π Lecture 23 β The Organizational School of Thought in KM
π Overview: This lecture explores the organizational school of thought in knowledge management, which emphasizes using organizational structures and networks to share and pool knowledge. It covers key approaches like managing common knowledge and the SECI process, as well as the critical components of knowledge architecture for communication, including people and technical cores. The lecture also examines how knowledge is created in organizations and the factors that influence knowledge transfer.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the organizational school of thought and presenting its key approaches: managing common knowledge and the SECI process. It then details the knowledge architecture for communication in organizations, breaking it down into the people core (including identifying knowledge centers, activating content satellites, and assigning experts) and the technical core (hardware, software, and specialized human resources). The lecture concludes with a discussion on knowledge creation in organizations through teamwork and the factors that can encourage or retard knowledge transfer.
π Lecture Summary
The Organizational School
According to Earl (2001), the organizational school describes the use of organizational structures, or networks, to share or pool knowledge. Often described as knowledge communities, the archetypal arrangement is a group of people with a common interest, problem, or experience. These communities are designed and maintained for a business purpose and can be intra- or inter-organizational. Two key approaches are presented: managing common knowledge and the socialization externalization combination internalization (SECI) process.
Managing Common Knowledge
Dixon (2000) defines common knowledge as the knowledge that employees learn from doing the organizationβs tasks. Common knowledge is managed through knowledge transfer mechanisms. Knowledge transfer in an organization can be defined as the process by which one unit (e.g., a group, department, or division) is affected by experiences. Another definition suggests that knowledge transfer at the individual level is how knowledge acquired in one situation applies.
Knowledge Architecture for communication in organizations
- Knowledge architecture can be regarded as a prerequisite to knowledge sharing.
- The infrastructure can be viewed as a combination of people, content, and technology.
- These components are inseparable and interdependent.
The People Core
- By people, here we mean knowledge workers, managers, customers, and suppliers.
- As the first step in knowledge architecture, our goal is to evaluate the existing information/documents used by people, the applications they need, the people they usually contact for solutions, the associates they collaborate with, the official emails they send/receive, and the database(s) they usually access.
- All the above-stated resources help to create an employee profile, which can later be used as the basis for designing a knowledge management system.
- The idea behind assessing the people core is to assign job content to the right person and to ensure that the flow of information, once obstructed by departments, now flows to the right people at the right time.
- To expedite knowledge sharing, a knowledge network has to be designed to assign people authority and responsibility for specific kinds of knowledge content, which means:
- Identifying knowledge centers:
- After determining the knowledge that people need, the next step is to find out where the required knowledge resides and how to capture it successfully.
- Here, the term knowledge center means areas in the organization where knowledge is available for capturing.
- These centers support identifying expert(s) or expert teams in each center who can collaborate in the necessary knowledge capture process.
- Activating knowledge content satellites:
- This step breaks down each knowledge center into more manageable levels, satellites, or areas.
- Assigning experts for each knowledge center:
- After the final framework has been decided, one manager should be assigned for each knowledge satellite to ensure integrity of information content, access, and update.
- Ownership is a crucial factor in knowledge capture, transfer, and implementation.
- In a typical organization, departments usually tend to be territorial.
- Often, conflict can occur over budget or control of sensitive processes (including the kind of knowledge a department owns).
- These reasons justify the process of assigning department ownership to knowledge content and knowledge processes.
- Adjacent/interdependent departments should be cooperative and ready to share knowledge.
- Identifying knowledge centers:
The Technical Core
- The objective of the technical core is to enhance communication as well as ensure effective knowledge sharing.
- Technology provides many opportunities for managing tacit knowledge in the area of communication.
- Communication networks create links between necessary databases.
- The term technical core refers to the totality of the required hardware, software, and specialized human resources.
- Expected attributes of technology under the technical core: Accuracy, speed, reliability, security, and integrity.
- Since an organization can be thought of as a knowledge network, the goal of the knowledge economy is to push employees towards greater efficiency/productivity by making the best possible use of the knowledge they possess.
