📘 Lecture 17 — Diagnosing Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture presents a comprehensive model for diagnosing organizational systems at the organization level. It explains the five major design components—strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems—and how they must align with each other and the environment for organizational effectiveness. Understanding this diagnostic framework is crucial for identifying performance problems and planning appropriate interventions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the comprehensive model for diagnosing organizational systems, starting with organization-level diagnosis and the five design components: strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems, plus organization culture as an intermediate output. It then examines organizational outputs including performance, productivity, and stakeholder satisfaction, followed by the concept of alignment between inputs, design components, and outputs. Finally, it applies these concepts through a detailed analysis of Nike's strategic orientation as a case study.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organization-Level Diagnosis: Design Components
Figure 23(A) shows that a strategic orientation is composed of five major design components—strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems—and an intermediate output—culture. Effective organizations align their design components to each other and to the environment.
A strategy represents the way an organization uses its resources (human, economic, or technical) to gain and sustain a competitive advantage. It can be described by the organization’s mission, goals and objectives, strategic intent, and functional policies. A mission statement describes the long-term purpose of the organization, the range of products or services offered, the markets to be served, and the social needs served by the organization’s existence. Examples include Walt Disney's "To make people happy," Wal Mart's "To give ordinary folk the chance to buy the same thing as rich people," Merck's "To preserve and improve human life," and Mary Kay Cosmetics' "To give unlimited opportunity to women."
Goals and objectives provide explicit direction, set organization priorities, provide guidelines for management decisions, and serve as the cornerstone for organizing activities, designing jobs, and setting standards of achievement. They should set a target of achievement, provide a means for measuring achievement, and provide a deadline for accomplishment. A strategic intent is a succinct label that describes how the organization intends to achieve its goals and objectives—through differentiation, lowest costs, or growth. Functional policies are the methods, procedures, rules, or administrative practices that guide decision making and convert plans into actions; for example, Intel allocates about 30% of revenues to R&D.
Technology is concerned with the way an organization converts inputs into products and services, representing the core of the transformation function including production methods, work flow, and equipment. Two features influence other design components: interdependence (how different parts of a technological system are related) and uncertainty (the amount of information processing and decision making required). High interdependence requires considerable coordination; high uncertainty makes tasks difficult to plan and routinize. Car manufacturing technology is relatively certain and moderately interdependent.
The structural system describes how attention and resources are focused on task accomplishment. It divides work into subunits and coordinates these subunits. Two ways to describe how work is divided are through formal structures (by function, product/service, or matrix combination) or through differentiation and integration. Differentiation refers to the degree of similarity or difference in design of subunits—highly differentiated organizations have major design differences among departments. Integration is how the organization coordinates work across subunits, achieved through plans, schedules, budgets, special roles, or cross-departmental teams. Required integration increases with environmental uncertainty, structural differentiation, and departmental interdependence.
🔑 Definition — Integration: The way an organization coordinates work across subunits; achieved through various mechanisms such as plans, schedules, budgets, project managers, liaison positions, integrators, or cross-departmental task forces and teams.
Measurement systems are methods of gathering, assessing, and disseminating information on activities of groups and individuals. Such data tell how well the organization is performing and detect and control deviations from goals. Effective systems link to strategic objectives, provide accurate and timely information, are accepted as legitimate, and produce benefits exceeding costs.
Human resources systems include mechanisms for selecting, developing, appraising, and rewarding organization members. Strategy and technology provide information about required skills and knowledge; appraisal processes identify if those skills are being applied; and reward systems recognize performance contributing to goal achievement.
Organization culture is the final design component, representing the basic assumptions, values, and norms shared by members. It is shown as an intermediate output because it is both an outcome (of history, environment, and prior choices) and a constraint (difficult to change). McDonald's culture emphasizes efficiency, speed, and consistency. 💡 Why this matters: Culture can either hinder or facilitate change, so diagnosis must understand the current culture's alignment with other design factors.
Outputs
Outputs of a strategic orientation can be classified into three components: organization performance (financial outputs like profits, ROI, earnings per share; for nonprofits, cost reduction or budget adherence), productivity (internal efficiency measures like sales per employee, waste, error rates, quality, units per hour), and stakeholder satisfaction (how well the organization met expectations of different groups—customer satisfaction via market share, employee satisfaction via opinion surveys, investor satisfaction via stock price).
