideas focused on making the public sector more managerial, emphasizing performance, efficiency, and private sector techniques.
Massey, one of the contributors to new managerialism, said reforms had several other goals:
- To reduce the role and extent of the 'state' to enhance the role of the private sector.
- To facilitate the acquisition of entrepreneurial skills and activities in society.
- To prevent future expansion of the public sector and welfare-demanding coalitions linked to bureaucrats.
- To de-politicize many (mainly economic) policy decisions and entrust them to professional experts.
- To inculcate in public sector organisations the best techniques of private sector practice to bring discipline.
π‘ Why this matters: These goals reveal that managerialism aimed to make the public sector efficient and reduce its size.
7 Main Points
Another author, Hood, looks at new public management as comprising seven main points:
-
Handsβon professional management in public sector β Managers should be allowed to actively participate in organizational goals and implementation. Accountability requires clear assignment of responsibility for action. Governments now want to know what departments do, how well they do it, who is in charge, and who takes responsibility for results. The primary way is to "let the managers manage", meaning senior managers should achieve results. Political leaders increasingly choose managers with good records who are sympathetic to the minister's goals.
-
Explicit standards and measures of performance β The main change is for organizations to focus on outputs or outcomes instead of inputs. Managerial reforms have stressed performance by individuals and agencies. Performance measures can be developed in any public organisation, though there are more difficulties than in the private sector. The performance appraisal system should aim to measure the performance of individual staff.
-
Greater emphasis on output controls β The most important change has been performance and programme budgeting systems to replace the older line-item budget. The focus was formerly on inputs rather than outputs. The line-item system was precise in control but governments had little information on actual programme delivery. Governments have also aimed to develop better methods for long-term planning and strategic management β deciding the organization's mission, looking ahead to goals, and how the organization fits its environment.
-
A Shift to Disaggregation β Disaggregation means splitting large departments into different parts by setting up agencies to deliver services for a small policy. For example, if a large organization performs several functions (maintenance of parks, housing, education, health care), it should split these into smaller organizations, each performing one function separately. A specific aim was to reduce the number of staff in the core civil service to a small group engaged in advisory functions. In some ways, disaggregation reverts to Woodrow Wilson's ideas with an organisational split between policy and administration.
-
A Shift to Greater Competition β Cutting the scope of governments and bureaucracies is another part of the managerial programme. Competition is introduced for government services with the idea of cutting costs. Proponents argue that if services are 'contestable', they should be put out to tender. Widespread privatization is part of this, but not the only means of reducing governmental role.
Conclusions
The reforms in developed countries had some influence on developing countries through organizations providing loans. There was a shift in the approach and goals of government in service provision. There is now a greater shift towards new public management. NPM involves more competition, reduction in government role, and greater role of private sector. NPM is the response to the changing economic philosophy of the present time.
β Key Takeaways
- Reforms in developed countries were driven by resource constraints, political leadership, economic restructuring needs, and the large inefficient size of government. The managerial programme (managerialism) focused on improving human resources, performance pay, staff involvement, relaxing controls while imposing targets, using IT, serving clients, user charges, and contracting out.
- Massey's goals emphasized reducing the state's role, promoting entrepreneurial skills, preventing public sector expansion, depoliticizing policy decisions, and adopting private sector techniques.
- Hood's seven points of NPM are: hands-on professional management, explicit performance standards, output controls, disaggregation, competition, and others (covered in the lecture). These represent the core operational principles of NPM.
- The shift from line-item budgeting to performance and programme budgeting is a critical change, moving focus from inputs to outputs. Disaggregation splits large departments into smaller agencies to improve efficiency.
- NPM ultimately aims to make public sector organizations more efficient, competitive, and responsive to citizens, with a reduced government role and increased private sector involvement.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the four main reasons for public sector reforms in developed countries?
- What are the seven main features of the managerial programme (managerialism)?
- According to Massey, what are the five goals of new managerialism?
- Explain Hood's first three points of NPM: hands-on professional management, explicit performance standards, and greater emphasis on output controls.
- What does "disaggregation" mean in the context of NPM, and why is it pursued?