- A knowledge core usually becomes a network of technologies designed to work on top of the organization's existing network.
Knowledge Creation in Organizations
- Knowledge update can mean creating new knowledge based on ongoing experience in a specific domain and then using the new knowledge in combination with existing knowledge to come up with updated knowledge for knowledge sharing.
- Knowledge in organizations can be created through teamwork.
- A team can commit to perform a job over a specific period of time.
- A job can be regarded as a series of specific tasks carried out in a specific order.
- When the job is completed, the team compares the experience it had initially (while starting the job) to the outcome (successful/disappointing).
- This comparison translates experience into knowledge.
- While performing the same job in the future, the team can take corrective steps and/or modify the actions based on the new knowledge they have acquired.
- Over time, experience usually leads to expertise where one team (or individual) can be known for handling a complex problem very well.
- This knowledge can be transferred to others in a reusable format.
Factors Influencing Knowledge Transfer
- Personality is one factor in knowledge sharing.
- For example, extrovert people usually possess self-confidence, feel secure, and tend to share experiences more readily than the introvert, self-centered, and security-conscious people.
- People with positive attitudes, who usually trust others and who work in environments conducive to knowledge sharing, tend to be better at sharing knowledge.
- Vocational reinforcers are the key to knowledge sharing.
- People whose vocational needs are sufficiently met by job reinforcers are usually found to be more likely to favour knowledge sharing than people who are deprived of one or more reinforcers.
β Key Takeaways
The organizational school emphasizes using structured networks and communities for knowledge sharing, with two primary approaches being managing common knowledge and the SECI process. A successful knowledge architecture is built on an inseparable and interdependent combination of people, content, and technology, starting with a thorough assessment of the "people core" to create employee profiles and identify knowledge centers. The "technical core" provides the hardware, software, and expertise necessary for effective communication and knowledge sharing. Knowledge is created through teamwork, where experience is compared against outcomes to generate new insights, and this knowledge can then be transferred. Finally, effective knowledge transfer is influenced by personal factors like personality and attitude, as well as the presence of vocational reinforcers that motivate sharing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Earl, what is the fundamental principle of the organizational school of knowledge management?
- What are the three inseparable and interdependent components of a knowledge architecture for communication?
- What is the purpose of identifying "knowledge centers" within the people core of a knowledge architecture?
- How does a team create new knowledge from performing a job, according to the lecture?
- What two personal factors are mentioned as influencing an individual's propensity to share knowledge?
π Lecture 24 β Importance of Tacit and Explicit Knowledge
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental concepts of knowledge creation, capture, and transfer within organizations. It examines the distinction between tacit and explicit knowledge, the process of knowledge creation through teams, and the practical challenges and methodologies involved in capturing expert knowledge for knowledge-based systems.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers knowledge creation as the process of combining new experiences with initial knowledge to improve performance, knowledge transfer through teams including the steps and impediments, tacit knowledge capture and its unique characteristics, the three-step process for knowledge capture, indicators for identifying expertise, guidelines for working with experts, and the benefits and limitations of using multiple experts.
π Lecture Summary
Test Your Understanding
1. What is knowledge creation?
Knowledge creation is using the new knowledge acquired from ongoing experiences in a particular problem area, in combination with the initial knowledge, to come up with extended knowledge that should improve the quality and effectiveness of performing the same job the next time around.
π‘ Why this matters: Knowledge creation transforms routine work into a continuous learning cycle, making organizations more adaptive and efficient over time.
2. A job is more than a task. Do you agree? Give an example.
True. A job is a series of specific tasks carried out in a specific order, format, or sequence.
π Example: The job of procurement coordination requires several tasks such as:
- Planning short-term purchases
- Creating profiles for suppliers
- Selecting the best supplier
- Tracking orders progress...etc.