Alignment
Organization effectiveness requires determining alignment among elements through two key questions:
- Does the organization’s strategic orientation fit with the inputs?
- Do the design components fit with each other?
For example, if external environment elements are fairly similar in certainty, an effective structure should have low differentiation. If the environment is complex with different uncertainty levels, a more differentiated structure is warranted—as shown in Chevron Oil Company, where regulatory affairs is formal and bound by protocol while technological departments are flexible and adaptive.
Analysis: Application 2 — Nike's Strategic Orientation
The Nike case provides an opportunity to perform organization-level analysis. In 1993, Nike had over 30% market share in athletic footwear, but after six years of solid growth, international sales were falling, basketball shoe sales declined, stock dropped 41%, and stakeholder groups attacked the company for labor practices and lack of diversity.
Key diagnostic questions for inputs:
- General environment: Nike's environment is uncertain and complex—technologically dependent on breakthroughs, socially and politically aware of multiple stakeholder demands from different countries and governments.
- Industry structure: Highly competitive with high threat of entry, high threat of substitutes, low supplier bargaining power, moderate buyer bargaining power, and severe rivalry among firms (Reebok, Adidas, New Balance, etc.).
Key diagnostic questions for strategic orientation:
- Strategy: Nike's strategy is clear on some points—differentiation through high-quality, high-performance athletic footwear—but nebulous on others, with no formal mission statement, nebulous goals, and tension between growth and profitability.
- Technology, structure, measurement systems, human resources: Technology is moderately uncertain and interdependent; structure is a product division structure that is moderately differentiated but appears not highly integrated, with contract relationships creating a fluid network-like structure; human resources and measurement systems are underdeveloped with no compensation policy and formal control systems generally resisted.
- Culture: A dominant feature driven by athletic norms of winning, competition, achievement, and performance—very entrepreneurial, captured by the "Just Do It" marketing campaign.
Alignment analysis reveals: The complex and uncertain environment fits well with Nike's differentiation focus and flexible design. However, strategy elements are not internally aligned—growth goals and diversified mission do not align with differentiation intent. Technology aligns with structure (product development requires flexibility), and the Futures program reduces uncertainty and provides integration. The lack of formal HR systems supports fluid design but creates problems for hiring and development.
Two intervention possibilities suggested:
- Increase clarity about strategy without formalizing (which culture would resist)
- Increase integration and coordination of structure, measurement systems, and HR systems without increasing formalization
⭐ Key Takeaways
For effective organizational diagnosis, students must understand the five design components (strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems) plus culture as an intermediate output. Alignment is the central concept—organizations must fit design components to each other and to environmental inputs, and misalignments reveal root causes of performance problems. Culture is particularly important as both an outcome and a constraint that can facilitate or sabotage change efforts. The Nike case demonstrates how analysis proceeds from assessing inputs and outputs, through examining each design component, to evaluating alignments and identifying intervention possibilities—always respecting the organization's existing culture.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five major design components in the comprehensive model for diagnosing organizational systems, and what is the intermediate output shown in Figure 23(A)?
- What are the three components of organizational outputs, and how do they differ for for-profit versus nonprofit organizations?
- What two features of technology influence other design components, and what is the difference between them?
- In the Nike case study, what three aspects of its strategy were misaligned, and what two interventions were suggested?
- Why is organization culture described as an "intermediate output," and how does it function as both an outcome and a constraint in organizational diagnosis?
📘 Lecture 18 — Diagnosing Groups and Jobs
📖 Overview: This lecture covers the diagnosis of groups and jobs, the second major phase in planned change. It presents diagnostic models for work groups and individual jobs, explaining how to assess their design components, inputs, outputs, and the critical fits between them. Understanding these levels is essential for identifying root causes of organizational problems and targeting effective interventions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining why small groups and departments need their own diagnostic models distinct from organization-level diagnosis. It then details the group-level diagnostic model, covering inputs (organization design), five design components (goal clarity, task structure, group composition, group functioning, and performance norms), outputs (performance and quality of work life), and the necessary fits between inputs and design components. Finally, it applies the group-level model to diagnose a top-management team at Ortiv Glass Corporation, analyzing how mismatches between design components and task demands explain the team’s ineffectiveness.
