π Lecture 13 β What Affects the Decision Making?
π Overview: This lecture examines the multitude of psychological, emotional, intellectual, and environmental factors that influence decision-making during crises. It also explores decision-making at the state and interstate level, emphasizing how internal and external conditions limit the range of choices available to decision-makers. Understanding these factors is critical for crisis managers who must guard against biases and distractions to make effective decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first outlines factors affecting decision-making including perception, expression, emotions, and intellect, with detailed sub-factors for each. It then covers thinking skills, distinguishing between creative thinking and analytical/logical thinking. The final major section addresses decision-making at the state/interstate level, examining the area of choice, external conditions, internal conditions of the state, the approach of political realism, alterable and unalterable factors, and the macro-level versus micro-level analysis of decision-making processes.
π Lecture Summary
Factors Affecting Decision Making
Decision making is a difficult job involving many factors and dimensions. One must guard against distractions and ensure ground realities are not lost sight of. The factors affecting decision making are organized under four main categories: perception, expression, emotions, and intellect.
a. Perception
(1). We see what we want to see. It is a very common tendency that one wants to see what he likes to see. It is called 'wishful thinking'. This single syndrome can lead to a disastrous or an absolutely wrong decision. Facts and figures, ground realities, correct data and visible factors are the essential ingredients for making a correct decision. Throughout the process of decision making, emotional and psychological temptations keep our attention drifting away from existing realities.
(2). Incorrect Recognition of Crisis (Situation). Correct recognition or perception of crisis is the fundamental pre-requisite to reach some good decision or at least a workable decision. World history shows that very often, crises were not recognized correctly and decisions were made keeping false or faulty data in view, resulting in devastating results. Many kings lost their kingdoms, many states lost wars, and many companies lost their business and became bankrupt.
(3). Stereotype Applications. In the fast changing world, crisis always emerges with new face and new dimensions, demanding innovations and new measures for proper resolution. The simple lesson learned is that measures of the past may have become absolutely outdated today and we need to apply new methods and measures to overcome new crisis.
(4). Getting Out of Perspective. This is another problem where it is human tendency to deviate from the actual problem. Crises are a period of extreme anxiety, tension, stress and strain demanding instant decisions. However, the crisis management team often indulges in unrequired, non-essential and aimless discussions and arguments, shifting attention from the original aim. The crisis management process is not the time to prove credentials, abilities, knowledge and skills which are not appropriate to the prevailing crisis.
b. Expression
(1). Inability to Express. Expression is the real essence of understanding or presenting any problem which demands a decision. If someone has correctly grasped and understood the causes of crisis but cannot express and present them, the vision or perception is of no use. Decision makers must be expert in expression as well. If a patient knows the points of pain in his body but cannot explain to the doctor, there are all chances of a wrong injection or harmful medicine being administered.
(2). Use of Incorrect Terminology. Every subject has its own language and terminology. Terms used in economics cannot be used in medical sciences, and language used in literature cannot be used for mathematics. Correct terminology should be used keeping in view the field being addressed. Jargons, local expressions and invalid abbreviations must be avoided.
(3). Linguistic Ability. Whatever language is used for presenting or explaining a problem, one must have command over that language. Weak linguistic ability results in inappropriate use of words which can mislead the reader or the decision maker.
(4). Lack of Oral Expression. Oral expression is of pivotal and vital importance in the process of decision making. In crisis situations, time factors often do not permit proper written documentation. Decisions are taken based on oral presentations and discussions. Reluctance, hesitation and inefficient and ambiguous oral expression can lead to big problems. One must remember four Cs:
- C: Clear
- C: Concise
- C: Comprehensive
- C: Complete
c. Emotions
(1). Fear of Making Mistakes. Emotions are the basic factor in following a course of action and making a decision. The biggest element prevailing during tense moments is the fear of making mistakes. One is afraid of being blamed at a later stage or losing credibility.
(2). Impatience. Crisis management is highly tense and laborious work. Loss of life, loss of property, potential of escalation and changing forms and direction of crisis test one's patience. If decision makers lose their patience, it will drastically affect the whole process of crisis management.
(3). Becoming Anxious. Sometimes unbearable scenes make a person sad and anxious. This anxiety can result in drifting away the thought process and concentration, leading to a bad decision or unwanted wastage of time and efforts. People involved in crisis management must keep their senses together and guard against being carried away by emotions.