3. How is knowledge created and transferred via teams?
Essentially, a team commits to performing a job with an initial knowledge β The team performs the job β Realizes outcome β Compares outcome to action "before and after" β New experience/knowledge is gained β Knowledge captured and represented in a form usable by others β This new knowledge is reusable by same team on next job.
4. Explain the main impediments in knowledge sharing.
The main impediments are: Personality, Attitude, Vocational reinforcers, and Work norms.
5. Explain the main steps in knowledge transfer.
A team gets together with initial knowledge β It performs a specific job β The job outcome is realized and is compared to action β A new experience or knowledge is gained β The new experience is captured and codified in a form usable by others β The new knowledge is reusable by the same team on the next job.
6. In your own words, define tacit knowledge capture. What makes it unique?
Knowledge capture is the process of extracting the knowledge of how an expert arrives at a solution for a particular problem. This includes the actual steps and reasoning involved in arriving at the solution as well as the subjective logic that an expert uses in addressing the problem.
Knowledge capture is unique, in that the procedure does not follow an algorithmic flow or a particular syntax to solve a problem.
7. Are there any particular steps involved in knowledge capture? Explain briefly.
Knowledge capture involves three steps:
Step 1: Using an appropriate tool to elicit the information from the expert. Extensive interview with the expert usually accomplishes this step.
Step 2: Interpreting the verbal information and inferring the expert's underlying knowledge and reasoning process. In this step, the knowledge developer decides where the information gathered fits into the development process of the knowledge-based system. Throughout the interviewing process, the knowledge developer gathers information on the expert's rationale for arriving at a decision. It is important that the knowledge developer thoroughly questions the expert on all angles of the problem domain.
Step 3: Taking the results from step two and using it to build the rules that represent the expert's thought process or solutions. This step may require several checks to ensure the resulting system meets the needs of the user and has captured "the expert" as closely as possible. Flowcharts, flow diagrams, decision trees, decision tables, and other graphic representation can be used to depict the rules for the expert's solution.
8. How would one identify expertise?
The collection of the several indicators of expertise would help the knowledge developer identify who would be an appropriate expert for a problem domain. These include: a. Genuine respect from peers with regard to the expert's decisions as good decisions b. People consult the expert when a problem arises c. Admitting to not knowing everything about a problem which demonstrates his or her confidence and provides a realistic view of limitations, avoiding irrelevant information and focusing on the facts d. Working with a clear focus e. Being able to explain the information to different audience levels f. Depth of detail and exceptional quality in explanations g. Demonstrating no arrogance regarding personal credentials h. Years of experience i. Strong ties with people in power
9. Working with experts requires certain skills and experience. What suggestions or advice would you give to an inexperienced knowledge developer concerning: a. working with or approaching an expert b. preparing for the first session
A and b are interrelated in the overall effort and interactions with the expert(s). Any knowledge developer, no matter how well experienced, must educate himself or herself in the expert's area and be fully prepared for the knowledge acquisition phase. Perceptions are extremely important in knowledge capture.
10. Working with multiple experts has definite benefits and limitations. Cite an example in which the use of multiple experts is a must. Explain your choice.
An example in which the use of multiple experts is a must could be for development of a knowledge-based system to predict the next direction of a given stock on the New York Stock Exchange. The reasons you would need multiple experts are the complexity of the problem domain, listening to a variety of views on stock exchange theory and behavior before attempting an approach or a solution. With this example, there is no single individual who is an expert in all aspects of the company stocks or the stock exchange or even the economy.
β Key Takeaways
Knowledge creation involves combining ongoing experiences with initial knowledge to improve job performance, following a cyclical team-based process of action, outcome comparison, and knowledge capture. Tacit knowledge capture is unique because it does not follow algorithmic flows but instead requires extracting subjective reasoning through a structured three-step process of elicitation, interpretation, and rule-building. Expertise can be identified through multiple indicators including peer respect, clarity of focus, ability to explain at different levels, and years of experience. When working with experts, knowledge developers must thoroughly educate themselves in the domain and prepare extensively for knowledge acquisition sessions. Multiple experts are essential for complex problem domains where no single individual possesses comprehensive expertise.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the main impediments to knowledge sharing within teams?
