π Lecture 45 β The Future of Knowledge Management
π Overview: This lecture examines what makes Knowledge Management initiatives successful, focusing on the strategic and operational requirements for success. It explores the fundamental tension between tacit and explicit knowledge approaches, detailing their respective advantages, disadvantages, and practical applications in real organizations such as Toyota, Motorola, and Philips.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with golden nuggets derived from KM research about success factors. It then presents the two fundamentally different views of knowledge management practice: the tacit knowledge approach and the explicit knowledge approach. For each approach, the lecture explains underlying beliefs, provides organizational examples, and analyzes advantages and disadvantages. The lecture concludes by highlighting the challenges organizations face when implementing explicit knowledge management.
π Lecture Summary
What makes a KM initiative successful?
The lecture opens with critical questions about KM success and presents research-derived "golden nuggets." KM success factors are dominated by management onesβculture, process, and organizationβwith technology being the least important. KM requires the integration and balancing of leadership, organization, learning, and technology in an enterprise-wide setting. An atmosphere of trust is necessary for sharing knowledge, and national culture affects KM implementation especially at lower levels. Knowledge assets are strategic and must be accounted for and valued accordingly.
π‘ Why this matters: These findings challenge the common assumption that technology is the primary driver of KM success.
Tacit knowledge versus explicit knowledge approaches
Many KM recommendations appear contradictory but actually derive from two fundamentally different views of knowledge itself. These are characterized as the tacit knowledge approach and the explicit knowledge approach.
The tacit knowledge approach
The salient characteristic of the tacit knowledge approach is the basic belief that knowledge is essentially personal in nature and therefore difficult to extract from the heads of individuals. This approach holds that knowledge dissemination can best be accomplished by moving people as 'knowledge carriers' from one part of an organization to another. Learning occurs when individuals come together under circumstances that encourage sharing ideas and developing new insights.
π Definition β Tacit Knowledge Approach: The belief that knowledge is personal and difficult to extract, requiring people movement and interaction for knowledge transfer.
Managers are urged to identify the knowledge possessed by various individuals and arrange interactions between knowledgeable individuals. A common initiative is creating 'know-who' forms of knowledge. For example, Philips created a 'yellow pages' on its intranet listing experts with different kinds of knowledge; typing keywords retrieves contact information for knowledgeable people worldwide.
π Example β Toyota's Tacit Knowledge Transfer: When Toyota opened a new factory in Valenciennes, France, it selected 200-300 new employees to train for several months in an existing factory. These workers were then sent back to the new factory, accompanied by 100-200 experienced Toyota workers who worked alongside all new employees to implant the production process.
π Example β Toyota's Quality Circles: At the end of each work week, groups of Toyota production workers spend 1-2 hours analyzing performance to identify problems. Each group proposes 'countermeasures' to correct problems and discusses results. Through personal interactions, employees share ideas, devise tests, and assess results. This practice progressively identifies, eliminates, and prevents errors, making Toyota's production system one of the highest-quality in the world.
The explicit knowledge approach
The explicit knowledge approach holds that knowledge can be explained by individuals, though some effort may be required. This approach assumes that useful knowledge can be articulated and made explicit. Formal organizational processes can help individuals articulate knowledge to create knowledge assets. Explicit knowledge assets can be disseminated through documents, drawings, standard operating procedures, and manuals of best practice. Information systems play a central role in facilitating dissemination over company intranets or the Internet.
π Definition β Explicit Knowledge Approach: The belief that knowledge can be articulated and codified into explicit knowledge assets that can be disseminated through documents and information technologies.
New knowledge can be created through a structured, managed, scientific learning process. Recommendations focus on generating, articulating, categorizing, and systematically leveraging explicit knowledge assets.
π Example β Motorola's Pager Design: Motorola introduced new pager generations every 12-15 months. Each design team received a manual of design methods from the previous team. Each team had three deliverables: (1) improved pager design, (2) design of more efficient assembly lines, and (3) an improved design manual incorporating new methods. This manual was passed to the next team, systematically capturing and leveraging knowledge.
π Example β Toyota's Explicit Documentation: Toyota creates detailed task description documents for each assembly line task, specifying how each task is performed, how long it takes, the sequence of steps, and self-checking procedures. When improvements are suggested in Quality Circles, production engineers evaluate them and formally incorporate them into revised task documents.
π Example β Chrysler's Book of Knowledge: Several platform teams of 300-600 engineers create next-generation vehicle platforms. Each platform team is required to place its selected design solution for each aspect in a 'Book of Knowledge' on Chrysler's intranet, making good design solutions available to all teams.
π Example β GE Fanuc Automation: Engineers create detailed design methodologies for each type of component. These methodologies are encoded in software, so design of new component variations is automated. Performance parameters are entered, and the computer system automatically generates a design solution.
Advantages and disadvantages of tacit versus explicit knowledge approaches
Advantages of the tacit knowledge approach:
- Relatively easy and inexpensive to beginβjust identify what individuals claim to know
- May lead to improvements in employee satisfaction and motivation when knowledge is officially recognized
- Avoids motivational difficulties of getting people to make knowledge explicit
- Leaving knowledge in tacit form protects proprietary knowledge from leaking to competitors
Disadvantages of the tacit knowledge approach:
- Individuals may not actually have the knowledge they claim
- Knowledge profiles need frequent updating
- Knowledge transfer is constrained by moving people, which is costly and limits speed and reach
- Organization may lose key knowledge if key people leave, become incapacitated, or are recruited by competitors
Advantages of the explicit knowledge approach:
- Articulated knowledge can be moved instantaneously anytime anywhere by information technologies
- Codified knowledge can be proactively disseminated to people who can use it
- Explicit knowledge can be discussed, debated, and improved, stimulating incremental organizational learning
- Makes knowledge base more visible and analyzable, helping discover knowledge deficiencies
- Systematic dissemination minimizes risk of losing vital knowledge if key individuals leave
Disadvantages of the explicit knowledge approach:
- Considerable time and effort may be required to help people articulate knowledge
- Individuals may resist due to fear that job security or influence depends on tacit knowledge
- Employment relationships may need redefining to motivate knowledge articulation
- Expert committees must evaluate explicit knowledge assets, using valuable people's time
- Application must be assured by adoption of best practices, requiring organizational discipline
- Explicit knowledge assets may leak to competitors, requiring security measures
π‘ Why this matters: The advantages of the explicit approach are a "mirror image" of the tacit approach's disadvantages, and vice versaβthe tacit approach is easier to start but offers limited benefits, while the explicit approach is harder to start but offers greater long-term potential.
β Key Takeaways
KM success is dominated by management factors (culture, process, organization) rather than technology. There are two fundamental approaches to KM: the tacit approach, which treats knowledge as personal and requires moving people to transfer it, and the explicit approach, which treats knowledge as articulable and codifiable into assets that can be disseminated via information systems. Toyota uniquely uses both approaches simultaneouslyβmoving people for tacit transfer while also documenting tasks explicitly. The tacit approach is easier to start but risks losing knowledge when people leave, while the explicit approach offers greater long-term benefits but requires overcoming resistance, evaluating knowledge, and ensuring application through best practices.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two fundamentally different views of knowledge in KM practice, and what does each believe about the nature of knowledge?
- How does Toyota use the tacit knowledge approach to transfer its production system to new factories?
- What three deliverables did each Motorola pager design team produce, and how did this create organizational learning?
- What are the main advantages and disadvantages of each knowledge management approach?
- Why might individuals resist making their knowledge explicit, and what organizational changes are needed to overcome this resistance?