(4). Avoiding Hard Work. Crisis management demands mental and physical robustness and stamina. Since everyone is not alike, there are people who try to escape hard work. Such people should be sifted away at the time of selecting the team for managing a particular crisis.
Climatic Conditions. Climatic conditions also play a vital role in crisis management. Freezing cold, scorching sun, ruthless winds and heavy rains affect our five senses and physical ability, thus affecting efficiency. Conducive environments aid our function. Alternatives and possibilities must be kept in view with arrangements ready to meet such situations.
d. Intellect
(1). Lack of Knowledge. Whatever type of crisis we face, we must possess relevant knowledge about the subject. If we tell a vehicle mechanic to write a novel, we are asking too much. Likewise, if the mechanic tells us to fix the engine, we cannot do it. Lack of knowledge is the first problem in decision making.
(2). Lack of Creative Thinking. The syndrome of rigidity is common. With time one develops a mind set and it becomes hard to deviate from that thinking style, which is a hurdle in making correct decisions. Creative thinking explores new possibilities and options, examining crisis from as many angles as possible. It has also been called divergent thinking. Those people who have many new ideas with a high rate of excellent ones are called creative thinkers. With a little creative thinking, possibilities are endless. Albert Einstein recognized that "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking, we were at, when we created them."
(3). Lack of Logical Thinking/Scientific thinking. Scientific thinking goes by many names like logical, critical, analytical, convergent, straight-line and predictable thinking. It follows certain logical and scientific assumptions. Logical/scientific thinking is best used when the problem requires one answer. During crisis management, every dimension and problem comprising crisis requires one different solution. Creative thinking should be skillfully welded together with logical/scientific thinking.
(4). Rigidity. Strictly sticking to only one decision or solution is not helpful during crisis management. Flexibility is always the need of the hour as rigidity restricts innovations and quick switching over.
(5). Not being Methodical. Crises are not usual phenomenon and not identical to common problems. In crisis management, every major step must be taken precisely, keeping before some proper and tested method. No hit and trial method should be used.
2. Thinking Skills
a. Creative Thinking
Creative thinking demands several elements. This skill cannot be acquired merely through academic studies. One has to know, rehearse and practice time and again.
Originality. No two crisis situations can ever be exactly identical. Every crisis demands absolutely original thinking. Past experiences can be of great help but cannot be applied exactly like mathematical formulas. Every critical situation will demand new and original decisions.
(2). Flexibility. No matter how original or scientific a conclusion is, it cannot prove to be the last word. Many new situations keep emerging at the implementation level demanding quick and practicable measures. Flexibility simply means having many alternatives and options.
(3). Fluency. Decision makers have to think, decide and disseminate in written or oral form. If thoughts are not properly disseminated and questions or doubts remain, the aim may not be achieved. A good creative thinker must be very clear, understandable and fluent in written work or verbal expression.
(4). Elaboration. While disseminating creative thinking to associates, nothing should be left to their interpretation. Whatever has been thought must be elaborated and explained to sufficient extent, leaving no lacunas for filling in the blanks.
b. Analytical or Logical Thinking
The Duke of Wellington says: "I mistrust the judgement of every man in a case in which his own wishes are concerned." Thinking should not be based on day dreaming and fallacies but on analytical and logical realities. Never make quick generalizations but always follow systematic and analytical approach. Suggested steps: (1). Identify and define the problem. (2). Define goals and objectives. (3). Generate solutions. (4). Raise questions. (5). Make a plan of action. (6). Have alternatives. (7). Identify practical problems. (8). Ask yourself: will it be implementable?
DECISION MAKING AT STATE / INTER STATE LEVEL
Introduction
"Decision-making ranges from the administrative procedures by which messages are distributed and filed, to the quality of perception and interpretation, and the degree to which action is guided by adequate consideration of all possible choices." The decision making process can be faulty at many specific points; any one weakness can affect the efficiency of the whole. Failures are frequently due to parts of the total system overlooked by decision makers and operational research consultants β parts which are the responsibility of senior and final decision-makers. Eayrs has commented that a physician whose patient dies faces an inquest; an engineer whose bridge collapses faces a Royal Commission; but the statesman whose policies bring ruin to a nation does not even ask forgiveness.