- Describe the three specific steps involved in the knowledge capture process.
- Why is tacit knowledge capture considered unique compared to explicit knowledge capture?
- List at least five indicators that help identify an appropriate expert for a problem domain.
- Provide an example where using multiple experts is necessary and explain why.
π Lecture 25 β SECI Process and BA for K. Creation
π Overview: This lecture explores Nonaka's influential model of organizational knowledge creation, focusing on the dynamic conversion between tacit and explicit knowledge. It explains the SECI process (Socialization, Externalization, Combination, Internalization), the concept of ba as the shared context for knowledge creation, and the role of knowledge assets. Understanding this model is crucial for managers seeking to foster innovation and leverage knowledge as a strategic resource.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Nonaka's Model of Knowledge Creation & Transformation, detailing the four modes of knowledge conversion: Socialization, Externalization, Combination, and Internalization (the SECI process). It then explains ba as the shared context for knowledge creation, distinguishing it from mere physical space. Finally, it introduces the concept of knowledge assets, including their four types: experiential, conceptual, systemic, and routine, and discusses the role of management in fostering knowledge creation.
π Lecture Summary
Nonaka's Model of Knowledge Creation & Transformation
In 1995, Nonaka introduced tacit knowledge (personal, context-specific, hard to formalize) and explicit knowledge (codified, transmittable in formal language) as the two main types of human knowledge. The key to knowledge creation lies in the conversion between these types through four modes.
- Tacit to tacit communication (Socialization): Takes place between people in meetings or team discussions.
- Tacit to explicit communication (Externalization): Articulation among people through dialog (e.g., brainstorming).
- Explicit to explicit communication (Combination): This transformation phase can be best supported by technology. Explicit knowledge can be easily captured and then distributed/transmitted to a worldwide audience.
- Explicit to tacit communication (Internalization): This implies taking explicit knowledge (e.g., a report) and deducing new ideas or taking constructive action. One significant goal of knowledge management is to create technology to help users derive tacit knowledge from explicit knowledge.
Socialization-Externalization-Combination-Internalization Process
Organizations create and define problems, develop and apply knowledge to solve them, and then further develop new knowledge through action. Developing new knowledge is often more important than keeping track of existing knowledge. The organization is not merely an information processing machine but an entity that creates knowledge through action and interaction.
Nonaka et al. (2000) argue that the most important aspect of a firm's capability is the dynamic capability to continuously create new knowledge out of existing firm-specific capabilities, rather than the stock of knowledge at any one point. Knowledge creation is a continuous, self-transcending process through which one acquires a new context, a new view of the world, and new knowledge.
To understand how organizations create knowledge dynamically, Nonaka et al. (2000) proposed a model with three elements:
- The SECI process: the process of knowledge creation through conversion between tacit and explicit knowledge.
- Ba: the shared context for knowledge creation.
- Knowledge assets: the resources required to enable knowledge creation (inputs, outputs, and moderators).
The three elements interact to form the knowledge spiral. Through the conversion process, tacit and explicit knowledge expand in both quality and quantity. The four steps are:
- Socialization: The conversion of tacit knowledge to tacit knowledge. New tacit knowledge is acquired through shared experiences, such as spending time together or apprenticeships. It is the sharing of tacit knowledge between individuals, usually through joint activities rather than written or verbal instructions.
- Externalization: The conversion of tacit knowledge to explicit knowledge. Tacit knowledge is articulated into explicit knowledge, which can be expressed in words and numbers. Successful conversion depends on a common knowledge space and the use of means such as metaphors, analogy, and mental models.
- Combination: The conversion of explicit knowledge to explicit knowledge. Explicit knowledge is collected from inside and outside the organization, then combined, edited, and processed to form new explicit knowledge. This involves synthesizing knowledge from different sources into one context (e.g., a financial report).