π Lecture 45 β MANAGERIAL PROGRAMME AGENDA β II
π Overview: This lecture concludes the discussion of the seven points of new public management, focusing on private sector management practices and resource discipline. It then presents a comprehensive critique of New Public Management (NPM) and concludes with a summary of the entire course, revisiting the fundamental question of government's role.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture completes the final two points of the public management agenda (private sector management styles and resource discipline), explains the theoretical bases of NPM in economics and private management, and then presents seven major critiques of managerialism: its economic basis, private management foundation, neo-Taylorism, politicisation, reduced accountability, implementation problems, and unclear specification. The lecture concludes with a summary of the entire course's coverage of public administration concepts.
π Lecture Summary
MANAGERIAL PROGRAMME AGENDA β II (Internal Changes - continued)
6. A stress on private sector styles of management practice This includes staffing changes designed to better fit staff for their positions, to appraise their performance and to reward them accordingly with merit pay. The emphasis on performance also leads to short-term appointments by contract and to terminate staff who is not performing. This concept is based on economic idea that wages increase productively.
7. Discipline and parsimony in resource use New public management requires increased attention on the best use of resources. This includes cutting costs but also involves directing resources to emphasize those programmes which most assist the attainment of strategic objectives. Governments have been able to control spending far more by having better information.
All these changes drive from particular theories β they are theory-driven to an unusual degree for government administration.
These last two points strengthen the previous point that individual performance be linked to wages and that organizations should aim to reduce cost.
Theoretical Bases of Management
The traditional theories of public administration were criticized. The traditional public administration was based on two theories:
- Theory of bureaucracy and
- Theory of separation between politicians and administrators.
There are also two main theoretical bases to new public management. These are economics and private management.
That economics and private management are the two main theoretical bases for NPM is not a matter of controversy, because management is 'clearly an activity which is concerned with using resources so as to achieve defined objectives' and these objectives 'are defined predominantly in the language of economics' (Pollitt, 1990)
The economic basis to managerialism allows it to draw on what is the most powerful of social science theories. There are two key assumptions in economics. First, there is the assumption of rationality: that individuals can be assumed to prefer more of something rather than less. Secondly, the individual rationality assumption allows the elaboration of models which can extend to high levels of abstraction.
Economist and economic thinking became influential in government also:
- Cost-benefit analysis
- Public choice theory Gave rise to market based public policies
Critique on Management
Since the upsurge of reforms in developed countries and implementation of reforms in public or civil service, they called it 'public management' instead of 'public administration'. The effects of this change are taking place in developing countries like Pakistan as well and privatization of public organization and encouragement to private sector is taking place. Although now the work done by public servant may be called as management, because the focus is on the achievement of results. But there is some criticism of managerialism or NPM. The critique is as follows:
1. The Economic Basis of Managerialism The foundation in economics forms one of the criticisms of managerialism. The questions on assumptions of economics are on its "approach to rationality". The critique is that all individuals do not behave rationally, likewise all bureaucrats do not maximize own advantage. There are two main critiques of economics. First, that economics is not a 'perfect' social science and its application to government will not give 'perfect' results. This is not a new critique but has been there ever since economics and capitalist system matured. The second critique is that economics can be for economic system, but government cannot provide services on consumer transaction basis (costing every service on profit basis) β that consumer behaviour laws do not apply to public sector, because public sector is different from private sector, because its objectives are not to make profits.
2. The Basis in Private Management That "managerialism" derives its spirit from private sector is a source of criticism. The public sector is different and that private sector models of management become irrelevant. For example, changing the focus of organization from inputs to outputs i.e. results has logic which are: Setting objectives, devising programmes, setting structure, measuring performance and evaluating programmes. All these steps are logical progression and once objectives and results are defined clearly other steps will follow. But in public sector objectives sometimes cannot be defined clearly and therefore, all the logical steps that follow do not stay relevant. Since it is difficult to determine objectives, this may be the key difference between public and private sector. However, this does not mean that effort should not be made to define objectives because without objectives the meaning of creating government organization is lost.
3. Neo-Taylorism The main theoretical critique is that managerialism represents revival of F.W. Taylor's ideas of efficiency, output measurement, piece wage rate etc. It is argued that going back to this theory ignores the development of human relations and other theories. The emphasis of NPM (or managerialism) to control government spending and decentralising management responsibilities with performance management is seen as management philosophy which can be described as neo-Taylorism. Authors like Pollit see managerialism as the direct descendent of Taylor's scientific management; and that human relations aspects are down played.