Decisions do not come from a single source or single mind. Decisions made in isolation are very usually wrong. To examine efficiency in decision-making, the area of choice that decision-makers have must be determined. What authorities should do in particular circumstances on the basis of ideology or normative rules is not immediately relevant; what alternatives exist is the first consideration.
1. Area of Choice
What is required is an analysis of the area of choice of decision-making generally, in light of which alternatives in particular situations can be examined. A usual means of defining areas of choice is to refer to static and dynamic influences on States over which they have little or no control, and the changing environment that might be more subject to influence. The more direct way is to examine areas of the environment or conditions that are alterable and unalterable by the deliberate decisions and policies of States.
2. External Condition
Alterations in environments must be treated as part of the unalterable data to be taken into account within the total decision-making process of States. Conditions of extensive and discontinuous change, presenting States with adjustment problems beyond their capacity, might often be held to be a sufficient cause of conflict between States. Before the First World War, former colonial areas were industrializing rapidly, forcing widespread adjustment upon metropolitan powers. The Great Depression of 1929-31 was evidence of structural maladjustments. The rise of Hitler to power was against this background. Japan's demands for a South-East Asian co-prosperity sphere were directly related to the restrictive policies of the West. This was a war occasioned by interactions that led governments to aggressive acts in the protection of their interests.
3. Internal Condition of the State
The internal conditions of the State must also be treated as unalterable for purposes of decision-making. The State structure, its pressure groups, its nationalism, and its fears of the environment are unalterable within any span of time relevant to decision-making processes. Even State institutions and practices are unalterable. History, tradition, leadership interests, government control of information services, traditional alliances, religious views, language differences, dependence and interdependence factors have a bearing upon State relations. These are part of the environment which decision makers must accept as unalterable in their day-to-day planning and making of policy. Like gravity and friction in the operation of a machine, they are factors to be taken into account and offset; they cannot be eliminated.
4. Approach of Political Realism
This is an approach of political realism, though different from the classical school of realists. The classical realists were realistic in facing up to the nature of Man and the State. This approach takes the objects of their realism as unalterable data. Attention is confined to those decisions and acts that are within the capability of States in their contemporary environment. This realism also requires the exclusion of many areas that may be within the decision-making capability of States over long periods. For example, changes in culturally based educational policies do not take place within a time span relevant to the avoidance or resolution of conflict.
5. Alterable Factors
Alterable factors are probably few and insignificant. More radical decisions β creation of federations, elimination of States, creation of supranational organizations, disarmament or arms control β may seem more relevant to problems of international relations than examining decision-making in a very restricted area of choice. But in the real world of politics, it is not possible to decree that in the interests of avoiding a Third World War, States must be disarmed. Sweeping descriptions and generalizations no longer satisfy the student who wants to see at the micro-level what processes give rise to broad movements.
6. At the Macro-level
At the macro-level, relevant questions are: why do States enact unacceptable roles? Why do they pursue policies that provoke aggressive responses? What are systemic influences? These questions can be answered only in part at the macro-level. The processes that lead systems to change can be seen only at the micro-level of decision making. At the micro-level, questions are: how are decisions taken within political systems? What use is made of information? How accurately is the external world perceived? What capability do States have of responding to their environment?
That the range of choice in making decisions is narrowly limited at any given point might be discouraging. No easy and quick solutions to serious political problems can be contemplated. Even the limited range of choices that exists is responsible over long periods for systemic changes and for resistances by States that ultimately lead to conflict. If States finally become irrelevant to world society, this will be due to decision-making processes β to limited choices made at many points of time.
CONCLUSION
Decision making is a tedious process involving manifold abilities. Particularly in crisis management, it involves many challenging factors. It demands physical and mental presence, robustness, strong nerves, creative and logical thinking, and updated knowledge of all dimensions of the crisis. Decision making demands skills and expertise in a variety of fields. The most important thing is innovation, originality and ability to make minute-to-minute decisions to overcome moment-to-moment upcoming novel situations. Constant monitoring and altering or modifying the decision at implementation level is the key requirement.
π Wishful thinking: The tendency to see what one wants to see rather than objective reality, which can lead to disastrous decisions.
π Creative thinking (divergent thinking): A thinking style that explores new possibilities and options, examining crises from as many angles as possible.