- Internalization: The conversion of explicit knowledge to tacit knowledge. Individuals convert explicit knowledge (e.g., from documents or manuals) into tacit knowledge, which becomes part of existing mental models and know-how. Learning by doing, on-the-job training, and observation are key examples.
The movement through the four modes forms a spiral, not a circle, as knowledge expands and develops continuously.
π Definition β SECI Process: [The four-step process of knowledge creation through the continuous, dynamic interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge, involving Socialization, Externalization, Combination, and Internalization.]
Ba: The Platform for Knowledge Creation
The second element of the model is ba, the location or context where knowledge creation takes place. Knowledge needs a physical, mental, or virtual context to be created. Ba is the real cultural, social, and historic context which is of importance to each knowledge worker, enabling them to understand and appreciate information. It is the place where information is understood so that it becomes knowledge.
The key concept in understanding ba is interaction. Knowledge is created through interactions among individuals or between individuals and their environments. Participants of ba cannot be mere onlookers; they must be committed through action and interaction. Ba lets participants share time and space, yet it transcends time and space, as it can be mental or virtual.
Knowledge Assets
The third element is knowledge assets, which are firm-specific resources used to create value for the firm. They are resources required to support the knowledge-creating process. Important knowledge assets include:
- Trust: Stimulates knowledge workers to share knowledge.
- Roles: Define how the knowledge creation process is to take place.
- Routines: Ensure consistency in how different knowledge workers handle knowledge creation.
Knowledge assets must be built and used internally. Nonaka et al. (2000) categorized them into four types:
- Experiential Knowledge Assets: Shared tacit knowledge built through shared hands-on experience (e.g., skills, know-how).
- Conceptual Knowledge Assets: Explicit knowledge articulated through images, symbols, and language (e.g., brand, concepts).
- Systemic Knowledge Assets: Systematized and packaged explicit knowledge (e.g., manuals, product specifications, databases).
- Routine Knowledge Assets: Tacit knowledge routinized and embedded in actions and practices (e.g., organizational culture, daily routines).
π‘ Why this matters: These four asset types form the basis of the knowledge-creating process. To manage knowledge creation effectively, a company must map its stocks of knowledge assets, understanding that they are dynamic and new assets can be created from existing ones.
Management and the Knowledge-Creating Process
The three elementsβSECI, ba, and assetsβrepresent requirements that all must be managed for successful knowledge creation. Executive management is responsible for articulating corporate knowledge ambitions. Middle management is responsible for creating and sustaining ba. Both levels are responsible for the availability of knowledge assets. The knowledge-creating process cannot be managed through traditional control of information flow, but managers can lead by providing conditions for knowledge creation.
Fostering love, care, trust, and commitment amongst organizational members is fundamental to knowledge creation, as it creates a safe atmosphere for sharing tacit knowledge. It is also crucial for leaders to cultivate commitment based on a corporate knowledge vision.
π Definition β Knowledge Assets: [Firm-specific resources that are indispensable to create value for the firm; they serve as inputs, outputs, and moderating factors of the knowledge-creating process.]
β Key Takeaways
The SECI process is the core dynamic of knowledge creation, describing a spiral of continuous conversion between tacit and explicit knowledge through Socialization, Externalization, Combination, and Internalization. This process does not occur in a vacuum; it requires a shared context, or ba, which provides the physical, mental, or virtual space for interaction and can transcend traditional boundaries. Knowledge assetsβincluding experiential, conceptual, systemic, and routineβare the essential firm-specific resources that fuel this process, requiring internal development and management. Successful knowledge creation is not a matter of controlling information but of fostering trust, commitment, and a supportive environment led by management at all levels. Ultimately, the dynamic capability to create new knowledge, not the stock of existing knowledge, is the most critical competitive advantage for a firm.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four modes of knowledge conversion in the SECI process, and what type of knowledge is converted to what in each mode?
- Explain the concept of "ba" and why it is more than just a physical location in the context of knowledge creation.