📝 Lecture Summary
Group-Level Diagnosis
Diagnosis is the second major phase in planned change. While large groups or departments can be diagnosed using organization-level models, small departments and groups behave differently and need their own diagnostic models. Work groups consist of a relatively small number of people working face-to-face on a shared task. The group-level diagnostic model shows inputs, design components, outputs, and relational fits. It is similar to other popular models like Hackman and Morris’s task group design model.
Inputs
Organization design is the major input to group design. It consists of the design components of the larger organization: technology, structure, measurement systems, human resources systems, and organization culture. Technology determines the group’s task characteristics; structural systems specify coordination requirements. The human resources and measurement systems (e.g., performance appraisal and reward systems) play an important role. For example, individually based performance appraisal and reward systems tend to interfere with team functioning because members may maximize individual performance to the detriment of the team. Collecting information about the group’s organization design context greatly improves diagnostic accuracy.
Design Components
Groups have five major components: goal clarity, task structure, group composition, group functioning, and performance norms.
Goal clarity involves how well the group understands its objectives. Goals should be moderately challenging; there should be a method for measuring, monitoring, and feeding back information about goal achievement; and goals must be clearly understood by all members.
Task structure is how the group’s work is designed. It varies along two key dimensions: coordination of members’ efforts and regulation of their task behaviors. Coordination is the degree to which group tasks promote effective interaction. It is important for interdependent tasks (e.g., surgical teams) but unimportant for independent tasks (e.g., telephone operators). Regulation is the degree to which members can control their own task behaviors and be free from external controls like supervision. Self-regulation occurs when members decide on task assignments, work methods, production goals, and membership.
Composition concerns group membership. Demographic variables (age, education, experience, skills, abilities) affect how people behave and relate. Demographics determine if the group has task-relevant skills and interpersonal skills. People’s internal needs, such as individual differences in social needs, influence group behaviors and whether membership is satisfying or stressful.
Group functioning is the underlying basis of group life – how members relate to each other affects task performance. Some groups have interpersonal competition and conflict; others may be too concerned with sharing good feelings. Group functioning involves task-related activities (giving and seeking information, elaborating, coordinating, evaluating) and the group-maintenance function (encouraging, harmonizing, compromising, setting standards, observing), which holds the group together as a cohesive team.
Performance norms are member beliefs about how the group should perform its task, including acceptable levels of performance. Norms derive from interactions and serve as guides. Once agreed upon (implicitly or explicitly), members routinely perform tasks according to them. For example, problem-solving groups often decide early that decisions will be made through voting; voting then becomes routine.
Outputs
Group effectiveness has two dimensions: performance and quality of work life. Performance is measured by the group’s ability to control or reduce costs, increase productivity, or improve quality – a “hard” measure. Quality of work life concerns work satisfaction, team cohesion, and organizational commitment.
Fits
Group design components must fit inputs for groups to be effective. Research suggests these fits:
-
Group design should be congruent with the larger organization design. Organizations with low differentiation and high integration should have groups with highly skilled members performing interdependent tasks. Organizations with differentiated structures and formalized systems should have groups with clear, quantitative goals and standardized behaviors. When group designs are incompatible, groups may develop norms counter to organizational effectiveness (e.g., horseplay, goldbricking).
-
When technology results in interdependent tasks, coordination should be promoted by task structures, composition, performance norms, and group functioning. When technology permits independent tasks, design components should promote individual task performance. For example, when coordination is needed, task structure might physically locate related tasks together; composition might include members with interpersonal skills; performance norms would support task-relevant interactions.
-
When technology is uncertain (high information processing and decision making required), group design should promote self-regulation. Members need freedom, information, and skills to assign tasks, decide methods, and set goals. When technology is certain, group designs should promote standardization and external control by supervisors, schedules, and plans. For self-regulation, task structure should be flexible; composition should include members with multiple skills; norms should support complex problem solving.
💡 Why this matters: These fits are the key diagnostic tool. A group may have excellent design components individually, but if they don’t fit the inputs (organization design, technology), the group will fail. The diagnosis must explicitly check these alignments.