π Logical/scientific thinking (convergent thinking): A thinking style that follows logical and scientific assumptions, best used when a problem requires one correct answer.
π Political realism: An approach that takes the nature of Man and the State as unalterable data, confining attention to decisions and acts within the capability of States in their contemporary environment.
π Formula for effective oral expression in crisis: The four Cs (Clear + Concise + Comprehensive + Complete) β ensures unambiguous communication when written documentation is not feasible.
π Example of incorrect crisis recognition: World history shows many kings lost their kingdoms, many states lost wars, and many companies became bankrupt because crises were not recognized correctly and decisions were made using false or faulty data.
π Example of stereotype application failure: In the past, a simple ladder, few buckets of water and a basket of sand sufficed for fire. Today, with multi-story buildings, wooden structures, and massive use of electricity, gas and fuel, modern mechanical and electronic equipment is required. Measures of the past may be absolutely outdated.
π Example of state-level decision-making failure: The rise of Hitler and Japan's demands for a South-East Asian co-prosperity sphere were directly related to restrictive Western economic policies following the Great Depression. This was not inevitable war due to psychological drives but war occasioned by interactions leading governments to aggressive acts.
π‘ Why this matters: The recognition that decision-making at state level operates within a narrowly limited range of choices (due to unalterable internal and external conditions) explains why dramatic solutions like total disarmament are unrealistic. Understanding this helps crisis managers focus on what can actually be changed.
π‘ Why this matters: The distinction between macro-level (systemic) and micro-level (process) analysis reveals that broad historical movements are actually the product of countless small, limited decisions. To understand and influence outcomes, one must study the micro-processes of how decisions are actually made.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that decision-making in crisis is affected by four major categories of factors: perception (wishful thinking, incorrect recognition, stereotypes, losing perspective), expression (inability to express, incorrect terminology, weak linguistic ability, poor oral expression), emotions (fear of mistakes, impatience, anxiety, avoidance of hard work), and intellect (lack of knowledge, lack of creative/logical thinking, rigidity, lack of method). Equally important is mastering both creative thinking (originality, flexibility, fluency, elaboration) and analytical/logical thinking (systematic steps from problem identification to implementability assessment). At the state/interstate level, decision-makers operate within a narrowly restricted area of choice because most factors β external conditions, internal state conditions, and systemic influences β are unalterable in the short term. Political realism demands focusing on alterable factors, which are few, and analyzing decision-making at the micro-level to understand how limited choices accumulate into broader historical outcomes. Finally, innovation, originality, and the ability to make minute-to-minute decisions with constant monitoring are key requirements for effective crisis decision-making.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four sub-factors under "Perception" that affect decision-making during crisis, and which one refers to the tendency to see what one wants to see?
- What are the four "C"s required for effective oral expression in crisis decision-making?
- What is the difference between creative thinking (divergent thinking) and logical/scientific thinking (convergent thinking), and why must both be welded together during crisis management?
- According to the lecture, why are most factors affecting state-level decision-making considered "unalterable," and what is the implication for the area of choice available to decision-makers?
- What does the lecture mean by stating that "decisions do not come from a single source or single mind," and what is the danger of decisions made in isolation?
π Lecture 14 β RESEARCH SKILLS
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of research, emphasizing its importance in discovering truth and challenging historical misconceptions. It covers why research is necessary, defines what research is, outlines its specific characteristics and objectives, and presents a systematic sequence for conducting research, particularly in the context of crisis management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by exploring the meaning and history of research, highlighting how historical misbeliefs can persist. It then addresses why research is necessary through illustrative stories about Aristotle, Einstein, a mathematician, and examples of blind following. The definition of research is provided through multiple lenses, followed by its specific characteristics, various objectives including theoretical, applied, and action research, and concludes with a suggested sequence for conducting research.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
The word 'research' comes from the prefix 're' (again) and the verb 'search' (to find out or look for). This indicates that research is a constant phenomenon with no end, as there are countless hidden realities and suppositions. While history is known as the mother of knowledge, it is also the mother of doubts and apprehensions. An example is the historical belief that the sun revolved around the earth, which was later disproven by the Holy Quran and scientifically proven centuries later, demonstrating the advantage of research in discovering facts.