- List and define the four types of knowledge assets proposed by Nonaka et al. (2000).
- How does the SECI process form a "spiral" rather than a "circle"?
- What is the role of "love, care, trust, and commitment" in the knowledge-creating process, and why are they so important for tacit knowledge sharing?
π Lecture 26 β Knowledge Spiral and Sustained Organizational Advantages Through SECI Process
π Overview: This lecture examines the dynamic process of organizational knowledge creation through the interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge. It introduces the SECI model (Socialization, Externalization, Combination, Internalization) as a framework for understanding how knowledge is converted and expanded within organizations. The lecture is critical for understanding how companies can systematically create, share, and leverage knowledge for sustained competitive advantage.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the concept of knowledge conversion as social interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge, then systematically examines each of the four modes of knowledge conversion: socialization (tacit to tacit), externalization (tacit to explicit), combination (explicit to explicit), and internalization (explicit to tacit). It concludes with an analysis of how these modes interact through the knowledge spiral at different organizational levels.
π Lecture Summary
Knowledge Conversion: Interaction between Tacit and Explicit Knowledge
The lecture establishes a critical foundation: tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge are not separate but mutually complementary entities that interact through social processes. This interaction is called "knowledge conversion" β a social process between individuals, not confined within an individual. Through this social conversion process, both tacit and explicit knowledge expand in quality and quantity.
The lecture notes that the ACT model from cognitive psychology partially aligns with this view, as it hypothesizes that declarative knowledge (explicit) must transform into procedural knowledge (tacit). However, the ACT model has a limitation: it views this transformation as mainly unidirectional from explicit to tacit. The SECI model argues that transformation is interactive and spiral.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that knowledge conversion is a social, bi-directional process rather than a simple one-way transfer is essential for designing effective knowledge management systems.
π Definition β Knowledge Conversion: The social interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge through which human knowledge is created and expanded.
Four Modes of Knowledge Conversion
The assumption that knowledge is created through the interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge allows for four different modes of knowledge conversion:
- Socialization β from tacit knowledge to tacit knowledge
- Externalization β from tacit knowledge to explicit knowledge
- Combination β from explicit knowledge to explicit knowledge
- Internalization β from explicit knowledge to tacit knowledge
Three of these modes (socialization, combination, and internalization) have been discussed in organizational theory, but externalization has been somewhat neglected.
Socialization: From Tacit to Tacit
Socialization is a process of sharing experiences and thereby creating tacit knowledge such as shared mental models and technical skills. An individual can acquire tacit knowledge directly from others without using language. The key to acquiring tacit knowledge is experience β without shared experience, it is extremely difficult to project oneself into another's thinking process.
π Example 1 β Ronda's "Brainstorming Camps" (tama dashi kai): Informal meetings held outside the workplace at resort inns where participants discuss difficult problems while sharing meals and bathing together. The meetings are open to any interested employees. There is one taboo: criticism without constructive suggestions. These camps serve as forums for creative dialogue, sharing experience, and enhancing mutual trust.
π Example 2 β Matsushita's Bread-Making Machine: Ikuko Tanaka and engineers apprenticed themselves to the Osaka International Hotel's head baker to capture the tacit knowledge of dough-kneading skill. Through observation, imitation, and practice, Tanaka noticed the baker was "twisting" the dough β the secret for making tasty bread that X-ray comparisons could not reveal.
π Example 3 β NEC's Customer Interaction: NEC developed its first personal computer through sharing experiences and continuing dialogues with customers at the BIT-INN display service center. A wide variety of customers, from high school students to professional computer enthusiasts, contributed to the development of the best-selling PC-8000.
π Definition β Socialization: A process of sharing experiences and thereby creating tacit knowledge such as shared mental models and technical skills.
Externalization: From Tacit to Explicit
Externalization is a process of articulating tacit knowledge into explicit concepts. It is a quintessential knowledge-creation process where tacit knowledge takes the shapes of metaphors, analogies, concepts, hypotheses, or models. Externalization is triggered by dialogue or collective reflection.