Application 3: Top-Management Team at Ortiv Glass Corporation
The Ortiv Glass Corporation produces plate glass. It has an organic organization design with participative management. A top-management problem-solving team was formed at its newest plant, consisting of the plant manager and five functional department managers (engineering, administration, human resources, production, quality control). Members had good technical skills, managerial experience, and a desire to solve problems collaboratively. The team had been working together for only five months.
The team met for two hours weekly to share information and deal with plant-wide issues. Meetings were described as informative but chaotic. They started late as members straggled in. They were interrupted by “urgent” phone messages, with recipients leaving. The group had problems arriving at clear decisions; discussions rambled, problems were postponed, leading to a backlog, and meetings lasted beyond two hours. When decisions were made, members often failed to follow through, and there was confusion about what was agreed. Everyone expressed dissatisfaction.
Relationships were cordial but strained, especially on complex issues. Although the plant manager said he wanted all sides, he often interrupted or changed topics when members openly disagreed, followed by awkward silence. When a solution was not forthcoming, members either moved on or informally voted, letting majority rule decide. These behaviors emerged informally over time and became acceptable.
Analysis: The group is having ineffective problem-solving meetings. The key diagnostic issue is the fit between inputs and design components.
Inputs: The larger organization design is relatively organic, promoting flexibility and innovation. The team’s issues involve high interdependence among functions and high uncertainty (complex problems). These inputs require high coordination and self-regulation.
Design Components Diagnosis:
- Goal clarity: Goals are clear (solve problems), but there is no clear agreement on specific problems. Members come late because they have “more pressing” problems.
- Task structure: Face-to-face meetings facilitate coordination and allow members freedom to regulate their task behaviors.
- Composition: Members have task-relevant skills and experience. They are interested in collaborative problem solving.
- Performance norms (inferred from behaviors):
- “It’s okay to come late.”
- “It’s okay to interrupt meetings with phone messages.”
- “It’s okay to leave meetings.”
- “It’s okay to hold meetings longer than two hours.”
- “A good group member should not openly disagree.”
- “It’s okay to vote on decisions.”
- “A good group member should be cordial.”
- “It’s okay to postpone solutions.”
- “It’s okay not to follow through.”
- Group functioning: Interpersonal relations are not healthy. Members do not confront differences openly; the plant manager intervenes when conflicts emerge. Members fail to examine underlying causes of dissatisfaction.
Fits Analysis: The key difficulty is a mismatch between the team’s performance norms and interpersonal relations and the demands of the problem-solving task. Complex, interdependent problems require norms that support sharing diverse, conflicting information, generating novel solutions, and explicitly addressing how knowledge and skills are used. Instead, the team’s norms promote a superficial, haphazard problem-solving method subject to external disruptions. Members do not confront differences or examine the ineffective norms. Diagnosis suggests the need for interventions aimed at improving performance norms and developing healthy interpersonal relations.
🔑 Definition — Goal clarity: how well the group understands its objectives.
🔑 Definition — Task structure: how the group’s work is designed, varying in coordination and regulation.
🔑 Definition — Group functioning: the underlying basis of group life, involving task-related and group-maintenance activities.
🔑 Definition — Performance norms: member beliefs about how the group should perform its task, including acceptable performance levels.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The group-level diagnostic model analyzes five design components (goal clarity, task structure, composition, group functioning, performance norms) and their fit with the input of organization design. The critical diagnostic insight is that a group’s problems often stem not from any single component, but from a mismatch between these components and the demands of the task (interdependence and uncertainty). Performance norms are a powerful but often invisible driver of group behavior; identifying them requires inferring from actions, not asking members directly. The Ortiv case demonstrates that even with good people and a good structure, unhealthy norms and poor interpersonal functioning can completely derail a team’s effectiveness.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five design components in group-level diagnosis, and what does each one refer to?
- Why is it a problem to diagnose a group’s effectiveness by looking only at its design components without checking their fit with inputs?
- What performance norms were operating in the Ortiv Glass top-management team, and how did they contribute to the team’s dysfunction?
- In the fits section, what should a group’s design look like when technology results in interdependent and uncertain tasks?