1. Why Research
a. Aristotleβs Fly Many problems with research stem from being impressed by authority and knowledge. A story illustrates this: Aristotle caught a fly, counted its legs, and announced it had five legs. No one questioned him for years. The fly Aristotle caught was missing one leg. This demonstrates the limitations of relying on personal experience and authority as sources of knowledge.
b. Einstein Another story involves Einstein, who helped a young girl with her mathematics homework. He solved the sum 2+2=5. When the teacher saw the answer, she did not mark it wrong, commenting, "If Einstein has done it, he will prove it also." This illustrates the burden of authority and knowledge which necessitates research.
c. Misinterpretation (Mathematician and Bridal Procession) A bridal procession with a mathematician encountered a wide stream. The mathematician calculated the average depth was four feet and said they could walk through. Only the swimmers made it; the rest drowned. The mathematician replied, "I had worked out the average depth of the water, which was only four feet." This shows the danger of misinterpretation of data.
d. Blind Following People blindly follow things found in books or quotations. Two verses were wrongly attributed to Dr. Sir Allama Muhammad Iqbal. One verse, using his symbol of "UQAB" (Hawk), actually belongs to Muhammad Sadiq Qureshi. Another verse, often found on educational institution entrances, was written by Khuda Baksh Muztar Nizami. This demonstrates how blind following perpetuates inaccuracies.
π Definition β Blind Following: Accepting information as true without questioning its source, simply because it appears in authoritative books, references, or quotations.
π‘ Why this matters: These examples show that research is essential to sift truth from history, broaden mental horizons, and bring past experiences to a crisis manager's knowledge for future decision-making.
2. What is Research?
- Hunting for facts or truth about a subject (e.g., researchers lessening disease).
- Organized scientific investigation to solve problems, test hypotheses, or develop new products (e.g., atomic research, cancer research).
- Systematic application of a set of methods to provide trustworthy information about problems.
- Systematic investigation to increase knowledge and understanding.
- A careful, critical, disciplined inquiry varying in method, directed towards clarification or resolution of a problem.
- The formal systematic application of scientific method to the study of a problem.
- A process of conscious, premeditated inquiry, well planned before time.
π Definition β Research: The systematic application of a set of methods to provide trustworthy information about problems, involving a careful, critical, and disciplined inquiry to increase knowledge and understanding.
3. Specific Characteristics of Research
- A flawless and clear description of the problem is essential.
- The hypothesis is tested, and a conclusion draws whether it is true or false.
- New hypotheses may be formed during the process which are further investigated.
- Research is carried out according to the priority of the subject.
- Many research works investigate a specific condition.
- Research produces concepts.
- Concepts are modified or rendered obsolete through research.
- Research explains concepts and rejects them with logic and reasons.
- Science is alive due to research.
- Research sets a standard of 'right' and 'wrong'.
π Definition β Hypothesis: An idea as to a probable solution to a problem, an intelligent guess or hunch, which is tested during research.
4. Objectives
a. Theoretical or Basic Research Conducted to develop theories or know basic facts about a theory. It is completely academic.
b. Factorial or Applied Research Aims to apply or test a theory and evaluate its usefulness in solving problems.
c. Practical or Action Research Aims at finding out some immediate action to address a localized problem.
d. Addressing the Defined Problem To find ways to successfully manage an existing problem.
e. Designing New Methods of Research There is a constant need to modify and find new research methods, tools, instruments, and techniques.
f. Discovering New Concepts The universe's problems and mysteries are not fully unfolded. New challenges arise from daily changes, making this a key objective.
g. Modifying/Updating the Existing Concepts/Methods Nothing is final; there is always a need for updating and modification of existing or believed facts and concepts.
5. Sequence of Research
Following a system is essential for desired results, especially in crisis management which requires flawless data. A suggested sequence is:
- a. Identification and definition of the problem.
- b. Formulation of hypothesis, an idea as to a probable solution.
- c. Collection, organization, and analysis of data.
- d. Formulation of conclusions.
- e. Verification, rejection, or modification of the hypothesis by testing its consequences in a specific situation.
- f. All therein, laws are called the generalization.
β Key Takeaways
Research is a systematic, conscious, and formal process of inquiry to discover truth, requiring clear problem definition and hypothesis testing. The need for research is driven by the limitations of relying on authority, personal experience, and historical blind following, as illustrated by the stories of Aristotle, Einstein, and a mathematician. Its objectives range from theoretical knowledge to immediate practical action and the continuous updating of concepts. For crisis management, following a structured research sequenceβfrom problem definition to hypothesis verificationβis crucial for making sound decisions based on trustworthy data.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is researching necessary, based on the story of Aristotle's fly?