Among the four modes, externalization holds the key to knowledge creation because it creates new, explicit concepts from tacit knowledge. The answer lies in a sequential use of metaphor, analogy, and model.
π Definition β Metaphor: A way of perceiving or intuitively understanding one thing by imaging another thing symbolically. Metaphors reconcile discrepancies in meaning and create networks of new concepts by relating different things, even abstract to concrete ones.
π Definition β Analogy: Reduces the unknown by highlighting the "commonness" of two different things through rational thinking focused on structural/functional similarities.
π Definition β Model: A logical representation where all concepts and propositions must be expressed in systematic language and coherent logic.
π Example β Honda City "Tall Boy": Project leader Hiroo Watanabe used the metaphor of "Automobile Evolution" viewing the car as an organism. The concept "man-maximum, machine-minimum" emerged through an analogy between this concept and a sphere (maximum volume within minimum surface area), resulting in the short but tall car design.
π Example β Canon Mini-Copier: A task force exploring how to produce a disposable drum cylinder at low cost discovered the analogy of an aluminum beer can. By applying the beer can manufacturing process to the drum cylinder, they developed a low-cost manufacturing process for the disposable drum.
π Definition β Externalization: A process of articulating tacit knowledge into explicit concepts, taking the shapes of metaphors, analogies, concepts, hypotheses, or models.
Theory of Organizational Knowledge Creation in Product Development
The lecture presents a table summarizing how metaphor and analogy influenced concept creation:
| Product (Company) | Metaphor/Analogy | Influence on Concept Creation |
|---|---|---|
| City (Honda) | "Automobile Evolution" (Metaphor); The sphere (Analogy) | "Man-maximum, machine-minimum" concept; "Tall and short car (Tall Boy)" concept |
| Mini-Copier (Canon) | Aluminum beer can (Analogy) | "Low-cost manufacturing process" concept |
| Home Bakery (Matsushita) | Hotel bread (Metaphor); Head baker (Analogy) | "Twist dough" concept |
Metaphor is driven by intuition and holistic imagery and does not aim to find differences. Analogy is carried out by rational thinking focusing on structural/functional similarities and their differences. Thus, analogy bridges the gap between an image and a logical model.
Combination: From Explicit to Explicit
Combination is a process of systemizing concepts into a knowledge system. This mode involves combining different bodies of explicit knowledge through such media as documents, meetings, telephone conversations, or computerized communication networks. Reconfiguration of existing information through sorting, adding, combining, and categorizing leads to new knowledge.
In the business context, combination is most often seen when middle managers break down and operationalize corporate visions, business concepts, or product concepts. Middle management plays a critical role in creating new concepts through networking of codified information and knowledge.
π Example β Kraft General Foods: The company developed "micro-merchandizing" using POS data to create new sales systems. By analyzing data with unique classification of stores and shoppers into six categories, the system pinpoints who shops where and how, controlling four elements of category management: consumer and category dynamics, space management, merchandising management, and pricing management.
π Example β Asahi Breweries: The grand concept "live Asahi for live people" was combined with the mid-range concept of "richness and sharpness" to develop Asahi Super Dry beer. This mid-range concept made the grand concept more explicitly recognizable and altered the company's product development system, requiring cooperation between production and sales departments.
π Definition β Combination: A process of systemizing concepts into a knowledge system by combining different bodies of explicit knowledge.
π‘ Why this matters: Combination shows how explicit knowledge from different sources can be reconfigured to create new knowledge, highlighting the importance of documentation, databases, and formal communication networks.
Internalization: From Explicit to Tacit
Internalization is a process of embodying explicit knowledge into tacit knowledge. It is closely related to "learning by doing." When experiences through socialization, externalization, and combination are internalized into individuals' tacit knowledge bases in the form of shared mental models or technical know-how, they become valuable assets.