- What is the difference between task-related activities and group-maintenance functions in group functioning?
📘 Lecture 19 — Diagnosing Groups and Jobs
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how to diagnose organizational systems at the individual job level. It presents a comprehensive model for understanding job inputs, design components, and the necessary fits between them, building on earlier discussions of organization and group diagnosis. Understanding job-level diagnosis is crucial because individual jobs are the foundation upon which groups and organizations are built.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the individual-level diagnosis within organizations, focusing on the inputs that affect job design (organization design, group design, and personal characteristics of job holders), the five key design components of jobs (skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback about results), and the critical fits between job design and its inputs to ensure effective performance and satisfaction.
📝 Lecture Summary
Individual-Level Diagnosis:
The lowest level of organizational diagnosis is the individual job or position. An organization consists of numerous groups; a group, in turn, is composed of several individual jobs. This section discusses the inputs, design components, and relational fits for diagnosing jobs. The model shown in Figure 25(C) is similar to other popular job diagnostic frameworks, such as Hackman and Oldham’s job diagnostic survey and Herzberg’s job enrichment model.
Inputs:
Three major inputs affect job design: organization design, group design, and the personal characteristics of job holders. Organization design is concerned with the larger organization within which the individual job is the smallest unit. Technology, structure, measurement systems, human resources systems, and culture can have a powerful impact on the way jobs are designed. For example, company reward systems can orient employees to particular job behaviors. Technology characterized by relatively uncertain tasks and low interdependency is likely to support job designs allowing employees flexibility and discretion. Conversely, low-uncertainty work systems are likely to promote standardized job designs requiring routinized task behaviors. Group design concerns the larger group or department containing the individual job. Group task structure, goal clarity, composition, performance norms, and group functioning serve as inputs to job design and typically have a more immediate impact on jobs than organization-design components. For example, group task structure can determine how individual jobs are grouped together. When members maintain close relationships and the group is cohesive, group norms are more likely to be enforced and followed. Personal characteristics of individuals occupying jobs include their age, education, experience, and skills and abilities. Individual differences in growth need — the need for self-direction, learning, and personal accomplishment — can determine how much people are motivated and satisfied by jobs with high levels of skill variety, autonomy, and feedback about results. Similarly, work motivation can be influenced by people's expectations that they can perform a job well and that good job performance will result in valued outcomes.
Design Components:
Figure 25(C) shows that individual jobs have five key dimensions: skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback about results. Skill variety identifies the degree to which a job requires a range of activities and abilities to perform the work. Assembly-line jobs generally have limited skill variety, while most professional jobs include a great deal of skill variety. Task identity measures the degree to which a job requires the completion of a relatively whole, identifiable piece of work. Skilled craftspeople generally have jobs with high levels of task identity, as they can see a job through from beginning to end. Assembly-line jobs score low on task identity. Task significance identifies the degree to which a job has a significant impact on other people's lives. Custodial jobs in a hospital are likely to have more task significance than similar jobs in a toy factory. Autonomy indicates the degree to which a job provides freedom and discretion in scheduling the work and determining work methods. Assembly-line jobs generally have little autonomy, while college teaching positions have more autonomy. Feedback about results involves the degree to which a job provides employees with direct and clear information about the effectiveness of task performance. Assembly-line jobs often provide high levels of feedback about results, whereas college professors must often contend with indirect and ambiguous feedback. Those five job dimensions can be combined into an overall measure of job enrichment. Enriched jobs have high levels of skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback about results. They provide opportunities for self-direction, learning, and personal accomplishment at work.
Fits:
The diagnostic model in Figure 25(C) suggests that job design must fit job inputs to produce effective job outputs, such as high quality and quantity of individual performance, low absenteeism, and high job satisfaction. Research reveals the following fits between job inputs and job design:
- Job design should be congruent with the larger organization and group designs within which the job is embedded. Highly differentiated and integrated organizations and groups that permit members to self-regulate their behavior fit enriched jobs. Conversely, bureaucratic organizations and groups relying on external controls are congruent with job designs scoring low on the five key dimensions. Congruence across different levels of organization design promotes integration of the organization, group, and job levels.