- What are the three main definitions provided for "research" in this lecture?
- List three specific characteristics of research as discussed in the lecture.
- What is the difference between Theoretical (Basic) Research and Factorial (Applied) Research?
- What is the second step in the suggested sequence of research, and how is it defined?
π Lecture 15 β MAIN TYPES OF RESEARCH
π Overview: This lecture introduces the six primary types of research essential for a crises managerβs toolkit. It emphasizes historical research as a detailed specimen while briefly covering the other five approaches. Understanding these types helps managers select appropriate methods for investigating and managing crisis situations effectively.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture categorizes six main research types: historical, descriptive, co-related, causal comparative, experimental, and qualitative/quantitative. It explains historical research in depth as a specimen, noting that all types follow similar methodologies. The lecture also touches on additional terminologies and sub-types of research relevant to crisis management.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
Our basic subject is crises management, for which it is essential for any crises manager to have knowledge of research skills. We are discussing the research skills only at introductory level. However, historical research has been discussed in detail as a specimen. Rest of the types have been briefly described as almost all types of research follow the same methodology. There are many other terminologies used in research or sub-types of research which have been briefly included in your course.
Most of the researchers agree on the following six types of research. There are differences; agreements and disagreements as far as, the types of research are concerned. However, we will restrict only to the following six approaches:
a. Historical research b. Descriptive research c. Co-related research d. Causal Comparative research e. Experimental research f. Qualitative / Quantitative research
π‘ Why this matters: A crises manager must know which research type to apply in different crisis scenarios to gather accurate data and make informed decisions.
Historical Research
Historical research is discussed in detail as it serves as a specimen for understanding the general research methodology. Historical research involves the systematic collection and evaluation of data to describe, explain, and understand actions or events that occurred in the past. The purpose is to reach conclusions about causes and effects from those events, which can help predict future occurrences.
π Definition β Historical Research: It is the systematic process of searching for facts or truth about the past to understand present phenomena and anticipate future developments.
π Formula: Past events β Systematic data collection β Interpretation β Understanding of present and future
π Example: A crisis manager investigates a past industrial accident (e.g., a chemical plant explosion) by examining old safety reports, witness testimonies, and company records to identify root causes and recommend preventive measures for future crises.
Brief Overview of Other Research Types
Descriptive research describes the characteristics of a population or phenomenon as it exists currently. Co-related research examines the relationship between two or more variables without manipulating them. Causal Comparative research attempts to determine cause-effect relationships by comparing groups where the cause is already present or absent. Experimental research involves manipulating one variable to observe its effect on another under controlled conditions. Qualitative research focuses on understanding phenomena through non-numerical data like interviews, while Quantitative research uses numerical data and statistical analysis.
π Definition β Descriptive Research: Research that describes the current state of a variable or population, answering "what is" rather than "why" or "how."
π Definition β Experimental Research: Research that tests hypotheses through controlled manipulation of variables to establish cause-effect relationships.
π Example (Descriptive): A survey of employee stress levels during a crisis to describe current conditions without intervention.
π Example (Experimental): Testing two different crisis communication strategies in a controlled simulation to measure which yields faster public response.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that a crises manager must understand the six main types of research β historical, descriptive, co-related, causal comparative, experimental, and qualitative/quantitative β each serving a distinct purpose. Historical research is the exemplar method involving systematic collection and evaluation of past data to explain present events and predict future crises. All research types share fundamental methodology, with differences in data handling (numerical vs. narrative) and purpose (description, correlation, or causation). The choice of research type depends on the crisis situation: historical for past incidents, experimental for testing interventions, and descriptive for understanding current conditions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six main types of research discussed in this lecture?
- Why is historical research treated as a "specimen" in this lecture?
- How does descriptive research differ from causal comparative research?
- Give one example of how historical research might be applied in crisis management.
- What is the key difference between qualitative and quantitative research according to this lecture?