4. Politicisation The changes that are taking place in public service are said to be "politicizing". This means that ministers who head ministries will select own division/department head and will then expect that heads of departments achieve goals which ministers have given them. This idea of NPM cuts across traditional model's emphasis on neutrality and impartial administration. The dichotomy between politics and administration and neutrality of public servant is no more there. This is negation of what Woodrow Wilson's idea about non-political and efficient bureaucracy, which he put forward in 1880.
5. Reduced Accountability There is concern whether NPM concepts and procedures fit in the system of accountability. There is a conflict between the concept of public management and public accountability. If public servants are to be accountable for results then politician's accountability is absolved. How can public servants be accountable to citizen? It is the politicians who take vote from public to serve them and it is the policy direction of politicians that civil servant implement. So in NPM accountability gets more diluted.
6. Implementation In NPM strategy, goals and objectives are formulated at top and there is little attention paid to implementation. Improvements in strategy and budgeting occur at top, but at lower level implementation or performance management leaves much to be done. Evaluation of programme is still considered unusual and is not comprehensive.
7. Unclear Specification A final area of critique is that specifications are unclear in NPM model. It means there is no real definition of public management or managerialism. There is listing of things involved: performance measurement, incentives, programme budgeting, and so on but no clear definition for these concepts.
Summing the Critique
The critique of NPM has some valid points, but these are to be proved as yet because the real test of new theory is the performance. It has to be seen if NPM will work. The basic concept of NPM decentralises responsibility and accountability to manager who has to achieve results. It is to be seen that NPM will achieve what it intends to achieve i.e. better performance and efficiency.
What is the role of government?
From the time the public administration was the practice of managers to the time it acquired the shape of a discipline to be taught in colleges and universities there has been one fundamental question: What is the role of Government in providing goods and services? Is government going to be welfare state? To what extent government will provide services? To whom government will provide services? What services will be provided by the private sector? Will government charge for services that once were provided free? How should government charge? Should it cover cost? Should it make profit on the services that it provides? There have been these questions asked. The reason for asking these questions is that government's cost of providing services is increasing, because of its large size and inefficiencies mainly. So governments have to see what can be done. Besides there is the upsurge of markets and by markets we mean commercialization of all activities: make money on the sale of services; sell services to those who have ability to pay etc. Therefore, the role of government is undergoing change under market pressures and commercialization of services. This needs to be questioned whether this is the 'correct' role of government?
What have we covered?
In these 45 lectures an attempt was made to understand the concepts, theoretical framework of public administration/management, definitions etc. We started off with the explanation of public administration; and one definition that was given is: "It is the continuously active, 'business' part of government, concerned with carrying out the law, as made by legislative bodies (or other authoritative agents) and interpreted by the courts, through the processes of organization and management." This definition covers most, rather all, dimensions of what government does. We also covered significant area of constitution that establishes organization, institution of state, rights of citizens, etc. We covered evolution of the management, core functions: Planning and organizing, public finance, administrative accountability, skills of manager, district administration, and local government and then the changing concepts of public administration/management.
β Key Takeaways
The final two principles of NPM emphasize adopting private sector staffing practices like merit pay and contract appointments, and exercising strict discipline in resource use by linking spending to strategic objectives. The critiques of NPM are substantial and include its questionable economic assumptions about rationality, the inapplicability of private sector models to the public sector where objectives are often unclear, and its revival of Taylorism while ignoring human relations. Further criticisms highlight that NPM leads to politicisation by undermining neutral administration, reduces accountability by diffusing responsibility, neglects implementation, and lacks clear conceptual specifications. Ultimately, the fundamental question of what the proper role of government should be remains unresolved, as market pressures push toward commercialization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key assumptions from economics that form the basis of New Public Management?
- List the seven critiques of New Public Management discussed in this lecture.
- According to the critique of neo-Taylorism, which earlier management theory does NPM revive, and what aspect of management does it downplay?
- Why do critics argue that NPM leads to reduced accountability, and how does this conflict with traditional Woodrow Wilson's ideas?
- What fundamental question about government's role has been central to the entire course, and what pressures are currently changing this role?