- Job design should fit the personal characteristics of the jobholders if they are to perform effectively and derive satisfaction from work. Generally, enriched jobs fit people with strong growth needs and those possessing moderate to high levels of task-relevant skills, abilities, and knowledge. Jobs scoring low on the five job dimensions generally fit people with rudimentary skills and abilities and with low growth needs. Because people can grow through education, training, and experience, job design must be monitored and adjusted from time to time.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Job-level diagnosis is the lowest level of organizational analysis and focuses on inputs (organization design, group design, and personal characteristics), design components (skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback about results), and the fit between them. Enriched jobs, which score high on all five design components, provide opportunities for self-direction and learning but must be congruent with the larger organization and group context. Furthermore, enriched jobs are best suited for individuals with strong growth needs and relevant skills, while simpler jobs fit those with lower growth needs. The overall effectiveness of job design depends critically on achieving a good fit between job inputs and the job itself.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three major inputs that affect job design according to the lecture?
- List and briefly define the five key dimensions of individual jobs.
- What is a "growth need" and how does it relate to job enrichment?
- According to the research on fits, how should job design relate to the larger organization and group?
- What are the key outputs of effective job design mentioned at the end of the lecture?
📘 Lecture 20 — Collecting and Analyzing Diagnostic information
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the critical process of diagnosing organizations before implementing change. It explores the key dimensions consultants must consider when planning diagnosis, explains how to establish a productive diagnostic relationship with clients, and details the four major methods for collecting and analyzing data. Understanding these concepts is vital because the quality of diagnostic information directly determines the success of any OD intervention.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by outlining seven key dimensions to consider in diagnosis: timing, participation, confidentiality, variable selection, integration with long-range strategy, target population, and technique type. It then defines organization diagnosis and the data collection and feedback cycle. The diagnostic relationship is examined in depth, including establishing a contract with eight critical questions. The data-collection process is broken down into defining objectives, selecting key factors, and choosing a method. Finally, the four main data-gathering techniques—questionnaires, interviews, observations, and unobtrusive measures—are compared and contrasted in detail.
📝 Lecture Summary
Dimensions to Consider in Diagnosis:
In addition to having descriptive, analytic, and diagnostic theories, a consultant must consider seven key dimensions when planning diagnostic activities. Timing is significant because collecting data when participants are not prepared can waste resources. The extent of participation is crucial, ranging from unilateral to fully participative problem identification, with the underlying assumption favoring participative diagnosis. Confidentiality must be managed carefully; in early, low-trust stages, individual interviews with anonymous responses are appropriate, but as trust grows, group surfacing of data becomes possible.
The degree of pre-selection vs. emergent selection of variables varies by technique—some questionnaires tap 19 dimensions under categories like leadership and climate, while others like the Managerial Grid focus on concern for people and production. The integration with a long-range strategy is important; diagnostic activities should be part of an overall action research plan, not isolated events prompted by whim. The nature of the target population affects acceptability, interdependencies examined, and issues that can be worked. Finally, the type of technique has major ramifications—interviews can build trust while collecting data, whereas questionnaires cannot, and the composition of subgroups in workshops (heterogeneous vs. homogeneous) affects data candor.
🔑 Definition — Diagnosis: The process of collecting information that will be shared with the client in jointly assessing how the organization is functioning and determining the best change intervention.
Collecting and Analyzing Diagnostic information:
Organization development is vitally dependent on organization diagnosis. Data collection involves gathering information on specific organizational features such as inputs, design components, and outputs. The process begins by establishing an effective relationship between the OD practitioner and those providing data, then choosing data-collection techniques. The four methods are questionnaires, interviews, observations, and unobtrusive measures. Data analysis organizes and examines the information to clarify underlying causes of problems or identify areas for future development. The overall process forms a cycle of data collection, analysis, and feedback.
💡 Why this matters: The quality of information gathered is a critical part of the OD process. Organizations are often "data-rich but information-poor," meaning they have lots of data but little structured, useful information.
The Diagnostic Relationship:
Before collecting diagnostic information, practitioners must establish a relationship with those who will provide and subsequently use it. This relationship affects the quality and usefulness of the data collected. OD practitioners must clarify who they are, why data are being collected, what data gathering will involve, and how data will be used. This helps allay fears that data might be used against members and gains participation and support. Establishing this relationship is similar to forming a diagnostic contract meant to clarify expectations and specify conditions.