π Lecture 16 β Historical Research
π Overview: This lecture explores historical research as a systematic method for investigating past events, particularly in the context of crisis management. It details the purposes, steps, and rigorous evaluation techniques needed to learn from past failures and successes, emphasizing the critical distinction between primary and secondary sources and the dual processes of external and internal criticism to ensure genuineness and accuracy.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining historical research and its purposes, such as learning from the past and assisting in prediction. It then outlines the four main steps of conducting historical research: problem definition, data collection, data analysis (external and internal criticism), and data synthesis. Following this, it categorizes different sources of historical data, including primary and secondary sources, documents, numerical records, oral statements, and relics. The lecture concludes with a detailed examination of external and internal criticism, providing key questions for researchers to evaluate the genuineness and accuracy of their sources.
π Lecture Summary
HISTORICAL RESEARCH
Historical research is the systematic collection and evaluation of data to describe, explain, and understand actions or events that occurred in the past. It allows us to see the present in perspective, for example, by studying how people managed crises like floods, earthquakes, food shortages, epidemics, and wars.
π Definition β Historical Research: the systematic collection and evaluation of data to describe, explain, and thereby understand action or events that occurred sometimes in the past.
Purposes
The purposes of historical research are multi-faceted. First, it aims to make people aware of what has happened in the past so they may learn from past failures and successes. Second, it helps researchers learn how things were done in the past to see if those methods might be applicable to present-day problems and concerns. Third, it assists in prediction. Fourth, it helps test hypotheses concerning relationships or trends. Finally, it enables a more realistic understanding of present practices and policies.
Steps
The steps in conducting a historical research study are essentially the same as for other types of research. The process begins with the definition of a problem, where the researcher limits themselves to available data and studies a well-defined problem in depth to answer one or two specific questions. The second step is data collection, where the "literature" refers to all sorts of written communication, including legal documents, records, minutes of meetings, and letters, and may also involve interviews. Here, the distinction is made between primary sources (first-hand information from actual participants or direct observers) and secondary sources (second-hand information from reference books, encyclopedias, or associates of participants). The third step is data analysis, which involves both external criticism (determining authenticity) and internal criticism (determining accuracy). To determine accuracy, four factors must be considered: the knowledge and competence of the author, the time delay between the occurrence and recording of events, the biased motives of the author, and the consistency of the data. The final step is data synthesis, where historical data is organized and synthesized, and conclusions and generalizations are formulated using logical analysis rather than statistical analysis, requiring the researcher to remain as objective as possible.
Category of Sources
Sources are categorized into several types. A Primary Source is prepared by an individual who was a participant in or a direct witness to the event. A Secondary Source is prepared by an individual who was not a direct witness but obtained their description from someone else. Documents are any signed document pertaining to an event. Numerical Records are quantitative records that can be considered a separate type of source or a sub-category of documents. Oral Statements include stories, myths, tales, legends, songs, and oral interviews. Relics are objects whose physical or visual characters provide information about the past, such as furniture, artwork, clothing, buildings, or monuments.
π Example: Examples of Relics include furniture, artwork, clothing, buildings, monuments or equipment.
Evaluation of Historical Sources
A researcher can never be entirely sure about the genuineness and accuracy of historical sources. For example, a memo may have been written by someone other than the person whose signature appears on it, a letter may refer to events that did not occur or occurred at a different time or place, or a document may have been forged or information deliberately falsified.
Key Questions for Researcher
The two key questions for a researcher are: βWas this document really written by the supposed author (i.e., is it genuine)?β and βIs the information contained in this document true (i.e., is it accurate)?β The first question refers to external criticism, and the second refers to internal criticism.
External Criticism
External Criticism refers to the genuineness of any and all documents the researcher uses. To evaluate the genuineness of a historical source, several questions must be asked: Who wrote the document? For what purpose was the document written? When was the document written? Where was the document written? Under what conditions was the document written? Do different forms or versions of the document exist?
Internal Criticism
Once researchers are satisfied that a source document is genuine, they need to determine if the contents are accurate. This involves internal criticism. Both the accuracy of the information contained in a document and the truthfulness of the author need to be evaluated. Whereas external criticism has to do with the nature and authenticity of the document itself, internal criticism has to do with what the document says.
Key Questions for Researcher, With Regards to the Contents of the Document
The key questions regarding contents include: Was the author present at the event described? Was the author a participant or an observer? Was the author competent to describe the event? Was the author emotionally involved? Did the author have any vested interest? Do the contents make sense? Could the event have occurred at that time? Would people have behaved as described? Does the language suggest bias? Do other versions of the event exist?