For explicit knowledge to become tacit, it helps if the knowledge is verbalized or diagrammed into documents, manuals, or oral stories. Documentation helps individuals "re-experience" the experiences of others indirectly.
π Example β GE Answer Center: Over 200 telephone operators respond to up to 14,000 calls daily, using a database of 1.5 million potential problems and solutions. Product development people visit the center to chat with operators, thereby "re-experiencing" their experiences. Four full-time programmers update the database with new solutions by the following day.
π Example β Matsushita MIT'93: The company launched a policy to reduce yearly working time to 1,800 hours. The MIT'93 promotion office advised each department to experiment for one month by working 150 hours. Through this bodily experience, employees internalized what working 1,800 hours a year would be like.
Internalization can also occur through reading success stories β if the story makes members feel the realism and essence, the experience may change into a tacit mental model. When shared by most members, tacit knowledge becomes part of organizational culture.
π Definition β Internalization: A process of embodying explicit knowledge into tacit knowledge, closely related to "learning by doing."
Contents of Knowledge and the Knowledge Spiral
Each mode of knowledge conversion yields different content:
| Mode | Content Created | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Socialization | Sympathized knowledge (shared mental models, technical skills) | Kneading dough skill at Matsushita |
| Externalization | Conceptual knowledge (concepts, metaphors, analogies) | "Tall Boy" concept at Honda |
| Combination | Systemic knowledge (prototypes, component technologies) | Micro-merchandizing program at Kraft |
| Internalization | Operational knowledge (project management, production processes) | Bodily experience of working 150 hours at Matsushita |
These contents interact in the knowledge spiral:
- Sympathized knowledge about consumers' wants β becomes explicit conceptual knowledge about a new product concept through socialization and externalization
- Conceptual knowledge β becomes a guideline for creating systemic knowledge through combination
- Systemic knowledge β turns into operational knowledge for mass production through internalization
- Operational knowledge β often triggers a new cycle of knowledge creation
The knowledge spiral occurs as the interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge becomes larger in scale, moving up through expanding communities of interaction that cross sectional, departmental, divisional, and organizational boundaries. Organizational knowledge creation starts at the individual level and moves upward.
Each mode is triggered differently:
- Socialization starts with building a "field" of interaction
- Externalization is triggered by meaningful "dialogue or collective reflection"
- Combination is triggered by "networking" newly created and existing knowledge
- Internalization is triggered by "learning by doing"
π Definition β Knowledge Spiral: A process where the interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge becomes larger in scale as it moves up ontological levels, starting at the individual level and moving through expanding communities of interaction.
π‘ Why this matters: The knowledge spiral explains how individual knowledge becomes organizational knowledge, showing that knowledge creation is not linear but a continuous, expanding cycle.
β Key Takeaways
The SECI model demonstrates that organizational knowledge creation is a dynamic, spiral process driven by the social interaction between tacit and explicit knowledge across four modes: socialization (sharing experiences), externalization (articulating tacit knowledge through metaphor and analogy), combination (systematizing explicit knowledge), and internalization (embodying explicit knowledge through learning by doing). Externalization is the most critical mode because it transforms valuable tacit knowledge into explicit concepts that can be shared across the organization. The knowledge spiral operates at multiple ontological levels, moving from individual to group to organizational knowledge, with each mode producing different content (sympathized, conceptual, systemic, and operational knowledge). For sustained organizational advantage, companies must create mechanisms that support all four modes β such as brainstorming camps for socialization, metaphor/analogy use for externalization, databases and networks for combination, and hands-on experimentation for internalization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four modes of knowledge conversion in the SECI model, and what triggers each mode?
- Why does the lecture argue that externalization holds the key to knowledge creation, and what role do metaphor and analogy play in this process?
- How did Matsushita's bread-making machine development team use socialization to capture the master baker's tacit knowledge?
- Explain how the knowledge spiral operates across different ontological levels, using an example from the lecture.
- What type of knowledge content does each SECI mode produce, and how do these contents interact in the spiral of knowledge creation?