The diagnostic contract answers eight critical questions:
- Who am I? — Introduces the OD practitioner to organization members
- Why am I here, and what am I doing? — Defines goals of diagnosis and how it fits the developmental strategy
- Who do I work for? — Clarifies who hired the consultant; having those people help build the contract builds trust
- What do I want from you, and why? — Specifies time and effort required; involvement should be voluntary
- How will I protect your confidentiality? — Addresses who will see responses and in what form; consultants may guarantee anonymity or require open sharing
- Who will have access to the data? — Clarifies access; respondents should generally get their own results
- What's in it for you? — Describes benefits members can expect, usually through the feedback process
- Can I be trusted? — The diagnostic relationship ultimately rests on trust; consultants need ample face-to-face contact and active listening
Careful attention to the diagnostic relationship promotes three goals of data collection: obtaining valid information about organizational functioning, rallying energy for constructive change, and developing the collaborative relationship necessary for effecting change.
The Data-Collection Process:
The data-collection process is a fundamental step in any OD program. The practitioner is gathering data and deciding relevance whenever meeting with the client, observing, or asking questions. An OD program based on systematic and explicit investigation has a much higher probability of success.
The word data (from Latin dare, "to give") refers to unstructured, unformed facts—an aggregation of all signs, signals, and clues. The word information (from Latin informare, "to give form to") means data that have form and structure. A common problem is organizations being data-rich but information-poor.
The Definition of Objectives:
The first step is defining the objectives of the change program. A clear understanding of broad goals is necessary to determine what information is relevant. Usually, preliminary data gathering (such as interviews with key members) clarifies problem conditions before large-scale data collection begins. Data gathering provides the basis for organizations to look at their own processes and begins a process of self-examination leading to improved problem-solving capabilities.
The Selection of Key Factors:
The second step is identifying central variables (such as turnover, communication breakdowns, or isolated management). The trend has moved from narrow issues (pay, immediate supervisors) to broader issues like culture and values. Organizations generate "hard" data internally (production reports, budgets, turnover ratios, sales per square foot, profit per employee) that can be compared with competitors' data and industry averages. Additional data gathering may examine: degree of dependence between units, quality of information exchange, degree to which vision and goals are shared, norms and attitudes, and effects of power distribution.
The Selection of a Data-Gathering Method:
The third step is selecting a method of gathering data. There is no one best way; selection depends on the nature of the problem. Data should be acquired systematically to allow quantitative or qualitative comparison.
Methods for Collecting Data:
The four major techniques for gathering diagnostic data are questionnaires, interviews, observations, and unobtrusive measures. No single method can fully measure all variables important to OD because each has strengths and weaknesses. Perceptual measures (questionnaires, surveys) are open to self-report biases like socially desirable answers. Observations are susceptible to observer biases. Because of these biases, more than one method should be used when collecting diagnostic data. If data from different methods are consistent, variables are likely being measured validly.
📐 Principle of Multi-Method Data Collection: Using two or more data-collection methods (triangulation) → increases validity. If questionnaire and observation data conflict, a third method (e.g., interviews) should be used to resolve discrepancies.
Table Comparison of Methods:
| Method | Major Advantages | Major Potential Problems |
|---|---|---|
| Questionnaires | Responses quantifiable; easy with large samples; relatively inexpensive; large volume of data | Non-empathy; predetermined questions; over-interpretation; response bias |
| Interviews | Adaptive; source of "rich" data; empathic; builds rapport | Expense; interviewer bias; coding/interpretation difficulties; self-report bias |
| Observations | Collects data on behavior, not reports; real-time; adaptive | Coding/interpretation difficulties; sampling inconsistencies; observer bias; expense |
| Unobtrusive measures | Non-reactive (no response bias); high face validity; easily quantified | Access/retrieval difficulties; validity concerns; coding/interpretation difficulties |
Questionnaires:
Questionnaires are one of the most efficient data-collection methods. They contain fixed-response queries and can be administered to large numbers of people simultaneously, analyzed quickly (especially with computers), and easily fed back to employees. They vary in scope and degree of standardization. Standardized instruments are based on explicit models and have been refined over time (e.g., Survey of Organizations, Michigan Organizational Assessment Questionnaire, Job Diagnostic Survey). Customized questionnaires are tailored to specific client needs, often combined with standardized instruments.