π‘ Why this matters: Rigorous application of external and internal criticism is essential for ensuring the credibility and trustworthiness of historical research, which in turn provides a reliable foundation for learning from past crises and applying those lessons to current management practices.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that historical research is a systematic process for learning from the past, specifically to understand present crisis management practices. The core of the research involves meticulous evaluation of sources through two distinct types of criticism: external criticism to verify a document's authenticity, and internal criticism to verify the accuracy of its contents. A clear understanding of the difference between primary sources (first-hand accounts) and secondary sources (second-hand reports) is fundamental, as is recognizing the potential for bias, forgery, and errors in all historical documents. For an exam, students must be able to define historical research, list its purposes and steps, categorize sources, and articulate the key questions for both external and internal criticism.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define historical research and state its primary goal.
- What are the four main steps involved in conducting a historical research study?
- Distinguish between a primary source and a secondary source, providing an example of each.
- What is the difference between external criticism and internal criticism in the evaluation of historical data?
- List three key questions a researcher should ask to evaluate the accuracy (internal criticism) of a document's contents.
π Lecture 17 β Descriptive Research
π Overview: This lecture explores descriptive research, a non-experimental approach focused on collecting data to understand the current status of a subject. It explains how researchers describe and interpret existing conditions, opinions, and trends without manipulating any variables, and introduces the logical reasoning methods used to arrive at generalizations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines descriptive research as a method for testing hypotheses or answering questions about current conditions through questionnaires, surveys, interviews, or observation. It outlines the characteristics of descriptive research, including hypothesis formulation and testing, and explains the logical methods of deductive and inductive reasoning used to arrive at generalizations from data.
π Lecture Summary
DESCRIPTIVE RESEARCH
This particular approach involves collection of data in order to test hypotheses or to answer questions concerning the current status of the subject of the study. Descriptive data are usually collected through a questionnaire, survey, interviews, or observation. Just as the historical researcher has no control over the past, the descriptive researcher has no control over the present and can only measure what already exists.
A descriptive study describes and interprets what is going on at present. It is concerned with conditions or relationships that exist, opinions that are held, processes that are going on, effects that are evident, or trends that are developing. It is primarily concerned with the present, although it often considers past events and influences as they relate to current conditions.
π‘ Why this matters: Descriptive research is foundational for understanding real-world situations without interference, making it essential for fields like crisis management where observing existing conditions is critical.
Characteristics of Descriptive Research
- It involves hypotheses formulation and testing.
- It uses the logical methods of inductive-deductive reasoning to arrive at generalization.
Deductive Definition: Moving from the general assumptions to the specific applications. For example: (All men are mortal) β Generally for all. "Salaam is a man" β Specific to a person. This logic is called deductive.
Inductive Definition: Moving from the specific observations to the generalization. Francis Bacon (Philosopher) gave the idea of induct.
π Definition β Deductive Reasoning: Moving from general assumptions to specific applications. Example: "All men are mortal; Salaam is a man; therefore, Salaam is mortal."
π Definition β Inductive Reasoning: Moving from specific observations to a generalization. Originated by philosopher Francis Bacon.
π Formula: Deductive Reasoning β General β Specific. Inductive Reasoning β Specific β General.
π Example: In descriptive research, if a survey shows 80% of employees are satisfied (specific observation), an inductive conclusion might be "the organization has high employee satisfaction" (generalization). Conversely, if the general rule is "all crises follow a pattern," a deductive approach would analyze a specific crisis to see if it fits that pattern.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that descriptive research is about observing and measuring what already exists in the present, with no control over variables. Data is collected via questionnaires, surveys, interviews, or observation. This approach involves hypothesis formulation and testing using inductive-deductive reasoning. Deductive reasoning moves from general to specific, while inductive reasoning moves from specific to general. Descriptive research describes conditions, relationships, opinions, processes, effects, and trends.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main methods for collecting descriptive data?
- How does descriptive research differ from historical research in terms of control over time?
- What is the difference between deductive and inductive reasoning?
- Which philosopher is credited with the idea of inductive reasoning?
- Name five things a descriptive study can be concerned with (e.g., conditions, relationships).