Major drawbacks: responses limited to questions asked; impersonal (employees may not give honest answers); elicit response biases like socially desirable answers.
Interviews:
Interviews are the most widely used data-gathering technique in OD programs (a study of 245 practitioners found this). They are more direct, personal, and flexible than surveys. Two advantages set them apart: flexibility for different situations (determining motives, values, attitudes) and two-way communication allowing deeper learning about problems. Data-gathering interviews usually last at least one hour, aiming to get interviewees to talk freely about important matters. The advantage is providing data virtually unobtainable through other methods, especially subjective data like norms, attitudes, and values. Disadvantages include time involved, required interviewer skill, respondent biases, and difficulty ensuring comparability across respondents.
Interviews take several formats. Directed interviews ask specific questions formulated in advance (open-ended questions allow free responses but are hard to quantify; closed questions are easily recorded and quantifiable). Non-directed interviews have direction chosen by the respondent. Structured interviews derive from a conceptual model of organization functioning. Unstructured interviews include broad questions about goals, current performance, strengths/weaknesses, and barriers.
Group interviews save time and allow building on others' responses but may inhibit some people. A popular type is the focus group or sensing meeting—unstructured meetings with 10-15 employees representing cross-sections or homogeneous groupings. Another is assessing an intact work group by directing a question to the group about its functioning.
Observations:
Observation is a direct way of collecting data by watching organizational behaviors in their functional settings. It can range from complete participant observation (practitioner becomes a group member) to detached observation (using film, videotape) where the observer is clearly not part of the situation. Advantages: free from self-report biases; puts practitioner directly in touch with behaviors; involves real-time data (avoiding recollection distortions); adaptive to circumstances. Problems: difficulties interpreting meaning (may need coding schemes); observer bias and subjectivity; sampling issues (which people, time periods, territory, events to observe).
Unobtrusive Measures:
Unobtrusive measures are not collected directly from respondents but from secondary sources like company records and archives. They include records of absenteeism, grievances, quality/quantity of production, financial performance, meeting minutes, and correspondence. They are especially helpful in diagnosing organization, group, and individual outputs (market share, return on investment) and organization-level design components (structure, control systems, human resources systems via organization charts, MIS, and personnel manuals). They provide a relatively objective view, free from respondent and consultant biases, and permit statistical analysis of behaviors over time (e.g., monthly absenteeism trends).
Major problems: data may not be in usable form; built-in biases from changes in accounting or recording procedures. Despite drawbacks, they serve as a valuable adjunct to interviews and questionnaires.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The quality of diagnostic information is critical to OD success, and seven dimensions—timing, participation, confidentiality, variable selection, strategic integration, target population, and technique type—must be carefully considered before any data collection begins. Establishing a diagnostic relationship through a clear contract answering eight questions (including who the consultant is, how confidentiality will be protected, and what's in it for the participants) is essential for obtaining valid data, building energy for change, and developing a collaborative partnership. The data-collection process involves three sequential steps: defining objectives, selecting key factors, and choosing an appropriate method. The four main data-gathering methods—questionnaires, interviews, observations, and unobtrusive measures—each have distinct advantages and potential problems, so using multiple methods (triangulation) is recommended to ensure validity. Interviews are the most widely used technique because of their flexibility and ability to build rapport, while unobtrusive measures provide objective, "real" data that can validate findings from other methods.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven key dimensions a consultant must consider when planning diagnostic activities, and why is each important?
- What are the eight questions that form the substance of the diagnostic contract, and what purpose does each serve?
- What are the three goals of data collection that careful attention to the diagnostic relationship promotes?
- Compare and contrast the four main data-collection methods—questionnaires, interviews, observations, and unobtrusive measures—listing at least two major advantages and two major potential problems for each.
- Why is it recommended to use more than one data-collection method when gathering diagnostic information, and what should a practitioner do if data from different methods conflict?